Skip to main content
Loading video...

2024 Spiel Des Jahres Nominees Review! Who Will Win the Board Game of the Year?

Transcript 32:31

hello and welcome to board shid my name is way and I'm Matt and you may have noticed this stack of games in front of us Matt why are these specific games in front of us well because all these three have something in common even been very different games they all been nominated for the game of the year absolutely so they've been nominated for the Spiel Des yarus it is is the biggest award in board games yeah uh probably without doubt at this point there are some other contenders but it's certainly a real big award it is it is and uh yes these are the three games for 2024 so we got in the footstep of Darwin we got Captain Fleet and we got Sky Team so we going to have a look at the three games and then we got to have a little bit of a chat about who we think is going to win yeah we're going to talk about these games and probably have a little debate between us as to which one we think should win and which one we think probably will win and if you want to find out then I think you should probably hit the Subscribe button it's the easiest award you will ever win and on top of that as soon as the um win is going to be announced we're going to do another video about it and uh talking about specifically about the the winning game we already had an in-depth review of this that you can go and check on the um on the rest of the content that's going be L up to that we are making content while we're talking for the

captain flip and and in the footstep of Darwin that's going to be uh on the channel in the future so definitely check the hit the Subscribe button and check the rest of the content so you can know it and if you don't know what the SPI Theus is we are doing a very interesting history of the winners of thei jarus you can find that playlist here as well and that I'll give you everything that you need to know about the winners of that award Matt before we move on is there something else we should tell the people yes I think the guys should be be ready for the summer with you should be ready for the summer amazing new clot from into the a yeah we've got by pressing this link down below and using this code that's flashing up on the screen for you a phenomenal 10% discount on top of any other discount and there's a a all new summer collection on the website something like this indeed this lovely t-shirt right here model they are some fantastic wonderful designs that you should go and check out uh and get a new wardrobe for the summer what what do we say Matt yeah treat yourself summer of these let's go talk about these games let's do it so Matt should we give everyone at home a taste of what these games are about absolutely let's talk about it let's should start with the first one yes first one is Sky Team Sky team is a

two-player Cooperative game where you and the other player are trying to land a plane and uh is um um hidden dice rolling and placement uh where there's no verbal communication between the two players so during your turn you will have to allocate dice in certain position of the boat to make sure that the the the plane stays level that the the the the speed of the plane is correct then there are no other planes on your route and that you can e you can actually get the landing gear out and uh and make it home it's a fantastic fantastic design that does really clever things with limited communication and you need to be able to somehow without talking communicate with your teammate exactly what it means when you place a dice on the uh on the plane sort of dashboard it's really great the production is also really wonderful it's absolutely stunning I see why this is in this list absolutely definitely there's lots of stuff in the Box lots of different modules that you can bolt on as well um yeah Sky team is is a real good one let's go with the second nominee absolutely uh the second nominee is what I think is probably the lightest game in the list and this is Captain flip it's a two to five player game by Mori and it is a tile placement game you are going to be essentially grabbing tiles out of a shared bag and you're going to place it on your ship and the

ti will give you various effects it might get you some coins from the supply which is how you win the game or it might flip other tiles over or it might give you the ability to draw an extra tile but there's a special little hook in this game isn't there m if you don't like the tile you can flip here that's why it's Cy and flip that's I guess that's why it's once flip the tile you must use that tile so you can't flip it back so think think about it if you really want to do it uh it's a very um it's definitely the the lightest game in um in this pile of games um is but it's very nice and easy and clever and uh it's fun to play it's 20 minutes game and uh it's a family plus game family plus game very yeah really light Breezy uh fantastic little game yeah you just po it's either got one thing on one side or one thing on the other side as simple as that you just put them in rows and columns trying to score more points than the others exactly so uh that was Captain flip and let's look at the final one shall we yes so Matt what have we got last well we got the heaviest box yeah the ni bigest box in the footstep of Darwin um very nice tile placement game so two tile placement games in this in this list yes and uh you basically are as you say in the footstep of Darwin trying to collect all the pieces of animals in and insects and birds from around the globe and make a little collection it's a

