TCbH Podcast - The Purge!! (of Board Games)
Transcript
hello and welcome to the cardboard heral podcast I am Eric joined as always by my lovely co-host Jack wearing a beautiful little shirt you got on there hey yeah Christina made this shirt for me uh it's based off of an inside joke that uh came up during board gaming I don't know 10 years ago or something where H someone was taking their turn for a long time and then Christina was like hey are you going to take your turn or should I go make a box cake for you uh while I'm waiting and it just kind of became a thing so she made this shirt um actually ostensibly as like a a prototype for something that we could do as official merch but you know possible is what it is possible um well welcome into our listener uh it is a beautiful Monday morning which is not typically when we record our podcast uh due to some things we we're a little delayed this will be coming out tomorrow I think on Tuesday not that they need to know the exact timeline of my editing schedule um but uh it's been a long week which means we've had a ton of time to get games in uh Jack have you played anything fun or interesting this week I play played some White Castle matcha last night the the expansion to White Castle which uh if you've been
following the channel That was like my favorite game of 2023 uh and it's pretty good I don't know I'm I'm I got two minds on this thing one is that it adds more cool interesting stuff and so the combo box these sandbox that is White Castle has even more combos that you can like crunch your head around but on the other hand it doesn't make it any tighter of a game so like if the thing that you really loved about the White Castle is the kind of like almost fetishized the levels of minimalism where it's only three actions each round only three rounds and you really got to squeeze the most out of it you have four actions round now and you don't necessarily have to interact with different aspects of the game now so I don't know like it's cool but I think depending on what you come to White Castle for it's either going to be something that you really enjoy or just don't even want to bother integrating at all yeah I that game was so tight and I think think that's what I really enjoyed about it so I guess in my mind I don't I didn't think that it needed
necessarily an expansion I get why like it's a popular game board game companies have to make money expansions are a really fun way for them to make money um and sometimes expansions are really awesome even with like there's a minimalist design and expansion sometimes can just make that economy even tighter but I just feel like so frequently it adds like new bells and whistles that smudge the uh the things that were really cool about it um yeah I was hoping that it was going to be kind of like uh viticulture to Tuscany situation where I I really love viticulture essential Edition as it is I think that's like just the right amount of game uh for a lot of situations but Tuscany kind of dissects viticulture but in a meaningful and interesting way that uh adds New Paths but it kind of forces you to integrate that stuff I was kind of surprised by with matcha how how much you don't have to interact with any of the new elements uh which was maybe not disappointing but a little surprising because it's a different vibe than what uh the White Castle has brought in the past I anticipate that because I already have it I'm going to continue playing it but I don't know that it's something that I'm going to like be able to
cleanly recommend to people you know yeah definitely I mean and I think that it's not it's definitely not the same but it's probably similar Vibes as I have with like Arc Nova Marine World so far where it's is it nice to have yeah there's a lot of cool things to it but it just you so frequently don't have to interact with the new things that it just it changes the experience a little bit but maybe not enough to just like be full sale on it um I've gotten some of that played again I'm still just I'm having trouble formulating my opinion on it so I I feel like I have to play it a lot where it's it's good but yeah I I think you put it in a good way where it's I don't know that I can just full send recommend it but if you have it it's nice yeah it's one of those things where if uh Arc NOA came out with a second edition I wouldn't want all of the Marine expansion in there but definitely like the university that allows you to search for specific tags that should just be back in the base game you know like those are the quality of life improvements I really liked um being able to kind of more reliably tap into a specific engine without having to um you know just worry about the luck of the draw the rest of it is pretty cool and
it's not like Ark NOA is a terrible game without it it's not like there's a big marinized hole in arcova yeah yeah definitely just like I don't think there's a matcha sized hole in in White Castle well speaking of marine stuff I did play fin span have you have you been kind of following the trajectory of uh what's going on with wingspan and then worm span and fin span are are you a big spanner I like wingspan a ton my wife and I played a lot I played worm span with you a couple times I thought it was fun I didn't go out and and get it cuz for me it was a little bit in the for me at least worms span felt like it was a step up from wingspan but in a bad way where it the thing I love about wings spin is how relatively easy it is to teach people like it's not the easiest game in the world but it's something that I can pull out and teach my sister and she'll really love but it wasn't complex enough that I would want to play it with people who are really into board games like I'd rather break out something like Ark NOA if we're going to do an animal themed game so I that was where I fell with worms span um finpan I'm interested in I really like that they're making them all feel like they they seem like they all feel really different I haven't played finpan but um it does seem like it's its own game even with the span title A as
far as you can in something that's clearly a derivative work right you know like it says on the front of it that it is a wingspan game it says that it's developed by Elizabeth Hargrave so it it very much is a wingspan game there are Touchstone familiarities there that uh carry over from the original to now the two successor titles but the it has a surprising amount of difference that um I'm not sad that I have it uh we're we're on a podcast where we're going to be talking about getting rid of games and you know that makes it the more span games you have the the more you're like well is this Niche filled but so far I'm like I don't know I could see myself being in a mood for worm span or wingspan or uh fin span it's um it's interesting that it consolidates a lot of wingspan like there's um food is completely removed uh you have like eggs that are effectively in two different states uh there's like an egg and then a hatchling which is like a flipped over egg and then all of the resource costs for all of the fish is are either discarding cards from your hand so cards become a much more precious resource uh or uh it's uh consuming eggs or the um
