TCbH Interviews Podcast # 110 - PAX Unplugged Big Ol Group Interview
Transcript
hey everyone this is some continuing coverage of packs unplugged 2018 which I had a tiller time I got to hang out with so many awesome people many of whom are actually on this podcast right here that you're about to listen to I did want to let you know that if it's your first time listening to the cardboard Herald typically we put a lot of effort in making some really high production good quality stuff especially the audio making sure that all the sound levels are great here well we had to record live in an Airbnb kitchen which I think it turned out awesome but I wanted to let you know that if you wanted to check out some of our other interviews they are definitely going to be more of what you are expecting out of a typical podcast that said this conversation went awesome we were all super exhausted on Saturday night after two days of doing all kinds of business at the convention but yeah I think this came out great I'm already looking forward to doing it again next year so with that out of the way here's our interview with Sean Epperson Nick and Carla cop Rob calmly and David Smith let's get to the show hello and welcome back to the cardboard Herald my chain stock of creative gamers and game creators I am doing yet more packs unplugged 2018 coverage seemingly endless amounts of coverage and I'm here
at the cardboard Herald HQ right next to the convention center with a host of awesome people to talk to so I guess I'm going to just say right up front this is kind of an open environment with people maybe coming and going and making a bunch of noise so you may hear some background stuff some echo some weird levels but I think you the listener and all of us can get through this just fine so to do some introductions I already said my name is Jack and I'm going to go around the table so with me to my left Nick up from weird direct games why and like seven other co-producing project slam sure you've signed on to between now and the last time that we talked Sean Debrecen from think 12 games and you are also doing things Beale and indeed I'm also here with the board game Alliance BJ's burgum Alliance podcast well this is awesome thank you guys so much for coming here for most of you this is actually at least the second time on the podcast Carla's been on like 20,000 times at this point but for David this is your first time officially on the podcast so we done talking forever on Twitter so I wanted to talk to you first and anyone else I want you to be able to jump in on this because David is doing a ton of play testing in the unpop
room today and how did that go today man it was fantastic I've been to the unplugged convention le three times and the foot traffic here was proportionately better than the unpublish like constantly people waiting to play tester games at one point we had 17 people standing around flicked and furious like waiting to play it or watch it the night was great you had two games here right yes yeah a flicked and furious is the dexterity combat racing game and then another one is a asymmetric cooperative two-player tower defense game called right now under siege okay and you haven't published anything yet right you're gearing up to publish both of these game is kind of seeing which of them is the most viable which ones all ready to go do you have an inkling of that now after the convention that's a tough one because flicked and furious the feedback is fantastic everyone has just been very positive about it and like I've had so many people say I want to buy this game I will buy this game but it is a big neoprene mat it is an abstract game to produce a lot of logistical issues we've netted a lot of quotes through a lot of manufacturers and so I'm leaning towards the tower defense because it'll be a little bit more traditional the game to produce and I've just seen lately that a
lot of dexterity games for your first or second game I've been very tough recep you know reception you know on Kickstarter right right and very tough yeah the next day it's a challenging thing to break into especially with the judgmental eyes of gamers out there now Nick Carla Sean do you guys remember what it was like before you had actually published games like what what did it feel like when you were on the precipice of actually getting something out there but you still didn't have the confidence of something already as proof that you could make it I just didn't know I was so nervous like even like getting to launch day it was like well anyone back I don't know when we find how long will it take like there's all these questions and like I don't think I slept for maybe a week before the Kickstarter do you sleep before Kickstarter's now
was like the most calm but like I still like only slept like six hours I like I usually like when I'm not in Kickstarter I need like eight or nine hours to function as a like a regular human but yeah that's the most I've gotten and that was Kickstarter for so Sean how about you have you exclusively published things via Kickstarter currently yes okay that's we're looking at doing some standard publishing in the future coming projects but the four think Martin four and a half things that we've done by Kickstarter have been all Kickstarter which makes sense right so the first thing we did actually didn't fund and yeah that first time you're like terrified and then you know things start going and then we kind of hit this brick wall them things not happening and that was that was like a gut punch man it was like oh god this didn't go the way I thought it was going to go so all we did was just reach out to all the backers you know we cancelled the project and then reject everybody and just ask them you know what were your concerns what did you not like what did you think we could have done better and then take that feedback and process it and try and do something a little bit different so I tend to be a very optimistic person and so I'm very curious like at what point did you like decide to cancel or like when were you thinking strategically like I would be geared towards all right there's still hope there's still something to grass on
here I bet we're gonna get this huge surge at the end because I've talked in this person in that prison there are certain metrics that you couldn't watch and after about having about two weeks in we realized yeah and we just don't have the track and we're not going to happen so realistically we need to have that come to reality moment like yep okay this isn't going to be successful so let's cancel it so it doesn't look like it funded or didn't fund right and then just you know figure out what we do next and the next one actually was very successful so we did take a lot of that feedback back and and the biggest thing we had for people was that they didn't know who we were so we didn't have any trust with anyone and that the product price point was higher than what they felt as someone that was new could actually complete like they didn't think we'd actually be able to deliver the game we said we were going to deliver like okay those are valid things so let's take a smaller game and try and knock it out of the park quality wise you know get things out on time and you know send people their stuff so they know like yes they can do fine means they can do things that look good and build up that trust that's been my main concern I'm ain't concerned with flicks and fears I've talked to people I know what cost I know it's gonna it's MSRP should be I know what people want to pay I've asked a hundred people what you're willing to pay for this game and I haven't that idea but my fear has been like I'm new you know I know I know I'm new at this and for a first game being a large four foot by two and a half foot neoprene Mac dexterity game that's yeah
