Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 170: Jarrod Carmichael on Red Dust Rebellion

Transcript 58:52

it's adbreak time I'm proud to announce that the Beyond soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University Center for Learning through games and simulations this week I want to remind you all that se GS continues to offer classes in partnership with Gen Con and the next one starts on October 14th veteran instructor aloy Lanta will be teaching when Worlds meet mechanics turning fiction into games I know this class is going to be amazing and you should absolutely sign up for it also if you want to support this podcast please visit patreon.com beond soliter and help me keep the lights on but for now let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davids from beond Sol here and I'm super happy to have a special guest on the podcast this week this is Jay Carmichael AKA that guy from three minute board games how you doing Jay hey yeah I'm doing great uh K to everyone out there kto um beaming to you live from the sunny South Pacific and it's actually a pleasant uh sort of cold Winters day at the moment so yes I'm in the Midwest and I'm annoyed that it is not cold enough I moved to the Twin Cities to be cold and it's like in the 80s outside right now this is lies oh dear but we have the same outfit on so yeah I mean it's it's really nice outside it's just it's just chilly but the thing with New Zealand a the we we don't have temperature extremes so like I think we go between like 60 and 80 we don't go outside of that so it's it's never particularly hot or particularly cold that sounds kind of wonderful honestly yeah that's

great it's fantastic you can wear you can wear shorts all year most of the country or you can wear hoodies all year most of the country whatever you're more comfortable doing but you could do a hoodie with shorts and then you've got The Perfect combo um I'm not gonna show you but yes you can do a hoodie a hoodie with shorts all right so down to business down to business um so I've actually had you on the podcast because uh you are not just a content creator much as I dislike the term uh you are a game designer uh and that's what I wanted to talk about today so you got a game that is hopefully going to be hitting the porch soon uh Red Dust Rebellion I think they are planning on starting charging for it on September 17 so very very shortly after this is being recorded and then it'll start shipping after that it's been coming into the warehouse as they've been doing GMT has been doing their yearly sale um so they like had you know limited amount of capacity to deal with the yearly sale and this this big game game so I think it'll all have arrived um hopefully because it's quite they've done quite a big print run apparently um it'll all have arrived in time to be sent out hopefully at the end of the month so so for people who don't know what red dust Rebellion is what's like the the quick overview of this game so red dust Rebellion is part of a series of games called the coin series

or counterinsurgency series uh counterinsurgency games are war games where one side is not balanced to the other so in a traditional war game you will have armies of knights or Napoleonic soldiers and cannons lining up or tanks and whatever but there'll be people wearing uniforms or and ranged on a battlefield going to fight a regular War consists of one faction like that uh but the other factions uh tend to be um either local peasants or something who are um rising up and you know they take up to go fight and then they go back to their Village at the end of the day they're not regular soldiers and earlier games in this series include a game about Viet the Vietnam War um which you know strongly featured people in South Vietnam um who were villagers essentially that was their day job was farming and then they would fight against the American and South beames government there's one about Afghanistan where one player plays the Taliban it's that kind of regular Force versus irregular Force course the difference with red dust Rebellion the the special Source here is that this is the first game in this well received and well regarded historic wargaming series that is completely made up that is complete fiction that is a u fictional conflict that has been created solely for the purpose of making a war game and the

funny thing about it is we go go back way back to 2017 even before I started three minute board games and I was just fiddling about with this idea for a Sci-Fi coin game and I was like oh maybe I'll do a print and play or something uh I should probably ask like volco if it's okay if um I do a printer play of of because you know I'm borrowing his game system you know it feel rude to put out a printer play of his game without first asking permission and literally is like we have been thinking about doing sci-fi coin game and no one's sort of done anything and you've kind of turned up with a half buil game so do you want to make it and I was like well yes and just that is literally the pitch was me going I'm I've made a print and play I I'll throw it into the pot and then it got packed up so here we have the science fiction setting that I've built heavily inspired by a ton of uh classic Mars sources um because Mars and science fiction is always the birthplace of rebellion against uh Earth it's always where they tell either anti-colonial stories or stories that parallel the American Revolution because like here's the first colony that is rising up and trying to get its own independence the whole Patriots and T party and all that kind of stuff um really mirrors into what

