Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Greatest Board Games Ever Made?! | Legacy Games Explained

Transcript 12:40

legacy it's all about what you leave behind the memories and the impact your actions had on the future in my case that might just be the frustrations when prizing my possessions from my cold dead hands after years of finger strength training but for a board game it's usually the sting of losing or the sweet taste of victory or the general annoyance of someone playing chi in scrabble on a triple word score isn't that right sharon anyway how was your new years but that's the thing because that absolute con job of a scrabble game was swept away back into its lovely green felt bag and the next time that we i mean the characters in the story got it out again the slate was cleared of any remnants of wrongdoing except in here on the whatsapps so how do you give a board gaming session a legacy well at their heart legacy board games are ones that you play multiple times and you unlock stuff as you go but everything you do unlock permanently changes what the next game is going to be perhaps you'll be writing your name somewhere on the board and permanently claiming some territory on the map as bumsville usa or maybe you'll be applying stickers to it that permanently changes the powers or abilities that players can use in future games or maybe and it genuinely pains us to do this you'll tear up cards never to use them again i just felt someone walk over my grave unlike other genres of gaming that emerged slowly and undetectably from other influences and inspirations like a

recently evolved quadruped crawling out of the sea we can trace the creation of legacy games to one board game and one board game designer and that game came out in 2011 and it was called risk legacy designed by mr rob davio it's a board game that you play multiple times and when you take out a box your game is like everyone else's but when you play it some of the things you do in one game are going to sort of cause echoes in the future game so when you start your second game your game is going to be different from other people's games and these are permanent changes you might be adding a card in or adding a sticker to a board so the game mostly resets but it picks up a little bit where it left off and you're going to play a series of games and new rules are going to come in and rules are going to come out cards are going to come in and out and your game is going to kind of become your own story and at the end of a set number of games sometimes 10 12 14 or something that the campaign and the story will end and your game will have been a different experience from every other person's game so it's sort of like a season of television because risk used to be a game you'd bring out every so often with different people but with a similar experience whereas risk legacy demanded you play it regularly with the same group of people to tell one long evolving campaign style story with surprises changes to the gameplay and crucially a fixed limit on how many times you'd play because you play 15 games of risk legacy no more no less you can't even play regular risk afterwards using a legacy set because the game will instruct you to destroy

country cards the winners of games can name their own cities which are mostly variations on the word bum bumsville bummington bumbleside you get the id bum on tweed that's a good one you can then choose bonuses that will change future games and then they can make their next step on the campaign long journey of being a global superpower risk is very conquering and very aggressive and has a lot of like trash talk and in your face sort of approach and the idea of like taking a card and ripping it up in front of someone felt very um taboo but also very risk like oh you wanted this well it's gone forever how do you like that now and it's that sort of get under your skin thing that risk was known for because risk legacy existed for a time by itself a one game genre in equal measure baffling exciting and traumatizing players who really didn't want to mess with their precious games just look at adam stop making me do this in 2015 four years after risk legacy came pandemic legacy season one and that's when legacy games really exploded because much like pandemic popularized the fledgling co-op genre of gaming back in the late 2000s pandemic legacy made legacy games the next it style of gaming like risk legacy it re-skinned pandemic taking mechanics that everyone knew and loved the travelling the world treating diseases everyone having unique power and working together and tied multiple games of that together with a campaign that told an epic story we have 12 games

so we have to tell a story and like well if we do it in three acts then you've got three acts of four games each and what are big changes and what are little changes and how do we start and we really like we read up on screen writing and thought of like beats and upbeats and downbeats and characters and introducing new characters we thought about it as 12 episodes of television and that's the key word that made pandemic legacy different story because while risk legacy gave players a toolbox to tinker with their own game pandemic legacy sat players down and told them piece by piece a tale of panic violence cities falling and governments having to make difficult often inhumane choices oh and the people making those choices that's you and your choices have permanent consequences maybe you'll lock off a continent forever behind permanent barricade stickers that last for all future games sure all of those countries are doomed but what choice did you really have scared you're ready you will be i mean i've just remembered what's actually happening in the world right now here's some lovely footage of pigs pandemic legacy was so beloved it shot to the top of the board game geek top 100 and stayed there for two years only to be knocked off that top spot by gloomhaven another legacy style game involving a long sprawling campaign bonus characters you can unlock and enough stickers to put on your board

