Professor Evil and The Citadel of Time Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Professor Evil and The Citadel of Time
Professor Evil and The Citadel of Time is a 2017 cooperative heist game for two to four players, designed by Matthew Dunstan and Brett J. Gilbert and published by Passport Games. Players sneak through the mansion of a time-traveling thief and try to recover four stolen artifacts before he hides them. Reviewers agree that the rules are simple to learn and that the physical production is strong. They split on whether the game's randomness and thin theme are features or flaws.
The most detailed discussion comes from the Rolling Dice and Taking Names episode hosted by Marty, where the group spent a session with the game and came away calling it a keeper for casual groups that hardcore players could also enjoy. Their view is that the dice-driven movement of the professor is what makes the puzzle tense. The Dice Tower's Tom Vassel takes a briefer look, describing the game as a fun, light cooperative experience.
The sharpest critique comes from Actualol. That reviewer found the rules easy to get into but felt the mechanics overwhelmed the theme, and found the professor's movement too unpredictable to plan around. This disagreement is the clearest split in the community. It centers on whether careful planning is rewarded or whether the dice dominate the outcome.
Core Mechanics That Define Professor Evil and The Citadel of Time
Asymmetric Player Powers
Every player follows the same core rules but receives a unique power that bends one part of the game in their favor. Actualol notes that one player is strong with switches and another with doors, so the team has to coordinate who handles which part of the mansion. The Rolling Dice and Taking Names hosts stress that the powers should be chosen with synergy in mind, since each one is different and the group gets more out of them when the abilities support one another. One host's power let them shift loot tokens around the clock, and moving a token the other way could be traded for two extra actions, which made the powers feel like tactical options rather than simple bonuses.
The Clock and the Dice-Driven Professor
The center of the board is an analog clock. Loot tokens sit on the clock at positions that show how much time remains before the professor reaches them, and a black pawn moves around the dial as the game progresses. When the pawn reaches a loot token, the professor captures that treasure. The team must reach each item before the pawn does. After the players finish their actions, the professor moves according to dice: one die advances the clock, and two others determine his direction and distance. Actualol explains that he closes doors that players have opened and reactivates switches they have turned off. The Rolling Dice and Taking Names episode adds that anyone who shares a room with him is ejected from the house and must crawl back in through a window on a later action.
The Professor Evil and The Citadel of Time Experience
A Ticking Clock That Keeps the Table Moving
Reviewers describe a steady sense of urgency that comes from watching the black pawn close in on a loot token. The Rolling Dice and Taking Names hosts describe the clock as a visible countdown, and one host admits they had to hurry to reach a treasure before it was taken. Teams spend their turns debating which action to take first, which player should move, and whether a particular card is worth keeping. That shared decision-making gives the countdown a cooperative rather than solitary feel.
Frustration as Part of the Puzzle
The other dominant feeling is frustration with the professor's movement. Actualol describes watching a carefully planned turn get reversed by a single roll, and the Rolling Dice and Taking Names episode admits that players felt the same frustration when the professor kept standing in the rooms they needed. The episode defends the randomness, arguing that without it the game would be a straightforward puzzle. Players who lose their first game are encouraged to keep going, since the team that lost its first game learned the powers and the professor's habits over time.
What Makes Professor Evil and The Citadel of Time Stand Out
Production Quality
Multiple reviewers single out the physical product. The Rolling Dice and Taking Names episode praises the thick boards and tokens with embossed emblems rather than stickers, calling the production top-notch for a simpler cooperative game. Actualol also describes the production as very good and the character art as strong, although that reviewer found the board's graphic design hard to read.
Scalable Difficulty for Repeat Play
The game ships with an easier and a harder setup. The hard mode requires deactivating three sets of traps instead of two, and places the most difficult loot about 30 minutes from the black pawn. The Rolling Dice and Taking Names hosts note that the game gets easier with repeated play, but they do not expect it to become trivial. Groups that find the game too easy can add advanced rules that give the professor a better chance of reaching the loot first. That flexibility is why the hosts argue that a co-op game should resist easy wins.
Potential Drawbacks
Randomness That Can Undo Planned Turns
Actualol's most serious objection is that the professor's dice roll can reverse several turns of work in one move. The reviewer described a sequence in which one player opened a route, the next player tried the same approach, and the professor's movement canceled each effort until someone finally succeeded. The reviewer felt this leaves less room for clever cooperation, and preferred a game like Pandemic, where threats are more predictable. The Rolling Dice and Taking Names hosts acknowledge the same frustration but treat it as intentional, so whether this drawback bothers a group depends heavily on how much uncertainty that group enjoys.
A Theme That Does Not Land for Everyone
Actualol felt that the idea of breaking into a mansion to recover historical artifacts never fully came through in play. The reviewer described the game as feeling mechanical, with the systems creating an artificial challenge that does not match the story. The same reviewer found the board's color palette hard to read visually, which made it harder to pick out the next step. Players who care most about narrative immersion should keep these reactions in mind before buying.
If You Enjoy Professor Evil and The Citadel of Time
Players who want a light cooperative game with simple rules should consider Forbidden Island. Actualol explicitly compares Professor Evil to it, describing a similar level of complexity and a shared focus on racing a timer to collect objects while sharing actions with teammates. Groups who want more thematic weight than Forbidden Island offers may find Professor Evil more satisfying, while groups who want the threat to be fully predictable may prefer the more stable structure of Forbidden Island. The choice comes down to whether the thrill of an unpredictable villain or a steadier cooperative challenge appeals more to your table.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"For me, the biggest highlight was that whole time mechanic. I thought that was just really neat, how the loot tokens sit on the clock. You see how much time you have in order to go grab that loot, and then that black token that moves basically on the professor's turn. It just shows us like a ticking clock."
— Marty, Rolling Dice and Taking Names
"It feels very mechanical. What you're doing, it just feels like the game mechanisms are creating this artificial environment to make it difficult without it making any real sense with the theme."
— Actualol
"Professor Evil in the Citadel of Time is a fun cooperative game where you're trying to stop this evil professor. You know he's evil because it's in the name, and it's a decent light, lighter-weight cooperative game."
— Tom Vassel, The Dice Tower