happens in Martian conflicts in science fiction and it also ties into a personal experience here which is the identity of New Zealand as a country so if you don't know um New Zealand was up until 1945 a a British Dominion so we were directly ruled by by Brit we had sort of Independence but for most purposes uh Britain could tell us pretty much what to do and and we just went along with it we are like 18,000 km away from the United Kingdom as far as you can be on the planet pretty much if you if you drill a hole uh in in New Zealand it comes out the other side just in Spain somewhere so just down from from the UK and we've only really had our own sort of nationhood in the last like you know few generations and we we don't really know what it means to be a New Zealander yet that we don't have a really strong national identity we're still trying to figure that out so this game about Mars uh allows me to sort of explore that idea of of what is it what does it mean to create a new a new people um and of course the analogy is the distance between New Zealand and the UK is basically like Earth and Mars oh that's awesome man this is actually this is so I I've only recently started getting into sci-fi I used to

just totally avoid sci-fi themes and I've really like done a major 180 on that in like the last year or so so it sounds like you are very deeply read on sci-fi topics especially Martian Rebellion topics I don't fiction yeah I do not read fiction so no I don't I I watch movies and stuff and I read non-fiction books um I basically haven't read a novel I think the last novel I read was one of the Harry Potter ones uh 15 years ago oh it anymore well there's that too um and that was when I was training to be an English teacher and I was like I should probably read more fiction um but yeah Fiction's never been my thing I love um non-fiction and I especially love um like roleplay games that publish World Books so they're fiction but they're presented in a non-fiction format so that like like talking you know having all of his his histories and stuff like that or a d and supplement which is like here's the kingdom of blah and I can read 300 pages on their history and stuff because deep down deep down I'm a historian like that's that's what I trained to do I've done political science defense studies and history and as even as a kid I was the dropped me off in the non-fiction section I'll read encyclopedias and and books about war and tanks and um engineering and all that kind of stuff I didn't really read a lot of fiction which is funny because I love sci-fi so

so if you're watching if you're watching the movies then or reading fake history um what are what are some good like Earth Mars conflict films watch probably like the classic one is the the original Arnold swz andega Total Recall like that that that has it all it's got um you know explosions and mutants and and the fantasy about a green Mars terraforming Mars uh in it uh it's got amazing Gunplay catchy line see you at the party RoR um it's just a great film um and also like uh Babylon 5 uh was a a show that did it really well um where there was a central Earth government that was becoming more and more fascist and uh Mars was really the first place that started fighting back against them and they played out this Martian Rebellion all the way through that story and more recently uh so after after I did all the stuff with red dust Rebellion I saw the expanse TV show and that is another show that while it didn't directly influence um rust Rebellion because I saw it after um writing the setting up it definitely could have like there's so many like common themes with the expanse and I was watching going oh yeah no this is people who like the expanse will definitely get a kick out of red dust Rebellion the main difference is Red Dust Rebellion uh has zero alien stuff so I I've gone for

absolutely a human focused conflict there's no strange relics or alien presence or wobly things happening uh it's all very very grounded and very real so why did you choose the coin setting for this yeah so really really easy easy answer for that uh so as I said my background academically I used to teach a paper at wer University or co- te because I it was a senior lecturer and I was their assistant uh on the ethics of armed conflict so that revolved around things like just War conventions uh Guerilla Warfare war crimes torture all that kind of those ethical questions uh that pop up with with armed conflict or the use of Violence by the state so I've had this passion and interest in that kind of field of irregular and versus regular war and all of those hairy questions and I've never found a war game that really represented how those conflicts work uh because if you try to model those conflicts in a standup fight then Vietnam could could have been one with more bombs and we know that the Vietnam War could not have been one with more bombs they could have bombed everything and they still would not have won the the US would not have won the Vietnam War and South Vietnam would not not have won because more bomb doesn't win an Insurgency and then I played a dist plane and I was

like this gets it this is this is exactly what gets it and I was playing a distant plane and fapping about with it one day and it was a documentary on uh Mars by sort of dood drama so it had like documentary bits and then dramatic bits and it was done by Ron Howard and it was all about Martian colonization so they did talk to some scientists about the various issues and then they' acted out as a sort of dramatic dramatic scene so buggering about with this rule book and watching this and I'm

like and that's exactly what happened like I'm like huh a distant Martian plane maybe and yeah so I started thinking well what about what about like what happens once this Colony gets to a certain SES and starts going we want our own rights if you've got all these corporate interests that have sponsored it who 200 years later uh is going to care who the billionaire um who paid for the initial thing is if if you've got six generations of you living on this planet and um it's not an easy thing to go back and forth so if if we we're building there there will be people who end up staying um and they will become martians and eventually they'll be like um actually I wouldn't mind a little bit of say in my life so yeah it's almost entirely caused by watching um this doco drama while reading the or setting up a solo game of adusted plane so fantastic and solo game a man after my heart all right so um the thing that's funny about that that you say that though is you know I okay so full disclosure everybody out there I've edited the rule book for for this game so uh a great job you did thank you I appreciate that so I I haven't played it which means that I like have read the rule book but then my my memory of the mechanism gets hazy but on that first pass I remember feeling like a lot of the stuff that you were doing in that game was pretty edgy and