that's that's why I would want to do another game first yeah that would be a tough first game I think that's my perception based I listen to a lot of podcasts and read a lot of articles I mean hearing that from you is exactly why I'm like I probably should do this other game first well it was a small price point I think that so our initial one was a $10 buy-in so we were like okay if they don't deliver what they said they're going to deliver I'm out $10 whatever ransom that huge of a risk versus the first way we did that didn't find was $40 so that's a much bigger investment so yeah make sense yeah I'd also agreed to like go the small room cuz my first one ten dollars like as Sean said sorry like I was thinking BJ people are like ten dollars that's okay to lose yeah well I think the the overcoming the problem of visibility and trust that people may have is a great way to start out with small things that are easier projects and I think that's true in podcasting too like for me I didn't start out
immediately contacting the the biggest names in the industry saying yo biggest name in the industry Carla cop will you come on to my show I started with like yo hey friend of my group who publishes print and play games I've been doing this podcasts about writing reviews which you would come on and just talk about like making print and play games and I could use that to say I've done an interview and then I could use that to talk to other people in the industry of I have competently done an interview can I do something that is with someone else and that led from one thing to another and I think that could be said that it's the same trajectory with publishing one game that's small and then moving on to bigger things that are perhaps more risky well there's another thing there that if you're doing something smaller there's a lot of stuff you you know but then there's a lot of stuff that you don't know that you don't know and all those sub writers didn't come in if you're doing a smaller game it's easier to kind of weather all that craziness it's gonna happen if you do a bigger project like you've got all the nightmare of that as well as all the stuff that you're not aware that's gonna be smack in the face a lot more risk proportionally I guess the side of the project the more risk copies yeah yeah like every project I've done there's been something that I missed or didn't understand that I would have to like paid for and do like penance you
know down the road it haunted me like you asked people questions and they give you answers but then you realize oh I raise that question in that manner like you know not everyone welcome especially when you're talking to Chinese manufacturers like you might think you're in you're asking the right question but you might not be find out the hard way it also definitely add 40 to 50 percent to any budget that you create for a Kickstarter project for all of those unknown unknowns yeah because we for every one of our projects we had come up with this budget and we ended up blowing it completely out of the water because of you forget tariffs or something happens something changes and it's just been insane to see all this new stuff that we keep learning about even with like our third project we're still learning things wait I thought board games were the most lucrative business and you were just pocketing all that stuff going to you being a Kickstarter it's like what like 90% profits right yeah the padding thing that you mentioned that's a good idea and in the vein of padding things pad your schedule as well like whatever time you think you're gonna have I'd like three to six months on top of that so what I do is you take every single step like oh you have to get graphic design done you have to finish illustration like okay what's the longest that could possibly take what's the longest that
each step could possibly take what if you know Chinese New Year that's that adds a monthly because everything is like a range of times and it could be the entire time and then he had three months to that well you know one of the things that I wanted to spend some time talking about is that we went to this convention last year the cardboard Herald and now Rob Robert and also David who I should say for full disclosure is sleeping in the same environment as us what happens after everyone else leaves this is No so the thing I wanted to bring up is that this is definitely a bigger convention this year there are more exhibitors there's more attendees there's more security and I imagine that came with its own concerns I'd like to hear from the from the publisher perspective of that but I also want to hear from Rob who is with me last year do you feel like there's a different vibe this year or have you noticed any substantial changes or it has it impacted your view on the Continental right there are so
many more burgeoning designers and like every time I've gone in there it's been full tables with full people pretty much I've just been going in it's like perfect time see that but look how many people do you think are coming from the outside who are not part of the design community who are coming into the pub maybe for the first time to play test games well I don't know that I could speak to that but I imagine that David definitely him yeah I mean they're really four different groups of people today that stop by my table he's like I haven't even been to a gaming convention before not alone an unpublished I'm envisioning new people yeah yeah I think that like a lot of the guests not though like have gone into the exhibit hall walked around the night all right so it's not like the exhibit hall which is like all right what are the most popular games this year and have to hit all of them before the before there also I think for the general audience not the hardcore board gamer not the design
community I think for the general audience who may be coming because this is the Penny Arcade Expo and it's like oh I've read that comic when I was in high school you know I'll go to that this is all going to be about that comic right I'm plugged I don't know what that means but sure I'll go and then they end up coming here there's still a an aura of mystique surrounding the idea of like this is this is a board game and development are you kidding me it would and I know for all of us at the table we're like yeah everyone has a board game and development yeah my grandma has a board game of development right now but I think that for the general audience that that's still like wow I'm getting to see behind the curtains on what's going to be the next big thing are you guys the the published publishers alright are you guys working on any designs are you doing anything in the unpop I'm not so the UNPO groom is open from like what ten to seven and the six so we do have some advocates for us at Josh Mills yeah we still we hire designers are in there unpublish the up-and-coming games playtesting ringing out all of the the things so big easy bus Kings have been in there and I know Kevin's been in there with tiny animal Tony so yes we love on pubs as a publisher
yeah well I know that last year that I saw you like hop right in there with fire in the library and I felt like I saw a million different Twitter responses from several different conventions that felt like all happening at the same time of like Carla is somehow also here and over there showing off fire in the library at the same time it was quite spectacular it was amazing so this year you are primarily at a booth right oh yeah like the booth has been non-stop people the entire time like I got so excited today because like somebody showed up early so I got to go to the bathroom