younglings fry whatever the terminology is pans we can call them padawans padawans uh sacrificing the padawans or uh laying your fish on top of uh some other smaller fish uh thereby tucking them in the wingspan parlament and or some other combination amongst that uh and that does a pretty sizable amount to kind of change up the decision Matrix of the game you're still doing uh effectively um how do I get as many things onto my board so that way whenever I take one of these actions it's going to generate more cool stuff for me um but uh it it overall it's simpler than wingspan um but not in a way that I would say it's less satisfying um so I don't know I I like it I I don't think that it eclipses uh the prior two games for me um but I definitely see a niche for it where someone could prefer this over the other two okay well you know like I played these games but I I want to hear about you because I want to say that you mentioned you played some more Spirit Island I I'm always down for some Spirit Island talk yeah Spirit Island chat yeah I uh so I have had a lot of time where
I've just been waiting uh due to the thing that pushed our podcast uh down down the line a little bit and because of that uh I've gotten I've got a lot of plays of the spe Island app in um so just trying out a whole bunch of different character or spirits on that that I have either haven't played in a while or have just fully skipped over at some point or another like I didn't play through all of the horizons of spirit Islands Spirits before but I I have done that now um and I I don't think that I love the app more than playing in person person like even just solo just being able to see and read your cards more effectively than on the uh screen I think makes me a i i play better in person than I do on the on the screen at the same time oh my goodness it's so much faster the convenience is huge it is so much faster um and I feel like I'm doing good and like the no I'm never tripping up on rules which is nice uh so that's been I've gone a lot of place of that and then I'm I'm I'm down the batro hole at this point oh yes I'm down the batro hole I'm we all knew what
happened I I want to my brother who's a real Avid Magic Gathering player he was like bro blro and then also co-workers you know like I work in Social Services you know like uh but I have people who are coming up to me and they're like Jack Jack you playing batro so I I know what's up with batro I haven't played batro yet so tell me for the the board gamer out there how's it hitting the itch it's it's pretty awesome the so and I this kind of comes a little bit from I vaguely know poker I haven't really played significantly ever uh but the entire game is like a Rog like deck builder with standard poker cards but then you also have cards that become more than just standard poker cards and right you have Joker cards which provide extra effects to whatever you're playing in every round you have to like meet a minimum score through a certain number of hands and the score is determined based on what kind of hand you play so like a pair is just you have two points times or two chips times one whereas a full house starts off as like
40 * 4 and as the hands get better I will wait for the C they keep like blaring the siren just a little bit no thank you no no thank you no thank you they keep just doing it a little bit I can't hear it at all oh I can I can hear it a little bit actually uh Discord I think has a huge of noise filtration on it like I can hear ambient noise getting cut out in between some of your words sometimes um and uh that uh makes it so I probably can't hear a lot of the things that are being picked up on your audacity recording well we have the audacity so that'll be good that that'll you know umro so you have two chips yeah so a pair will get you like two chips Time 1 a full house gets you like 40 * 4 I'm not positive on those exact numbers but as you play like a better poker hand which there's like a really standard list of this poker hand beats this poker hand uh you get chips that
are better and you multiply the number of chips by a certain multiplier and the Jokers either add chips or they add multiplier or they multiplier multiplier and it gets like a really uh optimizing as much as possible to beat all of these different blinds which are like usually it's just the small blind is this amount the big blind is this amount and then there's a boss blind which changes the rules of the game so it'll be like you know you can play a full house but all of the cards that are diamonds don't count towards your points anymore for this for this one hand and then after this one hand you go back to just playing the normal things and then you'll get to the next boss blind and it's like all face cards are drawn face down so you know that they are face cards but you have no clue what they are um and it it's it's it's just rad it's so it sounds like a a progression from like slay the SP I mean obviously it's using poker cards but I think of that sort of run-based combo box uh being something that uh you know you're you're always building up to this exponential growth that feels so good when it just kind of all folds out in front of you um so it sounds like it kind of hits some of those same notes
yeah I think I think it does and I think that it is a just it's a it's a rad game it's good to have on the phone especially because run are usually like not that long like you can you can get through a run and even if you have to stop halfway through like it you you don't get lost in what this run like what you're currently doing so um yeah I think it's a rad game um it's been super cool to have I do highly recommend people check it out I don't we're going to do a review on balatro that would be a pretty significant change for the channel reviews I mean it's a video game that is using the uh what is it semitics of tabletop games right yeah so I think that makes some degree of sense uh also if it's something that particularly tabletop Gamers would be into uh then I think uh it would be nice to try to introduce some of our audience that may uh be not into mobile games into this is is not a mobile adaptation of an existing game but this is something that if you like what we typically play and you're not familiar with us yet this is so up your alley yeah so maybe maybe we maybe we'll get around to that um I've played that and then I uh just got back home so I have not played
anything too crazy to hit to the table but I have uh played some micro macr Crime City again nice yeah I'm I'm I'm putting together some footage just because I realized I don't really have a ton of b-roll of it and I think I'm going to try to put together something about it at some point or another um so it's been good it that one's also great I love I love the little spatial reasoning deduction there are like so many things that it's they just pop up and I'm like oh wow I just found this dead body that I don't think is related and then it ended up being related like that's cool that's really cool that that can happen in this game where you're like going back and forth Through Time almost with just a little map um it's not little I shouldn't say little map it is a massive map but you know you can tape it on the wall or something yeah it uh actually seems like something that would be great for my office to put that up in a wall and have it be like some little distraction that people can you know if they need a a 15minute mental break or something something like can move over to yeah just be like so I know you're having a tough time let's figure out who who murdered this woman yeah I mean that's what it's all about quick 15minute quick 15minute murder and you know then we'll wrap it up and we'll get back to this tough conversation we're having there you go perfect I actually interrupt all of my HR meetings uh with a quick like hey