like advancing coin in a New Direction you know you've got like an entire faction that like focuses on card play I had never seen in coin before like super cool so I guess really this is a Development question so I looked you up on YouTube and your your first announcement video that you had a game coming out is three freaking years old yep what happened between then and now in terms of development of this game and like when were those like cool changes introduced were they new were they in at the start like coming later so the development cycle kind of work like this so in 2017 uh when I first pitched the idea vco was like look I'll talk to GMT we're really happy to do this but we you won't get a shot at getting this on the p500 for years because we have like four four coins ahead of you already and I think like um pend Dragon was just just like the next one but there was a whole bunch coming out orbridge is burning um the Gandhi one there a few others as well that that were in the pipeline well ahead of this and like so just go away and work on it but we like the idea of Science Fiction we think that's really cool build up the setting as much as you want but try to keep it quite coin conventional um because we don't want to Spook people because we're going to put out a game that's um got a spooky setting that might bring in a new audience uh but it might scare off our

our established audience so keep it keep it a bit boring and we're like Okay cool so I I modeled it along and the game for all intents of purposes was a distant Martian plane like it was very much a distant plane with a couple of little little steps and pieces here and there to represent the difference between Mars and a few years later we had a you know they just let me do my own thing and I did iterative testing I had some friends help me out but mostly I just solo played solo played solo played and iterated until I got something I was quite comfy with um and then we had a big sit down meeting and it was Jason car uh from GMT volco and myself and I can't remember Adam who's the developer was there he may have been but he may have come on after that meeting um and there were like okay you've done a really good job following instructions and you've made this game very coin normal we hate it that is we've decided that is not the yeah that we've decided that is not the way we want to go at all and I'm like thank you because I have been iterating on this game and I've been just jotting down ideas of um other things we could do to make the game more interesting but I felt like itd been locked in this box so then we got the alren cycler uh which is the uh way that forces move back and forth between Mars and Earth and if

you're unfamiliar with the rationale behind an Elden cycle you've got Mars you've got Earth and you slingshot around one in an orbit and slingshot around the other one and you do this constant figurate uh back and forth and then when you're at the closest point um to either thing you launch shuttles that then go um to the respective planets load up and then go back so you basically there was a constant figure rate of these cyclers going back and forth and that's how we decided to do uh you know the resource system uh to do something different than Aid there were in a lot of coin games in fact most of them they had these things called lines of communication Locs um and they're quite a big big deal you know you you put troops on them uh the terrorists or Rebel forces attack them they can get lots of money and and shut down the the economy because of the way uh Mars was so split out I didn't think this made sense uh the lines of communications are going to be space ports and they're going to be Rockets back and forth and the magl livs that we've got there so we removed all of the economic factor from that and just just simplified that we then went okay we don't need a single board because Mars is so big we're going to make it into these different different environments to show showcase just how we're focusing on these three bits but Mars is a whole PL so Mak just kind of do that to get the scale of the game as well and I also love multi-

theater games because you can have one theater doing something while the other one's doing a different thing you can have three essentially three games playing out at once uh which I think is a really fun place to explore um and then about that time the Syrian and the ringa refugee G crisises were at their Peck uh and there were you know constant news stories about people being displaced U ethnic cleansing going on and just what happens when hundreds of thousands of people lose their homes and I was sitting there going and that's when you've got access to Water and Air what happens when you don't have those things when there's a refugee crisis on Mars uh so we brought in the displaced population system um which when you look at it it's actually quite Grizzly because if you don't have those people they're they're penal the the idea is that if all the infrastructure goes away the actual population of Mars drops and I think it's one of the few times you'll see in a war game where you can actually eliminate populations which is kind of grizzly um but I think I thought it needed to be in there to really reflect the model uh that that I was trying to describe we also added in the satellites at that point and IC can the red dust campaign cards so the red dust um political group gets to do these big campaigns where they like the Dock

