Battlestar Atlantica - Off The Table Jun 16, 2021
Transcript
also going to send you this link in case you want to go on youtube i jump to the googly google
okay hello anyone who's out there in streamland this is jack and john for with the cardboard held for the cardboard herald with of with the cardboard jason ii and this is the inaugural off the table revival this is setting things in motion for time immemorial to see if we can figure out how the hell to stream which is a thing that people do on the internet so uh john is here co-hosting the show the intent is that john and i are going to be getting together on a regular basis and we're going to be doing the discussion about the board games of all types and you may have seen john on our channel let's see what are some of the topics that we've hit on john i wore a top hat i don't know what we talked about but i did wear a top head there was a point in which you were wearing a top hat and like a mask over half your face we don't talk about where that came from it's just one of many things that come from too many convention attendances yeah yeah so uh john has been on the channel we've talked about the top 10 iconic games that we've never played our favorite uh i believe we talked about our favorite cooperative games we talked about our favorite area control games and he's shown up in some reviews here and there uh really john and i have been really good friends and gamer buddies for ages
at this point we just hit the 10-year mark official on hanging out together and john's the only person who i know who is as passionate about games as me and knows even more about games than me probably i don't know and we have similar origins we get along together so we're going to talk about stuff are you ready for that john as ready as i'll ever be excellent excellent so what is off the table well a little bit of announcements before we kind of get into some of the things that were individually covering today um off the table was a weekly show that the cardboard herald used to do it was a really tight 10 minute weekly news show in which we would sometimes have some guest spots from other people come on uh and drop some knowledge we would talk about uh news going on in the tabletop gaming universe and it was grueling it was one of the most demanding things that i'd done with the cardboard herald and it never had the audience participation that i really wanted some people really loved the show but it didn't give me the the vibe that i wanted out of it and it took until recently that i realized you know what i i still really like doing topical stuff and having these discussions
but having it in a live stream format would allow it to be this longer kind of nebulous thing where we could talk about anything we need to and yet and yet address the the the uh the audience as needed we could have some participation there there's all kinds of reasons why this seemed like a good format to do so the hope is we're going a live stream list on a weekly basis and we're going to pay attention to chat we're going to ask questions uh or answer questions at least uh as we have time and to stay on top of things i don't know about john's sense of brevity here but anytime that i say yo john you want to record something for half an hour it ends up being an hour so we're going to shoot for half an hour and then um probably go about an hour per episode uh but the discussion is worth it uh we talk about all kinds of great stuff i think there's a lot of a great perspective that we can share that audience can share and this kind of gives us that open environment that isn't as rigid uh in order to kind of have those more nuanced conversations so that's that's the hope that's the idea here behind off the table now um john have you ever streamed anything before can't say that i have now okay
um yeah me neither uh aside from uh testing out some stuff recently but i'm going to hit a trans ishon button over here in obs we have a little bit of a delay on the live stream uh between me doing something in meat space and it happening in digital space but if all things worked out that actually brought us over to uh john and i and chrome on the page the most sophisticated of obs setups that can possibly be uh and we got like an agenda we got some links we got a background of kyle farron's artwork for root which i'm hoping isn't a problem for me to have in the background on a live stream and yeah i i think we're going to get into some discussion uh if you notice on the thumbnail and in the um in the title uh battle star atlantica is what our our main topic is here today the recently announced unfathomable the the incredibly hard word for me to say uh from fantasy flight games um but before we get into that we're going to hop through some news we're going to get through a couple announcements and then we're going to just dive into talking about that um and john actually did some research we we got an audience question you did some research in preparation for this right oh a little bit yeah you might want to do your own fact checking but
uh but i did uh and so this was about metal coins right this is the uh question we're tackling uh well towards then we'll get to the audience uh questions there i just wanted to to tease the audience with the possibility of some metal coin discussion and that you actually did some research i'm not sure exactly how that's going to i'll be named university studies even an era of legitimacy john john your your audio it's it's getting awry it's getting staticky we're having craziness it might be a connection issue see this is the the the meat grind that you work out when you are doing uh streaming live and you know tempting people with uh having to watch all this business okay how are we doing now that is not sounding good it was sounding so good earlier when we were testing it it's all um you're getting that geth voice again it's like mass effect i've been playing a lot of mass effect on account of the legendary edition and it's like uh project overlord or the geth it's very distressing let's test it again all right testing no no it's horrible um why don't you uh see if you can go into your zoom settings and switch over to the audio input being uh your um like your webcam
see if that fixes anything that way you have the audio output of your headphones hey what are we doing now oh that's even worse that is significantly that's that's the webcam right there that that is the we're back to uh we're back to headset why does this all why does this kind of stuff always work at tests and as soon as you go live it completely fails yeah well we had a little bit of that earlier but it seemed to uh cut out and it um we had some live discussion and it wasn't uh going into that so uh meanwhile um let's see what we can do in order to work a little bit we'll see if that works out this is what everyone came for any uh any improvement here brooke nelson says it's not awful um let's hear it again john now i'm getting no audio okay okay i think it's good all right all right i'm just not gonna move or touch anything yeah there's there's a little bit of crackling i i wonder if there's some like uh feedback loop that's happening but it wasn't terrible earlier uh so i'm not sure what sort of situation is coming up as long as you have the uh the the the live stream muted if