let's take a decompression murder my solution uh break oh great it's it's fun I like having it I need to I'm I'm at this point where I know at some point or another I had cases that I hadn't played like one or two of the like uh middle tier difficulty ones that I hadn't played but it's been so long since I open that box up that I'm at the point where I don't I don't know which crimes I've solved already which is good because it's like oh yeah replayability I'm getting like a lot more that I didn't like you know I forgot the answer to this case so this is just I get to play it again this is fun yeah replayability via you are getting older and forgetting the details exactly right that's how I revisit every video game from my youth you know it's like going back to it and being like oh I totally forgot this happened that's cool I'm surprised all over again yeah it's been yeah I you know I think I have played all the cases at this point but I I just can't be sure anymore um I'm just I yeah I'm going back and forth on it because I think at this point just because there are limited cases like I've played it I like it I think that this would be a game that I'd be okay passing along even though I I really enjoy it and I enjoy having it
but I enjoy passing it along because they have other versions that I haven't played and so it makes sense for me to like I don't need I don't think that I need all versions of micro macro crime city but you know it's not the the spaniverse you don't need to hold on to all that I don't need the spaniverse no and here we're already talking about our subject which is getting rid of games right exactly as intended The Purge everybody get welcome for the welcome to The Purge all board game crimes are legal for the next 12 hours is it one whole day or is it just 12 do they get like I don't was Ethan Hawk in the first Purge mie I think he was wow man I guess that's that that's kind of like uh Carrie elw being in the first uh Saw movie it's one of those things where the The Prestige of those movies uh does not seem to mesh with who was in the original outing well strap your boots in for saw seven whichever one it is where Kos comes back yeah he has like a little thing where he's like they have like a saw Survivor talk and he's there I'm pretty sure nice nice yes Ethan Hawk Lena HTI also in it but yeah that's what we're talking about we're not a purge podcast
but we're going to be talking about purging board games today and I think that you know this is a topic that is every board gaming as a hobby I think in a lot of ways becomes buying board games is the hobby mhm like I think there's a a really tough line of consumerism that you have to have for board games um um and I don't think that it's necessarily like I love all of the games on my shelf if I never was able to buy a new board game I would still play board games all the time but there is a little bit of cult of new and I think with that there comes a just overwhelming amount of board games that we own like I have I have this shelf I have a different shelf in in a different room and it's just like I at some point or another I will have games that I just don't think I will ever play again and also recently I moved and I had to get rid of games because I just couldn't fit them into the moving boxes yeah they fit a a unique space in the hobby market right because like if my hobby is riding bicycles which that's one of my hobbies um I don't have the need to buy a new bicycle every two or
three months or you know keep up with the latest bicycles even if I have multiple of them for different scenarios and they might take up as much space as a board game shelf uh that drive to continually uh a crew and then uh dismiss board games out of your collection isn't something that necessarily uh carries over to the majority of other Hobbies I mean books are uh pretty good analog because when you get a book typically you read it and you might want to hold on to it in your collection um as something that you might revisit or you know it's part of a collection aspect you like being surrounded by the stuff that you have but a single book gives you a lot of time uh and takes up far less space than the typical like 12 x 12 board game box um and board games they they have you know their their games that you play they they're entertainment um they don't necessarily have the like cultural investment that say uh you know reading novels does or something like that but unlike video games which now uh with digital media you can have an entire steam library that is more games than you could ever play but all contained within a hard drive or on the cloud board games
you you got them on your back uh so to speak you know you're carrying them with you across country you're looking at them you're accounting for the space you're buying shelves specifically to store your board games and sometimes the math works out that instead of cutting down your habits and your collection to fit the space that you have you start examining how do I get more space to put more of these things on yeah and I think that it it can be really tough to purge your board game collection like there I I had so many memories with a lot of the games that we MH got rid of during the move like there are so many games in there that I really thoroughly enjoyed but just they had something had to give and those were the things that made the most sense and so I think that it's I totally get why this is like a thing that can be difficult for people this is you know you attach memories and emotions to to board games and playing them gives you a experience that any other board game might not be able to give you that exact same exper experience but if you have a lot of
board games that are doing the same sort of thing it can be really difficult to justify having all of those and I mean we I'm not like we're not swimming in games but like you and I because we reviewers get games pretty regularly that we may or may not like or we may or may not already have something similar in our collection so I think we might Purge our board game collection a bit more than than the average person yeah but I think this is something that the anyone who is in the business of collecting board games is going to face us at one point or another um so unless you're the type of person who like listens to board game podcasts uh even obscure board game podcasts like ours uh thank you for listening um you know tell some people about us and then we won't be so obscure um but uh but um if you happen to be that person but at the same time you don't have the compulsive need to be the Omni gamer you know who brings everything to game night and everything then you know good on you but for everyone else who is likely to be listening to this podcast you're the person who owns a good chunk of your group's games you are the person who learns those games and you are the person who must suffer under the weight of them so um I think to me the best way
to approach this is you know like breaking into kind of mini topics there's you know why like what reasons you might have for wanting to get rid of games um than how you decide what games to get rid of and then what are things you can do to successfully get rid of them because the those seem to be the three pillars of you know like questioning uh that you see uh in this hobby space particularly when people are confronting this for the first time so you know like you mentioned moving uh what are some other reasons that you think of like why you should get rid of games um I think um you don't play it and you need the space for something else like I think just needing space for more board games or even just you have a really big collection that you realize you might have another hobby that also is competing for space and maybe your board game collection is easier to wrap wrap up so to speak um I think that is a super valid one uh money uh board game board gaming can be an expensive Hobby and in some ways people can kind of view board games as an investment I mean you're not going to
