Necromunda: Underhive Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Necromunda: Underhive
Reviewers see Necromunda: Underhive as Games Workshop's reworking of the 1995 original, set in the Warhammer 40,000 universe in the toxic depths beneath a hive city. The channels that covered it agree that it delivers a deep, personal miniatures experience with a relatively small model count. Board Game Replay calls it one of its current favorite miniatures games and describes the whole match as a gigantic action sequence. Rolling Dice & Taking Names devotes a long segment to it, with Rodney Smith of Watch It Played as a guest, and the group frames the game as a blend of a board game and a miniatures wargame.
Where reviewers differ is on who the game suits. Enthusiasts praise its crunch and its long-term investment, while the Rolling Dice hosts note that it asks more of a table than a typical board game does. Reviewers agree that the game rewards a regular group that is willing to commit to a campaign over a single pick-up session.
Core Mechanics That Define Necromunda: Underhive
Layered Combat and Injury Dice
Combat is the mechanic reviewers explain most often, and they describe it as a chain of decisions rather than one roll. A fighter rolls a number of dice equal to their attacks, hits are measured against weapon skill, and each wound roll compares the weapon's Strength to the target's Toughness. The defender may then attempt an armored save, for example with the furnace plates many fighters wear, and any wound that gets through is resolved on injury dice. Those dice produce flesh wounds that lower Toughness, serious injuries that knock a fighter down, or outright death. Rolling Dice & Taking Names argues that this is far more than a simple roll-off, and the Board Game Replay match shows how the same system produces pins, falls from ledges, and fighters who take damage from the drop.
Persistent Campaign Play
The campaign layer is what most separates Necromunda: Underhive from a one-off skirmish. Between sessions, wounds carry over to the next battle, captured fighters can be bartered back or put to work in the underhive, and survivors gain experience and better equipment. Rodney Smith, speaking on Rolling Dice & Taking Names, recalls months of play in which everything mattered, and a fighter who lost an arm in one game was still missing it in the next. The Gang War supplement adds elevated 3D terrain and the full campaign rules for players who want that layer, and reviewers note that the game recommends campaigns of two or three months before starting a new one.
The Necromunda: Underhive Experience
Personal Ownership of Your Gang
Reviewers consistently describe building a gang as closer to a role-playing game than to a conventional wargame. Each fighter is assembled, outfitted with different heads, weapons, and gear, and painted if the player chooses. The Rolling Dice hosts say that once a fighter has a name and a history, losing one stings, and they recall older players writing names on the bases of their models. A gang of roughly ten to fifteen characters is small enough that each one can become a personal story, which is why the hosts describe the game as the closest thing to a role-playing game they have played with miniatures.
Cinematic, Swingy Tension
The other dominant feeling is a cinematic swing of fortunes, where a single roll can decide a fighter's fate. Board Game Replay describes the whole game as a big action movie, full of crunchy dice rolling and moments where a fighter should have died an hour earlier. Rolling Dice & Taking Names recounts a session in which one player rolled five ones in a row at the start, and a morale failure then sent much of the gang fleeing just as the group set up its decisive turn. The tension is often funny and sometimes deflating, but the moments of survival and reversal are what the reviewers remember most.
What Makes Necromunda: Underhive Stand Out
Assembly That Snaps Together
Reviewers repeatedly praise how Games Workshop's models fit together. Rodney Smith, who has been assembling miniatures for fifteen to twenty years, says the process is like putting together a perfectly fit puzzle, and contrasts it with older Malifaux and War Machine figures that needed finagling and sometimes green stuff. Board Game Replay makes a similar point about terrain, showing how the Tinker Turf pieces it used, with catwalks, ladders, and adjustable heights, can be arranged in minutes. Reviewers treat the easy assembly as a reason the game is approachable, even though the box still involves a good deal of gluing.
A Complete Two-Player Starter Box
The base box is praised for being playable right out of the package. It includes two starting gangs, House Escher and House Goliath, with ten models per gang, along with cards, dice, the rulebook, and terrain such as doors and obstacles. Rodney Smith points out that a new player does not need to buy anything else before a game can be played, and that the box is designed for two players. The Rolling Dice group found the first session easier when each player controlled three fighters and could coordinate with a partner.
Potential Drawbacks
Dense Rules and a Long First Session
The most frequent caution is that Necromunda: Underhive is rules-heavy. Board Game Replay describes it as really crunchy, with many small rules to remember, and Rolling Dice & Taking Names reports that its first session, including learning the rules, ran about two hours and fifteen minutes. The hosts believe a group that already knows the game could finish in around 90 minutes, but each fighter's stat line, weapon profile, and special rules have to be absorbed before play flows. Rodney Smith adds that the group had been playing the advanced rules rather than the basic game, which explained why the game felt so heavy. Reviewers suggest that it fits enthusiasts better than casual board gamers.
Morale Checks That Can Deflate One-Off Games
Campaign-oriented design also creates friction in single games. In the Rolling Dice session, the gangs were routed by morale tests, and the group felt that fighters fleeing the battlefield took the climax out of a game that was otherwise building to a finish. The guests recognized that the rule exists to keep campaign games from running for six hours and to stop players from risking expensive fighters, but they argued it works against one-off play. Their proposed approach was to play a one-off game to its scenario objectives while ignoring the morale tests, with the caveat that abilities tied to a fighter's survival would need a check.
If You Enjoy Necromunda: Underhive
Reviewers place Shadow War: Armageddon as the closest relative. On Rolling Dice & Taking Names, the guests describe Shadow War: Armageddon as Necromunda with 40k military soldiers, and they say players looking for the old-school Necromunda feel should be happy with this edition. Anyone who wants the same Warhammer 40,000 setting at a larger scale can look to Warhammer 40,000 itself, which the same discussion describes as a bigger hobby with more models, more rules, and far more involved setup. Age of Sigmar is another large-scale option within Games Workshop's range.
For a smaller, quicker Games Workshop skirmish, Rodney Smith points to Shadespire, whose models Smith says can be put together almost instantly. Readers who already know Malifaux or War Machine will recognize the small-gang style, though reviewers note that the models assemble more easily. Rodney Smith also cites Blood Bowl as a model for how Games Workshop has released team-based boxed games with occasional additional teams, which Smith hopes will be the pattern for the other Necromunda houses.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"When you go into combat with a guy that you created, like an RPG character that you are invested in, it becomes a personal thing for you, and that guy starts to have a story of his own."
— Rolling Dice & Taking Names
"The whole game just plays out like a gigantic action sequence and just a big action movie and tons of fun. … There's tons of dice rolling, it's really crunchy, there's a lot of little rules and stuff here and there."
— Board Game Replay
"Right now we have a copy of a game to give away, Necromunda Underhive, which will represent lots of miniatures for somebody else to have to put together."
— Watch It Played