really beautiful production this I think but yeah arguably one of the best of these three for sure it's really really wonderful great artwork this lovely sort of watercolor Splash and it does a couple of um quite cool things on your turn is very simple you take a tile from like a 3X3 grid you put it on your own board and then you move Darwin's boat around the grid and then the next player can only pick from the tiles that are in front of that boat really really smart it's um out yeah the the market the the movement of the board will decide which raw column of the market you can actually have access to and at the same times you uh filling your your book of of species trying to complete again rows and columns um of on your book and depending on which kind of like um scoring you got at the end you will get this or that points the scoring mechanism is very very clever because not everybody will not score the same type of points every time that you can manage to um stuck the um species and type of animal the together you will get another theorem yeah Theory I guess yeah publish a theory that'll score things in different ways exactly that that will let you that will tell you how you're going to score at the end of the game so there is a this Twist on the final scoring that is really really interesting and it makes the games um really fun to play because it's not like everybody is going to score the same kind of point or next game you're not

going to scare the the you're not going to score the same type of points so yeah absolutely a really really smart design okay should we get a bit spicy now about let's chat about it okay Wayne we we add a look briefly to the games now my question to you is going to be what are the criteria which the the judges use to actually decide who's going to win that's a great question and actually there's quite a few different criteria and even to get to the nominee point I must say is a really big deal for a game and it will probably do your sales no end good to be honest with you usually if you are in this top three you're going to sell yeah you're going to yeah it's it's a huge deal but the criteria is in four broad categories four Broad Strokes first you've got the concept of the game so this is how original is it fair enough how playable is it not yeah how Innovative all that sort of stuff is it easy to play do you want to keep playing it um is it good value as well so that sort of comes into the concept the value of the game for what you're buying um the second bit and what's I think is very important for the Spiel theis jges is the rule structure rules layout so is the composition of the rules clear is it um well laid out is it comprehendable can you can you understand it and teach it well and that's really important because I think a good game's got good rules so an amazing games got amazing rules they go hand in hand they can't be they can't be separated you can't have an amazing game

with with poorly written rules no one's going to play your game right and that's part of it right they really want a nice solid clear rule set that everyone can understand and that's e probably easily translatable um then they've also got the layout so another consideration is the layout of the box so what's in the box how it's segmented um and also the layout of the board and the layout of the rules so how everything is sort of structured I think fair enough as a product I I will say if the game is too fitly or it's got too many bits and pieces that is probably going to score lower on this category I'd say so and then finally You've Got Game design in general and design thing is things like functionality and workmanship so I think functionality matter is and workmanship is how readable is your game so when you've read the rules how easy can I apply that to what I'm looking at and then workmanship I think is more just pure production the pure production does it pop absolutely absolutely well um let's start talking about this then let's start talking about it okay so let's talk Matt about the first category there which is the general game concept so we're talking about originality playability and game value okay so if we start very quickly if you take the three games we got two Tower placement games one is slightly uh more complex than the other I'm talking about um footstep of Darwin is something that I would say family

plus plus yeah while the captain flip is a family minus definitely a family game is a family game it's not it's something that you can definitely teach um younger um kid yeah to play and play very easily while Sky Team on all of the three is definitely the more complex I agree uh and it's got the minus that it's got It's a two- player only game however my pick for this category will be Sky teams in terms of like how Innovative the game is uh rather than the than the other two um it's purely because it's um it's something that kind of like it's never been seen before um um it's a very inovity things about this non communication with the play within within the players uh the fact that the board itself looks like a cockpit from play um and and the entire idea of the game uh what I was saying earlier is um footstep of Darwin uh we're going to play this game a lot it's going to come on the table a lot uh captain flip it's a it's a fun 20 minutes game that it's going to be played now and then uh Sky Team um I almost finished the the the missions are it's it's like play this a lot yeah and you play the same so if you were to order them in terms of this