it's it's very unlikely you make money on on any board game that you purchase but you might be able to sell it for money that you then can use to purchase other board games like if you if you are going to be buying new board games selling your old board games is a way to have money to buy new ones like especially if you have a budget that's maybe a little tighter but you still want to participate in the new games that are coming out um that that's one that I've seen that I've not necessarily like participated in but it is a thing that I have like seen on our board games of you know no buying a new game until you've played and sold three old games yeah I I think emotional investment is a big part of it to like maybe uh like even headed uh rational well adjusted people don't have this issue but as someone who has anxiety who you know has uh kind of felt the pressure of obligation to inanimate objects so for example like if I have all these board games on my shelf I feel like I need to play them and if I'm making choices about playing a game that maybe kind of like disappointment uh like say for example like I have a game that I haven't played
in ages but I kind of love it I have good memories of it and then I also have this obligation of like well if I own it I need to get it played even though I really want to play this other game over here I guess I should do the play on this other game because if I own it it needs to get played if you're having to do that kind of exchange um more often and you are rotating things in out of a sense of obligation then that's also probably a good sign that you are no longer um playing these things out of the joy that they're bringing you and instead you're letting your things become burdens um so it makes a lot of sense in that case to uh uh cut down your collection or think really hard about like what games you want to own um and not uh have them hanging over your head yeah and I just I think that there are so many games that come out each year that sound interesting to me that I think that if you're a person who is going to be purchasing new games pretty frequently you know it kind of makes sense that they're going to fill spaces that old games filled but better like in in theory of board games are getting better which I I think is somewhat true like I I guess I don't know I think that's a
that's a topic for a different podcast but you know just in theory there are going to be board games that fill the niche that you're looking for better eventually will come out like eventually a board game that fills what you're looking what you get out of this game better so I think that's another reason where and that I feel like a little bit crosses over into the what reasonings do you take for which games to keep and which games to get rid of but I think that's a reason where if there is a game that I just am never playing because I have another game that does what I want from the first game better I'm just going to get rid of that game like I think there are a ton of games that play in a lot of the same sandboxes but some of them can just build better castles yeah yeah I that makes a lot of sense to me and I think we these categories of topics do kind of blend into one another uh I I was thinking about like gifting you know like sometimes if there's a game that I know that one exact friend really loves and I really love playing it with them but I'm never going to be playing it with anyone else that's that's good opportunity to make some room in your collection by gifting that to that friend who it brings them a lot of Joy um but in that
case again you have to be looking for getting rid of games and there's a lot of reasons to get rid of games and you know like the gifting itself might not be the reason to get rid of it but uh yeah so let's see here when you've decided that either because you're downsizing space you're making room for space um or or upcoming games um you need to make some scratch um you know like times are tough maybe you're making rent maybe this is your budget to uh be able to buy more board games whatever it is that is preempting you to sell um uh or whatever other reason that you're trying to get rid of games what's your process for like weeding out the ones that you want to get rid of yeah I think I like to start with Vibes first where it's like where what are these games doing like what fun am I getting out of these games like Splender is a really awesome like Market game where you're trying to gauge what everybody else is doing so that you can kind of strike what cards you want first and maybe take an extra turn and it's all about kind of figuring out what other people at the table are doing and how they can interfere with you and that plays in a like much lower complexity level than a
lot of other games that have a similar like economy Vibe where it's you know the economy in Splender is five gym colors and also gold is there but it's like or is it six oh I forgot at this point it's it's five colors and then gold as a six it's yeah and then I I kind of take that and just you know what am I getting out of this game and I pretty much always compare it to how much space is it taking up on the Shelf because if it's a smaller board game I can keep three of those versus one big board game but if that big board game is doing something that none of the other games are doing mhm you know you it it's like a back and forth between those two um at least in my mind that's where I start and then I go down to like well how frequently am I playing this game can I play this game solo if I would like to cuz for me that's a big thing just cuz I play gamees solo I think a lot more than you do and probably a lot more than a lot of people do I would guess I'm not positive but I play I play games solo pretty frequently and for me if there's a game that I have that is pretty much only for multiplayer that does something kind of similar to a game
that has a solo mode and I like them both relatively equally or even if I like the multiplayer one a little bit more if there isn't like a solo mode somewhere out there like I'll go onboard Game Geek and do the solo mode there but if that is like not a good implementation or if it just doesn't exist I lean I lean towards the the game with the solo mode right well I think a good starting point for me is usually uh pretty similar you know just kind of looking at the Shelf uh feeling out the vibe but then I start doing comparisons like especially if I know that I like a specific genre I know I like a specific thing do I have too much overlap in that um the wingspan collection at this point is a good example of that I ask myself not just as part of doing reviews but in holding on to these games on the Shelf is there any situation where I would pick one over the other that isn't necessarily my favorite you know like if 10 out of 10 times I'm going to pick Wings ban over worms ban then I've already answered my own question you know like I I don't need worms Span in the collection but then I start going well is it like 50/50 how different are these experiences and how different is it from other games in my collection and why would I choose to
