My Games Collection - Shelf by Shelf - #43 - The Broken Meeple
Transcript
welcome to another shelf shelf video we are on 2 shelf 43 now and we're looking at mainly I mean that there are some other publishers involved but primarily this is the butch and friends or Hutchins friends I'm not entirely certain how you pronounce it German based company I believe and they it's very interesting I do realize I had so many games from them but I think it depends on who published them because 2 of them you could argue actually got published by other people but it just happened that I have these particular copies but there's an interesting mix here from abstract all the way up to you know mid weight euro so let's start off with the abstracts I think that's on the far end no no we won't because the chair is in the way that's getting stuck on
this end Camus are though max now who cares about the max the max basically is just some extra rules that you can use the play the game with where you upgrade towers nobody plays it I think that I think the only reason it's in the game is good I think the designer wanted a different way to play with this kid but commissar though is just a straight-up abstract strategy game but it's such a good one and so simple with this you've got this kind of like almost like chest like boar but all these different colors on there and you have these really nice looking like well produce towers with the color symbol on top in the row at your starting point bit like how pawns are set up on the chessboard and with this you move a tower forward either diagonally or straight on but no never backwards never to the site and the idea is is that where your piece lands depending what color that piece lands on that is the color of the tower your opponent must then move on their turn and your object of the game is to get one of your towers to the opponent's side that is it that is the rules but my god is this one of the most tense abstract games I've ever played I mean you know that as soon as you make a mistake your fault they win your fault there's no luck in this game everything's there everything is public information there is no hidden card drawer or anything like that it is straight up I am moving this tower here you must move the orange right you've moved it a blue I've got to move the blue right you've done it the purple I got to move the purple I'll move it the green you must move the green yes it's that all the way through but you
are searching for the openings you're trying to plan ahead to try and see if you can goad your opponent into letting you through if so tense though because you're like any movement I might just shoot myself in the foot and if you lose you gave your opponent the move they needed to beat you oh you nobody else you can't blame anybody but it could have been maybe a smaller box because it's quite a big box for what it is but styrene board and there's a few rulebook snare I've noticed a few little summaries doesn't quite need all of that because I've got all the languages in here that's why but yes so much stuff in this box look at these these oh these lovely things yeah that is the towers that you have so these like course or bakelite pieces the green polka fell on there they've got you won't be able to see this one but you can see hopefully the red symbol there imagine you've got army of these all on your board now as I said you don't need to worry about these little tokens basically the max rules I think allow you to upgrade your pieces a bit like how like rooks pawns upgrade in chess I believe I don't know it's a waste of time it's just not worth it you know you want to play this in the I can teach you the game in 30 seconds and we'll play it in five to ten you know because this is literally is a 10-minute game pretty much I will teach you it in 30 seconds and chances are we're finished in the next nine and a half minutes it's that fast but really really
cool all right yeesh well my other favorite abstract games this one is one of the gift projects so this guy could Chris Byrne he's done lost right now probably best seven or eight of these now in the years a couple of recently actually and he basically just does these two-player abstract games they're nothing but two players and they usually involve pieces on some kind of grid or what map and your move the pieces around to achieve a goal this one goes by the hole five in a row concept which everybody is familiar with and the idea is is you must get five in a row three times and what happens is you have these rooms on the board and you follow the lines and you move the Rings across but as you move you pop one of your little bakelite plastic pieces in on your color side black or white and the idea is is that you can't move through rings they block each other's paths but every time your ring passes over other pieces whether they're yours or the opponents they flip to their opposite side so white and black are constantly flipping between the two and so you're trying to maneuver the Rings in such a way that you can get five of yours your side up in a row of course your opponent is doing this all the time and oh my god the gamestate can change so much in this add to that the cool idea that when you get one that's five in a row your ring goes on your side of the board to track your score it is off the board you have less rings to move around you have less like options available to you so it's
almost like a self balancing mechanism you know to allow the other person to catch up you can get some tense games in there I don't think I'm particularly good at this game I'll admit but it's really enjoyable I mean my gut this will test your brain as you're trying to conjure up right if at flips there that flips there I'll move it over to there that flips all of them and you can create such like massive swings in terms of the game state on this one and it's just really good fun and again I can teach this to you in about 60 seconds although chances are I'll probably take us a good 20 minutes the planet because you are going to be thinking a fair bit during this one but inch there's other ones in the gift project I have only played I think Devon and czar I have not played any of the others Devon I quite like czar is average I think it's fine I would play it again but Devon is quite good if you just do random setup and don't spend ages on it but I've not played any of the others I would like to but again to player only games that is the problem it's hard to get into the table so why do I even have them in the collection because they're that symbol and have that much fun and there will hopefully be a time in the future so let's move on to our and our games slash Butch and Friends Rogers are the Ganges boxers in a little bit worse where Inca and Marcos brand this is a very beautiful looking euro game and again I would say this used to be underrated but it's starting to get into the buzz now that has ended a bit more wide distribution with Roger the Ganges it's got a mix of everything