category so when including everything things like original originality and the playability oh we go like this that's your order for with Sky team winning this um okay this one all right um I think I think that's a fantastic point I think Sky team is by far the most original the most Innovative of these three games um however I think in terms of playability and what you not even what you get in the box but for me in terms of the games that I like I love in the footsteps of D and what it does mostly around what you said about how I think the the scoring is quite Innovative because your end game scoring will be different every time you play absolutely and each player's end game scoring slight that's why I say that this is going to hit the table a lot of time yeah uh probably more than Sky Team uh just because Sky team again it's got the plus or minus of being a two-player game so in a in a larger group you will not you will not take this one out not even consideration because he uh it's only two two players and um and probably once you finish all the mission in the box there are other one online you can download but probably once you finish all the mission in here you can replay some of them but it's going to be something that you already seen absolutely and you're probably more likely to want to play the more complex missions once you've done that right so for me I think I would probably order it like this uh because I think I I am a big fan of this I will 100% concede that

it is significantly less Innovative than Sky Team y but I think in general I like the playability of in the footsteps of Darwin slightly more because of the things you mentioned slight there more players and I think there's you could probably get this to the table more often more often so that's just my thoughts on that should you move on to the next category M so the next category um is Rule structure again we say that rules are important for a incredibly important yes so a very good game has a very good rules they always go together now in terms of rules what what do you think about these games again we're talking about easy medium medium hard games but in terms of like the structure of the rules yes are they clear yeah are they clear are they composed well can you read them and is it easy to teach them via the rules right do I have to then retranslate that and teach it to someone else I think actually I mean when you get to this point I think when you're in the last three all of the rules are going to be excellent so I'll be honest I don't don't know how heavily this is weighted um from the spish charish judges but I will say for Captain flip the rules are phenomenally clear and clean it's a simple game it is but it is uncompromised I mean when it comes to like you can't mistake what the rules mean in this box I mean it's very very

good um in the footsteps of Darwin again it's a slightly more complex game we sort of stacked them that way so in slightly more complex but again the rules are laid out in a really beautiful way I don't think there's really much in the way of ambiguity there the only thing I have to say is while you're playing the game a couple of people will say what does this mean on a specific scoring tile and I might need to go back to the book and maybe see what that scoring but actually very limited the amount of times that happens but that's fine even because there are some icons and stuff they're not um they're not super common true same in Captain as matter fact when you have iconography on your game you're going to have to refer to the rule book but the question is is it easy to find that information yes in both counts actually very easy to find that information and I'll let you speak to Sky Team cuz I have read the rule book but not as much as you I will say the sky team of the three is the more um it's more the complex um it's still pretty easy once you get you rule the you read the rules and you go through and and uh and understand what they means uh but being more Innovative more new things is it's less like there are less common rules with the gam like you can fall back and think about oh it's like that it's less of that it's less of that plus the the the things about each mission that you play you're going to play with different module of the cockpit uh so sometimes you will play with the uh with a fuel module sometimes with a with a wind module sometimes with

a fuel and the wind sometimes with a passengers so the rules will change be quite Dynamic yes so each Mission will have um his sets of rule that um if you play a lot yes easy peasy you're going to do it if you pick the game up every month once a month you will have to go there and R them re rrde them um sorry reread them uh but again this is just because it's the most Innovative game they got most Innovative mechanics yeah uh but I do agree that in my view is this in terms of rules inms rules Captain flip is the easiest it's got the less rules but all the iconography and everything is is super simple so this takes you two minutes to learn the game quite literally two minutes this takes you five minutes to to learn the 10x maximum Sky Team it's going to take you a little bit more exactly so that's my I I don't think I can argue with this order I think this is an excellent order I mean and I think it might just be in formed by the complexity cuz know what we've also done here is we' reversed how complex these games are and that is potentially um reflected in the rule set so something to can think about is how likely am I to make a mistake while reading the rules and get confused with the game right and I think maybe this is probably the order that's the that's the order probably the order yeah Matt let's move on to our

final category which is going to be the general sort of design and produ right yes um so they we're literally talking about the design of the games what it looks like and everything and how the box is what's the insert inside the box is it easy to set up tear down does it have player AIDS all that sort of stuff and at the same times it's going to be the the production itself so they literally like what are you paying for yeah is it worth it is it good production he got like if he has um components like tokens or coins or little meatles are the meatles like the standard one can we actually use meeples in this video after all that things we might get soon we might yeah we might talk about it in another video about we'll leave that situation um but yeah so um should we take this slightly one by one quickly talking about I think so so um let's start let's start with Sky Team um so Sky team is um the the fact that he got that very unique board that is made of um double cboard boards and layer yeah double layer you got all the switches that you can switch on and off and everything is done with cardboard and um I think this one in terms of design straw WIS yeah it just like is in terms of purely the design yeah okay um the production is is really good in