Workers are on strike and that has an ongoing effect until the next reset or um mothers of Mars are protesting um so if the corporations do anything they they get Negative PR and the final one was the complete overhaul of the reclaimers so taking that faction and going I'm going to make these guys something very me and very different because I want an unpredictable unusual faction that just pops up out of the great deserts of Mars because the scale of Mars is mindboggling we have water over most of our planet right yeah so even though Mars is smaller its actual land area is the same as if you ignore the bits of the cab in water i' never thought of that before yeah so the amount of space you have to hide on Mars is mindblowing like there like with the level of population we have you'll have areas the size of Asia that have no one in them um and I kind of wanted to to represent that that you'll have this faction that's out there somewhere and in like a storm blows and all of a sudden they're there they're at your Gates they've comeing through the storm you're like oh damn I guess we got to deal with these guys now oh that's awesome yeah so we had

this big big overhaul and that was going along really well and that was mostly in place when we went to the p500 um because if you look at the p500 picture it's got all of that stuff in then we got Co and Co completely shut down um the advancement of things like uh the factory just wasn't printing stuff the shipping cost went through the roofs GMT kept delaying things um and that delayed the project quite a while um very little we could do about that and then I think the last bit was because I completely an utterly broke coin and they had to and solo modes are a really big deal for GMT now they're massive especially in the coin series I also broke the solo modes and um they took a lot of fixing so Joe Dost was brought on board um who uh Nick coin designer as well he's come got the pure land coming up shortly um and he had to build rebuild the Solo System for the ground up because the card system for the reclaimers utterly broke it and he had to test and test and test the and test the hell out of that and uh yeah so we got a that was another big job that took quite a while so that's where we got got your delays make him work make him work he's he's done an amazing job

because you know we had this established system that they brought out and because the reclaimers don't work anything like anything else coin yeah he had to go solve he had to go solve a problem that I didn't want to solve okay I like I like solo games but I I can't design modes for them like that just what come on come on man I'm kidding um so I have a question that kind of calls back to some of the stuff that you said and in this development chat so you mentioned that you wanted to hopefully help coin appeal to a broader audience um and then also not spook people who are already into it so coming into an established system that's perceived as difficult like coin um do you have concerns about your game reaching an audiences as broad as it could because it's in the coin series uh yeah like it's we haven't shied away from the complexity uh we have definitely sort of embraced that um but I don't think it's I don't think Red Dust Rebellion is remotely as complex as say a Twilight imperior no I don't I don't think I think the comp systems complexity is massively overrated once you understand the uh the main um Action System and how the cards work you can play it off those little reference sheets you can play it off fullpage reference sheet all you

need to know for your faction really is what are my four actions and three specials so yeah it but it might will likely bounce off a bunch of people but I honestly think coins um complexity is is egged and a huge part of my focus which is where you come in was on making the rule book uh more accessible and more easy to follow and there are a whole bunch of you know little techniques we we came up with like the um sign posting on each section with the icons whose faction rules those are yes so it's nice and easy to pass having a robust and easy to follow um glossery lexicon on the back where you can just go oh there's the article There's a summary as well that's I I love that I love the that we've got where you go back and you read up what's a unit and it actually gives you a blurb of what a unit is and then gives you the full length if you need to go look further and that is such a great uh great glossery then we got the play a uh the play playbook for the examples and stuff in there and if people actually sit down and go through that I think Red Dust Rebellion is quite accessible plus the scenario with put in the box has you IM medior like a lot of um coin games will start off sort of a little bit on the back foot Red Dust is

designed to be just straight into it like you should be throwing forces at each other pretty much from turn one and the plan for the expansion that I'm currently working on is to give people who are wanting a bigger Chun um Red Dust experience um the option for a long War so a much longer conflict because Red Dust is really designed to go two to three campaigns so yeah it's complex but it's not it's not far on the lake where you go through six campaigns like it is it's fullon frenetic but it's quick compar that's fair that's fair all right so oh there's a couple as we could go do you want to talk about Shadow Moon syndicates now or later uh we can do that we can do that later all right so here's what I want to know then uh so um you know you mentioned that you started design for this game before you began your channel so I find this interesting because I started my channel and I had no interest in ever ever designing a game I never thought I'd be a game designer I sore up and down it was never going to happen oops uh just like I don't like sci-fi apparently um but what um I guess do you think the same thing that same creative Instinct that wanted that pushed you to design a game drove your Channel or do you see

them as two totally different ways of engaging with the hobby I think it's I think it's two very different ways like my channel was actually motivated by rage more than anything else so game design was motivated by me wanting to create something I love I like creating things I've I've been a dungeon master I've run LPS um I've been the person who organizes game events so I've always been an organizer and and designer of play you know I made fan mods for my own games the channel initially started with me being so pissed off that when I look for a review of a game the shortest one I could find was 28 minutes and it was some get talking in circles going over and over the same points time and time again I'm like some someone has to be able to do this better than 20 minutes going back and forth someone has to be able to get the key points of of these games out in a short enough time frame because this is so frustrating I was like stuff it I'll do it myself and um so I did and apparently there were several thousand people who um thought the same thing were like oh thank goodness um now I can now I can find out good chunk about the game and then go look at a bigger review later that was the thing like three minute board games is not I don't think be indle channel it's one you look at to triage again so you go that sounds vaguely interesting what's said about