you have it open right i yeah i don't have it open right now so okay any loops on my hand okay well um seems like we might as well continue uh cool um well the the last two announcements i wanted to get to if i go over here to chrome and go up to the top here uh just a couple quick things uh one we have a uh discord group for the cardboard herald now which uh there's been some great discussion in that so far i really appreciate people joining into that if you want to communicate with us in order to help this whole thing grow not just off the table but the cardboard herald in general that's a great place because it's a little bit more organized it's not so formal i i think that's a good place for conversation to happen especially if this does grow and we have a lot of live chat then i don't know that i'll be able to get to every audience question but if you ask something in discord then john and i can participate that in that a little bit more and make sure that we get that feedback onto the show uh also i don't know if discord allows for like polls and that kind of stuff uh but i may ask for like focus topic discussion we'll get into that a little bit more um and then lastly patreon um i don't want to plug this too much you know like you're doing enough just by being here you're doing enough by joining the discord uh but i am trying
to make a a bigger push on the patreon as far as you know giving access to early videos and that kind of stuff for patrons i've been uh this week putting up our veil wraith review or our adventure tactics review normally i put things in the can and then just put them into the release schedule because you don't want to release all of your videos and all of your hard work at once and then be like oh man i have nothing to post later on but they're usually done ahead of time sometimes a week or two ahead of the time that they actually get released so i i'm trying to do that more often if you want the skinny the full scoop on cardboard herald stuff and you want to to help us grow and you know just support this because it is a costly endeavor between cameras and microphones and conventions and zoom pro and all that kind of stuff that's a good way to do it so uh i think that kind of covers it for the announcements do you have anything to announce john am i just skipping by here no no i'm taking this opportunity to watch the uh keep an eye on the chat and see how we're doing okay sounds good audio is sounding good too by the way uh it doesn't tilt my head the right way as as as an expensive gamer on the digital space i think these headset the sense that might be wearing out it might be time to replace it okay well there we go we might have to get a separate microphone set up see there's the official streaming microphone i'm sure
that like yeti blue is at this point the most used streaming microphone that's out there so you know maybe we have to get you set up with that um okay so uh as far as uh some news there are some things happening it was e3 this this weekend and this week but in spite of the the concentration of the gaming world being on digital games there was quite a bit of recent announcements uh having to do with tabletop games um one i i was pleased to see that dragomino won the kinderspiel award this uh this year the the uh kinder spiel is the uh best children's game from the spiel de jaris uh from the german game awards uh they've announced the um nominees for the other awards the uh spiel proper as well as the critter spiel which i believe is the like advanced strategy game uh but they haven't announced the winners now this is a bruno catala co-design joint uh so this has got to be like the 700th bruno catala win for various gaming awards that guy has been in so many things uh as of late uh but he co-designed it uh with uh marie and wilfrid forte uh and this is
like um it's like a uh a children's version of king domino which of course was a monster and i think one the the spiel in its year proper um john do you do you ever pay attention to like awards on the side of boxes or anything like that it's an interesting thing like a marketing thing that a lot of publishers want to proudly display it's a spiel winner or it's a you know winner of a golden geek award or the the the dice tower seal of excellence that kind of stuff has that ever swayed to you you know i don't think it has i'll be honest if i were going to look at those sorts of things i think of those as being more in the realm of the games that i choose for my family experiences maybe maybe it's more useful indicator for that so i would definitely take this as a high recommendation my daughter's a little bit older than this at this point she'd be playing king domino by now but back in the day i think i might take this as a good indicator for that kind of game maybe not for my own personal preferences you know i i was talking a while ago um on the cardboard herald in an interview uh with the the owner of frosted games uh and he's uh from germany and we were actually talking about the the spiel and how important it is for uh the german as well as general european game audience like the the recognition
of being a spiel winner is tens of thousands uh of copies more will be sold just on the the prestige alone and the the press associated with that um there there are a significant number of families that will just buy the new spiel winner every year i i don't know if that's uh that's still true to this day and if that's true for the the kinder spiel but this is this is a great looking game i haven't played it yet but some of the past winners uh particularly like some of habba's recent releases um the uh dragon's breath and valley of the vikings have crushed it in my house uh so i i think this award has historically been pretty spot-on whereas the spiel proper you know you got some winners like uh dominion settlers of catan you have your your kingdom builders and camel up you know like i think there's a lot more debate on uh you know whether those are automatic recommendations and who those are recommendations for which is why i think the critter spiel critter spiel i think it's the critters feel was created uh which uh wingspan won that was pretty cool well you know and just as a little side note i will say that we take those recommendations really highly when we're forming the roster games for our learn to play area at the local convention
and uh every year we feature at least one or two right yeah so uh for those of you who don't know uh who are getting up on your john knowledge because i share everything about myself on this channel uh and getting used to john as a co-host here uh john is heavily involved uh with the the the platypus con here in juneau alaska which is the largest alaskan tabletop gaming convention um it's a fantastic convention we've had designers come up for it particularly last year was really great to see some some panels and stuff but uh john has historically been like man in charge of well a lot of day-to-day operations in general but uh the the learn to play area specifically um when you're doing the learn to play area do you try to target like different audience levels like you know you you gotta have your kids game over here you gotta have your mid-weight game over here you know i i've seen you have everything from uh everdell and terraforming mars to um photosynthesis i've seen there in the past hamster role yeah side by side with terraforming mars yeah so you can definitely see that we we span a lot of brackets there no it's it's exactly that it's uh we usually try to have uh varied player counts because the the convention is all about engagement um in the middle of probably the worst