so let me say last year where we were where where Carla was and I were we were in the unplug him 24/7 just like David this year we have a 10 by 20 booth because we realized that 10 by 10 booth was way too small at origins and so it's been amazing we've had people at the booth almost the entire convention we've had fire a game a fire in the library and a game of stellar leap or demoing and we've had people at those tables the entire convention even though we're art all the way in like the side the absolute side of boom it's a not a super optimal location but we've had traffic the entire time so I really feel like pax unplugs has grown from last year it kind of debuted at as a awesome convention I heard somebody say it's the number three board game convention to go to in the United States behind Gen Con and origins I they might pass one of those for next year it's growing so much I think when things that makes Paxson plug a better board game convention is that it's very much focused on the participants the players that are going there whereas those other bigger cons they kind of nickel and dime you want a lot of different things and it's not as conducive to playing necessarily where this is all about the play like you can go to the booths and play you can go to the vet the new hotness games that are on the tables that are sometimes being taught by people you can play those they've got them set up for you just
read the rules and sit down with your friends you go check things up from the library you go ahead love the free game library yes Brina it is you a $2.00 per at origins like want that well in origins do you have to play to go to the events you have to play to get into the library area like there's not a lot of like tables available if you just want to play a game that you actually buy yeah well it seems like they also took into consideration a lot of things that were concerns or complaints last year I think that they streamlined their lending library a lot better this year I think they doubled the unpublished
Penny Arcade as an organization or PACs as an organization cares very much about fostering relationships and and showcasing indie developers doing their thing and also I think that this hobby is unique among many other hobbies and how tightly knit all of the design and publishing community is and it seems like this con as much as it is for just the the person who's wanting to go to play games it's also facilitating a platform for publishers and designers to actually get some work done but that may be me just looking on the outside of that no it's very much to I mean it's just a whole synergy thing right so if you have an event that is really conducive to people coming to play games and you're a publisher then that means people are picking up your games and going to play them and then people see other people playing those games and that's great and you know being let check things out then you're just becoming more aware of everything you know it's everybody kind of coming together to help each other be more successful and do the things they want to do and I really like what VJ / Sean said I like how you said it exactly it's Max's focused on the gamers and it really is it's here for them you don't nickel and dime everybody and I really think origins and Gen Con can learn something from what pax has done and I wouldn't be surprised if next to your
pax unplugged gets close to or Beats origins or Gen Con because of that not everybody I looked around at the gaming room if everybody was just so happy playing games it's just everybody was like in boom it wasn't even like loud because people were just like in the games and it was massive you know like at first I was like oh and foerster they're gonna like be like origins where their origins was always like oh we could see some cardboard somewhere you better fix that all the time but here the PAC's enforcers are there to help you like I had um I think the the people at the Dragoon booth like they needed some help in their enforcer like went to target and got them things like I was talking to another enforcer and he's like yeah I can just go get you lunch like we had this thing happened today where there was a child without a parent and they didn't have a phone or anything and I was like I don't know what to do in this situation but then I was like enforcer and I was like enforcer here's a child can you manage this and they did they just took control this situation and I didn't have to and it was just like yeah I feel so much better with all these enforcers like bad things won't happen like there won't be like a lot of people stealing games or like sexual harassment like there's enforcers there they're here for us to like feel safe yeah it's
a really a positive environment and it really allows people to enjoy their time here at the colony and it's just a really good vibe that's a lot of what we talked about last year when we did a similar podcast Atlas was just it's a real positive uplifting vibe personally for me from a very selfish perspective I love getting street food from my man Denis who is here in Philly and only in Philly so it is the best convention for me but also of any convention that I've gone to and this includes comic conventions this includes animations that this is the convention that I just see the most general joy and happiness out of people who feel like they have access to the things that they came here for in the first place and that's not only for people who are in the industry this is for people who want to go here to play games but you mentioned the enforcers and that you're you're so relieved that they're here Carla did any of you guys who are actually presenting things or publishing things or having booths that you're working on did you have any security concerns this year or issues that came out of security I know that as an attendee I dare not care consider myself a media person yeah media media okay I don't get to go to any cool
exhibitor line though when I'm going through security but it was really surprising at first that we were confronted with like metal detectors bag checks and also empty all your pockets I mean I'm from Alaska and so are the guys that came here with me and that's not something that I'm that familiar with outside of an airport you know our schools don't have bag checks or schools don't have metal detectors and I think it's a very good thing especially given the current climate and some things that have happened recently but was that security extended to you guys in the exhibition hall or you guys who are doing any other types of things at the con and did that cause any issues the only thing that it really caused an issue with was just getting in to the con so anyone that was an exhibitor had a little bit easier time getting in but as if you're coming in as a media and I was actually coming in his media it took me a lot longer to get in which is something that we're hoping to bring up to address and they've always been really good about listening to feedback and trying to make things better right so hopefully that's an issue that they can try and improve on but I love the fact that they're doing you know checks and the metal stuff because we're in a climate now well that's kind of a real thing we have to be thinking about and be aware of so that's really cool name they're really focused on safety yeah regarding them forces to they've been