pick one of these versus the other and now fin span has you know added itself to that conversation and I'm having to do that calculus as part of the review now why would I as someone who has the prior two games hold on to this uh and that's the lens through which I'm judging all of the changes that are made in the system um and surprisingly it has stood up to a lot of that scrutiny uh but I do that all the time with you know two games that have pretty similar zones uh for instance I think uh splendor and Century spice Road occupy very similar weight very similar Concepts uh and those are two games that are both currently in my collection but anytime where I'm like I need to make space they are right up against one another and I have multiple times been like I think I'm ready to let go of Splendor whereas uh that's one that Christina uh has held on to as like well we should hold on to Splender because you know like uh you know when my folks come to town they really like it or you know like this other thing what what niches it's filling um but uh I also tend to look at like what I haven't played in a while and
then how do I feel about that if there's a game on my shelf that I haven't played in a long time am I feeling like man that's a bummer that I haven't played that in a long time uh like say Game of Thrones uh Second Edition is a game where I really would love the opportunity to play that in it's full six player glory and I have that on my shelf I can see and justify keeping that though if there's a game on my shelf where I have that same like man I haven't played that in a year I really should get that played and the the sense is is that obligation that I was talking about earlier that's a good indicator to me that that's a game that I just need to let go and even if it's one where I have a lot of great memories of Game of Thrones second edition if push came to shove and I were trying to set limits upon myself of you know I need to have only 50 games or only 30 games or something like that there would be a much higher level of scrutiny and and to put on to that and I probably wouldn't be keeping it because I can't keep games that I'm not going to find situations to play in um I'm just kind of in a position of privilege where I have space you know like I I own a house where this entire office area here you know is my
wife and I's living room and um my work office and the entire back half of it is dedicated to board games I have the space to hold on on to some stuff that isn't seeing as frequent a play yeah and I one thing that you mentioned there that I think definitely uh factors into to my P my my board game purging is uh you know extra extra credit which I'll say is is the term for the games that my wife will not let me get rid of even if I want to yeah there are there are some games that I'm like you know I don't think that I don't think that we needed to we did not need to take this game and she said no that is not allowed to to leave so we're keeping it uh one game of such and this is a game that I really like but just it never gets played and I think that even though it's great I I don't think that I need to keep it I actually was going going to donate it to platypus conon just cuz I think that it would be good to for them to have in the collection but it Hive which is great it's a good two-player game it has not it's gotten played once like five years ago my wife and I played it once five years ago and she said no we're keeping this game and I said
okay okay I guess it's coming like it's not that big so I wasn't like that like oh no that means I have to get rid of something else but like that game was like okay sure I I guess we'll keep it didn't think we needed to I have a couple of those yeah yeah you know we we got Partners you know like family friends kids you know whatever it is there there's usually more than just you as an individual who's evaluating a collection you know this is very much Christina and I's collection of games and most of our interests tend to align but I would say that there's like a a 15% on the periphery of like things that are very much that is a game that Jack wants to keep uh and this is very much a game that Christina wants to keep um so th those are things to be cognizant of um I I've heard of some techniques you know like to uh help you organize your mind you know I mentioned earlier putting an arbitrary number on it I can keep 50 games um that really makes sense to me like if if you want to set a number whether that's 100 or 50 or 30 or even 10 I think that's a fun exercise and a great way to kind of consolidate yourself um for really asking hard
questions about what games mean a lot to you um and you start thinking about like what is the likelihood that this game is going to get played um um can I cover a unique aspect of playing games with this game that isn't being fulfilled by any others that I'm holding on to what's the emotional and sentimental investment that I have in this game that I want to hold on to and be able to revisit um I've also heard of some techniques of you know like not going out of your way to play specific games but then looking at either logged plays uh or trying to kind of keep a good head space for um you know every 6 months looking at your shelf and going what games have I not played at all in the last six months and any that I haven't played I have another six months you know I'm going to put like a sticky note on the inside of that game uh and if I haven't removed that sticky note within the next 6 months then clearly I am not looking for opportunities to play this and I'm just going to cut it from the collection yeah I think that the sticking it on the inside of the box that's a good one um but yeah just having some sort of indicator of like once you have played the game it's safe for at least 6 months um or a year or whatever arbitrary number you set uh I think that's a good way of doing it because I
also am a little bit of the mind that we are in this hobby to play games and if you are aren't playing a certain game um it's kind of not doing its job at the same time there are definitely like spells where I just I have had times where I just have been busy and haven't played a game and like I I've definitely had like a month or two months where I just like I didn't really get more like I've played board games once over the course of this two Monon span and that's less the games fall that I think just requires you to be a bit more you know forgiving of that of that metric but whatever number in time makes sense for you where it's how many months do I want to give each game and how many times do I have to play a game for it to be considered considered safe and it's just it's a little bit of a balancing act because there are times where I've gotten rid of a game and then gone oh I really wish I really wish I had that game like I when I moved up with I moved up to Juno with Gloom Haven and I got rid of Gloom Haven jaws of the lion and I've frequently been like oh it would be nice to play through Jaws the lion again like just I it's not difficult to get but like just having the like flip uh book so that I can just get it
out and played Super quickly compared to Gloom Haven that takes a little bit longer like there there are things where it was like funny I did I have Gloom Haven still Gloom Haven fits the exact Niche that jaws of the lion fits but they're just for me at least just a slightly different experience of convenience to get to the table and off the table in a way that I was just I I've had times where I've regretted getting rid of that game even though it made total sense within my all the things I've set so far where I wasn't playing that game very frequently because I just had Gloom Haven I had Gloom Haven which fits the exact Niche like by all barometers we've given so far in theory Jaws the lion is a game that I didn't need to keep because I had Gloom Haven the advice yeah that I give every new board gamer that I meet is you don't need to own every game that's fun um and inevitably there are going to be things that you get rid of where you're like ah would be nice to play XYZ but it's also not worth the cost of lugging around XYZ I mean sometimes you will get rid of something and go like you know I kind of changed my mind on it I'm going to get that again um but you know like at a certain point you're getting rid of good games as well games that at one point you thought were super fun and you have to kind of like be okay with I didn't
