Cascadia: Alpine Lakes - Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked. And today, I'm doing a discussion over Cascadia Alpine Lakes. Now, this is kind of the standalone sequel to the original Cascadia, which over the course of the years, they have done a few variants within this kind of system. Uh they had the original Cascadia, and then they had an expansion for that. Then, they had a series of roll-and-writes, which I haven't played cuz that's not a particular genre I jump into. But then, they did this one, which I was incredibly intrigued by because I enjoy the original quite a bit. It's one of the few games I've kept over the years, cuz I've always enjoyed that spatial awareness puzzle.
And original Cascadia had it to where you were relying on the certain type of animals. The animals scored, uh you know, based off of of a variety of things. Each animal had like its own unique way of scoring, and each one had various cards, so you'd have a different way of playing every single time. So, the question is with Alpine Lakes, is it different enough from the original Cascadia to worth buying? And if it is, should you still own both? And I would say they it's still the same system. You still have options of tiles and wildlife tokens in the middle. Uh and you pick a pair, and you place it. But, I think this one actually does a good enough job of separating itself, so that it's not just wow, a different terrain types and different animals, but still the same game.
Cuz if that was the case, they could have just made another expansion, throw in five more animals, and be done with it. Uh but that's not what they did here. So, like I said, you are still doing the terrain placement. And taking those animals and placing them on spots that they are allowed to go. But, the two big differences in Alpine Lakes is that one, you are now scoring for terrain types uh mixed with animals. So, there are three different terrain types. There's forests, there's glaciers, and there are meadows. And there's, you know, a deck. I not really a deck, but a handful of cards of each one. So, those are going to score different, but still have a similar theme in around them.
And then, the second thing that I think is kind of the biggest change is now you have to deal with something called elevation. And in the original Cascadia, you were just building out on one level. In this one, not only are you doing that, but the tiles that you are taking can now be stacked on top of previous placed tiles. And there are obviously placement rules around that, but a decent amount of the cards are based around their elevation. You know, uh score a pair of groups of animals based off their level. So, this meadow one, for example, in this recent game was uh each group of animals uh at two or more will score eight points based off their level. If they're at level three, seven points if they're at level two, and uh six points if they're at level one.
Uh and then, you know, uh I lakes, which are uh they're the static, like the constant uh scoring. Uh you get a point based off the level of the lake, but then if it's fully surrounded, it's double. So, if you have a lake at level one, it's just one point, but if it's fully surrounded, it's now two points. And then if you have a lake at level two, it's four points. A level three is three points. And then you know, you can potentially go up to a level four. But if it's fully surrounded, that'd be eight points. So, then everyone is competing for the highest elevation of each individual animal. And then based off the number of players, will be a certain amount of points. So, that is actually an interesting thing to take into a game like this because for the most part, I thought Cascadia was already not necessarily a brain burner, but a decent puzzle of trying to maximize placement with animals and keep in mind all the different scoring elements to try and score for at least all of them. And that was good enough. So, then whenever you take that same concept and now have it to be Well, now you have to take height into consideration.
Kind of takes it up a notch. I But at the same time, it also gives you a little bit more freedom because the only rules around where you're placing is if you're covering up an animal, which you are allowed to do, the tile you're covering it with has to also be able to take that animal. Um and then if you are trying to score in a particular way, but the way you've originally originally laid it out isn't working, well, you can take a tile and now kind of just place it on top of something and make it work that way. And I mean, for table presence alone, it actually helps because you're not just constantly building out to cover up the table. Everyone's kind of piece is in a smaller section. So, that was also a nice nice change of pace. So, I do actually really like the the level of elevation, even though it takes some getting used to.
And if you're playing on the advanced game, there are now habitat scoring tiles. And there are three different types for that as well if you want to play on an even more advanced level where you have to take into consideration animal scoring and the three different terrain types scoring. Now you have three different types of habitat tiles or habitat scoring markers. I wouldn't say those are necessarily you know, important because in my experience those cards don't really add a bunch of point values. For example, one of them is bio yeah, bio diverse alignments. You got three points for every line that had individual animals.
So all five types if you had five of them in a straight line, you got three points. That's not necessarily worth going out of your way for if you cuz all the other scoring concepts are going to give you just more points. To me those kinds of scoring just happens to be happenstance. Oh, hey, I actually have all five in a row. Cool, three points. Or oh, hey, I have a decent group grouping of level two tiles. So that's 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 that's eight points. Okay, cool. So they're there, but I would never say focus on those more. You're going to get more points off the other stuff. But other than that, I think Cascadia after all these years still holds extremely well for this. And for the longest time, I always wanted them to kind of just make more original Cascadia. Everything else that they've announced just hasn't ever been something I was interested in.