fantastic this morning I mean I just have an attendee badge I came in this morning carrying a bag with my prototypes in it and one like I said a very large rolled-up neoprene the enforcers have you know in the morning before 10 o'clock there's everything's roped off you can't go in I couldn't get to the unpucker room is like 9:45 the enforcer just saw that I looked like a designer and so I got that thank you what was it the eat sleep play test or a t-shirt maybe that gave it away she said hey are you trying to get into unpop are you a designer was I guess yeah I just figured I couldn't get in there until 10 o'clock she said oh no come on in you know you can come in we're letting you all in even though it's you know roped off mm-hmm I have been attending bad she's just like she called me out and said hey can I help you you know get into the Ungaro that really stood out to me I wouldn't expect that in another convention that was really good the enforcers are all they say we donate their time their their payment is basically the badge and be able to be a part of the common and stuff like that and they get breaks and that sort of thing but they're incredible it's one of the coolest things for packs is having those people that was going to people you can be an attendee and those enforcers are there for you you can be a publisher at those unfortunately nobody you can be the media person they're there for you from what I can tell and I haven't been to many other paksas in fact I've been to eight packs and that was a plug and that was last year even though it's
right close to me in Alaska I mean I I think I said it recently but Juneau is essentially just northern Washington but as far as I can tell the enforcers like that for many people is kind of like a prestigious or or it's a badge of honor it's something that people do every year because they feel like they are contributing to their community the gamer community and participating in something that maybe gives them an outlet or a sense that they they are able to take part in and help other people to attend these things to exhibit at least things to develop things it's an access that they might not otherwise have and it's a really cool thing to see yeah I've got a couple friends and our enforcers and they look forward to it every year and and it really is a badge of honor like they really treat it as a serious thing like you know I'm gonna do this and I mean no really be that helpful person for people at the con right right well let's talk about what's causing everyone to lose sleep right now so III know that where I talked about some of the projects that David is working on is anyone else here like on the verge of working on something and you're preparing for it alongside working on convention stuff like this if you have any releases coming out soon I don't
think we're doing anything right we're just ready Sean oh yeah with Carla I just look at her and I'm like it's just wheels upon wheels and just Mecca Nations in motion and it's just constantly working I get exhausted just thinking about weird draft games and going like there's so many things but it doesn't stop there galactic Raptor like there's there's even things beyond that and then there's going to be more things because there's always going to be more things you know so so what's really eating at your time right now I mean but when I'm not in there I've been taking a lot of pitches to find like the future games for like 2020 I've been talking with a lot of people I actually got to talk with panda manufacturing today and I got them to start investigating seed paper because I might be making a game that is like well it's dexterity in a few like whoa all dexterity games have like that thing we're like oh you can do something bad and throw it away but this in this game I really wanted to be like kind of a legacy thing where if you're really bad at it you have to go take that card and like plant it outside and grow what was the genesis of this idea with Catherine's nipple who also did Nyctophobia yeah what what an amazingly
clever game that is like just whatever anyone's opinion on the the game as like something that you know is a strategy game or is it more of an experience or anything like that is incredibly clever and it's also a very noble idea the genesis of how that game came about yeah pure amazing like everyone should meet her she's here at the cons but um this game it was about nature and trees and like I really loved green stuff and like board games aren't necessarily green because they are made of trees but I was like okay how can I make this game even cooler than it is I was like looking up like different kinds of paper and stuff and I found seed paper and I was like whoa but then like as a publisher I get all these people coming up to me and being like hey send us money pay us to do things but panda was like hey we're here and I'm like panda you're expensive and they're like but if you have anything weird and I was like okay yeah that's kind of built into your name right off the bat I mean what are you and just like Carla we've got a ton of stuff in the hopper for sniffing into
2020 the current one that's coming up the earliest is dinosaurs not assembled DNA this was a game that was designed by the son of one of the designers that's working with daily magic games and the the concept was one that was really captivated by and so we did some play testing with it at anyone's PAX West about a year or two ago and adults were really enjoying it and it's kind of a quick family sort of style game where you're basically going out and getting getting bones as an archaeologist and you're using those bones too as a recipe to create these dinosaurs and you're putting the dinosaurs in this museum now the thing that's gonna be a little different for us is we're taking that next step is that we're making actual boards and player boards and custom meatballs so we're doing a couple new things with games that we haven't done before so it's all a learning process again for us which I'm kind of excited about and the art is adorable oh my god we've got this amazing artist that's so fantastic it looks really good I've been seeing the pictures it looks awesome so cute it's amazing so yeah I'm really excited about that that's gonna be in the spring we've got ice of dragons coming up in the fall I've got several other things that we're working on with a couple different designers so yeah kinds of stuff so I want to capture this
moment this is Saturday evening there's been two days of the con so far personally I am both exhausted and height - all at the same time I think I've slept like four hours each night which I imagine is about like 25% more than Carlos sleeps any but I definitely feel the energy and enthusiasm for the con even though my body is like wearing down like please not another hour with this backpack but like what are you guys really excited for tomorrow and I guess I want to hit everyone at the table because this is going to be the the last day of Maxim plugged and it's kind of we've gotten our bearings maybe there's more appointments maybe there's things that you're working on but you know what's your main objective for the rest of the con so I'm really excited because we brought a hundred and 24 copies of fire in the library and I believe right now we have some 17 Oh it'll be the first time like if we do sell out I assume we will sell out because 17 it's actually been like so cool it's the first time I have a demo table and then like the games to buy right there and people demo it and then they buy it like every game and it's so cool so it'll be like awesome to be like yes we sold out we did the thing that like I don't know leader games does
