Cooperate (but not really) to stop the enemy! - Tianxia Board Game Review
Transcript
Hello everyone. This is Johannes
and this is Cinema
and you are watching Board Gaming Ramblings
and today we are taking a look at Tiana.
We are. This is another spiel release and we are going to play it. No, we're not. We have played it. Now we're going to talk about it. I got it confused. I confused how the review works. I thought we were first talking about it. We already did that. Now we're going to play it the other way around. And this is a release. It was sent to us from the publishers. So, thank you so much for that. We hope to see you at Spiel because we will be there. If you're not going to spill, you can come along with us basically because we're doing daily vlogs from the fair. So you will see that. So we hope you enjoy that. If you are going to the be there, we will be there every single day. But if you want to make sure to find us, we will be at the Alliance Chili Foxa area on Saturday from 10:00 to 2:00 and Sunday from 1 to 5. If you see us there or if you see us wandering around, please say hi. Please stop us and please show us the secret sign. We would love to see you there. With that out of the way, let's talk about this game. As always, a brief little overview in this game, which is a action selection kind of worker placement game where you are trying to build buildings. You're trying to move on tracks because you're and you're also trying to stop these nomads which are moving on tracks. They are moving on tracks. You're like, "No, no more moving on those tracks for you, nomad." But when they move too much, they will attack you. And then you will have to have built these towers, these walls, and sent out these these military dudes, soldiers to try to stop the nomads from moving farther on their track because the track is going all the way down there. And if they move too far on their track, you will lose points. And if they move forward enough on the track, they will destroy the buildings that you have put your governors into to get stuff.
And stuff is good. So this game is all about tracks and antitras. Basically, it's tracks versus antitras. every round which there are four of them. You are going to have three of these action discs. You can also on your turn do three different things. You can pass. Last thing you do get some bonuses, be able to pay to move on some tracks. Other than passing, which is boring, you can put people into these boats to get resources. And when you do that, let's say I pay to put in here, I will assign this one there. And I will boom move this over there. And this one is now going to go back to the playerboard which I have over here. It looks like this. It's not that interesting to look at, which is the reason why we don't have it in frame. It will go over here as a merchant. And I have one of these filled out. This is an extra action that I can do whenever I want to. Other than that, the last one, which is the main thing, is I can use one of my discs, the action discs kind of workers to place in an area of the board. When I place an area of the board, I can build buildings. I can ship things. We've just put some ships here. They're supposed to be over there, but because of size, this port is pretty big. I put them here. you have to pay some resources to get some stuff back. You can as build buildings, you can trade resources into goods, which the goods are what you mostly use for the ships. And if you go over here to the military actions, you can build towers and walls. And you can also assign soldiers to the different walls depending on where you want to defend.
And we're going to talk more about that in the review. At the end of each round, you're going to see if people, the nomads, have gotten too far on their tracks, which you had to stop them in their track. Hey, I like that one.
So, if they move to their last space, you just put them down to make it easier to see. They will attack. And looking at the de the attack, you will subtract the defense. Everything is a one defense and the tower is two. If it goes through the tower, it will kill the soldiers. And if it still has more, it will go and destroy the building, which will destroy everything that's there. So, take away the the governors that there and add a tile that makes it more expensive. And then it will lose some more strength. It will continue down if it comes all the way to the end. and still have strength and all the players are going to lose points or coins depending on the strength that is left. And you're going to continue doing that. You're going to score some points for some uh objective cars. You can also throw them away to get the onetime bonus. If you don't think you're going to be able to achieve the goals and at the end of the game, the player who has the most points is going to be the winner of Tanga.
This is a pretty tight resource management game, I would say. Uh especially um the first time we played it, I felt like I had zero resources all the time. So this is all about spending resources on something that might give you resources back so you are able to continue doing stuff. I love these boats, by the way, because they are like there are notches for them in the board, which is pretty awesome. But paying one coin to put a uh mele there uh will not only gain you the this bonus right away, but it might potentially give you income at the start of the next round and also if it gets bounced off, it will also make you able to do those abilities and being able to snag some of these buildings. Mhm.
I I like to see at the beginning of the game, okay, which of these buildings do I think that will benefit me the most throughout this game? I feel like that is pretty important.
It is one of those where there's just like a different layout every time. There's more building than these.
It is one of those games where I feel like even I played it a few times now, I still feel like I'm doing stuff and I'm forgetting how to get points.
Yeah.
