Beyond Solitaire Podcast 200: Thoughts on the State of Historical Gaming
Transcript
It's ad break time. I am proud to announce that the Beyond Solitire podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations. This summer and going into the fall, CLGs has some seriously exciting projects in the works. On July 8th, they're going to launch a campaign featuring two games, Witch Hunt 1649 by Martha McIll and Making History by Nicholas Proctor. Both of these games are exciting in the classroom and beyond. And actually, both have been discussed by the designers on this podcast. So, keep an eye out on July 8th. And let's get on with the show. Hey gamers, this is Liz Davidson for Beyond Solitire. And uh this is the beginning of episode 200 of the podcast. I'm super excited we've reached this point. And for this episode, I decided to do what I did for episode 100, which is interview some luminaries in the hobby about the state of historical gaming, where things have been going for the past two years, uh, and where we think things will go in the future. So, there's a variety of interviews coming up. It's a bit of a longer episode, but feel free to pick and choose. There will be timestamps and names in the show notes, and I hope you enjoy it. All right, gamers. I'm here with game designer Vulco Run, who's also here for episode 100. So, now that we're recording for episode 200, we're going to like reprise our previous conversation about the state of historical. Yeah, which was like two and a half years ago. So, yeah. Yeah, I had to go back and and and watch it and see what we all had to say back then. Yeah, it was wild. So, that was back when Almarid was new. Yes. Uh and you were
teasing some new game series. So, how has Levine Campaign developed in the last couple years? And then what are those series and how are they? So, uh, and I had mentioned back then we were just about to release Inferno volume 3 which was set in Italy and we had several more in work and all of that is still true and still going forward. So, since then volume four plantaginate came out the first uh uh 11 campaign design that I was not a designer. I was involved but the designer um Paco Gradisha um and developer Chris Koreah you know had larger parts in that and it and it's so it's that much different right I mean think about like in the coin series the first few I was involved they're pretty similar and then they start to get more and more different as as more and more designers take over so plantaginet um you know took the series of new very wellreceived sold out faster actually than you know any of my volumes did which is great uh and um I think was seen as as as more accessible um and uh and you know did it did its own thing with a very different kind of conflict a civil conflict in the late middle ages the wars of the roses. Anyway, so we're about to have Seljuk volume five by Justin Fisino go to go to press. Uh and we and um then after that will be um Henry um by Joe Schmidt which is a um a smaller more digestible volume even I think than uh than Plantaginet was and
and and we'll go on and we've meanwhile also expanded to ancients uh you may know um with um or I don't know but basically the Athenians in Syracuse during the postian war for living campaign ancients volume one so that hopefully also will be um printed someday and and we we go on. Excellent. And then uh I guess at least the beginnings of your teased new series are out there in the world right now. So I I uh as you know with Lebian campaign I was very interested in like logistical affairs and operational warfare in the middle ages and just the middle ages military thing in general which I thought was underrepresented and also command and control and social relationships and how does the feudal system use military forces that kind of stuff. Uh, I've since become fascinated with how in board games do we represent limited information, secrets versus mysteries, in particular, how does that affect um deception, which is uh I've got some secrets, but I can selectively release some information to you to mislead you as my opponent. And I've got a uh I wrote a an article published in C3I that kind of looked at the history of how board war games handle that stuff. And of course, standup locks and cards and all kinds of things like that. Anyway, so I've got a couple of games that are, you know, nearly printed but not printed
yet that do that. One is Hunt for Blackbeard with Fort Circle Games and the others is Coast Watchers with GMT Games. And um both of those um could be uh the first volumes of new new series that do that in somewhat different ways. They have some similarities, but they're really uh mechanically different. Um so we'll see how Hunt for Blackbeard goes. If folks like it, there could be other Hunt games. Coast Watchers is volume one in what I call the Recon series. Coast Watchers is set in World War II uh in the Pacific. And volume two, which is already on P500, is called Draen Reconnaissance at Verdun 1916. So set in World War I, but very similar block, chit, pull, card mechanics that try to emphasize secrets and discovery of secret information and thereby uh including deception.
Nice. And then how do you think that our field has evolved over the last two and a half years? like what trends do you see? Yeah. Starting or continuing? Yeah. So, you know, when I rewatched episode 100, uh we were talking about the breadth of topics in historical board games and and uh you know, other other uh designers you had on I think sounded some similar themes. um whether it's glass half full or glass half empty, you know, um c certainly there's plenty of room to grow, but that that was the trajectory that we were seeing more and more different kinds not just and not in different kinds of war games in different settings, different parts of the world, different eras like the Middle Ages, but also more historical simulations, serious treatment of historical dynamics in a board game that are not focused on military affairs or warfare. fair. So we all it seems like we had some agreement that was happening and kind of my forecast was there's nothing that's going to stop that. Um, and I do think that that that is coming true. And so some seinal moments in that, for example, what Fort Circle Games or or WHL gig are doing, I think.
um votes for women from Tory Brown seems to me I mean it's almost like a it's almost like a a wingspan in terms of you know kind of throwing open the doors to the general board gaming community and saying well and I don't know if it says this it's a little bit hidden but but votes for women mechanically has a war game genealogy you know through through card driven games it's certainly um a a a compelling model of a historical dynamic and a historical episode of great consequence, a serious issue um but presented with a um euro or mainstream aesthetic, right? Like you know chunky wooden pieces and beautiful art and all of that quality uh by by Fort Circles team. uh and that has succeeded so wonderfully well and gotten such great um exposure not just by the way in the board game community but in the in general news media um that uh so that's just like one kind of to me shining example of uh the direction that we have been going in the last um uh two and a half years. Um I mean another one to mention just very recently is is Molly House um which was one of the projects that you know Zenobia helped whatever give more exposure move along you know I don't know how much we can claim you know Zenobia didn't create it Joe Kelly created it but uh Molly House
but um uh the the the early reception to that title um seems to be um enthusiastic and and and broad enjoyment and uh and that's again a a historical topic you know it's it certainly not anything to do with uh you know with with war um but more than that a historical topic um you know g gay society and 18th century London that I you know would we have expected to see that 20 years ago almost certainly not you know and here it is broadly popular. So, I know just some signs I think that our um projections from two and a half years ago have been coming true. Yeah, I think um while the traditionalists among us have like sort of fought this, I do think that historical wargaming is more of a mixed stew than ever. Yes. What do you mean by mixed stew? Like that we're all sort of collectively there's no true separation.
If you're going to conventions like SD Hiscon or DC, like there's not a separate this is a war game and this is a historical game. It's the same designers, the same players, and the same spaces. Yeah. Where this is all showing up. U that definition collapse is happening. Okay. Yeah. So, I wasn't sure if Big Stewie meant kind of some good, some bad, which is also typically true of human affairs, right? But yes, the boundary lines are getting blurrier and blurriier, is aren't it? the definitions are getting harder and harder to crystallize and pin down. And I noticed exactly what you said about players. And I noticed that too about um you know uh content uh creators um and and designers uh so so so people like yourself um that that I almost never now encounter encounter let's say videographers who only do traditional you know what I mean only do traditional war games it's like there's just there's the typical case seems to be somebody who enjoys traditional war games and also enjoys things that are anything but traditional war games at the same time.
And and it's yeah, you're right. It is in our in our individual participation another sign of the blending of our our tribes, you know, of our crosspollination because it happens within our within individuals like us. Yeah. Uh so um we are at an uncertain time when it comes to the future of gaming in general uh because of tariffs and market uncertainty and you know lots of small companies with small margins. But what I'm just going to assume we're going to do this again for episode 300 in about two and a half years. And so what do you think um our trend lines are going to look like going through our rough patch and then hopefully out of it in a couple years? Well, I'm I'm going to give you a new forecast in in that regard, a trend line that I I feel like I'm experiencing. You know, when I watched episode 100 and your co-designer, um David Thompson, I thought had a very astute comment on how we are answering your question, which is he said, you know, he's speaking from his own, you know, what he's fascinated by at the time or whatever. And I'm the same. So, I don't, you know, I'm not really an industry analyst. I don't have any numbers here, you know, to justify here's the trend we're seeing. And this may be to some degree what I am seized by at the moment, but I do think it's it's real. So, I will venture this this forecast. And you know, we've been talking about kind of the breadth of the coverage, right? Like what do what kind of topics do we take on? And that is an aspect of um broadening the um the the
the accessibility of the medium of board games to explore history, right? That if we kind of take on the kind of historical topics that interest you, you're more likely to experience our medium, you know, and and and come and join us uh in exploring history in this way through board games. So that there's an accessibility aspect to it. Um uh the forecast I have is that historical board games across, you know, on average, right, across the genre will be more accessible to more people, to more board gamers of of different tastes two and a half years from now than they are today. And so what makes accessibility So, so one thing is, would you agree, Liz, that traditional war games tend to be more complicated than other board games?
Would you agree with that? I think at least in their feeling they're not there's lots of stacks of things, small pieces everywhere. They at least appear complicated even if the rule set itself isn't right. Yes. Um, so that's an important thing right there is how you present the M. When you say the rule set, I'm thinking like now mechanics, right? Yeah. Like what you're actually doing, how you resolve situations can be more or less complicated. And then how you present that, what are the physical pieces look like, how are the rules written, how right all that user interfacey stuff. Yes. The UI stuff, right? that affects complicatedness, accessibility. And so my um when I look at kind of my internal my axioms like my assumptions maybe uh maybe they're right, maybe they're wrong about games, other historical board games, other board games generally, Euro games and so forth. One is that war games the actual mechanics on average tend to be more complicated. put the UI as stuff in the presentation aside. The nature of the pieces tend to be more complicated for a reason and the reason is they are trying to model historical dynamics. Like a part of the fun is we're recreating history as it was. And whenever you model something
that require that you know desire for fidelity can lead to a desire for granularity, you know. And now we might say, well, let's say we introduce this exception or this detail, this wrinkle to the rules of how to play the game, the mechanics. Well, it's going to make it harder to learn and harder to execute. It's going to take more time to play, but we're going to do that because then we can show in a more detailed, higher fidelity way how things really worked, right? Because real history is enormously complex, right? and we're already massively simplifying it to make it a tabletop experience, a model, but you know, we put value on that fidelity. Whereas, if what we're trying to do, let's say, is deliver a fun gaming experience, you know, in a charming setting with attractive art and nice player interaction and all of that. I mean, fidelity to what? I mean, it doesn't really, you know, it doesn't matter. And so if we want to make it less complicated, that's almost always the way we'd like to to go. Right? So anyway, so there's that kind of there's that kind of part of it. And we can try as designers to be elegant. We right we design elegance, which means we're going to give you a lot of historical dynamics and flavor and fidelity for as le as as as uncomplicated a procedure as we can manage. Right? So then we're trying to use our cleverness to kind of, you know,
shave off that that corner. And we can do that to a degree, but to some degree, if we want to make the game easier to learn and play and quicker to play, we're just going to have to simplify history more. I mean, if you if you buy Yeah. We have to choose between evocative and granular. Exactly. and and and evocative is a is a nice po I use that word all the time, you know, like if somebody says, well, well, h why did you simplify this out? You know, because it's not really accurate. I'm like saying, well, because all models are simplifications. This is a model. Yes, it's simplified and I've simplified it to be evocative rather than granular to make it easier for you to play, right, and learn. And that is absolutely a legitimate defense. But granular we do lose granularity then you see and the question is how interested are we and so the range of interest in granularity is going to be on the higher side um for the tradition of of war gaming.
Okay. So anyways, so that's one whole issue that is its thing and we're going to try to be as clever as we can and we will evoke rather than literally articulate dynamics as as we choose to make the package easier for you to use. Okay, that's one thing that's like at the core of it. Then then then the the user interface part is a whole segment and that's actually what I'm focused on now where I think we have so there's only so many gains that we can make by design elegance over here with regard to how granular do we want to get and and and and how much do we can we afford to rather than articulate simply evoke. Yeah. Okay. So that's like over here. The gains to be made in the next two and a half years in my view are over here with the the user interface. And so I'll give you some some examples of what that might be. So in the coin series, for example, coming out of the wargaming tradition, I could have had cardboard counters for the little gorillas and troops and police and bases and things like that. I went with wooden pieces because to me, they were more accessible. It's easier to see what they are at a glance. It's easier to see how many are there for area control. They're easy to manipulate. Um I don't have to read any text or numbers. I just look at the shape and the color, you know, and and I've understood the symbol, you know, and I can play. It's more accessible. And that's why so many um you know, Euro games and mainstream games go with wooden or maybe plastic bits. But but anyway, simple wooden
pieces, a cube, you know, a cylinder, a disc, that kind of thing, right? That's user interface, right? That's that's to be be accessible. Um, and so so we have seen more and more and more of that, right, over the last decade or two where we have serious historical simulations, even war games, and they're using wood, not not paper with little numbers and symbols and stuff on, right? Okay. So that's already been been happening on the UI side, which also kind of imposes a a you know, now you got to keep your mechanics simple enough, evocative rather than granular enough that you can get away with using just a plain wooden piece rather than a half inch of cardboard with a lot of tiny print on it where you can put a lot of information.
