The City of Kings Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About The City of Kings
The City of Kings inspires passionate but divided opinions among reviewers. Board to Death TV gave it a strong 9/10, calling it a "very solid game with a unique experience" that keeps players hooked from story to story. They appreciate its puzzle-like structure and the tight tactical decisions required throughout. However, Board Games UnLocked painted a more critical picture, revising their score down to a 5 or 6 after returning to the game years later. Their core issue: the game's grind-heavy progression, particularly in late scenarios, overshadows its innovative mechanics. Getting Games found the experience uneven across player counts, particularly noting that 4-player creature scaling creates brutal, seemingly unwinnable encounters. Despite these criticisms, even skeptical reviewers acknowledge the game contains genuinely cool ideas that deserve recognition.
Core Mechanics That Define The City of Kings
Worker Placement With Resource Management
Each hero commands workers who gather vital resources like wood, stone, and lumber scattered across the Ageless Realms. These resources become the currency for trading and building, creating a tight economy where every decision matters. The worker system runs parallel to your hero's combat actions, forcing constant trade-offs: should you explore more tiles for resources, or focus on getting your hero strong enough to fight the dangerous creatures threatening your progress? Board Games UnLocked highlighted this as a unique hybrid that blends worker placement strategy with RPG-style character progression in a way they had rarely seen before.
Randomized Enemy Abilities
Each creature appears from a predetermined stack, so their base stats are consistent, but what makes them lethal is unknown until you draw ability tokens from easy, medium, or hard bags. One creature might summon hounds or teleport, another might reflect damage back at you or heal itself. Board Games UnLocked called this system "stellar," noting that it transforms combat into a genuine puzzle: you see the creature's stats and abilities, and now you must figure out how to bypass them and deal with the threat. This unpredictability keeps encounters fresh within a single story and across different playthroughs.
The City of Kings Experience
Tactical Puzzle-Combat Tension
Board to Death TV captured the core appeal: "The City of Kings plunges the player in a puzzle-like chapter each time which will have the players make heartily tactical choices while keeping a watch on time and overall mission objective." Every turn requires you to weigh exploration against combat preparation, resource gathering against morale maintenance, and pushing forward against the clock. The game excels at creating moments where you must coordinate with teammates (the "Holy Trinity" of attacker, tank, and healer), debate which creatures to engage, and plan several turns ahead. Getting Games confirmed this, noting that even though the rulebook is thick, the game teaches quickly and engagement runs high during those critical early and middle encounters.
Procedurally Generated Discovery (That Wears Off)
Early in a story, the novelty of not knowing which tile you will turn over next, which quest will appear, or which creature ability you will face creates genuine excitement. Board Games UnLocked appreciated this roguelike spirit but found it a double-edged sword: the procedural generation novelty completely wears off in the grind toward boss fights. Unlike roguelikes such as Dead Cells, where runs last around an hour with instant feedback, City of Kings stories stretch 1.5 to 3 hours without a save system, turning the back half into tedious resource loops rather than engaging exploration.
What Makes The City of Kings Stand Out
The Enemy Randomization System
Board Games UnLocked marveled that this mechanic had not been copied more widely in the hobby: "You have this banner of them, and you draw tokens, and that's what they can do... figure out how you can bypass all that and deal with it. I think that is stellar." The system is elegant. Every enemy encounter becomes a tactical puzzle you must solve with your current resources and abilities. The stat line might be the same each time, but the ability draw ensures no two fights feel identical. This is the element reviewers consistently praised as innovative and worthy of emulation.
Deep Character Progression and Specialization
Each of the six heroes brings unique skill trees that allow you to build them into roles: healer, tank, attacker, or hybrid combinations. As designer Frank West emphasized, "the game is designed for each player to have a specialization and if you don't have that specialization then you're really gonna struggle." You earn experience by defeating creatures and completing quests, then spend points to unlock new abilities or boost core stats. Board to Death TV appreciated the freedom to customize heroes mid-campaign, resetting them for different story roles and discovering new synergies. This progression system, combined with gear acquisition from resources, means your power curve is genuinely under your control.
Potential Drawbacks
Unbalanced Boss Encounters and Difficulty Spikes
The most common complaint from reviewers concerns the brutal mismatch between late-scenario bosses and the progression pacing that precedes them. Board Games UnLocked described a first boss that escalated to the point where "she one taps us" and "we're not even close." The stat scaling does not feel tuned to match the resources you've gathered or the experience you've earned through earlier fights. The designers offer difficulty settings (easy, very easy), but reviewers felt these options underscore the imbalance rather than fix it. GetGames experienced a similar frustration in 4-player mode, where creatures seemed to spike in power suddenly and unpredictably, leaving the party unable to recover. This is not just a balance quibble; it fundamentally breaks the pacing of otherwise engaging campaigns.
Grindy Late Scenarios and Uninspired Side Quests
Board Games UnLocked found that late-game exploration degenerates into a tedious loop. Once the procedural novelty wears off, you are essentially running the same resource-gathering patterns over and over until you are strong enough or lucky enough to face the next boss. The available scenarios (as opposed to stories) often feel generic fetch quests, one infamously asking you to "bring 50 wood to the old barn." Even reviewers who appreciated the game's combat puzzle conceded that the road to the boss feels artificially lengthened. The game's length (1.5 to 3 hours per story) amplifies this issue: a 1-hour roguelike can sustain grind because the payoff is quick; a 3-hour board game that pivots to pure resource loops tests patience far more severely.
If You Enjoy The City of Kings
If you love the enemy ability puzzle system, you will find similar satisfaction in Too Many Bones and Assault on Doomrock, both of which treat combat as a tactical puzzle you solve rather than rolls that determine outcomes. Fans of the character progression and skill-tree customization might explore Frosthaven, which pairs a campaign system with permanent character growth. For the roguelike aspirations, Dead Cells and other video games in that genre deliver the speed and replayability that City of Kings attempts but struggles to achieve in board-game form. Those who enjoyed the cooperative storytelling and worker placement might try Sleeping Gods for narrative discovery, RuneWars for the hero and army hybrid, or Kingdom Death Monster for settlement-phase permanent advancement. Isle of Cats, also designed by Frank West, shows what Frank West's design philosophy can achieve with a tighter, more celebrated tile-placement mechanic.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"The City of Kings plunges the player in a puzzle-like chapter each time which will have the players make heartily tactical choices while keeping a watch on time and overall mission objective. City of Kings certainly keeps you hooked from story to story in figuring out how to beat each puzzle which heroes to use with what skills which might prove useful in the story ahead."
- Board to Death TV
"It's easily the best part of the game. You have this banner of them, and you draw tokens, and it's like that's what they can do. The enemies come out, and they're level seven, here are their stats, and then draw from the bag, read what those do. Now, figure out how you can bypass all that and deal with it. I think that is stellar."
- Board Games UnLocked
"The problem is, again, that's all in a video game. So, all those drops are instant. All those loots are instant. All those deaths are instant. So, you reset, and then a run in a roguelike is typically, at most, I think the longest roguelike I've played is like an hour to do one full run. This is not an hour. And it doesn't have a save system to even make it bite-sized. So, the stories are just insanely long for the procedurally generated stuff to completely wear off until you eventually get to the loop."
- Board Games UnLocked