Skip to main content
Loading video...

The ULTIMATE ROOT Faction Tier List

Transcript 49:50

if we take a look at the core of root with all of the factions plucked away you're left with a dry and tasteless game like having barbecue in Europe only about 10% of root is the actual core rules and the other 90% is all the faction specific additions the base rules are just a canvas for the factions to do their own song and dance so this leads me to scratch my chin and Ponder if the game is 90% the factions mechanics isn't the game's quality almost entirely dependent on the quality of the factions and how well they mix together yes my friends the answer is yes the ultimate faction tier list so here's how we're going to do this we're ranking the 10 released factions under a few different criteria each also out of 10 complexity to play since each faction is so wildly different their difficulty to understand and play also matters throughout this list I'll start off with the least complex FX and work my way up how much fun is a faction to play for a game to be good it has to be fun and since the vast majority of Route is based on the faction you play each faction needs to be fun to Pilot and to actually play as how much fun is the faction to play against likewise if you want good interaction your enemies need to be fun to fight and not just a furball of frustration how strong is the faction there's a pretty hefty competitive scene on tabl top simulator and a bit over the

online digital adaptation so power levels matter and especially for those who want to take the game more seriously it is important to know how they rank up next to each other also it's nice to know you have agency and can actually impact a game the overall quality most important the overall Vibe of the faction and how all the elements mesh together for how good the faction really is for the game as a whole great I hope that all makes sense let's go starting off we got the mares de cat with a complexity of 1 out of 10 a fun to play factor of 7 out of 10 fun to fight 10 out of 10 and a strength of three out of 10 the overall quality is 7 out of 10 okay so the cats are the most basic and simple faction you know the type generic Space Marines but in feminine cat form you can Implement any RTS knowledge that you might have and for the most part it will translate to the Marquees zat they start off with a huge board presence as they represent the current rulers if they can maintain their control of their Network they will be able to create an industrial Haven like Nestle and our water supply the cats industrialize the forest for their gain to score points you need to build and each building serves a unique purpose The Sawmill makes wood the workshop lets you craft the recruiter lets you get more troops then there are actions you can take but all of them are basic and easily resolved even though there as basic as bleach the cats are still enjoyable to

operate they have a similar vibe to Ryu and Street Fighter or the Teran and Starcraft they feel like they operate with the base mechanics in the most logical way and reward an understanding of the fundamentals like Rule and basic actions of movement and fighting so yeah super easy to play and understand so they get a 1 out of 10 for complexity likewise the logistic lines of wood can give great Glee and present a fun little optimization puzzle to spread your labor camps the cats are reliant on bird cards to gain extra actions so some games can feel less active than others dependent on draws but overall they still feel fun game after game so a 7 out of 10 for fun to play is pretty reasonable now I love seeing cats in my games because their initial setup creates the best counterbalance to all the other factions they always feel threatening but due to their limited action economy it's rare for cats to attack immediately they create points of tension through outout the board without feeling overwhelming it's honest to play against them and they alter the board state in a very healthy way for the game they have good presence and clear weaknesses that can be strategized around which is perfect for the other players so they're an easy 10 out of 10 to play against that said from a strength perspective cats are weaker than average they suffer from an almost their syndrome where they can get to about 20 points consistently but then they just kind of Crash due to their wood transport system falling apart they're the weakest of the militant factions but they aren't the weakest

faction in the game so they're ranked three out of 10 in terms of strength still the cats get a 7 out of 10 for overall quality they represent the standard for what to expect from the game and really just add a lot of good to any match while they're a tiny bit boring compared to the insanity later on they can still be a fun little puzzle while presenting a good entry point into route overall a healthy fun addition to the game that can sometimes feel a bit weak but that's all right you know the Eerie dynasties with a complexity of two out of 10 a fun to play of 10 out of 10 a fun to fight also 10 out of 10 a strength of 8 out of 10 and an overall quality of 10 out of 10 the Eerie are a group of four bird dudes who are trying their best to recover from complete failure like a bunch of tech Bros these four leaders like to program each has their own ability and loyal vizer that sets the pce for that plan they then program a list of commands called a decree and if the decree is failed that leader puts the kingdom into turmoil and is then disposed of and a new leader replaces them the Eerie perfectly demonstrates the simplet to-play heart to master game design for new players the idea of programming a decree and then following what needs to be done is very approachable and rewarding it's like a flowchart so they get a 2 out of 10 for complexity for experienced players pulling off a stacked decree is a t ton of fun and gives that Yu-Gi-Oh Millennium Eye foresight the decree