Okay, so that's already been happening. Um the area where I think we have big gains in the future is uh the presentation of of information on play aids and especially rule books. So I've been having a number of interesting conversations with folks about war game rules, rule books and how rule books are written and presented. And I've I've you know I've am myself now trying to completely redo how I write and present how to play my games from what I did just two and a half years ago. Uh and ending with like Inferno which we were talking about was just about to come. So, Inferno um uh published in the you know the last couple years and I was writing those rules pretty much the same way I wrote my first rule book Wilderness War 25 years ago. Okay. except that gradually over time I had gone from using the sharpest economy of words I could possibly, you know, manage to be unambiguous in the fewest possible words in that booklet to getting more wordy and repeating things and explaining a little bit more things and adding examples. I did that kind of gradually over time in response to to the to the market. But fundamentally, the way I organized and wrote and thought about the rule book was the same as 25 years
ago, which was fundamentally the same as the rule books I grew up with 25 years before that. Okay. All right. So, yeah. So, go back. I'm 63. I've been wargaming since I was in the 10th grade. Okay. So, if you go back half a century, what were game rule, board game rules like? By the way, this isn't just war games, right? That the emphasis was on, you know, tightly, unambiguously presenting the information that resolves all the cases in text with minimal illustration and example. And back then, if you had a mainstream board game like Monopoly, right, you know what the rule book looked like?
Like a couple pieces of paper. Yeah. It was a very often there wasn't a booklet. It was printed on the inside of the box top. Oh god. Okay. So, so there weren't like illustrations and here's what it looks like when you set up board and tutorial booklets and all. No. Learn to play. No, no, no, no, none of that. Right. So, to some degree, the market has evolved because we've become used to having a lot more help with user interface than than we had back then. Yeah. And to some degree, so some degree was available and to some degree fashion therefore has changed. In other words, my when I did my rule book for Wilderness War 25 years ago, I will tell you in the wargaming community that rule though that rule set was extolled, right? As and and and Inferno's rule book couple years ago was not extolled. Okay, it was many even even traditional war gamers saw the way that I had done the rule book as a barrier to learning and enjoying the game. Okay, that's a shocker for me. Time has moved on. But of course, we are, you know, we behave in our traditions. You know, we kind of until we're shocked out of it, right? We kind of keep doing the same thing. So, so what I'm how I'm processing that shock is looking at what is what is
being done that is more modern and more helpful in how war games are presented. And of course, just like with the wooden bits in the coin series, we have so much to learn in the traditional war game genre and therefore also the historic the larger historical board game genre from Euro games and other and family games and so forth because there there's such a premium on helping players easily. You know, like they they're not people are like, "Hey, I'm a you know, single retired guy. I sit in my basement at and I have a ping pong table where I set up all my monster war games and I just sit down there and will spend a hundred hours learning your game. No.
Right. That's not their market. Right. And we are seeing uh we are seeing the uh improvement in the presentation of war games to make them whether they're more or less complicated, granular, um evocative in their model in their that they present that that we can present them in new ways that new ways for traditional wargaming, right? that um take the best of what other board game genres do to present their rules. And so for example, one um cool experimenter in that area is uh Jerry White. Um, so for example, Atlantic Chase, anybody who knows Atlantic Chase, which was a very popular game, sold out very, very quickly, very um innovative dynamics, traditional war game topic, traditional approach to um wanting to tell you something uh in some detail, by the way, about a historical dynamic, but wanting to show you that historical dynamic from a new perspective and in a new way through new mechanics um uh in a in a fairly complicated game.
Okay. And then a lot of effort by the designer to present these innovative mechanics and rules in a way that will be more digestible both more digestible to learn for the first time and also easier to use at the same time. Easier to use as a reference as you play. Right. So, a lot of cool stuff and and Jerry has Jerry um has the advantage that he himself is doing the art for the game, right? So, it's like one brain who designs the mechanics and designs the graph designs, the rule book, the examples, the layout, everything. I mean, he did all of that. So that's so he's in an advantaged position to experiment with some some cool new um ways to to present the game, right? To present the system. So I've tried, you know, I did kind of my Vulco mimic Jerry in Coast Watchers to So like if I were doing the Coastwatchers materials the way that Jerry did Atlantic Chase, it's different. I'm I'm not Jerry, you know, but I'm kind of trying to draw inspiration for that. And so if you end up getting either Hunt for Blackbeard, by the way, or the Coast Coast Watchers game and you compare that to Levian campaign or the coin series or Labyrinth or Wilderness War, I think you'll see that it's a very different mindset. Uh
it's a very different value system that I'm applying to how to present those games. And time will tell if if those efforts on my part will succeed. But I I am seeing enough of that happening like I just named Jerry as one example. I'm seeing enough of that happening that it's substantially augmenting that blurriness of lines between the tribes that that that that you mentioned, right? that that you know we had among the barriers for board gamers who might who don't know historical board games but are have some interest in historical topics. The number of barriers to those kinds of people discovering, learning and playing his serious historical um simulation games. Among the barriers is the traditions of how war games presented themselves, right? And that barrier too is dropping. And I think for two and a half years from now, we'll notice a substantial enough drop that we can point to a number of examples. All right, homework for the next couple years. Pay attention to your rule books.
All right, Bal, thank you so much for coming on. I'm very excited to see where our field has gone in the next couple years and uh I'm I'm hoping that we're both like going strong and and excited to check in about it. Well, I'll see you next time, Liz. All right. Uh, see you soon, Vodka. Hey gamers, I'm here with Eka from No Pun Included, uh, to talk about taking games seriously. How you doing, Eka? I am taking games very seriously right now. Excellent. Uh, so, you know, you've never been on the podcast before, but I wanted to have you on for like just like a short clip. Um, because I was very taken with your video. Uh, I think the title was, "Are is every game really political?" Really in all caps? Because, you know, that's the question, isn't it? Yeah. I think I should just switch to all caps all the time so people know that every word is serious. Uh, but you know, when when I saw that video, I really enjoyed it, by the way. But it also made me think about um kind of how I feel like no pun included has been actively working over the past couple years to like do more than talk about whether a game is good or fun. And it kind of hearkens back to your original like like that vagrant song review from a couple years ago.
Yeah, that was actually that was uh mostly not my video. I had a little um uh editorial input towards it, but but that was mostly Elaine who wrote all of it, did all the research and uh did the leg work and uh that's you know all credit goes to her. Excellent. Well, you know, behind all functional channels is an organized woman. So, uh, but, um, I I guess I wanted to kind of have a little chat about your perspective on how your media has evolved since that review and the response to it and, you know, how you're trying to, I guess, reach into deeper analyses of games that you're covering over time.
Well, I guess that's a thorny subject immediately because the response to that video was very strange because it it was not a review, right? And and it it maybe is a little bit of a whiplash moment for uh an audience who's used to, you know, watching reviews. uh seeing something that is talking about a game in depth and in detail, but it in no way comments on it as a product. It just analyzes uh the themes and history and background of it. And and we've had a running joke since then that whenever we do that, you know, there'll always be a comment that says, "But what did you think of the game?" Right?
And our kind of weird internal answer to that is well that this is what we thought of the game right never mind the mechanisms not never I mean not never mind the mechanisms but like there it's not just mechanisms there is more happening there's a broader scope and more things to explore and I think I have personally really internally struggled uh with that because maybe even that video specifically that vagrant song video the response to it was very polarized and very split and some people have really enjoyed it. You know we've had uh a lot of people saying I really want more of that kind of thing and this is this is interesting to me. This this doesn't just feel like another game review. But we've also equally noticed that, you know, uh the algorithmic response to that sort of thing can be a little bit lukewarm and muted because because I think it's just not something that people are used to. So for me, the longest time of uh spent is is trying to figure out how to bridge that gap and how to find um how to explain what the joy of that kind of analysis is.
And there is because in so many ways it is a similar kind of joy to unpicking a game mechanically. uh you know uh I I I love untangling mechanisms because that's the active part of what you do in play. you're trying to uh you know figure out like maybe you know a more optimal pathway if it's like an engine building game or you know how to outsmart someone in a tactics driven game and and you always leverage mechanisms against that but but I think it is equally you know just as interesting as trying to find parallels between you know foundation and arcs uh because they they are there they very much exist and uh you know kind of discovering that and plucking at that thread and and and you know pulling to see what spills out can be so joyous because turns out that sometimes when you do so many things emerge, right?
It's it's like you open the Pandora's box and you can't you can't stop it anymore. All you can do is keep thinking and thinking and thinking and thinking about it. And I mean, I think that's the one thread between um both that kind of mechanical analysis of games and and a more kind of media analysis of games is that you you just you just think that that's that's how you engage with the thing, right? Yeah. I I think I wanted to ask about the Vagrant song video actually specifically because I remember the responses being really polarizing, but I saw it as something that was very exciting because I really enjoy conversations about I guess games as culture or like games as statement. Uh but as a reviewer, you know, I know you were also working, you know, with games as product. So, how do you I guess handle those ongoing expectations uh between like you know you're reviewing a product but then what do I want to talk about? Yeah. So, this is this is kind of like a thing that I also struggle with a lot and I actually found an answer that satisfies me. I don't know if this is going to satisfy everyone, but I think at some point you have to acknowledge that games are product and that those these two things are inseparable, right? Um because if if you only consider a game as as a cultural a game as a cultural object and and and
and you know, you approach it only from like a media analysis kind of standpoint. it it's it's very easy to turn like at you know to not look at at the product elements of it but at the same time I feel like there's an element of dishonesty in that you know it's like we're pretending that something doesn't exist whereas it very much does exist so so I I guess for me right now sometimes I can look at a game as a product sometimes I can look at a game as as as and as an object of you know uh culture but most of the time it's both and sometimes these two things are entirely separate in in one game and sometimes they are cohesive they speak towards each other you know um like in the way where like Daybreak for example you know is both a game that has something to say but the way it is made and produced also speaks to what it has to say or the same way as with earthborne rangers, you know, it it the their physicality informs the the themes and motifs, you know, and I think what's sometimes funny is that when it it it works across purposes as well, you know, where uh you know, the way the game is produced is is entirely the opposite of what it is trying to say and what it is about. And and and that's equally
interesting to unpick and untangle. Um, so I never shy away from the uh product analysis part of it because the two are together, right? Uh, and but but I also don't want to shy away from the media analysis part of it. Uh, because that to me is ultimately what's very interesting. Yeah, I mean that makes sense. Uh, I also I I really like your comment about cohesion. Uh, in part because yes, I think sometimes like the form that the product takes and then what it's trying to say are very much in alignment, but also because I think that even if you don't think that you're saying anything, you still kind of are because you're still like a product of your environment and the community that you're trying to play with. Um, and so I guess that kind of leads in your most recent uh video that made me uh, you know, contact you, which is, you know, are board games, are they all really political? Uh, so it turned out that Sausigil was in fact political. I mean, yeah, that was so funny. And um you know, the the funniest part of that uh was uh that I am pretty sure that when Ian originally showed me sausage sizzle, he explained that to me.
I am pretty certain that he went, "Oh, yeah, and in Australia we have this thing, you know, with democracy sausage." I remember him saying that, but that part left my brain entirely and I managed to pick up on everything else but the obvious, which is such an effer thing to do. Um uh but yeah, it it really is political, isn't it? Um uh but I I think I think what for me what was fun about that video is that I managed to go to great lengths and depths exploring the many weirdly intertextual elements of of game design and uh you know how it relates to other media and then I effectively arrived at the same place but via a much longer route than what was intended by the author.
Um, and again, that's that's that's kind of it. That's part of the joy of it, right? That's part of part of the joy of of discovering um, you know, not discovering, but untangling um, media in in a way where like you you look at not just the surface level and the mechanisms, but like what could lie underneath that. And then there's there's so much to uncover. There's there's so many things to find that that like you could you could spend forever in in even such a little game as Sausage Sizzle, which is ultimately a very silly game. You know, it is it is just like roll some dice. I played it again recently over the weekend because Elaine's parents were visiting and we were like, "What will we play?" Oh, yeah. fruit fight and sausage sizzle because you know it takes like two minutes to explain them and they are very silly and fun.
That's awesome. So over the last couple years, how do you think that your audience's tolerance for more political or analytical or or cultural board game content has evolved? Um, are things continuing to be polarizing like they were when you released the Vagrant song video or has your audience mostly kind of come with you? Uh, yeah. I still get called an idiot a lot. Uh, sometimes I get called an idiot in Lithuanian. Uh, because, you know, I am Lithuanian and some of my audience knows that and some of my audience is Lithuanian. So, it's funny when when they use Lithuanian swears at me. Um but but like it it kind of reminds me in a in a way that you know audiences are always polarized by by everything. you know, you can't get people to agree. But I think in terms of like the most passionate response, you know, it it has been positive because because even even since you know that that first Vagrant song video and and it wasn't even I don't think that was even the first one where we started to look at board games as more than just uh like mechanisms. we kind of often alluded to those sort of things, but like that was that was a video that really I think you
know pushed the pedal to the metal. Um I think yeah people keep saying I really want you to do more of this and and they'll be understanding. They'll say you know I I know you can't do this all the time but I really want to see more of this. And often times, this isn't a shout out to my patron. Uh, often times a patron backers will say like the reason I supported you, right? Which feels a little bit like, you know, um, I'm just trying to think of a polite way to say this. Uh, which feels like they're holding me hostage a little bit. But the reason I supported you is because I'd really love to see, you know, more things like that. And and that's cool, you know, because that that kind of informs us, you know, that this is what people are passionate about and this is kind of what not many people are doing. So, so they really want to see more of it. They want they want to explore this space. So, there there will always be naysayers, I guess, is what I'm trying to say. But but how people react and respond to that positively is is the most heartwarming thing because they are literally throwing money at us to say, "Yeah, please more, you know, do that." And that that makes us feel pretty certain about the direction we're going in. Absolutely. So, you know, um
you're in media, you're kind of marching the way that you're that you want to, but also that your audience like is encouraging you to. I think that's a good thing. Um but how do you see, I guess, the trend line for talking about games as cultural objects and doing more media analysis uh developing over the next couple years? Are we going to want more or is it going to always be niche? Yeah. Yeah. So, I was very I was very pleased when a couple of there were a couple of um uh newspapers uh that interviewed me since co um and uh like it was the Atlantic at the New Yorker and both of them interviewed me as as not like I wasn't I wasn't uh part of the article or wasn't part of the article in a major Okay. Uh but uh because they were uh one of them was about Cole Vley and uh the other one was about Ammoil Holland. And I think the one that was about Amabil Holland at that time it still wasn't about Ammobile Holland. It was just the author trying to find like an in a story and I I got interviewed to maybe narrow down where the story could go and what direction to take it in. So, it wasn't even an interview. I think it was more just a conversation that was looking for information, right? But I I
was very pleased that these interviews happened uh because they both picked two very interesting people who are working in our industry who are trying to make games that are overtly more than just you know like here's some mechanisms rather these mechanisms mean something and relate to something and and again in that video I did on on sausage sizzle I say like I got asked a question once you know How do you do media analysis for a game that isn't designed by Cole Cowley? Because, you know, like with him, it's overt that there's a thesis here that something more is happening, right? Uh but like what if it isn't, right? And so I guess I guess it's we're not going to go further until we can accept the idea that that it doesn't have to be Cole and it doesn't have to be Amabel. Any game can be this even if it doesn't intend to or mean to. And I think until that shift happens, maybe not so much in audiences, but maybe in people who who talk about games, you know, we're not going to get much further. So part of me is doing this for a selfish reason because I enjoy interacting with games like that and and so the more I talk about it, I hope the more people also see that joy.
