Emerald Flame: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over the Emerald Flame. This is one of the uh post curious big box narrative puzzle games. And I'm going to go ahead and preface this uh discussion by saying that I definitely think that this box of uh this puzzle game is certainly for a lot of people. Uh however, for me, I found it unbearable. This was not in my wheelhouse of this type of uh genre at all, which is kind of a shame because I did another one of theirs, their smallbox one, um the light in the mist, and found that one to be completely enjoyable. this type of um puzzle genre of board games um is very very swingy in my book because you whenever you're designing puzzles you have to one make them extremely creative and fun and that's all subjective. It's all just based off how people's brains work and some puzzles are going to be really, you know, right up someone's alley and some just completely aren't. And that's something, you know, going into, you know, a game like this. Exit, unlock, the hunt a killer, uh, you know, series thing. This, there's definitely just going to be puzzles that are like, this doesn't work for me. And I therefore,
I'm not enjoying it or oh man, this one was really creative. It clicked. And that's just how puzzles are, you know, like if you if it if it makes sense to you or you're able to work it out and have it and and solve it, then you're having a good time. And I mean, many of the unlocks have that of like this is just isn't making sense to me, therefore I'm not having fun. Uh but then you just have those. The light in the mist, the other one had a lot of really good creative puzzles. Some were very simple, some were more challenging, some were just, you know, extremely left field. You had a wide variety and that made it worth it. Um, unfortunately for the Emerald Flame, um, I found every single puzzle completely unbearable to go through every single one of them. Now, they say in the rules rules um that you're going to have a wide v uh a v variety of difficulty. Um and by wide variety it means oh you might kind of know where to begin. Um others you just have no clue. And I think the issue that I mainly have with this, well, there's there's a lot actually, but I found every single puzzle homework. Like there wasn't ever one that we came across that was like, "Oh, this one's fun. Oh, this one's
challenging. Oh, this one's creative." Every single one of them boil. I mean, literally, a lot of them were kind of repetitive in how you went about it. It's like, "Oh, find the comparison between these flowers." And I'm not going to spoil any of the puzzles, but it's like, oh, find the direction that all of these point. Oh, okay. Now, start measuring. It's it was very very analytical. And whenever you're talking about this being like a narrative puzzle adventure, you would expect it to kind of be in the sense of your puzzles are part of that nar narration. And maybe that's just something that I had in my head going going into it because I had just done their light in the mist and their light in the mist was very narrative focused on like boom every puzzle was like its own isolated thing and or the narrative element of the unlock games. And here basically you would read a sheet of of nonsense of whatever like of just basically text that just was kind of whatever. Um it almost felt like it was a business memo and that and then you were just flooded with just papers of stuff. And I've done these before um primarily with the hunt a killer and those I've come to realize that those types of puzzle games or those types of deductionesque games I just don't really enjoy. I like
my puzzle games to be a lot more linear focused where it's like I can isolate and segment each puzzle and not have to worry about a lot of the components. And here it's just like, oh, okay, we're in part two. let's open it up and we're just flooded with eight sheets of of of puzzles and then you have to parse out what goes with what and you're not quite sure what if this goes with that and it just feels like every single puzzle is just designed to drain hours of your time and for a lot of people they will love that. they will think that that's the most fun thing in the world. After solving like one puzzle, uh like in in like part one, for example, it's like after solving one puzzle, it's like, oh, I immediately don't want to do any of the other ones. It it it's not like, oh, okay, yeah, that one was rough. Didn't really work, but we got it. Awesome. Let's see what the next one is. Oh, this one looks fun. Nope. it was immediately look at the sheet and just stare at it and know that you're going to have to start doing some equation to figure out the answer. And it all always just boils down to one word. And then they incorporate some tech which is completely unneeded. Uh and actually some of the uh tech is misleading for some of the puzzles which is extremely frustrating. But like whenever you put in your answer, it it's supposed to be like this chat room element and it's not incorporated really well at all. Like
whenever you talk about a narrative puzzle adventure, you would think the narrative part would have a huge portion of it. Like you would have some major story being told throughout the entire uh game that then pulls in puzzles. Not really. It's like, "Oh, hey, there's this girl that you kind of have a chat blog with." And then she just every single one you just put in the answer. It's like, "Here's the answer." And she's like, "Ah, cool. You found it. Good work. Anything else?" Nope. How are you? It's like it just you get nothing out of it. And so then you just put in the the three answers and then cuz each each part has like okay you find these three answers then you do like the big puzzle which is just completely repetitive. Um but then you put in three answers then you do the big puzzle and she's like all right cool let me know when you get the next package and it but you already have all the packages. So, I will say this the best comparison I can have with this is to the Hunter Killer where you get uh a box in the mail each time and it just has a bunch of stuff for you to try and solve, but each month you had to find one answer. Like the Hunter Killer, which I have a series of on my channel, is like, oh, today you're trying to figure out who a a witness is or something. and and that was like that month's goal, but then you had to wait a whole month, even though you could expedite the next part. But if you did it regularly, you had to wait a whole
