The BIG Tend Episode | The Design, The Success, The Future | BGSS ep_033
Transcript
first when you first said we want 10 expansions, you said bring me three expansions in a standalone and I made three expansions in a standalone. We're always down to cut a rondelle, right?
Yeah. Austin's always trying to add Rond
and we cut them all
for a game that then won a bunch of like game of the year awards. It it was it did not break any sort of like Kickstarter records. I can't make small stuff. I don't that's not how I work. Like I got to make I got to have meat on the bone.
I have a a funny quote from somebody. Playing 10 literally made me have a midlife board game crisis when I realized I was a grown ass adult scratching off lotto tickets for wood in my free time. Today my guests are Toby Sarnell and Zach Dixon from Ivy Studio. This is the Big Tend video. If you love Tind or you don't know what Tend is, we talk about everything Tend. We talk about the development. talk about how the heck Toby got involved in Ivy Studio because he has a full-time day job developing video games and now is a highly decorated designer. He's also designed most recently Alterara that just got off of crowdfunding. We go deep into the design. We go deep into the influences. If you've played Tind, you might know that there's a little bit of Stardew Valley in there. And most importantly, we go into Sellar and Hive, the new expansions, the threeame campaign mode, and Hive, the new bolt-on that's going to completely break your brain. There is so much good stuff in this episode. I say that a lot on these intros, but really this one pays off, especially if you get to the end. And with all that said, please welcome both of these gentlemen to the Board Game Secret Show.
I wanted to get you all together because Tend I was recently introduced in the last couple months and absolutely loved it. And then I saw that there are expansions coming. So I had to get especially you Tobies. Like Zack, you know, you know, we're it's old news. We've talked we've talked plenty already, but I'm highly interested in kind of the journey of Tend, how it got here, where it's going, and then where it might even go deeper into the future. Are we down?
Yeah, definitely. Sounds awesome.
Cool. Um, so I first just want to know, somebody tell me the story. How did you, Toby, this is was your first published board game, Intend? How did you get on the same box as Zach?
Uh, yeah. So, I started working on this game, God, how long ago now? Like seven years ago, maybe something like that,
dude. You're dragging your feet, man. What took you so long?
Yeah, it's a long time. Uh, I was uh I'm I'm a game designer, a video game designer. Uh, in general, I was working at a studio called Play Dots on mobile game Two Dots. I was a lead designer on Two Dots. And, uh, I had always loved board games and I made them in my spare time. And so, I came up with this idea of I wanted to make, uh, I honestly I had played the Stardw Valley board game. I play a ton of Stardw Valley in general. And I played a bunch of Rolling Rights recently, and I went,
"Yeah." Right. I played a bunch of rolling rights. I was like, "These feel like a thing that would work really well together." kind of that like cycling upgrading of stuff and
kind of feels like what I get when I play a game like Stardy Valley. So, I decided I wanted to make it for fun. Uh this was my second board game I had made like kind of thinking I might actually publish it for fun behind the one that became Alterara eventually. But the first one, if you're familiar with Altera at all, it has like a million dice. It is in an insane design. Like there's a ton of stuff in it.
Heavy boxes, right? Like that's that's your number one design constraint is I have to make sure that shipping is as much as possible. I need those boxes to be really heavy and dice is a great way to do that.
Yeah. So I after making that this is going to sound even funnier now is tend was what I came up with as I want to make something I think I could maybe make myself
if I wanted to like I could publish myself. So lower on the component side easier to produce stuff like that. Uh, and then I I linked up with Zach because we have a mutual friend uh David Hen who was the original founder uh of well original creator of two dots. Um they worked together on a campaign for David's company for a Kickstarter and I knew they had worked together. I said, "Hey, I know you worked with these guys who do board games and Kickstarter stuff. Uh he put me in touch with someone from them just to talk about what it would be for me to launch my own Kickstarter because I was thinking I'm going to publish this thing myself." And so I I got a meeting with Zach. We started chatting and I'm saying, "Here's my idea. Here's the thing I'm trying to make. Do you think I could actually publish this myself?" And he goes, "Well, we're actually thinking about publishing external stuff we have not designed yet. Uh, it's hard." Like he kind of went through all the stuff you have to do to do it. I'm like, I knew it would be hard. I I you know, I knew I would then have to like raise money and do all this be a job essentially.
All the unfund stuff which all the publishers tell me like the whole crowdfunding thing is the unfund part. Yep. And they had just worked with Robert Hovmian on uh Moon Rollers, right? And he said, "Just did this thing that was really cool with somebody who's not originally from our team. We're interested in potentially more. What do you have?"
And so I I told him what my ideas were. Alter was the first one and then Tend was the second one. And he went, "Well, that first one's a lot. Uh the second one sounds kind of cool." And then from then on, we were we were interested. There was no like signing or anything, but we were like, "Let's play it. Let's see what we think. let's go through and it kind of iterated from there. I think I knew it was serious when after we had played it for the first time, they went on a retreat for a week and they came back and they were like, "We have a lot of ideas."
That's cool.
Did you consider
Did you consider having scratchoff cards in the game? Because that was a thing that was not in my prototype because I was trying
I needed the I needed the scratch off uh story a little bit later, but yeah, that's
Yeah. Yeah. So
that was one of the first ideas that they that they introduced
from them. Yes. Classic
idea. As you think about it, I was trying to make a game I could produce. So to me it was just the reason it was all six-sided dice. It was colored six-sided dice and sheets and that was it. And I'm like, well, I could do cards, sheets, and dice, standard dice. That that's something I could actually produce.
Um, and so when he came back with that, I said, well, I was trying to keep this as something I could make. So, I didn't even know that was possible. Like that I could do scratch offs. That is awesome. Like the idea of that is actually exactly what I want this to feel like. So, that's like perfect. And from there, it was just kind of like, well, the ideas kind of built on each other. Uh, and it was just it was off from there basically.
Zach, walk me through when he was first pitching the game. First of all, in that initial conversation, did scratch off occur to you? But secondly, like what were you thinking? Was it was Alterara the like the side piece and you're like, "Oh, Tend is the one."
I think so. Alterara was has like kind of always been Toby's baby. I think it's I don't know if it was the first game that you were ever like, "I'm gonna like gonna make a game, but it was like this was like this is what I want to make." And I've got some other prototypes. And I played Alterara and I did not know what to make of it. I just like didn't I like I I couldn't quite grasp it from a standpoint of like like the theme was very like kind of just like fantasy adjacent and so it it didn't like grab me right away and uh I was also really bad at it. Like it was very intense and I was just like I don't know what to do with this. Like I think there's something here but like I don't even know where to send it or like what feedback to give. Um, but really hit it off with Toby. Uh, strong many many mutual friends. And I was like, "What else you got?" And I also am a huge Stardew fan. Uh, and he's like, "I've got this farming game." Uh, and he listed a few other things. I'm like, "Farming game? I want to try the farming game. That sounds great." Uh, like I I think people would get down for that.
And I would love to make like a world around that. Like like what if we could as like a creative director and an art director? Like that got me excited and also just someone whose job is to be like what do I think people will want? Uh and I was like, "Oh, I think I could I think I could sell that. Like I think we could do something there as long as it's good and fun." Uh and then we played it and we're like, "Oh yeah, like this is this is great and fun. Let's table Alterara for a minute and let's go to this this farming game." Uh and which I believe had Stardew Valley Temp art at the time, which is very funny to look back on. I was wondering if this was full-fledged Stardew Valley rolling right when you got your hands on it.
Like I think Toby, you knew you knew it always. Obviously there was already a Stardew game, so it was like
there was no intent to actually be a Stardew game.
Um, but like I I remember play testing with one of my friends at work and she said, "Uh, this game is so fun, but how can you make it? It's Stardew." And I was like, well, Stardew is just Harvest Moon, which is just like a million. There's like this is a whole genre of games. Like, it doesn't have to be Stardew. It can be whatever we want it to be. And
beyond that, like I I was never designing it from a point of
Well, so the interesting thing is at the very very start it was very Stardew tilted. Like I was following too much of what Stardew was,
like more interaction. No, it was more like, well, I need four tiers of tool upgrades, right? It was like like all these like continuously iterative stuff. And then as I played it more and more, I was like, well, this just isn't conducive to a thing that you want to be done in an hour or two,
right? There's a reason that's a video game hours. Yeah, exactly. Um, and so kind of just like looking at what parts made sense from that kind of like uh general core loop of Stardew and what parts didn't make sense for this kind of thing. Um, and so like parts of it are inspired by Stardew, but like like the way that it it works is not exactly the same as obviously a game like Stardew. Like it's trying to invoke the feelings without literally just being
which honestly is one of the things I think is an advantage of not being licensed, right? Is that when you have a licensed game, you have to hit these touchstones of like I have to have aridium tools and I have to have iron tools and I have to have bronze tools. Whereas it's like here, well, we don't need any of that. if it doesn't make sense for the game, we'll just make a cool upgrade and that'll be fine.
Yeah. It's like that was that would be a huge constraint, especially with what Stardew ended up being, which is this monstrosity. And I say that in only a good way that that uh the designer built on over many, many, many years. There's so many intricate layers which I could see tend eventually getting there which we'll talk about future later but there's so many different mechanical layers that that he built over time and that was what it is now is nowhere near what his like initial concept was but I but the the the tell for me was the neighbor mechanic as soon as I which my wife does not engage with. She won't be nice to me at all and it kind of pisses me off. Um, but that that was the big tell and the badges as well. Kind of like what is it like grandpa's um oh gosh, what's the mechanic center?
The community center. That's what it is. Yeah. Right. Uh, but yes, there's still definitely not a copy paste uh Stardew Valley at all, but I definitely see the DNA in there. And I think it's pretty cool that you tried to uh represent it in a game. Uh, how much Zach did you encourage to cut out of the original design or was it a buildup? Like was there was there way too much there I'm assuming. Right.
Yeah. Yeah, there was it was it [clears throat] was a lot. So, I mean like so one of the one of the initial things was just like, oh, we do have a game design team inhouse, so there's going to be some amount of development. We're going to run it through our play testing uh, you know, processes. We're gonna we're going to make changes. we're going to cut stuff and like uh and and Toby was a great fit with that team. Uh and so we we definitely got in there. I mean, the core was obviously there and still lived on, but it's like we cut things, but then like there was this moment where I was I don't know what was wrong with me, but I was like, we should make this a like a legacy game. Like what if
you pre love that idea.
Yeah. Yeah. So it's like what if what and and and some of this made it into seller which we can get into but it's like what if you had this like mega sheet where it was basically like a tech tree. So like when you're done with tend what if you
you know use some of the points that you got in certain areas to kind of like build out different starting abilities for future games. And it was this whole it was huge. It was like way too much. Uh, and I think like in theory it sounded very cool, but like we should just like maybe focus on making like one game of this really good rather than like being like what is like a 20 game campaign? Like uh so it was both. It was we cut some stuff, we changed some stuff and also wildly overcoped it and then also cut that back.
