Squirrel Away Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Squirrel Away
Squirrel Away has captured reviewers' attention as a genuinely novel addition to the party game landscape. Grant's GameRex, a prolific board game reviewer, ranks it among the top 5 party games and top 10 unique games of 2025 for its distinctive design. The game draws consistent praise from the board game community for its audacious use of sleight of hand as a core mechanic, something reviewers note is virtually unprecedented in hobby board games. However, the consensus also emphasizes that the game's success depends heavily on the group playing it. BoardGameCo's Alex Radcliff observed that Squirrel Away delivered "a ton of fun" with some groups but was "a complete dud" with others, reflecting that it is fundamentally a social experience where player energy determines the outcome.
Core Mechanics That Define Squirrel Away
Sleight of Hand
The signature mechanic that sets Squirrel Away apart is its integration of sleight of hand, a technique borrowed from close-up magic. Players use misdirection and deft hand movements to grab acorns and gems while other players are distracted or focused on the claimed card. This creates a unique layer of deception where the physical act of gathering components becomes part of the game itself. Players must watch each other carefully, noting not just what is claimed but also what is actually being collected. The Tantrum House team described it as "the art of distraction," capturing how sleight of hand functions as both mechanics and theater.
Bluffing and Set Collection
At its core, Squirrel Away is a set collection game layered with deception. Each turn, a player plays a card face down and claims what it represents. They then grab acorns or gems from the central pile, truthful or not about both what they claim and what they actually collect. Other players must decide whether to challenge the claim by pointing to either the card or the hand, betting that something is false. If a challenge succeeds, the challenger gains gems. If it fails, the player who was called out wins gems. This core loop of playing, claiming, grabbing, and challenging creates constant tension between maintaining a facade and actually collecting the matching sets needed to score.
The Squirrel Away Experience
Playful Deception and Mind Games
Reviewers consistently describe Squirrel Away as a game defined by playful scoundrelism and psychological warfare. Grant's GameRex notes that "the key to most of the strategy is going to be coming in watching the player before you reveal their card," but the real fun emerges from the mind games at the table. Players can drop a phone to create a distraction, make exaggerated claims to mislead opponents, or use verbal misdirection while physically grabbing more than they claim. One reviewer described deliberately grabbing too many gems and then pretending to correct themselves, all while other players try to determine if the act was genuine or staged. This creates what reviewers call "big emotional moments" of laughter and disbelief when a bluff succeeds or fails spectacularly.
Social Trash Talk and Group Energy
Success with Squirrel Away depends entirely on whether players embrace the silliness and engage in active trash talking. The game thrives when players lean into accusations, banter, and playful accusations of cheating. Grant's GameRex emphasizes that enjoying the game requires embracing "that social trash talking," while another reviewer noted the experience "feels like a silly heist" when everyone commits to the spirit of trying to outsmart one another. The 20-to-30-minute playtime is brisk enough to keep energy high and prevent the social dynamics from wearing thin, yet allows multiple rounds for shifting alliances and escalating accusations.
What Makes Squirrel Away Stand Out
A Mechanic Without Precedent
Sleight of hand as a board game mechanism is genuinely rare. Grant's GameRex explicitly states that Squirrel Away is "the first game I've ever played that uses slight of hand as a mechanism in the hobby game," and no other reviewer could cite an equivalent in modern board gaming. This novelty alone explains why the game appears on lists of unique and innovative designs. While the mechanic itself is simple, its application in a social game creates an experience that feels fresh and unlike anything else at the table. It bridges the gap between parlor games and structured board games in a way that catches players off guard.
A Spiritual Successor to Sheriff of Nottingham
Grant's GameRex draws an explicit comparison to Sheriff of Nottingham, one of gaming's most beloved bluffing experiences. In both games, players are attempting to deceive opponents about what they possess and what they're claiming. But where Sheriff of Nottingham uses negotiation and contract, Squirrel Away uses physical misdirection and quick reactions. The comparison highlights that Squirrel Away taps into the same desire for social deception and outmaneuvering opponents that made Sheriff of Nottingham a classic, but through a completely different avenue. Reviewers recommend Squirrel Away for those who loved the mind games and social aspects of Sheriff of Nottingham and are looking for that experience delivered through a more kinetic, theatrical mechanism.
Potential Drawbacks
Extreme Group Dependence
The game's success or failure depends almost entirely on group composition and energy level. Alex Radcliff from BoardGameCo played it with groups who had "a ton of fun" and other groups where it was "a complete dud," leading to a decision not to keep it in the collection. Squirrel Away requires active, engaged players who are willing to watch carefully, make accusations, and engage in playful banter. A table of cautious or quiet players may find the game falls flat, since the hidden information is less about deep strategy and more about reading social cues and committing to the act. It is not a game that works passively.
Requires Commitment to the Silliness
Players who prefer cerebral strategy or formal game states may struggle with Squirrel Away. The game explicitly demands that players lean into the silliness and accept the theatrical nature of the experience. Those who approach games as optimization puzzles may find the subjective element of accusations and physical deception frustrating. Additionally, competitive players who want a clear, unambiguous path to victory through superior play may chafe at a game where factors like charisma, distraction, and the willingness to act foolishly at the table carry significant weight. This is not a game for players seeking a level playing field where skill alone determines the outcome.
If You Enjoy Squirrel Away
For anyone captivated by Squirrel Away, Sheriff of Nottingham is the natural next step. Both games center on the delight of deceiving opponents and negotiating your way around their skepticism. Where Squirrel Away uses sleight of hand and rapid-fire bluffing, Sheriff of Nottingham uses negotiation and contract. Both reward charismatic play, reading your opponents, and the ability to lie convincingly. Both also require table buy-in from players willing to engage socially and embrace the deceptive play rather than treat the game as a pure calculation. If you found yourself genuinely enjoying the mind games, the accusations, and the theatrical element of Squirrel Away, Sheriff of Nottingham will deliver that same satisfaction through a slower-paced, more negotiation-heavy lens that some groups may find even more rewarding.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"This is the type of game I live for where I'm just messing with you and I'm like, am I doing this right now or am I telling the truth? You don't know. You don't know right now."
— Grant's GameRex
"I played it with some groups that were a ton of fun, and I played with other groups that was a complete dud. And games like that I tend to be less likely to keep."
— BoardGameCo
"If you lean into the silliness to the trash talking of the game, I think that's what makes it really fun. You can create distractions like that. It feels like a silly heist to me."
— Grant's GameRex