Uh but but we need we need more people. We need more people who see games that way and and talk about them that way. Uh because uh you know until until more people get on board, it's going to be a really hard ticket to sell. Well, you know what? That's actually the perfect place to cut this off because I'm going to make you come back on here probably next season just to chat. But we will check in about how all of this went at episode 300. I'm going to optimistically assume there'll be one. I'm pretty sure there will be one. EFA, thank you so much for coming on. I really appreciated this. Thank you for having me. It was a real joy. All right, I'll see you in the next clip. All right, gamers. I am here with Candace Harris from Board Game Geek. Uh, how you doing, Candace? It's good to have you back on the pod. I'm doing great, Liz.
It's great to see you and it's great to be here. Thank you for the invite. Yeah, I you know, you and I have seen each other at so many like little war game events in the past few years. I feel like we should talk about the state of the hobby so that we can check back in on it after a couple more years of going to cons. Yes. Yes. And it it like I'm glad you're actually doing this kind of checkup because like I started taking kind of notes like so I could collect my thoughts a bit even though I'll probably be all over the place but but just to like actually think about like what the past few years have looked like and you know where things seem like they're going you know. Yeah. So from your perspective I mean you're on you're affiliated with Board Gamegeeek. you're doing kind of a lot of different stuff with them. Uh, and so you see the hobby in a really broad way, but you're also here in your Landon Freedom shirt, which I absolutely dig. So, so over the last couple of years, what's your perspective on, I guess, the integration of historical and war games into the broader hobby?
So, I think well, first of all, I'll say I'm an optimist and I tend to always like see the positive side of things um versus the negative. But, um I think it's really exciting and I feel like I've been into historical games and war games for um a little over four years now. And I feel like there's been this wave that I've been a part of and I feel it with like the whole modern board game industry too in terms of like more women, more people of color, more diverse uh voices and content creators out there. Uh but I was like looking I was like when did I write my all Bridges Burning article? So, when I was writing for BG News uh pretty actively, I wrote this uh big article on like why the coin series hooked me in and it was also an overview of all bridges burning and I looked up I looked to see when that article was and it was about four years ago and like I remember shortly after that Rodney was showing like his interest in the coin series too and like So that like just started like giving the coin series more attention. But then we have the Zenobi Awards started and there are so many of the games from the Zenobi Award um are being developed. Um
some have been published. Um some are coming out, you know, like we like Molly House just came out. Joe Kelly's Molly House. Um, Ion Games has uh, Cartini from darkness to light. I think that was crowdfunded. I don't think it's out yet. And even at ION um Bime's game Samu Ramit like there are so many different historical topics that are being explored and have been over the past several years because it definitely like you know unless you were like digging a lot like it was a lot of like World War II this World War I that you know and and I think for sure like there are just more and more and more like games exploring like really interesting historical topics. And I think the other thing with that is you have more game designers coming out. you have more like hybrids in terms of mechanisms where like not every war game needs to be like a hex encounter game and you have I told you I wasn't going to ramble but Oh no it's good but you have like indie publishers that are getting more attention like um Taylor Schust is like Stonewall Uprising with Catastrophe games um Holland Spiel is
always exploring ing like you know Amabel Holland and like the game does that that she puts out um for Holland spiel they're exploring some really cool historical topics and they're unique games like I picked up Striking Flint and yes you know they're they're more like cooperative games you know we David our good friend David Thompson like before it seemed like Undaunted Normandy was like the almost only like kind of like stepping stone. But like nowadays there are so many and it's like you have a game coming out with David Witches. Yes. A World War II hex encounter game.
It's a co-op though. It's a co-op though. It is a co-op. Um but yeah. So like so I I see that just like I saw it slowly build up and it seems to be just like going and going and going and it's really exciting. Um, the other thing is, and this kind of like ties in, but there are a lot more entrylevel like uh war games and historical games coming out to like ease the barrier for entry to newcomers like who who want to try to like maybe dabble in this space, you know, like you have like games like uh Twilight Struggle are being re-implemented as Twilight Struggle Red Sea and I forget the next one that's coming out, but it's like Asian Monsoon, I think. Yeah. Yeah. But um yeah, so they're like lots more games coming out that are like quicker to play. Um they have a hybrid of mechanisms, so that's drawing people in the different historical topics. I mean, think about the uh Salt and Peppers uh Battles Without Bullets series with the Battle of Versailles where you're fashion your fashion industry battling and then you have um but you're exploring what happened in history. Um which is which is super cool. And now they have Battle of Divas coming out
which is like opera singers that are are battling and you know I'm super into this. Well, yeah, it's it's it's really really exciting. And then you also have like, you know, I talked about the coin series, but you have GMT's Irregular Conflict series, and that kind of like stemmed from more people getting into the coin series and wanting to design something in that vein, but a little different. And you have like Fred's adjust of Robin Hood, you know, like that is a way to introduce people to the mechanisms of historical games and and war games. And you have Undaunted 2200 Kalisto and Red Dust Rebellion. Yes.
That are like sci-fi versions of historical games. So, I'm sure a ton of people who get into those games are going to be like, I love this system. I want to see the other games on Dante Normandy, you know? Yeah. So, um so that's that's super cool. Um, and then a couple other things I was like thinking about is like there's a lot of attention being focused on getting people into these games via the rules too. Like I know um I know GMT for example has been like just really trying to make the rule books more digestible. you know, adding some color, some images, more examples of play. Examples of play now will have female names, you know, cuz Yeah, Liz, we play these games too, you know. Yes, we do.
So, like, so I think that's super cool. And then I guess along those lines, um, just about ever since I've been working full-time, uh, for Board Game Geek, I've like partnered with GMT and some other publishing companies because I'm like, let me make how to play videos because some of these games, the bigger ones, um, like Edward from Heavy Cardboard was just like thanking me at Circle DC for making the the, uh, rules video, how to play for Border Reavers And it's like Border Reavers is not like the most complex game, but if you have never played a game like that and you open that rule book, it's it's going to like be a little daunting. So, I love the fact that you and me and other content creators are now covering these games more, whether it's a how to play or just like an overview or a review. Like, that's all exciting. I mean, I found out Jamie and Jeff from Foster the Mele love war games. I had no idea. I'm like, let's play.
Yeah, I I too have seen and really appreciated I think the broadening of the types of people who are openly excited about playing these games. Yes. Um they're getting more kind of like normal buzz at release instead of just like only certain people off at the side of the hobby care. Um and I think that that's really really exciting. I uh I personally also I mean as long as our industry survives the current economic uh instability Yeah. Um I I think culturally within our hobby we're moving in a direction where there's going to be a lot of cross-pollination continuing to happen. Yes. And I think the other thing that is like contributing to that is there are more content creators going to like historical board game conventions like Circle DC and SD Histcon. you know, SD Histcon is always trying to like diversify the the the people that are coming like the games, everything. And it's like you have so many advocates that are pushing for this and I think it's working. I mean, even here's another story which is part partially why I wore my land and freedom shirt. Um my friend Ben Mandelker, who you met um from the Game Brain podcast, Yeah. he was cool. Yeah. He loved you, too. He happened to be in DC when Circle DC was happening and he stopped by and he had
been so excited to play Land of Freedom and he finally played it there and he has now played it more and he loves it and and he's not like he has not gotten into historical games on the level that we have. But who knows? Now he's probably going to start dabbling, you know, dipping his toes in more and and talking about these things on his podcast. So yeah. So anyway, I I think like things are like moving forward and it's exciting and like I almost can't keep up. All right, so um just so we can look back in a couple years and either laugh or be like, "Ha, she was psychic." Um, what do you what do you think the next like two and a half or so years leading up to episode 300, which will of course happen. Um, uh, what do you what do you foresee over that time period? Um, I think we're going to see we're going to continue to see even more of these like quicker playing, you know, hourlong or like this the salt salt and pepper games. I was almost said salt and pepper salt and pepper games. Like I think we're going to start to see more and more publishers um digging into signing games like this, more people designing them. I mean, I even think about the the wave of trick-taking games. Like trick- taking games have gotten super popular um you know, with
more and more people over the past few years. And it's like now all of a sudden like there are all these different publishing companies that are like I have a trick taking game. I have a trick taking game. So I think we're gonna see more of that on the um historical board game front. Yeah. I think that would be really exciting. Um I personally foresee I think what we're going to see is continued I think historical games that are presented more like hobby board games. Yes. And the wider hobby. So, I think we're going to see rule books with better pictures and text that's divided differently from what you see when you open a traditional GMT rule book. Like Vulco actually in our conversation talked a lot about changes he's making for Ghostwatchers. Um, yeah. And I think that we're going to see, you know, games with art direction that's marketed to look more like something that you could see at Target as opposed to something that you're only going to see. Sure.
Yeah. No, I so I think we're gonna see like more more cross mixed messages in the marketing but like in a good way. Yes. And that that's exa like that is kind of the direction things are going like they're more co-ops too which like and solo games you know another shout out to like David Thompson with his uh series with Danver Games Valiant Defense series like those games are accessible. They're exploring like different topics and they're kind of they're like really good solo games. So yes, I think I think that is going to be the key. I think we're going to see more hybrids that are like kind of building things from the mainstream integrating it with these war games and historical games. Yes, let it be. So, um Candace, thank you so much for coming on and giving us a little bit of your time. Absolutely, Liz. Thank you for inviting me. It's always awesome to chat with you and I can't wait to see you at whatever the next convention we're at together. Yeah, Gen Con probably. Okay.
Unless you're going to UKG, in which case I'll see you then. No, no, one day. E. All right, Jen Con is awesome. Have a good one. All right. Uh, hey everyone. I'm here with Dan Theorough of Space Biff. Uh, he is a repeat guest of the show, so hopefully you know who he is by now. How you doing today, Dan? I am so tired. But I'm good. High spirits, low energy. Hey, you know, the spirit is willing. Yes. The flesh is spongy and weak. So, uh, I just want to record a short combo with you um, to kind of follow up on our conversation about two and a half years ago, uh, where we did this for episode 100 of the podcast. So, this is now going to be episode 200 of the of the Beyond Solitire podcast.
Wow, you are really good at producing episodes, Liz. You know, it's about persistence. You've got that stick tuitiveness that I lack. I think actually the trick is just to divide it into seasons so you always get a break between Oh, that's a good idea. So then I'm like ready to go again after a month of not talking to anybody. What I do is I divide it into episodes and take a break in between. That's the problem. I mean, uh, the episodes you produce are good. So, what I can't argue with the, uh, with the quality produced by this method. So, this is your victory lap, right? So, for those who don't know, you won the Golden Geek, which was very deserved, and I got runner up, which means you just kicked my high knee. So this is this is like a little struggle session. No, we give testimonials about why you beat us and it's be and and the answer is very simple. It's because Beyond Solitire is incredible and deserved that win. Like I cannot think of anyone else who deserved to win best podcast. Golden Geek, I really appreciate that. But I am pretty sure your year will come given that like we got your podcast registered on BGG like late into voting and it still got nominated and it still got I mean if you made one ounce of effort like it's your fault too cuz you were like no you can it's pretty easy to get it registered on
BGG and I was like is it I don't know anything. See I could have just not helped you. That's true. That's true. I I was thinking about that when I got nominated that first of all, I am shocked it got nominated. But I was like, this only happened because Liz basically told me how to do it. But hey, you know what? I believe in fair competition. Actually, what I believe in is um historical games and attention to them and people covering them. Um, so I kind of see both of us making the final three as like a big indicator that the stuff that we were talking about two and a half years ago has just kept growing. Like we're our our part of the field is making progress. I think you're right. I do think that there is a hunger for kind of like the deeper discussion instead of just like let's get it let's do a round table and talk about what we played this week, you know.
