Citadels Duel Review: "Citaduels" is Right There
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vasel.
I'm Zee Garcia.
And one of the first games that got me into the hobby, or the current modern Euro game hobbies, was with Citadels, which came out just around 2000. I think it was
The year 2000.
the year 2000 or 2001 or something.
2000.
So Citadels is a very old game, but a fun game where you pick a role, and then you build these buildings in front of you. And it's a game that hasn't it's stood the test of time in some ways because it's still in print consistently, which is rare for games that came out back then. And there's been modifications to it over the years, and we've there's issues with it. You it can go up to seven players. You shouldn't, you know.
Right, right, sure.
There everyone always says you should build one less building than it says. Anyhow, but it's still a game that I like to play.
And it is one that had a two-player way to play. You could play with two, which also was not something I would recommend. Right. But lo and behold,
Citadels Duel!
Yeah.
So this is not from the same designer, Bruno Faidutti, who designed the original game. This is from um two other guys, Giamane Montiage and Manuel Rozoy.
Mhm.
Close enough, I think. Anyhow, this is a two-player version of Citadels. Is it different? Is it the same? Well, let's show you. At the beginning of the game, players are going to have council seats. Each person gets four. You flip the last one, and whoever has fewer council seats is going to go first. Each You're going to be building a grid, a 4 by 4 grid of buildings out in the middle. Each person starts with one. Every building has two sides to show if the white player or the black player has it. Each player also has a little board where you'll draw two special buildings, purple buildings, from a bag. And then the game begins. At the beginning of the game, players will be taking these nine cards. They're going to shuffle them. One card is out that round. And then each player gets four. Of the four you get, you'll pick two to keep, pass the other two to your opponent. Then of the four cards that you have, you pick three of them. The other one's discarded. After that happens, you will go through each card, starting with the number one, and going down. Now, what do the cards do? So, the number one card, the assassin, you call a character. If your opponent has it in their hand, they discard it. Number two is the thief. You say a character. If your opponent has it in their hand, you can steal three gold from them or from buildings that aren't protected. So, let me talk about this. Each building at the end of the game is going to be worth points equal to the gold coins on it.
When you build a building next to a building of the same color, you put a coin on that building for each building of the same color it's next to, whether it's yours or not. These coins are going to make these more valuable. There are other ways to add coins onto them. There are ways to steal buildings from people. But, as the number three, the king, the king, first of all, gives you a seat at the council table, which means you will flip one of your opponents there, and he also gives you one for each yellow building you control. So, if I was white, I'd get another one here. And he moves the king's guard. The king's guard protects the building it's on and all the adjacent ones from a lot of different things that are going to happen. The abbot, if you have fewer than your opponent, they give you a gold. You build a district, so you can build the top one from one of these piles here, and there's a one to four of each color mixed in there, or you can build one of your purple buildings.
And you'll reduce it by the blue buildings you control. Five, merchant gives you three gold, and you can put a gold from the supply on each green building that you control, or up to two of them that you control. The architect lets you build two districts, reducing the cost by one. The diplomat lets you steal someone else's unprotected district, but you'll have to pay seats giving them to the other person equal to the value that you've stolen it from. The warlord also lets you take control of something, but there you pay gold for it, or you can move the king's guard, and then the queen gives you council seats here up to the number of colors. So, let's say the white player, I would get two because I have two different colors. Now, this matters because after you go through all the cards, and each player will be playing three of their cards, then whoever has more council seats is going to get three gold from the supply, and they can build a building.
The other player will get two gold from the supply, or they can build a building. You're going to continue doing this. When you build, you are restricted to a 4 by 4 grid. So, once the lines have been made, that's it for the grid. And at the when the grid is finished, that ends the game, and you simply count up the gold of each building that's worth of your color, plus the gold that's on them, and whoever has the most points wins. Oh, yeah, each every two seats in the council is also worth a point.
Obviously, this is not a two-player card game of Citadels.
Right.
But at the same time, I think that they have effectively captured the spirit of the original game in many ways.
I agree. It's a really nice I I think in the spirit is a good way to put it. It feels like Citadels in many ways, while giving you things Citadels does not even contend with or deal with the idea of, you know, putting out buildings that that care about the geometry of the thing, what's next to what. That's not a a concept in Citadels. There's a nice push and pull in this that gives you that feeling of, "Hmm, what are you doing? Maybe I'll do this over here. Maybe I'll I'll distract you over there while I steal this thing from under you. There's definitely some of that confrontation that you get in Citadels, but funny enough, I think it feels less mean in this game because anything I do is effectively pushing you down and vice versa. Whereas in a game with five players, if I pick on Tom, I am basically helping the other three at the table, kind of sort of.
Yes.
That's interesting.
