Stonesaga Second Printing - Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip
Transcript
Let's get into it. Final grade for Stone Saga second printing. Do I want it? Yeah, I do. But, um I feel like I could want it more if you just put that awesome video up here instead of pictures of the like that. Just boom. Simple tweak, I think would make it better because your video was very very well and it did a great job spotlighting components and it made me feel like $300. So, yes. But, still at the end of the day, yes. Prices, the pledges all feel reasonable. You did a great job spotlighting. This is a 30-plus-hour game. A 100-page rulebook letter codex or whatever it is. Like, that's a lot. But, yes. Do I want it? Yeah. Can you do it? You have three projects out pending and a couple just shipped out. But, I like the cut of the jig.
Feels like good customer service for the most part. I don't think that like anything that there was major. And the track record of the games, that's the other thing. I I I am I am personally curious. Cuz 8.3 doesn't mean a lot to me, honestly. I think the numbers like what are you actually ranked? Like, I'm the number 6,430. Yeah, 2147. That's great. That that is way way way way way more hits than misses when people play that game. Uh and I imagine a lot of people came into that game with very high expectations cuz that was a very expensive elaborate Kickstarter if I recommend. And 2147 means And then 2162. Holy crud. 4211. Like, oh well, that's double. That's still very rock solid. That's way more hits than misses than Stone Saga. 6984.
It's, you know, that's that's that's that that's that wasteland where it could go either way for me. But, still more hits than misses, I will say. I'm Nom Nom Nom's a great children's game, by the way. It's one of those rare children's games where you could play it with a 3-year-old and they don't have to know anything. They just play a card. They can play it. Fantastic game. I don't know what it's printed on, but anyhow, that's a great track record. I would spotlight that track record. I honestly Yeah, yeah, yeah. Let's not Let's not brush that off. Like that feels like the kind of thing where you should have an Awaken Realms type track record cuz I guarantee you this was probably Yeah, nominated for different things. I'm sure some of them probably won awards or you've sold a certain number of games. Like I feel like they really could use just one graphic that it's like, "Hey, here's the stuff we put out." Like it Maybe it's got a smattering of like absolutely fantastic components or stuff like that cuz I believe Mythwin had like some cool triple layer system. Like I feel like that graphic and just keep adding to it is something they could definitely should definitely add to their repertoire. But overall solid grade for this. Do I want it? Yes. Can you do it?
Yes. How much is it? Feels Kickstarter reasonable. Final grade is a B plus. Yeah, yeah. I think with a video I think you just slap that video up there we're an A- minus. Uh and you could you might even be able to talk No, you couldn't talk me into an A. I don't think you could talk me into an A without some more here. But um just how quickly they got in and out. Very much appreciated. I think some more videos would be nice. Like I feel like just just adding some beef feel like some video dumps. But the quotes do a lot of the heavy lifting and then Oh, what? How did I skip all this? I skipped all this. What in the world? Did What How did I I No wonder it was so quick. I skipped half the page.
I don't remember seeing any of this. Did my WHOA, WHAT IS THIS? Is this a table to That looks great. I would have played that. And once again, like this is the kind of thing that should be in a video. That looks like a cool system. Oh boy, I'm glad I saw this. Now you might be able to talk Oh, there are more videos. Okay. I'm just a complete noob the noob noob noob. Well, let's see Let's do a quick backing thing cuz wow, how did I skip past all of this? Yeah, this is where we ended. Yeah, okay. Looks great. Oh, yeah. Price wasn't something I was concerned about, but yeah, the the way those terrain trays I'm in. And now we're going to sell me on the the bigger pledges. Uh four reference sheets, cool. Adds a fifth player, awesome. More stuff, more things, I'm in. Uh nature of the be- Ooh, box rolling thing, excellent. Want it. Yeah, this is great.
Like the price already felt fine, and I felt like they needed more beef, but honestly, yeah, I think it might be a minus range. Even though I did appreciate how quick they got you in and out, this is a lot of text though. That was a that was a massive. But then here's the videos, cool. I'd take some quotes for this. You got quotes from people. I'd take a quote from each one of those as well. Use the app. Wow, awesome. Holy Toledo, I'd have that up higher. Wow, that's a great shot. What is that? That looks so well done. Oh my, yeah. Just a video, personal touch video, I think would be great here. And then we got to the shipping. How did I skip past everything? Holy Toledo. Uh yeah, A minus. I'm going to go with an A minus cuz I felt like that was really rock solid. I definitely feel like the choice to not have a video though is is is just a wild one cuz it's there, and it's so well done, and it's for the exact game that you're making.
And I think if it had that, I think I'd give this an A. So yeah, A minus feels reasonable.