part of the time for juno in january right our weather's not so great so the idea is getting people out as a community engaging with games and so we have two player games we have uh those those light easy entry games with maybe five-minute rule explanations and then we have some of the deeper strategy games working their way up to something a little we usually have maybe one heavy game going at any time like the terraforming mars is a little heavier for that area and if you want a little bit of platypus gaming flavor the cardboard herald has done some interviews at platypus con itself including one of a mr john being the the rep for the con at the at the show floor itself um so uh you know you know an interested time uh making sure that we're we're not being too uh elaborate in our discussion of drag domino our very first news topic um there were a couple things that i thought were interesting and i think they're going to kind of tie into some of our discussion later about unfathomable uh the the word that i still cannot say properly um that's orlean was picked up by capstone games which more interestingly to me is that uh tasty minstrel games will no longer have or leon and that uh z-man has announced that tales of arabian nights is getting one more print run and then they're that that's kind of it for tales of arabian
nights from them uh which is interesting to have that kind of announcement i haven't seen many like yo get it while it's hot because it's not going to be available anymore announcements uh but it feels like the end of an era and and i don't know how i feel about that uh all these exchanges and and changes though i guess in the case of tales of arabian nights it's something leaving uh the the great uh behemoth of a company that is asthma day at this point yeah it feels a little like maybe when uh games workshop and fantasy flight parted ways and i wonder if there'll be a rush on on that last print run although you know the argument can be made that everybody who's going to play it pretty much already has it i mean i've played it certainly and early in my my gaming upbringing and so uh yeah i don't know it'll be interesting to see and i'm sure it'll live on somewhere else this is the kind of game that doesn't go away permanently i don't think right and this kind of is a follow-up to a previous story that uh steve over here at zman games had uh put forward a few months ago even before we were talking about doing this uh off the table thing uh steve had announced that some of the classic reiner kenicia and i think other uh classic euro game designer uh games were leaving the the catalog and i i i don't know too much about the inside baseball of this but i wonder if there's
um an aspect of the the designer uh especially a designer like reinhard kenitzio with a you know he has the the tagline of over 500 games have been designed by ron arkanesia i i wonder if he has licensing agreements with these um these publishers and just that license was expiring and the the company itself had decided you know what we're just not renewing the license so it was already kind of in the works and just a question if they were going to continue it as opposed to a lot of companies that you know just properly own the design uh which i think is kind of the norm as it happens in the industry at this point um but yeah interesting stuff uh some real classic titles are leaving the grips of asthma day which i i you know there's a lot of amazing people that work at asmoday uh and um you know a lot of employees of former smaller companies or what ffg became azmoday north america are really great amazing people in you know gamer focus but um i'm surprised that if given the option uh the these companies would let go of some of these evergreen titles um but maybe again that was part of the license agreement that they had to actually keep it in uh publication in order to to keep it going um maybe i'll i'll see if i can get some
inside scoop on that at some point um brooke nelson is asking a question here john did i meet you at shucks 2018 absolutely brooke and i do remember you i i had some questions for you about uh getting started on social media and some of your time over it uh if i'm not mistaken as the social media person for fantasy flight at the time and i coincidentally i was volunteering at shucks to uh in their their vendor area yeah well brooke is awesome brooke is uh actually a a rep uh of uh leader games so uh brooke has a lot of uh social media knowledge and i rely on brooke's uh expertise on quite a few things i i bounce things off of brook time to time uh so we're really glad to have you in the audience here uh but brooke of course is gamer first uh so uh continuing uh our deliberation i gotta get used to multiple windows i feel like i'm djing at this point i i have my stream window where i can take a look at chat but then i have the obs and then i have this uh this chrome there's a lot going on uh streamers this is no joke um two last uh quick announcements uh before we kind of get into the the meat of it or really three here uh one dune house secrets uh was announced by portal games which is interesting we're both dune fans and how
can you not report on that uh but it's a re-implementation of detective a modern crime board game uh which in some ways smacks of something like uh like love letter you know there's a million love letters and it's great that there's a million love letters but uh seeing a re-implementation for a movie tie-in on dune is interesting uh but portal games releases a lot of cool titles and i know that people love detective i've personally not played it have you played detective at all i haven't no i started the convention i haven't had a chance to yeah yeah um i'm interested to see where that goes with dune uh and then i had to put this on here wizkids announced uh zombie princess with the amazing tagline of once upon a time she was looking for love now she's looking for lunch um and the game just looks like a delight i mean the this is ridiculous how how cute this game looks uh it looks like a tiling competitive game where you're trying to distract and disorient the zombie uh the zombie princess and be the first person to escape this maze that you're building as you go along which is kind of a different take on tile laying so i'm excited to see um seems like something that uh would be a nice light family game so
uh i i couldn't help but have that in here it looks pretty it totally sounds fun uh and you know it's always good to highlight some light games in the face of ffg behemoths yeah but i'm gonna get you to get to the next one honestly um as cool as that looks uh i am really excited to talk about the art designer now or never the box blows me away i love that color scheme yeah i i actually specifically was going to bring up that box uh so there's a couple cool things about this so first off um the the chat can correct me if i'm wrong but red raven games has historically uh been a kickstarter company and this is a pre-order for now or never um and uh the previous games in the series above and below near and far they've been kickstarters um and i think sleeping gods was a kickstarter uh so it's interesting to see them making this leap into just trusting that they can fully knock this out on pre-orders alone which is really cool um and the box art yeah no kidding uh ryan laucat has had amazing illustrations in in all of red raven's games uh but it is a not an easy thing to have a red and green color scheme and not have it