terms of like how these elements are are produced it's got that very nice nice little um airplane meols they are they're really really well done um in terms of the Box the box is is pretty simple there's no iner there's a kind of an insert but it keeps everything in the box there not that many elements that you need to to worry about so um yes I think it's a tremendous production yeah yeah absolutely uh Captain flip uh Captain flip is the one that for me is a little bit shorter than the others um in terms of like um the design is uh it's nothing inov it's not there's nothing Mega new it's absolutely super clear and simple and easy to play easy to read and easy to read but in terms of like design and components the the production itself is a little bit um the the paper a little bit lacking I would have I would have um prefer something else keeping in mind that these three games the same price we are talking about the same price that pound wise is around the 2025 plusus 25 so let's say in dollar is going to be $30 plus $30 more or less and more or less same things in in in Euros um the components in Captain flips are the are the worst of the three no they're not they're not bad they're just

in the three I objectively the worst of the the yeah I agree but the sign wise what using you see I agree I mean I think I don't the art design is fine it's my least favorite art design of the three I mean I think Sky team's art design is functional yeah and it's readable yeah but it's not pretending to be anything else it's a flight simulator yeah it is so I think it does what it needs to do um this is obviously aimed at much younger audience and the art design yes reflects that it's not bad per se it's just not what I like so in terms of the production I couldn't agree more captain production is is objectively the least good of the three it's not a bad production it is for what you get in the physical box of things that you're paying for you know it's the the Lesser you got the L you got the less yeah absolutely couldn't agree more yeah and uh yeah let's talk about in the footsteps of Darwin yes now this one I think is this one is my favorite production I will say I think the artwork is stunning I think it is a beautiful looking game it's so clear so clean this lovely sort of water splash it has a great sort of an untreated paper rule book which is you very specifically chosen to be sort of historical right unbleached untreated paper uh not even bound with staples bound with like a a string right they've done they really thought about production it's really really nice I can see yeah the the all the books are made all the folding player boards as well which f it looks like a notebook that

you might have had in and the play yeah yeah the player boards and the board itself absolutely great yeah beautiful to see the insert is also fantastic in this game it is the best insert of the three absolutely you can set this game up in seconds because of it and you put it away very easily you have a great space for the tiles it tells you how many tiles per player that you use in the box which is great you have a lovely sort of cloth bag to store all over the other bits as well there's not a bit of plastic in the Box it's plastic free which is great as well um it's just a beautiful production the tiles are chunky and thick I don't think there's anything to hate about this production now no my only comments will be um I would like if on the tiles there would be like a little like sentence of information about that animal that would it's something like I don't know if you think about wingspan it's just a sentence or this this is the bird that I don't know with the with the biggest Wings some something like that even something uh little bit silly a quote about that animal or or something like that make it more um I agree it would it would be lovely the the tiles do have the Latin name which is always hilarious to read out that's true and also quite lovingly they've included a separate book which just has the information on theime yeah no no that's fair enough which is very nice that's really nice cuz he's um very ucy for for educational piece right if it was on I don't know

probably there a little bit something more on the tiles I don't know probably then it would have been too big but that is just um um my half right yeah yeah nice but no um absolutely the production is uh is really good and again you getting four player stuff in this box while five players while Sky team is still a two player um I still think that Sky team has the best production for what it is y however I think this is the actual this probably the order I think in terms of what you get yeah what you get the the overall design overall production overall quality uh this is the thing cuz you get you're getting a lot this is a heavy box a heavy beautiful stuff as well and very very well laid out Matt I mean it's it's a hard choice but should we should we do a little conclusion let's do a conclusion let's see um let's see who's going to be the winner oh gosh okay Mt I am oh I'm stressed even thinking about it because you know it's such a big thing for all of these Publishers right to to win the SPI Charis I mean it's a massive thing again can't underestimate or understate how important just being nominated is out of the 5,000 or so games that get released every year it's a huge deal uh to be the one um or the three or the three three let's think about these three games being in the top three they already won they already won and there's

