Skip to main content
Sleuth box art

Sleuth

Game Info
Year
1971
Players
3-7
Age
10+
Playtime
45 min
Publisher
The Avalon Hill Game Co, 3M, Kärnan
Collection
Ratings
Mechanic profile
Waiting on more creator content
Vibe profile
How this game feels to play
Description

In Sleuth, a classic deduction game from master designer Sid Sackson originally released as part of the 3M Gamette Series, players are searching for a hidden gem, one of 36 gem cards hidden before the start of the game. The remainder of this gem deck – with each card showing 1-3 diamonds, pearls or opals in one of four colors – is distributed evenly among the players, with any remaining cards laid face up. Thus, you and everyone else starts with some information about what's not missing.

A second deck contains 54 search cards, each showing one or two elements, such as diamonds, pairs, blue opals, red pearls, or an element of your choice. Each player receives four face-up search cards; on a turn, you choose one of those cards and ask an opponent how many gem cards they have of the type shown. If you ask for, say, pairs, the player must tell you how many pairs they hold but not which specific pairs; if you ask for something more specific, say, red diamonds, the player reveals to everyone how many such cards she holds while you get to look at them in secret.

Players track information on a score pad. You can guess the hidden gem at any time, or on your turn you can ask any one question regardless of which search cards you have, then immediately make a guess by marking your sheet and checking the hidden gem card. If you're wrong, you keep playing but can only answer questions; if you're correct, you win.

The simplicity of the rules and the cards belies the complexity of the game. In some cases you see cards, while in others you hear only the number of cards that an opponent holds, making it tough to deduce. Any notation system you devise must be both flexible and reliable, recording negative information as well as positive in order to tick off the possibilities one by one...

Reimplements:

The Case of the Elusive Assassin, with the core mechanisms of that game being used in Sleuth, minus the game board, movement and player proximity.

Description

In Sleuth, a classic deduction game from master designer Sid Sackson originally released as part of the 3M Gamette Series, players are searching for a hidden gem, one of 36 gem cards hidden before the start of the game. The remainder of this gem deck – with each card showing 1-3 diamonds, pearls or opals in one of four colors – is distributed evenly among the players, with any remaining cards laid face up. Thus, you and everyone else starts with some information about what's not missing.

A second deck contains 54 search cards, each showing one or two elements, such as diamonds, pairs, blue opals, red pearls, or an element of your choice. Each player receives four face-up search cards; on a turn, you choose one of those cards and ask an opponent how many gem cards they have of the type shown. If you ask for, say, pairs, the player must tell you how many pairs they hold but not which specific pairs; if you ask for something more specific, say, red diamonds, the player reveals to everyone how many such cards she holds while you get to look at them in secret.

Players track information on a score pad. You can guess the hidden gem at any time, or on your turn you can ask any one question regardless of which search cards you have, then immediately make a guess by marking your sheet and checking the hidden gem card. If you're wrong, you keep playing but can only answer questions; if you're correct, you win.

The simplicity of the rules and the cards belies the complexity of the game. In some cases you see cards, while in others you hear only the number of cards that an opponent holds, making it tough to deduce. Any notation system you devise must be both flexible and reliable, recording negative information as well as positive in order to tick off the possibilities one by one...

Reimplements:

The Case of the Elusive Assassin, with the core mechanisms of that game being used in Sleuth, minus the game board, movement and player proximity.