mechanic is really quite brilliant because it gives an excuse for players to actually be aggressive and expand without making it feel personal and the mechanics of the Eerie tickle the brain in all the right places and are logically presented so people can catch on really quickly the eie are both extremely fun to play and to fight because you know what's in that decree you know what's incoming and you know what you can play around as an enemy to the eie you can perfectly sabotage a decree with a single wellth thought out attack but the decree as a mechanic is still powerful and it's a tool that keeps the Eerie extremely competitive they act as an expanding force that starts off huddled and localized in one clearing but grow in ability to spread quickly as the pilot playe the Erie has a constant sense of being on the knife's edge which your decree and fulfilling a huge decree is a great step forward to Victory while for opponents having to deal with every single approaching force can add to a healthy tension because you can then predict and interrupt their plans through sabotaging their decree so 10 out of 10 to play as and to fight against the Eerie are often considered one of the most powerful factions in the game and a top pick in the tournament scene the only real blemish I feel from the Eerie is that most games start off with the charismatic leader for that sweet sweet troop advantage and the Builder leader is rarely used but overall it's a minor critique of an overall Stellar display of game design the eie are super solid and if every faction was this good I would be dying to play rout every sing single day until my bones are cooked so 10 out of 10 for the overall quality for the Eerie the

corvid conspiracy with a complexity of 3 out of 10 fun to play four out of 10 fun to fight five out of 10 a strength of 1 out of 10 and an overall quality of 4 out of 10 next up we have the other birds the corvid conspiracy the corvid are an underground network of slippery spies who can plant little plots that can be flipped and revealed for their gain they can pop up across the board and are in general little agents of chaos now these sneaky birds are surprisingly intuitive to play the concept of converting troops into undercover plots and then given the signal to activate them makes perfect sense and is thematically strong to make life a bit easier they have the Nimble ability where they can move around clearings without concern for Ru which I find is very helpful for newer players simply put the crows need to reveal their plots and as they reveal they accelerate their points so the the really only difficult part is knowing what each four plot does so they get a 3 out of 10 for complexity playing as the corvid though does feel frustra their main mechanism of scoring is very easy to disrupt and ruins the flow of their points many other factions tend to ramp up naturally as the game progresses and a corvid ramp based off how many plots are already on the board the thing is it's very easy for enemies to just go and Destroy these plots or even worse expose the plots before they even go off yeah it's a blast when when you can get that perfect bomb off but it's often easy to predict because there can only be a maximum of two of each plot in play

worst case plots can be exposed via multiple enemies attempting multiple exposure actions which is a minimal sacrifice if it means that the Corvette are out of contention of the game there is a counter raade token that rewards the crows if the token is removed except when it's exposed but even that doesn't really do much because if they can't convert those new Birds into effective plots it becomes uneventful in a way the whole raid token is cyclic the crow becomes a raid token then it gets attacked and removed and then more crows come and then those crows become more raid tokens sure there's a lot of crows but they don't really necessarily translate to points if they all get exposed by other players this is especially frustrating when the crows feel so limited on their action economy and to squeeze out more actions you need to reduce your card draw I've seen interesting openings where players start with a raid token to get revealed as soon as possible so that the point scoring is accelerated while also creating a deterrent to attack in that one token or even players who put tokens completely randomly which in a way is to recognize that the effects are less important than the points generated but nothing really seems to be a great way to ease the frustrations of playing as the Corvette so yeah it's not great for either side the crows aren't that fun to play as and they aren't that fun to fight so four out of 10 to play as and five out of 10 to play against for a faction all about plotting and schemes they're kind of boring but if someone is really interested in playing a sneaky faction I guess they fit the fantasy but they don't really excel in what could

have been from a strength perspective the crows are often considered the weakest faction in the whole game there are just too many things working against them the risk of exposure is too high and their abilities like nimble and embedded agents aren't enough to dissuade people from attacking them and ruining their game they don't feel like they have much control or they don't gain much power throughout a single game and winning with them will often just feel like you weren't even considered in the first place so yeah the crow dudes they get a 1 out of 10 for strength now one interesting buff I saw during the 2023 tournament scene is that the crows can have three of each plot instead of two this is actually super good because now you can have two of each plot face up and people still need to guess between four total plot types even better is that the physical game actually comes with three of each plot token anyways because the people at letter games thought it might be a good idea in case one or two gets scuffed so it's a fun buff for the crows and it's actually resulted in the crows having a huge win rate increase in the tournament so let's go letter games make it official right overall I don't hate the crows I just feel like they could have been more small changes would go a long way but for right now with the rules as written the corv it are a 4 out of 10 for Quality the Vega bond with a complexity of 4 out of 10 a fun to play as a question mark out of 10 a fun to fight of one out of 10 and a strength of 10 out of 10 the overall quality of the VAB bond is a one out of 10 ah the VAB