scream christmas uh yeah no this is uh this is impressive in a world where you know we get a thousand new games a year this one would catch my eye at any convention if i walk past it on the strength of the yard alone yeah one of the things that i i would like to see out of this series uh personally uh i played uh near and far quite a bit uh i like the the storybook adventure system that it has but uh it still never really clicked as a competitive game to me uh and this game is still competitive i mean it's the third game in a series so they're sticking with a shtick even though there is significant difference in the the overall structure of above and below versus near and far but um you know i i i like my adventure games to be cooperative i like my my eldritch horrors my agents of smersh you know i like my my uh you know what whatever adventure game uh you take your pick i like them you seem to be dropping that way you know you look at journeys of middle earth and the descent the new descent you know those kinds of titles are trending towards more cooperatives i think you'll find that yeah if you're sharing a story together it's better to be in on it rather than you know head to head right right so uh this game is uh i i think it's going to sell gangbusters it was the top of the board game hotness uh red raven has uh proven themselves
quite a bit uh ryan has proven himself and his entire team um time and time again so they have an extremely loyal following and i'm really excited to see this evolution of the company and to go to a pre-order focus i don't necessarily have a problem with kickstarter i mean there are some companies that i really love that still use kickstarter as their primary platform i mean thinking about um greater than games leader games i mean they have monster hits like uh like spirit island and root and oath just came out and you know at this point i i've kind of made my piece with kickstarter as like a a pre-order system so to speak uh but it is cool to see companies have the ability to pivot and do a more traditional model even in today's market i don't know are you ever off put by companies doing kickstarter at this point like are you a purist we've had lots of discussions there's a lot of people out there who are like this isn't what kickstarter was designed for kickstarter is supposed to be like that yeah but i think the thing is there's plenty of space out there that kickstarter still works as design i mean there are still small productions out there you don't hear about them as often they're making fifty thousand sixty thousand a hundred thousand dollars instead of you know one point four million or you know what and that's small potatoes for a cool mini you know kickstarter
but uh right i mean a great example is uh chemet the uh the matagot title you know that second edition went to kickstarter i don't know they're a smaller their smaller operation i don't know that they could have published something with the more deluxe components they have in the second edition without going to a somewhat of a pre-order system and honestly kickstarter comes with a lot of free overhead of the publicity i mean it's a really i hate to say the fomo works for it really well as a good thing but when it's a game you want to see succeed i kind of don't mind that it really kickstarter knows how to generate a hype train you know whether it's stretch goals or daily updates and all that stuff i don't know that you can do that with a pre-order campaign on your own website say as as well and at this point it's it's like an embedded social network you know like uh the the audience is there i talked with carla copp of weird uh weird giraffe games um and galactic raptor games and like 16 other companies because i feel like every other day she's starting a new company um but i talked to her specifically about uh game found as a new platform for uh for for crowd funding games and even though their shtick is that this is free for publishers as opposed to taking the the big cut that kickstarter does the the embedded entrenched population that are are
going to kickstarter on a daily basis because that's where you go to look at new games uh that's where you get notifications you have all the history backing and all that kind of stuff you know that she at least at this time deems it worth the cost of kickstarter um i guess until the point in which it isn't you know game found grows enough then hopefully they can have that that same infrastructure as well all you have to do is take a quick look at there are journal there is there is internet journalism dedicated to kickstarter releases i don't have to rely on just the publisher of kickstarter's fact i can get news feeds on what is hot on kickstarter fed to me you know until until game found has that kind of following i it's you know it's not as big of a competition i don't think right right i don't have them feeding the information too now okay well uh we got some things to talk about we got unfathomable we we have to bring this sucker up so wha what is this game how how long have you been following this because they've been teasing this for a while when did this first come on your radar john oh six months ago i mean as soon as they stopped printing battlestar galactica and you knew you'd eventually get a new addition i mean i take your pig um and and i'd call it very fathomable i mean this isn't to me it's an obvious move like it's you know i i don't i don't know the nature of the
business as far as licenses go and you know bsg has been out of the the nerd consciousness for a while or maybe the the nerd consciousness is still very hot on vhd but maybe the mainstream consciousnesses and i don't know you know it's it's been out of there i mean it's like when are they gonna stop making game of thrones games in a couple more years when that sort of dies down um so maybe maybe it was not worth picking up the license maybe it wasn't available and they're pivoting to their in-house uh public domain you know lovecraft licensing or or lack of licensing i guess when in doubt just slap some cthulhu on it and you got yourself a banger yeah yeah just you know slide a shotgun under the door and you're good to go so so this is a a very obvious uh re-implementation of the battlestar galactica uh game the beloved and old battlestar galactica game in the the arkham files universe and you know they they had been teasing this for a while as early as like a year ago you were seeing posts on reddit of people saying hey my buddy my my uncle who works at nintendo has been playtesting a new battlestar galactica game that supposedly is like a cthulhu game and it seems like a pretty obvious move i mean the this has been consistently one of the highest ranked board games of all time it had been out of production
for a while um the the like you mentioned the licensing disputes i think the big question uh which to a degree is still lingering is how much would they change it because battlestar galactica is still a great game but it is an old game and design philosophy has evolved considerably since the original release of that game the the market and who you cater to has changed dramatically from the time when bsg originally was like hey let's just get some nerds playing some some secret mafia in space um and if you look at this preview like you go through this you can see almost a one-to-one comparison with all of the elements of uh bsg you have your you are a human versus you are a hybrid you have skill tests yeah the shape of the ship itself you know very reminiscent of the battlestar galactica the way that they move around the board the only difference i can see so far is maybe the boarding actions you know you can see the the mini they've gone out the gate with with more deluxe miniatures and you can see the miniatures might be boarding the ship somehow somebody that's a little different right and then i noticed uh here on i'm going to be terrible at pronouncing this but their revealed character kailani uh tatupu uh
has uh demoralized when you reveal as a traitor if you were not in the brig lose one's sanity which your characters in bsg didn't have like a health metric and you know arkham horror eldrite you typically have both health and sanity
