Kart (D) Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip
Transcript
I want to know who's running this campaign. There were a lot of people who were pictured on that and surely one of them is the Kickstarter head of the spear and this final grade is for them. Do I want it? Yeah. Yeah, I do. I like Leader Games. The one I played I think I played two. Root was fine. I I'm not dogging on Root. I just don't get all the love. Op was fine. I liked all too. Oh, actually like open blood runes. Yeah, I like leader games. The games I've played, I'm sure I'd like four. It looks fun. So, do I want it is yes. The video once we got past the first Yeah. The video once we got past the first 20 seconds of just generic artwork and theme was was good.
So, do I want it? Yes. Can you do it? Yeah. Yeah. You got this many people and you're putting out a pretty unimpressive looking game, right? It's like, ah, cardboard, screen printed meeples, cardboard with a spinner in it, some dice, screen printed meeples, maybe more cardboard, maybe wood. You'll find out. You should just treat that like an unlock. Like, hey, on the 27th, we'll let you know for sure if we're going with wood or cardboard. Ah, yeah. Um, and then and then this, which doesn't feel like a great amount of cards. It does not. And then you mentioned this juice box, but then at no point do you tell me how many cards are in said juice box. Add new and more powerful upgrades. Tedious. Yeah. Which is like, okay.
Why? So, everybody else wants to focus on the wooden components, but I'm here like this is the this is not the first time they're not telling you everything you need to know information-wise. This is not the second time they're not telling you. And heck, this isn't even the third time because they pulled the whole shebang where it's like, haha. You don't get to know either the five and six race. Then you get like, oh, it's a guy people with basketballs for wheels and it's like, oh, cool. Are they asymmetric? If these are asymmetric characters, oh man, are these as because that's a full point bump down. Like, and I really do want to know that if you if I because I think they are cuz that dribble ability. I wonder if that syncs up perfectly with a different ability. I I want to see just the starting cards, but you did just such a terrible job on this. Uh 18 starting cards. So, let's see. So, 18 starting cards for four characters would imply three per four per, but then two would have two, which would that would just So, that means asymmetry, right? If you have 18 starting cards for a four-player game, that would imply that in some way, shape, or form, at the beginning of the game, there is going to be asymmetry with your characters. But here's the bottom line. I have just spent the last 40 minutes on this Kickstarter page, and I am now trying to piece together the information to find out if your game has asymmetric CHARACTERS, DESPITE THE FACT THAT WAS YOUR FREAKING CALLING CARD.
THAT HAS BEEN YOUR CALLING CARD FOR since you started making games. What was the WHOLE POINT OF VAST? LITERALLY, THERE'S LIKE FOUR DIFFERENT RULE BOOKLETS. Everybody had to read their own rule booklets. Root. Oh, asymmetric fashions. PRETTY SURE WITH OATH. SO, IF THIS IS IN FACT ASYMMETRIC CART RACING, you lean so much into your stupid artwork into a GIANT CART. CART, WHY DOES CART TAKE up 60% of the screen? This does perfectly fine. It is. And you're a week in. And it's like, no, we have gut. Like, I get it. And we we need to talk about the obvious elephant in the room is there's a lady in a wheelchair on the front. And that's probably why they want to spotlight their art. Okay, GREAT. WELL, ALSO SPOTLIGHT SOMETHING ELSE other than your stupid graphic design name. You have so much room here to mention so many things. AND ALSO, WHY THE HELL DO YOU NEED $50,000 to make this What is What are you telling me that you're asking for? $50,000 for this game and you can't commit to wooden pieces. Are you serious right now? What do you need 50 grand to make here? I worked for a manufacturer. I made quotes. You got three. Unless Unless they're just jerking you around for that fort.
I bet I Yeah, the more I go through this, the more I really don't like the cut of the jib. And once again, I want to go back to what I was looking down here. Who's in charge of this Kickstarter? Cuz this is just Did you really think people would be fine not knowing those components? Like the the wood versus that? Like they're just be like, "We don't care. We don't care." Like 50 grand. What do you need 50 grand for here? There is nothing in this game that is impressive component-wise. Like not a single thing here is impressive component-wise. They've been making spinners for 50 years, probably longer than that. So, I don't know why you need 50 grand. I don't know why your shipping sucks so hard. I don't know why I have to really look around to figure out if this is an asymmetric cart racer because you know what? At five and six players, expansion for an asymmetric cart racer is yeah, I 100% want that. Whereas if it's just, you know, art and theme, I'm like, "Okay, well, I don't need that."