Bond these nine little hot messes are the most divisive faction in the game since the veon is the man with no name esque RPG character who helps and hinders those that they wish they are a versatile and very powerful faction and very UNC so let's get started shall we learning in the VAB Bond as a concept is fairly easy but the execution can be tricky because they have so many exceptions it's easy to understand that each item is connected to a different action boots for movements swords for attacking root te for refreshing items hammers to craft and repair tissues for all your whiny enemies it's all fairly easy to grasp conceptually the problem comes with the exceptions for example when you move into a territory with a hostile faction It Takes Two Boots or what happens when you get trapped in a revolted space what about a mob raise it can be a little hard to know what to do when effects only explicitly refer to troops buildings and tokens but not to the singular Vega Pond that said conceptually the Vega Pond is still approachable it's the exceptions that toss people into a law of rout so still they get a 4 out of 10 for complexity now a whole another discussion is needed when it comes to the VAB Bond fun levels the fun really does stop here and it's not a good time for anyone I can do a 90-minute video on why the vegab bond is bad game design but let's get into it first the vegab bond offers no reward for the player who takes the sacrifice to attack them every other faction has tokens that will be able to be removed

to score some bonus points but the vegab bond does not reward the player who hits them but just hinders the vagab bond and reduces the action economy of the player who does it it's like a really garbage prisoner dilemma because everyone doesn't want to hit the VAB Bond but someone has to otherwise the VAB Bond will spiral out of control second even if you want to stop the VAB Bond it's one piece in one clearing that can move freely even if you want to hit them you might just not be able to hit them which is not a problem that other factions have because every other faction tends to be in multiple spaces at any given time which increases the opportunities for counterplay and interaction which the vegabond lacks there's just a general lack of interaction with the Vagabond from the perspective of other players third let's say you have a table that's all actually down to attack the aab Bond then the vegab bond has to go into the forest and just skip out on turns constantly which isn't fun for them either but then their progress isn't really hindered as they come out good as new so trying to stop the Vega Bond and recovering as a vegab bond is unfun for both sides fourth vegabonds are the strongest King makers in a game of kingming if they aid one player and attack another player it's so awfully one-sided and vegabond are actually encouraged to help one player to get to their Ally status and there's nothing intrinsically wrong with kingm but this gameplay from the very start is not fun for the table and the vegabond encourages making Kings with one player to get them to that Ally mechanic 4.5 coalitions just coalitions they are

counter to what dominance cge should be which is a risky Gambit to turn the tides but instead they're a safety net to hop on someone else's back as a vegabond since coalitions are made with the player in last place the vegab bond could potentially Aid them enough to accelerate what ever engine they were building for example the Woodland Alliance are incredibly bursty and tend to lag behind until the end game so they benefit tremendously from the vegab bond becoming a coalition with them fifth with the base game deck some of the crafting options just feel busted especially with the Tinker VAB Bond so almost everyone who plays rout will just use the Exiles and partisans deck as a fix the sixth point oh my God they keep going once decked out with items it is common strategy just to come out of the forest and swing as hard as possible since they score off troop kills which means they can get seven8 nine points in just a few combat actions where other factions would only get points for buildings and tokens that are destroyed now these problems are minimal in a vacuum but when you blend it all together and put all of this bad game design into one little Pawn it's just a bad experience for everyone involved games without the VAB Bond are significantly better and it's just the sad reality of it all even the competitive scene uses a modified rule to reduce scoring off troops called despot infamy which only lets them score off the first troop killed in a combat which even the creator of the game endorses anyways for all of this I'm putting the vabon as a question mark to

fun to play as some people love playing as this little Havoc Destroyer chaos man other people can't stand it I just find it so uncool so I don't understand how people can like these vegab Bonds on the other hand playing against the vegab bond is a objectively awful one out of 10 every single other faction is better to have on the table no question asked again root is noticeably a better game without the vegabond seriously that said they're also the most powerful faction in the game so they get a 10 out of 10 for strength so yeah people still play vegabonds because they're just so dang powerful and if winning is important they're your best bet the vegab bond is kind of like a guy at a party who hasn't showered in 3 weeks and Gorges on all of the food spits in the punch bowl as a joke but happens to be the dean's son so everyone pretends to like his company it's awful overall quality is 1 out of 10 the underground duy with a complexity of 5 out of 10 a fun to play as s out of 10 fun to fight three out of 10 a strength of 9 out of 10 and an overall quality of 5 out of 10 okay thank God the duy the duchi are extremely strong they're muscle boys who get swall in the borrow and they have this great power fantasy but it can be frustrating to deal with their various strategies since it all feels very overwhelming I'm happy for them though relative to the nightmare that is a vagabond these moles are much improved they have a little kingdom with Barons and Earls that can be swayed into the fight against other

