Santorini: New York Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Santorini: New York
Reviewers see Santorini: New York as a reworking of the original Santorini that swaps Greek mythology for turn-of-the-century Manhattan and adds a shared layer of chaos on top of the familiar move-and-build core. Edo of Gaming with Edo & Jessica calls it a game that is legitimately a two to five player game, and Edo praises the production, especially the components, the buildings, and the cars. Tom Vasel of The Dice Tower gives it an 8 out of 10 in the Look Back series and argues that it works better with more people than the original does. Vasel does find the title awkward, noting that it is set in New York because it is based on Santorini, and admits the name makes little sense on its own.
Core Mechanics That Define Santorini: New York
Initiative and the Statue of Liberty
Each round, players play a role card face down, and the lowest number goes first. The highest number takes the Statue of Liberty, and Edo points out that only the player holding the Statue can win the round. Because that player acts last, everyone else gets to move before them, which creates a natural pressure to gang up on the leader. Edo describes it as a dynamic where the win conditions are easy but only available to one player, so the rest of the table has to stop the Statue holder without letting them reach the top.
Move, Build, and Role Card Powers
On a turn, players move a worker and then build, climbing structures one level at a time without skipping levels. A player wins by ending a turn on a third-level structure while holding the Statue, and capping a building makes it impassable, which gradually blocks positions. Role card powers change the routine. The Ironworker must build in two different spaces, the NYPD Officer can push an opposing worker one space straight back, and the Subway Operator must move in a straight line to the first unoccupied space. Edo also notes that the Engineer must build a massive building at the start of the turn and can win by building a rooftop, which is a second way to finish.
The Santorini: New York Experience
Dynamic Tactics Rather Than Locked Strategy
Edo describes the game's feel as dynamic tactics. Because players draw role cards and cannot know exactly which abilities the others will have, it is harder to plan far ahead, and the game does not lock up the way the original can. Edo is careful to say this is not a deeper strategic experience, but it rewards reading the table and reacting to what other players are able to do.
Quick Games That Scale With the Table
Edo says a game can be finished in a few rounds, and that players can approach it competitively or keep it light. Edo sees the roll call system as a clever answer to the question of how to support more players in a way that stays fun. Tom Vasel likewise says the game feels loose in a way that suits larger groups, while still working well with just two.
What Makes Santorini: New York Stand Out
Production Value and Artwork
Edo calls the production incredible and praises the components and buildings in particular. Tom Vasel singles out the artwork of the New Yorkers, saying that the illustrations work well for the setting. The presentation gives the game a strong identity even for players who already know the base mechanics.
Role Card Variety
Edo emphasizes how different the role cards are from one another, noting that there are many of them and that each changes how the game plays. Edo says the way the cards are dealt and used makes the game stand apart from its predecessor, even for players who have spent plenty of time with Santorini and will recognize much of the structure.
Potential Drawbacks
Less Strategic Depth Than the Original
Edo acknowledges that Santorini: New York is not as deeply strategic or as deeply tactical as the original. Tom Vasel is more direct, saying it is not as good as Santorini, though Vasel still recommends it for its own strengths. Players who want the tight, predictable planning of the base game may find this edition looser than they would like.
Blocked Positions and Sudden Endings
Edo points out that the game gets more restrictive as builds accumulate, with fewer and fewer options as players become more blocked in. A player can get stuck and be unable to win. The fast pace also means a game can end quickly if someone misses a line of attack, which Edo describes as part of the appeal but which can frustrate players who prefer a slower, more controlled finish.
If You Enjoy Santorini: New York
Reviewers consistently treat Santorini as the reference point. Edo notes that players who know Santorini well will recognize much of the move-and-build structure, but the role cards and the Statue of Liberty change how each game unfolds. Tom Vasel says that Santorini is best with two players, while this edition works better as the player count rises. Edo's advice is to start with Santorini: New York if you have never played the original and prefer games that are not head-to-head, and to stick with Santorini if you like abstract two-player play with one regular opponent. Edo also says the two games do not replace each other, which makes this edition a good companion for players who enjoy the original's tighter design.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"it has what i like called dynamic tactics"
— Gaming with Edo & Jessica
"It actually works better for multiplayers."
— The Dice Tower
"It's not as good as the original Santorini, but it plays better with multiple players."
— The Dice Tower