Skip to main content
Loading video...

Which GREAT Western Trail Board Game Is The GREATEST?

Transcript 16:12

when I was younger I was really drawn to board games like Monopoly I have vivid memories of collecting all of the railroad stations and trying to force other players into bankruptcy and it wasn't until recently when a glorious Euro caught my eye kind of like Clint Eastwood in an Old Spaghetti Western Great Western Trail is the game that toys with this idea of moving along a path just like in Monopoly you hop from property to property chair picking the actions and the quality of the cattle as you go it is one of my favorite Euros of all time but now a new version of the game has appeared Great Western Trail Argentina a gorgeously re-implemented version of the original game so he begs the question can we take a beloved Euro and transform it and make it even better is there a place for both games in your board game collection which one is the greatest trail of them all we'll find out in this video foreign

Trail is a game where the journey is sometimes just as important as the destination it's a game about Pathways and sometimes navigating multiple Forks in the road throughout the game players were using ranchers to travel along the Great Western Trail by following lines that connect different buildings together some Pathways will lead you through towns others may lead you to Bandits or even unexpected hazards the path you choose will be yours alone each turn you'll move your Rancher forward along the trail according to the speed on your player board if you pass over certain locations with these hands you'll have to pay a toll when you've finished moving you'll stop at different locations and choose to either use your actions on your playboard or actions at the location you've rested at different locations have different effects such as allowing you to construct buildings hire workers and acquire new cattle into your herd the goal of the game is to acquire the highest quality cattle as represented by an numbered cards in your hand and transport them to Kansas City to see them for a profit these in turn will move your train engine down the train line to different locations in which the cattle will be sold off to the higher the breeding value of your total cattle the further the locations you'll be able to reach by train it's like a slingshot effect load the slingshot with your cows and let go and see how far they actually fly once your cattle have been transported to Kansas City you loop around the trail to the beginning and start it all over again as the game

progresses players will build buildings that will make traveling to Kansas much more grueling and longer this Trail will be counterbalanced by the fact that you'll have access to more unique actions tailored to your game strategy players will continue looping around the board hop stepping and jumping to Kansas City as quickly or as slowly as possible milking every action space you need to achieve your goals I think you're really great oh thanks you're pretty great yourself oh I wasn't talking about you I was talking about the board game the original Great Western Trail feels like a well-oiled machine you grease your engine as you try and put those discs from your player board onto those stations at the end of the track so that you can unlock more efficient actions and extra bonuses your primary focus of the game is to try and acquire and cultivate the highest quality cattle possible you really want to cultivate a unique herd of cattle that will increase your breeding value so by the time you reach Kansas City you'll be able to access some of those higher valued City points along the railway track the second edition of Great Western Trail even includes the cemental cow variant which is a particular species of cow which grows in age and value each time you deliver it to Kansas City which adds for some cool deck growth that happens throughout the game it's such a brilliant game that feels so rounded in every single way what's that I'm late for my flight for Argentina hang on folks as we change destination Great Western Trail Argentina introduces

us to some new changes firstly we now have a new resource grain grain is so important as you'll need them to feed your cattle as you load them onto ships at the Port throughout the game different ships will leave the port at various times to various cities including Le Havre Rotterdam and Liverpool the cattle will be loaded into keys and then with more grain they can be shipped to different districts within those cities to earn extra cash or end game victory points it essentially takes the train station locations from the original game and mobilizes them joining the crew are a fourth type of worker farmers who you'll meet along the trail which can be hired to work for you provided that you pay them well and have enough grain they can be flipped over to help gain you extra grain from the fields and also help you to load your ships more efficiently these Farmers appear in four different regions of the board and can sometimes slow you down on your journey with the prospect of meeting different Farmers comes the need for strength some of the worker tiles now have this Scythe symbol this symbol is also printed on the cattle cards when you visit a farmer you can hire them by showing your strength by adding up these Scythe icons by discarding cattle cards from your hand or even having them on your player board however using your cattle up is pretty exhausting so you may end up adding new cards to your deck which hinders your ability to build an efficient herd don't worry though because if you have these exhaustion cards in your hand when you drop off your Cadillac bonuses you can get rid of them so use your strength wisely because