Who talked you off that ledge of this giant giant scope increase? Uh because that's where my mind immediately goes to, especially if you have Stardew Valley in your head, right? Like it's and you don't say like, "Hey, how do we make this as consumable as possible?" Which is kind of hilarious because it's like the biggest roll and right flip and right whatever that has ever existed.
Oh, I know.
So, it's like it's already funny to talk about that it was so much bigger.
Who Who taught me off that ledge? Everyone else.
You talked I was say you really talked yourself off the ledge more than anything. It was just we we spun on it for like six months or so. Like it was a long time.
Uh like there's I could at some point if you want I can show you
some of the the old files from that stuff because it's wild.
Send all that to me. I'll put it in during this interview. I would love love to have that on there. So
yeah, there was a really cool tech tree. There was this concept of like different colored stars you could unlock in between your different games. I mean there was a lot of really cool stuff in there. The real problem was that there was just so much going on and it was like you were trying to pair down the original experiences. So, one of the things we were really interested in is the game is very complicated. It's honestly it's still it's one of the hardest games to teach because you have to teach everything up front and all of the different actions.
Yeah.
A little bit different.
Not conducive to a rolling teach.
Yeah. And it's like once you know how to play it's pretty easy. like everything is kind of intuitive and it's fairly clean.
Uh but that first initial learning is tough. So one of the thoughts at the beginning was what if we pull it out so that it's just bits. So it's like in the first game you only have planting and mining and then in the later one you unlock a new type of thing. And the problem there was that the games where you only had one or two options were just not very fun because you feel like you're on rails, you're not taking a lot of decisions. just like it it wasn't great. So, it was like, well, do we want to put our first foot forward with this thing that isn't the best version of the game for you to play it like three times to get to the part that's like the really intended experience, which is not great. So, we ended up kind of just I don't know. We we played around with it a whole bunch. There was some cool stuff in it. Uh the actually a lot of the stuff from the current expansions actually came partially from that. But also like to defend me for the original design. When I first made this thing, I was mostly designing it for my friends.
So there was like I had no concerns about like teach time or how easy it was to learn. It's like well I'll make them learn it. We'll have fun. We'll figure it out. Um so like a lot of the stuff that was cut, like the the seller for example, which which was in the original version of Tendellar the whole time. It was like one of my favorite features in the whole game, but it totally made sense to cut it because it was just like this is like another thing on top of everything else and there's so much other stuff here. We could just save it for later. We're getting later. And honestly, we tweaked it a little bit when we brought it in later. And I think it's even better than it was when we originally had it in the in the base.
How hard was it to get to let go of that? I mean, that's that's your baby and this is your not not at all. That's the good part about being a professional game designer is that I've been I've been making video games for like 15 years and like cutting stuff is like you have to be able to know what part is going to be the thing that if you cut it the thing no longer works like it's no longer fun but you need to know everything else can go like this is the core you cannot get rid of this chunk if you get rid of this the whole thing is going to fall apart but just start pulling stuff off the way they the way that I usually design honestly is I put more stuff in there that I expect should be in there and then we play it and we start figuring out which parts we like and which parts we don't and then we take out the stuff that isn't working. You take out the we don't like.
So, Zach, he said the right answer, but is that true? Did Did you ever get the sense as you guys were cutting his baby apart that he was just like, "Oh, that feels bad."
No. No. Okay. What what he said is 100% the truth. and and we we probably wanted to like I think that's that's our vibe as like a team. It's just like we you gota you got to cut stuff and that's why I like working on a team as well too because like it's I know it's so easy for me to get tunnel vision of just like oh man we need walls in the scratch off and that's so fun and then everybody else is like no that's dumb and we need to cut it and I'm like
that one made it all the way to prototype printing didn't it? I know. I really wanted those walls and then we took the walls out and I was like, "Oh, yeah, that's better." Uh, and so it's just it's I don't know how solar designers do it.
There were walls inside of the mine.
So like you would hit a dead end in cuz we wanted to be more like a labyrinth.
Oh, got it. I thought you were stopping me from going over the edge and cheating.
No, no. They were literally little walls in the thing. No one knew what they were. You didn't really know why you cared about me place. You just kind of They were not. It was a bad idea and that's why we have a team to tell me when my ideas.
Now, walls would work on a legacy game that you just have more time to recover, but in that one hour scenario, I would be pissed if I hit a wall.
Uh, but no, I like it was we we cut cutting things, adding things left and right here. Um, and and Toby is a a true professional, so he's
We're always down to cut a Rondell, right?
Yeah. Austin's always trying to add Rond
and uh we cut them always.
Last time we talked there might have I thought there might have been one that was a possibility. I don't know if that ever made it through. I'm guessing not if we're still cutting them.
Check this. Check this prototype out. Huh?
Oh wow.
Is that yours?
Yeah, that's one of mine.
You're trying to get on Austin.
I feel so bad. I feel so bad about us cutting all these rondell's. I said, Austin, I'm gonna make a rondelle game that the whole game is the rondelle. You can't cut it. and it hasn't gone anywhere yet, but it's title. It's fun. It's got good stuff in it, but uh but yeah, it's uh it's it's a little it's Yeah. Yeah.
So, you mentioned your past in video games. Uh you were at two dots. A birdie told me that you used to bring in board game prototypes into that space. What? Take me back. How long ago was that number one? And what type of games were you making your video game brethren uh play?
Yeah, I mean I that was pre and during COVID. So I I worked at Two Dots for 10 years. I was actually their longest tenure employee.
Oh, really?
So yeah, the uh So I started in 2014, I believe. So from then till 2024, is that right? No. Yeah, 2013 maybe. Something like that. About three or four years ago. Um is when I moved on from there. And then I was the lead designer at uh uh Tempotorm working on the bizarre uh until very recently. Um, but I started bringing I honestly I remember the I' I've been into board games for a very long time and the thing that got me starting making prototypes was talking with my friends at Dots on a lunch break going, "Do you think you could make old not great board games into fun stuff using like modern design learnings?" And so my my I made a challenge to myself of what if I designed a a Monopoly, a version of Monopoly that fixed the stuff that is generally not liked about Monopoly, but still had the same core concepts. Uh that was the first pro board game prototype I ever made. Um and it was pretty fun. It's still pretty fun. Uh it definitely I've learned a lot since then. I probably should tweak it a bit if I ever wanted to play it again.
Um but from there I just kind of started making them in my spare time. Um, and I've I've probably made 10 was probably like my fifth that I made like of broer game prototypes, but it was the second of the ones that I took more seriously that I was like, "Okay, let's make one that like I fully finish and I iterate on and I play it a bunch and get it to a place that I like it." And then the funny thing is that's when I take it to IV, at which point it's not fully finished and there's a million things still to iterate on, right? Like scratch, get other people in there. Yeah.
Cut your rondell's. Yeah.
But yeah, so it's it's been a long time.
You talked about um or we talked a little bit about constraints that board games naturally have. What can you do in a board game that you can't do in a video game? Like is there is there anything that you feel freed up as you're designing a board game that that a video game doesn't allow you to kind of design off of or off?
Not really that there's nothing you there's you can do everything you do in a board game for the most part uh in a video game. It just has a very different context, right?
Like the the way you interact with people in a board game is so different from the way you interact with people in a video game. Even if you're like playing it online with your friends, it's just so wildly different that like different interactions will feel very differently. Uh and then also like the tactile things you do in a board game can bring you so much more satisfaction than some of the things you do in a video game. That's like one of the the benefits of like rolling a dieice in a video game is not very exciting. It's not particularly fun. You just kind of click a button, you see what the number is. But for some reason rolling a dieice physically and seeing what it is just like feels more exciting, more interesting. Um, so I would say that a lot of the times honestly it goes the other way of like what things work in a video game that you shouldn't do in a board game. Um, but there are there's some level of like
like unless you are making a board game video game, which there are a lot of those now also. Yeah. uh like dealing with like interactive tablet talky type stuff of like like table politics like that. That's not really a thing you do in most video games. But even now like
like we said there's a lot of there's like like the whole friend slop genre, right, of this like new stuff that people are just the whole point is just goofing around. It's kind of similar to a board game, right? Um, so
yeah, I was say
it's different, but it's still it's still channeling kind of the same vibes.
So I was going to say like the the one thing that uh you can do in board games that you can't do in video games is one of the things that you don't particularly like in board games, Toby, which is I feel like the table politicking like type of games, which are a lot of our other board games that are non Toby uh games have. Um, so it's it's funny. I was like, "Oh, there's a huge I mean, there's a reason why there's no like Moonrakers the board game video game is because like negotiation online like sucks. Like that's it's just like I don't want to do that over
like voice chat with people I barely know." Uh, like I think that is why so many of our board games lean into that kind of thing because I think it is unique to the to the genre. Uh, but Toby Toby doesn't get up for those games. That's not his typical I will that's exactly what I was thinking.
Go ahead, Toby.
I will say that the um the thing I like the most about board games versus video games is how fast you can prototype stuff
of like
Yeah,
I have like I had an idea for a football gambling game, right? Um and I made a prototype for it in three days. It's like I cannot do that with a video game. Like I cannot have a thing that I can bring people in and sit them down and have them actually playing a thing and going this is good and this is bad in three days. It's just not possible. even if you like are great with AI tools or whatever using engines or what it's just not as quick and easy and you know iterative and then also you just have to grab a couple people and sit them down in a room and play a thing which is like really really nice and if you have you want to make a change you just take out a pen and you write something on the card right like it's just so fast and iterative
one of the things that occurred to me especially when I was looking at bizarre the bizaar before this is that is a looks like a quick dopamine fest meaning like it's constantly ly hitting you with sounds and level ups and b playing into everything the video games play into today, right? Where it's like cheap dopamine as quick as I can get it. Where board games on the other hand, you I would guess I haven't designed a board game, but I would guess that you have a little more leeway in being able to delay gratification and lets you play the long game a little bit more than say a video game where it's like the the context is important, which is I want dopamine really quickly and and I need bright sounds, beautiful images, like all of that stuff flashing. I don't know, that's just comes to my mind is is giving you a little more leeway to to work on on a longer term.
Yeah, I would almost think of it a differently. I think of it as uh a video game has distractions that can keep people engaged that are beyond the gameplay, right? Like there those dopamine hits you're talking about can make up for an uninteresting choice or like a a game play part that's like this is not super engaging. But there was a big flash and I leveled up and some cool stuff happened. And in a board game, you can't rely on the stuff like that. Like it's part of what I love about board games is that it's such pure design. Like if your game design is not fun, it doesn't really matter how pretty your stuff is and how nice your cards are. It's just not going to be fun. People are not going to play it. Whereas in a video game, you can have a thing where it's like it is so gorgeous and it has this really cool story and like the gameplay is just the most wrote same old corridor shooter gameplay you've played a million times, but there's all this other stuff that you really like. And for me, as someone who loves game design very specifically, like board games are really like the ultimate essence of that, right? Like if your if your game design is not good, your game's just not going to work. And I I would say that like to some extent the bizaar kind of plays a little bit into that also because it is a card game. So like so much of it is driven by the way the game plays and and granted you're right there is all this like
flashy stuff and it's really fun and engaging to play and to listen to and to experience and all that and it does help makes it easier than if it was just a card game, right?