it could be group sanity but that's i couldn't see exactly um and it could also correspond to like some card draw stuff that's probably one of the the resources that you're interacting with um there are a couple really awesome things about this game that make me want to play it right away i mean the the visual aesthetic is great they show the backs of the cards um battlestar galactica is a great game you and i have both gotten rid of our respective copies of battlestar galactica at this point because you know you can only have so many so many games in your collection at one point and unless you're you're just filling your house entirely you got to make some hard choices even about good games um but this may revitalize some things especially if they change it i mean almost every major game at this point has to cater to two players in some way there were official variants or two players but you know is that going to be successful uh what about fully cooperative will there be a fully cooperative mode in this game i mean ffg themselves have kind of steered away from having uh having a lot of games where it's one versus all or team versus team in the way that this is so i wonder if they'll they'll have more considerations for widening this game's reach well i think it also begs the
question too and i hate to be the negative person in the room and this isn't holy negative i love bsg when we played it i love that era of my gaming but i look back on it and i think you know it epitomizes a design philosophy you know shift i feel like in the last decade and a half where you know bsg had some really amazing high points some of some of the best adrenaline pulse pounding bluffing moments of staring my friend in the face telling him no i'm not a cylon you're a cylon and having everybody at the table believe me or not as it were uh but but the thing is is you know those high points come you know at 20-minute intervals sometimes in that game and over time you start to see game design really looking to capitalize on how can i get the high points more often and i'm going to throw back to my hotness of the week whitehall mysteries is exactly that taking the white chapel design that fantasyflight had previously slimming it down and trimming it down into whitehall where i'm getting the same pulse-pounding moments in that game at a faster drip because they've cut out all the middle gate and i wonder how much of this is going to do that you know and if it doesn't then i wonder i speculate how much do we really need this or is this just for people who have heard about bsg and haven't realized that maybe maybe we've moved up i don't know well tell me about even even in our uh chat here don clemson says i've never played bsg and
it's good to keep perspective i mean you and i have been playing games together for about 10 years and one of the earliest games that we played together was bsg and even at that time bsg was already a thing i mean if i go over here to let's go take a take a peek because we can be informed about this right 2008 yeah 2008. we didn't pick it up until probably 2011. yeah i i think it was a tie-in with the show as the show was on which is is ridiculous um and uh yeah uh there are so many people who have joined this ever expanding tabletop gaming realm there are so many more gamers that probably never had a chance to to get a copy of battlestar galactica um and even the ones who may have had the opportunity to again some of the things that we talked about kind of limit the space it's a big heavy game there's a ton of rules overhead which i hope their their their focus on real clean and easy to read rule books uh is a big boon for them here um and you need people who are willing to put up with the time investment on that and realistically battlestar galactica was a game for five players at least i mean you could kind of get away with four um and that's just not really
how modern games are designed so to speak nowadays i like when they are i like niche things and i like that if asmoday is sticking to their guns here if ffg asmode north america is sticking to its guns here then they are kind of diversifying their catalog and not having it so homogenized it's a missed opportunity to not have uh edward james olmos in your game uh that in itself is a little bit disappointing yeah yeah exactly that that's the looming almost saying let me back on the ship um speaking of the cover i just want to call it one thing before i forget um props to ffge and and i again i'm not very in on the industry politics of how this works but um it's cool to see that even though you've got the game design credits up there and i know that's a that's got its own history of including game design credits on on games that didn't used to be a thing way back when um and designers had to fight to get credit for their work and so it's cool to see the game designed for the the new designer it's also nice to see based on the design by cory k i don't bother to say his last name i'd butcher it but um that's what i've always said but i could be saying it wrong i'm going to rely on to do his own thing and he's got some games coming out but i've got a lot of old ffg games with his name on it it's cool to see him still
referenced on this because he was that was him all over bsg so yeah well what a monumental impact on the industry in general that corey has had i mean him and christian t peterson like changed to the shape of what american gaming is at this point uh what it was at the time i mean uh monumental uh impact on how uh american games are perceived and you know games in general how they're designed at this point so i'm actually really excited about this game um even though my my interest in battlestar galactica proper had waned um the the visual overhaul and the potential for modernization has me really excited about this one um and what it could represent for asthma day but it did get me thinking about some some other things that are kind of related to like our own tenure as gamers right um and i was thinking about how fantasy flight has at this point taken most of their classic lineup and come out with modernizations of those games i mean you you have twilight imperium 4 out that's a fairly recent game and then you have uh uh you have journeys of middle earth which can be seen as kind of a successor to um to middle earth quest uh and then you
have um the the marvel champion stuff and eldritch or el or arkham horror lcg as modern implementations of the lord of the rings system they're bringing a lot of these games to their forefront now we have battle star galactica uh i wonder oh even dissent even dissent is getting descent to legends of the dark which they're saying this isn't descent third edition it totally is descent third edition they just don't want to commit to that second edition this is third edition thank you yeah this is third this is third edition i'd call whatever you want i'm getting it too right right and so i wonder uh what things from their classic lineup are they really missing like are they looking at game of thrones right now and going like is it time for a game of thrones third edition that's another one of those older games that even the second edition has been out for ages and as much as i love that game it's pretty long in the tooth it could use a freshen up and it just so happened that in spite of killing interest in a franchise with the the the final season of game of thrones on hbo the announcement of a new spin-off show has resurged some of the excitement so i i think there's at least got to be some some spitballing going on at the ffg america headquarters where they're like is now a good time to kind of
