Even for the mightiest pirates there comes a time when they must retire from their lives of invading and plunder — but what's coming afterward? Well, on the five peninsulas of Grog Island, they can invest their loot in rock-solid businesses, such as peg-leg shops, carpentries for figureheads, workshops for voodoo dolls, or the infamous "Grog Hole" pub.
The core of Grog Island is its unique auction mechanism, which uses five colored dice. The players use these dice and the pips on them to create and raise bids. While the winner of an auction can claim buildings on certain peninsulas, the players who have passed are also rewarded: Not only do they receive goods like grog bottles or treasure maps but they also visit merchant ships where they can trade these goods for money, parrots or treasure chests. The auction mechanism of Grog Island makes for tactical and interesting gameplay as in certain moments, passing can be almost as rewarding as winning an auction. Finding the right balance between bidding and backing out is the key to winning.
The game ends as soon as one player has claimed a certain number of buildings, then all players score the secret goal cards they received both at the start of and during the game. These cards may give points for majorities on peninsulas as well as for claiming certain types of buildings or collecting certain goods. The player with the most points wins.
- Enjoyed the bidding mechanism and its trade-offs.
- Everything else was lackluster.
- Lacking in decisions.
- Better video games exist.
- Bidding
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
- bidding — Dice are used as a bidding mechanism where players must descend in value or match previous values. More dice used secures victory but reveals more tokens for opponents.
- Set Collection — Players collect certain cards based on objectives.
- Worker Placement — After winning a bid, players distribute workers on the board to control different building types based on objectives.
Video topics + discussion points
Quotes (from this video)
- This is a really well ultra streamlined and clever it's kind of area majority Style game as you're trying to claim dominance on this map of Japan by surrounding these different cities and towns and collecting these items on them.
- It's just a wonderful game that takes around 30 minutes to play.
- This is definitely um impressed me immensely I'll be massively surprised if this doesn't end up in my top 10 or even top five of the year when it comes to 2022 releases that's how much I think of this game.
- It feels different which is quite a hard thing to achieve nowadays.
References (from this video)
- offers a fresh take on bidding with dice and color-coded components
- hidden scoring cards add strategic depth
- can be data-dense for players new to this style
- requires careful resource/fund management
- auction/bidding and influence spreading
- peninsula map with island geography
- accessible, slightly quirky bidding
- Pillars of the Earth
- Merlin
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
- Auction / Bidding — Dice of different colors are rolled; pips are used to bid for actions.
- dice bidding — Dice of different colors are rolled; pips are used to bid for actions.
- hidden scoring cards — Scoring remains partially concealed to encourage plan adaptation.
- patterned bidding/placement — Bids must be placed in a way that preserves order and aligns with available actions.
Video topics + discussion points
Quotes (from this video)
- I'm kind of making an effort to go through Knizia's back catalog because his games just resonate with me so well
- this is a 60 Minute area control game by Konitzia
- it's very concise, it's nice and small
- I'm always interested in trying games that do fly under the radar
- almost zero luck... deterministic
- I might have to think twice whether to cover this one on the channel