Um but but it still has to rely on that a lot more than like you know a story- based game which which needs to rely on a story which is obviously extremely important too. It's not like the story isn't isn't important, but that's not what gets me going, right? What gets me going is the game design, the pieces fitting together.
I guess it is easier to hook somebody and keep them going along in a video game where that hook is more difficult in the board game to recover from if it's not hitting right out of the right out of the gates. So maybe you have better ways.
You can teach them, right? Like in a video game, you can teach them slowly over time with bells and whistles while it goes and hold their hand all the way through the whole thing. Whereas it's like in a board game, they got to learn on their own or I mean you'll have a video probably in a rule book, but like you got to trust they're going to do that, right? It's going to be all upfront and like it's better hook them quick. I mean the one plus side is it's not free. So like most a lot of the games I've worked on have been free to play games. uh you don't have to worry about the fact that someone's just gonna bounce after two minutes, right? Like in in two dots it's like you have to hook someone in the first 30 seconds or then they just leave,
right? Whereas it's like well people spent 50 bucks, they're going to at least give it a shot, right? Um which is nice. Um, but yeah, it's it's really hard to to kind of to get people to do that where compared to a video game where you just go through the tutorial, you have all your learnings, you have all this stuff to help you to get you, you know, keeping keep that cycle. In video games, you have constant tracking. You could deal you math can go into the millions. Like you have none of these constraints that you do on a board game. Was did you have a hard time transitioning to a board game because there is no autotracking and you have to depend on a player being able to wrap their mind around it?
I would say that that's what I like about a board game is that like I find that designing without constraints can be really hard like like when you it's like the empty page problem, right? As a writer of like you sit down and you have no idea what you're doing.
You could do anything. It's really hard. But when you're like, "Okay, these things are not going to work. I have to do I can only do this. I can only do that." Like, it just it tightens your focus. Gets you more in tune with what you're trying to do. Uh I think it's actually for me personally, I find it to be easier. I I significantly prefer designing board games. If I was able to do it all the time, I would probably just design board games. This just it's so much more satisfying to me.
Does it help with keeping ambition in check? Zach, I can even throw that at you. You know, knowing that there's, you know, I don't know if you have the a heavy video game background, but like that's that's probably pretty easy to get over your skis on on stuff like that.
Yeah. I mean, yeah, I've I've I've made a video game in the past. I'm working on one right now.
I mean, yeah, you made it too free time. Um, but not not nearly on the level that that Toby has. Um, I I think I come at them very differently. I think actually Toby and I think about games uh like I a bit quite a bit differently, which is why I think we really enjoy working together. Um, it's like you can see to I think Toby's incredible making game systems. like he he just like int has a really strong intuition for like engines, how things can ramp up, how getting this thing can have you get this thing, how those things are balanced together and how those flow. Um and and I and to your point, I would say that like some people would probably look at 10 and be like there's too much here. There's too many things to keep track of and there is an overflow of resources.
Uh, but that's also I think what makes it fun is that like level of overwhelming
uhness to it. It's like, oh my, like it's like a good problem, right? It's like, oh my gosh, I just had the best turn of my life. My brain is completely overwhelmed, but I also feel amazing and very smart,
right?
Uh, and so like I think that overwhelmingness actually is part of the fun of TEND. And if you're not into that kind of thing, you're just not going to like tend and that's totally fine. Um, but I think that snowballing is something that like I would never come up with. And then Toby's just like, "Oh yeah, and this goes in this and that's why this is two and this is that's why this is three." And like and I know exactly why they are those prices and why these waterfall into these things. And I'm always just like, "Wow, how do you do it, man?"
I would imagine the cargo manifest is the the slush bucket that allows a game like this to exist, right? Where it's like, if you don't know, throw it in your throw it in those cargo holds, right? you know that that allows that overflow to be dealt with elegantly.
Yeah, you definitely need some sort of output like that. I would say that one of the things that also helps is like with a board game, you're also limited physically, right? Like there are there are component issues. Yeah. Of like things of like, hey, we'd love to make this, but it means a thousand dice. Like a good example is in Alterara, like we cut one of the the guilds. The game was four guilds. Um, and we cut one of the guilds, not necessarily because it didn't play well, but because we just, it was just too many dice. Like, we needed to cut back or else it would have cost so much money for people that they wouldn't want to buy it. And it's like, well, if people really like it, maybe we can bring it back in expansion. Like, we have ideas for things like this and that that, you know, that kind of goes with anything. But like, if it was a video game, it probably would have had four guilds. Like, that was only cut because of constraints, right? And like
yeah,
those things are actually really nice uh a lot of the time to keep you a little more constrained onto like what you are doing. Like I might get more carried away if I could do whatever I wanted, right? So having a little bit of of a constraint there is nice.
Well, and it's like there's the the Bellatro pl. I feel like there's a lot of like games out there that are trying to make the bellro thing work. But the thing that makes Botro super fun is like you don't have to do multiplication like on your own. It just does it for you.
Number go up.
Exactly. And like it's I think it's a really hard design problem and I think we really push its limits in 10 of like oh man you want that curve right? You want the exponential curve of like I start weak and then I just get exponentially better. But you at some point you reach the limits of the human brain. I know I I hit mine all the time while playing tend. Uh and the things that you can keep track of and uh it's I don't know. It's a very different different problem.
Yeah. I mean we might be at our limits on a rolling right and being able to track mentally like I thought it was tough with and I love both these games. Fleet the dice game with three sisters as well. I thought I would be my mind would be coming to a halt in trying to do that and then you throw this at me and then there's going to be the hive.
So it's like have we reached the limit
that flow state get into that flow state and then you start
start seeing all the all the pumpkins in between the lines of the grids
all the numbers flying at your face and
Exactly. Exactly. Uh, so undoubtedly Toby, you've patched tons of video games in your life, but you can't do that with Tend other than with an expansion or Narata. What would you patch right this second in Tend if you could?
Um, I mean, we we had some we had some misprints. So, we patch the misprints, right? That would be the first thing I would say. Um, this is a funny one. Uh I while we were at uh Gen Con, I actually had an idea for a way to make So one of the things I don't like about TEND is teaching people that to to scratch the bottom section of the mines in the woods, it takes two uh power of mining or chopping, right? It's like we've we've it was necessary because if you don't do that, you you exponentially grow and you get way too much stuff. We had versions where it didn't work like that. It just didn't it wasn't functional. Um, and so we we have this rule where once you're past the bottom line to chop an area down there, you need to have two chops as opposed to one. It's very hard for people to understand. It it is one of the rules that people mess up the most. It just isn't great. And I had an idea at Gen Con of a way we could have potentially not had to do that if we had made the bottom section larger and had interspaced like blank spots and other stuff. So you could still scratch two boxes, but you're just only getting one every other actual stuff every other box in the bottom section. Now the downside is would have made the sheets bigger and that may not have been tenable. Like it just may not have been physically possible. What?
And also my my push back.
It feels bad to get nothing. It like I that was my note for you at Gen Con was like I I don't I wouldn't want to spend my my one action and get nothing.
Like when I whiff on fishing
sucks.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Fishing. Exactly.
It's true. It's true.
I whiffed on fishing this morning and it reminded me how much that pisses me off and how I need to upgrade.
Yeah. I do kind of wonder if we could have even like interspersed those with junk and it would have still been fine. Like if it was like every other one was a stone or a coin or something like that doesn't really until the seller expansion then it becomes cracked. Uh but that doesn't really change things that dramatically. Uh right. So, like I I wish there was like that's something maybe we would have patched, but even then it's like we'd have to look at it. Like the Oh, actually no. A better one is um on right now you can only ever have one cow in a game because on the farm sheet we only printed one line for cows. Uh because in the base game we're kind of pro protecting you from yourself because getting two cows would probably have been a bad idea. It costs so much. It takes so much space. They take a long time to to grow. However, in seller, you can get so much stuff at the start of a game that getting two cows is not only reasonable, but it's something you really want to do and you just can't do it because it doesn't exist on the sheet. And that sucks. Uh, it is fixable. Like we we could have like and maybe after Kickstarters, we can always The nice thing is the sheets are not set in stone still, right, for the actual printing. So, if we come up with things we want to do between now and the printing, we can still change stuff for like the official versions. Obviously, the prototypes are how they are and that's how it is, but like there's no way for us to fix that right now. And honestly, the sheets so packed that even if we wanted to fix it on the the seller sheet, I don't know where we would put it.
Oh, the seller sheet so pack because I I see some spacing in here, you know, we could
Oh, no. And we as a patch, we 100% could have added it to that if we had just been like, "No, it actually really is important to have the ability to get two cows, but in the base game it's not." and I kind of wish you could batch that now.
Do you think that um chopping and mining gets too much love because it's a scratch off or is it overpowered?
I don't really think so personally. I
And that's just my personal opinion. I just love to scratch the stuff off. I can't stop.
Yes, I would say a lot of people do. I've we've actually gotten a lot of feedback about fishing. I mean, maybe it's kind of tilted because of Dice Tower is very loud and Tom at Dice Tower especially is very loud and Tom really likes fishing in tend like a lot.
So, we get a lot of feedback, positive fishing feedback. Um, I would say that more than that, the feedback that we get the most is that tending is overwhelming and people don't love it. Um, I really like it. I think it's really cool. It is definitely the most complex and the hardest to wrap your brain around, the hardest to be good at. Um, but I just I kind of love manipulating your little your little grid area and like getting the getting your optimizing. I'm a big optimizer. Probably makes sense based on the game and everything.
Um, but the idea of like when you can like plant a big crop in the middle and then optimize a bunch of them around it and then water one and they all go up and you get a whole bunch of stuff is like I love that. Like it it feels so good and uh you can't really do that in any of the other. Is it hard to be good and 10 focused? Meaning like score a lot of points and be 10 focused. Do you have is this the skill ceiling significantly higher?
Yeah, significantly higher. Like it's not even close to the other ones. Like where you place your crops is really important. Which crops you get when is super important. Uh when you sell a crop versus when you put it in your manifest versus when you put it in a badge is really important. Um, all of it like what you upgrade and what order, when you till, when you expand, like all of these things matter so much and like it's it's hard. Like it's really hard.
The right cards come out that give you the the milestone bonuses.
Not really. I mean, if you want to peak, right, if you it's kind of the same with every every uh 10 build is like if you want to do the absolute best you could ever do at it, yeah, sure you need the cards, but you should even with no cards. I mean, if you luck into getting no 10 cards at all, yeah, it's going to be hard, but like that's kind of the numbers of the game should not allow that to happen generally
uh for extended periods.