they have consequences the final big change is the introduction of shortcuts in this version of the game as your engine chugs along the train line it gets closer and closer to home moving your engine essentially makes the Great Western Trail a lot shorter the further along the track your engine is the more access you have to shortcuts which allows you to leave the trail early avoiding risky building spaces or improving the speed of your cattle delivery the interplay of grain ships and shortcuts does change the dynamic of the game the cogs run a little differently and so does the flow of the game the tempo of the original Great Western Trail is simply unbeatable I really love the fact that the tempo of the game really came down to how many buildings players deployed out onto the trail at the beginning of the game you can really cycle around the trail and get to Kansas City really really quickly because there weren't many properties out on the board but as the game progresses and the board fills up the choices of which way to go along the trail becomes a lot more significant also the order in which you place your properties Out means that each time you cycle back to the head of the trail again the order in which you access the actions becomes really important for generating what you really want in the game so also each time you reach a fork in the road deciding whether to go left or right or going over someone else's property kind of factors into whether you're willing to help other players by giving them some money or go through some hazards instead in terms of the strategy of Great Western Trail Argentina the tempo of the game has

shifted here the focus is trying to get you to the destination of bonus airs as quickly as possible as you move your engine down this track you'll be able to access more and more shortcuts earlier and earlier on in the track meaning that you'll be able to avoid this risky section in the latter part of the board you're also really focused on trying to get your discs onto particular shifts so they arrive at the keys on these three destinations by trying to be able to fulfill and get your discs onto those boats you'll be able to all really high level victory points as well as earn extra cash Danny there's quite a lot of dairy in this game I forgot to tell you I'm lactose intolerant oh that's okay so am I that's why I drink oat milk and soy milk while I play the game really does have a bit more of a ticker timer effect where the efficiency that you move around the board becomes uh more quicker shorter more efficient and more distilled and I think that is in the game's favor by having that really long trail and then the trail condensing as the game progresses and giving you more options to kind of exit the board when you think you need to or access certain actions where you want to means that you have a lot more choice at your fingertips the workers in this game definitely feel a lot more fleshed out than the original game it feels like there's a sense of purpose and the bonuses really feel like there's a particular Avenue that you can pursue each time you play so in terms of

the depth of the game strategy and the laid amount of choices I would say that Great Western Trail Argentina wins for me what I really liked about the deck building in the original Great Western Trail was that you're collecting all of these unique casual cards with high breeding in value so that you can access stations further down the train track I like the idea that you can kind of discard certain cattle types along the trail to try and get rid of them from your hand the cattle market was also quite fluid in terms of trying to access particular species and acquire them into your deck but also the cemental variant really added some great variability to how your deck evolved in terms of the deck building Great Western Trail Argentina certainly adds up the level and uniqueness of what you can actually do with your deck it introduces the use of the strength icons that appears on different cards there's even a new species of cattle that has a low value cost to it but a high strength value which you can use to try and persuade the farmers to work for you now I love how trying to persuade Farmers which are these kind of worker tiles with the little side symbols on them as you acquire them if you use the strength value of your cattle you do have to uh introduce exhaustion Cards into your deck which kind of makes your deck a lot less efficient so there's a bit more of a binary Choice when it comes to how you're going to discard cards and use them as you progress along the trail and

