The Anarchy vs Hadrian's Wall - Board Game Review & Comparison
Transcript
Hello everyone. This is Joe Harris
and this is Cinema
and you are watching board gaming ramblings
and today we are taking a look at the anarchy
and also Hrien's one. The anarchy was just sent to us as a review copy. So thank you so much for that. We're going to talk about both of these games today. It's going to be review but it's also going to be a comparison between the two. As always, we're not going to go deep into the rules but I'm going to very briefly explain what you are going to do. There's a theme here. The theme is pretty cool. Check it out. I like the theme, which is something I don't usually say, but I do like this one. In this game, you are using resources to tick boxes to get more resources. This is a and an Android game on steroids. This is like if you played Hrien's Wall and you thought, "Oh, this is a lot." Play this one. We haven't played Twilight Inscription, which I think is like might be even bigger. I don't know. But this one has a lot going on. You will basically be using these resources, these five different colored meeples and three different resource types to pick off boxes to help you get more stuff to help you do even more things. And what you're trying to do is of course you get victory points in the four tracks like in Hadrian's wall, but this time you also have this fort that you're trying to build up. So you're using this up here to build up the fort because every round you're going to have attack cars that's going to attack you.
Some of them you will know, some of them will be hidden. And at the end of the round, you try to have enough defense both with the fortress that you built, but also the knights and the soldiers to defend against the forces coming in to attack your fort. That will give you some positive points. So that's like the the way from Hedin's wall just exploded like there's you're drawing some cards. See, did I do it or not? It's like all these things happening. So that's basically what you're doing. You're filling in as always. You're trying to probably focus on a few of these elements. You're trying to move up here. Don't get too much discontent and try to be the player with the most points at the end of the game.
This is, I think, the most convoluted um roll and right like X and Wright I've ever played. I remember playing Hrien's Wall and being like, whoa, this is a lot. When we played Hrien's Wall after we played this, I'm just like,
this is what is this? This is easy. Walk in a park. This is so much information on these sheets and you have a lot more resources and meo colors to um keep track of now and it's pretty clear the cost and everything that I I can't agree. I have no problems with I think it's great
but it is a game of how much can I squeeze out of my action. So, uh, for example, I use a gray worker to takeick off this box that gives me a red worker and then I can do something else now with that. So, you're trying to use stuff to get stuff. So, you can use them more and so the rounds can
be pretty long because you're squeezing out so many extra things.
Yeah. So probably the more your longer you play, you're going to also think more about all the attacks and all that because in the first round you're going to have only like a basic attack which you always are going to have and you're going to have one more attack card each round. So you're going to have from two to six attack cards and half of them are going to be face up and face down. And in these kind of games and Hans as well, I remember the first time I played it, I just had to jump in. I just had to pay something to tick a box and see where that took me. It is I would say it's tight but it's not one where you have to like think about every decision because most of the time if you not like spend very like not thinking at all you will be able to maybe squeeze out this one thing if you do like the most important things first
even though we jump right into the game.
The first time you play this game two player took three hours.
Yes it took
and then after that like two 15 two and a half. The box says 90 minutes,
which I think
would be long enough.
So, I don't know why it takes that much, but I think like the worse you are at the game, the the shorter it's going to be because you're going to do less stuff.
Not to say like, oh, we're so good at the game. That's not what I'm meaning because I don't get a very high score. But it's a game where you are doing many, many, many things. And there is a couple of reasons also why we add AP to the game and we're going to talk about those soon because first before we go into the rest of the review.
Mhm.
Do you like this game?
Yeah, I do.
Do you have fun when you play it?
Yeah, I do.
Yes, I like almost everything I do in this game. But one big change from Adrian's Wall, which we thought worked ex like surprisingly well as a multiplayer game, even though you're just doing your own thing. This is one of those.
This is one of those where I I don't care because I have so much fun in my little bloody puzzle
that I don't care what you're doing at all. It's not like most simultaneous action games I don't like because I I'm like a disengaged. It's like I have all my energy here. Yes. and I I can't do anything what you're doing.
But there is one thing that they added a lot of in the anarchy. One of our favorites elements in games and what is that cinema?
It is luck.
Yes.
Uh and there's a lot more luck here than in Hrien's wall.
So much more
added for example a lot of luck in the things that you do on your play player board. Yes.
Player sheet. So these elements all these are you have to draw some cards and depending on there's a lot of symbols and they correspond to the the specific
action that you're doing
action that you're doing and depending on what you get you either get stuff or you don't get stuff. And of course when you do it multiple times you will cross off more and more symbols here and the chances of you getting more stuff will increase but
it's not very satisfactory when you are using the resources and then you don't get anything.