a wider pry um but what we'll do let's have a little chat about your finals for all three of them and then give us the one you think will win and the one that you want to win yes um so I think they are all three um amazing games for different reasons yes uh the playability and the easy learning of the of the game of Captain flip play with almost anybody of any age the the beautiful T placing and very interesting score mechanics that changes every time so a lot of replayability an absolutely stunning game of um in the footstep of Darwin and The Innovation and the production and the the break yeah the break of the market that this game did yes um cuz don't forget it this we got this copy a Spiel elb had to fight to get a copy yeah um this game was so hot yeah so I think my overall will be uh my preference will be Sky win the sky team to win but literally in this in this order first second third your preference yeah I'm afraid that Captain flip is going to win just because L why why did you say that because lately um the Spiel the yish um started to um um to let more like kids friendly games

win that it's not a bad things if you think about like yeah do romantic one last romantic one yes more but anyway more on the Lighter Side uh what I think it should be overall mro macro as well was another is this yeah okay so um in the footstep of DN is definitely overall the best game of this three from my from from an objective point of view the game that I love the most is Sky Team but I do think that this is going to be the winner yeah I think if I went on pure Innovation it would be Sky Team I think that is UN without doubt okay um the game that I want to win is in the footsteps of Darwin I think it's a tremendous game I very much enjoy it and if you haven't played it you should actually should play all three of these FR yes you should play all play all three especially but I I very much like this um and for Captain flip I mean this isn't for me I will just say it's a solid game and I can appreciate how smart it is with the flipping and how that can com with other tiles and things like that it's clever um and it's got a great Mass Appeal especially when you've got for kids as well if you've got family yes that's the game I think yeah if you got if you got a couple of kids um that you want to play play with Captain flip is absolutely the best of the three I think the game that I think will win is in the footsteps of Darwin yep I

don't know if that's my brain at all my heart saying that but that's the game I think will win and it's the game that I want to win and I think the reason for that is I think Captain flip is too close to the Kinder speler yes that is the the awards for the kids game yes yep and I think Sky team is too close to the Kenna buer that is the um awards for the most complex game the connoisseurs Games The Connoisseur games I I do agree with you that uh in the footstep of Darwin hits the perfect spots in in between in between them um yeah yeah I Le yeah and it's not like this is a very complex game or this is a completely brainless game that's not the case no no no no no it's just like putting these three in an order that is uh that is yeah I mean if yeah I think I think it will and I would also want it to I think if Captain flip one I would be I I'd be less satisfied with the with the judges decision fair enough yes but again I don't have a family where this would matter me exactly EXA but if you do this might be importance to you so take that as you as you hear it and uh you know what's going to happen uh that next week we're going to do another video talking about the winner cuz the it's literally just in a couple of weeks time and uh so if you're watching us from the future yes did we get it right in the future in

the past in the future go back to the future you know what let's go to the conclusion let's go we'll work it out okay so Matt that was a really interesting discussion and the exploration of these three wonderful games right three amazing games that they already won been in this in the top three for for these Awards um thinking about these are the top three of thousands of games that came out this year so absolutely they are already the best of the best and I will be really really interested when the when the voting comes out in uh in a few days absolutely but what we want to know is what you think which one of these three games do you think will win I want you to let us know in the comments below absolutely which one is your favorite so tell us pick with your heart and then pick with your yeah have you played any of these three have you played all the three let us know in the comments below and while you adding a comment please press the like button it's going to help us um and uh most of all you need to hit the Subscribe button you need to hit that button when you're going to watch us in the future you going to have a notification from when the next video is coming out with the actual winner so there we go yeah everybody wins you hit the Subscribe button you're right in the past the future the future is the pass go back to

the future and press the Subscribe button no no don't go back to the F do it now and then go back into the future subscribe and then check out the rest of our content and we will catch you again real soon ciao

Progress saved