It does a good job. You the assassin and the thief, which are both very mean cards. Actually, there's four mean cards in this set cuz there's also two that let you steal buildings. But the assassin card, which is some people hate that card from original Citadels, he calls out the king. That was the one thing I'm out that round, basically. I get something, but I'm not really in it. In this one, if if I don't have the assassin, I know you probably do. Or I've given it to you. Or there's a good chance it's out. But I know the five five of the nine cards that you might have.
Mhm.
I know that you went down to three of them. You know that I know that, so there's a bit back and forth. But here's the thing, if I use the assassin and I'm not successful, all I've done is slightly negate you, which is a legit thing, but it's not all powerful. New players are going to think the assassin's amazing. I played this with my son and he was He thought the assassin was the greatest thing on earth until he realized, "Oh, that doesn't actually help me build buildings."
Right.
Sometimes it's important because I'm going to stop you from building two.
Yeah, I know. It's very
it might be.
Right. If you get the right thing, if you attack the right thing, sure. Yeah, but in the original game of Citadels, at the beginning of your turn, you would gain income or draw cards. Then you could possibly assassinate someone and take their entire turn out. In this one, the assassin does not come bundled in with any income. You The cards have to do that. So, at best, I have one fewer character, so do you. At worst, I whiffed and I just shorted myself a character. It's It's great because, yes, it seems powerful, and it can be it can be a key removal of something if you're speeding up a little too much, but I think it really achieves the the the the intent behind the assassin, which is which is I have to remove a key piece of your machinery.
In the original game, that that's gotten lost on new players, I think. It just feels like, "Haha, skip a turn." Yeah, but why? In this one, it makes sense.
The game looks and feels great. I love the dual-layer board in here, and hilariously,
Yeah.
they sell a playmat version of the board.
Like a neoprene thing.
Why would you want that? This board is great. And but I like the pieces. I like the They've been They're still using these little gold like on butterscotch pieces from the original game. I like them. I like the art. And I think it plays really smoothly. It will take a bit to get used to, and you have to remember you're fighting for those king seats or the seat that seat the council seats because that's a huge swing at the end of every turn for me to get money and build something and the other person to not.
Yeah.
And in fact, the game could be a huge swing, but it doesn't bother me because it's the box says 30 minutes, but it could easily be a 20-minute game. It is not particularly long.
Yeah, yeah. I think mechanically that push and pull, which you have to do I I feel like al- almost every dual game includes some sort of tug-of-war mechanism in it.
Otherwise, it shouldn't be called dual.
Right. So, it's It's sort of a given. In this, it's very well implemented. I I like the translation of the cards into tiles, and I like that push and pull with the seeds, you know, the back and forth. And kind of the round about way of of getting more influence, of doing more, building more is is, you know, translated through that. Uh I like that they're worth points, very few points, but points also. The scoring in this game feels good. The idea of the buildings getting richer, putting money on them. That's a character that that used to be in one of the Citadels, you know, expansions or follow-ups. There was a character that would enrich districts. They've taken that idea and removed it from that character and just put it in the game. Very well done. These guys, these two designers, clearly know Citadels inside and out, clearly understand the the drive behind that game, what's kept it in print for so long, and they've been able to distill that really, really well. Is it a game I want to play all the time? No, it is, by its very nature, limited in some ways. Uh but it's a really nice spin-off, and that's all you can really hope for with a game like this, that they nail that spin-off in the feel and in not excluding the original game, right? No one will play this and go, "I'll never play Citadels again."
That's not going to happen, and I love that.
What would you give it?
Um I'm going to come down at an eight on this one, but it's a really strong eight. I'm like, "Ooh." I could see myself um playing this a lot, I'll put it that way, and I could see it creeping up in the future because it is punchy, man. It's a real punchy game. I think it's one that's going to It's going to have some legs, uh which is great, you know. So, yeah, for me, an eight out of 10. Absolutely try it out if you like Citadels, if you were just kind of okay on Citadels, and you love dual games, you still might love this cuz a lot of those issues go away with two.
Yeah, I'm also giving it an eight for pretty much the same things. I think if you love Citadels, you will like this.
Yeah.
I think it works really that crossover is going to work really well. And if you didn't like it, and I know some people who don't like it because of the assassin and thief in the original game, this this might this might It might not, though, because again, then this game, the architect feels meaner, and there's also the council seat. Sometimes you're like, "You have seven council seats. I need to get them back."
And it might feel swingy, but that's kind of the nature of the beast, yeah.
But it's fast and quick, and I think it stands out as a good two-player. I would never play Citadels at two. I just wouldn't. It just it doesn't work. I'm I'm sure there's someone's going to say there's some amazing variant. But now I'm never going to do it because I have this.
Yes, right.
So, if you're looking for the two-player version, and if you never even heard of Citadels,
Yeah.
It's still a very interesting back-and-forth game that's really beautiful, too. I like the whole look of the thing. So, that's Citadels Duel. I'm Tom.
I'm Zee.
We'll see you next time. Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you liked this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.