every time I saw their big pile of roots when I first came here and I noticed that big pile wasn't such a big pile in the second day it's gone yep sold all 300 copies great games he's a fascinating dude he was actually the like first big bean to come on the podcast and I was like super scared I think he was in the middle of the second printing of vast at the time and actually the buddy in my group did a lot of print and play stuff with him and that's how I did an interview with Mike and then Mike was like hey I know this other designer and he does this bass game you know you know Patrick leader and I was like yeah I could probably connect him to you and Patrick probably did like I read like a hundred podcast I'm sure in preparation for that but he somehow thought it would be a good idea to take a chance on someone who had maybe like five episodes of a podcast published in Juneau Alaska and you know he he took the time to talk with me and my heart was pounding in preparation for that and throughout the duration I can't even imagine feeling that way again about an interview like I I was borderline ready to call him Sir after every question cuz I was like I've talked to my buddy Mike and now I'm
talking to the Patrick leader but he was so cool and he's been so cool in every Interac since and you know the leader games is really doing something special with developing all of these really innovative ideas and I love seeing when these publishers are kind of moving from designer slash publisher self-publishing gigs into true publisher entrepreneurial gigs where you are looking for other creative people to help empower them to see their dreams come true it's really something that was just kind of like a leader games tangent and like commercial by route but you can't because it's sold out I'll plug right now I'm working on my route review and it just goes to speak to how awesome this community is so Patrick to three years ago like I had not gone to Kickstarter or anything yet but like I went to Patrick and I said that I liked fast and I got him to sign it or whatever and then we just had a meeting like we went into another room and talked for like an hour or something like in the middle of Gen Con when he was like that was the first gen con with vas that he was like selling out of but
he took the time to really just sit with us and talk about Kickstarter and you know being a person that's developing a game and it was amazing it's awesome so anyone else really focusing on something tomorrow the objective you want to get out of your last day of pax probably play some games today I didn't play anything No
so I want to go in there tomorrow a little bit more when you were in the unpopular you kind of scope and out some other games later where there are certain things that you're thinking about hitting up or seeing if you get a chance to play at either this convention or future convention actually I have a few two other designer friends here from other conventions and I actually stopped by and played their games today so I'm kind of I've hit my own pop mark yeah so something that I totally didn't know about going into the cardboard Harold it actually wasn't until going to packs last year which I had already been doing this for over a year at that point was that there are so many dedicated board game design groups in different cities and different states where it's these really tight-knit communities that a lot of people just know each other off the bat I thought it might be there are these big major conventions and so at the five conventions in the US where it attracts people from all over there might happen to be some people who make connections and then see each other at next ones until I started reading that there are the board game designers group in North Carolina and the board gamer designer group of Orlando and board game designer group of Seattle and that there are all these different established communities that meet on a regular basis play test each other's games show each other's games and hopefully help uplift one another and get the best for everyone are all of you participating in
those communities so I actually was on a panel today on how to build a play test community ooh well this is pregnant actually I'm also excited okay the only time you get to see a panel ladies talking about anything in a board game convention it's about being a lady and that's dumb I think we talked about that last podcast we did it a panel of all ladies talking about how to build a playtesting community and it was awesome and there's been like a number of other like all lady secret panels about building a playtest community it's just all these like people that are qualified that happened to be women totally so I was really excited about that but yeah like Plato's communities are amazing and I forgot the original question well one do you participate in those communities and two for anyone that's listening that maybe is working on board game designs themselves and may not be aware of these existing communities or interested in establishing one in their City like what are the benefits of this what do you guys actually get out of it well there's two different things so for the community part it's really getting feedback from other people that aren't design minded as well so they're gonna be looking at your game in a much
different way than the average player so my gay Joe blow off the street plays my game and they're gonna give me feedback a little bit they're gonna tell me if they like it you know that sort of stuff but then if I have a designer take a look at my game they're gonna be looking at the mechanics they're gonna be looking at the flow and really like really picking it apart and hopefully being brutal but you know honest and that's what you kind of looking for right yeah designers can digest the game a lot better and I mean you all know like most play testers can point out that there's a problem or throughout the play testing you'll see that there is a particular problem in a game but the designers are a little bit better giving suggestions on how to solve it or pinpointing a little bit better for you and communicating that yeah so that's that's something that these groups really work with so there's one a DC area break my game group and they're really good a lot of play testers and designers in that group and they're probably at least 8 or 10 of those here at PAX I've seen for listeners who
searching like there's gonna be game nights around okay and you start asking questions and stuff like that you make it sound like it's a speakeasy yeah there's going to be game nights and you just start rubbing shoulders and asking questions like yeah you know how you get into this there are groups like beat up there's an app for meetup - people do build groups like that go to your local game store sometimes people will post things on like notices like hey we're meeting on Tuesday for you know a special game design night things like that Facebook's another great one because I was you know new to the area a few years ago and I was like I'm just gonna go on Meetup and see what board game stuff there's and then I saw a board game designers meet up well that's actually something that I witnessed recently that that brutal feedback that you were talking about and it came let's see Greg Lauren Albright is one person who came to mind he's published a few kind of standard games but he also does like these pervasive games I think he was on a panel here about alternative styles of gaming but he was going into the unpop room to show off some of his things but he got there early enough so he could sit and play other people's games and his main interest was I want to help