I feel it some of them are more bothersome than the others. Like for example the Sylvanas has festival you're going to get a couple of these like you're going to bit lucky if you get all of them if but if you you have to go for everything and then you might get all of them if you're lucky here. It even has like a uh mitigation where you can go left or right there. This one has a lot of elements to it where you have many options and you can like do it and you can continue later.
This is the hardest I think because you can get like really unlucky with the numbers because you're adding up and wanting a specific number but it's very cheap. Yes,
it's just like one yellow dude and you can get potentially three resources.
This is not my least favorite. like this is okay for the most part. The first time we played, I played tournaments trying to do that. I lost my three first tournaments with four four first tournaments. We basically lost me four points. Yeah.
And four different soldiers. If I had more luck, I would just have four more points. And four points is quite a lot in this game. One thing that's a big change from Hrien's Wolf. In Hrien's Wall, you draw a card for everyone. That's the resources everyone get. Then you draw two cards from your deck. You choose one that's going to be your scoring card and you choose one that's going to be your card with like the uh good that somebody can trade the path you can write in your sheet in the left corner here. There's a place you can can write and also the bonus resources you're getting in this game. You're drafting kind of you're drafting if you're first. Yes. if you're second or last if I'm in a multiplayer game if you ever choose to play that you you just get what you get. So turn order is kind of important but also you're just going to like the resources I did you feel like oh I have to take this one over this one? Oh, no. I looked at the scoring basically and chose always the scoring that I thought were best for me. And of course, you kind of do that in Hrien's wall as as well, but I the draft didn't feel as satisfying here.
No, I there's I would have loved that to be maybe one more card on number of players, but then again, maybe not. I don't know. I just I'm
It's still not the thing that bothers me the most. the the the luck element that bothers me the most of in this game is the combat because you will draw these combat cards that tells you where the attacks is going to happen. Some of them are face down. So it tells you something but not all the information. And for example there you you look at the fort here. There's a lot of
It's a very good fork.
Yeah, I love the fort. Like the
I just meant also this is a very like high level fort.
It's a high level fort. And also uh this um like these components are much cooler than just taking off a box.
This is amazing. Yes.
Yes. But the thing is that you can have built up, let's say that you've spent a lot of resources building up your walls. Yes.
But you draw only attack cards with towers. So you can't defend with your walls. No.
So then
either you have to use your entire round to uh build up your towers or you will get those negative points and there is nothing you can do about that. And it's like a double negative because you are it is both like you don't get the positive point and then you also get a negative point. That's the same as in Hadrien as well. Just feels harder here. H and the face down cards not sure I like them. And we played like the easy mode the first time then we went on to play the medium mode or hard mode.
He did it.
Wouldn't do that because it just adds even more randomness.
I couldn't do anything out there. Well, I could, but I had to use so much resources to max my castle at all costs. Maybe you can play like
rounds of the game where you just ignore defense, but
kind of that's the theme of the game is that you're defending yourself
and there are ways to mitigate like the like if you get discontent, there are ways to get content like get the positive to get it back.
Get content. But the reason this luck bothers me a lot is because it's a multiplayer game and I like to play a game where my what I do in the game make me win. So all this randomness if you happen to build a lot of walls
and you get lucky and you draw a lot of ladders for example or the arrows and you can of course we didn't tell you like you could use knights but they they die. So like all everything you build in your fort is permanent. So when you play it a multiplayer game
Mhm.
it will be a position and this happened a lot of times where it's like oh I can't do this but no oh you half of your cards are the things that you built.
Yes.
And that is frustrating and
that is basically without saying like I think you understand what we mean without going like even deeper into it. I feel this does not work as a multiplayer game if you care about playing a game where you want to win.
Yeah, I I you you said the things that I wanted to say basically. I I agree.
Okay. So, do you do you feel like Hadron's Wall is better as a multiplayer game?
Yeah, I think so. Also, because it takes a lot shorter time for me.
An hourish to play Hadron's wall and this is going to be two to three hours.
But I feel like Oh, what did you want to say? But like if I'm if I'm just looking away from the luck Yes. and I'm looking away from the time.
This is very fun.
It's more fun.
Yes. Because you can take up a Henri's wall um
sheet
sheet
so we can compare
because there's a lot more stuff in the new game like and and there's a lot less of these uh blank spaces. Here we have these tracks that kind of you have to do this one before you can do that. And that's gone from H.