I'll just say the skill ceiling on this game is it is high. And the reason why I know this is we we've played this game one million times. I am not I'm not bad at the game. I would crush any like average player because I've played so much, right? And that I think tells you that the skill ceiling is high, but also we'll pick roles to test when we play. Um, and so like Toby like I'm going to go fishing. I'm going to go farming or whatever. Um, and Toby will beat me no matter what I pick and no matter what he picks. Doesn't matter what the cards are going to be coming out.
Is that 100% you've never beaten Toby? I think I've beaten Toby maybe once on a play test that we then nerfed my strategy because we were like that's unfair
and that's how I will say
was that Toby's decision like oh that must be broken if he won.
The nice thing though is that because it is so consistent because it's so consistent we can use it as a baseline or if beat me there is probably something broken here
like
we you can't do that with with everybody. You can't do that with all like if Max beats me, we don't nerf his strategy.
Max Max wins all the time.
Uh but yeah, and it again it's not like Zach is way behind like he'll score like 20 less points. It's not crazy number usually.
Um yeah, but it's Yeah, it has happened very rarely.
Well then, okay, so take me through the secret then. Like as you're going into a game of 10, what are the things that you're thinking about? Are you waiting for any signals before you actually decide to specialize on something outside of your testing sessions?
Like what what should the player be looking at? Right.
Yeah, for sure. So, I I would say that the the key is being flexible. Um don't lock in too early.
Uh and always think about efficiency, right? Like always think about what I do in the early game. how far is like an investment in the beginning can pay off five times in the future, right? Like if I like I think the thing that opened my eyes the most. The funny thing is
I got really good attend not just from me but from when I first saw the first play testers. So when we first uh it's other Zack Ztorm uh is one of our our mods on Discord who runs our play tests. when we first put gave 10 to him and the other people to play test, they were putting up ludicrous scores, like absolutely insane scores. And I basically sat down with him and said, "What's going on?" Like, "I want to see, are you playing the game wrong? Like, is is this okay?" And there were problems. We we had to fix some There were things that were oversightes. They had like found loopholes, which is obviously good. That's what you want them there for. But one of the things that they taught me that was that was so correct and just the way to do it is energy bars. energy bars. Energy bars. Like
I was gonna ask that question.
Energy bars early and you use them to get your upgrades. Then you will have your upgrades rounds earlier than you would have otherwise. And every one of those actions will be doubled. Right? So like an investment of two energy bars in round one or two can end up paying off in round three or four by having a tool one round early, which can then cascade to everything else, right? as quickly as you can get that first tool upgraded. And then knowing which tool you're going for and why is like so important. And then the other thing is is making sure you're following those cards, right? Like you shouldn't be trying to to accomplish the goal on every single card, but like on turn one, if you see a card that says two plus mining levels coming next round, you probably should mine twice pretty much no matter what you're doing. like you should try and get yourself that bonus because that early game bonus like getting the card bonus on turn two is huge because those those resources in the early game, well, if it gives you like two wood, that's two coins, that's that's almost an energy bar, right? And getting that energy bar round one, round two is so different from round three, round four.
And then spend them as soon as you possibly can. Like use your energy bars immediately. You should never be saving them. This this was actually something we changed in development because it it was working the opposite. Originally, when you use an energy bar, it gave you an extra task entirely. So, you could like if you had upgraded tools, you would get a double like if you had a, you know, a two mining tool power. When you used energy bar charge, you would get two mining, which was way too powerful. That was part of what broke the game. And then it also meant you were better off saving your energy bars until you got to the end game and you had your tools upgraded. And that's kind of the opposite of how we wanted them to be used.
Like it gave you an extra double action early. Okay.
Yeah. Exactly. So you would need you would want to wait until you had upgraded your tool and then you would use all your energy bars and you'd be getting entirely like double actions every round and it makes your late rounds take forever also, which is not particularly great because they're already longer because you're already doing other stuff. Um, so we changed that long long ago. It's it's much better this way. But it as a result, uh, energy bars are actually pretty bad when you have tool upgrades. Like if you have an upgraded mining pick and you're you're scratching in the bottom section, you use an energy bar, it doesn't give you another scratch in the bottom section, you have to scratch in the top section.
So like you're no longer getting the upgrade you really want. Like you need to use those things early. Um, or you can use them to like get to the bottom of the lake or the mines quickly, which is another thing that that that it's worth using. Um, so like I will often sell almost everything I find at the start of the game unless it's directly leading to a tool upgrade or unlocking
bonus. Well, how do you balance that against the season one um goal? Like is that something you're ignoring is season one goals?
I almost always ignore season one goals. Um, now the Max thing is Max.
Yeah, I was gonna say it it is not necessarily the only way to play because our other designer who's very good at the game, Max, uh, he almost always does the season one goals and he's way more goal focused and we often score.
It occurred to me when I was playing this morning, it was a trap. Like it felt like a trap to me because I wasn't optimizing for what I was seeing. Right. Of course it could be you could be lucky
but friend bonuses. Friend bonuses are great early because you you should be giving the stuff anyway because you're going to get on net more stuff than you give to people. Uh so that's one you would always go for. If there's like if it's a huge swing in points and it only requires you to do like a little bit of stuff, then I think it's usually worth it. Um but it it is even if you're going to do that, that should still be like the last two rounds of season one. You should not be doing that the first three rounds. Like I think basically if you're doing anything to try and complete a season one goal in the first three rounds of the game, you're probably not playing optimally, which you know, also do whatever you want. You can do whatever you want.
They also seem kind of hard.
Highest score
like this.
They can be. I mean, some of them are easy, some of them are.
Yeah, it it to me it seems like the the season cards bonuses are the absolute key to everything. That's the efficiency the biggest like focus and efficiency puzzle. If you have any idea of trying to strongarm a particular strategy, unless they happen to line up, you're kind of screwed
in the beginning.
Yeah.
Were those bonuses always powerful? Was this always part of the design is having those bonuses on there?
Yeah, generally because that's that to me they need to be that powerful so that you don't play the game the same every time.
100%. One of my my huge uh goals with this game was to make it feel like it's infinitely replayable um out of the box and that like because it I mean I I work in rogue likes like that's one of the things I've I've made a lot of games uh with. Uh and so having that feeling of like I want to play this thing over and over and over and not feel like I've solved it um is like so important to me in any design I make. Uh, and so those needed to be pushed so strongly that when what cards were in your game dictated the way your game was going to play, right?
Yeah.
Um, and we've we've improved it, I think, even with the seller expansion. Like there's some really cool stuff with how the goal cards uh or sorry, not the uh not the season goal cards, but the actual like action cards uh work in seller. Um, and then there's also like uh we I don't know if you saw but we we released like free content
last week back. Um, and one of the things
about week.
So, I came up with the idea for those season goals in that in that uh for that for that content. And uh the thing that actually going back to the season one stuff that I really was interested in is I wanted to come up with a season one goal that didn't feel like a trap that didn't feel like if you go after the season one goal, it's actually going to pay off for you long term. And so we have one now. Um, and I think it's really cool and maybe in the future would love to make more of those where essentially at the end of the season if you've completed a certain amount of your season one goal, you get resources. So, it like gives you stuff back. So, it's like you've paid forward, you're going to complete this thing and you don't just get it for free. You have to like have actually committed to it. And if you [snorts] fail, it's going to be bad.
But even then, if you do get there,
optimize for the bonuses that are coming out on those season cards long run, it still could be a trap. even if you do get the extra stuff. Is that true?
Yeah, potentially. I mean, it depends on what the stuff is. I tried to make them fairly like generically good of like I expect that the amount you put into it is going to be more coming out
pretty much no matter what you put in there. Um, but you do obviously yes need to pay attention to that. But, um, yeah. And then I don't know I don't know how familiar you are with the seller expansion, but in the seller expansion uh players essentially draft a season card. Yes, I saw that.
Were they not a season card, a an action card? What?
Are they They're season action card.
There's season cards.
Task cards.
Season card. Not a goal card. Task card. Task card.
The mat just says season up there, but yeah, the task cards.
Yeah. So, everybody knows one card in the deck at the start, which is really cool. Um, now the funny thing is that up until I think a week before it went into prototype, the game was a deck builder. So like you were choosing what cards
went into the deck every round.
So like those two that that are up there that come down
that was there was a drafting part where the person there was like one person who was the the like lead player for the round that was still simultaneous and then that person would choose one of three cards to go into the deck for the next round. So you were like building the deck as
so it was a shared deck builder in that case.
It was a shared deck builder. Interesting. Now, there's a huge problem with that which we never were able to figure to fix. I mean, there were there were two huge problems with that. Uh, one of it is, uh, you cannot play that with any number of players. Like, it gets weirder at different player counts. Um, and that's something we really care about
because only one person is making a selection.
Yep. And there even if you're doing like two people at a time, like it's so different if it's only two players versus six players versus 10 players, right? Like the number of times you're going to get to choose a card to go in there is wildly different. And then the biggest problem and the one that made us ultimately cut it was uh if I am putting cards in there that are pro fishing, the best strategy for you to do is to just fish and put in cards that are pro fishing,
right?
So it ended up being this like parasitic everyone is putting the same cards in and if you tried to buck the trend, you just got annihilated like you just got swept away by the tide.
Uh and it was not a good experience. Um so this limited version of
Yeah. Yeah. There was a third problem too which was time and pacing. Like it was it was just like
that was the other reason that was my reason for cutting it.
Well, no, it was just sitting there thinking about which one.
Well, it broke the flow of it too. It was just like oh somebody went to go to the bathroom but because they were done but then like oh it's like their turn to pick the card and we got to wait for them to come back and then you're out of your like flow.
You let people go to the bathroom in the middle of a game. That's not allowed in my house. Like let's keep going. Yeah. You got a You got a You got a jar onto the table and you can use the jar.
You don't strap a catheter before you play games. What's going on?
But yeah, so that with the seller expansion, I feel like we found a like the perfect middle ground of like you get a little bit of planning ahead. You start it from the beginning of the game, which is even better because now you know what you're building towards like later depending on where you put the card. Um, and but it's not like everyone is picking all the time. It's like one time thing that happens in the game. And we actually even put in the rule book, uh, hey, this is a variant. This rule works for base 10. And if you want to play normal 10 with this rule, we think it's cool and you should do that.
So, you're talking about the seller. I have a million more questions on 10, but I also want to make this consumable for the normal person so they can actually listen to this this entire thing.
I have a bonus forever. Is this going to set me up to eventually get the 365 day legacy uh game where I have to play 365 as if it's in a real year? I really want that that that uh Stardew Valley feel and go through the seasons and just have this never- ending game. Is that ever going to happen? I
mean, it could, but I don't that is not really it's not on our radar.
I know people that have played 10 over a hundred times. Oh yeah, it's crazy.
We do. We do too. Many people who had to buy replacement sheets.
Yeah. Yeah. I know somebody that backed multiple copies before they even knew the game because they knew they were going to play it so much.
Shout out Eli over at the Grove. Uh yeah, he's he he said he backed multiple copies. I was like, why why would you do that? Yeah, he plays plays it an absolute ton. Okay, so um then that's my that's my ultimate dream. We're going to pull back the scope a little bit. Tell me a little bit about seller. Um, or should we start with Hive? Which one? Which one works best?