Ask a Rules Question
All mentions
Browse transcript mentions, sentiments, pros/cons, mechanics, topics, quotes, and references.
Total mentions: 10
This page: 10
Sentiment: pos 10 · mix 0 · neu 0 · neg 0
Mentions per page
Showing 1–10 of 10
Video QbfUpKCTfXE Chairman of the Board Other at 19:49 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Sleuth video thumbnail
Click to watch at 19:49 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
none
Cons
none
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deduction — classic deduction game
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • guests which is a great deduction game
  • cartographers pergamon uh karuba and Miyabi these are from the hobby uh habba line
  • the quacks of quettenberg I believe with one expansion inside
  • favorite of the Pharaoh so this is actually a Tom Lehmann um dice rolling game like a yahtzee variant but with loads of player powers and things you can acquire I'm surprised this one didn't take off because it actually has quite a lot of things that tend to be popular so maybe there is um you know this is going to be a bit of a sleeper and there might be a reprint or something which will inject some life into it
  • a Savannah Park hits a table table off and often for me
  • mysterium now this has my copy of detective Club in it as well um if you want a Dixit variant Style game um this is a kind of my go-to box
  • Marrakech concept which is another party game
  • first enroll which is an American football Style game
  • Sheriff of Nottingham this is the is it the first edition or second edition I think it's the first edition with the expansion
  • Ship Shape Can't Stop we have the bunk uh fantastic factories dice minor five minute mystery uh Cryptid tumble Town Martinique and psychic Pizza deliverers go to the ghost town which I didn't really like
  • get on board Patchwork Rapido which is brilliant um kind of pushy luck game
  • shanghai-en a heroba Hashi and next station London
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Ul4TPbxB8cM Chairman of the Board Top List at 18:47 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Sleuth video thumbnail
Click to watch at 18:47 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • brain burner deduction Style game
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • deduction
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deduction — brain burner deduction Style game
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • number 176 I have push down from 142 last year I think a main reason for that is because I got Rapido into my collection which is kind of my my Forefront push your luck Style game where push did have that place so it's kind of been replaced for that reason but I'll keep hold of this one because it is a very fun game with really um really tense moments
  • number 177 I have Shakespeare down from 1 to7 so again this is always going to be towards the bottom of my accomodations because I can never make it go below a 7 out of 10 but I kind of played it so much that I don't need to play it anymore um a great game as you're trying to Clans these tracks kind of um acquire these actors and put them in costumes but the thing I really love about this game is the initiative mechanism where you can bid to have fewer actions in order to go first I don't really see that very often and and it works to a te here and also has one of the best expansions I've ever seen
  • number 185 I have Arc NOA so um probably the most controversial one here huge fall from number 48 last year now I think arova is fantastic let's get that make that clear um the card play is great the Tableau building is fantastic it's just too long for me and my gaming group you know you're looking at three three and a half hours here it's very rare I'll play a game that's that long and if I am going to play a game that long I want it to be in my top 10 you know so for that reason you know length is very important for me a game length
  • finally on this list at number 189 I have colum um down from number 149 the year prior this is a negotiation auction Style game as you're trying to put on these Grand displays um in the Coliseum um to trying to draw Spectators a great scoring mechanism here as every round you'll score your performance but only your best performance after each round or or overall rounds will be your actual score so it kind of has this kind of um TI line style mechanism which is really unique and you don't really see it very often at all and I prefer this one to the original which is the princess of Florence which actually played this year I mean this is I had this game on my list for many many years now and it's actually getting reprinted I think next year so you know if there if this one appeals to you then um check out Coliseum you a great theme there um
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video JHgbYSlmL0I Chairman of the Board Top List at 22:45 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Sleuth video thumbnail
Click to watch at 22:45 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
Positive
Pros
  • Pure and simple deduction
  • Works well with fixed questions
  • Can be a blast to play
Cons
  • Can be brain-burning
  • Fragile like many deduction games; a wrong clue can break it
Thematic elements
  • Deduction
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deduction — trying to deduce what the missing gem is from this deck of cards
  • question asking — you actually have four different options in which you can ask to any player anytime so you do not have to actually think of the questions you have fixed questions you can ask
  • Set Collection — gems themselves you've got like diamonds you've got opals and pearls they come in different cluster types you get like threes twos and ones and they also come in different colors
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • this is a hidden role or at least a secret identity tug-of-war style game
  • i quite like the concept of this game and it looks absolutely fantastic as you say this game is wonderfully produced the artwork is out of this world and it looks great
  • i thought the gameplay had some serious issues i thought this was like beyond tactical there was no degree or forward planning here
  • unfortunately despite looking wonderful you know this was kind of all bells or all sizzle and no steak at all
  • pretty light little tableau builder or engine building dice rolling game
  • i think this game lacks quite a lot in terms of mitigation so you're pretty much quite a big subject to the luck of the dice rolls on this one
  • ultra light roll and right style game that actually comes with four different maps or four different types of shoots you can play with all represented by a different season