Wow. And oh man, hopefully hopefully they're very honest with themselves and they add like I don't even know. I don't know. Final grade is um Do I want it? Yes. Can you do it? Yes. I have no doubt in my mind. This isn't going to be that s thing that sinks leader games, right? They want to make that money off of Root. So, they're not going to have this be the gigantic black eye. Not to mention, it looks like 111 people are just here for Ford as it is. Um, cuz that's the only add-on you have. It's either they're here for Fort or they're here because they think your Kickstarter isn't good enough to get their money yet. Both of those are arguably bad. Um, so who do we got? Customer communications and event manager, head of sales, director of marketing, productions. I just want to see the Kickstarter head honcho person.
Localization. I don't know. Customer support coordinator. I don't know. Whoever's whoever's the one at the tip of this spear for this page is like, go look around the room cuz I Final Grad's not good. Just the more I learned about your game, the more I'm like, huh? Like what? and and it's it's it's just and I don't understand why they've done so many other Kickstarters. They in theory had so many sets of eyeballs on this page. You're telling me all these people were like, "Yeah, like when we go to like some of the stuff like like I hate to do it, but I think it's another D." God, I've given out so many D's lately. final grade is uh how much is it sucks like if you're in UA like especially because I'm also factoring in the fact that you you're asking for 50 grand and I'm like why for what? For who? Huh?
Um I'm trying to think of what I liked about this page. There's a how to play video. That's really nice. And I like cart racing. There's quotes. Tons of clickable quotes. There it is. So, you can get previews. These all just previews. Do you have a preview dump? I don't want previews. Is there a gameplay here? Oh, you have one down here. They're coming out. I'm trying to It's either a D+ or a D. And I uh It's a D. The shipping sucks. I don't know how much is in that juice box expansion despite the fact every single person backing this is getting this. Unless of course you're buying fort which 111 people presumably or 111 people who aren't decided if they want to buy this because once again uh it it just didn't feel like they just it didn't feel like you're I'm the target market and I'm like huh also it's not two to four players it's two to six like why would you do that?
You literally know going in here. It's not a two for like ah just put an asterisk there if you want to be honest. Upgrade this, upgrade that, upgrade so much. Let me know what your components are finally going to be. And then maybe we'll get back with a C minus. But right now, I'm at a D. I'm not even giving them the plus. This just
I'm out. Let me know in the comments what's your final per cart. If you enjoy the content, please sure to click on that subscribe. But yeah. Oh, no, no, no, no, no. We're not done here. We're not done here because what I do want to know because what I do want to do is I want to go back to them not spotlighting their pedigree because especially if this says asymmetric factions, they could have just done so much. Like they don't mention that they lost arcs or rude or whatever or all that crap, but it doesn't matter. You just have a graphic that says here's the games that we have published at Kickstarted and YOU CAN PUT ALL THIS LIST OF AWARDS. YOU CAN you could do that. We're like no no let's let's show something else. Let's have our main image cover 60% of screen. Oh 338 game of all time. We could just put but all the words but no NO NO NO.
WHY WOULD WE POSSIBLY DO THAT? THAT'S not our game anymore. IT DOESN'T MATTER IF IT'S YOUR GAME. YOU PUBLISHED IT. YOU WERE THE FIRST PERSON TO PUBLISH. IT WAS YOUR GAME. IT WAS YOUR BABY. You found it. You brought IT HERE. YOU HIRED THE PERSON. YOU DID WHATEVER. YOU DESERVE ALL THAT DAMN CREDIT. AND THE FACT THAT YOU HAD 18 PEOPLE ON STAFF WHO made the decision. Let's not mention that. You don't mention a hoy either. Like, what are we doing? You literally could just have the first half of your page just drowning in awards in quotes. And instead we get to the video's like, "Oh, here's four previews." D before I get a D minus. I did one yesterday. I want to do two in a row. So we are gone. And I