The Siege of Runedar Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About The Siege of Runedar
Reviewers who cover The Siege of Runedar tend to find it intriguing, but they are less unified on whether it earns repeat plays. Board Game Animal places it in the lower reaches of Justin's top 100 Reiner Knizia list. Justin describes it as a deck building co-op that almost verges on a dungeon crawl, and notes that it is not what a player would typically expect from a Knizia design. Justin thinks it has the ingredients of a game Justin would enjoy, yet has never felt drawn back to it, which Justin sums up as a disconnect that is hard to fully explain.
The hosts of All You Can Board approach the game from the angle of design novelty. In episode 19, Dylan calls it a 2021 or 2022 release that felt genuinely new within Knizia's recent output, and credits it with a cooperative structure and deck building combination not seen before. Dylan is careful to add that the game did not leave Dylan super enamored. A later holiday pick video from All You Can Board features the game as an import copy, chosen for its cooperative deck building and its production. The hosts say openly that they had not yet played it and were judging it largely from its design and presentation. The overall consensus is admiration for the concept and the look of the box, paired with more measured enthusiasm for how well the game holds up over repeated sessions.
Core Mechanics That Define The Siege of Runedar
Deck Building
In the transcripts, deck building is the engine that drives progression. Carlo, speaking on All You Can Board, explains that players use their cards essentially to upgrade their weapons and upgrade their defenses against successive hordes of monsters. Each card a player acquires changes what that player can do on later turns, so the deck becomes a record of the defense the group has built. Dylan singles out the way the deck building sits inside a cooperative frame as the element that felt most original. Justin of Board Game Animal also labels it a deck building co-op, which signals that the reviewers see the card system as the main vehicle for the game's strategy rather than a side feature.
Cooperative Game
Every reviewer frames The Siege of Runedar as a shared fight. Carlo describes the players as all defending the encampment, the castle, or the fort together, and Justin's "co-op" label places the group against the game rather than against one another. Dylan's comparison to tower defense makes the structure concrete: threats come at the fortress, and the table has to decide collectively where its limited resources go. Because the win or loss belongs to the whole group, the reviewers' comments focus on how the threats are managed rather than on outmaneuvering other players. Justin's remark that the game is procedural speaks to this structure, since the co-op flow is orderly and predictable in a way that felt less compelling for repeat play.
The Siege of Runedar Experience
Tower Defense Tension at the Walls
Dylan's tower defense comparison captures the feeling the game aims for: a fortified position under steady pressure, with the group deciding what to reinforce next. Carlo's description of hordes arriving at the fort reinforces the sense of a siege in which the threat comes to the players rather than the other way around. The tension in the reviews is external and collective. Players are not racing each other; they are watching the walls, weighing upgrades against the next approaching wave, and hoping that the shared plan holds.
Procedural Calm Rather Than Lasting Pull
The reviewers' emotional read on the game is more restrained than their intellectual interest. Justin says the game was good and intriguing, but also calls it procedural and says it is not something that typically nags at Justin's attention to revisit. Dylan similarly says the game did not feel super enamored or super impressed. The experience they describe is satisfying while it is happening and interesting to think about afterward, but it lacks the urge to return that they associate with their favorite games. For players who prize a sense of discovery, that calm can be the defining feeling of the game.
What Makes The Siege of Runedar Stand Out
A Cooperative Deck Builder That Feels New
The strongest praise in these transcripts is for the combination itself. Dylan calls the game pretty novel cooperative deck building and says it was never seen done quite like it. Dylan treats it as a standout within Reiner Knizia's catalog, a designer whose recent work Dylan describes as more polished than groundbreaking. Justin similarly says the game has all the ingredients of something Justin would really enjoy, which indicates that the design choices land well on paper even when they fail to create lasting attachment. For reviewers looking for a fresh spin on familiar mechanics, this blend is the feature that gets the most attention.
Production and Presentation
All You Can Board highlights the production as a reason the game stood out to them. The hosts note that the production is very nice and that it does not look like a typical Knizia release, which they associate with simpler presentations. They also praise the artwork, describing the visual style as a major draw. For a game they had not yet touched, the look of the components was enough to put it at the top of their wish list, and the reviewers treat the presentation as a real part of the package rather than an afterthought.
Potential Drawbacks
Limited Pull to Revisit
The most consistent criticism is about replay appeal. Justin admits the game has never nagged for Justin's attention, and is unsure why it fails to connect when it has so many qualities Justin normally values. Dylan's comment that the game did not feel super impressed points the same way. Both reviewers suggest that the first impression is stronger than the long-term relationship, and that players who want a co-op game to become a regular fixture may find the appeal fades faster than they expect.
Availability and Price Uncertainty
The hosts of All You Can Board chose the game as an import copy, which placed it at a premium price point for their holiday list. One of the hosts says they are holding off until the game is available at a more reasonable price and expects the regular retail price to settle lower. For readers outside the market where the import was sold, this uncertainty is a practical concern. The reviewers themselves note that their assessment rests on the design and components rather than extended play, so a buyer may want to weigh the price against how much they expect to return to the game.
If You Enjoy The Siege of Runedar
Players who enjoy The Siege of Runedar's blend of cooperative play and deck building will find similar satisfaction in other cooperative deck builders, the genre reference that appears throughout these discussions. Players who want a game in the same spirit as the hosts' favorite Knizia novelties should look at Renature. Dylan praises its area majority tiebreaker, where equal strength cancels out and a lower total can win, as one of the most novel moments found in the designer's work. For players who want deck building with a competitive edge rather than cooperation, Carlo points to Quest for El Dorado, a race game fueled by deck building that is considered the closest comparison that comes to mind.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"I thought it was good, but it's not something I ventured back too much at all. It was intriguing, but procedural and not one that's typically nagging for my attention to revisit."
— Justin, Board Game Animal
"The siege of Runar, which was a 2021 or 2022 release, was pretty novel cooperative deck building where you play inside the box and it's like tower defense. That was super novel; I had never really seen a game done quite like that."
— Dylan, All You Can Board
"This is another Canadian game, but it's a deck builder cooperative game, so deck building cooperative game where you're all defending, you know, the encampment, the castle, or whatever the fort, against different hordes of monsters, and you're using these cards essentially to upgrade your weapons, upgrade your defenses."
— All You Can Board