  • it's really simple fun it's 15 minutes and the decisions you have in this 15 minutes are pretty strong to be honest
  • cooperative train logistics game
  • for a cooperative game this one has a completely different niche and a different feel to any game out there
  • the oldest game by far on this list from 1971 i have sleuth which is a sid saxon classic deduction style game
  • this is as pure as deduction gets
  • it can be pretty brain burnery if you don't you know denote things perfectly on a player sheet
  • this is the updated version or the re-implementation of let's make a bus route
  • i love the way you can have long threads of strategy here
  • a really breezy experience get paid in 30 minutes good decisions
  • this is the kind of sequel or the next in line from the blitzkrieg system
  • one of the best examples of a streamlined area majority area control style game
  • it just pulls it off to a very high standard i was massively impressed with the way this plays a tremendous amount of depth to be had in 20 minutes
  • an ultra cutthroat bidding auction style game and with a really strong economic edge to it
  • this is a dynamic game where one minute you're in a strong position the next minute you're in a weak position
  • i like the level of interaction in this game because you actually do things and you're buying things not only to hurt other people but when you hurt other people you are actually helping yourself
  • a bit of a classic euro with saint petersburg
  • this has been a grail game for me for a long time very hard to come by nowadays
  • it's so clever and it's one of those games that's definitely better than the sum of its parts
  • a throwback worker placement game beige euro all mechanisms no artwork they're very boring and bland to look at but i'll tell you what the gameplay here is outstanding
  • the economy in this game is very tight money is a really hard resource to manage
  • i love that pack as passing mechanism i think it's probably my favorite feature of the game
  • you can be a bit of a dick and go to a spot and just just to do it to cut other people off off their workplace and spot to make them waste waste their money and waste their time from placing that worker
  • the game itself built around that is wonderfully well designed
  • i think the only slight thing that's wrong with it is that it does take a little bit too long i would like it to be you know 10 to 15 maybe even 20 shorter
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video sFpfr_R-bcM Chairman of the Board Top List at 7:06 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Sleuth video thumbnail
Click to watch at 7:06 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Pure deduction genre
  • Rewarding experience when solved
  • No fat on the game, no excess rules
Cons
  • Can be fragile if mistakes are made
  • Taxing and requires careful note-taking
Thematic elements
  • Deduction
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deduction — Players try to deduce which card has been taken out of the deck by asking questions to other players using question cards.
  • Information gathering — Players map everything out and try to work out what people could physically have.
  • question asking — Players are restricted by their hand when asking questions, for example 'How many green Opals do you have?'
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • five board games that despite being old are still fantastic
  • these ones still hold their own in the marketplace and deserve to be hitting your table
  • definitely one of the strongest um bluffing games I've ever played
  • it's such a fun and Ruckus experience that I absolutely love
  • considered and I personally consider it one of the pillars of forefathers of the two player only genre of games
  • your hand limit is really tight in this game and everything you do feels excruciating and meaningful
  • it does have this real cool visceral tension
  • there's some great laugh out loud moments with this game
  • when you actually solve the mystery get it correct it is just such a you know a rewarding experience
  • this for me is still up there probably my top two deduction games
  • there aren't many economic games that are better than a choir
  • it's always nice to kind of show a bit of appreciation to the games that laid the path to a lot of these newer games coming out there
  • often the older ones are just as good if not better than the new ones
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video iq5tvE3apYY Actualol Top List at 6:24 sentiment: positive
Actualol - Sleuth video thumbnail
Click to watch at 6:24 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • A cleverer version of deduction games.
  • Simple and streamlined.
  • Very smart piece of game design.
  • Feels very contemporary.
Cons
  • The theme of finding the missing gem is a little bit boring.
  • While still fun, other deduction games might be preferred today.
Thematic elements
  • Trying to find the missing gem by identifying its properties (type, color, cluster).
Comparison games
  • Cluedo
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deduction — Players ask questions of other players by playing cards to deduce which gem is missing.
  • Hidden Information — Players have information about gems and must deduce what is missing.
  • Set Collection — Players are trying to identify a set of properties for a missing gem (type, color, cluster).
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It is absolutely a storytelling game.
  • It is known in some circles as Sherlock Holmes insulting detective because he's not polite about it.
  • Sherlock still stands the test of time and, you know, 40 years on it's like it's brilliant.
  • Perhaps inevitably this is the third Sid Saxon game on the list. Absolutely the number one.
  • This is a proper grown-up game for proper grown-ups, though simple enough for kids to play.
  • It is not just a classic. It's still a banger.
  • I'm on a mission to convince people that they really ought to try this 60-year-old game.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video Gtgf5laI5vo Chairman of the Board Unboxing at 1:37 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Sleuth video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:37 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Hoped to elevate the original game with more life
Cons
  • Original had limited replayability
Thematic elements
none