and you look at my channel and if there's big red flags on the game you're like oh it's got negotiation in it I hate negotiation then you can back off um if you go oh that looks intriguing then you know maybe go watch a shut up and sit down video uh maybe go watch gaming rules or watch it played or John plays games um you know video on on the rules or something TR track down another reviewer's take on it or look look at a playthrough or the rule book or whatever um it really is just there as a sort of a TR almost like a trailer in another way and I think one of the the reasons the channel my my my activity is very different into most board game review channels which go you know lots of views and then nothing mine just tick along I have like flat numbers for pretty much all my reviews they just keep taking along every single day and I think that's because people go oh uh we're playing um we're playing Seven Wonders tomorrow this is what it's like and they send it to people um so I just have this real strange flat like my wingspan uh track literally just goes like this and has not dipped or dropped since I put it out it's very odd when you look at other other channels so what's interesting about that is that you've had this kind of explosive Channel success that I think really changes your profile uh in the industry and how are you I guess reconciling the fact that you're board

game famous already uh with that you have a game coming out well I'm actually I've actually been really nervous that um because on one of the funny things and I'm not sure if you've had this experience but I've had a few content creators be quite nasty to me when I passed them if uh you know a bit of jealousy and a bit of um oh I just never passed anybody I languish here in the cellar so rough um I I've had like a reasonably wellknown content creator come on my channel and say that the only reason um I've got more subscribers than they do is that my audience are idiots with short attention spans and whoa out of line yeah so I've had a few bits of that plus I'm also quite Progressive so if someone's being like you know scummy or whatever I'll be like hey ease up on the racism sexism transphobia and that also has made me a few people out there who don't particularly like me because I'm quite steadfast and forth right in that regard so I'm actually kind vaguely worried that some of these gu uh folks are going to be like oh you've got a game out there allow me to destroy it and you know burnings or something I'll confess something about that which is that so I didn't even pay attention to who the designer was when the rle book came across my desk I was like oh jar car Michael I don't know who

I don't know who this is and so I just like read book and then I saw you announce it on Twitter and I was like oh oh it's that guy I know that is I had no CL well CU it's it's comparatively rare like I mean Tom vessel's done a game but he did that like a decade ago it was nothing personal um but I can't think of anyone else who's like got a got a really high profile that's that's sort of put out a game like you so I think it's starting to happen so um I actually have a prototype that I'm going to cover soon that Mike delissio and Dan Hughes did called that it's like I made you a mixtape so they made a mixtape game and you know Dan Hughes who got his start with you know a big podcast you know this game is broken and is is a dice tower face you know he and his daughter did cor quest ah yeah yeah yeah yeah that that that went off I've seen Ben Maddox from five games for doomsday say that he's working on stuff but I'm not 100% sure what it is um yeah and then if I were a big content creator I guess that' be mean but like I'm just yeah you know it's the shut up sit downs and and um yeah r or EA and Elaine um you know it it' be fascinating to see what some of them would come up with as a game I think I think and Elaine could could actually put out quite a good game because they they do have good thoughts

on board games and I but there's Al also the hazard of being a Critic yes sometimes like you don't necessar neily you aren't necessarily good at the thing that you're you're being a Critic of so it is it is a different skill set and you might might expose yourself so who knows these game these two games of M could hit stores and people get them and they'll absolutely rubbish them but I have good people around me who hopefully have uh cleaned up all my foibles and mistakes and polish the games up to sufficient standard to uh cover up my own inadequacies as a Des I think I think it looks good I think it's good uh but you know I think actually in that sense you and I are in a similar boat in that we both have games that are kind of on the way but not out yet yeah um I've had to completely change the way I do my channel because I now work for a leader so I um you know I'm now an industry creature and so I on that note there's a ax in three minutes is just being finished and I have uploaded it on my uh channel will be going out in a couple of weeks excellent uh it better be positive no I'm kidding spoilers uh yes very positive uh what a what a what an amazing game what a what an experience and something very outside the box so yeah here's me doing a promo for your for your the you're now