need it for my collection anymore you know I didn't need it to be available at a moment in notice if you really really really really really really really wanted to play it you'll find Opportunities to play it um you know you borrow it from friends you could you know play it online and a bunch of the online resources or you could go to a convention there's all kinds of ways that you can play a game um what was funny about the Gloom Haven thing is uh this could be a whole separate podcast in and of itself but we recently completed our Frost Haven campaign uh which was a beautiful fun event uh we played through like 90 games of frost Haven uh and at the conclusion of that I had to make some hard decisions about like what do I do with this game that we've we've now beaten like we played a majority of the side content and we unlocked every character and I didn't see myself playing through it again and I have Gloom Haven jaws of the lion and frost Haven I was like you know what I'm looking forward to the next Haven game but the only one that I could see myself really playing through again is Jaws of the lion because convenience so what I did is I took out all of the characters from Gloom
Haven and then put into the bottom of the frost Haven box all of the characters from Gloom Haven and frost Haven and then got rid of anything that is like the actual campaign materials tiles everything wow um the only thing that I kept uh was characters The Minis so that way I could play them in future versions of uh any of the Haven games or play them in jaws of the lion because you can do that the system does allow you to play with any of your characters in jaws of the lion if you want and so I have this nice cute little Consolidated jaws of the LI box inside of my Frost Haven box along with all those characters so that way whether it's Gloom Haven's second edition or it's uh I don't know Sun Haven or whatever the next Haven game is if there is backwards compatibility I have access to all those because that's something that we did in Frost Haven like at certain points we were retiring characters that didn't have um and we didn't have new characters to play that no one at the table had uh touched so we were like well let's grab a Gloom Haven character let's you know like play with some of those that we didn't see much play with um and played them in our Frost Haven campaign so I anticipate doing much of the same um I don't know if that was necessarily the right choice broadly speaking but it was the right choice for me and it
dramatically uh cut down the footprint of uh Haven in my house yeah when Haven Haven comes out you're going to be super ready you're going be really ready when Isaac childis releases smoke Haven like they all of the Haven games now now are going to have a home with you but just the characters once once their job is done they're they'll be done I think the future of that series is legit doing smaller more bite-sized things like jaws of the Lion but with more um a little bit more of branching paths and a little bit more of a integrated compatibility with other stuff like again you can do that but it's not really intended to be something where you're taking your prior Gloom Haven collection and uh playing with those characters in the jaws of the lion stuff but if it's all done with the like forethought to um do that and just coming out with new modular adventures and stuff I I think that's really an exciting territory they could go but this isn't a Haven podcast either it isn't a Haven podcast one thing that just I mean since we're on the topic of Haven I know that's not a Haven podcast but you know just since we're on the topic they could do like what sowat did with doomed run where they're just like we're going to release some new content but you're going to use a lot of the
same characters and we're just going to give you new scenarios to play through like we're not going to give you a ton of new characters it's just going to be new scenarios that you play through with the characters you already have could be fun I think it could be nice I mean they I don't think that they could do the storage solution that doomed run is but that that is what it is um we had yeah go ahead well I was going to say what What's um do you have any thoughts on like the recommended ways if someone's like okay well I've identified the games that I want to get rid of what do I do now you know like if they've never gotten rid of games before what's your go-to outlet so my go-to outlet is either Board Game Geek like geek Market works for the most part uh you might have games on there for a pretty extended period of time but I think you're going to have that case with any of the options where you're trying to sell them like if you're doing Facebook Market Marketplace or you're doing like eBay um all those options from what I've seen just take a while for for a game to actually sell and you'll have a lot of uh false false uh alarms where people are like I'm super interested can I come pick it up today sorry change my mind right which happens a lot that's that happens when you sell anything on the internet ever um but yeah I think that if you're going to sell it
Board Game Geek at least you're selling it you're reaching the audience that you're trying to reach which is board gamers I feel like with other ways that you're selling it there's a chance people are not looking for like strategic board games that uh you're passing along if it's a game that is maybe either like more simple like in theory if it was something like Splender um or if it's something that is is a little bit more complicated like wingspan like not insanely complicated but something that you're and I'll put both of those with and something that you don't expect you'll be able to sell easily both of those you'd probably be able to I i' guess there'd be some Market on Facebook Marketplace for those but like if it's a game in that realm your local library might be interested like I know Juno Public Library checks out board games I checked out quite a few board games from them one of my favorite board games I checked out from them to test test out for the first time um and I think that that's those are games that are you know libraries are an option where you're still giving that g board gameing out life um board gaming conventions in your area like I donated quite a few board games to platypus uh which is Juno's Premier board gaming group
what are you laughing at you laughing at Premier uh Premiere and platypus you know platypus is i' I've gotten a lot of questions as I talked about platypus con people being like what does a platypus have to do with Juno or Alaska you know like it's a whole thing but um yeah so you know like it sounds like broadly speaking we have the options of you could sell your game you could trade your game you could donate slft your game or you could dispose of your game which hopefully um means that you're looking for whatever components can be recycled out of that um and unfortunately that may mean that uh if you are at the result of disposing of a game um some of those components just can't be recycled um but you know like like we learned in school uh the 3 RS reduce reuse recycle mhm it's always best to check your consumption first you don't have to own every game that's fun if you play a game and you really enjoy it you don't have to buy it like just understand do I need to own this first second is reuse you know like play the games that you have that you love and then if you are going to get rid of them then try and look for Avenues where they're still going to have life and value um with someone else Beyond you um that's where we get into the sell