really and the board is busy matt is a problem with it but what you're doing is that you have this province here and you're building up almost like a Carcassonne styled map in front of you with these markets and these buildings on and the markets can get you some money the buildings can get you fame points but there's a catch as well get to the catch later the way you're doing it is that you essentially have this kind of like you know like Buddha statue with colored ice all over it and the colored ice is how you do the action so it's one of those dice placement games but the dummies value you know depends on the action you're doing but they're different colors as well and the colours correspond to some of the buildings that you've got like the markets you can trigger or the cost of the tiles themselves have to be bought with certain colored ice so you have to exchange colors from time to time the various tracks and that can get you lots of cool little bonuses and abilities which is really nice you know the game kind of rewards usually go through it's a cool little puzzle but just looks really cool as you build up your little map and have this board full of just color everywhere color wood translucent dice but the real cool thing about this is the twist how you win it because we're all bored with victory points now and I mean I'm actually being tempted to do a top 10 list of games that where you don't win by victory points or something or something to that effect or throw a twist on victory points I don't know I don't know if I could think of 10 games that could do that you know cuz I mean I'd have to exclude racing games and all that law I don't think there's enough to
kind of grit it down but with this one you have a Fame track and a money track and they start at different ends and then go around the board as soon as the two meet that's the winner so it's a race to that point but you go high money and low fade you go high Fame and low money or do you go for in-between typically you're in between but I have seen high money and low Fame work and I almost got high fame load money to work you know it's a juggling act that you've got to do this one has probably been high up on the list of remember the top ten I did the other week the top ten games it escaped me this is one of those games I think it's escaped a lot of the people you know they want to play it and they haven't had a chance to trust me it's really solid and then finally oh yes this is another darling and I just this is one of those games where you think Luke why do you like this game and sometimes I've had to ask myself that question as well fully expanded with farmers and that butchering friends or our indie games key flower now this guy Rita breeze has done various key games this is the only one I've really got behind keeper was okay but it was ridiculously complicated this one still has a bit of a dismal rulebook but thankfully once you've got the rules down you know it's doable to play and board game arena has a copy of this on there so you can learn it by that but key flower again I don't know why I like it it's it's weird because it kind of goes against my my typical tastes because one it's a fairly dry
gyro I mean yes you're building up this little village and you're getting resources to upgrade the buildings and that but at the end of the day that you're doing it by a weird bidding mechanic where you're using these different color me paws as the currency in order to acquire the tiles and then the resources go into the buildings but it doesn't really correspond to the building just to how you upgrade things and the theme is kind of not really there but it's just a nice setting but it's colorful we know when it's on the board you have got all those color meatballs and it's a cool puzzle because the color meatballs are hidden from other players so they don't necessarily know if you've got a lot of red blue or yellow so if you bid on the tile for like two blue meeples I'm like does anybody ever have three blue meeples am I gonna get outbid I don't know how badly don't want this tile but then you give away the me pause you don't have a huge inexhaustible force of the things so you kind of need to be careful with your peoples especially if you're gonna put your meatballs on tiles that have already been built in other players villages because they're you getting the meatballs not you now of course they might come visit you but then the problem with that is they visited you and now your tiles are more expenses to go out even though you're going to get the meat was at the end there's a lot of stuff that comes from this and my god people can screw you over right royally in this game but it tends to happen across everybody but it's weird I just I like it the puzzle I think I get immersed in the theme of building that village even though the theme isn't really there although when you throw in farmers you do get to have pigs and sheep and that which is really cool but it's it just it's a bidding
game again I'm not usually the biggest fan of like bidding games but this one feels like all the choices are meaningful there's a good amount of interaction in this game because you're going to each other's villages maybe that's the thing this is not a multiplayer solitaire euro by any means you are interacting directly with players and this is also one of those few euro games where I can go we have six players do we keep our it's weird this actually works good at every play account I play it with two to six and that had a good time and all those counts but five and six I'm perfectly happy to play this game it just seems to work yes there might be a bit of downtime before your turn but the interaction with the players just seems to work very nicely with the whole five to six player thing so as much as I do I dare turn it over because the insert it's kind of ojung but yeah it's just a really cool where you've got the color meeples to bid on the tiles but then each player has their own little village they've made it themselves very near different paths to victory most of them pretty valid actually I mean I have won this game using all sorts of different methods and you don't even know necessarily what some endgame bonus scoring stuff is gonna be until the last round so there's some really interesting mechanics in here it if it dogs you to learn rule books have never been Richard Brisas our strong point sorry mate but the word is but and I haven't necessarily gone through the other key games as a result but key flower is just kind of stuck with me I like on board game arena I like it in its full version with a believe broken token insert and
everything yep broken token insert all the tiles and that nicely organized I think this will be sticking around for quite some time cool all right that shelf 43 have I got time for one more today I will have to see but shelf 44 is entirely now yellow games it wasn't originally but I've had to do a bit of a shift around recently and yeah there's one new addition in there actually if I've done this video any later you wouldn't have had this game on the shelf so on consider that eight bonus but yet five really fun yellow games to come so I'll see you them take care stay safe and just keep enjoying and watching the show