Shadows of Brimstone: Forbidden Fortress Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Shadows of Brimstone: Forbidden Fortress
Reviewers treat Shadows of Brimstone: Forbidden Fortress as a strong standalone entry point into the wider Shadows of Brimstone system, and the praise is consistent across channels. On The Dice Tower, Joey Evans gave the box a nine and called it a great starting point for players who do not yet own the earlier sets. The channel's weekly roundup, also on The Dice Tower, scored it a nine and highlighted the new characters, new monsters, and added melee focus. Meet Me at the Table approaches the box from the other direction, playing it as a long-running narrative where the story grows across many sessions rather than as a single evening's game.
The areas of agreement are clear. Reviewers find the monsters more distinctive than those in earlier sets, they welcome rules text that clarifies how status effects compound, and they regard the miniatures as a major draw. Disagreement centers on how well the system works outside a campaign. Joey Evans argued that single scenarios do not show the game at its best, and the practical complaints about tracking and record keeping came up repeatedly in the playthrough coverage.
Core Mechanics That Define Shadows of Brimstone: Forbidden Fortress
The Darkness and the Depth Track
The escape scenario played in the Meet Me at the Table video shows how the box turns exploration into a race against a rising threat. The party marker moves along a depth track that starts at 15, and each exploration token bearing a clue icon advances the marker while adding an extra threat card to that encounter. Each round the group must Hold Back the Darkness with a dice roll against a target number, and a failed roll pushes the darkness further. Growing dread cards are revealed immediately in this mission rather than being stacked for later, so the whole group must decide on the spot whether it can afford to spend grit to cancel them. Once the marker is low enough on the track, the heroes can roll for the fortress entrance, and the mission turns on whether they can burst through the gates before the darkness closes in.
Scavenging, Grit, and Loot
Between fights, heroes peer into rooms, draw from the Shadows of Brimstone deck, and scavenge by rolling three six-sided dice, where each six produces a find. Meet Me at the Table pointed out that the scavenge deck has no discard pile, so the group reshuffles after each draw, and that every loot card drawn is a separate reward for the characters who took part in the fight. Grit, which each hero starts with, lets players reroll dice, add movement, or recover from injuries. Joey Evans cautioned that scavenging is a weak choice in a simple scenario because the results split roughly into thirds of bad, neutral, and good outcomes. The reviewer's view is that the loot economy only pays off when gold accumulates across a campaign.
The Shadows of Brimstone: Forbidden Fortress Experience
A Campaign That Grows Heroes Over Time
Joey Evans described the box as a dungeon crawl with role-playing layers, where heroes grow stronger across missions instead of resetting after each session. Experience comes from scavenging, defeating enemies, scouting rooms, and healing allies, and the Meet Me at the Table group tracked those totals on paper for each hero. Injuries carry forward as well. A concussion imposes negative one initiative and removes a die from skill tests, while a broken collarbone lowers the maximum grit a hero can hold. Downed characters in that playthrough were rescued by returning allies and entered the next mission with their scars, which reviewers found rewarding because the narrative moves with the mechanics.
Pressure That Never Fully Lets Up
Reviewers describe the fortress as a place where no formation feels safe. Joey Evans singled out the Tengu, whose flight and movement let it strike heroes standing at the back of a group, and the Harionago, whose animated hair hits every hero within three spaces at the end of its move. Meet Me at the Table felt that squeeze during the escape scenario, where the darkness closes in around the party and the mission cannot be fled as it could in other scenarios. The result is a steady sense of urgency, with heroes constantly weighing whether to press forward, scavenge for resources, or stop and recover.
What Makes Shadows of Brimstone: Forbidden Fortress Stand Out
Miniatures and Artwork
The box's 27 multi-piece hard plastic miniatures receive consistent praise. Joey Evans called the detail on the monk, the oni, and the living statue impressive, and noted that assembly is simple enough to be relaxing. The double-sided map tiles, which offer the Japanese Fortress and Belly of the Beast sides, also drew comment, with Joey Evans describing the artwork as gorgeous on both sides and praising how well the tiles fit the theme. The result is a physical presentation that reviewers say sets the expansion apart from the earlier, more generic-feeling monster lineup.
Mix-and-Match Design Across the Line
Reviewers praised how cleanly the box plugs into existing Shadows of Brimstone collections. Joey Evans said the heroes and monsters can be placed into other systems, and the portal structure of the map deck makes it natural for characters from other sets to appear in the fortress. The rulebook also earned praise. According to Joey Evans, it clarifies how status effects compound and tightens monster targeting, so a group can no longer hide behind a single hero. The emphasis on melee heroes such as the samurai, ninja, and assassin was seen as a fresh direction for the series, while the sorceress and monk keep ranged and support roles in the party.
Potential Drawbacks
Bookkeeping Asks a Lot of the Group
The clearest practical complaint came from Meet Me at the Table, where the host repeatedly forgot ability details and character-sheet effects during the playthrough. Items purchased in the feudal village, such as a kimono that adds health and sanity, exist only as notes on paper, and the host said that cards for town purchases would make the game easier to track. Joey Evans also noted that the components slide around in the insert, which led to bagging the pieces before play. Groups that track experience, grit, dark stones, and injuries across many sessions should expect a fair amount of record keeping.
Scenarios Show Less of the System
Some reviewers feel that the strongest version of the game requires a campaign. Joey Evans argued that scavenging is unrewarding in simple scenarios and that the progression only becomes compelling once gold and experience accumulate. Meet Me at the Table also showed how a single escape mission can take a long time to reach its payoff, since the depth track starts at 15 and must be worked down before the entrance can be sought. The monsters are punishing as well. The oni is described as brutal, the Dishonored Dead defend themselves better than expected, and the living statue is a tough fight, so new groups should expect to lose ground early.
If You Enjoy Shadows of Brimstone: Forbidden Fortress
Players who enjoy the campaign-driven progression and the mix-and-match heroes will find the same core loop in the base Shadows of Brimstone game, which reviewers treat as the foundation for the whole line.
- Shadows of Brimstone: City of Ancients: Players who appreciate the heroes and monsters of Forbidden Fortress will find a useful contrast in City of Ancients. Joey Evans described it as the Old West counterpart with more ranged emphasis, so it suits players who want to move away from the melee-heavy party.
- Shadows of Brimstone: City of Angels: Players who like bringing characters from different sets into one campaign will enjoy City of Angels, which Joey Evans said sits comfortably in the same collection as Forbidden Fortress.
- Shadows of Brimstone: Feudal Japan: Players drawn to the folklore monsters such as the Tengu and the oni will find the same Japanese mythic tone in the Feudal Japan setting, which is the theme at the heart of this box.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"That's one thing about this, is this system's been thousands of people play this, and because of that they have a large community of feedback, and Flying Frog, to their benefit and to their credit, they actually listen. So they do kind of change this, and it kind of progresses and it gets better and better and better."
— Joey Evans, The Dice Tower
"Of course you do have to assemble them all and of course paint them yourself, but it's once you get them done, it's pretty satisfying."
— Meet Me at the Table
"New characters, new monsters, and a bit more melee. Definitely check that out if you know about Shadows of Brimstone, or if you don't and you'd like to see something in this theme."
— The Dice Tower