trade or um or donate uh SL gift so selling you said you use uh board game Marketplace um and that's is is it pretty easy to to navigate I've never sold anything on board game Marketplace bought things on it yeah from what I've seen it's easy to navigate uh you put a listing up you'll get messages through Board Game Geek that are just like hey I'm interested this is my ZIP code how much would it cost to ship there and you typically you provide a shipping estimate and then they say yes and then they PayPal you or vinmo you whatever it is and then you send it and then it's done uh you do if you sell it through Board Game Geek have to pay them a fee which I forget what it is but it's like I if my memory is correct it's like 1 or 2% if that is not correct We'll add like a little note uh here right but it's you know you pay them a little bit of a fee but that's I think the case any well I guess Facebook Marketplace you don't but yeah yeah and there there's other communities uh like I use our Board Game Exchange on Reddit uh is where I typically sell games uh but that's because I have such a volume of games it's much easier for me to just put up you know like a text list of here's all the games here how much I'm charging here's my ZIP code get in touch with me I I've never had had a failure of an exchange on that but then again it's
much less regulated than Board Game Geek Marketplace so you know like use caution um Facebook Marketplace uh particularly in communities where uh you want to sell local uh but you don't have um Outlets where you can sell it to you know like uh consignment shops or places that will buy your used games to then sell hopefully at a profit um which here in Alaska there's very few of those then board game uh sales on Facebook Marketplace might be a thing you do uh Eric and I met through a Facebook Marketplace uh where I was selling some games and he was one of the people who responded to that boom right out there I didn't buy that one I I didn't buy that one from you but I bought other I bought the other iium from you that's right that's right um which you know like again we're in this privileged position where we get a lot of free games uh and uh I don't charge for reviews or anything but uh when I get done with games um I have to find homes for them oftentimes I'll give them to friends who really like them uh sometimes I'll trade them sometimes I'll donate them but when all it fails and I don't really have Avenue for that game I sell it online um local if possible and then I look at uh
uh online if uh if needed so those are some ways to sell um I think it's a great method to go as always you know be safe uh I wouldn't necessarily put something up on Craigslist and have some Rando person meet you in an alley uh buy some board games that is how I got uh Gloom Haven okay through a random Craigslist ad and actually I wasn't even buying I wasn't even buying Gloom Haven from that person I was buying Dungeons and Dragons Minis and they said hey I also have Gloom Haven for $50 and I was like sure sure just put it out on the porch with the D and D Minis and we're good love it um yeah so just use use a degree of caution uh whenever you're doing that um or throw caution to the wind you could also do that caution to the wind or throw caution to the wind but don't say that we told you to do it um trading is a great way that I really love um and uh there's a ton of like convention meetups chances are that if you're at a larger Regional convention uh there's a board game geek uh listing where people have done like um either uh auctions or math trades or other things that are very easy to get signed up for and essentially you just say here are the games that I have does anyone want them
and then it's all pre-arranged who is going to get what in advance of the convention and then you just bring those games that are pre-arranged to sell so that way it's not like you're just kind of like standing around a convention hall and uh saying does anyone want to buy this game you already know and then there's a designated time where people will meet up uh I've done that a couple times at packs unplugged uh where it's like all right anyone who participated in the Big Board Game Geek uh Meetup it's going to be at 6:00 p.m Friday night uh from 6:00 to 7:00 so everyone is going to be in that exact Zone here are the implications if you don't show up or that kind of thing um so that's really cool um trading and gifting to friends like I I've given games to you you've given games to me like we we've uh looked for that um uh or other people in your game group were particularly like public meetups um especially if there are newer Gamers I think uh gifting games is a great way of making them feel special making them feel welcomed and kind of taking down some of the barrier to entry to like actually find some of these things so we've been doing this devil's club Meetup uh regularly there's a lot of people who are very new to board games who are coming to that uh and that's a good Avenue for me to uh play games for review but then if a game really hits
with someone but for me it's like yeah that was pretty good but it's not necessarily you know one of the games I want to keep forever then that's a good indication that you know I might be like hey you know like I remember when we played this game a few weeks ago um I'm all done with it I don't need it anymore uh do you want it you're you're welcome to have it that's a great way of keeping people in the zone yeah and I think especially with us when we just sometimes they're like oh I really need to get a shot of that game especially if you just gave it to somebody you know you might be able to have them just bring it back to to the next time you're going to play to get a shot that you really need if but that's that's more for the two of us than I think our listeners do you ever mess around with the board game geek um like trade uh mechanisms that are available not necessarily the like math trades and the forums but you have collection Management on your profile on Board Game Geek and you can you know log every item in your collection as like a I own this or I've I've played this or I want to own this or I own this and it's available for trade and then you can then have Board Game Geek match you with other people that have listed the games that you are wanting in trade and they are wanting games that you have for trade and then you can just message them and be like hey I saw that you had this
for trade I have what you want and trade let's work something out uh I have not done that that sounds really really rad and helpful um sounds really cool I should maybe participate in that yeah uh I haven't done it in a few years but it is a very cool uh tool and it's something that I used to do uh fairly regularly uh especially when I wasn't um I I guess the cardboard Herald maybe over like the last five years uh particularly about 5 years ago is when it kind of transitioned into a new level of where I was getting review copies or we were getting review copies with such regularity that you know like I still buy games I still trade for games I still look for games but it wasn't um to be perfectly honest the majority of the games that I get at this point are games that either I've requested for a review or were sent to me for review I would say about 60% of the games that come into my collection so I don't use as many Avenues to gain games anymore but you know like back then and I'm guessing I'm probably going to do more of going forward uh just as a reminder in this conversation that's a great way of trying to obtain games that uh you uh
