The Big Squeeze - Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip. Did they leave money on the table?
Transcript
So, final grade is Do I want it? Yes, I do. I think the video is very well done. I think the theme, the humor Like, I think even though you did skirt with like a little too much theme as opposed to gameplay, I think it was still so short and the humor came across and the artwork came across and you showcased your nice components. I was like, this looks like an approachable, easy to learn game with a fun theme and I'm excited to see more about it. Yes. Can you do it? Yes, you led off with from the creators of 5-Minute Dungeon. Now, personally, I feel like you still could have put much more respect on your name and spotlighted how many games you've sold or, you know, your BGG ratings, the track record, any variety of number of things. Cuz like this is the number 382 family game of all time and I'm pretty sure Excuse me.
The game you're trying to sell me is a is is is another family game, right? 1127, 2062, 2706. But they didn't do I don't think they did VL. Klask, that's a really fun stacking game. One Deck Dungeon, 56. I'm just saying, I would spotlight that a little bit more. It's a nitpick, but it's still one I think would be nice. But the sense still fantastic. So, do I want it? Yes. Can you do it? Yes. How much is it? Feels fine. You did a nice job on the pledge levels. It's a logical, okay, there's a decent price and then there's a slightly deluxified version with components that I want and then more cards which I obviously want for a slightly higher price. I'm in at that. And then you segued into making a bunch of box sleeves, but in the end, since you know, the Trojan horse is really the 200 deluxe wooden tokens. Cuz now, you just had a thousand print run of those, which means the cost of those, boom, drops down and then you can buy a whole bunch of them and sell them after the fact and then they're going to sweeten the deal when you're trying to sell stuff at conventions cuz they routinely, I think, sell stuff like this at conventions. I'm pretty sure I've seen the 5-minute people at various different conventions.
So, good for them. It's all good. But at the end of the day, the decision to go to Kickstarter, I I just And I know it's based off of limited information. Like cuz 5-Minute Dungeon is their evergreen baby and this I'm actually is based off an immensely popular intellectual property that already exists. And the other one is is their new one, but still I just I feel like they probably left some money on the table like left the money on the table there going to BackerKit. And I know I hate talking about stuff like that, but I'm I'm judging how I feel like they ran the Kickstarter project and going to BackerKit. 83,000 still great. This is still a very solid grade. But you know would they have more backers and more money if they were on Kickstarter?
And I don't think they would have less, do you? I guess there is an argument to be said that they would would get they might get lost in the shovel the the shuffle, but there is no shuffle at BackerKit. You literally are sending people specifically here. It's not like people are just perusing. So, I'm going to go with a I think overall before I I take in the BackerKit switch, I'd go with a B. Right? I think it's a really nice project. Really well done. Quotes, eh. But they had plenty of videos. I'm sure there were some gameplay videos. Did they have a rule booklet down here? You know, it felt like it had all the information you really needed. Right? Like all these down here, it looked good. Did they have a Did they have a rule booklet? Hopefully that's in there. Actually, I'll probably check it up real quick. Can I search? No, I can't. Oh, there's no Whatever.
Final grade is I think a B plus. I think overall was a solid project. I think the the main image is definitely lacking though. I think the main image should focus on a price would be nice, stretch goals would be nice, from the makers of 5-Minute Dungeon would be nice, especially when you factor in just how many, you know, copies of 5-Minute Dungeon have sold when you factor in there's 5-Minute Marvel. Right? Which once again top thousand family game. So, um I'm going to go with a I'll to a minus. I think a B minus is fair. Cuz I I just I just don't feel like they'd be doing worse on Kickstarter, right? I don't see the logical way you'd be like, "Oh, yeah, this is why they would be doing worse on Kickstarter." Which then inevitably means how much better would they be potentially doing? And judging based on their track record, you know, a couple extra hundred units to a couple extra thousand units feels like a realistic number to guestimate.
And yeah, I'm going to go with a a B minus. God, I hate doing that. But who's going from Kickstarter to BackerKit? I don't Good for BackerKit, by the way. Like cool to a third of a point grade bump up for BackerKit for greasing the wheel enough to pry people away from Kickstarter and Gamefound. But it's still it's a choice. It's choice. And for for some it's paying off, for others we don't know. It'll be interesting to see how BackerKit shakes out, but I'm going to go with a B minus. Let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for The Big Squeeze. It still looks like a super fun game. And if you enjoyed the content, please be sure to click on that subscribe button down below. Or if you have an upcoming Kickstarter, Gamefound, Indiegogo, BackerKit project that you would like to check out, please drop in the comments below. I will try to get to that. Or