The Light in the Mist Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About The Light in the Mist
Reviewers broadly agree that The Light in the Mist, published by Post Curious, is a polished puzzle experience built inside a tarot deck. The puzzles are the main reason players recommend it, while the story and the game's length divide opinion. Board Of It said the puzzles are great, with only about one in 22 feeling like a dud, and praised the production as high quality. Board Games UnLocked gave it a seven out of ten and called it a very solid puzzle game that it would pick over any Exit title, while still placing the Unlock series above it.
The sharpest disagreement concerns the narrative. Board Of It described the story as decent but not perfect, while The Board Game Garden found it immersive enough to make the game a favorite comfort pick for solo play. The Cardboard Herald went further, calling it one of the leaders in the narrative mystery puzzle genre. Pre-release coverage from John Goods Games framed the title as a communal, fully cooperative puzzle experience, and the channel was interested in the format before any play had taken place.
Core Mechanics That Define The Light in the Mist
Multi-Use Cards
The minor arcana cards are the game's central resource, and reviewers describe them as both its cleverest idea and its most confusing element. Each major arcana card carries a set of symbols that point to the minor arcana cards needed for its puzzle. Board Games UnLocked explained that some of those minor arcana cards are reused across several puzzles, so players must decide which icons belong to the puzzle in front of them. The reviewer admitted that early on the group would look at stray icons and hope they had nothing to do with the current puzzle, and said a cleaner design with one icon per card would have been easier to follow. The Cardboard Herald highlighted the same multi-use structure, describing the cards as being used in some unexpected ways that make each puzzle feel distinct.
Cooperative Play
The game is labeled for one to three players, but reviewers consistently recommend keeping the group small. Board Of It found that two players sitting on the same side of the table worked well, while a third player struggled to see the cards laid out in the middle, and the reviewers agreed that they could not imagine playing with more people. The Board Game Garden described the game as cooperative for one to four players, but noted that its puzzle format is where the solo experience shines. Players tackling the same story together must stay in sync, which is why Board Of It advised that anyone who wants the narrative should play solo.
The Light in the Mist Experience
A Cozy, Intimate Evening
Reviewers describe a quiet, personal session rather than a loud game night. Board Games UnLocked played it with a partner who enjoys tarot, and the reviewer said the pairing made it a great way to spend time together, even though the reviewer does not personally believe in tarot reading. The Board Game Garden called it a very cozy game to take as much time as needed. The mood is calm and contemplative, with a sense that the player is wandering through a foggy story at a comfortable pace.
Satisfaction Mixed With Friction
Puzzle play swings between the thrill of cracking a clever solution and the frustration of being stuck. Board Games UnLocked described a bell curve of quality, with a small number of puzzles that frustrated the group and many that felt good or great. The reviewer described the moment of checking a hint to confirm a path as satisfying, because it provided reassurance without giving away the answer. When a puzzle does not click, however, the experience can turn tedious quickly.
What Makes The Light in the Mist Stand Out
Puzzle Variety and Flexible Help
Reviewers consistently praise the way the game lets players choose how much help to take. Board Of It noted that the back of the rulebook lists which cards to use for each puzzle, that beginners can start with the suggested easier puzzles, and that a QR code leads to step-by-step hints. The same reviewers pointed out that players can check how many solutions a puzzle has, which saves time when none exist. Board Games UnLocked praised the hint system specifically because it asks questions rather than issuing commands.
Presentation and a Tarot Keepsake
Production is one of the most frequently mentioned strengths. Board Of It said everything in the box is high quality even though the components are limited, and Board Games UnLocked called the card art amazing. Players who finish the game receive a tarot deck they can keep, along with a companion book that explains how to read the cards. The Cardboard Herald described the visual presentation as unlike anything else in its genre, and The Board Game Garden called the cards stunning.
Potential Drawbacks
A Repetitive Story
The most consistent criticism concerns narrative variety. Board Of It said the story often makes the same point over and over. One puzzle has eight solutions, and each solution leads to a passage that makes nearly the same point, so the table lost interest after the second or third. The reviewers still considered the story a decent one, but they were clear that it is not a standout.
Long Puzzles and Uneven Clarity
With more than twenty puzzles, reviewers noted that a few take far longer than they should. Board Games UnLocked said that two or three puzzles were ridiculously long without being challenging, and that some hints did not clarify the solution at all. The reviewer also found that because every answer is a single word, the game's logic could feel repetitive by the final puzzle, which required a solution that did not match the intended method.
If You Enjoy The Light in the Mist
Players who enjoy The Light in the Mist's puzzle variety will find similar satisfaction in the Exit series and the Unlock series, which Board Games UnLocked uses as the benchmark for this style of game. Board Of It directly compared the game to Lost in the Shuffle, preferring it for offering more puzzles and an app that tracked clues for the player. Players who appreciate the book-driven narrative will recognize its structure from Sleeping Gods, which Board Games UnLocked referenced when describing numbered story passages. For a contrast in tone, The Dark Quarter was offered as an example of a more overtly mature story, showing how The Light in the Mist handles its darker themes with more restraint.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"So, the first question is, of course, how are the puzzles? Well, we're happy to report we think they're great. There was only about one in 22 that we both thought was a dud. And there's a lot of variety in the puzzle difficulty, complexity, and how many cards you need to solve it."
— Board Of It
"I think the hint system is actually really good. It doesn't flat out tell you, "Hey, look at this. Hey, do this." It will, but it will kind of ask a question."
— Board Games UnLocked
"The emotional highs of the storytelling and the visual presentation is unlike anything else I've seen. It is the most cohesive I've ever seen one of these games and it is in this beautiful small package that could be played in a few hours."
— The Cardboard Herald