Yeah. Yeah. So, actually, I want to circle back to that. You know, a couple years ago, you and I had a lovely chat about how hopeful we felt about historical game designs and how exciting and interesting the themes were. John Company was just shipping. You had just been interested in this cool little game called Persuasion by Zoe Ared. And um we were we were we were talking about like sort of the departure of from like message games as being the only series games and into games that had like more of a thesis or were more mechanically evocative. So how do you feel things have gone on that front over the last couple years? I I think things are going well. You know I I I have spoken about my distaste of message games in the past not because I don't like a message but because I like a thesis. I you know I'm sure that I ragged on train um Brenda Romero's train game which is it's just so easy like I love to get together with Annabelle and just rag on that kind of thing where like a message without real clear thought and intentionality I think can be as damaging as almost anything else like making a game with the opposite point almost like and so something like persuasion or especially John company that are willing to tell you what their goal is, that are willing to document that. Um, that aren't going to just trick you into things. They're going to like invite you
into the model and try to show you what it's doing. I I think we're doing pretty well. Um, I just think of some of the games that I've played over the past year that have been so good at presenting a thesis and walking you through it. Um, and they're still persuasive, right? They're persuasive. This is persuasive rhetoric. That's their goal is to try to show you something and persuade you of something. But I think they're really good at it. Like they're open with the fact that they're trying to be persuasive, right? Like to me that's one of the differences between a thesis and just like a message game that's trying to like train. Okay, I'm sorry if if Brenda Romero is listening. I'm so sorry. But the entire conceit of that game is to trick you into being part of the Holocaust, which it was not a trick to be part of the Holocaust. You signed up to be part of the Holocaust. And then like the game is basically just like, okay, you're in the Holocaust. What do you do? And it's like, well, I don't know. So, the only choice is not to play. Whereas, you play some of these games like um I I just played Dan Balock and Joe Schmidt's. Is it Joe who did it?
In the shadows. Yeah. In the shadows. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. where it has you openly if you're playing as the occupation player in um occupied France, you're exporting things out of France. You're leeching it dry and being a participant partially in the Holocaust. And that game is really open about what it's saying. It doesn't have to resort to like tricking you into learning. Um it just tells you what it's doing and does it. I think it's I I love that. So, I think we're doing pretty well on the whole. Um, how about you, Liz? What do you think? Uh, I think we're doing really well. I basically I feel like every time I go to either Circle DC or SDCON, I see something that's really exciting. I play prototypes that make me feel hopeful and engaged.
Mhm. Um, and then of course I think that actually what's really funny for me is over these past couple years like my own participation in those activities as a designer has only increased as well. So like I'm also finding the waters fine as somebody who's making the games as well as well as somebody who's playing them. And so I I feel growth. I mean there's always people who want to test. There's always people who need to talk. Everybody's got cool designs. Like I really enjoyed Circle DC. You know I've played Spindle Top. That's Brooks Barber Barber's like Texas oil drilling game. Um, you know, I got a kick out of Fruit, which is Dan Bulock's like banana Latin America game. Um, there's just always something good to see. Uh, Vulco, you know, the the old guard continues to produce really cool stuff that's like new. Um, you know, he never just sticks to one series forever.
Yeah. And so I mean I always see things that make me feel like we're continuing to evolve and progress. And the other thing that I've really noticed at these conventions actually is media people of different stripes have started to show up. So like since last time we talked like you know Chris from the Dice Tower has now been to a Circle DC. Um you know Foster the Mele comes Sam Lord of the Board was at Circle DC this year. Um, Rodney finally came. That was a delight. Uh, but you know, it seems to me also that, you know, when I was making more review videos and stuff that I've kind of stepped back from that because I'm doing the making and not the reviewing. Um, you know, I remember feeling like there's a really limited number of media people who were engaged with what I was engaged with. And yeah, you know, I think that is slowly changing. So, the people you always see like Mike from Zillow Blitz or Candace Harris who is a fantastic advocate, um they're all being joined by people that I wouldn't necessarily have expected to see and I really I'm I'm here for it.
Nice. Yeah, I I hadn't really thought of it from that angle, but I think you're absolutely right that there has been more engagement, more thoughtful engagement, not just like engagement in the sense of, oh, this space seems to be booming, so I'm going to jump into it the way sometimes we media folk can do where we're so reactive to everything, but also like, oh, it's booming. Why is it booming? I think is is kind of the interesting question. Yeah. Actually, I think it circles back around to what we were started out talking about, which is um you know, people wanting a little bit more than let's sit around and talk about the hotness. Um I started my podcast because I felt that particular hunger. Um I feel like your reviews are a deliberate attempt to flout the expectation that that's all you're going to talk about.
Um, but you know, even I guess you know, you and I have chatted about this casually like in the aftermath of Polygon crashing, being bought and everybody getting fired that a lot of the online discourse was about, oh well, I want to hear about games as culture and, you know, I think we should, you know, treat games like they're real art or like however you want to talk about it, right? Um, the the hunger is there. I think it's just a matter of making sure people know that like we are also here, like we have been here. Yeah, there's room for more, too, right? And that I think that's a real challenge. You know, I was a little like everybody, I was discouraged to see the Polygon staff get destroyed, right? Um, and then there's just the gall of their new overlord being like, we're, you know, we took this good thing and we're going to build something better. And it's like, right, but the thing was the people, not just the brand. You you leeches always just think in terms of like these dispassionate nouns that Polygon has any value without any of the people who made Polygon. It is just such a business manager way to think of things that like and then you're like why is why is the value not replicating and weird alien.
It's because the value was the the people who were making the value. And I was a little discouraged, you know, not only by that, but then to see some of the discourse around it where all of these people were like, oh my goodness, well, now what we can we do? And some folks were like sharing links to like, well, where is the good work now? And a lot of people were voicing like, well, I want to see more analysis like this, you know, historical analysis or industry analysis. And someone said like, "I want to be able to go to a site that I can hear about board games that I've never heard about." And I was sitting there and for each of these requests, I was like, "Okay, well that's Beyond Solitire. That's Board Game Wire. That one's me." Right? Like my whole thing with with Space Biff is I want to show you games that you've never heard of and um games that are maybe a little deeper and a little more culturally aware because often those are the games you haven't heard of. And when someone's asking for historical or industry analysis, I'm thinking of you. And when they're talking about like industry news, I'm thinking of Board Game Wire.
And so I'm getting frustrated because I'm like, "No, we're here and we've been doing this work for a long time." Um, but how we bridge that gap is some that's the difficult part. And I don't think that it can all come down to like the individual creator or critic promoting their own work. It just can't. It also feels gross to have to insert like, well, I'm here. Me, you should listen. No, I have too much pride to do that. Yeah. I saw a few people doing that and I was like good on you for not having internalized your parent shaming the way I did or something. I don't know. Like I was just like I was raised in such a like you never promote yourself. You do good work and you'll be found kind of household.
And now that I'm older I'm like but you weren't ever found. like the people, you know, my mother is a is a composer who has just kind of quietly been an educator and quietly created these wonderful compositions and never like sold any because she never really put herself out there. So, yeah, but I don't think the solution even the people who are jumping out there and being like, "No, look at me. Here's my articles that are good." I don't think that's enough. I I I and I'm not sure what the answer is. Like I don't want this to be a plea where I'm like, "Okay, listeners of Liz's podcast, go out and share it, please." I mean, yes, do that. But I don't even know if that's enough. I I have some pretty big reservations about the internet we're transitioning into right now. Yeah.
Where so much where we're not rewarding people who create, we're rewarding people who scrape the creations. um you know, people who copy stuff or Google that scrapes creations so it can put it on its search page. Like I I just heard the statistic that something like 70% of internet interactions don't even have to leave the search page anymore because they just get the either AI generated or scraped answer right on the top of the search results. Um that's killing us. And um a no-click internet where no one has to leave their search page is not going to work long term because then what are they going to scrape? What is the AI going to copy? There's going to be nothing left.
So I don't know. I don't know what the answer is. Liz, what's the answer? You're smarter than I am. Oh god. I do not know what the answer is. Actually, this is a really interesting place to take this up because like I I think the answer is historical game design is going great. Uh provided the terrorists don't destroy us all. We'll see. But uh I uh one thing that is actually happening to me maybe maybe this is a conversation about media and the future of media because I have actually struggled to make media other than my podcast since since changing careers since moving. But I don't think that that's all that's wrong if that makes sense. Um something else is wrong. I think it's because being on the internet right now is such a toxic experience. Yeah, that doesn't adds up. I think it has to do with feeling like it's hard to be seen and for work to be rewarded, which is of course what everybody wants when they pic the internet. Uh it's realizing that, you know, the internet's not really a free place anymore.
And also feeling like you have to get out there and compete with just crap, AI generated crap. Yeah. And you know, how do you get heard through all that noise? Um, you know, it's all very depressing. Yeah. Yeah. You know, I try to stay upbeat. Um, I'm really grateful for the listeners and readers that I have because I do see a lot of good. You know, people are coming in. They're they're engaging. And you know, I got runner up on the I don't know if you know this, Liz, but I got runner up on best podcast on the Golden Geeks. And I hadn't even I didn't my podcast wasn't even on Board Game Geek.
Like 11 days earlier or something. I don't know. I don't know how that happened, but the uh I think some a good friend of mine told me how to put it on Board Game Geek. Um, so I I try to stay upbeat, but I do see a like I I just don't know how we're going to keep this running. Um, and we're working uphill not just against like the culture of people wanting to just have everything centralized. We're working a pill against like tech giants who seem to have like made a suicide pact like that they are going to decrease their own value at all costs. Um and I don't know what to do about that. No. And actually, you know, my video paralysis comes in part, I think, to it it feels kind of like it did when I was going to leave academia when I felt like I didn't know what I wanted to say. except that this time I feel like a pressure of wanting to say something actually kind of like the same creative energy that made the podcast happen in the first place, which is that I wasn't happy with the general available conversations to have. And so I was like, well, I'll just make something.
But I don't know what you say in the face of so much and I'm just going to have to like figure it out or not. Maybe I'll just speak through my games. How do you see your own stuff developing? Like you and I have talked several times over the years about writing versus trying video versus, you know, more consistent podcasting. Yeah. I, you know, personally, I think I've come to terms with what I do where I like the type of podcast that I do, which is I try to interview people who normally don't get interviewed. That's kind of my main thing. and every so and it's kind of funny because now I I've interviewed people like Amabel and Cole Worly um multiple times and obviously now they're getting a lot of interview requests but dang it when I started no one was talking to them um and so now I so I I have I I get to talk to them sometimes I think so but I'm I'm loving doing that like I I just did a an episode with Jono Naido Tetro um who's the head of uh DVC games, this wonderful little design collective. And so I think there's value to that. But I think I'm just going to keep writing. You know what? What's really changed is I I don't know if you know this about me, Liz. I write fiction.
I do know this about you. And I don't talk about it. Well, here's the thing. I do write a lot of fiction, but I don't try to publish it. I don't show it to anybody really outside of my little circle of of pals and family. And I think that I need to be a little more bold. Yeah. Don't be your mom. You got to break and not be my mom. I know. I've done a really good job in my life of breaking certain cycles that I inherited, but not this one. This is my like cycle of abuse. I'm like, "No, I got that cycle of being like this weird just detached parent broke it." But now I'm like the cycle of being like Protestant work ethic about your stuff. I I'm really bad at this one. Um, so I'm thinking I I need to be better at like actually like putting out my creative work into the world, which is hard.
Yeah. Yeah. And like what does it look like? What medium? We'll find out. Yeah. Do I just tweet it or whatever we call blue sky things? We should just make Z. I know. I think that would be a cool idea. Like, could we make But what would that be? Because I'm talking about fiction. You're talking about historical like writing. Look, The New Yorker has a fiction section. I'm just saying. Oh, yeah. That's true. That's true. A board game. Like, what would a zen look like? That's board game criticism, historical thoughts, and only Dan Theorough's fiction. That would guarantee publication, right? Like I would I mean, would we even charge for like you just like put the PDF online for like two bucks?
Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. Oh man. Maybe this is something your listeners can help with. Like what what kind of proactive measures can people like Liz take? um to help the media ecosystem because for a long time, like we talked about in episode 100, my attention has been focused entirely on board game designers. Like how can we help that? Yeah. And maybe we need help, too. Maybe maybe like a baby boomer parent like my mother, maybe we were so focused on helping others that we never learned to ask for help ourselves.
You know what? I'm actually going to conclude this right here because it's kind of interesting. We're going to check back and like I'm assuming we're going to make it to episode 300. I'm just going to be optimistic about that at least. Uh, and we can see what happened to coverage of historical games, like serious games coverage over the the next expanse of time because I think that'll be interesting. Oh, no. I'll be shut down. No, we'll still be here. We'll still be rolling. Uh, all right, everybody. Um, thanks. And Dan, thank you so much for your time. Thank you for having me and congratulations again on your very welldeserved win. Congrats to you for just like almost sniping the whole thing just out of nowhere. No, good stuff. All right, gamers. I'm here with a show regular and now a design partner regular, uh, David Thompson. How you doing today, David? I'm good. How are you? I'm doing good. It's kind of fun to do this like checkup because a lot has happened to us since December 2022. Yes.
Yeah. It feels like uh I mean it kind of feels like just yesterday, but so much has happened at the same time. So that's really cool. Yeah, it's it's weird like looking back over the conversations, it's in some ways it's like no time has passed at all. And then when I really think about it, I'm like, "Oh, whoa. Lots has changed." So yeah, so much has happened. That's right. Yeah. So you mentioned the Fifth Platoon early on in that little mini interview. Um I know a lot has been going on with Fifth Platoon, but do you want to update people? Yeah. So, Fifth Platoon, it's it's interesting because it it's a game that's not on contract. So, uh you and I have talked about this a little bit in the past. Most of the stuff I do nowadays are like games that are on contract before I start work on them, which means that I'm sort of obligated to get them done by a timeline. And Fifth Platoon's never been that way, right? Fifth Platoon's always been sort of this thing that I want to work on sort sort of indulgently. And so the problem with that is of course is since I don't have a deadline, it winds up unfortunately getting pushed to the back burner a lot. But more recently, um, I've started working on it with non-breaking space. So he agreed to co-design it with me, which is really cool, really exciting. And we've been working on it. We have a publisher that we've been chatting with about it.