Even though original Cascadia and its expansion landmarks has enough variety for how often I play it that this is not necessarily something that I was you know, extremely thrilled about. I wasn't like, "Oh, thank god. My original Cascadia is boring as hell. I've played every single combination. It's automatic for me at this point." That's never been the case. Uh but I do like the fact that this is uh kind of its own thing. So, that brings me to the question of if you own original Cascadia, should you go out and grab Alpine Lakes? And my answer to that for a lot of these types of standalone expansions is is Cascadia OG worn out for you? Is that you you own five games, one of them is Cascadia, and you play it weekly, and you haven't stopped since the original came out? Then yeah, this would definitely be completely fresh and give you a different layer of thinking.
Uh I wouldn't say if you own Cascadia and you play it about as often as I do, which is very very not very often, that this is going to um really just kind of you're not going to play original Cascadia more now. You're now have to think of this and that one and which one you want to play.
[snorts]
Uh but if you don't own either that's actually a more difficult question to answer because if you don't own either, they're very similar in skeleton. Uh and you know, honestly, I probably like them about equal, which is because they both do similar scoring systems. I like the elevation, but I don't like it enough to say I like this better than original Cascadia.
[snorts]
And you can't really mix them. The expansion, the mini expansion that this one came with, I think lets you mix a little bit of them. I haven't tried it yet. Uh it's their Yeah, Alpine Animals. Um All you'll need is a number of wildlife tokens of three different types, one for each player. So, it's not even really a combination expansion. Uh so, that's not even an expansion worth really talking about. One thing that Uh yeah, and I mean, I can't necessarily say I I would rather I I wish you can combine them because then that would just be two it it'd be too random because you couldn't have habitat scoring, you know, with meadows, glaciers, and forest and then all the different animal types because A, you combine the animals, then you're probably not going to get enough of them to justify trying to score them and same with the tiles. You can't shuffle all the tiles together to make it to you you know, even of a system.
So, I mean, if you don't own either, it kind of depends. Do you want Do you like that I would say this one's a little bit more complex, just a little, with the elevation. Uh but they're both relatively the same weight. Uh so, yeah, I don't know. It's going to come down to I guess theme. Do you like animals or do you like landscapes more? Is kind of where it comes down to. Uh but I'm going to keep this. I I like the extra level and to me, I actually kind of like that I can't combine them because if I did, then I think it probably wouldn't get played as much. So, So, yeah, I mean, very solid. I will say for what whatever reason, the the verbage that they use in this game is weirdly more confusing for the scoring cuz they use this group of corridors, which I which basically means
[cough]
basically means group. But, they chose not to do that. And it's very weird. Now, to give them some credit, all of the cards and their scoring is clarified in the back of the rule book. It's a little weird how they do it cuz it's just one massive paragraph, but they're separated by numbers. The cards have numbers or letters on them so you could find it and it explains what it means. So, it is nice, but they also it's just kind of weird. I feel like some of them are a little bit more confusing than they should be. And that was that was a little bit uh to get used to. Uh and then they also have I think original Cascadia might have had this, too, but they have this kind of achievement sheet you can go for uh or you can play on different types of scenarios.
Just to give you something of a more competitive edge between players. Uh I've literally never used stuff like that, but it's there in the back of the rule book if you want it. And that's pretty much it. I think I would be surprised if they came out and made an expansion for this one. I think this the expansion for Cascadia Landmarks, funny enough, gives me the same feeling that this kind of does in that I thought or base Cascadia was good enough and the expansion just made it a little bit more uh more of a of a thought-provoking uh expansion where it made something that was very straightforward, very clean, still very puzzling, but made it over the top to where I wasn't too thrilled to ever play with that expansion the whole lot.
Um if they made an expansion to this one, I don't necessarily think I'd like it uh, as much. So, we'll see what they do with it, but I'm happy with base Cascadia, Alpine Lakes, and base Cascadia. I think both of them are amazing. Now, on a scale of 1 to 10, uh, you know, what do I give original Cascadia? Cuz it's going to be the same score, I think. Uh, original Cascadia, I have it at an eight. I'm going to give this one an an eight as well. I was thinking eight, I just didn't want to see OG Cascadia and give it a seven and be like, "It's a seven." Uh, yeah, I think this one's an eight as well. So, that's my thoughts on Cascadia: Alpine Lakes. Let me know what you think of the game in the comments below. Uh, other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.