month, then come in and then you just have to try and recall everything that you did from two months ago. Luckily, you have everything here. You don't have to wait. You have all parts and the the would let me know when you get the next package is just part of the theme. Um, and so the narration I absolutely didn't give a [ __ ] about. Um, there was no type of of overarching story. It feels very escape roomesque, but again with no direction or rhyme or reason on what you're really doing with the puzzles except just to solve a puzzle. So that part of it was just unnecessary. And then the second part is like I said every single puzzle just just felt so overly complex for the sake of being complex. And I know whenever I hate doing these kinds of discussions cuz then it's like oh well maybe you're just stupid. It's like maybe maybe I am because none of these and we solved uh a a large portion of them without looking at at hints. The only time we went to look at at like the hints was to verify if we were on the right path.
Um but they were just so unfun even figuring out oh hey we are on the right path and then okay we got the answer there was no sense of satisfaction after that. It felt like it almost felt like you were doing this insanely difficult test in school. Um, except you don't really get the satisfaction of getting a good grade. Like it's kind of like, ah, all right. I guess I I guess I did that. I like It's like, uh, teacher, did you know, did I get an A? Oh, I don't tell my students their grades. Um, but you're doing all right. It's like, okay, thanks for that. like one of the ones that um that we we like because you you are isolated a little bit with each puzzle, but you're just overloaded. So, it becomes extremely overwhelming as soon as you open up a uh a container, but then you're like, "Okay, the opening letter says that the this is what we're looking for." So, I believe this is what this sheet goes to. This is what these go to, and this is what these go to. And then you have all these components for something else at the end.
And then you figure it out and it gets you your word. You tell the girl in the chat room what it is. She gives you a cool a thumbs up emoji and then you just move on. There's no sense of like each puzzle connecting to the next, which would be cool. Like it again, if it's supposed to be a narrative puzzle adventure, it would be cool if part of the narration like, hey, you come across a door that has this this element um this combination lock or whatever you might need to get past the door. And then you put that in. And then it was this this whole really cool website narrative like kind of a choose your own adventure but not not like a like a textbased adventure that like pulls you along with it. Um and then the puzzles hit you. It'd be awesome if it was just they they piece meal out the puzzles to you so that it felt more organic and this just isn't that at all. And that might be my own set of expectations, not necessarily the game's fault, but I just don't enjoy puzzle games like that. I'm all for a challenge, but whenever it's like you have to do this algorithm to figure out a word and then the next puzzle is a logic puzzle and this is what you set to do in a night and it's immediately just overwhelming and exhausting. You're just like, I just want to go to bed. Um, and they're long. I mean, like it says 6
hours for I think like a 70. I mean, to be fair, for a puzzle game, it is extremely expensive. Like, you're like, you're and I usually don't bring price into it, but I I have to because I am not happy with the product. So, I'm like, okay, what did my money really go to? They do give you a few gimmick items. Um, some don't even actually really work like the way they I felt like they originally intended. Uh, there I there are ways to make it work. Like I guess small spoiler, but a good example is the in the very in part one, you get an item that is supposed to change color and the way it's read to you as if you're supposed to do something with what you have on your person except it just doesn't work. Uh, so then you have like the only way I was able to get it to work was I had to go get something at in my house to actually get it. And I mean that was kind of neat. Um, but then that just kind of led to it's like, okay, well this one's done and now we have to solve the rest of rest of the stuff. So really, at the end of the day, I the narrative is is really as deep as what what the exhausted 16-year-old reads to you at the start of an escape room. And then the puzzles, while in depth, the puzzles are in depth, um, I just found
none of them fun. Like there wasn't ever a single one. There was no wide variety here of okay, just didn't like that one. That one didn't work for me. The ones that did work for me, I did not enjoy. And the ones that uh didn't work for me, I still didn't enjoy. Even the ones that didn't work for me in The Light in the Mist or any of the other escape room style puzzle games that I've uh that I've played, even if I didn't know how to solve it, but I found out the answer, some of them I'd be like, "Okay, that's who the [ __ ] is figuring that out?" like that's just being uh like complex for the sake of being complex. Um but some would be like oh man that's clever. I would have never never would have thought of that but ah I can appreciate that here whenever we would be stumped on something and you know be like we have no idea how to solve this one. And we would go through it and be like okay that's obscene like who is this for this? I I I don't know. I don't know who this is for, but it's definitely not for me. I will say, and this also kind of follows a little bit of what the Exit series does, which I've definitely completely grown out of.