Nothing official, nothing on contract. Um, but we're at a point now where we we the core is done. The core game is done. We've designed scenarios for it. We're actually working on a tutorial that I think is really cool because it is going to be very much a almost like a video game tutorial like very much walking you step by step and that's how you learn the game. So that's been our current focus. Um but yeah, still super excited about it. It's just going to go, you know, kind of going at a snail's pace because of all the other projects. I'm still super pumped about it. Um, also at the time of recording that interview, you and I had started working on Night Witches seriously around August of 2022. Yeah. Yeah. So, so much with Night Witches has changed, right? So, it's, you know, it was signed by Fort Circle, which is awesome. We wanted the Fort Circle treatment, right? We wanted our our first baby to be like just amazing.
Spoiled. Spoiled. Exactly. Exactly. Um, I mean, we've obviously we've worked with Raina throughout the entire process. We have like the world's best, you know, historical consultant because she's a, you know, super gamer. Um, she's been brilliant and we have some amazing historical documents that are going to be with the game. And then the big news that we didn't know at the time, right, was that Ian Oul is the artist for it. And we started seeing all of his work now. So it feels like even though it's been a long road, it feels like we're very close to, you know, that that last critical step of getting it into into actually manufacturing production. Yes. Yes. And also in all that time, you and I have designed and sold a second game, um, Queen of Spies. Yeah. So, when we last, you know, when we last chatted, uh, one thing that I said I was interested in doing was exploring more historical games that were not like kinetic warfare, right? Um, but I think I I probably mentioned this, I don't know, but um, that's not my like that doesn't come as easy to me, right? It's easier for me to like do the the sort of like traditional military at least uh, topics. And so one way to to approach that is have a co-designer that you know can help me out with that process. So, so I think it was you, you know, we were both sort of like going off and reading different topics and books or whatever and throwing back and ideas back and forth and we had a list
that we were building up and we're like, "Yeah, these are cool ideas." And then you you kind of tossed over the idea of Queen of what became our game Queen of Spies, right? Which is Yeah. essentially like that whole, you know, uh, World War I, World War II, uh, spy rings that with so many women involved, but their their sort of place in history often overlooked, right, which is kind of what inspired Queen of Spies. Yes. Uh, fortunately, my family loves me, so my boyfriend gave me a gift, a book about women and intelligence, like Christmas 2023. I remember I was reading it and I was like messaging you frantically about everything that I was reading. Yeah. Yeah. And I and I often say like you and I are always batting ideas around, but what's true about every time we like we want to work on a new topic, it's one of us throw an idea and the other one immediately was like, "Yes, we are doing that." And that's what happened with Queen of Spies, right? Yes. Yes. And so, just so yall know, David and I have like a list. I actually sent you the list in Messenger yesterday because I was thinking about how big our list is getting. It's a long list.
Um, but uh I don't want to talk too much in the open about our our new baby, but we are working on a third game. I will tell y'all it is not a historical or war game at all. Like totally different. Totally different. We do what we want. We do what we want. Yeah, that's right. That's right. Most of our list is historical, but we're taking a an unscheduled break. Yeah. To do something else. Yeah. um that hopefully will turn out well and if it doesn't we're having a blast so screw it. Yeah, that's right. Yeah, very different than anything I've ever done before. Um it's been super refreshing. So just Yeah, very uh very interesting exploration for sure. Definitely. But you know, you're very prolific beyond just things that you and I have touched base on or worked on together. So, how do you feel the last couple years of historical gaming has gone and like what what seems to have been the overall trends and like how is our hobby progressing from your perspective? Well, I think you know when we last talked we talked a little bit about Zenobia. Zenobia one had ended.
Uh, a lot of the designs were were getting attention probably at the time some of them were signed by publishers. The big difference now is we're seeing a lot of games from Zenobia one actually like they're available now, right? So, I'm thinking like Molly House, um, Orange Shall Overcome, uh, and then we've got some that are and Rising Waters. We've got some that are just about to come out, right? Yeah. Like Cartini. I'm very excited about Cartini. Cartini is the one I'm super looking forward to, but but I just received in the mail recently. Winter Rabbit. Yes. Right. Oh, yes. Now, now I'm going to tell you, so Winter Rabbit, I got it. I looked, I was like, "This is awesome. I've been looking forward to this, but I didn't have a haven't had a chance to play it still." But yesterday, I was sitting on my deck and I opened it up and I took out the rule book and then underneath the rule book is the rule book in Cherokee. Yeah. And I'm like I'm like, "This is without Zenobia.
I don't think like that's just not gonna happen, right?" Like I mean maybe maybe it could but it just seems like we're at a good time. That's that's the maybe not Zenobia but maybe like I think a broader interest in games that are about something other than the Battle of the Bulge, right? Yes. Yeah. Right. Yeah. And I mean, you know, I've made my Battle of the Bulge game kind of, you know, so I mean I'm there I'm there contributing to the to the uh to the pile of Bulge games, but um but we can have this too, right? We can have those. We can keep making those, but we can have Winter Rabbit, right? Which is, and you know, I've I've been pretty vocal about this, like Winter Rabbit of of Zenobia was probably my favorite game. And I think it it's it even in the historical game, uh, whatever genre, it pushes the bounds a bit because it really makes you rethink what's a historical game, right?
Yeah. I love that the game was there to have us have that conversation. Um, it pushed my personal openness in ways that I thought was really good. I um Yep. I I was I was very happy to see Winter Rabbit get as far as it did. I would I would have been happy to see it go further. Uh but um you know but in good news too like you know a car uh Tyranny of Blood is not out but he's still working on it and he also um has other games that he's showing and became a professional war gamer postobia. So yeah. Well and and not only that Yeah. Yeah. And not only that, but look at look at what Akar is doing for other people, right? As a key member of SD Hiscon and you know, just like helping others out, mentoring. And so we've so I mean, you know, we can't sing the praises enough that like it it not only opened the door to a lot of people who otherwise wouldn't have been able to design or might not have designed. It resulted in an amaz, you know, huge list of amazing games that have been published and it's brought these people to the forefront who can serve as mentors for other Yes. Yeah.
I'm personally just I don't know. I feel like without Zenobia, we wouldn't quite be seeing the landscape that we are now. For sure. Yeah. And I'm super happy with all the new people who are now becoming established people. Yep. Yep. um as a result of having done Zenobia and like just like it brought people into our ecosystem that I want to spend time with and make games with and hang out with. Yeah. And the other the other thing I'll mention too similar to to Zenobia is the Summit Award, right? So we've got the Summit Award coming out of SCCON. Um some amazing, you know, the last this past year uh landed freedom. Yes. The winner, right? Yeah. It's welld deserved. What a good Yeah. You know, I'm like the world's biggest advocate for land and freedom. I think it's amazing. And then the year before that it was votes for women. So like these are amazing amazing games about topics that are underserved. And what's interesting about both those games is those are both firsttime designers, right? So just and it's not it's not these are not awards for first-time designers. It just so happens that we have brilliant games about amazing topics from first-time designers and awards like the Summit Award can draw attention to that. Yeah. Well, I mean, the Summit Award is meant to reward either so basically like games that are more welcoming either by their topic or by their mechanical Yeah. um makeup. And so maybe, you know, maybe it's not for first- time designers, but it makes me
wonder, maybe first-time designers have the freshest possible perspective. And so you end up with games that are doing something fresh if you're looking for that, right? And it might be somebody who's less entrenched in the in the current system because they're more likely to have a different idea than all of us who've got a little bit stuck. Yeah. Yep. Yeah. For sure. I don't even know where I am in that spectrum. I've designed many things and yet nothing. We'll find out. All the things are going to come out at once. I know. It's It's just like I've I've spent all these years waiting and there's just going to be a glut. Yep. Yep. Oh my god. Um so where do you think that historical games will be going? Like I've noticed with Undaunted y'all have switched to sci-fi. Mhm. Yeah.
um you're designing kind of a wider range of stuff right now like um I mean you've always been an omniamer so that's not necessarily surprising but I feel like um you'd be an interesting person to comment on this so when it comes to like design trends you know are you any less committed to historical gaming how do you see your hobby flowing how do you see your own career flowing it yeah it's interesting I mean every every sort of for me personally I'll I'll start with me personally for for me it's every single game has it like its own origin story and so for like undaunted this is going to sound crazy but for un the sci-fi undaunteds that we're exploring now they came out of a constant call from people gamers who were saying hey I'm really interested in Daunted I've heard a lot about the system but I don't want to play a historical war game so it's it's like it's kind of like the reverse of you know of hey we want to create these historical games for new people. It's it's like, hey, we want to take the system and and let people who are interested in it try it without the theme. Whether you like that or not, that but that's that's sort of the origin of it. But for me personally, I mean, this is going to sound silly, but it's it's literally as simple as I just kind of do what I want, you know? And I mean like whatever I'm interested in at a time. Now, personally, what that means is I'm going to be interested in games, creating games like uh Queen of Spies, right? Th those are the ones that are.
But there's also going to be opportunities like I've got a game called Agia that's coming out next year for Mighty Boards that's co-designed with with Brett Gilbert and um and uh Trevor Benjamin, but the origin story of that one is goes back years and it's, you know, it was born of like a kind of a design constraint challenge of making an abstract game with those guys, right? So, it's it's not that I'm more more interested in exploring that genre. It's just that every game has its own little origins to it. But if it's up to me, left to my own devices, doing what what I want to do, and I'm the one sort of creating a new topic or talking to someone about creating, it's going to be more based in like a historical, you know, backdrop for sure.
Yeah. Um, most of ours are. So, yeah. Yeah. I mean, and well, actually, you and I are a perfect example. If you go down and look at the list of the things we want to do together, out of the list of say 10 items, nine of those are historically inspired and one of them is a crazy idea that we cooked up, right? So it's yeah, you know, that's I think that's very similar to kind of what I'm interested in personally. Um, now more broadly, without getting into too much of this, I think I think that we're still in a very good place. I think we're in the best place we've probably the game board games have ever been in terms of historical whether that's military history or non-military history. Games that are true, you know, with a good theme on the game, not the pasted on Euro themes, but like the the actual, you know, historical themes and games. Um it's interesting that like in the last few years that was emerging at the same time as what I would say like a larger um socopolitical sort of uh progress and now we have like at least in America a lot of push back against that. Yeah. So now we're now we're seeing like this is going to be a interesting challenge for the the our our hobby, right? because we're not living in an environment that's supportive of this change. We're living in an environment that's pushing actively pushing back against it. I personally think that our hobby is strong enough that it's going to be able to to uh withstand that sort of, you know, attack or whatever, but but it'll
be an interesting time to to see. Oh, that's a really interesting way to put it. I had not fully thought of it in those terms because the economic problems have been so to the for my mind. Um, so for just for context for people listening in the future, uh, today is May 12th, 2025 when we're recording this and uh, the New York Times just reported that the United States and China are trying to step back from their trade war. Uh, and the China tariffs are currently 30%. Which means that board games are still more expensive and stuff in this country is still going to be more expensive. And then China is loving 10% tariffs in the United States. So like we are having an economic crisis but yeah we are also having a social crisis. Um we're in a world where you know our government is killing IMLS which is responsible for inter library loan. Um museums are getting cut. National parks are getting their funding cut. Uh but more than that anything that says equity on it is getting cut. Um, and so if you care about those things, you have to figure out how to sub subsist in an environment where the powers that be are actively trying to stop you. Right. Right.
Exactly. Yeah. And and just one, you know, one other point on your on the topic of the economic state is it's not just the the tariffs themselves, but the volatility of the situation makes publishers scared to actually be willing to, you know, to pull the trigger. So, it's not just purely the finances, but like what will the state be in in a couple of weeks? and say yeah we we are at this weird like point of you know the sort of the the there is an active effort to undermine DEI uh you know in as a whole coupled with massive uncertainty in the economic landscape and so all of that just sort of combines to push against all the progress that's been made in the last you know four sort of like whatever four or five years. Yeah, I believe in us.
Um, I think that I think that we will prevail uh because we really care about what we're doing. Like it's easier to keep going when you have something to push for instead of just something that you don't like and that you're pushing against. Yeah. Um so, and I, you know, I live in hope. I have to, right? Because, you know, everything that you do comes from hope. Every game you make comes from the hope that somebody will want to play it. Um, every podcast you make comes from the hope that somebody will listen. Um, so I'm trying to be optimistic right now. I'm very curious about where we'll be in two and a half years when I'm optimistically going to assume we're doing episode 300. Episode 300. That's right. Yeah. And by episode 300, okay, we're going to look back and we're going to look at the transcript of this one just like we did, you know, episode 100. Uh, Night Witches better be out. Uh, Queen of Spies better be out. Yes. If Night Wishes is not out by episode 300, I don't David, I don't know what I'm going to do. Like, I'm gonna have an aneurysm on camera.
Oh, but it'll be awesome. We'll look back and we'll be able to celebrate all of your all of your babies that will be in the world at that time. Yeah. And you know, you and I Okay. If we're trying to do roughly a game a yearish, we'll have several other projects to talk about. That's right. That's right. So, that' be awesome. Oh man, thanks as always for coming on, David. All right, thanks for having me. All right, everybody out there. Catch you in the next clip. Hey gamers, I'm here with Sebastian Bay. Uh he is a professional war gamer. He teaches war games at Georgetown and you're still an analyst at CNA, right? Yeah. Fantastic. So, last time that we did a touch base like this was in December of 2022, uh, for episode 100. Uh, and we talked 22. Yes. I know it's crazy. So, like, you know, we kind of checked in about the state of, you know, historical historical gaming of war gaming. Um, things were growing and looking good at that time. Your classes were thriving. So, how have the last couple of years been for professional wargaming? has it continued to grow or to like entrench itself in in professional government world?