to mummify a dog these poor dogs happy pigs again so the top two board games of all time voted for by gamers themselves the top two games ever made are legacy games and now loads of them are being made every single year betrayal legacy a variant on the classic betrayal at house on the hill clank legacy machikoro legacy pandemic legacy season zero just came out to rave reviews we've got frost haven in the works what is so intoxicating about them to produce such a strong reaction for me um what makes legacy games so appealing is knowing that you're going to be going on a journey with a set group of people and knowing that there's always going to be some kind of surprise in the next session it's very similar to why a lot of people i think like tabletop role playing games you have a set group of people that you know that you enjoy playing games with and you just get to go on an adventure with them for me it's that kind of half stress half morbid pleasure of like permanently damaging a game i'm so anal about my games like i sleeve all my cards i get really really precious about the components so doing like going in there and like permanently not wrecking but kind of like deforming your game in order to suit this one story that you're on that it just makes everything feel like high stakes

gifts presents treats how do i get to the trees i can't open it why you're telling me i can't open it so now i want to open it right how do i do that and that was like the biggest finding i had out of risk legacy other than this actually works is that those things are very precious and are major draws and major plot points for making the game flow and it's just true surprise parties people like surprises and treats and feeling special and the unknown and having things sort of wrapped up it's like you know why people say no no spoilers don't tell me because you like to discover things on your own for the first time and that's what a legacy game does that a lot of board games don't do a lot of board games let you discover how it's played how to play well what a good strategy is and this offers all that but it also offers some of the same things you get from other entertainment so are there any warnings you need to know about before you rush out and buy a legacy game well there are one or two you see legacy games are on the most part luxury items they're big boxes stuffed with bonus components extra cards rules stickers and envelopes all the extra bits needed to make subsequent games feel properly different from each other and that can come with a hefty price tag pandemic legacy season one will set you back 50 bucks season zero is going to set you back 80 bucks and blue maven you're gonna have to sink a cool hundo to play that and obviously build a shed to keep it in there it is and that is a galling price tag for something that is by its own

admission a game that you can only play a limited number of times and people do really get hung up on that idea of a board game that you can complete that it's kind of a cardinal sin to have a board game especially an expensive board game that you can only play so many times i am choosing how many games you play and it feels like this reel up front like i've somehow violated this trust between designer and player and i can see how that's off-putting but what i'm trying to say is let me constrain the number of games you have but i will give you 14 really good games you might not get a hundred okay games you're gonna get 14 good ones and are you willing to make that trade i'm going to give you more of a concert rather than listening to the album but honestly it's not the expense that is really that much of a problem because after all the rigid format of legacy means that you're going to be playing with the same people every single time these are not games that you just keep in your closet for anyone to play they are games for specific teams so why not split that cost amongst all of the people playing because suddenly three people paying 35 quid makes gloomhaven insane value for money and now most new legacy games come with something called eternal mode meaning that once you finish the campaign you can then use your set to play regular games forever long as you don't mind stickers all over your board which i do i don't know who i'm looking at over there i'm just cross so no what really makes legacy games a luxury product is something else other than money that you're gonna have to invest and that's

something that's far more valuable frankly time it is literally by design impossible to get all or even most or even some of the legacy games full story and gameplay potential from just one session bits of the game are being actively hidden away from you what you need to do is you need to form a group come up with a schedule and try to meet up often enough just so you don't forget half of what you've done already so in that sense legacy gaming is much more similar to role playing games than regular board games and have you ever tried to get a group of people together on a regular basis for an rpg it is a nightmare luke's in my dnd group he'll tell you absolute nightmare it is also usually luke's fault so in conclusion legacy games are in a lot of ways the most that board gaming can be the most expensive the most time consuming the most just big but if you do have the money and more importantly the time to spend they can also be the most exciting as every new development makes the next game a fresh cool challenge well the most nerve-wracking is you make decisions that carry more weight than any decision you'll make in a normal board game and more importantly your gaming group is going to have the most memorable experience because thanks to all the different decisions from each game piling on top of each other you're gonna have an experience that no one else is getting within jokes moments and memories unique to your select group of friends so should you invest in a legacy game

yeah 100 absolutely but for the love of god only invest in one at a time and if you'd like to know which legacy game would be right for you to invest in check out the collection starter this week as adam runs down some of the best on the market synergized content right i'm off to actually achieve something now so that when i do give my own eulogy at my funeral i faked for myself i actually have something good to say

Progress saved