18 Holes Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About 18 Holes
18 Holes is a golf-themed game for one to five players in which the table builds the course, drafts clubs, and races to reach the green first. Only two reviewers have covered it so far. Meeple University previewed the game ahead of its Kickstarter launch, and BoardGameBollocks reviewed a copy after playing it. Both reach a similar verdict: the game is light, quick, and enjoyable, but it has real friction in its setup and in how much control players have over their shots.
Meeple University presents 18 Holes as a light game with a small random element. The reviewer compares the feel to playing mini golf, which makes the luck easier to accept. BoardGameBollocks is more critical and says the game is "flawed" while still concluding that it is a fun, fast-paced title. The two channels agree on the core appeal and disagree mainly on how much the luck and production problems weigh against it.
Core Mechanics That Define 18 Holes
Simultaneous Actions in Club Selection
Every round, players choose a club card face down and reveal their choices together. BoardGameBollocks explains that the number printed in the top left corner of each club sets the player order, with the lowest number going first. Meeple University lists simultaneous action selection among the mechanics that define the game, and it is the reason the rounds stay brisk. Because all players commit before anyone moves, no one can wait to see where a rival lands before choosing a club.
Card Drafting for Clubs and Shots
Before play begins, each player drafts a hand of clubs by picking one card and passing the rest along. BoardGameBollocks describes the number of clubs drafted as depending on the player count, and players can reset their hand by returning discarded clubs once the hand is empty. The club itself then determines the shot. Meeple University explains that the shot card drawn from the deck matching the club's icon tells the player how far the ball travels, which ties the draft directly to the outcome of each turn. Reviewers say this link is where the game's tension comes from.
The 18 Holes Experience
Trusting the Shot Card
Much of the feel of 18 Holes comes from the moment a shot card is turned over. BoardGameBollocks says that a player is often "just going to be drawing a card and doing what it says on the card," with the choice limited to which club to use. That produces a mix of satisfaction and irritation. A good draw feels earned, while a bad one leaves players wishing they had more say. The reviewer describes this as the "random card and curse under your breath" moment, a rhythm that is frustrating but never entirely unpleasant.
A Quick Round With Light Stakes
The game is meant to be played fast, and reviewers say it mostly delivers. BoardGameBollocks notes that the holes move quickly because everyone completes each hole on the same turn, and that a basic game does not outstay its welcome. The reviewer advises keeping a session under about an hour and a half. The feeling is that of a casual, low-stakes round, where a single bad bounce costs a turn rather than the game.
What Makes 18 Holes Stand Out
Course Variety and Replayability
BoardGameBollocks singles out the variety of courses as the game's strongest point. The reviewer states that the book includes a substantial set of courses and that the publisher's website offers many more, so players are unlikely to repeat the same layout often. In their words, "the first thing that we really like about this is there is a bazillion and one different courses available." Meeple University also highlights the modular board and the option to build maps in several different layouts, which supports the same idea that each session can feel different.
Asymmetric Golfer Abilities
Each golfer card has an A side with a basic ability and a B side with a more complex one. BoardGameBollocks gives examples such as Iron Giant, who selects clubs from the available pool before the draft, Slugger, who must carry the driver and is guaranteed to keep it in hand, and Shark, who treats water hazards as normal hexes. The reviewer says these powers "doesn't quite break the game" and praises their balance. Meeple University also points to asymmetric powers as one of the mechanics that give the game its character.
Potential Drawbacks
Luck-Driven Shot Selection
The most consistent criticism is that players control little beyond their club choice. BoardGameBollocks argues that a missed draw can leave a player with a shot they did not want and no way to recover, especially when the club hand does not offer a short shot to clear a tree or a bunker. Meeple University also notes the small random element and cautions that a ball can travel too far or in the wrong direction. The reviewer's conclusion is that the game would be better with more control, even though the draws still produce memorable moments.
Setup and Tile Production
BoardGameBollocks is most direct about the physical side of the game. The reviewer says that the tile numbers are hard to read, that the shot cards are difficult to align with the hexes on the tiles, and that a box with 40 or 50 tiles makes setup a chore. Setup can take 15 to 20 minutes, and sorting the tiles afterward adds more time. The reviewer also questions the design decision to discard clubs, arguing that golf purists would not expect it, though they admit the rule adds a small strategic choice.
If You Enjoy 18 Holes
Players who enjoy 18 Holes's simultaneous club selection will likely enjoy Sushi Go!, which also has players secretly choose a card from their hand and reveal every choice at once, keeping rounds quick and removing any chance to react to a rival's play. Players who value the draft-driven feel of choosing a hand of cards and then living with the outcome will also enjoy Race for the Galaxy, where each round everyone simultaneously selects a role card face down and the revealed choices decide the turn for the whole table.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"What I find as one vital strategy is the card trap and play you need to look at the course at the start and try to time playing your cards right to be the most efficient golfer."
— Stella, Meeple University
"The first thing that we really like about this is there is a bazillion and one different courses available I mean there's a load in the book."
— BoardGameBollocks
"At the end of the day you're just going to be drawing a card and doing what it says on the card right you can't really control your shot any further than choosing what club you want to use."
— BoardGameBollocks