Yeah. No, it's a great question. So I you know I mean I remember when you told me this was like going to be one of the main questions of this like discussion and I thought about it and I went back and forth of like ah do I think the state of the of the field in professional gaming good is good or bad and I would say it's a mixed bag right um earlier in the in earlier years it was very much on still on the upswing right we're on this high renaissance of like gaming is expanding, the topics are expanding, the uh you there's more money flowing into it, there's a new generation budding at the bottom, right? That is helping support the like sort of the inverted pyramid demographic. And now I would say it's a mixed bag. um and the next year or two or three will really be the inflection point of if if it stays swinging up or if it goes swinging down. Um for example, one of the major reasons is that some of the facts that professional gaming even though we as war gamers like the uh game designers like myself and institutions like CNA that support the wider defense enterprise, we're still doing well, right? Um there's lots of games. I'm busier than ever. I get to do really cool projects with our allies and partners um and work on wicked hard problems. So like in that regard it's fine, right? But also at the same way if
I look up from my desk and look around our community like the Wilson Center which is was the think tank for the government that was congressionally mandated. got dis dismantled like you know what I mean uh in the past couple weeks and their whole gaming team disappeared overnight just poof and they did uh not so much defense gaming but a lot more like sort of educational analytical games in support of like wider topics like plastics and other things, right? So like that that small really cool team just disappeared overnight, right? uh and all of them are trying to find work and ironically or I guess well timed uh is like a few weeks before they were dismantled they uh did a webinar for uh Georgetown right and they were talking about all the great work they were doing and then in in in the sad reality looking back at it as like the last harrah of like explaining what they were doing right uh there are similar teams around like our our field right that look at like the USA development whole community is just self-employed it including the gaming team that like supported it in some regards. State same thing with State Department, right? Uh there's a lot of concern that the State Department gaming community which is tiny. It's like you seven seven people maybe tops is going to collapse on itself just because of budgets and you know who knows what's going to happen in the state department. Uh so there's a lot of concern of where gaming will survive in the professional realm. Um,
but yeah, it's a bit of a mixed bag, I think, the next couple years of whether those things get to find new homes, new ways to stay alive, uh, or whether this funding squeeze really squeezes out everything else, uh, except for defense gaming or even and even for defense gaming, we are eyeing the next couple months as the point of whether this is a continue continuation or a downswing. uh mainly because as the continuing resolution in September expires and they have to you know think of a real budget hopefully for at least a year right we'll start seeing if like analysis studies and war uh wargaming in general will even be a priority anymore or whether that funding stream will go away and then we also have to do the same thing of shrinking right so I think a lot of it's uncertainty just like it parallels our our commercial kind parts, right? Like a lot of people are are afraid of what may happen with tariffs, what may happen uh uh with the markets in the future and then certainty is breeding anxiety. Um but whether that anxiety turns into certainty of whether good or bad, right? I think it is still up in the air. We're still waiting for the shoe to drop.
Yeah. Yeah. I I totally understand waiting for the shoe to drop. Um, but you know, you personally have had a tremendous last couple of years uh with Latoral Commander. So, do you want to talk a bit about that and it continued development because that thing has just grown like a weed? More expansions all the time. Yeah. Yeah. Uh, so was it 22? Yeah. So, that was just before like Lal Commander like officially hit the streets. That that was probably like right in the pipeline when it was like at the printer or something. Um, so yeah, in Lal Commander, IndoPacific came out, I think 23. Uh, yeah, 23. Um, and then 24 is when I started working on Baltic, and it's come out just this past couple months, like this past month. And Baltic and, you know, it's about to hit retailers and so forth. And backers got their copies and so forth. Um, and then Australia just got funded last night, actually, I found out. Um so Australia got funded last night which is going to be the first of the national expansions.
Um and then after Australia we'll move on to Japan and then I think someone in uh UK sort of Norway combo maybe Canada. Uh so we have a lot of expansions coming up and it's really exciting mainly because like you said it's been awesome because I thought it would just be a very small game for my small niche community and we talked about that last time. Uh, but it's been really awesome to see hobby gamers embrace the game, to see people who um typically don't do war games, right, come and play my game. So, like yesterday, you know, in Jason Matthews, you're in Twilight Struggle. He does these um wargaming Wednesdays uh at Labyrinth Games in DC and they're awesome. So, they usually run all year round minus the summer. So, the last last night was his last one, right? And I was the speaker and I got to talk about L to Tal Commander. it sort of journey, its origins, and where it's going into the future. But it was awesome to talk to a bunch of people who are like, I've never played a game. I've never played a war game. Uh, and like I want to try this out. And so like that was very um meaningful to me, right, to be uh their first like gateway into our community, right, into our very a small niche. Uh so that that's been awesome.
Uh it's been really awesome to also because one of the things I do for my day job is allies and partners and gaming right so I do a lot of games for work at CNA for the Navy for the Marine Corps for the defense department with Korea NATO you the Japanese um Australia and so forth but uh lal commander has also mirrored a lot of that growth right um and it's like some of it's just like random and like I don't I just find out about it which is even better because I don't have to like cultivate hit it. So like uh I found out uh found out via B a BGG post that like a college course in Korea at the university level is using my game as a like capstone capstone event and like the students were trying to figure out like hey are there any tips and I was like oh man and I found out like they were using it in Korea for school which was awesome. Um and then the Australian Defense Force and I have been partnering to make a official version of Latoral Commander Australia which will convert into the commercial version. So that's been awesome and we're working with a couple other NATO partners um and institutions to create other expansions, right? So because the idea is like hey we all want these different people at different table at the table. Um, and one of my favorite like at this point it's like a monthly if not weekly like thing is that the faculty over at command general staff college right which is the sort of school for majors for the army that uh
they all go through at Fort Levvenworth. Um they have been they have a elective using wargaming and they use lal commander. So it's awesome to see them posting photos on Twitter and blue sky and so forth about how they've been using it. And it's awesome because you see officers from not only the army and various communities within the army, but also people from like you mean France or you I mean the Philippines all playing the game. I'm like oh man like that's awesome. Like this is your opportunity to be exposed to a game. I'm glad it's one of my games on the table for you. So it's been personally like you said very exciting, very busy. I'm on the road all the time these days. I actually uh for those who are going to be listening to is like one of the reasons we had to do it this early in the morning is because I'm like leaving for Mindola like tomorrow kind of thing. Uh so it's very exciting. Awesome. So do you see yourself doing hobby releases beyond Loral Commander or is that not something? No. No. I I absolutely want to do other games be beyond Lal Commander. Um in some ways I'm really in love with Loral, right? I'm sure you're like this too, right? Um and and I finally feel I think not in terms of financial or even success, but like oh, I know what it feels like to have a hit series, right? And then a hit series is maybe a strong word, but like a series that is popular enough that people want the continuation of it. Yeah. And you're like, hm, I maybe I don't want to do
season 4 of this show anymore. Maybe I want to do season one of a new show. Right. So, there's a couple of different projects I'm working on that I still want to devote my time to. Um, and my hope, and this is I don't know if this is a delusion or hope, or ambition, uh, but like my hope is that when I get Australia out, right, it will be easier to get the others because the others are also supposed to be farmed out more to others. Uh but like because lal commander Australia is one of the first ones that is like expansion um it has has evolved a lot of my like sort of guidance and shaping and like like direct intervention. Yeah. But my hope in the future is like be like oh Liz here like here's like a a ver like here's an example here's l toal commander Australia. Go like make a version of this on whatever country you care about right and then bring it back.
Cool. Like excellent like thumbs up right. Um, I would love it to get to that point. Uh, but right now it still requires a lot of my time. But there are a couple other things I still want to work on. Like I still want to work on an imaging game uh for Kevin at Four Circle. There's a couple other things I you know I mean there's a project I want to do with Mark Herman, right? Uh possibly World War II. So like there's lots of other things I still want to do, right? Google is just like sucking all the oxygen out of the air at least from my like energy time. you know, you you understand. Yeah, I do. Yeah, I'm in the I'm in late stage oath right now, so I totally understand. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Um and uh you know, one more thing we got to check on, which is your students. So, you're continuing to help train the war gamers of tomorrow. Um how has your class been going? Like, have you been adjusting it over the years? Teachers always like to tweak. And then, um what's your what are your current gins looking like? No. So, it's ironically like that you asked. Like we just finished our final on Monday which has been awesome. Like my class for those who are unaware is in the center for security studies at the school of foreign service at Georgetown, right?
It's a graduate program uh where students will um research, design, develop and play test and execute like a a educational manual tabletop game, right? For a sponsor. a a sponsor, usually a DoD or state department or some kind of government agency will say, I want Liz, I want a game on IU fishing, or hey, I want a game on insurgency that teaches XYZ, right? So, it has a very specific purpose for specific client uh that they get sponsored to to do so, right? Um, and it's supposed to teach them not only how to deal with sponsors, but do the research and how to do design. And it's like a very long design jam is how I describe it, right? And the game at the end is not like is not often publishable, right? In the sense that like anyone who has designed a game understands like you'll get to the first good prototype, but the last 20% of game design like the proofing, the play testing, the the the development of like is this the right word? Did I, you know, me format this right? Right. Are these the right examples to give all those kind of like hard but important small details that make good games into great games? Yes.
Right. Uh is hard and tedious and they're not there. Most of my students will be at best at the close like really good prototype stage, right? Uh which is not to knock on them. It's just you have 14 weeks to learn game design and do it, right? Kind of thing. Yeah. I mean that's a process. Oh yeah, absolutely. Um, and some of the games are so have so much high potential. I'm like, "Oh man, if they had another year to like develop this, work with a publisher, work with a developer, some of them would really shine." Uh, and some of them have, right? Like mentioning Command General Staff College before. They were sponsors in the past for two games, Thor's Hammer and Major Gambit, both uh, which have gone like uh, Army internal publications uh, with the game, right? So there are box versions of my students majors gambit which is like a hex encounter like you know brigade level game that the army sends out to units and that they use they like they sent me a box I have a box on my shelf of like that's so awesome like my but the thing is that that group and their sponsors worked on it for another half year to like hone it write the rules like make them work with blue panther who ended up like doing a small print run for them at the at the college right so there's a lot of potential I'm really excited for them and my students students are on the high right now and so am I, right? Like there there you remember as a prof as a teacher like oh yeah there's highs and lows of like teaching right um and I one of the first slides I have in my class is like I have this slide in my class I'm like you will hate me at one point in this class and I will not blame you
right um and one of my students comes up to me during the final and she's like she's like uh and she's like I was like oh I was like joking with one of the uh people who came by to play test their games who are all like uh defense professionals, national security professionals, and I was like, "Yeah, my students hate me." And one of my students goes like, "Oh, we don't hate you." Uh uh I was like, "What?" And she's like, "Yeah, we didn't see you for last week, so we didn't hate you last week." I was like that. And I was like, "What about March?" Because March is like the point of like them really converting their game design into like real prototypes, putting on the table, and they're like have to start thinking about rule like rules in very specific manners versus just a broad concept. And they they truly hate me in March. Like it is their comprehensive exam season. It is like they spend their spring break not doing fun things but doing my game design class kind of thing. Yeah. March is a hard time. But what's not fun about that? Yeah. They're all on this high, right? But you also like remember doing group projects in school. Like who enjoys those, right? No one. Um this is why I'm a solo gamer too. I actually hate Yeah. Exactly. Right. Uh so but they're on this high, right? Because on Monday they ran their games. They got to talk about it. They got to do it in front of people they respect and things that they may work with, right? Uh we got people from, you know, I mean the Taiwan Navy and we got people to um you know I mean from like the Atlantic Council, from this office of the Secretary of the Navy. So it was a really cool time for a
lot of the players uh and also the students to engage with each other and talk about the game and talk about all the hard work they've been doing. Uh so like I see a steady post of my students coming out of finals and posting photo photos and LinkedIn you post about their class. I was like at least they end on a high note. Right. Right. Uh right. So even so all of us are on a very excited note but I would say honestly one of the uh difficulties for my class which is a microcosm of the wider defense professional field but also for professional wargaming is that um a lot of them are struggling to find the path after. Right. Yeah. Right. Like imagine you're a grad student who's 26, you 28 or even 30 and you you paid all this money to go to Georgetown, go to school, and you you think you have you have you you're you did all the right things. You hit all the wickets, right?
And then you come out and organizations are disappearing that you maybe have wanted to work for. You're like imagine if you wanted to work on international development. Well, that field has been demolished, right? Um if you want want to work at state department a lot I know also a lot of my students currently um without saying specifics like they got job offers with their dream job to work for you DoD or state department and some of them are just stuck in limbo right they're just waiting because of the firing freeze and the probationary stuff like I have young analysts who are like oh like who sent me excited emails of like professor I got the job thank you for writing this letter recommendation blah blah blah and and 3 months later like hey and they're like hey do you know any jobs because I'm still waiting because we don't know if they're going to hire if they're going to fire all of us as soon as we get in the building like all this stuff right um and I think and I also particularly empathize with our young uh like foreign students right like we have students who are on fullbrite who don't know if fullbrite will like during the course of the semester like their fullbrite visa like as a student like as a scholarship like went away and then came back then went away and maybe have gone back like so like they went through this like roller coaster, right? uh same from a a lot of our other international students who are here from the UK and or Japan or other places and they're still waiting to see what happens right so it's really a tough time for different
demographics for different reasons but in some ways it's you know I mean some parts of our field are thriving right like places like CNA places like Rand places like MITER and IDA are still thriving in many ways right um but at At the same time, I think if you're coming out the it is different from three years where in three years ago we're like we're like yeah young people let's get them in the building right um I think right now everyone is like hold on like what does our future look like as an organization? What does that affect our hiring? Does that mean we're going to continue expanding? Do we stop and we're like okay we hold fast for like three four years, right? Yeah. Um and also there because like you like you said like like you me like maybe two years ago like a lot of people were like getting new jobs even in the commercial people are moving around there's a lot more opportunities right uh and certainty in the mark uh in the in the field but now I think people are like hunkering in they're like like it's not like you're going to leave leader right like like there's a very there's a a feeling of people who are already in the field to be like oh let's entrench and like hold the line, right? And like hopefully we weather the storm, right?