Woodland Critters and they like to build markets for card draw or citadels for more troops or Tunnels for sneaky movement plus they have the burrow secret hole with jacked little mole meeples the duy are still reasonable for a new to approach they have a nice flow to them and really only the idea of swaying ministers is a little tricky because of the criteria of needing to have cards in your hand and pieces on the board in a matching clearing it's still easy enough with a guide in hand but it will take a few rounds before it all clicks together they have a lot of viable options and each one feels good to interact with so a complexity of five out of 10 they're just about bordering a complex faction but once swaying ministers clicks they're very reasonable the duy also Al have this very nice rhythm of play they have a safety to them with the burrow since it's immune from other players and a nice feeling of leveling up as you sway more ministers in a way it kind of imitates the decree as you gain power but you can lose it all if you're not careful you gain actions by building up your suede ministers and in later stages of the game you can score huge points through their activation there are a lot of different strategies some involve in building citadels or markets and then going to turtle and protect those places while other strategies involve no buildings at all so you can never really pay the price of failure they're very flexible and strong with a ton of good options I especially enjoy how the community has named their strategies like small swell mmart small to swall

and it's all good fun so they get a 7 out of 10 for enjoyability to play on the other hand to fight against them can be very frustrating because they are so strong they need a lot of policing before they spiral into a bunch of jacked blind molds who can just pop out and Destroy anything the Brigadier minister is so strong and provides so much value that it really does feel kind of busted all of this leads to a gameplay style that has spiral and action economies that makes the moles feel uncontrollable if left to their own devices the mechanism to slow down these moles is to destroy one of their buildings to get them to pay the price of failure and lose that steam but to counter this some mole strategies involve no buildings at all it's almost comical it's like the moles huddled together and said we can only be slowed down if a building falls so let's agree never to build any buildings and somehow this strategy Works truthfully they're overtuned and are the strongest faction overall except for the Vega Bond fighting them feels more frustrating than any other strong faction even like the eie so they get a three out of 10 for fighting against them and a 9 out of 10 from a strength perspective the moles are a 5 out of 10 from a game design quality perspective they are a standout when it comes to the sheer strength and flexibility of that faction but they aren't really fun to play against which really just docks a ton of points from their design they would benefit from a

redo of a few of their ministers especially the Brigadier and there should be more ways to encourage them to actually build so that they can pay that price of failure they are strong they can be fun to play but since they have so much frustrating elements to play against I just can't say that they're a well-designed faction lord of the hundreds with a complexity of 6 out of 10 a fun to play of N9 out of 10 a fun to fight as 9 out of 10 a strength of 5 out of 10 and an overall quality of 9 out of 10 okay the lord of the hundreds are up next in term of complexity and we've had a couple Duds so we're back to some colossal brain design the incredibly Moody rats are a boisterous aggressive and clever example of how a faction can work they sit at 6 out of 10 for complexity because they have a few interlocking mechanics like the mob Tokens The Warlord meeple their mood cards and their unique use of items I've encountered a ton of choice paralysis from new players when decid in what mood to put their rat warlord as and it spirals from there into a bunch of decisions that can often be hard to link together but the rats are the Border between medium and high complexity factions the complexity of the rats can be explained through thematics for example if a mob exists long enough it will destroy everything and steal all the items hidden in the ruins give back to the rat warlord's horde which then allows for more actions but also limits what mood he can be in or how the

hundreds score by completely oppressing a clearing which is to only have their pieces in the clearing as they watch the rest of the forest collapse the rats are fast aggressive and have a a lot of influence on what happens on the board thankfully they don't feel overwhelmingly strong due to their criteria to score requires complete domination of a clearing the faction presents a lot of player decisions and has a nice flow of inight in mobs and grown in power from the wealth of The Horde and the increase in size of their army plus the idea of a unique singular piece in an army is novel but doesn't feel overpowered or fundamentally broken it's just fun and different so yeah easy 9 out of 10 fun to play as likewise playing against the hundreds presents a clear pathway for interaction they have a need to constantly move destroy and occupy so finding choke holes as another militant faction is key to counter them or if you're playing as an Insurgent faction using the unique spawning methods to sneak and take over poorly defended hundreds clearings presents clear counterplay to their strategy their card draw is also abysmal and their buildin action takes from both card economy and action economy which makes it especially painful to have those buildings destroyed they have a lot of board impact and they do feel like a moveing horde that decimates everything in its path and playing against this style is actually very enjoyable without ever feeling awful so yeah they get a 9 out of 10 to play against the hundreds are also a fairly balanced faction right in the middle of

