Ships Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Ships
Community reaction to Ships, Martin Wallace's 2015 trading game published by Tree Frog Games, is measured rather than enthusiastic. The reviews that address it treat it as a competent, thoughtful strategy title that is worth playing without being a headline favorite. The Dice Tower's Tom Vassel calls it a solid Euro style game about building ships and moving them across the map, and in a later retrospective Vassel gives it a 7 out of 10 and describes it as a good strategy game within Wallace's catalog. That middle position is the closest thing to a consensus.
The sharpest reservations come from Drive Thru Games, which says Ships is not really its kind of game because of technology obsolescence. Drive Thru Games ties that complaint to train and stock games in the 18XX family, where older equipment suddenly becomes useless when the game moves into a later stage, questioning why an old asset should stop working just because something newer exists. Drive Thru Games still finds Ships more coherent on this point than 18XX, because a small wooden vessel really is outclassed once a battleship arrives. The disagreement is therefore less about whether the design works and more about whether the obsolescence theme appeals to a given player.
Drive Thru Games also expresses hope that Ships will return in a new edition, which suggests reviewers see more potential in the design than the existing print run has realized.
Core Mechanics That Define Ships
Ship Building and Movement Across the Map
The central activity in Ships is building ships and moving them across the map. Tom Vassel places the game in a transport series from Martin Wallace that includes Planes and Automobiles, and Drive Thru Games describes Ships as a riff on the Automobiles design with its vehicles transplanted onto the sea. Drive Thru also notes that the game blends this transport focus with the feel of a civilization game, which Drive Thru cites as the reason the design feels distinct from a straight vehicle game.
Obsolescence Across the Ages
Obsolescence is the mechanic reviewers discuss most directly. Drive Thru Games explains that in 18XX games a trigger, such as a particular round or an action taken by a player, can make level one and level two trains worthless and force players onto later equipment. In Ships, the same kind of decline applies to the vessels players build, and the reviewer argues that it fits the theme better because a small wooden boat is plainly overmatched by a battleship. The game's three ages, galley, galleon, and steamship, provide the historical frame in which this decline unfolds.
The Ships Experience
A Deliberate Euro Strategy Feel
Reviewers describe Ships as a solid Euro style experience, and Tom Vassel's assessments emphasize its strategic soundness rather than spectacle. The feel is measured and methodical, and the reviews point toward players who enjoy strategy-first games over dramatic swings.
A Sweeping Historical Scale
Drive Thru Games frames Ships as a civilization style game that moves through a long arc of maritime history, from galleys to steamships. The reviewer calls the way the design handles that arc "very unique and cool," even while saying the obsolescence theme is not a personal preference.
What Makes Ships Stand Out
A Thematic Approach to Decline
The most consistently praised idea is how Ships treats older equipment. Drive Thru Games argues that the way Ships handles obsolescence is more sensible than the train game equivalent, because a vessel that is useless against a battleship is simply outdated, not broken. Reviewers who find the mechanic off-putting in other games may still respect this version for its internal logic.
Its Place in Martin Wallace's Transport Series
Both Drive Thru Games and Tom Vassel place Ships within a family of transport games from Martin Wallace, and Tom Vassel describes it as the last entry in that line after Planes and Automobiles. For players who already know Wallace's designs, Ships offers a recognizable approach applied to a maritime setting.
Potential Drawbacks
Obsolescence Is Not Every Player's Taste
The most direct criticism is that obsolescence is a theme some players find frustrating. Drive Thru Games expresses a dislike for the idea that functional equipment must stop being used simply because newer equipment arrives, and that objection carries over to Ships even though the naval version is found more convincing. Players who value the continued usefulness of their investments may find the design less satisfying than its strategic core suggests.
A Modest Enthusiasm Ceiling
Reviewers rarely describe Ships as a favorite. Tom Vassel's 7 out of 10 rating in a later retrospective, and the description of it as a fine strategy game, indicate respect without excitement, and the coverage of the game stays brief rather than enthusiastic. Players looking for a title that earns a reviewer's strongest recommendation may find the tone here more measured than they'd like.
If You Enjoy Ships
Reviewers most often point to Automobiles as the closest relative, since Drive Thru Games describes Ships as a riff on that design with its vehicles moved onto the sea. Fans who appreciate the transport focus and Wallace's measured approach to economic play will likely find the same qualities in Automobiles, and Tom Vassel's account of the series also names Planes, which shares the transport theme and the Euro style pacing of Ships. Players interested in the obsolescence mechanic in its original context should look at 18XX, which Drive Thru Games uses as the reference point for how train games handle outdated equipment. Those who share that objection may prefer Ships' more coherent treatment of the same idea.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"Ships is weird. It's kind of like a riff on his Automobiles game, but it's with ships in the sea. But it's also like a civilization game. So the way this thing does it is just very unique and cool."
— Drive Thru Games
"Ships was from a series of games Martin Wallace did, Planes, Automobiles and Ships, I think. Um, I think that's what they were called. And Ships was one about building ships and moving across from Tree Frog Games came out 2015, a solid Euro style game."
— Tom Vassel, The Dice Tower
"This is from Martin Wallace's series. I think he was trying to do a planes, trains, and automobiles. I mean, he's done train for years. Then he did a game called Automobiles. And then his last one was ships. Um, ships is a fine game. It's a it's a good strategy game for Martin Walls."
— Tom Vassel, The Dice Tower