have been getting your eye on but you don't necessarily have access to or you want to see if you can get it without having to pay money yeah yeah that's a that's a good that's a good pathway um yeah and it does seem like the reduce reuse recycle dispose would be the would be the last R I don't really know rot rot yeah reduce reuse recycle rot uh H having it be that pathway of game collection and game disposal uh I think it's a good late Sage capitalism brought in the fourar yeah oh yeah dude oh but I think that's a good listing of why or the ways to get rid of games um with that uh we got a lot of comments on we put a post out basically saying like this is a topic that we have um what what tips or tricks do you have uh to our audience on YouTube and I kind of wanted to highlight some of them just cuz I think some of them make good points that we might have like roughly said but they say either better or more concisely um sweeper 177 said it all boils down to Marie condos question does it uh being the game on your shelf spark
Joy whatever that means to you and it's I I think it's a lot of the you know is this game really fun for you to play still or are you only playing it out of obligation like what is this a game that you look at and go oh I really want to play that if it isn't that's as good a reason to get rid of something as any um see seems on point to me um blue SE Pearl uh suggested you know a coing consideration as whether a game would be appreciated by a friend or loved one uh their godson loves gaming so they were gifted did um some Gateway games um they had friends who they thought CO2 second chance would be a really good option for again getting your board games from your shelf to a place where they will have a bigger life uh will be really helpful I think uh just in kind of keeping our consumption of goods on this Earth down um and then let's see what was the if I had one more that I thought was just really really good um just one well all there are a ton of great comments we did get quite a few comments on this post I think people are in The Purge right right
no sometimes we have to make room for us to Rattle on for an hour uh and that sometimes means the sacrifice of a worthy comment or two here I did find it I found a second one that wasn't the one I was looking for uh cam obscure 88 said that they have around 450 games and that's a lot it they they comment that somehow that feels like too much and I I do feel like I might have to say as as as a voice of reason as a person who owns a lot of board games I think that might be too much that means like if you played a board game every single night night of a year and you played a different board game every single night of a year then you would still not have made it through the entirety of your collection that just seems exhausting to me like when you when you think about it like the the sense of obligation and also like relearning and everything like I have about a hundred games that I keep um which is pretty sizable uh certainly not uh in the realm of some uh people uh but just thinking about having to relearn all of those games all the time and expansions and just H it's it's exhausting but at the same time I feel like cam obscure 88 will just never have to worry of like oh I really wish that I had kept that game because they still
have that game right they'll never have they'll never have whatever that game that I you know they will always have the game that they hoping to have which you know great for them if you and if you have space for it who am I to tell you how to live you know I'm just some guy yeah if if your board games are security blankets then I guess that's a way to go yeah um the the last comment that I did want to touch on is from Joshua Taylor uh who just did this with their collection uh it you know I think that's a great person to talk to about why or how you would do it uh and they went through their games uh most of the games were an immediate keep uh but the criteria that they had for the ones that were on the border were how many times do we think we have played this did we enjoy it when is the last time we played it what has kept this game from getting to the table since then and if I get rid of this game do I think I'll miss it 6 months from now and I think the what has kept this game from getting to the table since then is a really important con consideration like for just to talk about a game that I almost got rid of with Hive the thing that kept it from getting to the table is just there are so many great two-player games that I hi just wasn't a game that got played Super frequently when it was just my wife and I right and I still kept it for for for
her sake but you know like that can be a really determining factor of what is going to be kept and what isn't is like why have I not played it recently if you haven't played in a while like it could just be you know maybe you have just bought a ton of new games and you are excited to play those new games but if you're getting rid of those new games you should still keep the games that you have played and you you know you like I mean that's what it all comes down to right yeah um keep the games you like keep the games you like um be prudent uh and uh be uh somewhat Frugal with your space um think of well we we shouldn't be trying to take advice from Tyler Jordan uh that's taking the wrong message from Fight Club but the line you know about your the stuff you own end up owning you um that at least is I think a cautionary bit of advice that you know like unless you're in a very specific use case scenario um a game is about getting played about having fun about bringing Joy uh about entertainment and sharing space with others or playing solo uh and you should be able to look at your collection and um feel that you have uh the games that you really like
to play uh and that you have opportunities of things that you want to get to the table instead of obligations yeah I think that's that's a great way of putting it I think that's a great way to cap off this episode uh we've had a lot of people who seem to be interested in this topic and I hope that we answered any questions you have uh if we did not feel free to comment on whatever platform you're on whether that be YouTube or Spotify um or our website um or feel free to email us at cardboard at gmail.com um we'll be having another post about whatever our next podcast is going to be here shortly so look out for that CU we love listening or seeing your questions and answering them and it's much more fun when we have like the plethora we had this week uh and we are going to you know continue trying to engage in all of the comments that we get uh I would love to listen to questions you know like if you want to record like almost like it is like a Reading Rainbow uh type of like hey cardboard Herold here's my question you know you can put that into a unlisted YouTube link and send it our way or you know like you could bring that email the3 yeah email the MP3 we would put it in the podcast yeah I'd figure out how to edit it in and it would be good so I
would figure out how to get Eric to figure out how to edit it in well thank you for listening thank you for watching for those of you on YouTube uh thank you as always for tuning in and being a great Community um I am Eric with the cardboard Herold along here with Jack thanks for tuning in later