I think they both they both work great. Um, the So, Hi, both of them actually have elements from the Waybacks of Tent in We talked about the original, well, not the original, but the the legacy version, right? One of the things in that weird legacy version was that every season uh on the sheet, I had a different sheet for every season, and every season had a different miniame in the space where the farming was. Um, so at the first game it was just farming, but then in a later one it was animals instead of farming. So it wasn't that they were you could do both. And then in the next game it was apiaries, it was bees. Um, so that actually I had made that miniame [snorts] long ago for this and it was like, hey, this feels like a cool little thing that kind of we always liked it because it sat uh separate from the core game, right? It doesn't require a new action, which is a big deal. like you can't really add another action or else your cards are going to be all messed up. Um, so it kind of just floats alongside everything else and it's so simple from the way it works and it has like a lot of the fun roll and write elements of like having a die that you're rolling and actually writing it down like it's an actual roll in right now, right? Like
shared dice, right? And is there a constraint on what numbers you place where?
Yep. Exactly. So, it's kind of a lot like what you would think of like uh that's so clever or the dope world so clever the the like you know the German roll and right was one that I really liked a lot um where you're rolling these dice everybody sees them on the table you can use one of the dice by default to add into one of your apiaries and then you can unlock the ability to use the second die also so you can essentially run write down one number in a turn or two if you get an unlock and then you have four different hives that you can unlock throughout the course of the game each one of them has different rules about what how you can write numbers in there. Uh they're very simple kind of things you would expect of like all the number has all the numbers have to be different in this one. All the numbers have to be the same in this other one. All the numbers have to be high numbers in this one. All the numbers have to be low numbers in this.
No adjacency constraints at all.
No, no adjacency. Just trying to keep it simple. I mean again part of the goal was anything we add here needs to be very streamlined and clean because the rest of the game is a lot, right? So, we don't need to add anything that has like
complex stuff going on.
Um, and then
I had always wanted more upgrades for uh your equipment in general. We kind of talked about that way back in the beginning, right, of like what is it like with escalating tool upgrades. Well, those didn't work, but I did always like the idea of what if you could be better at mining in a different way than I can do two things at once kind of upgrades. Um, and so that we ended up coming up with this whole set of different upgraded tool stuff. Uh, one of the things that I kept running into was we have all these dice, uh, and you don't roll them that much. In fact, the the currently you don't roll the plant dice at all, right? Like you have all these dice in the box you never
It's sad. These big chunky dice I don't get to I don't get to throw.
Well, in the Hive expansion, you can roll them. There is that was one of the
funny that was one of my questions was like my gripes with the game is I don't get to roll these giant dice.
Yeah, I felt exactly the same way and that Yeah, that was the So that was the genesis of one of the upgrades in Hive. It's the compost bin. Uh it was me sitting in a room going I want to get you to roll these dice. How can I do it so that it doesn't feel like the whole game is decided by rolling these dice? Because we don't want it to feel like everything is based on dice rolls. uh but also that it feels good and like sufficiently like a thing you would want to do and then also makes sense. Uh so the way the compost uh in works is once you've unlocked it whenever you gather a resource a plant uh you roll the die and if you don't roll a blank it gets to go right back. So you know you've you're composting you put it back in the field and sometimes something just grows right back out. I don't know if you ever had a compost bin, but that's that hap I do remember that being an experience for me as a kid being like, whoa, these pumpkins are growing out of nowhere.
Yeah.
Um, so that kind of fed into the the theme of it. And then all the other ones are just kind of like, how can I push synergies between uh things that you don't normally synergize with, right? Like, so in the base game, trying to do like a tending strategy at the same time, it's kind of just a bad idea. like it doesn't really work very well because you need some amount of wood and/or minerals to do stuff to upgrade your tools to upgrade your rods to do all this different stuff. And if you're completely skipping out on that stuff, well, you're in a lot of trouble. Well, with the upgrades that you have now, you can upgrade so that when you take 10 actions, you have a chance to get wood or a chance to get minerals. And so these these can supplement those things that you would be missing out on if you were doing uh not doing chopping or mining. And now you can actually combine these two things in a way that will make sense. And then you can also have a thing where when you fish, you get better at tending stuff. You can tick your dice uh on your farm. So there's like a reason to specialize in fishing
uh that would then improve your tender.
You said hi was hive was originally part of the design, right?
Parts of it.
Was this synergy aspect that you just described also an original part? Is that a reaction at all to people thinking attending is hard? Not really a reaction to people think tending is hard and more just a reaction to people felt like I felt like people were too locked into specific builds of like
uh if I fish I do fishing mining or I do fishing shopping. I never do fishing tending and I wanted to be like hey there's here's a way you can do fishing tending. Now obviously
it's not like there's only one build for fishing, right? Like there still is a lot of variety even in the original version. Um but it felt like a way to get even more variety in there which is always fun. Ten's been like app praised almost universally. Not almost. Some some people don't, but it's gotten great great reviews. Does this materially make it better or just different and more complex for the super fan?
I would say that it if you did if you did not like original tend, I do not think this will change your mind. Like it's not fundamental. [clears throat] Even if the person was just like you, I'd never I wanted to tend and I really couldn't synergize with it. Like if that was their gripe, would this fix
that for them?
I would say probably not because realistically you you could you can tend fine in the base game. Like you just never really got
good enough at it, which is fine. Good at it.
People love hearing that.
Yeah. Yeah. Uh I've delivered a lot of patch notes to users in my time and I tell you they do love it.
Yeah. Uh
yeah, right. You know more than anyone. Hey, just get better, man. We tested this
of everyone on this call. I've been review bombed the most for sure. Uh so I have dealt with this firsthand. Uh but yeah, no, I would say that most of the gripes that people have with Tend, which you know, it's totally fair to have gripes.
Yeah.
I would say that like the thing that I love the most about Tend is not that it's universally recognized in any way. It's more that the people who love it really love it. Like
yeah.
Yes.
I think the dream when you make a game is I I remember uh Mark Rosewater, the lead designer of Magic, is always talking about this in his design talks of like you don't want a game that everyone feels like it's fine about. You want a game that some people hate and other people think is the greatest game of all time. Like you want to to channel emotions from people. You want people to be like like the thing that that is the most incredible for me is seeing content creators that are like this is my favorite game of all time or of the year or like I saw Bonds had it in her top 10 list of games all time after a year. That's crazy. Like
that that is like resonates to me of like
Tom B calls it the best roll and right that he's ever played.
Exactly. And like that that kind of feeling
whether everybody likes it is whatever. I want to make people who love it absolutely love it. And I think this expansion will make those people love it even more. And that's kind of like what you're aiming for here. Um, so yeah, I I don't think that if if I think most of the people who had complaints about it are like it's too much, which it's a lot. I I totally get it that like sometimes I have trouble keeping everything in my head. Um, you know, the theme isn't for me potentially. Like I I guess a lot of people like the game, but like some people don't like farming in general. Um or like there's not enough player interaction. Like that's a thing we've heard. Like some people want a really interactive game. This is not what that was designed to be. Um those things are not really going to change. Yeah,
these are these expansions.
But like if you like the game at all, we I think this makes the game just way better. Like I
I don't want to play the normal version of the game anymore. Like
most importantly, Zach, can you beat Toby with Hive Bolted on?
Only if I have a broken build that needs to get patched. Yeah. Uh but uh No, no. I I may maybe Oh, the problem is I also like to think and they're always rushing me along in my turn.
Are you You're the slow guy, aren't you?
Trolling me.
He's the slow guy.
How I'd say it, but uh
Okay. If we ever get to play together, I'm gonna have to bite my tongue. You're going to see me over in the corner going like, "Oh, come on." Well, to be to be fair to Zach, I don't think he's the slow guy in every game.
Okay.
I think he's the slow guy in a couple of my games because they're really they they crunch him in a way that is not the way he normally crunches that like the games you I don't think Zach plays this type of game
for fun. Normally,
is that true?
It's uh I don't know that that's true. I I mean I I wouldn't have made tendon and Altera if I didn't love them. Uh, and of course, so like I I enjoy that. It's not a game I would design. Like you you come at it from like a systems approach that like I just am not capable of. Like it's just not like the the the like the the fantasies that I'm chasing when I'm like playing a game like but is it is certainly one uh that I enjoy. Um
were you a Roland Wright fan before at all?
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean like yeah like uh I have ctographers raight um what what else we got? I
were any loved uh
Twilight Strugg Twilight. What's the Twilight Imperium, right?
Yeah. Incription.
Incription.
Yeah. Yeah. Play played that. Um and yeah. No, I mean I like I like all those. Um but I did want to double double down on what Toby was saying though. I mean like that is that is a thing we talk about all the time is just like we are here to make someone's favorite game. like we're not going to publish a game unless we believe that it can be someone's favorite game. Uh and and then when we make expansions like that is who we're making these expansions for. Uh we're we're not like expansions are not a time to just like broaden your audience. It's like we want to go deep. We want to we want to like double down on that person's uh
we want to give them more of of what they love and enrich that. And uh and that is exactly what these these expansions are are for. Um and it's also something that like I I believe as as far as art goes as well too. Like we're trying to find specificity. We're trying to find art styles that people haven't seen before. We're going to put out art that people don't like um but other people love intensely uh and have strong opinions about. Um and that's how I think you make it to that. like that is our success metric is like, "Oh man, like this is my favorite game." Like that's what we want to hear when we go to cons. Um, and
yeah,
what do you think sells more copies? A bunch of people liking it, everyone liking it, or people?
I would say that I think that probably if you're just looking to optimize sales, then I think that probably broad appeal is often more what you want to do. But that's not really what we're trying to do here. Like, like if you trying to absolutely optimize your sales using a broadly recognized, appreciated art style and generic game that everyone knows and likes, like a like a what's going to make more money, the the licensed new version of Code Names or like, you know, the new uh Feast for Odin expansion, like the new Feast for Odin 2 that's coming out, right? It's like, yeah, I think the code name Dave is probably gonna make more money.
Like, does that make it better? Like, does that I don't think so. Like, and it's not like you can't make plenty of money to get by with, you know, and be extremely profitable. Like, it's just about like scale. Like, what do you want to be making, right?
You also probably shouldn't make an $80 roll in right flipping right and right.
Yeah. Yeah. That's probably not That was I mean that's the the really I think one of the interesting things with Tend is how the
because of that because of what you were just saying there like the Kickstarter didn't do that well. I mean it didn't do poorly.
It did. Like
for a rolling ride, it did great.
Oh, for a rolling ride. Sure. But it's not really a rolling right. Like it's a I mean
if you compare it to the other IV games, it did okay. And if I would say more so if you compare it to the accolades it got post launch, it did not do that incredible. Like for a game that
then won a bunch of like game of the year awards, it it was it did not break any sort of like Kickstarter records, right? And I think a lot of that was due to what you said of like it's an $80 roll and right.
Yeah.