I'm not being I'm not very good at this game. I'm not the worst, but I'm not like very good because I am in positions where I'm like, okay, but I want to build this building and do these things because that gives me this bonus, but I'm like, where does the point comes from? And I feel like a lot of the points come from the combat. But it's an interesting mechanism because let's say that three players have built here. But let's just say a in an example that the blue player hasn't built anything here. H, and the blue player is winning over here. So the blue player has built like it's the same. This is this is stupid. and the the tie break is broken by the soldier. So let's say this is attacking now and let's say blue is thinking okay I can put more stuff in there but it's just going to help you by not destroying your pieces but if you are the winner of the area you will get more points if there are pieces left so it's like a balance of these things but it is like a lot of actions to be able to like to lose them is a bad thing
and it is just like a it's an interesting interaction there I feel like
yes and I don't think this is a very interactionheavy game but But it is some like Euro interaction there. And the interesting thing about this as you called it like an action selection um worker placement game, but you don't block the actions. You just make it more expensive to go there. So that's also a a neat thing
which sometimes is a blocking because depending on what the other players have. I would say thoughite that this is kind of like a semi co-op thing. Yeah.
So that way it has more interaction than many other Euros that we usually play. Then also it's like the area majority feels like also here.
It is an area majority but it's this kind of that thing of I'm not only thinking oh it's for the points but I'm thinking okay I want to save that but if I want to do that I get points will help you depending on what you're trying to do that polling is very good so maybe I should go and save this area so that you have to go and work for that where you save that area. So I would say like interaction wise it has a bit more than most modern Euro games which is mostly like a heads down kind of thing. It's it's a tad up. It's not if you're looking for a heavy interaction game. It's not this but it is in there. Absolutely.
I agree. I think it's interesting the balance between uh because as you said this is a great way to score points but this is like the fun stuff because this is this is not my most favorite thing that I do in this game. No, it's building up resources and placing things.
Yeah. And that's just like I do it for the points and I do it for not getting a lot of negative points if they go all the way through, but I want to do this stuff, but then you're just like, but but I have to do this as well. I like the balancing. You have to balance doing the fun stuff and also doing like, okay, they can't kill us entirely. We have to defend us like in a in some ways. You have the objective cards and some of them is telling you none of these but some of them are telling you to have like uh this one for example the shipping it's you can just do that you can ship to the different actions it's not that hard to do this one is having specific amount that one is also like if you start early and people if you know everybody know the game they oh you're only placing in those two areas so you're trying to do this to score the points but and the the tracks as well it's kind of like you try not to be too obvious But there is like one of the categories is the uh one where you want to be in a specific area with your governors and that one is feeling like depending on the group you play with because if you people are just trying to get the most points they're trying to defend the areas.
Yeah.
But it's kind of like you cannot score those points by yourself. You need that other people are helping. Like let's say I have one where I have to have I don't remember exactly what the card is, but let's say I want to have in this area and this area and this area. Yeah. To be able to have those there at the end of the game, I would need to to save both this area and this area and if it's depending on the way the game plays because sometimes they will attack often and sometimes they will attack less but have like a high attack value. So that ends up then being a harder scoring I feel. It's harder to control if you're scoring or if we're not. Let's talk about the two-player experience that we had because in the two-player game, you need a bot.
You do
and the butt works.
It works well like it does what it's supposed to do.
But it felt like kind of to me clunky that we had to like, oh no, we have to remember that the bots should be doing something. Uh and also it felt as bots are random. is just like says on card what's it supposed to do. So I felt like when we played it with more players, I liked it way more. So I would not buy this game to play it with two players.
If you don't mind bots, this is a good bot. This feels like a solo bot just made for two. H if you're used to playing solo and then you're playing on two player and you don't mind the bot, it works perfectly. And it it has three cards h going to do three actions. Each round of three actions is going to do bunch of bunch of things,
but the second one is going to be face up. So when you know the game, you can see, oh, it's going to do those things. is going to block that space. Maybe I want to do that. We didn't get that far to playing it with that. So for us, we usually we used to be the way or if I opened the box and said two players use this dummy. No, let's do something else. We're not that averse to that anymore. But still, it's not my favorite thing. So I agree with you. For me, I wouldn't play this again with two. But if you are used to playing and you don't mind a bot, I don't think it is a problem at all. How do you feel about the uh variability of the game?
I think it's good. I think um because of it has so many interchangeable elements. For example, all these are different every time. As you said, there's different ones also you can change with in the box. And also these um basically what uh action areas corresponds with the tracks makes it a little different as well, but you're doing kind of you will do the things every time.
But also the player boards have different merchant actions different on both sides. So you have different feel like when I play the one where I had three coins now players are going to get pushed pretty often. So you know you're going to get to fill this up if you choose to fill this up instead of the other ones. So I know that okay I have those three coins in the bank. I can use them whenever I want to. But if you play with another one you're going to need okay where do I find those coins and do something else with it. So I do like that. I have to say
because this game is pretty tight. You have few actions h and everything matters. It feels like and and things will this game will have and this happened last time we played will have positions where somebody's like I'm just going to do this now and do this action and then the next player turns like that was my whole plan
and now I can't do anything because I only I have one coin to do it for example. So it does lend itself to a lot of AP because of that.