other people be as good as possible at what they're doing and that means giving really actionable feedback and critical feedback but it still is in a very positive way of like if you are going to publish this game here is how I think that you're going to have the most success because I think this is going to be a serious roadblock for this type of person and here's some of the reasons why I think that maybe you might want to consider this as an alternative or explore some of these other things when your next play testing the game just to give it a try um you know do you guys who are designers here feel like that sort of feedback is something that you're able to take without letting it crush your ego and crush your soul or do you have to just kind of swallow that in the moment go this is what's best for the game don't think about how much that hurt I think waking when you're first starting out your first game it's kind of your baby and the tendency is to go I don't want anyone to tell me my baby's ugly right when I say brutal feedback I don't mean like I'll just clear this garbage you know that's not helpful but when you're getting like really difficult feedback like I wasn't able to be successful in this game I didn't feel like I had any any action in the game where I could be successful and you know why was that problematic and just been
like wow this person didn't have a good experience because of these different problems you have to be willing to go yeah okay hit me with everything you've got because all that stuff if you can make it better that's great you want to fail fast well on both counts like the fail fast and like how hard it was in the beginning like but once you learn to take feedback like once you start working on the next game like you just want to make the best game that you possibly can right and if you can take feedback well and fast like um there's been times where I've had to like hear the same piece of feedback like five times and on that fifth time I've been like oh yes that is oh yeah I thought that was going a different direction I thought you might be like I heard it five times and then I was like yeah I know I heard it I'm still working on the change but I guess that's not you you actually are like adjusting the cards as you go during play test oh yeah yeah so like at this point like I've worked on enough games where it's just like yes yeah like well there's some feedback that like it's just wrong because but like I want to make a good product and knowing how to make a product is like incorporating the feedback of others and making it the best you can be because you can't just play test it alone mm-hmm that would make a game that perfect for me and me alone and that's not the world or that's
also how you make a kitchen sink game that has every mechanism Under the Sun and you're like what if this were a deck building cooperative dexterity game yeah hidden roles betrayal social deduction
but Carlos is like actually hold on for a second because everything up until that point I think I may be able to work with that request like so at this point I don't like taking pitches from people so instead I'm pitching ideas to designers I think the biggest thing that you said is that a lot of times feedback is gonna come at you like what they want to see what if it was right social deductions so it's really important for a designer to get to the root why are they thinking that they want this exactly like if someone's like yeah I guess your games alright but have you thought about it not being a dexterity game because dexterity games suck but that's not exactly the kind of feedback that you're going to probably want to take action upon as far as your game but you know what is an example of some really good feedback that you guys have gotten or like feel like it is something that designers who are working on their games out there should hear and should act over so I could so it's kind of like the other side so as a developer we've been signing games and helping them develop in providing a lot of feedback and I in bringing that feedback
into the development thing I think the biggest example for firing the library was originally this game came to us with tools which were awesome and we said these tools are awesome we need to bring them out because like you had a set of tools and they do situations and I was like but I want to use them all the time let's just make it so you can use it all of them so it's essentially get to the root of the fun hey it's really fun to mitigate my luck of pulling things out of a bag right with using these tools that strategist make this game a strategic thing it's now you have input randomness and you can really mitigate it with strategy rather than it just being a flip a coin you guessed wrong kind of push your luck game and so it's like find that focus on the fun what's the fun part of the game and that's the feedback you might again well I think what really helped me is to really set the scene when we start play testing like instead of just letting people throw whatever feedback at me that they want to give I'm like okay this is exactly the feedback I'm looking for and also this is the list of feedback that I'm not looking for I don't want you to tell me that my graphic design skills suck because I know they hire somebody to fix that so um like preparing people in the right way before you even start before like
they play the game and like like just setting them on right path get you so much better feedback yeah and I know on that so I mean [ __ ] furious in the other game is not my first game I've done I've designed three other games that have shelved and my second game was a like party strategy game and I decided as a new designer amateur never published or anything I hired a consultant you know some you know a professional developer and I friended that money to like say hey can you meet me at this convention and I would just love a couple hours of your time to get your feedback and know like I expected it to be a little harsh but not half as harsh as it was yes it was great that was a learning point because I knew like okay I really pointed out that I don't know what I'm doing yet and so that was the best thing I could have done was to get that harsh criticism and be like yeah sure your game has player choices player agency but there's they're not meaningful that was like his main critics and there was no meaningful decision for the players there so I love what you said that's where it's a learning point yeah this is exactly because what the problem is is that if your game gets out there somebody's gonna think this no matter what at least right it's time they're telling you so you have a chance to mitigate it or deal with it right now and make it better based on that and I really suck at taking feedback I take it as a personal attack on me and whenever it's like oh
man I can't handle that so I actively have to go hey they're trying to help me and they're giving this feedback this is what they think no matter what it's good that I know it rather than the same then talking to face to me and saying what I want to hear I want to hear what's reality what I think of their notice is that I think it's useful to like talk to people and don't get their direct stuff but also like having a way to for them to give you feedback in a written form because some people really like and we're talking about like just regular players right um they're not really comfortable telling you like hey Sean I don't like this game I think it sucks like they want to be mean to you right they feel like even if they're giving valid feedback like I didn't this mechanic they could like they're telling you you're bad mm-hmm but if they can write something down and kind of be anonymous then there's a less pressure on them so they can actually be a little more honest do you guys actually get people who are like yeah I I think this game sucks like just straight up like that because everything that I've observed and a lot of it is in unpop situation so maybe it is that I'm witnessing people who are in the designer community which part of the reason why I am fascinated by the design groups or designer groups groups of people who are designing games is that it's also preparing one another for the process you know it's talking to one another about what to expect including preparing people for when you get