consolidate everything and and release a a game of thrones third edition or can i offer counterpoint and i'd love to i'd love to hear this is a topic that we just put on twitter you know what what older game would you like to see revived i and i know it's a doomed effort warrior nights i know it's a games workshop gig i know that's not you know but uh speaking of of games that that cory k touched uh i'd love to see warrior knight's third edition okay guys fantasy flight can you make good with games workshop can you make up or can you can you slap some cthulhu on it and give me something the tween shall never meet the the nail was in the coffin when suddenly suddenly the the whiz kids publication of uh furia dracula was happening that feels like the the complete severance of the ffg and games workshop relationship but we'll see if there's enough money to be made people people get into it um so yeah uh related to this game um one i would love to see game of thrones come back like that that's really cool uh if game of thrones gets a similar treatment to this especially if this is successful because to me that that dudes on a map area control game that isn't the 4x ti4 8 to 10 hour game session type of game is a missing spot on the ffg catalog at this point and they love their tie-ins
so maybe they can get to that um but it did get me thinking about like re-skins are are there are there other games that have been successful reskins or that we'd want to see as like games brought back even if they couldn't have their original theme i mean we just now uh uh ignacio troach over at portal games is announcing this dune game that's a re-skin of an existing property i i wonder if there's a lot of opportunity for bringing back some of these older license games which turned out to be really cool if you just kind of put a different lovecraftian face on it i don't know all along it was a fish person all along if you could take warrior knights and put any theme on it what would it be um gosh i don't know i got sidetracked because i was thinking immediately as you brought that up you know what game i want to see and and go ahead and correct me if i'm wrong internet but uh android can i see android netrunner is not uh you know we all want it back you know and it's not going to be netrunner anymore but android is still out there right right right universe in-house universe great theme and uh could work with a lot of things and there are a couple games that have that like uh infiltration was that the android game that was kind of like the smaller yeah they they really could take
advantage of that and especially with uh i don't know i think there's a resurgence and interest in cyberpunk as a theme not only because of the the video game uh that came out recently but you had the new blade runner movie came out i think cyberpunk would be you know a hot theme to utilize if they wanted to go for their android universe i could get behind it i played some warrior nights with you i could play an android warrior nights we could figure that out i'd just like to see that theme you know if they're going to start slapping their in-house themes on things or licenses that they've got more involvement with you know the star wars marvel game of thrones type stuff i'd love to see android find its way on some more uh you know re-skins as opposed to maybe say fewer tentacles and strongholds yeah and netrunner has one of the most devoted communities that's out there uh brooke mentioned yeah fan expansions keeping that thing alive trying to hold the tournaments and everything and i i get it you know when you have a system that you are like ride or die for uh which i was for legend of the five rings for a while i was the type of person who's like you kids are just playing magic i play a legend of the five rings it's far more tactical of a game and i'm not talking about the ffg one i'm talking about the og aeg uh game um but i i ended up moving and kind of was no longer part of an active community for that so hard decisions had to be made but
yeah the the those people uh still playing netrunner and still uh obsessing over it it's awesome to see and again i can't imagine that asmodeu is not looking at that as a potential resource to tap i think at this point it's just more so can they you know are are the dollars worth the investment in that when they could get more dollars in an investment of something else i don't think it's necessarily like a a a situation in which um you know it would be unprofitable uh to continue netrunner in some way or or to have a similar game but you know they got to make their choices unfortunately it was key forge which never never quite clicked with me did you play key forge i dabbled a little bit i got to check out the convention i bought a starter pack to mess around with it it's a novel idea i love the idea of no overhead in a ccg style game but ultimately i i just don't have the bandwidth for a game that requires a community like that to keep up right or even a dedicated opponent yeah hey if you got into key forwards as a die hard tomorrow maybe i'd follow you with it but also the theming i mean i'm just the cyberpunk theming or the the the asian fantasy theme on l5r you know those are both themes that are much more interesting than i'm not quite clear what keyforge theming is it's
um you know skylanders so we'll say the theme is like skylanders for teenagers that that's the thing but uh amalgamation well uh let's close it out with a couple questions here john um probably the most burning uh dawn 72 over at discord which may in fact be don clemson here uh he had some discussion there was actually a lot of great discussion in the uh discord um ironically enough discord discussion uh there was some talk about books and there were games and you know the dice forge uh was getting played uh there was a lot of cool stuff but why do we as gamers obsess over metal coins so much like you and i are both invested heavy heavy and metal really in terms of poundage heavy yeah uh so so like what do you think why do we have this compulsion to have metal coins often times costing as much of the board games that they're being utilized with uh in our games i i have some thoughts on this but i i'm curious to hear your own perspective i have a couple of a couple of thoughts on that uh i mean the first is obviously upgrades bling you know anytime you have uh you know a basic cardboard component you can upgrade it with something that is cooler looking well yeah that's great but what if the cardboard is you know if the coin looks roughly similar to the cardboard then it's not a
huge upgrade it's more of a material upgrade visually speaking so what makes that if it's not about upgrading the quality then why do we just like playing with them well okay you can also say it increases immersion because you know coins are made of metal in the real world everybody's at one point in their lives i mean i don't know about this generation my kid probably hasn't had very much pocket change these days but uh pretty much everybody's handled coins at some point and so you recognize it immediately for what it is and it increases immersion but i would also say that there is and the study that i read i don't know how applicable it is but it was it was another it was one i remember reading i don't know way back when maybe psychology 101 class or something uh but it was about the the weight of objects having some importance in the way we perceive things even on related things so the the study itself was okay we're going to hand a volunteer clipboard that weighs i you know two pounds and we're going to have another person a volunteer a clipboard that weighs one pound and then we're going to have them rate their opinions of various things whether it be currency or you know how much they think a pilot currency is worth or how important an issue was or whatever the case was and in almost every case they found that the person holding the heavier clipboard seemed to rate everything much more severely much more serious so i have to argue that as you're sitting there you know you're messing with these little coins you know it uh it does something to you where it just it instantly becomes more real more tangible and more important than if you're just