Like I love my job, but even if I didn't, I would love it right now, if that makes sense. Yeah, I know. 100%. I get it. Yeah. I mean, I do have long-term fear, but I mean, you know, everything we can turtle for now and everybody's turtling like Yeah. Yeah. Everyone's turtling. That means So that means there's less movement, there's less mobility up. So, if you're a young person like starting up and stuff, you're like, I'm just glad I get a job. You're not even thinking about your promotion. You're just like, I'm going to hold on to this job with like my bloody fingers. Uh, and hopefully like I don't fall off the boat kind of thing. And I feel for them. And I see it in my students. I see it in our young analysts and designers at CNA. And we're all trying to do as best as we can trying with the certainty that we do have. But it is um exciting times and we'll see how the all we're on the fence that falls but uh we're all sort of waiting and with our you know breaths sort of trying to figure out where the ball lands in a lot of ways but not to be all bad news uh it's also really great right in the sense that I I've seen in the past three years my students going to different places into state department and other places and uh one of my students uh He sent me an email. He's like, "Hey, um, you know, he he's like, I'm in Poland in with the army and he we're talking about games and the games he did for our class and how he loves doing games with his
soldiers as he's an army officer." Uh, stuff like that. Or um, you mean one of my former students uh, in in the defense intelligence a agency was like, "Hey, like I get a bunch of analysts together and we play board games now." And I was like, and I was like, "Oh, and remember when you were in my class, you didn't you said you weren't a board gamer. look at you now, right? Kind of thing. Uh, right. So, stuff like that. So, it's really amazing. And like as I mentioned like yesterday at War Game Wednesday, like the people that like um I'm always shocked when like you know like normal people, right? The normies come out and want to hear about my game, right? Because my game is weird and niche, right? Um, and that's okay and I knew that, right? But like, so that's when like every time like a normal group of people who are like not in my field, right? uh want are super interested in this game. It baffles me and also like really excites me. I'm like, "Oh, it's great." Right. Um like for example, I love there's like this hardcore group of Japanese uh board gamers who are like really enthralled with Latoral Commander on on Twitter, which I follow them all the time and like I use like Google Translate to like follow their they like create these long afteraction reports and stuff and they do multiple scenarios and I think arguably they play more than I do sometimes. Um, right. And then there was also a very like hardcore group of Spanish literal commander like fans, right? And I was like, God, like God, I don't know any of these languages. I have to use a lot of Google Translate to read your things. Um, right. But it's really cool, right? I
mean, amazing to see them embrace the game and so forth. So, uh, it's exciting times in many ways, both good and bad. Yeah. So, I guess we'll end on that note. It's like a it's a bittersweet sort of note, right? like things have been amazing. We don't know if they'll continue to be amazing, but you know what? I'm going to live in hope that episode 300 when we check back in. Um, things look things look good. Let's hope. Oh, yeah. And like we can't like we can't I don't think we can end this episode without like marking the point that you won. I mean, best podcast, right? Yeah. So, um, those of you who will listen to this in a couple weeks, um, yeah, uh, Beyonce alter finally won the coveted Golden Geek for best podcast, which means that this nerdy podcast has managed to win a popularity contest, and I'm so happy about that. Yeah. Still, like, but it's because of guests like you. Yeah. It's because like I think there's lots of good news, right? It's not to say it's all doom scrolling in in our world because there's lots of great news. you winning your your first uh golden year geek and so forth for best podcast like I'm really happy with the Tal Commander really happy with what I do for my day job right but also at the same time as I open my aperture right I I know there are lots of uncertainty a lot of struggle still going on in our field but uh and I think publishers feel the same way right so we'll see I think everyone's like holding their breath trying to figure out if what company survived what projects survive uh and so
forth right and what Jen Con's going to look like this summer. Like, who knows, right? Yeah. Uh, you know, so it'll be interesting to see how everything unfolds over this sort of summer con season uh in in the wake of everything happening, but uh like you said, it's I'm hopeful uh not in the sense that I mean that the world will correct itself, but I'm hopeful that we are resilient, right? And that we'll get through it as a community. Yes, I am hoping as well. Well, I'll see you in two and a half years. I'm kidding. I'll see you before that. Sebastian, thanks so much for coming on as always. No, it was my pleasure always and I'm happy to mark your your what 200th episode and your first Golden Geek. Thanks, Sebastian. All right, gamers. I am one mile away from Cole who's in the office.
So, things have definitely changed the last two and a half years. How you doing, Cole? I'm doing really well. I've decided we're not we're not going to report this minor truency. Yes, I I have a hall pass actually. Um so, uh two and a half years ago, December 2022, uh we were talking from totally different states. John company was just about to ship and we were both feeling or was shipping and we were both feeling very optimistic about the future of historical games. Yeah, and I'm still feeling optimistic about it. I mean, John Company was it was an interesting moment in my own historical game making because John Company was the game that Drew and I started Worly Gig to make. Uh, but we recognized right away that it was far too ambitious of a title to be our first like foray into publishing properly. And so we did Premiere to kind of like test the waters. And then Premiere has kind of had a life of its own and has done really well. But we wanted to do John Company. Uh we wanted to do it without really knowing if there was going to be an appetite for that kind of game. I mean, Premiere is a lot of things, but it's also like a sub3hour like mediumheavy interactive design. I know there's a lot of people who want those kinds of games. Do people want a socioeconomic 18th century simulator that could take all day to play? That was a very uh very different kind of question. I mean, I remember right before we shipped John Company, I was looking through a pre um a
pre-production copy, and it occurred to me how long the rule book was, like just holding it in my hands. And so, at at the last minute almost, uh Drew and I drafted this little letter that basically encouraged people to be gentle and take their time because they were about to do something kind of like big and scary and heavy. Uh and in the two years since, it's done really well. Uh we have run three printings of John Company. They're very small printings, but they're still like showing like a real life. We're actually almost sold out. We are sold out of John Company in the United States. We're almost sold out in Europe. Um, and so we're like looking at like potentially the next printing of John Company in the near future. And it has um it has really found an audience and has allowed us to I mean the money that we use in John Company allowed us to finish Molly House really well and is kind of powering like the next phase of our historical games.
That is absolutely wild. So yeah, I would say the last couple years of historical gaming have been great for you. Uh they've been great for me in the sense that I make them now. Um yes, you do. Uh and um so here's a question then. What sorts of trend lines in terms of topics that people are choosing? Uh and maybe appetite for depth of game have you noticed? Because I feel like there's a lot I mean I work in this area. There are a lot of kind of lighter historical games coming out that are beckoning people over to walk on our side of the hobby. Yeah. But um I think you've really Yeah. Well, I'll talk a little bit about the about the light. I mean, I think it's been really interesting to see the the rise. I mean, one of the big risers of the past couple years has been like Salt and Pepper Games. Yes. Um and have with a real like diversity of of look and topic, right? Uh, and so it's been it's just been really fun to see uh just a completely different spin on some of these old subjects. I mean, one of the designs that I was thinking about a lot when I was uh traveling recently uh was the game The Battle of Fair. Yes. Um which is so which is so compelling both in the the design and also just like how it is realized on the table and its choice of subjects. So you're seeing like a real widening of the of the aperture. Uh when Drew and I published this year uh Joe Kelly's Wonderful Molly House uh and that game um Dan Bullock uh jokingly asked I think Drew once like what does it feel like to
make a game that doesn't have boats or guns in it? Uh, and it it was just it was a it was a lovely it's a lovely sentiment because it is actually like a game about social history. And so I'm so excited to see more games uh about wider uh not not not a wider range of subjects but like even like a wider range of like genre within the historical game framework because you know Liz you and I both know um you walk into a bookstore a third of the bookstore might be the history section. Uh game stores should look more like bookstores in that way. there is so much history to cover, so many types of stories, and I just want to keep seeing that widen out. Yeah, I I agree. I also think that um since 2022, I mean, you know, I think Zenobia one had ended by that point, but we were seeing like the rise of all these games, I I've been really really excited to see so many Zenobia projects make it to publication or pre-publication over the last couple years. Yeah. And I mean I I just got my copy of Winter Rabbit in in the mail and open it up and it like is gorgeously presented and it's this amazing it's this amazing object. I can't wait to uh see how the final design turned out. Yes. I'm also very much hoping that Zenobia 2 produces a bunch of published games as well.
We had a really good we had a really good crop. I mean and and also there there were really interesting things I could have never predicted. For example, in Zobia 2, uh we had a lot of submissions from South America and Central America and uh it was remarkable to be bringing all sorts of subjects that were completely outside of my understanding uh just right to the forefront. Some really excellent design work too. Yes. Uh and so just you know, we are very much hoping there will be a 3. Stay tuned. It'll be a minute. We got to recover. I think, you know, you and I are both kind of on the on the board and it is a lot of work to run a contest and then it's even more work to run a contest that has a large mentorship component. Yes. And so this is an every other year venture um at least.
Yes. But I think we're getting better at it with time. We're getting there. So I'm I'm very hopeful. Uh and then so here's my question then going into the future. What kinds of historical game work do you find yourself wanting to do? Where do you think you're going to go with Worly Gig and your own work in the next couple years? So, I still feel like I am um paying like a debt at at Worly Gig towards stuff that I worked on earlier. So, I know that, you know, this year we have Hellraisers, which is a really wonderful game about labor history. And then I want to be working on Infamous Traffic and some other projects that I've like hinted at for a long time. Uh, and then after those are done, things kind of open up for us and we have kind of a wide um there's a wide range. I mean, one thing that I've talked about with you, Liz, is like I really want to do more games about like early Christianity and like the axial age.
like I want more games about the history of religion because I think it's extremely fascinating and also um it's just ripe for the sorts of um for the sorts of systems that games like allow play or the sorts of stories that games can tell with their systems. I think a lot of um a lot of the history of religion is just extremely well suited to it and it's a place that just hasn't been explored with any depth. I mean, I know there is, for example, like a game on the Council of Nika, but if the Battle of Bulge can support a 100 games, the Council of Nika should be able to support a thousand. And so, I kind of want to see just an an expansion in that in that direction. Um, I also uh am really interested in doing games that uh get a little bit more into early 20th century history. And so it's something that I've been exploring a little bit kind of like continuing my investigation of um imperialism over the kind of like it's modern what you know in the modern era in the context of the of of the western world. I kind of want to carry that into the late 19th and early 20th century. We'll we'll see how that goes.
But there's just there's so much to cover. I mean the one thing about history games, the one thing that I can say that's almost a knock on them is they take a really long time to execute well. There's just a lot of books that need to be read, right? And so when I, you know, I've been working on this game about um the the re re uh reconstruction following the Civil War and it originally was this like massive the entire swath of reconstruction kind of covered in one game. It's now looking like a study of Louisiana kind of in the 12 or 14 years after the Civil War. Um that project I probably need to be doing reading for another two or three years before I can like properly I can like properly get it going. Um, but that's okay because I've got other projects to work in the meantime. That is that is very fair. Um, and then people, you know, just because we have to talk about it given our our time, uh, Worldly Gig had a little bit of a tariff scare this year. Um, and that's also something that's, you know, felt throughout the industry at this moment.
Um, how do you how do you calculate the odds of historical gaming survival and continued growth going into this? because I feel like designwise, I think the space is actually in a great place right now. Yes. I'm really excited by what people are doing. Um, you know, every time I go to a convention, I see something that really thrills me. But, um, what's our what are what's our survival outlook? I mean, when I when I go to uh like Circle DC or SD Histcon, the kinds of shows where a lot even like Origins where a lot of historical game publishers sort of show up, I have never seen so many people working on a such a wide range of topics. I feel like it's uh the hobby is in a very healthy place when it comes to historical gaming. This tariff thing is frustrating, but I also think historical games are like uniquely uh situated to weather it.
Um be and it's because the historical a game audience uh they care a lot about quality of design and quality of presentation but they don't really care about like plastic miniatures. It's like there is a world like if I had to produce an infamous traffic in the United States like I I probably could and I think it would still be a really exceptional design and I know that you know some people are going to be sad that we're not going to be able to get like the clicketity clackety plastic aul tiles for the conspiracy pools but the design will still survive that because the folks who are playing historical games they're coming for the for the design they're not necessarily coming just for the physical presentation. Now the growth of historical games actually does kind of depend on those physical presentations. That was the argument that Whirly Gig was making in the um the kinds of like aesthetic strategies that that we we go through. The things that we we are doing to try to make our games um accessible, eye-catching, those are things that we only get when we participate in a global international uh industry. Uh, and so for that, for that reason, it's very frustrating because I think I think historical games are going to be fine. I would love to see them grow though. And in order to see them grow, we need to be working together.