It's like a thing that's unheard of and that people when they see it, they initially bawk at it and they're like what is this? Like this is not what I expect from the genre. and you kind of had to show them that like yeah, no, it doesn't have to be like all the other roing rights you've played. can be a fundamentally different like I would say that this game has more in common with something like Feast for Odin than it does with Welcome to right like the
right and you could say the same with like something like Hrien's Wall as well um where you do you are just writing things down but it does have the for lack of a better term that combotastic DNA where you're going back and forth and and getting those dopamine hits because you made a smart decision around efficiency. Um, so yeah, I I think I think it definitely transcends and exactly what I said is probably why it didn't do as well in your eyes as when somebody sees $80 and rolling right, those two words together, the association is overpriced, bloated, Kickstarter, like all of that stuff, but then people got it in their hands and I I don't know. I'd almost rather have this let's just let's just agree for a second that this was a was a disappointing, you know, um uh
I wouldn't say disappointing. I was
well it was just didn't you said it didn't do as well we'll say and I'm going to insert the word as you expected or would have liked
would have liked maybe more so than expected
like I think to to your point and to give give context like mid campaign first 10 we were like
like I I I thought maybe it could do a million like just based on like the genre like based on the vibes the how good I thought the game was
early trajectory as well made like it was
well yeah like you know ads all that stuff it
but then like mid campaign we were like oh man we need to shake up like how we're messaging this right like there's a whole I'm I'm designing the the page for this next one and it's like we
didn't do a good enough job reframing people's expectations of what Tend was ahead of the campaign during the campaign at the beginning of the campaign of like no no no this there is literally a slide on the campaign that we added halfway through that that says reset your expectations like at the top and it goes through and just like this is not like this is not like a cgraphers right like this is like a totally different thing um and I think it bounced for a lot of people because they're just like no I don't want to spend 80 bucks on a roll right that sounds insane um and but it is like an $80 type of game and like yeah we I think we just didn't do a good enough job setting people's expectations now we don't have that problem as much going into the the the next campaign is like people actually they've played it and it was such this play and we we literally ordered less because we're like oh man maybe there just isn't an appetite for an $80 roll and right and maybe we were wrong about that. Uh and we didn't order enough copies because as soon as people got it they were like oh this this rocks this is great. Yeah. And then and then we sold out so quickly uh and so there's this kind of weird problem.
You need to break it down as price per pound relative to other games is probably an insane value. Also, price per price per play,
right? When you have like this game, if you if you get this game and you're like, I'm probably going to be happy with five plays, it's not the game for you. It's just not like this is the type of game that I think reveals itself over 10, 20, 30, 100 plays as Eli Eli at the Grove would would probably tell you because of the dynamic nature, especially which we were talking about earlier, of these task cards that changes the way you play every single time. And I don't know, you know, you described what Hive does, but it seems like you're doubling down um on kind of replay-ability, dynamic play states, all of that stuff. And it's like, how do you how do you have help a customer see that? I mean now like you said it's a little bit easier because that there has a reputation of course and like I think the value speaks for itself but that early that early state I mean considering all of that I would say what 700k is pretty impressive considering what you're going up against right
yeah yeah no I mean we we budgeted 600 so like it it beat
expectations budget so like it was still like a success like don't don't hear us that it wasn't a success but it was just like
we just believed in it so much like I just such a big fan of it. I I was like, "Oh man, I think this art style is going to connect with people like in a in a crazy way." Um, and I'm just like, "Oh, man." And and then now the response that people have for it now, I'm just like, "Yeah, what uh we didn't do a good enough job."
Yeah. We just didn't do a good enough job getting them there ahead of time, you know?
Yeah. Like I I remember when we were first getting the uh the first influencer plays, right? like cuz uh you have people in the studio and they play it in on site and whatnot. And then
based on that and then the first stuff afterwards and Austin kept saying this over and over of like I think this game is going to win awards.
He said I think this game is going to win game of the year stuff and I was like you're crazy. I don't what are you talking like it's my first game. You don't win game of the year stuff. And then the awards came out and he was right and it won a bunch of awards and it was like whoa this is and I think that is that reaction from the people who were playing it that we were seeing before the campaign had launched is what kind of set like Zach said of like this could do a million because people are loving this. But it was that that expectation of people those people had not played it yet, right? So we need to get people actually play this thing before they actually understood uh you know what it was. And and I do think that the new ones, new expansions are not going to really have this problem at all. And like I think the seller expansion personally, it's my personal favorite. I absolutely love it. And I think it takes all the things we've talking talked about to like it doesn't even go to 11, it goes to 12. It goes so far past what base 10 does. It's like I just want to play that all the time.
Perfect segue. Let's talk about seller. This was the the when I heard that there was an expansion, the very first thing that I thought was a multi-play, you know, some sort of memory over time would be stellar because often you're left with, "Oh, I wish I could go longer. I wish I could see where I could go with this strategy." Tell me about seller and how that might help help quench my thirst. Yeah. So, I mean the I think the thing the most important part of it came from Austin uh was that that what if we did this mini campaign thing, right? So, like the seller part of it was a part of the absolute original version of Tend of like let's age your goods, let's get them over time. And when you were really good at the game, you could unlock that stuff really quick and it was really fun. You get all your stuff unlocked. But it always had this problem of you have to age your goods in your seller and it takes time and you can't do a 15 round game of 10, right?
So like how do we make it so that you can actually make those things something everyone can experience, not just the best players and something that like continuously goes over time with this stuff. And then Austin had this idea. So that's that's where the original like what if it's a legacy game came from. But that was insane. It was too much. Austin had this idea, what if we do these three game mini campaign and it's just you take one sheet, you go with it from thing to thing. And just as soon as he said it, it was like, yes, yeah, that's it. Like 100%. Uh the funny thing is so much of the design of seller came together so fast because it was like I have all the stuff from the original 10 for seller. We did change it a bit like it's not exactly the same uh in original seller. Uh so essentially the way it works is you can unlock spaces. You have a new sheet that goes with you from game to game. In on that sheet you have a seller. That's why it's called seller expansion. Um this is going to be place you're going to age your artisan goods, your refined goods, which is one of my favorite parts of Stardw Valley type games. In the first place, uh you're going to get things like wine, you're going to get things like mayo, cheese, etc. Uh to do that, you need to unlock a piece of technology to refine a specific type of good, and then you need to unlock some space in your seller to put that good into. All this stuff was stuff that was in the original tend. Um, in the original tend once you'd unlock them, spaces in your cellar were a little place to put a die. And then so when I would collect my egg or whatever, I would flip that take that die actually
and put it right into my seller. And now instead of an egg, it's now mayo. And now I'm aging my mayo. Um, we came up with actually a better system than that than using the dice twice. Uh, and we have instead these little tokens that slide down your your uh your seller growth I track, I guess. We don't really have a name for that, I guess. Um, but it works largely the same. And instead, we get these cool little tokens that uh look like the artisan goods. And so, the way it works is you unlock a space in your seller. You unlock a piece of technology, you gather a resource, and then you get to take a special artisan good token and put it onto a space in your seller track. And then every round it's going to age. It's going to tick up by one. And then when it hits a certain point, you're going to gain the good from that that space. Um, so it that part is super super fun just by itself.
Uh, just like having this plan for I'm going to get eggs, which are currently like you get eggs all the time in base 10, right? Like they're they're almost worthless. You have so many of them and they don't really do much. But once you turn it into mayo, now the mayo is a larger good and it's worth extra points in your manifest. uh all the artisan goods are worth two points for every stamped spot instead of one. Uh so it's like suddenly now this stuff is actually valuable. You have something to do with this stuff you have in excess of. Um so it also helps with that problem you were talking about before of if I have a ton of stuff all the time, what do I do with it? Well, you start refining it. Um and then it also adds a couple other things. It adds a storage section which is a place that you can essentially carry things over from one game to the other. So you can unlock these these bonuses that you will start the next games with.
uh which is really really powerful. Um
limited or are you able to kind of build heavily for the next game? Okay,
there's so you can build quite heavily because of the fact that everything that is in your cellar at the end of the first game will get refined at the start of the second game. So the idea is when you finish your first game, you've ended your first like year of working on this this this farm area. Uh, so all the stuff that you had in there when you start the next year, it's now aged for the next season, for the start of the next year. Like you're like going into the winter essentially. And so all the stuff that you had that was sitting there, well, it's going to have taken still aged while you weren't playing. And then when you come back for the second game, you get all of that stuff plus you get all the stuff that you unlocked in your storage, which is essentially like a new version of the projects area, right? So you can like cross off some stuff, get yourself a coin, but then you also get the coin at the start of each game. Um, so if you have a fully stocked seller at the end of the game and you have your your uh storage stuff unlocked, you can get a crazy amount of resources at the start of the first game, like at the start of your second game. So the start of your second game or your third game, you might end up with like 25 coins to spend or something like that.
Oh wow.
And like we've seen people like completely have a cow unlocked on round.
So you're starting essentially with a fresh sheet that you can then go and just spend those first turn.
Yeah. So, you reset your farm sheet and your project sheet, but you keep your seller sheet from game to game. Uh, and then it also has the last thing it has is it has this uh it's the market stall, right, is what we called it. It has this this point area essentially at the bottom right where you can put these artisan goods that you're going to be gaining over the game into this long-term grid that when you complete rows and columns, they're going to give you tons of points at the end of all three games. Um, and that is like a long long long-term planning kind of thing where it's like at the start of a game, you may sit down and go, I'm gonna try and do this giant row of 20 goods across it, right? And I'm going to try I'm going to get 150 points for doing that, right? And to do that, I'm going to have to make sure in one game I do mining because I know I have to get this diamond and I need to get all these other things. And this other game, I'm gonna have to do fishing because I need this fish from the bottom of the lake.
And then I also need to get a bunch of caviar which is the advanced fish good. And then I'm also going to have to do tending because I need a pumpkin and I also need all these pickles which are refined for pumpkins. So like you're going to have to plan around these across your three games. But then another game you might want to do a different row. And then also even if you're doing that big row, what what columns are you doing alongside it, right? To like maximize your points. So it leads to this thing where at the start of your first game of a seller game, you can have these lofty goals that you're shooting for. It's kind of like unlike anything you've ever done in 10. And then at the end of the first game, you're going to get this massive leg up for game two. And then you're going to be able to to build towards that over and over. Now, it can sometimes lead to you biting off more than you can chew. But you think, I'm going to do this column. I'm going to do this row. I'm going to do all that stuff. We had a game with Austin. I think it was the same one where you had you scored like that crazy amount of points, Zach, where he was like two fish away from completing row and a column because he had gone, right?
Yeah. It's like it's like 80 points, 90 points, 100 points.
And he had gone to the river to get to get a fish from river fishing, which is another really cool thing is like in the base game attend you very rarely unlock river fishing. It's just like often not worth it because you just you don't really have time to be fiddling around with that. Whereas in this, you need that fish from river fishing, the rare fish in river fishing for a bunch of different things. And so in one game, a lot of the times, not every single time, but in one of your three games, you're often going to go into river fishing, try and catch that fish. And Austin had done that, but he had only caught one of them, and he needed to catch three of them because there were three places he needed to put it. And so he ended up having to go back in game three to try and do it again, which wasted a lot of resources. And then he did not get enough to get to fill the entire thing. he lost out on likeund and something points. He was like,
"Oh man." But it it also gives you that fuel of like next time,
right?
