Imperial Settlers: Empires of the North – Roman Banners Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Imperial Settlers: Empires of the North – Roman Banners
Reviewers who have covered this expansion are enthusiastic. The most detailed take comes from Board Games UnLocked, whose no-run-through review examines both new clans, the Trajana and the Flavian. The reviewer describes the pair as factions that break from the core roster rather than reshuffling ideas already in the game, and gives the expansion a nine out of ten. The praise centers less on any single feature than on how much each clan changes the rhythm of a game.
The clearest point of agreement is that the expansion is a strong purchase for existing players. The same review argues that owners of Empires of the North should pick up the Roman clans, since they give a stronger taste of Imperial Settlers than the Japanese faction did. Opinions on the expansion's identity are more mixed. Board Games UnLocked's countdown of anticipated 2020 expansions placed Roman Banners among the releases to watch, but that host judged it from card previews rather than play, and worried that the "Empires of the North" name might blur what makes the two games distinct. Rolling Dice & Taking Names mentioned the expansion only in passing as part of Portal Games' Portal Con announcements, so its perspective adds little to the critical picture.
Core Mechanics That Define Imperial Settlers: Empires of the North – Roman Banners
Foundations and Building Requirements
The Flavian clan is built around a mechanic that Board Games UnLocked explained in detail. Players place cards face down as foundations, and those foundations carry icons for building types such as cyclops and army. Many Flavian cards require a set number of matching foundations or armies before they can be built, so every card drawn becomes a choice between using it as a building or keeping it as a foundation. Face-up building cards carry the same icons, which lets a player cover a shortfall by spending foundations to make up the difference. The reviewer also noted that matched pairs of foundations score points at the end of the game, which rewards the same stockpiling that the building requirements demand.
Resource-Scaling Engines
The Trajana clan runs on resource pressure. Its buildings cost a resource equal to the number of building types the player already has in their empire, including the one being built, so the engine grows more expensive as it expands. Cards such as Minerva's Blessing let a player spend food to harvest from several buildings at once, while the Souvenirs card spends stone for two points per stone with no cap on how much can be spent. The reviewer contrasted this uncapped scoring with other factions, where scoring is limited. Roman Crossroads adds a payoff for breadth, awarding points equal to the number of locations of the type the player has the most of. Extra harvesting cards exist to keep the resource supply from stalling the whole engine.
The Imperial Settlers: Empires of the North – Roman Banners Experience
A Satisfying Engine Ramp
Reviewers describe the expansion as a game in which early turns feel modest and late rounds accelerate. Board Games UnLocked recounted the Flavian clan climbing from around ten points to roughly thirty in a single round, after the other players passed and left the reviewer free to chain actions together. That is the feeling the reviewer returned to when praising the core game: the engine starts small, and by the end each action produces a burst of points. The Flavian clan's foundations make that ramp feel especially fluid, because once enough foundations are on the table, the player can build several cards in a row.
Tight Resource Juggling
The other side of that feeling is constant tension over resources. Board Games UnLocked described the Trajana clan as a slow build in which players must manage their resources or accumulate gold, or find themselves spending turns on harvesting instead of scoring. The spare-harvest cards that balance the clan still leave players planning several turns ahead. With the Flavian clan, the tension moves from resources to the board, because the player must track which icons are needed and keep the right foundations in place. The reviewer found the Flavian clan more demanding in this respect, even though it felt free-flowing once the foundations were out.
What Makes Imperial Settlers: Empires of the North – Roman Banners Stand Out
Two Clans That Break From the Core Roster
The most consistent praise is that neither clan resembles the existing factions. Board Games UnLocked said it could not think of a clan in the core game that was similar to either one. The Japanese faction, by contrast, was described as a clan with one ability that felt like a slightly altered version of an existing faction. The Trajana and Flavian clans were presented as changes that dramatically alter how the game is played, and the reviewer's verdict was that they are both very fun, very innovative, and clearly worth owning.
A Deck That Feels Distinct From Imperial Settlers
Board Games UnLocked framed the expansion's central idea as a reason for optimism before playing it. The reviewer expected the Roman clans to build on the way Empires of the North makes each player's deck feel more individual than the deck-driven play in Imperial Settlers. The same preview wished for more factions in the line, noting that the more the series adds, the better, and hoped the Roman clans would be a sign of further growth.
Potential Drawbacks
A Slow Start and Demanding Resource Planning
Reviewers do not hide that the Trajana clan asks a lot. Board Games UnLocked warned that players who underestimate how much stone or food their cards need will find those cards doing very little, and may spend many turns simply harvesting. The reviewer's own game ended with no resources left but thirteen gold, which shows how gold can cover shortfalls, though it also shows how much planning the clan requires. For players who prefer quick, flexible turns, this is the clearest reason the expansion may feel slow.
Foundation Luck and Limited Solo Content
The Flavian clan depends on the order in which cards come off the deck. Board Games UnLocked acknowledged that some luck is involved, since a player who keeps drawing the wrong cards may struggle to build cards that need a specific icon. Draw-to-keep cards and a construction option that ignores requirements soften that problem, and the reviewer did not find luck a serious issue in practice. The reviewer did rate the Flavian clan as the harder of the two to play, which may take extra learning. Separately, the preview host in the anticipated-expansions countdown hoped future releases would bring solo scenarios of their own, noting that the base game's solo material is limited, and doubted that Roman Banners would supply them.
If You Enjoy Imperial Settlers: Empires of the North – Roman Banners
Players who enjoy the Flavian clan's foundation mechanic will find similar satisfaction in Imperial Settlers, which Board Games UnLocked described as the closest relative of the Flavian approach. Players who enjoy the Trajana clan's resource-scaling engines and the thrill of ramping up points will feel at home in the core Empires of the North game, where the expansion's clans plug into the existing system. Players who want to widen the roster further should look at the Empires of the North Japanese faction expansion, which reviewers felt changed the core factions less dramatically than the Roman clans did.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I thought that they were both just phenomenal, very fun to play, very innovative with the way that you can actually combo off and play these factions. I think that this is almost a must expansion to go out and get if you like Empires of the North."
— Board Games UnLocked
"If this is anything like the Japanese expansion, it's gonna be great, because what they're doing with Empires of the North is very basically making your own deck feel way more unique than what they do in Imperial Settlers."
— Board Games UnLocked
"They're kind of a slow build and you have to very much manage your resources or be able to get a lot of gold because if you don't, then you're not gonna be doing a whole lot. If you're like, oh man, I didn't think that I was gonna need this much stone to be able to get anything out of these cards, then you're going to be hurting."
— Board Games UnLocked