my pick is Great Western Trail Argentina so what would you give Great Western trailers or rating out of 10. oh man Great Western Trail is probably one of my favorite Euros of all time it's definitely a 10 out of 10. but what about the sequel Great Western Trail Argentina how would you rate that do you think I just could go back and change my rating if you're comparing both of the trails and the maps from both games there's a really classic feel to the original Great Western Trail Map I like the idea that the game feels more constricting as the game kind of builds up and progresses and fills up I like that there's risk spaces in the original map where if you build a property there you can access those risky actions which might mean discarding a cattle cart to get money or increasing your certificate power I know with the Argentinian version building buildings in certain Wheat Field locations means that when you then Harvest you can actually gain grain equal to the number of buildings that you have on those wheat Fields the biggest difference that I see in the trail in Argentina is that there are plenty more Forks in the room when it comes to trying to decide which way you're going to go are you going to go through a field of farmers and try and pay them a lot of your income that you've been generating throughout the game or are you going to cross over other players properties and you know give them some of your hard-earned cash I find that the forks in the game are so much more fascinating it does add to the crunchiness of the game and how cool your choices are going to be and how laid they become especially when it comes to accessing the shortcuts you are

incentivized to move your train as quickly as you can around the track because by exiting earlier on you can avoid certain places on the board when it comes to deciding which of these two trail maps are greater like Western Trail Argentina one is better when comparing whether trains or ships are better in Great Western Trail I actually really love the train mechanism and the idea that you're putting your play discs at certain cities with certain values and connecting them adjacently together so you can get bonuses in between there was something really analytical about trying to put those discs and attain those values using the deck of cards that you've got the ships at a new timing element to the game which kind of adds a little bit more pressure to how fast you do Meander up this Trail because if you take too long to Circuit the trail you're probably not going to be able to get enough discs on the ships before they leave and I think that adds that extra pull when it comes to focusing you on what sort of decisions you're going to make on the trail itself in the old game I would tend to meander a lot and try and visit as many locations as I wanted to but here you gotta pick and choose the best choices that will prepare you along and if you miss the boat you won't be able to catch the next one but I did find the cities to be not particularly interesting yes if I had a lot of greens stored up I'd be able to get more cash and some extra victory points at the end of the game but the cities themselves didn't really feel different from each other and I'm not really sure whether it was worth the

extra mental and capillary effort to deciding should I get on this ship what sort of value should I put on my disc on and which key do I want to go to and then when I get to that key which region do I want to deploy my disc into seemed too abstract and mathematical for me and I'm really not quite sure what the Thematic connection is here in terms of um the delivery aspect because the regions whilst they all are different they don't feel very different from each other so I feel like this city mechanism could have been a little bit more thematic or fleshed out a little bit further maybe providing extra actions or bonuses that fuel how you do things in the game would have been a more preferential way to use these City tiles my pick is the original Great Western Trail now before we get to my final verdict if you really enjoyed what you've seen so far don't forget to hit the like And subscribe button and check out some of the other videos on my YouTube channel the original Great Western Trail is absolutely brilliant it's a focused game experience that has really tight mechanics and has some great interesting choices that you can make without overwhelming the plays the game feels smooth like butter through your fingertips and there's lots of different strategies and avenues to pursue and explore which I can see um the replay value of the game becoming a little bit diminished over time once you fully explored all of the options Argentina on the other hand feels like a Next Level Great Western Trail game that builds on the mechanics of the original game and extends them really far the

multi-use cards and Pathways around the track really provide some new and interesting choices but but is it different enough to own both of these games if you haven't got either of the games and you really want that Great Western Trail experience then maybe the original game is one that's good for introducing you to the world of Great Western Trail especially if you're delving into heavy Euro games for the first time but if you're a seasoned gamer and you're thinking which of the Great Western Trails should I get then I think maybe Argentina might be more your flavor it has the essence and the DNA of the original game and the enjoyment factor of it but it does extend it further thank you once again for joining me for another board game Sanctuary video if you are a patreon supporter thank you so much for supporting me and making these videos possible I absolutely and truly appreciate all of your support if you want to become a patreon supporter and support my Channel please head to the link in the description box below otherwise this is Danny signing up if you want to see more cool Euro games I've got a cool Euro playlist on my main Channel page definitely check it out otherwise I hope your next game is an amazing one see you later foreign

Progress saved