I'm going to get in there, I'm gonna catch that fish three times. I'm gonna make sure I do it. Um and yeah, it just it allows you to play a tender of like I have a like when Zach was doing his geode build, right? You had a game where you started the game with an upgraded rod and a lure on round one
for fish. That's crazy. You're catching two fish immediately right off the bat, right? It's so much funner. You have upgraded tools. You have all of your energy bars unlocked. It's just it's super super spicy.
It it almost sounds like it's it's showcasing what's already there, right? It's it's giving giving players the ability to get deep when maybe they didn't have the right skill set to get there on the on one game, but it also just allows you to do it more with multiple actions over the three games. And you're not necessarily specializing right through these three games in one particular area. You can't
you can't because of that market. There are like
there are some market stall things where you could like go hyper deep into one thing. Okay.
But most of the time you're going to generally be doing a little bit of everything. We don't really want you to be like I'm going to play three games at 10 and in every single one of them all I'm going to do is fish in mine because it just feels like probably going to get a little bored of that long term if that's all you're doing. Um, but there are
it's it's like you work backwards from like granted you might need to to look at the cards and how they come out, but generally I'm like, "All right, cool. I'm gonna I'm gonna aim for like this is going to be a wine and cheese game, right?" And it's like, "All right, I'm going to start with cheese early, right? And I'm going to get cheese going. That's going to be my first thing. And then later I'm going to work towards wine." Uh, and then you know, you fill in the gaps with like some of the other easier ones as well, too. But it's like you can't do everything. Uh, and so you kind of set some goals for yourself. And then you kind of got to be like, "Okay, cool." And then in the big wine and cheese row, there's also like these two fish. So like at some point in this game, I got to go unlock Grotto. And so I'm like, "Okay, this this I'm getting like pretty far down in the mines."
Like, "Okay, cool. This is the this is going to be the round where I get that fish." Uh, and so you get these kind of like interesting to-dos and and strategy kind of layouts based on the market stall of like, oh, there's these huge rows that are worth like a oh, whatund where do we land? I can't remember. 185 or something like that.
I think 15 some some huge amount of nut points. And you're like, okay, cool. These are my goals for these three games. I'm gonna try and go for this big row and this big row. And then you kind of work backwards into plans. And, you know, not everything goes the way you want it to. and and you always think you won't be able to get it done in the third game, but then you're just so insanely powerful that it's like, "Oh, wow. I can actually get this done." Uh, and it it creates a really interesting pacing uh throughout the games. The other thing that's like super weird about it that like I thought was a bug and then I think it I'm just like I've accepted it's a feature is like game one you can score like nine points and that's fine. uh like there there is a and then and then at the same time Max will score like 300 points and you're like well he's what is he doing over there? How did he do that? But then you have a way to catch up because it's just you can play an entire game of 10 literally just setting up for games two and three and that is a viable strategy. Uh and it's very strange but it's fun.
Can if you don't set up properly can you lose the campaign in game one? Yeah, you can, but it's it's not really so much about what you scored in game one, and it's more like if you didn't unlock anything on your seller sheet at the end of game one, you're going to it's going to be not great. I mean,
so you're going to really want to focus on unlocking in that seller sheet.
Yeah, at least some amount. I think to an extent I think if you were really really good at basic tend you could probably mostly play just three basic games of 10 and just like when you had extra stuff throw it in here and there but you better be really good like you better be scoring 250 or more every single
and this brings
this brings up a design point that we talked about multiple times and we made a a distinct decision on is like
we we kind of made the decision of like if you're going to play one of these expansions, you need to engage with the expansion or else like why are you playing with the expansion? Uh, and that was some feedback that we got. Like there are some people that were just like, "Oh, like I felt like you really in order to do well, you had to engage with a hive expansion and like I didn't like that."
And I was like, "Well, no, I mean that's that like that's
No, no, that's you should. You should. Make it obvious. You should." Yeah. Yeah. You just don't just don't play with it. Like that's fine.
Yeah. If you don't if you don't like it, just just play base 10. It's still still there. Or you can just just play it.
Yeah. Yeah.
Is hive. Can Hive be played with seller?
No.
Okay. It's a different thing.
I mean like
it's Yeah. It's
not so badly technically you can. Uh but the official IV studio statement is no, you cannot because
why not make them compatible?
Basically because it's too much.
It's too much. We're trying to protect you from yourself.
Yeah. Okay. Yeah.
There are no technically rules that make it so they do not work together, but you should not play them together. They are not It is not an ideal experience. You're going to have a bad time. If you hate yourself and you want to try it, I guess go for it. Like, no one's going to tell you how to live your life, right? Like
there's nothing that fundamentally like actively breaks,
right? They're designed to be a full meal, like a full experience. Yes. Right. Like it is designed to push you to the limits of each of them individually, what tend can be in its like fullest. And we filled up every crack that we thought we could and we put it into each individual expansion. Um, and so it's just from a, you know, decision space, from a strategy space, like it fills it all. It fills what I am personally capable of doing. And so like we think it would objectively be a bad experience to play them both together because it just wasn't made to be that way. Uh so yeah,
it's like eating two dinners.
Yeah.
As a man who has eaten two dinners in his life,
you regret it afterwards. It's a bad idea.
If one was technically liner and you stayed up really late and maybe had a couple beers, like you could get away with it.
A bad idea. It's
Oh, definitely still a bad idea. But it feels so good in the midst of doing it. I don't regret it until later. People will try it.
People will try it and people are welcome to try it. I think the big thing is
we don't want you to to judge the game and to think of the game as the the two things combined because that's not the way it's supposed to be.
I love that there's restraint there, right? And it's not just a, you know, throwing everything in there. Do you think there's a world where there's a player that should only buy one of these?
Yes, definitely. I think there is a world of a player who can only buy one of these. I I think that it will not be the majority of players. I think it's going to be like the vast minority.
Yeah.
But I think there are some people who
I think I think realistically if you're interested in the hive or sorry the seller expansion, I think you're almost always going to want Hive. I think that seller expansion will not be for everyone. Like I think there are some people that are like, I can't get three games together. Like I I can't play a three game campaign. It's just not feasible for me with my time. I mean, it's like saying people like I can't get a D and D group together, right? Like it is it's not as much of an investment as like a full campaign game.
And I would say to your
Yeah, you can play it solo and it's great solo, but like
even then like it's still a lot of time. Like it's a lot of investment. A lot of some people
Yeah, but if you're buying an $80 flip and right, you need to play it a lot of times, right? Pro
probably. I mean, again, I
that's what you want, right? You want this to be someone's favorite game,
you know? That's uh that that's the idea, I guess.
Uh okay,
that is the ideal.
That being said, I've definitely bought games that I have not played three times.
Oh.
Oh, certainly. But you're not trying to design those.
No.
Yeah.
Yeah. idea.
I will say we did try and keep it uh you can put it away and come back to it many, you know, many months in the future and pick up game two and that is totally fine. Like it's it's easy to set up. It's like there's there's stuff you write for to you remember all of the stuff. So like it is I think very accessible. Uh, and I say accessible in that it is still a hour and a half game that you have to play three times and that is that can literally only be so accessible.
So it is a significant uh addition to time.
Well, no. So I mean it is in the fact that you have to play three games, right?
Well, from a like how long does each game take? It's like five 10 minutes longer. Like it really doesn't.
Okay. So it's not a huge Okay. What about
I would say hive actually adds more
to there's like it's again it doesn't really add that much like we we talk back to like the the way the apiary was designed is like
it's a free action you do once per round and all you do is write down a number
in a box like it doesn't take that long. The thing that takes longer is thinking
some of the upgrades well also that and then also some of the upgrades once you have them they lead to you getting more stuff.
Yeah. And if you get more stuff, then you have to think about where to put it and then that's going to take you a little bit of time, right? Um, but I would say that that is actually more a part of Hive. Like I would say that I think the base time to play seller for one game and Hive to play one game, Hive is probably slightly long. Not like we're talking like 5 10 minutes, but like a little bit.
So if somebody has a big aversion to very long experiences, this isn't necessarily going to disqualify them on either of these expansions. No, unless they hate campaign stuff. Like if you don't if you don't want to play a three game sequence. Like some people just don't want to do that. I I personally would, but like Oh, yeah.
Some people may be like, I just want every time to just be the one time. I only ever play it with a big group, you know, and I'm not going to get that big group back together again.
Um,
yeah, sure. Then that would make totally sense. I'm not a big campaign game guy, but like I have never experienced anything quite like finishing up our very first play test of 10 seller game one. Like I was just like this is something different. Like the next game of 10 I am so excited about. Like I have made such plans. Like I am like I just got done playing an hour and a half play test and like I want to run it back right now in a way that I've like never experienced in a board game before
and we and we did that we did it multiple times where we we finished a game and then we were like you want to just go again.
I think 10 already for you. So saying that about the threeame campaign is really saying something.
Yes. Yeah.
Um, and then I mean the other thing that I've felt frequently is that when you place 10 seller a lot and then you go play base 10 or hive, you're like, man, where's my stuff? Like I I'm starting round one and I got no stuff. I want all this stuff.
Yeah. I'm wondering if this actually is the way that I will want to play and I won't want to play anything else
because I love the the idea of of progression over time in any game and then you to put it over multiple sessions especially that can be just picked up like the nature of what I do is I'm playing a lot of different games and you know like today with tend at first I was like oh like do I remember everything and then I just got into the flow state and it it went really really quickly. I just wonder if this is the only way I play it in the future. Well, if we go all the way back to the discussion about video games and board games, one of the things video games can do so effectively is like long-term goals, right?
Yeah. Oh, yeah.
Like come back the next day, get extra stuff, like retention stuff and freetoplay games, but also like long-term leveling and really, really long games. Something that board games have tried to emulate for a long time. I feel like this is the first time in 10 that you feel like the long-term goals are so satisfying. Whereas like previously your long-term goal essentially is your season 3 objective and those are just kind of like predefined things that are in your game.
Whereas here it's like I have made a long-term goal for myself which feels way more satisfying than if there was just one that was on the board and then I got there like two games later. It feels so satisfying and exciting in a way that you just can't do with a normal experience.
So is tend that is a that is a that's a Zack question more than anything.
Well, so you were real quick, Toby, you were quoted that I I think this was before the the previous campaign uh about like are you nervous about the campaign? Like no, I'm actually sad because I don't get to work on it anymore. I I'm done working on Tend. That wasn't true. So is that true? Is that something we're saying now
or will it keep going?