feedback that is not an attack on you that is constructive feedback for the game but when I'm witnessing the feedback happening it usually is something that's like hey I don't think this gives you enough agency in this game and I worry that this is just going to make people feel like they've lost their turn and didn't have anything to make critical decisions based off of out of that or like they just didn't get to play the game during this turn or or I I'm worried that the core amount of fun that this game provides is all in the first like 50% of the game and then it just drags from that point forward it the feedback that I tend to hear seems to be really really good stuff like and articulating important points and is that just I happen to be in the unpopular you guys getting some people being truly savage about your games oh well I haven't gotten anybody to be like truly sad that's what the internet is for right after like where people buy your game and they're like oh this isn't an engine building game I hate it yeah whatever but I do really try to get all the negative comments like usually my first question after the game is over is like hey I want to know the worst thing about this game and then I just throw out things that could be the worst thing like well if I'm like noticing things
like oh yeah weren't those player turns really long and I start like seeing the bad things about the game and then they like feel a lot more comfortable like they will admit or like agree with me and like just start adding it so it's never really like savage but like if I start saying bad things and like they're opening the door for ya yeah now that you mention it I did hate your game and that's something that happens in the podcasting space as well but you know I I welcome feedback for the show i but I also know what I want this show to be more or less so you know there there is a difference between yo your show just sucks because I don't like you as an interviewer I don't know that I can do much about that but if I follow that up with like well you know I know that I struggle with repeating my questions over again like rephrasing them or using the same phrases or going off on tangents and talking about random things you know what are the parts that you do like what are the specific things when you say I don't like you as a host you know what are those things and that's information that I can act on to see is that something that I feel like is a core part of what makes this thing unique and may give me listenership and
that's specific to this one person's perspective or is that something that I can do to become better at doing this thing in general and realizing a better version of I want to be putting out there um I did have a play test where I was for kliklak boom a player after the first round said that he couldn't play it anymore that it was too stressful for him and he was just kind of freaking out and like he's like I don't want to play this anymore like that's great that's mean idol I appreciate that feedback please go find another game to play at that's called decision for you but I also taught I took that as a win because that's exactly the kind of feeling I wanted that game to have I wanted people to have that sense of like dread and and fear of pressure no clearly not for him cool cool go have your thing but you just made me feel like okay this is a bond track so your negative feedback was actually positive feedback for me I want to make people uncomfortable Eli Roth about it I figured out my art well Sean I think we talked about some of the things that Lee so the guys are working on but what's going on with thing 12 games you know what do you have cooking uh gosh well I said we've got dad dinosaurs not assembled coming up in dice of pirates and we're also doing like more stuff with the podcast going out and it's one of things I'm really looking forward to for Sunday we're we're anything like the bigger guys as well but when we get to talk to the more
indie publishers I love doing that kind of stuff except we're giving them a lot more you know viewership and kind of getting the word out I got to play eschaton which is a deck builder game really really cool deck builder game and but they're definitely kind of an indie publisher and not a whole lot of people know about them so you know that was cool to kind of like get some more information out there for everybody else it's also you mentioned dice of pirates and I just wanted to say we played it recently we got our Kickstarter
worst filling out for you but I loved it I thought it was awesome so yeah I'm excited I didn't play it with the dice of Kings the other one and I so I'm excited to play with it together I noticed there was a way to play together so there is something that we're working on to have dice - dragon stakes of crayons and dice appearance together
tangent here you know like if you're wanting a really quick playing dice game but well dice of crowns and I got to play a prototype version of dice pirates last year and they're they're both really fun quick playing heavy player interaction games which is amazing for like a quick dice game you don't ever get that except when Sean brings but I got a no is the published copy doesn't die some pirates also have that like ballistic oh yeah oh my god that stuff is amazing you know I love your guys's rulebook because I've tried to destroy it in any number of ways and like some ancient like unholy artifact it will never be destroyed is invincible to any tools of man there's a bulletproof material you hold it up and like okay go to the cardboard Harold must officially say that we do not endorse or recommend that you try to protect yourself from bullets using the materials found in dice of pirates or geyser crowns but you know you lick the perfect size you know you have one next to each other just right there and you're invincible 100% invincible cannot leave
get killed by getting shot anywhere yeah yeah exactly from the number of people who have been miraculously cured like the next day in 80s action movies after being like it assaulted any number this is science so John said all right well the last thing that I wanted to bring up just because it's again the my favorite thing about it pax unplugged is the positive energy it's the connections that people make is an insulin enthusiasm is do any of you want to give any shoutouts to like someone else is here or something that you saw at the convention that you were like man this was really cool and I I think that people should pay attention to this well I did get one of the designers I've met in the past holy O Nazario has a lot of really cool designs is this one called dice dice revolution yeah it is amazing it has like a speaker in its I'm pretty sure he would win yeah yeah every other got like de he's got something signed by somebody else I love his designs yeah he thinks like outside the box Oh designs use the box inside and out oh