I don't like puzzle games that make you write or cut up components because if you're wrong, you have now [ __ ] yourself out of trying to solve the puzzle. happened many times in the Exit series because they ran out of ideas. So, they had to really start stretching the imagination. And if you are wrong and you're cutting something up and you're like, "Oh, whoops. Either I wasn't supposed to cut up or I wasn't supposed to cut that up or we still didn't figure out the puzzle and now we're done." The difference is the exit games are $15 or they were last time I played them. here. If you're cutting something up and you're trying to figure it out and you messed up, it's like, okay, well, I guess that's done. Better just get the solution uh for the hint. However, a positive note on that element is the fact that this game does come with its own refill kit and it tells you it's kind it's not a separate thing you have to get. Um, it replaces uh items that you might have needed to consume. Um, and any any of the sheets you needed to ride on or any of the sheets you needed to come up uh cut up, it does come with. So, that's nice. It's it at least they had the the foresight to be like, "Okay, we know you spent, you know, so much money on this." Each game of theirs seems to come with like a like two replays or one replay, two plays total, and I commend them for
that. Um, and that's why that's what makes this kind of discussion so weird is because it's not that their puzzles are unsolvable because otherwise this would be getting a one if it's like you can't even solve it. This doesn't they are all solvable. It's just that be prepared to spend probably an hour on each puzzle and each part comes with, you know, that's just what it feels like. And it just it it was exhausting every single time. Um and and yeah, and the narrative element that I was hoping to get kind of like like I was hoping to get kind of the the narrative element that uh um a hunted killer or an unlock brings to the brings to the table, but it wasn't that. Uh, I know their next one that's supposed to be a sequel to this one, the Emerald something, it was on their it's crowd or it was crowdfunded recently. Um, I think that one actually has more of a story to it. This one it it it like it technically does have a story to it, but I find it just so generic. Um, anyway, trying to think if there's anything else.
Uh, I mean, not really without actually going into detail on any of the any of the puzzles, which I'm not going to do because that would just be spoilers. Um, oh god, what do I even give this on a scale of 1 to 10? I mean, I had a bad time from off rip. Like I forced myself to play through this just to like I was like ah you know maybe the puzzles will get better and they didn't like I I didn't I I was frequently not having a good time. Um, but it's like do I give it a number based off of like my own personal experience because of just like which would be like around a four to five because I just really didn't enjoy anything here. But in terms of like who this would be for, like for me personally, this is like a four to five. So 4.5. But like for people who this is made for, this would be like an eight to a nine. I think I think they could really really dive into it. Um maybe this is one of those games where you just play within a a large group of people and you divide and conquer and every or you look at all at one and everyone is chiming in. that I have I have a problem playing these games with
a large group of people because of the fact that if you're needing everyone's help, there's not enough things to go around. Not everyone can really look at it. So, you have to take turns. It's like, "Oh, okay. Here you could your turn to look at it." And then everyone's staring at it and then they're trying to figure it out and you want to help and try and figure it out with them, but then you really can't. So, then you're like, "Okay, I guess I'll look at a different puzzle." And so I've always kind of kept these games at like a threeplayer max. Um, but maybe maybe it just requires more heads or maybe it requires uh me to play with someone who is just like who who this is made for. But yeah, I I have stepped away from this style of um of puzzle games. And yeah, which is unfortunate because like I said, I like their light in the mist well enough. I was excited to try all their other ones, but if all their other ones are like this, I have absolutely no interest. Um but that's just me. like everything you might I I wish I could give you more details on the puzzles because that might help you figure out if this is for you if this is something that might be more up your alley. But I don't want to give away any spoilers. So yeah, I guess I guess that's it. Um well that's the Emerald Flame. Everyone let me know what you think of the game
in the comments below. Other than that, like comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever day it is for you.