Same thing in the last time of I don't get to decide if it's over. They get to decide it's over. And largely the people who get to decide it's over are the people who are buying the game, right? Like if the game goes absolutely nuts, this is kind of exactly what you saw with Tend of like people loved the game, it sold out. People wanted more of it. People wanted more of the game and then also just more Tend. So we got expansions out quickly. like this is faster at like have you ever released an expansion this quickly after the launch of a game? I I don't know, but it's very fast considering when the game came out.
Yeah. I don't know. We're we're not that company, so it's like there's not that much. Uh
I don't know. You But you put out more games than most in your in your your short time frame.
Yeah. Yeah. No, it it I think it is it is fairly fast. Um, but also like we there uh yeah, I'm trying to think of how much to share, but it will be it'll become very clear on the campaign that we have more expansions planned for the future.
Well, this will I'm going to launch this on campaign day. Maybe Zach, maybe Zach had me a little a little behind the curtain is that
when we first when he first said we want 10 expansions, you said, "Bring me three expansions in a standalone." And I made three expansions in a standalone. And as you see right here, there's only two expansions. And guess what? We didn't stop there. Once two expansions got made, I there's plans for multiple other expansions that are not just like
like a little plan. Like one of them has been played. Like there things exist. It doesn't mean that they will ever actually come out, but like we had some cool ideas and we ended up cutting back what we were doing for this one because like
they asked me to make small expansions. I can't make small stuff. I don't that's not how I work. Like I got to make I got to have meat on the bone for me to really care about it. So all the things I made were too big to be like a little tiny expansion packin with something. So like you know
is it more hivesized stuff or more seller size stuff? Like what's the
Yeah.
Okay.
I think both. Yeah. Yeah. I think I got
We got both.
Yeah. Yeah. From from a um product decision standpoint, uh we had three expansions to work with. um played them all, love them all. Uh and I the reason why we said three is uh for those who might not be familiar, we we've done expansions in the past and we we have like Tribunal, which is a a campaign that we did for Veiled Fate. That is a three expansion box. Uh and and some of them are pretty small, some of them are kind of big. But the main difference here actually is that they can all be played all at once. and they actually I think function quite well in veiled fate all at once. Uh and so there's little modules you can pick off. You can kind of piece meal them, learn them over time. Uh and that's kind of maybe a route we could have taken for 10, but that was just wasn't it. And I loved each one of these that I actually came back um to the rest of the team and I was like, I actually think we should cut this to one expansion right now. I think these both of these expansions are good enough to have their own moment. Uh, and we should give them their own moment because they are and and we don't think you you you should not play them together. They're not meant to be played together. Uh, and then uh the the team had a lot of great feedback on that. I think Austin was the champion of this this idea where it was like look seller is going to be a lot for some people, right? Like some people are like this is too too much for me. Threeame commitment is too much. But Hive is this
perfect like anyone can get on board with Hive and we want someone to be able to have something to come to this this new launch and engage with it as like a uh okay cool like Hive is the logical next step. It's like just a oneoff. It's a way to add flavor. Um and more than just flavor, right? But it's it's it's a way to just like kind of change the core experience of Tend and then then seller and then the other expansion that is basically done like just totally change the game in a huge way. Uh and so like uh so I think at the moment the thinking is like we have this moment and then a future campaign would have like another hive like and then another seller like where it's like one is like a great like this is you know changes tend
in a big way but it's still like a oneoff game. Maybe it doesn't like
not something you would combine with Hive
another separate module as a alternative.
Yeah. It's like I think I think the problem is just
it's just played Hive. I'm sorry. I I can't remember if you played Hive.
No, I haven't.
If you once you play Hive like I
I'm not asking for it to be combined. I'm just
No, no, no. I think it's like if you play Hive, you will just be like, "Yeah, no. This does not need more. like this is plenty. This is plenty. I do not want more. Uh so like but I it is funny because a lot of people are asking that. Like so many people are like, "Oh, can we play them both together?" And I'm just like I think as soon as you play one of them, you'll be you will not ask that.
You're like, "Oh, no. I'm good."
Yeah.
So, well, what's the player experience that's missing? It sounds like these two expansions are giving new experiences to players. Is there an is there an experience missing that you want to deliver?
I mean, yeah. on the other expansion.
I tried it. I tried. Folks,
there there is a an experience that uh is fairly radical that is missing that would not appeal to everyone
that uh that we have planned for.
Um and then also
just tell me it's going to be more of the same. Don't worry about it. You'll want it because you'll be bored of the other stuff. Like
there is I also I have some really cool ideas. is I think for the next Hive style expansion where it's like it's not like a dramatic shift. It's not like a crazy amount of stuff, but it's like looking at the tools we have and a way to apply them slightly differently of like the idea I have for that one. I mean, we'll see where it ends up because it hasn't that one has been less developed. That one maybe could be integrated with another expansion, maybe. But we'll see. It it really depends on where it gets to, right? It's like the more cognitive load and the more table space it takes up are two of the like the large considerations for like should these things be played together.
And and I will say since you're saying this is launching on on campaign day. Uh so at this point you will see that there is a tier that you can back the game at that uh basically has room for base game 10 the two expansions we have now and a box of add-ons and then two other expansions. And so there will be a box set of what we have currently plus another campaigns worth of two expansions. Uh and that will all that all fits in this we which I don't know what the name of it right now is going to be. our our temp name is terrible. Uh what do we the box of holding is what we're calling it right now. It won't be called that on the campaign, but some some kind of big box solution. Um and then who who knows what happens after that. But we've even talked internally and I can't remember we talked about this Toby, but I also think there's a world where like after that there's also like tend to like it's like the winter version or like a different planet or something like that. There's just like the the formula of the game. Like I feel like I if I lock Toby in a room, he could give me like a new version of Tend in like a day probably with like totally different mechanics for every single module that still feels like Tend. We could bring in Kelly again who's this amazing artist and she could come up with a whole new world. And
can you add a Rondell?
People want it.
Yeah, sure.
Why not? Oh,
no. Rondell. Yeah, you got to draw the line somewhere.
We can add it initially. Yes. Yes. And then cut it. Yeah,
we'll cut it when Austin's on vacation.
So, you said something interesting. You are building tend a coffin on this uh on this this campaign.
That's what they that's what some publishers would call a big box. Meaning, it's only going to have in this iteration another two expansions ever. Period.
Probably.
I I don't know if I'd go on.
People would be pissed coffin
if Well, no. That's what I I I think I was talking to someone at Leader and I wanted a root big box like you mean a coffin like oh I guess I I don't want it to die but yeah
that that's a problem that's a problem for like three four years from now u me to solve but right now this fits this takes up a call spot right
oh and and so like if you if you want if we wanted to go bigger than that then we're going to have other problems right just just from like the limits of physics Like you're talking 10 is going to have to expand into multiple of those spots. I know that's a big big
People would not like that.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So like that is the limits of space that we have uh for whatever this big box is
but
the so far the the footprint in the box of the 10
box expansions is not insane. Like the amount of stuff that is in physically in the box is not so much that like if someday down the line there were more that came out, you could maybe combine two into one box if you had to.
It's It's getting tight in there, Toby. We've been We actually
Okay. Well, I don't know what they're doing by
We We didn't We didn't add stuff. The The box has actually got skinnier. So, the prototype boxes uh are it's a little bit skinnier because in order to fit
four expansions, an add-ons box and the base box, they had to get skinnier. And we had some room, right? Like usually our prototype boxes are are a a best estimate, our best estimate at uh what we think it will be. Uh so, we actually made them a little bit skinnier. Um, but it's also like it's it's it's been a real challenge to like figure this thing out and think back back make sure past backers get something great that works for them and future backers and future plans all work out. It's it's a huge huge puzzle uh shipping logistics. It's insane.
Well, originally you probably didn't have the ambition that you do now. Even though you know you we already talked about the campaign expectations and everything like you couldn't have imagined necessarily where it was going or did you from the very beginning?
No, I mean I don't know what Toby thinks. Like I always believe so wholeheartedly in everything that we put out like like I say we're trying to make other people's favorite games. Like that's kind of true. We're trying to make my favorite games. Like that's what we're that's like like every every game we put out I'm just like man I love this game so much. It's my new favorite thing. And so like I always believe in it and then I hedge because it's also my business and my livelihood. So I'm like maybe it won't do as well. But like like I'm always like I I wouldn't put it out there if I didn't think it could crush because I love it. Um and so I in in in one sense I'm always like I that's always the hope. That's always the dream is like people are going to connect with it. Um but but also like I I I we us as a business have never experienced this like like people I think were like at least they were cautious I think is the the they were cautiously optimistic about tent. I think people were like oh this is cool.
Um and then they got it and then it started to to to like kind of take off and people loved it and and the sales grew. Um and that's a a new experience. We're we're experiencing that a little bit with Realm as well too. Like I think people are like the love for that is really growing in a fun way.
That's awesome.
Thank you. Thank you. Um and so like I would love for that trend to continue. I would you know the the long tail is like what we're hoping for on all these games.
That's what most people I talk talk to publishers all the time on this stuff and it's like the the big the nut you want to crack is how to get attention post delivery. That's
that is the diamond that everyone is trying to unearth. And to have that here, it's almost so it's it is it's way better than cracking $2 million on a on a uh campaign and then nobody care about it afterwards, right? Like this is this is the dream.
Yeah. And not to say that we that hasn't been the case. Like I think all of our games people we were lucky enough that people care about it long term, but um I I think that I hope Tend continues to grow and and be, you know, continues to snowball um as people get into it. I think it really speaks to just the depth of the gameplay that that Toby and and our team have have put into it. I think it's just it really rewards that repeat play and I think that that is really helping it find its its audience and continue to grow
on those [snorts] unnamed expansions. Are there any more scratchers? That's the only thing I really care about or comp uh yeah there are. One of them, one of them, one of them is planned to have it's not it's not this is the one that's not fully fleshed out,
but one of them is largely the idea to me was what if we took the scratch or new and interesting direction like secret hidden stuff that you're trying to find or anything like that?
Who knows? There could be all kinds of stuff. Who knows what could be
a scratcher? I have a a funny quote from somebody. Playing 10 literally made me have a midlife board game crisis when I realized I was a grown ass adult scratching off lotto tickets for wood in my free time.
Yeah, I love it. Great.
I love that.
All right, gentlemen. We hit it. This we're we're about at two hours. I wanted to make this an hour, I think, on the email and you guys talked too long, so it's not my fault. It's yours.
Yeah, it's our fault.
Thank you very much for coming on. Zach, you're I think the only return guest on the Board Game Secret Show. Thank you for doing that.
I will come back anytime. You are such a wonderful host. I love your questions. Love what you do. So, thank you for having us.
Always a delight.
Toby, you talked way more than I thought. You You're the one that really made this go along and I think it became an awesome um episode for that. So, thank you for being so forthright and open and and uh chatting with me.
I am a talker. I'm happy to talk anytime, anywhere, to anyone. Uh, and it's always great to see Zach. Always great to hang out with my buddy. And then great to meet you. This has been super fun.
Awesome. Gentlemen, have a great evening and uh, we'll talk again.
Yeah. Thank you. Appreciate it.
Bye.