working for I also I did zero work on arcs I did none and so it was actually really funny like people at genom were like oh because I was at the leader Booth like oh y'all did did such great work on arcs and I'm like everyone else did great work on arcs actually oh good no I take full credit for this game that I had nothing to do oh man one of the funny things here is um root is probably Le the game's probably most famous game or most wellknown game is what I like to call coin adjacent it is in many ways like a like red dust Rebellion just f animals murdering each other um but it it uses so many of the same ideas of asymmetric War um like the the corebox straight out of it has the two conventional forces of the IE and the cat and then you have the Woodland Alliance and the Woodland Alliance are a classic gerer Force they are they are asymmetric Warfare in a nutshell uh and yeah Ro absolutely coin little Vagabond up doing just like whatever the hell they're doing yeah but okay so I will say before I came to work for leader I fully intended to continue my channel there are a lot of kind of designer critics out there I feel like it's common um you know Fred surl at H ludan is a designer and he has a channel um Edo who's done like lots of

you know games also has a channel where he talks about games um but do you feel that your I guess that your career as a designer and your career as a Critic um fit well together or and how are you making it work so my main thing is that I am signposting everything I I a big fan of disclosing things the last GMT game I reviewed uh I put a disim at the start saying GMT is publishing my game like and I trust the audience if someone hears that and then calls me a a shill I'll be like well I've disclosed it I've disclosed that I have this relationship bform um I think a lot you can get away with if you disclose exactly what um those relationships are and you set those boundaries so a real good example is I I'm friends with Garfield games like the the Sam and shim and Sam over there um and Bobby I used to work with Bobby uh Hill the designer of hadrians wall and the Anarchy uh we used to work together on the same project of the Department of Conservation we were working on bird banding uh so they're tracking things uh to keep track of uh of birds so you know conservation can monitor their numbers we worked on that project in a professional capacity and I've reviewed his games um and it's quite you're quite capable if you are professional enough of going

yeah I'm I'm judging this on its on its merits I always put a New Zealand disclaimer so if it's a New Zealand game I go we're promoting this game because it's a New Zealand designer and that's to say I probably know them really well because this country is this big so um and I've I've Savaged their games i' Savaged their games all the time like um the the last couple of Garfield games I thought have been just way too much like just too many systems too many moving parts and stuff they haven't been for me and you know you can be have these like professional relationships with people you but you can draw draw lines and you can signpost things and you can just have some integrity and not taking money um off them is is another thing as well so you know it's not like um gtha paying me uh through rev the games so right yes I mean I did have a financial relationship with chip theory for editing work and for video work um but again disclose disclose disclose you just gotta yeah you got to tell the truth so I think trust your audience to be mature yeah trust your audience to be mature adults about it and if there's people out there there are people out there who don't watch me because I take review copies and you know that's time Sher yeah that is that's on them they they can make that decision uh I signpost what I do so yeah yeah I yeah

one thing I've always found somewhat frustrating is that you know I'm explicitly have said on my channel I will no longer do board game reviews but you know I'll do little tutorials I feel like perfectly comfortable covering things that interest me because it's not a review but I know that somebody will say I love your reviews at some point in the next few years I'm G be like they're not they're not revie so speak their reviews how do you intend to I guess engage with criticism of your games once they're out there the world I probably won't an awful lot uh because I legitimately don't care uh there's One reviewer whose opinion matters to me and that's Dan thorough um I I read him ferociously and I'm I'm a giant Dan thorough Fanboy um if he hates my game I will feel sad uh all right I'll let him know to trash it just for otherwise I'm not that that fussed like people will like what they like yeah um the only thing I think I'd probably get upset about is if someone trashes something when they have got the world wrong if they go oh this is busted because of blah I'm like or the classic I've played this once this faction won therefore the game is busted and that faction will always wi that kind of thing will will irk me but if people genuinely don't enjoy the experience and for Red Dust Rebellion especially it's got a high complexity it's got very mature themes it's a very confrontational game you can literally be wiped out out of the game like people

can just smash you and you be certainly go there's not much I can do I'm I'm basically out of the game so it's not going to be for everyone and I think one problem I've dealt with with designers having designers and Publishers having a GU at me when I've review their games yeah is that not every game is for everyone like and that's fine if it's not for someone and it's their opinion that they don't enjoy that kind of experience I am not expecting if Ro ever plays it he'll hate it like Ro doesn't like games where you spend four hours punching each other in the face that is just not his Jam at all and that's fine like I would not feel um that Vado has done me a disservice by by pointing that out to his audience that in his opinion he wants a game that's L confrontational that again that's fine so I'm not going to I don't think I'm going to directly engage that much with um reviews of my game because I hate it when people look to me I I absolutely hate it when thank you so much for saying that because I also have absolutely hated that over the years um it's it's so uncomfortable it's like please let me just on your game and not have you watch me do it like I a particularly uh well-known uh publisher and um person um put out a game that had printing on it or symbols on it that was