That includes with our partners in China and other countries. Um, I was fortunate enough to be at a convention in Spain, and I was spending a lot of time with uh our partners at Two Tomatoes, which handle the French and Spanish translations of Worldly Gigs uh Worldly Gigs games. and I love those guys and they also are working on fantastic historical games and I I feel like we are in the same industry regardless of the fact that we're separated by an ocean and so some of this feels so silly so sort of like I don't know casually destructive when it when it shouldn't be. Um I will say though I mean I don't want to make any kind of political prognostications. I'm not a pundant, but my general rule for Trump has been like a loud loud a lot of loud noises and then fundamentally like a paper tiger just like utterly sheepish and constantly re- retreating whenever he meets with any kind of real resistance. And yesterday, I think, uh, they announced a pause on the the tariffs with China, which the pause in and of itself doesn't really do anything because when you start a production in China, it's almost certainly going to take more than 90 days. So, even if we were to like press print on Hellraisers right now, uh, it wouldn't even be done fast enough to take advantage of this pause. But the fact that a pause was announced at all to me suggests that almost certainly they're going to work out some kind of long-term solution. And the only thing that's going to come of Trump's trade war is a slightly underperforming stock
market and about six months of ulcer generation and all the people who try to find a way to to make business and profit in this world. Let's hope. All right, I got one more question for you kind of sprung from what David and I were talking about. So, um, you know, I know we don't want to talk too much about politics explicit. Uh, however, however, um, you know, historical gaming, I think part of the growth of historical gaming the last couple years has also walked hand inand with a push for diversity and a push for more inclusive topics, being more inclusive, and new designers. You know, Zenobia is explicitly about that. The Summit Award is explicitly about that. And you know at the time our general society was pushing in that direction as well. We are now under a political administration and at least half the country that is overtly against the kinds of pushes that we have been working on from within our industry. And so how do you think that we'll proceed with our mission going into more hostile territory? It's funny because it doesn't at some point it like doesn't matter like the world is a diverse place. history is a diverse story. It you can say it's not the case, but it doesn't actually change the facts on the the ground. So, as long as good historical game work is being done, those stories are going to get told eventually. And whether or not a library is able to buy them or not, like that that's a concern on a very very shallow horizon, right? So I I mean I I look at
some of the things that that are I don't know some of the um the weird kind of backlash, the emboldening. I mean think to me the way I'm reading it is like there are there are bad actors and there are people who I mean I'll just call them bigots out there. And to me the biggest change of this like this is the biggest change of the past like year or so is not that there are more bigots. is that the bigots have been like a little bit emboldened and they're a little bit louder. But like we have good work to do and it's not worth spending time like you know trying to either win them over or ignore them or anything. You just kind of keep doing the essential work because they can't change the facts on the ground. And the facts on the ground are that this world is an amazing complex place and it takes all sorts of stories and all sorts of storytellers to capture that reality.
And if if someone wants to cry about it on the internet, then they're welcome to cry as much as they'd like. That's a perfect place to stop. I guess we better get back to work. Uh I look forward to checking in on this another two and a half years. I'm going to be optimistic and say there's going to be episode 300 to do it in. Hell yeah. All right. Thanks, Liz. Thanks, Cole. All right, gamers. I'm here with one of my favorite repeat guests, Annabelle Holland. She Hello. Hey, Annabelle. I'm so happy to have you on again. Thank you. I I interrupted your introduction. It's kind of chaotic energy I'm bringing into into this. I'm here for chaotic energy and that's why you get invited repeatedly. But for those of you who don't know Annabelle, um she is a publisher and game designer mostly through Holland spiel and she's awesome. Uh so we talked about the state of historical gaming for episode 100 about two and a half years ago in like December 2022.
And yes, at that time um Endurance was about to come out. Okay. Um the Vietnam air rescue game, what's the title? Oh, uh that Others may live Live. The Brad The game. Yeah. That was also kind of like on the way into the world at that time based on our our transcript. So, how have things I guess been going in historical gaming for you and then more broadly as you perceive it since then? Well, for me, um, you know, it's been it's been a crazy couple of years, you know. Um, so that would have been like early 2022.
Late 2022. Yeah. At the time, you remarked that you were going through puberty for a second time and had taken stuff away. because I I that I would have been Yeah. And like I'm I'm kind of over I mean I've been in HRT for a few years now so I'm kind of over that hump to a degree. Um but at that time um you know 2020 and 2021 were like the biggest years we ever had because of the pandemic boom in in in retrospect. But at the time I was like oh wow things are going well. Things are going to keep going well. And it turns out uh 2022 was not as good a year by the end. I wouldn't I wouldn't know because I do it like half my business in like a week and a half in November. Yeah. So, um so it's the years have been a little a little thin, but we're still like uh putting games out, still trying to do weird games, weird historical games.
Um and that's kind of where I'm at. I mean, it's kind of surreal because right now, you know, as we're talking about this, we're we're into 2025. Uh, the the board game industry generally, there's just a big question mark. Um, and I don't know how that's going to affect my personal business. I have some ideas, but you know, I'm not printing overseas generally. So, everything is kind of in the US, but there's still like supply chain chain questions. The fact that a business like mine exists on the periphery of the industry, so if the industry is doing well, my business does well, and if the industry isn't doing well, I don't I don't know what happens.
So, I'm just trying to play it by ear, which is a little frightening. Um, but uh, yeah, I'm still, you know, making historical games and, uh, and some other things. I've kind of branched out a bit. Uh, you know, I had a game last year, uh, City of Six Moons that, uh, did very well. It's my bestselling game ever. Uh, and it did that in hasn't even been out for a year at this point. Uh, it's crazy. And like that's not really Is that a historical game? I No, but it's interesting and it's about more than just is it fun and so yeah, it still feels on brand for you. Thank you. So, um yeah, I I I you know, personally like I still am keeping my hand in with like traditional historical games. Um I have one coming out like uh I don't know in a week or two. So like that's that's pretty good. Um to try to meet that demand while trying to also do like more social history stuff is still like the direction I'm going as far as the industry generally. You know historical game space generally. It does feel like there's been more um new perspectives and new voices coming out. You know I was I was pleased to actually be involved with uh Zenobia the second time around. Um and a lot of the projects coming out of that were really quite striking. Um my if I had to make a prediction, my prediction for
games generally, but for historical games is that the big innovation is the thing that Zoe Ared is always talking about, which is um game unranked games, games where um you have goals, but you do not have a victory condition like not more than one person can win by achieving their goal. goals isn't winning. It's more the experience. It's more going towards these goals cooperatively or competitively and creating a space where you then have to parse the the what the result is rather than oh I won you lost right and I think that's an approach to games an approach to historical games especially that centers like the nuance of like living through history and engaging with history and desenters kind of the imperialist capitalist uh zero sum nature of of the way a lot of people approach it and I think that's going to be some of the most interesting work in the historical space. That's that's that's my prediction that that's that's my seeing the future.
Fantastic. So I mean you yourself have done a lot of experimentation the last couple years with games without victory conditions. Um is that something that is going to continue at Holland spiel and are you going to keep kind of pushing the envelope in that direction yourselves? I'm I'm going to try. Um you know um it's there are certainly things I have in mind that are in that space and uh there are some unique challenges to that. So it's it's a matter of try trying to um figure out that approach in my own work and then publish games from other designers that are working in that space. You know we just published Sykes Beco the the Brooks Barber game which is one of those games where you know each player has goals they're trying to achieve but what that result means really depends on the players and do they want to just try to prevent the other player? Do they want to help the other player to help themselves? Like it gives you a lot more space to play with. And uh we're publishing Zoe Average Game Persuasion uh later this year. And that also is one of those games. Um, so it's um, yeah, I I I really I think anything that desenters the the the centrality that's you can tell I'm talking on top of my head here of uh, of victory conditions I I think is a good thing.
Like even a game of mine like this guilty land which has victory conditions, has a winner, who wins is not what creates the meaning in that game. And I and I and I I think that's I think that's important. I I I I think that's uh a space that that's that's there's a lot of room to play with. Nice. Um so we have a we have a game prediction. I also kind of want to because you're also like media now in your way with your video essays. I love them. Um, so you know, Dan Throw and I talked in our clip about how historical game design is actually in a good place in terms of interesting topics, pushing the envelope, you know, and in a lot of cases kind of reaching out into the broader hobby. Um, I mean, I kind of feel like the state of historical game design is pretty exciting right now.
Yeah. Um, but media is actually where we're having some problems right now. you know, Polygon just got bought out and crashed. Um, you know, we're seeing Discourse asking for like meaningful engagement with games, although I would say that that already exists. Um, you know, what do you uh what are you hoping your video essays will bring you? How do you see yourself, I guess, in the larger media space? And, you know, what are what are you seeing that people want from that space right now? That's that's a very good question. Um I mean what I'm trying to bring to it in my video essay work um is generally is trying to express certain ideas or get people to think about games in a different way. And um how successful that is, I don't know. like I've gotten some some traction on some of it. Um I do think if I look at, you know, other video um board game stuff, it tends to be there's a lot of top 10 lists. There's a lot of reviews um which are generally fairly shallow. There are some exceptions.
Um, and there's a lot of a lot more stuff made by influencers than by critics, if that makes any sense. I think systemically we don't have like a I mean, I think generally arts criticism has been on a downturn because of of capitalism. But with games, you know, I don't think we have it as much as I'd like. And a lot of it is is about people who are just kind of doing it themselves. And there that's that's very good, but also has some pitfalls. There's certainly people who who do like really excellent work in the space. I'm talking to one of them right now. And uh you you mentioned Dan Theorough. be someone else who is doing excellent work in that space.
There are other people who uh uh um EFA uh from no pun included. Uh yeah, EFA and Elaine, great work. Um but there's a lot of people who, you know, don't try not to be mean. Uh there's I don't know how much appetite there is for serious thought because a lot of times when you express it, you put it out there, people, oh, you're taking it too seriously. You're getting too deep into it. You're too there's an anti-intellectualism in internet discourse especially. And I think I think that along with like the kind of the capitalism of it all, the the the wanting to be buddy buddy friendly with the publishers of it all. I think that creates a lot of potential problems. But there are people doing good work. I'd like to be more of it.
I'd like to be more widespread. But I like that for everything. I if I look at like film criticism today, how many film critics do I do I really trust and are able to like really approach it um with depth and with thought and how many of those are actually making a living at it? Yeah, I've gotten pickier with my book critics as well because I really enjoy watching book talk to kind of know what's out, but I've also kind of started to detect like influencer patterns and the same books appearing over and over again. And you know, the way I engage with all criticism of all art that I consume has changed in the last couple years. And and you know, and I'm not saying that this is like some new modern thing. I I think our our modern world has exacerbated a lot of this. But if you look at like film criticism in the 70s and 80s, there are there are a lot of film critics like famous film critics who uh have some compromised opinions because of how buddy buddy they are with with certain people. They want to go to the the interview, they want access, you know, and that all creates, you know, there's a lot of the incentive structure is bad and that's why capitalism needs to be dismantled. This is what you get for having an anarchist on your show. We need capitalism and patriarchy. These systems are not only killing our world
and our bodies, but our souls. I mean, I just read an article about how it is entirely possible that students are writing AI papers that then get graded by AI graders. So, I actually can't dispute that right now to be real. Yeah. But, uh, just end on a positive note, um, can you maybe give us some, um, maybe some sneak peeks into what you're working on next for your video essays? Um, since I think we talked about some upcoming games and stuff on our Philips uh, video essays. Um, so here's the thing. I'm not sure which one what I'm doing. I have some vague ideas and then like I try I try I initially said I'm going to try and do one every month. That's when the videos were 15 minutes long. Great. Most of them these days are between 40 minutes and an hour. So I tend to average like one every couple months. Though I do do some little videos in between.
Um, I have some general ideas. I want to do something about player count and how that affects um game design because I do feel like a solitire game and a two-player game and a three plus game are kind of different forms and often I draw comparisons with video games with my board game video essays partially because my my my partner Sin like video games are are what she does for a living is is is being a let's player on YouTube. And so like I'm getting a lot of these ideas from video games, but video games are quite different than board games in a couple ways. And one of them is just that traditionally video games are single player experiences. There are some multiplayer ones, but traditionally they're single player. Well, the reverse is usually true for board games. Video games are also a guided experience in many ways, especially those single player games where you have an intended experience with an intended arc and intended conclusion. And it's not quite the thing we have in board games. So I want to explore that and explore the capacity of board games to do that especially in a single player space.
Yeah. You know um I want to do a video about um player agency generally because so because I'm talking about game design a lot. A lot is focused on like how designers create meaning and like it get it's very designer focused. People be like, "Well, what about when what about me? What about the player?" Like, "Yeah, I I'll get to you. I'll get there." Each of my video essays really like it takes the the topic of game design or whatnot, and it approaches it through a framework, and they're overlapping frameworks, you know. Uh, I got a lot of traction for mechanisms as metaphors where I uh take issue with the idea that games can only be toys. And a lot of people are like, "What? But what's wrong with games being toys?"
Actually, nothing. I have this whole other essay about that, but that's not what I'm talking about here. It's a different I'm try my videos are actually quite concise. It's like, yeah, they're like sometimes an hour long, but uh which in YouTube video essay world is not actually long at all, but um I watched that entire H Bomber plagiarism one and that was like four hours. Yeah. Yeah. You know, I I I had I had people say like, I watched it I watched your video on two times speed and like thanks I guess, but that's like a deep insult. Like I take care I hate the pacing very seriously, right? Yeah. like anyway that's funny. Um, so I I have I have that like in those are some ideas I have for for next things. I want to do a piece about um the rep the the new addition of Meltwater once it comes out and I'm able to engage with it. Meltwater is a game that's very important to me. Yes. Um, I want to do a piece about like I I I have so many ideas. It's just waiting for them to come to the surface and then trying to go with what comes up. I also have more research projects I'm doing, you know? I I want I want to get more names off that list.
Um, love it. Yeah. All right. So, while the world might be bleak, it sounds like your own work, there's exciting things ahead, and that I'm very happy about. So, I'm going to assume that we'll get to check in and see how everything turned out at another two and a half years for episode 300. Um, uh, but for now, thank you so much for coming on. You're welcome. I'm sorry I went a little long, didn't I? You said this be like 10 minute thing, and I took 20 minutes of your time. I went almost half an hour. All right. Uh, so, uh, everybody out there, thanks for listening to these. There's still many interviews. Damn it. Um, and I'll catch you all in the next clip. All right, gamers, here we are at the end of episode 200. I want to thank all of y'all for being with me for the ride. Uh, this podcast is one of my absolute favorite projects. It means so much to me. Um, and here's to episode 300. Happy gaming, everybody.