Loot of Lima Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Loot of Lima
Loot of Lima is a 2020 pure deduction game in which players search a map of the Island of Cocos for treasure that pirates buried after the Spanish cargo from Lima was diverted. Reviewers consistently describe it as a demanding thinking game rather than a casual one. On Before You Play, Monique and Navine describe it as a game where each player knows only a small piece of the puzzle about where the buried treasure might be, and they call it one of the hardest deduction experiences they have played. On Ryan and Bethany Board Game Reviews, the hosts place it at number five on their top 10 games of 2020, calling it a logic deduction game and stressing that it is pure logic rather than social deduction. On Getting Games, the presenter approaches it as a new release of interest and frames it as a logic version of Treasure Island.
The general consensus is that the core system is clever and satisfying once it clicks, but it demands careful bookkeeping, patience, and a willingness to be lost for long stretches. Reviewers also flag rulebook accuracy and the work required to play solo or with two players as recurring concerns.
Core Mechanics That Define Loot of Lima
The Dice-Driven Question System
The island has 24 locations: 8 on the shore, 8 in the forest, and 8 in the mountains. Each location has a token, and at setup two tokens are removed from play to represent the actual treasure sites while the rest are dealt to players as known empty spots. On a turn, the active player rolls three dice that show terrain types and compass directions. Monique on Before You Play explains that the player then chooses two of the dice. If both show the same terrain, the question covers only that terrain. If they show different terrains, every terrain counts.
The two chosen directions define a sweep across the island. The asking player decides which way to encompass the area, moving from one direction to the other, and then asks a chosen opponent how many of their tokens lie within that region. Because questions are asked aloud, every player hears every answer, so a player can keep deducing during other players' turns. Three special abilities also appear during play, including one that lets a player roll again and another that allows a secret question only the targeted player hears.
Deduction and Note-Taking
Each answer is intentionally partial. The hosts on Before You Play describe receiving a count for a large region without knowing where any of those tokens sit, and the work comes from linking these fragments into overlapping clues. The reviewers agree that a notepad is not optional. The hosts call note-taking "absolutely vital" in this game and admit that they often reach a point about a third of the way through a session where they no longer know what a given answer implies. Ryan and Bethany describe a related feature from the outside, noting that a big answer book lets you check whether a final guess was right or wrong, which turns the endgame into a verification step rather than a guess.
The Loot of Lima Experience
A Hard Puzzle That Rewards Persistence
The feel of Loot of Lima is closer to working a logic puzzle than to a social deduction table. The hosts on Before You Play report struggling with it repeatedly and say they are rarely confident of winning, yet they keep asking questions because the activity itself is absorbing. They describe it as "very different from most other deduction games" they have played. In one three-player session with their friend Michael, even a player with a strong memory for information was left struggling for words by how hard the game was. Ryan and Bethany summarize the appeal in just a few words, calling the system "very very very cool" but "tough."
A Slow Drip of Information
Because each turn yields only a small amount of data, a session can run long. The hosts point out that when information arrives in fragments and the next player takes over, the solving process stretches out. They describe the game as long for that reason, which makes it best suited to players who enjoy extended puzzle work. One host says they play for the activity rather than to win, which suggests the pace suits players who value process over a quick resolution.
What Makes Loot of Lima Stand Out
A Question System That Keeps Every Turn Fresh
Ryan and Bethany single out the system as a very cool design. The three-dice question engine generates a different set of legal questions every turn, and the choice of which two dice to use, and whether to combine terrains, forces players to think about what information they need most. Getting Games notes that the components are relatively minimal, with player shields and rotating markers around a circular island, which keeps attention on the deduction itself.
Solo and Two-Player Play Through Scenario Booklets
The hosts on Before You Play highlight the design of the solo and two-player experience. The booklet uses lookup charts organized so that checking one answer does not reveal information about another player's answer. Looking up a result is a multi-step process: you find a code, turn to a different page, and then work out what the code means on the chart. That friction keeps the solo mode honest, and the hosts note that the community has since released many more scenarios on BoardGameGeek that extend the game considerably.
Potential Drawbacks
Rulebook Errors and Printing Variations
The most serious warning comes from the hosts on Before You Play. Their copy's solo and two-player booklet contained incorrect solutions, and they did not discover the error until about 80 percent of the way through a co-op game, when a deduction became mathematically impossible. They advise checking BoardGameGeek forums before playing to confirm whether a given booklet has correct solutions. Ryan and Bethany raise a related issue, noting flaws in the original first-edition printing and recommending either the later edition or the companion app, which speeds up the process and avoids some of those problems.
Note-Taking Load and Tedious Solo Lookups
Multiple reviewers agree that the game asks a great deal of its players. The hosts describe solo and two-player play as "a bit tedious" because each lookup requires cross-referencing charts, and players must avoid accidentally seeing adjacent entries. The combination of heavy note-taking, long solve times, and multi-step lookups means Loot of Lima is not a good fit for players who want a light evening or who dislike maintaining detailed records.
If You Enjoy Loot of Lima
Players who enjoy the hidden-information structure of Loot of Lima should look at Clue. The hosts on Before You Play draw the comparison directly, explaining that any deduction-style game shares similarities with Clue. In both games, players receive some pieces of information that rule out possibilities, mark those eliminations on personal notes, and then use partial answers from other players to narrow the solution. Clue is more social and easier to teach, so it works well as a gateway into this style of play.
Players who like the treasure-hunting theme should consider Treasure Island. Getting Games describes Loot of Lima as possibly a more logic-focused version of Treasure Island, since both center on pirate-buried treasure that players must locate. The reviewer's framing suggests that fans of the Treasure Island theme will find Loot of Lima offers the same search motivation with a much heavier emphasis on systematic deduction.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Most deduction games it is good to take notes, this one it is absolutely vital to take notes."
— Before You Play
"Pure logic and deduction trying to figure out where this treasure is. Very, very, very cool system, but tough."
— Ryan and Bethany Board Game Reviews
"It seems like it might be a little bit more of a logic version of Treasure Island."
— Getting Games