Yes, absolutely. But then again, some turns is super snappy. My turn can be I put a dude in here, I get a stone.
Those turns are usually not AP.
I'm done.
Those are like hm resource I guess.
So So not every single one is having AP and it really depends on the group, but but certainly with us, we've had some
Yes. Uh that use very long time on the return. And I can't imagine why because this game is so simple.
Okay. Okay. So, who do you think is going to like this game? Do you think Okay, first question.
This is a new way of doing this.
Yeah,
I'm making it up now. Never going to do this again. Uh,
do you think this is better for gamers or dogs?
Hm, that's a hard question.
Wrong answer.
I would say
gamers was a right one.
Okay,
you answered the hard question. That's the wrong answer. Next question. Do you think this is for Eurogamers? Mhm.
Or war gamers.
Uh, Eurogamers.
Okay. Who do you think this is for?
Hey, Eurogamers. Well,
I think if you like trying to squeeze out the most of the little things that you have, if you, for example, I I really like doing the the most delivering to the boats when that's possible because that could give you some pretty cool stuff back. uh especially that one boat that you have displayed over there. You can actually see that some boats are like because they're uh separate the sails on the trunks or what you call them.
So the boats.
Yeah,
the trunk from the boat.
The trunk of the boat. Uh so that boat is pretty sweet to deliver to right now. I like to find those uh see the opportunities and see like okay I want to do that and if I get to do that the first oh I have three of the matching resources that I need or I only have two but I want the third one is if you if you like wrapping your head around a game like that yes you can have a lot of fun with this game.
I'm feeling you're already kind of into your final thoughts so you can you can continue your final thoughts. Um, yeah, as I said, I think it's a a pretty like interesting and tight resource management game. I I like the way that they've done the action selection and the balance between defending and also setting up for, for example, more income or resources in future turns. And also, the track movement is pretty tense some uh times as well because you want to there's some set collection with these different what you call figurines.
Yes. So sometimes you you really scan the board for opportunities to be like, "Okay, I want a movement on the red track. It's super important for me now, but I really don't have anything to do in this area that gives me movement on the red track. So do I risk uh taking like a turn to get the resources so that I can go to the red track later or want to do it now?" And also uh you have some some areas that you can trade with as well. So you're trying to when you go to a an area to have the things so you can do all the things as so you don't feel like you're doing suboptimal things, but you're not going to be able to achieve that. So I feel like has a lot of interesting moments like that and I really like this game. So I'm going to give this a 7.5. Janga is a pretty good game. I enjoy it. I enjoy it from most of the things you said. I felt like the first time I played, we played with a bot the first time. So, it was kind of like a shoppy way of playing it and we played it more and with more players enjoyed more than that. I enjoy everything I do. It's not one that is going to be my favorite game of all time. It is a It's a good game. It's It's a It's a pretty good game. And I think that if you enjoy Euro games, I'm always doing the who is it for inside of my own.
Yes, you are. I I like this.
It I don't know. I like it. It's It's separate if people want to go and look at it, but then they should watch the whole thing because you will get the whole picture.
I'm going to land on 7.5 as well. I think it's a a pretty good game. I am happy to play it again.
It's not one I'm going to be like, "Oh, I don't want to play that again." Because it gives me a lot of fun feelings,
but at the same time, it giving me that brain brain thing. It gives me the brain thing.
Yes,
that's like a quote you can use.
Gives me the brain thing. So, yeah, that's it.
Yes,
I think your final thoughts were better than mine for this one.
And it's not your best.
No, but basically
7.5. I would not go e if I had to play it again. It gives me the brain thing.
I enjoy words.
I enjoy the action selection. I enjoy that I have so few actions. So I have to really think about it because I'm like, "Oh, but I should use one of my actions to build the walls, but if I also want to build the or get the new soldiers, that's two of my three actions this round. I can't do that. So maybe I will try to get more rice so I can then have more soldiers next time I do the action. And oh, should I do a little a little action and a little action or should I build up?" But then you're going to fill up all the spaces so I don't have any more spaces to fill in my walls. So, it's like a lot of these things and a lot of those decisions that makes it a 7.5. Was that better?
Yeah. Oh,
perfect.
Thank you. That is the end. We hope to see you in Spiel. Give us the secret sign. Come and say hi to us. Whenever you see us wandering around, we're going to be there all week. If you want to make sure to find us, you will find us at the Alliance Chil Fox support booth area to 10 from 10 to 2 on Saturday and 1 to 5 on Sunday. See you there. Thank you so much for watching. Subscribe. I'm Johannes. I'm And you've been watching Board Gaming Ramblings. And bye-bye.