our list at 5 out of 10 strength they have clear weaknesses and a fairly predictable over Aran strategy does limit their path of Destruction but their unique powers can keep them as a powerful police en Force they can move fast hit hard but leave vulnerabilities if they don't play carefully I don't find them weak at all but I don't find them overwhelmingly op so a nice 5 out of 10 in terms of strength relative to all other factions overall the rats are an excellent faction with clear strengths weaknesses and flavorful decision space it's a success in game design that flies to the top of what root has to offer so 9 out of 10 for overall design quality the Woodland Alliance with a complexity of seven a fun to play as as 6 out of 10 a fun to fight 5 out of 10 a strength of 6 out of 10 and overall quality 6 out of 10 the Woodland Alliance is the local foxes rabbits and mice of the forest clearings uniting against the tyranny of the other invading factions these little buddies play much more like a nice little Euro game than a war game since the Woodland Alliance works by rousing up supporters from their local clearing they need to have car cards in their supporter deck of that corresponding clearing these supporters can be rallied up and turned into sympathizers who then with enough support can be transformed into military bases through a Revolt then through the night these bases act as the military operations Hub to further spread support and attack usurpers so if all of that sounds a bit confusing it's fair because

that's because the Woodland Alliance from a conceptual standpoint can be a bit intimidating they don't start off with any of their funny little post soldiers on the board and their first few rounds can be infuriating as it feels like no progress is made that said they have the highest burst potential and isn't unusual for a well-positioned woodland Alliance player to win the game from 18 or so points the strength is shrouded in confusion until you really learn how to operate them and how they're able to transform various resources into sympathy which just skyrockets them into a point lead so yeah these little buddies get a 7 out of 10 for complexity from a fun toplay perspective Ive they're a little odd some players love the concept of gathering sympathy and spreading as an elusive Force others enjoy the nighttime military operations and the strength of their units is higher than everyone else through their gorilla Warfare trait they do feel slightly limited as they have the fewest amount of soldier tokens and that actually does decide their action economy that said the Woodland Alliance is especially reliant on how other players react to their presence having them in a game seems to centralize the three other players into a strategy of maintaining the spread of Sympathy by placing troops strategically in areas of future spread this is done by utilizing the martial law aspect of the Woodland Alliance resulting in more resources required to actually make progress as a woodland often trying to quash these sympathy tokens only result in more sympathizers and can result in slowing down your own progress and accelerating

the Woodland Alliance the thing is it isn't really that fun to play as or against the Woodland Alliance there are games where the player doesn't have much agency and they can feel like there's only one path forward while playing as the alliance on the other hand playing against the alliance can be frustrating due to your stronger battle mechanics and your constant loss of cards sometimes when you're playing against the Woodland Alliance the best strategy is just to sit a whole bunch of your own troops in a base spot which allows you to take over the rule and then nullify the ability for them to organize further simply because their troops can't move out anymore so I'm giving them a fun to play as a 6 out of 10 and a fun to fight against a 5 out of 10 that said the Woodland Alliance is still strong they have a ton of burst potential and can really swing games hard if the Gold Path arises they require active involvement to stop and can feel like a freight train of sympathy if you don't get the proper blockades in they are a strong faction from a competitive standpoint and can often centralize a game around their sympathizers and bases enemies of the Woodland Alliance will know that if the star is align these little buddies can get so many points in a single turn and close out a game which gives them a 6 out of 10 in terms of strength overall though the wooden Alliance is an okayish designed faction with strengths weaknesses and a unique play style it just isn't as magical as a lot of other factions and sometimes the path to Victory is so singular you'll feel like there's only one viable play style people at the table will need to address the huge

burst of points once you get established so there's a lot of good and a lot of bad with them so I'm giving them a 6 out of 10 for Quality next up we have the riverfolk company with a complexity of 8 out of 10 a fun to play as as 7 out of 10 a fun to fight against 7 out of 10 a total strength of 7 out of 10 and an overall quality also 7 out of 10 the riverfolk company is the most group dependent of all the factions in route different group metas and approaches to the game will dramatically change how these merchants of War perform the complexity of this faction isn't inherently from their own actions while they do have a lot of nuance such as their dividends or their alternate crafting options and how trade posts are slightly different than other buildings their main source of complexity comes really from knowing how other factions can use their services and thus continue to move their economy of actions for example knowing that a Vega Bond will always refresh three items even at their very first turn means that an uto player can can price a card for them right away at three and there is no real cost to the Vagabond the otter require a lot of game knowledge and a lot of their action economy is tied to a unique resource that isn't always available so 8 out of 10 for complexity also since the otter have a hard cap of 18 points through their tradeing post the riverfill company will need to find 12 more points either through crafting dividends or destruction which leads to a lot of play