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Dice Drafting — The host mentions the original game, Santa Maria, is a great little dice drafter.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • I just got back from the UK Games Expo. I had a great time as always and I just wanted to make a quick video talking about all of the games that I acquired during the expo.
  • The brig and buy was was great, but it was very chaotic and long long cues and longer than we've had before.
  • So, definitely um was at capacity. Yeah, the brig and buy was was great, but it was very chaotic and long long cues and longer than we've had before.
  • So, I definitely recommend going at least once if you have the faintest bit of interest.
  • But for everybody else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye-bye.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video bk5hYfcrR_w The Dice Tower Top List at 17:15 sentiment: positive
The Dice Tower - Sleuth video thumbnail
Click to watch at 17:15 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Difficult and complex deduction
  • A strong entry from Sid Sackson
Cons
none
Thematic elements
  • Deduction
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deduction — Players deduce the location of gems based on information gathered during play.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • It's all about the narration, the story, the the you know, and that's I still get caught up in this map.
  • It was called Remote Possibilities.
  • Scotland Yard, it just it's one of those games that's way ahead of its time.
  • Sid Sackson was Way ahead of his time.
  • This game almost just This started a genre, but then didn't.
  • Cosmic Encounter is the or one of the original asymmetric games.
  • Also introduced the traitor mechanism, which was a really cool concept that again didn't really become a thing till years later.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video pvLRYH87eFE TheGameBoyGeek - Hi Quality Hi Energy Board Game Reviews Analysis at 2:52 sentiment: positive
TheGameBoyGeek - Hi Quality Hi Energy Board Game Reviews - Sleuth video thumbnail
Click to watch at 2:52 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • streamlined from Clue’s original mechanics
  • very strong pure deduction experience
Cons
  • some randomness was removed but still present via cards
Thematic elements
  • crime investigation and logic
  • A murder mystery with a streamlined deduction system
  • pure deduction with minimal randomness
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deduction — Logic puzzle where players deduce the murderer based on given questions.
  • questioning constraints — Asks predetermined questions and deduces through a constrained set of possibilities.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Clue even inspired an entire genre of games called social deduction.
  • This is an absolute masterpiece.
  • Sleuth... best straight logic pure deduction games out there.
  • An art interpretation game, similar to say Dixit.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video wDcFroePx8g TheGameBoyGeek - Hi Quality Hi Energy Board Game Reviews Top List at 11:05 sentiment: positive
TheGameBoyGeek - Hi Quality Hi Energy Board Game Reviews - Sleuth video thumbnail
Click to watch at 11:05 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Grandfather of game design, Sid Sackson.
  • Pure deduction.
  • Interesting because the person has to answer.
  • Elegant in the 70s is ridiculous.
  • Absolute classic.
  • Strips out all the stuff we don't like about Clue but puts in the stuff you like it and makes it better.
Cons
  • There's a little randomness in like which questions you get.
  • You can get kind of like a bad draw at some point.
  • That's the only part that's like feels a little dated.
Thematic elements
  • Deduction to find a missing gem.
Comparison games
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • Deduction — Players ask questions and use logic to deduce the location of a missing gem.
  • Hidden Information — Players have hidden information (gems) that they reveal through questions.
  • Logic puzzle — The game is a logic puzzle solved on a sheet.
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • Drop Mix is the most amazing experience, especially if you like music.
  • This is one of the most fun I've experienced playing games.
  • Hot Streak is so much fun.
  • Skull is this great game of bluffing and double bluffing and lying and tricking your play against other players.
  • Tammy Hall is a brutal, brutal bloodbath.
  • The game is four stacks, two going down from 100 and two going up from 1 to 100, and you cooperatively try to move through the deck without telling each other what's in your hand.
  • This is a brutal tug-of-war master of design.
  • Windmill Valley packs a ton into a short play time.
  • Mondo is a frantic real-time game with tension and spatial puzzle elements packed into 15 minutes.
  • This is an absolute gem of a game.
  • It is a brutal tug-of-war
  • It's more approachable than Twilight Struggle.
  • Mechanically so simple. Um, but very challenging, very tricky, very thinky. Um, just a masterpiece, man.
  • With lots of dirty politics and slandering and backstabbing each other.
  • It's a brutal, brutal bloodbath. Don't play this if you want to stay friends with the people we're playing with.
  • Man it takes a game that was really good and makes it great because there's one action that people just don't tend to do as much and this one adds all this extra benefit from basically choosing that option.
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Video s7z-PF9khY0 Chairman of the Board Discussion at 1:15 sentiment: positive
Chairman of the Board - Sleuth video thumbnail
Click to watch at 1:15 · YouTube ↗
Overall sentiment (raw)
positive
Pros
  • Classic deduction lineage; strong social interaction
  • Scales from 3-7 players (per video)
Cons
  • Speaker has limited hands-on experience; still early in evaluation
Thematic elements
  • Detective work
  • Deduction; missing gem puzzle
  • thinky, puzzle-driven
Comparison games
none
Mechanics (from transcript analysis)
  • information reveal — information is revealed to all players as questions are asked
  • preset questions — players use preset questions to elicit information
Video topics + discussion points
No key topics recorded for this video.
Quotes (from this video)
  • "Caesar sees Rome in 20 minutes"
  • "this is like the spiritual successor or at least a sister game or a partner game to paulo maurice blitzkrieg"
  • "I believe you're investing in these companies these companies can merge with each other so it's just all about making profit"
  • "Detective Club and the expansion"
References (from this video)
No references stored for this video.
Transcript Navigation
Top
Showing 1–10 of 10
Game Deep Dive