flipping around cardboard chits it reminds me of a mitch hedberg joke uh where he was talking about like ever notice how something that feels substantial you know explaining a joke is of course the best way of killing it especially if you don't remember it all but it was talking about how uh something feels substantial as a piece of electronics and you're like man this feels good in your hand and then you take out the batteries and then you're like this is actually just a piece of like this is this is flimsy and uh insubstantial unsubstantial and so i i think there's a a part of that too those look cool but as soon as you see a tub of all the different coins in a metal form in which there's dimension to them you know things are embossed and you know the the pressings in them it makes you want to investigate it further and anything that i think encourages you to to to want to play with it is going to make you more receptive in general to the immersion of the game the magic circle if you will uh of sitting around and playing a game you know i don't actually feel like i'm in some alternate universe world war one mech steampunk thing when i'm playing uh scythe but it does give a reality to the theme a lot more and i think the other thing has to do with like a certain
a certain level of gamer i guess you know i i don't want to talk about like hardcore gamers versus you know like entryway gamers or something like that uh but like time in the industry you know time time in playing games and collecting games and that kind of stuff um you tend to see certain patterns of people who are the the omni gamers the people who bring games to their game groups you know they start buying every game under the sun any game that's fun i want to own it and then you realize you own so many games that you're never going to play them all if you try to play them all you're not playing the ones that you love the most and then you start pruning your collection and then you start thinking about what if instead of obsessing over quantity of games what if i try to have the nicest versions of the games i really love uh and have that kind of intimate connection with them you know whether that's getting upgraded components or that's having the the the you know 3d printer in order to print out really nice inserts you know there's something really satisfying about uh this is uh getting to some weird places but like reciprocating the feeling so that you know the game giveth to you and so you kind of want to invest yourself in ways with the game even if it's not an aspect of the the the mechanical design
in playing pamper my games so that they know i love them exactly exactly you know you're not you're not wrong there is a certain psychological feedback loop there that you're just like you know this thing is important to me and i will demonstrate its importance by laboring on it but you know whether it's crafting inserts or whatever right right well um but before we move on to the next question you got a shout out for your favorite coins and game oh uh for me yeah yeah it was a kickstarter back back in the day and they've done a million of them now but personally i've seen some other good ones out there i like the uh i want to see if anybody can even see this bam this is one of my uh one of my many collections i have a tub of these things yeah this thing this thing must be like a five pound brick of coins and i've got three of them uh because you have to have a fantasy set you have to have an old-timey set and you're gonna have your uh your your european looking set uh because i use them as my all-purpose generic subs for you know if i'm playing seven wonders i've got a set that looks like old roman coins anything ancient historic civilizationy it's those old roman coins anything fantasy gets the elven coins and anything on the high seas or colonies colonizing european it's going to get the the european looking coins and they're from uh draw lab is the uh is the company that makes those yeah you know i i gave the shout out in uh discord but um if you can consider uh the the secrets in oath to be
a type of currency a type of coin which effectively it is the upgraded whatever that those components are made out of secrets are incredible uh and some of the best like component work that i've seen in a game in a long time outside of the hammer and habbas like new hammer time kids game which is literally packing a kid's game box with a wooden hammer and as soon as it came out my kid was swinging around a great component nearly killed me um i'm probably exaggerating a little bit on that uh but i think to date my favorite metal coins are the lords of water deep uh the the upgraded coins i think uh those are put out by the broken token i i think they manufacture those uh or maybe it's in partnership with someone else they carry them in these basically if nothing else yeah and those things are ridiculous they're ornate they're beautiful they're really heavy uh even for for metal coins in a game they're they're incredibly heavy and the shape i'm a sucker for weird-shaped coins in general uh even in in the real world uh but the the moon money i i'm a lured by the moon money it's all about the moon money well what's cool about those two is that they're uniquely tailored to fit that game exactly those are the coins that came in the game those are the unique cardboard shapes that the game came with but replicated in metal whereas like my generic ones you know they're cool but if i have a game that uses unique fantasy cardboard shapes
that's not what i've got right right that one is my second that was my runner-up i don't have a set of those but uh one of these days i'll get around to it for sure for sure okay uh well i i want to hit on i have an agenda with a couple more audience questions here so i'm going to round it out just a quick answer because emma plays green has been a supporter of the cardboard hero for a long time and has asked me this a while ago and i never got around to it um am i still listening to red hot chili peppers i have a tattoo uh you see it all the time i i have my my chili peppers tattoo uh they were the band that got me into playing music so that was kind of the homage with the tattoo i can still trace the moment in which i was like i'm picking up a guitar um yeah yeah i i i'm a big record guy i have a few of their records and i put them on i'm not obsessive about their stuff and um the the stuff with josh klingoffer recently it's all right um i'm excited now that john fushante is back in the band because you know like that period is some of the best like crafted alt rock music that i can think of and funk rock and all that kind of stuff um but i also was kind of disappointed by how unceremoniously uh josh klinghoffer was let go from the band that kind of left a a weird taste in my mouth but i'm excited to see where they go so uh yeah i i still listen to them i i probably am listening to at least an album