style diversities some otter are very protective of their Trade Post and will try to get a few dividends in and then will rapidly expand other otter will set on a war path and Destroy vulnerable buildings through Superior movement abilities and playing as the otter can be very rewarding fun and a social experience that creates new Dynamics over the table that aren't implemented normally in route the tangible exchange of services for actions or the open hand or the unique movement options all presents a ton of space for Creative play but there are frustrating moments when people will just ignore your services so they get a 7 out of 10 for fun to play likewise playing against the riverfolk company can be fun and rewarding as well the riverfolk company presents a good prisoner dilemma which is unlike the VAB Bond because if you are the sole purchaser of their goods you'll gain a significant Advantage without overly funding the riverfolk action economy but if everyone purchases from the riverfolk the riverfolk can easily spiral into Infinite wealth and become Merchants who trade in death it's a fine line of trying to gain an advantage without cre cre in the utterly Unstoppable otter merchants of death if the otter ever become oppressive it's at least partly to blame on everyone else which is a pretty good game dynamic in my opinion so they get a s out of 10 to play against now the river folk aren't perfect the biggest problem is that because the otter are so dependent on sales of their goods if the table just agrees not to purchase from them the otter are crippled and will have no

impact on the game unlike any other faction they will be eliminated from Victory without a single battle and this can easily happen if the opponents are not swayed by the otter players services that said the otter do provide real benefits to those who know what to buy from them and this dilemma between players can often result in the otter spiral into a very powerful faction so they get a 7 out of 10 for strength overall what these little buddies offer is unique and clever and healthy for the game but their Reliance on other players is a cursed blade that can really change the entire Vibe of a game so they get a 7 out of 10 for overall faction quality next up we have the lizard cult with a complexity of 9 out of 10 a fun to play as 10 out of 10 a fun to fight 7 out of 10 a strength of two out of 10 and an overall quality of 8 out of 10 the lizards are goofy little cultists they have stupid little mles that are adorable and perfectly match the vibe of playing them they're funny they're a little inept but dang they're a lot of fun playing the lizards are really more akin to a card game their entire Suite of actions is dependent on card draw and since they hate birds bird cards are used to create a unique resource called acolytes which allow for excellent Shenanigans since they have a heavy Reliance on what cards they draw and what other players discard there is a higher level of RNG than other factions which can feel restricting the whole approach to the lizard cult is

completely different than any other faction and they really don't share many similarities between their actions to wrap your head around them will take real effort and a willingness to relearn core concept of root which makes them one of the more complicated factions in the game 9 out of 10 for complexity that said the lizard cult is a very fun very wacky faction that captures the spirit of A Dysfunctional cult just the idea that when your troops die on the board they become acolytes which further convert and sanctify enemy pieces it's a lot of fun and they have a lot of play style expression their design results in a good balance of messing with enemy pieces while building their own Gardens using the cards to act in neat ways they're an easy 10 out of 10 for fun from the opponent's perspective the lizards are also pretty nice as well they can feel powerful when an outcast becomes hated and they can really go ham with those acolytes but other players will have Direct Control of what clearing becomes the outcast and can be countered through clever use of cards even when the star is align and the lizards go hard they never feel that frustrating because it takes a lot of work to make them win so they get a 7 out of 10 to play against which leads me to my next point the lizard cult is also one of the weakest factions in the game their wins are rare and overall the power level is kind of tepid they feel easy to sabotage if their Gardens aren't properly protected and the Reliance on card draw kind of makes or breaks the lizards from a competitive standpoint it's kind of on brand though cuz you got to pray to the deck and hope you get some cards to score off those Gardens so

they get a 2 out of 10 for power level still they're fun for everyone they're different than all the other factions and they can keep things interested so a very solidly designed faction overall I got to give these goofy boys an8 out of 10 last up we got the keepers in Iron with a complexity of 10 out of 10 fun to play 8 out of 10 fun to fight 8 out of 10 a total strength of four out of 10 and an overall quality of8 out of 10 okay last of all we have the jacked Keepers in Iron these buff Knights want to collect little relics around the forest and bring them back to their way stations to score big points they share a similar core gameplay mechanic with the eerie but instead of suffering through turmoil these Badgers use a retinue that allows for certain actions but the actions are not mandatory that said you can still lose your retinue cards if you don't rule enough adjacent clearings when you delve for relics or when you actually try to recover these relics you need to have have ownership of matching clearings when you first learn these Keepers in Iron it's a bit of a mess because their puzzle is a lot harder to conceptually understand in other factions for the Erie you got to build Roost for the lord of the hundreds you got to press clearings for the crows you need to reveal plots all of these other factions have simple game Loops that actually encourage these scoring mechanisms but for the Badgers the idea of taking relics from the forest which is already rarely interacted with and then moving them back to Way Station to