so small that my friend with bad eyesight could not play the game like it was impossible he was just like the these are small little icons on the bottom of these pieces I I he had to take our word for it that they were there and we had to sort of abandon that game and I had to play it with a different group yeah and I included that feedback in um my review and a publisher sort of had a go at me about it and I'm like I like we just report what we doing and um I did not get another review copy from that publisher for quite some time um so you know I I prefer when Publishers say something like thank you for your thoughts yeah I actually don't like to be engaged with at all like even if the review is positive I'm like just no like of course part of this is because I want I read a lot I watch a lot of book and the discourse over there is very different from what is in Borg that makes sense like we're in a young industry um I feel like designers and media and players all have a lot more access to each other in our industry than in other creative Industries right now that are more developed but the pervading opinion in Book World right is that reviews are for readers and that you authors should leave reviewers alone Y and I do think that that is true but in board games that is not prevailing behavior um and so I've decided that for myself like I

know David reads reviews so David Thompson my Cod forite which is supposed to be out there uh but I personally I'm gonna be subscribed to The Forum on BGG for like rules questions but I'm gonna do my very best to just leave people's opinions about the game alone yeah yeah absolutely I also think it's it's a sopan task if you end up engaging like that and if you let your ego get in the way as well you get your hurt feeling because someone goes this game is the poopies and you're like no it is not the poopies um where where does it end like what's are you g to convince that person that they're wrong that their feelings are wrong no you're not a big whiner like yeah just take your lumps um again I I think there is a a where you can call out a review there was a review of a leader games game recently where someone posted an inflammatory review based on utter nonsense um I can't comment but laugh at it yes well it walks like a duck uh anyway um and you know people called that out but the publisher didn't need to the viewers did they were like this is horseshit this is absolute nonsense you are misrepresenting the the game for click baity reasons please stop doing

that so the thing is like if a game is dramatically misrepresented there's a good chance you won't even have to lift the finger because other people who played the game would be like actually um you play that wrong so CL oh yeah the internet is full of plenty of people who will correct you for anything so y oh yeah if you want I I'll give you a great anyone watching I'll give you a great content creation tip if you want more comments on your next video set up a chessboard wrong in the background oh my God that's diabolical I'm gonna try it and see what happens now yeah I I have done it and it works oh my God they cannot help themselves I it's on my backg video as well I put it put pieces in the wrong spot and and I just keep getting comments about it and it's one of my recurring recurring things is I'll deliberately put a couple of pieces for all on videos popular games and just just to keep people commenting so I was gonna put the normal title for this podcast but now I'm just gonna put like J car Michael's top tip for YouTube engagement it's it's really it's really cheeky and silly but oh they can't help themselves it's so funny all right so I feel like you're it sounds like you're living your best life

in the game world like you've got a thriv channel you've got a wonderful game design that's on the way out and you actually have a second one that is going to Kickstarter soon is that correct yes so I think the plan is in uh sometime in October or November that kind of ballpark um I'm not sure we have a fixed date yet but we definitely got a countdown uh and we're we're slowly releasing content for it and that game is Shadow Moon syndicates and Shadow Moon syndicates is a very different Beast to Red Dust value even though it just looks like more angry people in space Oh it's totally angry people in space like it is still angry people in space don't get me wrong um but it's a very different type of angry people so this one's an area control game with card manipulation and it has a couple of features uh that make the game very different um so first of all there are 10 faction in the starter set and you'll only play with like six or seven of them in the game at any given time so there'll always be a different mix and each faction has like it's a core mechanic so you Shuffle those all up but no one plays one of the factions you are a criminal mastermind Drafting and manipulating them so you'll be picking them up and doing stuff with them but you'll not necessarily own one of them so some games there'll be uh very aggressive ones in the mix and other games will be more passive and manipulative ones so that changes the complexion the core way the game works

is each card has an above the line ability and then a below the line ability if you play the card um on top of any random card you'll only get the top top ability if you play the bottom uh the card onto an empty table so your first card you play you'll get both and if you match suits you'll get both so if you match from the same uh Syndicate you'll get both or if you play a card face down you'll get to do a really basic action and then the next card you play gets to have both now there are cards that FS with other people's discard piles that allow you to draw cards out of other people's piles to your hand and play cards down to them there are ways to FS with a tableau of cards in front of you there is a burn pile of cards that have been assassinated that you can manipulate or resurrect um so there's this massive card interaction and it's all about putting influence onto the board so fundamentally it's an area control game but unlike most area control games there are missions on the board and they're they're in multiple different spots and to get your points you burn down all your influence in a region if you control that and claim the mission so instead of like building up influ on the board you're like build up drop build up drop build up drop trying to maximize those points to to finish those