we'll say every month to every other month um and then last we're going to close this out this is a positive story here um not to get too distracted by music unless there are any uh questions like come up from chat kyle frost from give pause hobby awesome channel check out kyle's stuff awesome solo playthroughs reviews that kind of stuff but in all your years of gaming what game surprised you the most and i have an answer for this but but i want to give you the opportunity here first john do you do you have you had time ample time to contemplate kyle's vexing question you know i i thought about what it would mean and i'm sure there's a better answer i'm sure that the real answer is probably at the halfway point of my gaming where i had seen most of the core mechanics that were out there there was probably some game that blew me away with how good it was uh it was caught above the rest and i can't think of what it is on top of my head honestly um but what i can go back to is early in my gaming when we broke out i'm gonna pretend like it was dominion but it was really the resident evil building game which was an early adopter but at the boom you know dominion comes out it invents a genre and then all of a sudden everything's got a deck building game and resident evil the deck building game was a uh very topical with their game coming out recently been there they're number eight being so hot but uh oh my god like that was my first exposure to a deck building game and it blew
my mind it was all the core concepts of magically gathering building a constructed deck oh i gotta have 23 lanes the ratio of this i need to trim but it turned that that that activity into the game itself of well i need to trim my deck down i need to trash these cards because i need to get better cards because i need to do this and uh oh my god that gameplay loop was was so new at the time and so revolutionary to me that that was probably one of my biggest blow your mind moments early in my gaming uh in my what i would call my second age of gaming you know the early days was magic and d and that stuff when i was a kid and then maybe about 10 years ago when i really dove back into tabletop gaming as a hobby that was one of those first moments of just like well there's katan there's risk and then there's magic and and that's it right or there's games that completely blow your mind like that yeah yeah i i i actually went for resident evil as well um i was hoping that you would pick it um and there are other really sentimental games that i love and there's games that have completely blown my mind notably early on in my game playing the first time playing small world the first time playing catan you know like ninja was great set in the legend of the five rings universe but um at the time that we played resident evil it was a licensed game and i couldn't really wrap my brain around like a licensed game being good
uh at least at least like a risk yeah and um i had worked in a comic shop for a long time i i had seen a lot of games being uh sold and a lot of the times the license stuff just wasn't wasn't that great like the best you had was like versus system uh for for uh marvel and dc which was actually really good as a card game and then of course like battlestar galactica and then some of the lovecraftian stuff um which i would discover later there's actually a lot of really good license stuff out there but resident evil um but my buddy uh barry he was like yo uh i know we play this versus system game and you you've moved to juneau at this point uh far away uh but there's this other game that we've been playing that's you you build the game as you play and i think before i got a chance to play um resident evil i did play dominion once and i got it and i was like i mean that's cool that's fine uh but resident evil you had an antagonist and you were racing against flipping that you break down the door i want to see who's next and like the equipping thing so the theme was alive and i could connect it to the game and like you said the efficiency engine and all those elements of of fantastic you know dopamine hits from
playing magic except condensed into the game itself was so good i can remember so many nights in which we uh we stayed up so late playing game after game of resident evil it was ridiculous uh and some of my best gaming memories so uh as far as sheer anticipated payoff to the delight that came out of a game most surprising game sounds like both of us resident evil that's such a good answer um and another one of those games that uh i think will be lost to time because of rights and licensing issues and all that kind of stuff oh and it does not age well but but me me 10 years ago breaking that thing out was just like that this was revolutionary right right how many times i had three shotguns and nothing
well i'm getting some audio feedback from you at this point john but that's okay because we're at the very end of the show anyway it sounds like we went a little bit long we had some technical difficulties along the way um in order to take care of uh but that's uh how it breaks out when you're just learning to stream for the first time we're still developing our technology as well as our know-how and how to utilize all this stuff um so i really appreciate everyone coming into the the chat here uh that was really amazing john this is a great experience i'm looking forward to doing this again uh we'll probably plan on about the same time next week uh we'll announce if there's going to be any changes uh anyone who's watching this who wants to help cultivate this show for it to be meaningful discussion that you can hang out with and participate in then give us the feedback you know what what are the things that you wanted more of in the show and what could you have done without uh and have some a degree of patience for us since we developed this thing uh i'm really excited by the possibilities of what live streaming allows us to do uh and the fact that i can take this and this can just be a video that's up on the channel and that i can potentially take this and put it on the podcast channel as well if i can figure out the the the gymnastics the technological gymnastics in order to get that to work then that's going to be really exciting um so yeah thank you everyone for
being here thank you john for co-hosting and uh oh oh proposed topics for next time i wanted to throw out there if if anyone has any ideas for discussion topics they don't have to be specifically news oriented uh but culling games and management of a collection i think is something that john and i could spend hours talking about like how many games should you have and uh how do you get rid of games and how do you know that it's time to get rid of a game that you love uh we spent a lot of time talking about that uh off mike and i'm sure that uh we'd have some things to say uh building a collection kickstarters you know any number of topics if you want to see some more uh focused discussion on things then let us know and as always uh any just casual questions that come up ask us about anything ask about john's hound helmet in the background and how many sand original games he had to yeah uh how many sandor gains he had to chop apart or defeat in chicken eating contests in order to win that helmet um and uh yeah we'd be happy to answer those so i think that's it john anything else before we let the folks go nope just know that uh that you better watch the chat because i'm out here making promises for uh for next time oh okay okay i i'm going to have to get on top of it all right thanks everyone i will uh talk
to you later john and i'll talk to everyone else next week all right thanks for having me