score can be confusing for firsttime players along with that adding cards to the renue is a puzzle in itself because you can add as many as you want at the end of your turn and it's really a key place of skill expression so they get a 10 out of 10 for complexity as they are the most complex faction in the game that said after a few games the Badgers are extremely fun to play and extremely enjoyable to optimize and strategize with I love trying to figure out what micro adjustments can be made to solve their Relic colting puzzles and some things I've learned is usually best to make two way stations right away as well as to add two or three cards if you're feeling frisky to your retinue and work your way up to 10 cards the Badgers are constantly moving and recovering back to their was stations so expect to have a lot of moving parts and juggling all of these parts can be extremely rewarding and fun while also having a ton of skill expression so they get an 8 out of 10 for fun to play as from an opponent's perspective the keepers and iron are pretty pretty dang good to fight as well they have a lot of counterbalances built in for example while their devout Knights can block the first hit in combat they are good targets because if they lose their precious Relic token the opponent will score two points instead of one these Knights also live off the land so they can't really stack an army very efficiently it's all very flavorful but gives opportunities to counterbalance through decisive plays from opponents so they also get an 8 out of 10 to play against now for probably my most controversial opinion of this

list but I don't find the keepers and iron very powerful sure they can run a muck and score and huge burst if they're left unattended but there's a lot of counterplay and ways to hinder their game plan that can feel suffocated not that the keepers are weak per se but they're just not as strong as other factions so I'm ranking them four out of 10 for power level I would also say the Badgers are unusually map dependent and sometimes a bad role of random clearings for the winter map for example can really be felt by the Badgers in a way that isn't as bad as other factions all in all the Badgers are another very healthy fun and complex faction that adds to Root's repertoire of militant factions I never mind seeing them at my tables and I feel like they are a clever puzzle that feels fresh and unique from all the other factions in the game so yeah they get 8 out of 10 for overall quality I'm a fan of these buff Badgers okay there we go all of the factions all of their stats all of my takes it's all here so while you're here let's talk about root just for a couple minutes the problem I have with root is because the game is so dependent on what factions you play that the game is actually kind of busted if you pick the wrong mix of factions it just doesn't feel good to play and it's a fundamental design flaw that a lot of other asymmetrical games don't suffer from so the designers of root put two different ways to solve this problem the first is reach reach is just saying how much a faction can influence a board hats are at the very tip because they have troops everywhere at the start while our

buddies the lizard cult are at the very bottom so the big brains at root HQ said well if you want an optimal match you got to play a mix of factions that give a certain amount of reach for example a game with the otter corvid Woodland Alliance and lizards would only go to 13 reach while the game recommends at least 21 reach for four players it's a little goofy it's like yeah you want to play all these cool factions but you got to make sure there's enough action on the board otherwise the game will be kind of boring and unplayable so rout HQ took some fan inspiration and went with what the competitive scene was doing as well and that was a draft system the draft system is called adset or Advanced setup Advanced setup is a draft set where you put one more faction in a pool than the amount of players so in a four-player game there would be five factions of those faction there is always at least one guaranteed militant faction so you can't encounter the otter lizard Crow Alliance game I mentioned also if the last faction drafted is an Insurgent faction it is locked out until one of the militant factions is chosen in other words it guarantees at least one militant faction every single game if this is confusion for you that's fine just know it mostly fixes the issues around the game regarding composition and the faction choice but you kind of have to dive into playing the competitive mindset to really experience a better way to play route and once you go add set you really don't go back now there is a third pseudo fix which is the

hirelings and hirelings are little NPC buddies that change ownership across the game and you know what I rather like the hirelings but I feel like they play best at two and three player count to fill up a board and they're definitely an upgrade from the use of the AI Clockwork factions but I don't find them as a true fix to the optimal faction puzzle more like a Band-Aid for lower player counts to fill up the board and create more moments but yeah a nice addition they're fine for two and three player games so yeah root has some tricks to address the inherent variance that's likely to occur when picking factions and I'm I'm a big fan of the advanced setup so I use that almost every single game and it creates a nice puzzle of how to draft and set up your factions even before the game begins diplomacy or telling people what to do okay one last thing I want to talk about in route and this bit is about the quarterbacking and kingming in route there's two issues I have and I just wanted to talk about them one more time before I stop talking about root entirely first at a beginner level of play whoever is the most experienced will almost have an obligation to help guide people through their factions and what their goals are it's so common to play as your own faction but also help new players with each step of their own faction because each turn is so involved and there's so many options it's overwhelming trying to learn your own faction and three factions of your enemies simultaneously so this form form of quarterbacking is just a consequence that the initial complexity root demands