objectives and so unlike a lot of yeah area control games the board state is incredibly Dynamic and a lot of the cards also have Push Pull um teleport draft manipulate a whole bunch of stuff that goes around moving bits on the board so the board States just this evolving chaotic mess and the final Quirk uh and probably my favorite part of the game is it goes for three rounds and each round you play six cards in the first and second rounds you'll pick up your discard pile look at it and put three cards under your uh board and then you put the others away then in the final turn the Tableau of cards you can manipulate goes away and everyone draws their six cards and they play the final round with a hand that they have built through the course of the game and in that hand you're hoping to have like the best combos you can have to score um the sort of objectives out on the board um because the mentality is the first two rounds are you using CRI criminals in this in the system and then the ones you keep are the ones You' added to your gang so it's that um Oceans 11 that's right I'm in we' we've got a job you son of a I'm in It's that kind of um building a criminal Syndicate fantastic and that that final round has um more points than the others so you end up with this two rounds of like jockeying

and positioning and the final round is just straight into it so I think especially as like we've got the 10 um 10 different factions and because when I designed this I kind of went a little overboard I made 16 and so there's another six that are going to be in expansion uh later down the line which I think it's going to be at the first kick starter as well um so you can just mix and match these power set combinations and have like a very different game experience each time um and it's so confrontational it is so in your face uh but it's it's pretty fast-paced so like experienced players can play a game in 30 to 45 minutes um and that is the whole time will just be you know full on I think it's a game promising yeah yeah the funny thing is this one started Life as a thought experiment where I was like I wonder what a vampire the Masquerade board game would be like so they all started off as um the vampire Clans and I was like you know I'm never going to be able to sell a vampire game maybe they should be sci-fi space Ganges or something and all went from there so excellent well you know I wish you many many successful designs cuz it sounds like you do this for the love of it I I love that yeah absolutely absolutely and I've got like a in my workshop because we're inside in the house because the house has better

internet but I have a a separate building on the back of the property which is just for for board games um so it's like my my photo studio and and everything but it's also my game design space and up there I have pinned on the on the wall currently nine different pictures for board games I want to do so I've got so many ideas it's a matter of uh getting time because I'm not really a full-time content creator or full-time designer actually a full-time dad um my daughter is three and a bit um she goes to kindergartens two mornings a week and the rest of the time she's with me or Steph if Steph's not um working so um a lot of this happens after 7 o' at night to bed you just got to squeeze it in um so speaking of honoring your time like we've been on the on the line for a bit uh what are some games that have been bringing you Joy recently to play oh we just played arcs like so but that that feels like a Shameless plug um let me just quickly grab my trell board so I can see what I've played that I've really liked lately oh wonderlands War uh was one that I played uh recently that I thought was absolutely fantastic um and the reason I like that is I I've enjoyed qu of quinber but I

found it a bit point so like I love the bag building idear and it but ultimately I was like okay yeah we kind of pulled the bag it's it's fun one war takes that bag pulling system and basically turns into a area control war game and it's really good it's so much fun um I I love that if you're not involved in a battle in that game you can bet on the outcome and that gets you a point so while everyone else is pulling stuff from their bag you're actually invested because you're like oh I want I want that person to win because if they win then I get a free token so everyone's everyone gets uh hooked in into what's going on so that's been a NE game and the other kick I've been on is small box games at the right I've um we've been playing a bunch of cockroach poker Red Seven um Trio which I think it's called Nana it's a Japanese Japanese game uh wi the film which is another little Japanese card game love lad because I've done a whole bunch of very heavy Euros like Hony and stuff in the last we while um pulling out a game where I'm like this takes five minutes than just just play has been quite quite joyful and the other one is of course Arkham Horror the card game uh I have been pretty much one night a week uh sometimes two nights a week just doing Arkham that

that is the game I have played the most um the last year by a factor of T we've played through six six full campaigns in person and I've done about another 12 on tabletop soon so that is wild I all right and then um not this is probably more people listening this know you than me but where could you be found on line if people are looking for you so the easiest way to find me is three minute board games on YouTube uh we do have Facebook but Facebook's awful so don't don't don't look for me there find me on YouTube um we also have an Instagram but I barely ever use it so and blue sky blue sky not that stupid other side blue sky and I'm there are three games I think excellent uh I of course can be found everywhere as beyond solitire for those of you who listening Jay thank you so much for coming on the show this is fantastic and I really really enjoyed getting to chat with you yeah that was a really good station and I enjoyed talking to you too all right everybody out there uh please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming

Progress saved