There is like the crane that you have to build.
Yes. Yes. Yes. It is kind of like that. But this this feels like you're doing a lot stuff and it is kind of fun.
So because of the frustrations we had, I did something that I don't usually do. Yeah,
I sat down to play this solo because when I play solo, not that I do that, but when you play this game solo, that luck doesn't really matter because this amount of luck feels like the amount of luck that you usually get in a solo game
because there's supposed to be that luck there to not just be a static machine that you do this thing every time to be able to win the game.
So, I love this game solo. Mhm.
The game is great, but I will never play it again with other people.
Yeah.
Um, and I have I don't usually enjoy solo games. I even tried doing like a solo thing. Didn't work well. This is the most fun I had playing a solo game ever.
That's cool.
Because I was doing the exact same thing as I did when I was playing with you.
Yeah.
Except that I didn't have the frustration of you getting lucky and I getting unlucky or the other way around, which wouldn't annoy me, but it would annoy you. Also, it has this which is a solo campaign. I feel like this is a solo game. I'm unsure like because Scarfield games have already done a solo only game.
Yeah.
And this one I am unsure why isn't just a solo only game because but the thing is many people enjoyed Headwinds wall with multiple players and I do as well. I will always choose that if I play with more. I only play the first scenario but even the first scenario gives you like things you have to do. So every scenario has a a story and also has like specific things you have to do. So the first scenario I had to like I had to build all the mints. I have to have 15 loyalty, 15 influence. I had to have zero to two discontent and I had to get 60 or more points.
Cool.
And I I did that. But and also if you like get to the bonus where you get like have a bonus goal, you also get like a little bonus in the next game if you continue playing the campaign. And this one when I finished playing it, I was thinking I might do this again.
That's
and that never happens. So for me, this is like a very different beast as the solo game and the multiplayer game. And it is just because of that look.
Yeah.
So who do you think going to work like this? Do you think solo players? Yes. Or if you don't mind the luck or you don't mind the time?
Yeah. I think like if you don't Yeah. The solo game took me 1 hour and 15 minutes. I I can't explain that. Yeah. No. And well, I can explain it a little bit because when we play multiplayer, sometimes I'm finished when you're my resources and I'm waiting for you. And some rounds the opposite happens. And also I also want to stress that if you thought think that her wall is a lot and think that is borderline too much for a x and right, this is might not be for you because this is even more.
That is true. So, so solo players, absolutely. Or as I said, like if you if you are one of those players that you just want to do the best you can and not really care about the winning. Yeah,
that might be a problem that I I like to play games. Not that I have to win, but I enjoy playing games to try to beat a a score or here I enjoy it where you had the goals.
Yeah.
Okay. So, let's do some final thoughts. Do you want to begin?
Yeah. I like the game. I think it's fun one. I play it, but I don't think that I will play it
because I will not play it solo. I might if it were an app, but how would you make this into an app? There's so many things. It would be very hard to like then it would be have to be like a PC game because the phone would be too little of a screen to keep track of all this. I think that as you said, the luck bothers me a little too much when I'm playing against other people. You
even though you win.
Yeah. Yeah. But it kind of bothers me either way.
And also um um playing Hadron's Wall again made me realize that that also is actually a pretty fun game. though uh none of them are they are far from my favorite X and Wright games. I never loved Hadron's Wall. I thought it was a nice game, but I never loved it. And this will fall into the same category. So, I'm going to give this a seven. I think it's a good game, but I think
this had potential to have an even higher score, but because of the negatives that we've mentioned, this is going to be for me a game on a pile of games. And I don't think that I have a desire to keep this game in the collection.
I think before I played solo, I would have thought exactly the same as you. I think if you like this is a crunchy and right, this is just fun. When you play it, when you play it multiplayer, don't do that. When you play it solo, which I feel like it was designed to do, it's great. I enjoy it. And I enjoyed it so much that I think I want to keep it because I think I might choose to do it again.
Mhm.
Because it was just like a very relaxing, enjoyable 1 hour 20 minute that I I just really enjoyed. So before I played solo, I think I would have ended up like you. Maybe a 6.5.
But as a solo game, I will give it an eight.
Cool. So, I really enjoyed it as a solo game. Would not recommend it as a multiplayer game. And that is the end of the video. If you watched it, you can subscribe because it's free and helps us. And thank you so much. I'm Johannes and you've been watching Board Gaming Ramblings. And bye-bye.