and root really wants someone to teach and explain their faction but a lot of the time it feels like quarterbacking for introductory games secondly at the higher level the game can devolve into a king making Domino and let me propose a scenario in this game State you're playing as the Eerie and you're not doing so hot you went into turmoil last round and you're a little bit behind overall but the Marquita de cat they're at 28 and are sitting on enough wood bring them over the Finish Line likewise the Corvette are at 26 and have one plot that they can flip over at their bird song to cross that line so you have the choice you can attack the cats at their Sawmills and take out their wood which would then stop them from making the very last building they need to squeeze out a win on the other hand you can go and attack the last unflip plot that the corvid need just to hold on to otherwise they'll win as well you have the key role the god ordained role as king maker you can truly decide what player wins with all the Spite and favoritism that you decide to employ there's nothing they can do at this moment except barter their case with you and the thing is this is all a part of the core design of root this is intended root wants to have a king but also a king maker at a higher level of play a very interesting phenomenon happens in our quest for fair play people will King slay the next player who could win there's this Domino effect and let me go back to the example if you're the Eerie and after your turn it's the cats and then after the cats

it's the crows it is your obligation to stop the cats and then even if the cats can't win it's their obligation to stop the crows and then the crows obligation to stop the next player it's a domino effect of King layan which is totally not enforced by the game but happens naturally because players want to chase the idea of impartiality and fairness it's this strange moment route where people come together to figure out and stop the next potential winner everyone looks at the board and works out this who is the real winner puzzle and they do this communally and they do it continually by King slaying each other until the true Victor is crowned in other words our innate sense of seeking fairness leads to this quarterback in problem and I'll say it again players in root Will Group up together at the end of the game and work out who is the true winner by doing this Domino King slain routine until someone is revealed as that true winner and yeah it's not enforced by the game but it's a trend that's in our own little psyche that wants to create a fair game even when the game isn't meant to be fair and I know you might say well dude you're just wrong you're playing the game wrong rot isn't about kingming you're just bad and if you don't believe me some dumb fool who didn't back the kickstarter of arcs take it from the creator of the game a sort of central term and that term for me uh is kingming because ultimately root is a game about kingming I I always have like a good laugh when I see a thread and someone's like oh man root I

heard that it has a kingming problem and I'm like it doesn't have a kingming problem it is the kingming problem so whether you like it or not you need to face the truth kingm King slay the whole little thing it's a central feature of root not a bug root is mean but in our quest for a balanced and fair experience people who are familiar with root tend to default to King slaying the next person to win and we'll continue to do so until the true winner is crowned this is the fairest way we can do it which is actually counter to the design of root itself so let's let's do some final thoughts what's the grand trick of rout well beyond the fixes like the advanced setup reach the Exiles and partisans deck the rebalancing even things like high earings for lower play accounts the game has one big trick that is so obvious that it would be sinful not to discuss the game is cute that's it that's the secret the game penetrates the consciousness of non- Gamers and casual gamers and all the meanness and all the bickerin all the kingming it's all protected because the game is cute the theming of the game is the secret armor shielding all the complexity all the fiddling all the meanness everything all the spite it's all protected by this perfectly crafted cute Vibe and when I was read on the design of route and listen into a couple design Diaries I think what stuck to me the most is what the designer said about what he called

the dangerous game and Cole references another book by Bernard Deen the well-played game and to quote the koven and the wellplayed game our dangerous games can't involve those who haven't accepted the threat who haven't chosen to play with us we can't play dangerously with someone who isn't playing it isn't play and that's really what I wanted to leave off on I think root can be an excellent experience but it is a dangerous game that is dressed in the skin of a light-hearted family-friendly game root is a game where people can truly feel confused mad or even betrayed if they aren't aware of its innate meanness in other words for a good time people need to accept the threat of root before playing it and acknowledge that it is a main game it's paradoxical because what people see is all all this amazingly cute art these fantastically adorable meeples but underneath is a game that is complex vindictive and spiteful it's important that people know what they're getting into when they sit around a game of root and because the design of root is so centered around kingming and meanness it can be a little strange seeing this game at Target for unsuspecting families to buy expecting to buy Forest time summertime adventure for the designer's perspective he sees the art as a way to soften the mechanics by seeing the humor in the animals and the cuteness and the absurdity of it all it distances the meanness of root and makes it feel less intense and I can understand that angle

but I don't fully feel convinced being cute doesn't absolve root of being mean but instead cloaks to meanness to be revealed as the game progresses root is unsuspectingly spiteful and it can be a bait and switch if you aren't informed on what to expect in other words being cute doesn't mean that the meanness doesn't hurt which is to say I slightly disagree with Cole It's a grand trick of how a game can lure unsuspecting people into thinking it's fun and friendly until the family has to go to divorce court after a final in-game betrayal so there's my thoughts if I have to score route and its major expansions I'd give it a very solid 9.1 out of 10 but there are a lot of caveats in that score it's not a simple pick up and play like so many other games but a game that needs people who are down to get mean who are we're down to go through all the faction drafting who are really wanting to sit down and make some Kings the game quality changes dramatically on who you're playing with and who you're playing as plus no Vega Bond games with vegab bonds go down like three points anyways thank you for watching I hope you enjoyed it and thank you again and bye

Progress saved