yeah well he's got what four designs here that my going on into the room five games and you know I first thought like oh man this guy's been working on this forever he's like I've been designing games for about a year and a half like him what he comes up with like this new idea that's like something new and has never been done before I don't know how you do that yeah but so on just to piggyback the dice dice revolution it plays so fast you actually listened to ddr song and each ddr song introduces one little like new thing or mechanic to the game and so you have I don't know did you play today Jack or did you see it played I got to check it out and showed it to me earlier he was like oh you're a music guy so let's you know talk about this dice dice revolution so he went over it with me but I didn't have time to play it I'm hoping to check it out later on at the comment so each round lasts the length of a DDR Thor and with that two minutes or something like that so it mixes both puzzling like simple thinking and dexterity but because it's so fast you rushed at the dexterity elements and it's all about like doing it very finely and like if you have all the time in the world it's super easy and the puzzle stuff it's just a matter of like stacking arrows in the right order the easiest thing if you're not under pressure but because you're under pressure and you're doing both of them
simultaneously it's just a really good mix and just tie that in a like funny cool theme it was it was refreshing I really like that game but I do want to do a shout out well not only do I have an amazing like starts to do stuff but like they just like they do all the things and they're awesome so they're Liz from beyond solitaire Jeremy from John balaiah plays Danny from Derek and Danny Michelle from a geek Girls Guide Kevin who is one of my designers and Quinn like they have just like gone above and beyond and been there and taking over things and you know just taking care of me like I get to actually sometimes sit down it's great it's fantastic I'd like to give a shout out to seize the bean buy quality beast there outside of the US although the designer lived in Seattle for a while and just I happened to run into him and saw that he had his game here and it's it's fun on my Kickstarter and there they're already there close to capping all the manufacturing stuff done but it's a
really cool deck builder game with a coffee theme so you're actually are running a coffee shop again baristas and people coming in to buy stuff but they've also they're working with Panda and the the extra components they've got these 3d components like my donut and their first player token is a cup of coffee and they have these coffee beans and these sugar cubes that you're using and they look legitimately like those things so the quality bar in this game is just freaking crazy and he's super super nice person to so you know he's here doing this thing like oh yeah this is awesome I'm Greg I'm glad you're here I tried to get him some chat out on social media and like mr. nice guy that's awesome well Carla just put me to shame by like saying you know like instead of focusing on these other things going on we should focus on my booth staff and how helpful they are so I should say that Robert and Rob have done amazing jobs in helping me do all kinds of filming and podcasting and the the degree of sophistication that we are are producing anything this year is way above and beyond the like iPhone and lapel mic method that was being done in the past like now we have two cameras and only one of them is an iPhone this year yeah yeah it's a serious upgrade but as far as games like their there are
so many cool games out here but we played one last night I think it was called medium that was by greater than games that was this design team of two friends and they just signed it with greater than games I think three days ago but they've been working on this for a while and it's a social game where at first you may think of this just like a squishy social game this might as well be bald or something but it turns out that there is a sense of progression and strategy in it that becomes so much more intuitive and yet complex as you go on and you see the genius of the game design as it unfolds effectively it's an improv game where you're just guessing a third word based off of two cards that each player has played and you work in teams and you're hoping to get one associative word right after counting down from three to one word if you both get it right then you win something but if you get it wrong whatever different words that you said you try to guess again based off of those words and then you go again and there's a specificity that narrows down that makes this one of the most exciting and immediately satisfying games that I played a long time and there are so many social games
like this where I feel awkward like I'm the fool if I get it wrong and something about how this was structured both made it feel like I could apply some some intuition and some strategy to how I was honing in on words and also when it got when it was wrong it was also fun for me like I didn't feel like the butt of the joke when I got it wrong or did like people are going to laugh at me like yeah you didn't actually get that right how could you not know that code names word and that game was one of the most exciting games that I've played in a long time the last thing that I hope I'm going to get this name right and Shawn you may know more about this because I believe they're based in Washington but there's a non-profit games to grow and again game tomorrow game to grow in Washington and I'll put a link in the notes here but they work with I believe autistic children as well as children who have been exposed to trauma playing D&D as well as other tabletop games with them as a way of socializing with these children and giving them more adaptive skills and being able to cope with some of the things that they're struggling with and it is a super awesome program that I am like personally and professionally with my outside of tabletop gaming work very interested in learning more about
everything that they're doing we actually have them on our podcast a while back and yeah it's a super super cool concept the idea of using tabletop gaming you know replicating as a form of therapy to be able to work through things that you had going on and be able to help people be you know more social and be able to start to understanding different cues and things it's a phenomenal group and we're gonna be talking to them with them tomorrow as well just give them somewhere somewhere love all right well I know it's getting late we got one more day of packs ahead of us and I really appreciate everyone who's has taken the time to come on to this podcast this it has now been two years of doing this and I think it's officially the thing that I'm probably going to be looking forward to doing but most at PAX you three so thank you all for coming on to the show and for those of you listening if you're interested which you should be in anything that we've talked about here today I'm going to put the contact information as well as all of the good social media website stuff for all the people who are on the show thank you guys all for coming on thank you for having me thanks thank you for listening to the cardboard health as always everything we do is ad free and audience supportive if you'd like to help keep it that way find the patreon link at the top of our web page cardboard Harold calm we have several levels of support with various rewards if you enjoyed the show we do a
whole bunch of other stuff including reviews interviews and even recommendations cross writing podcast and video you can find that on our YouTube channel or by visiting any of our social media or our website so with that out of the way thank you again for listening to the cardboard Harold