Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top Ten Board Games of 2020

Transcript 22:50

welcome to allies or enemies i'm jess and i am sean and this time we are taking a look back at the best games of 2020 and you did hear that right we're not accidentally saying the wrong year we just we never did it 2020 and we kept saying all last year we're like let's do it and then we're like oh we didn't play enough games we didn't play enough games we didn't play those games we finally a whole year later got to the point where we feel like we played what we wanted to play and we really got a good idea of what our top 10 is so we thought you know what let's just do it a year late and we really loved so many games that came out that year that we were really excited to to make our list and see what ended up in the top 10. yeah 2020 was a great year like i i don't know if it's going to be one of the greatest ever years but i i don't know like i was thinking about like what are the great years like in movies it's like 82 it's like et blade runner um tron dark crystal like lots of cool stuff secret of dim in music it's like uh 67 or um 94. 94 was good for movies too i just i love 1994. but um for board games it just feels like 2020 is was really a killer year 2020 might be the the best year of board games we'll find out maybe i don't know we'd really have to look back but it's the best reason you're board games that's for sure and uh yeah we've got we've got a top 10 to count down and we did the same thing we did with our 2021 yeah we

ranked them for what we thought individually what were our favorite games then we compared that and based on the average scores is how we did our list um and they were fairly similar again we like very similar games um some small differences but usually that's just because we think they're all great there wasn't really necessarily for a lot of them even if you had it higher than i had it i still think it's a great game yeah we did we had some like i have i had two in my top ten that didn't make the top ten um so our top tens were were close we had like eight each oh actually you had nine in your top ten that made it which is not which is unfair uh but i guess without any more do we can talk about that so i can complain about my two um so let's let's kick it off with our with our honorable mentions do you want to go first with that oh okay i only have one that didn't make it uh and that was marvel united so marvel united is my honorable mention um it's super simple really really basic you play a card and it has one of three icons on it and then you just get to do those actions so it might be doing a heroic action or moving or punching somebody and then you also work with your partner so it's cooperative and that's one of the reasons why i love it i love co-op games i love having a light option that we can we can take out and play in 20 minutes and the the villains really mix it up as

well and that was my honorable mention and then i had two that didn't quite make it uh so the first of those is merv and merv great what is his name against right here fabio lopiano and he makes some really some really solid games and this i think we said it we did a little video about this and we said in that video it feels a bit like a like a lighter lucerta totally stand behind that it does and it's beautiful super fun work replacement game it just didn't quite make it which is fair uh and then santa monica is the other one and this one had a i think one of the biggest gaps of any just does not like this as much as i like this but i i love the look of it it's and it's super super light um and i think because we bought it when we're on vacation and we played it a bunch in the hotel but i like it even more because of that yeah it it looks lovely it's a really light game so if you set those expectations it does work really well for that i think part of it is the box is way bigger than it needs to be and for me that i don't know there's something about that that it just it brings it down a little bit yeah it could this box could be like a sixth this size and still have room left over um i totally agree with that yeah so let's get into the actual list um and right and i think i'm first here we're just gonna go back and forth on

them even though you had this one a little bit higher than i did but our number 10 is calico and yeah it's great it's a towel placement one of my favorite things it's you're putting cats on rugs that they like and it's really brain burny and it's uh it's tough to give up on the fact that you will not you will not succeed you will not complete all of your goals which is kind of fun just super high production too yeah and it it's so thinky so you you really have to strategize and then also just have a lot of hope for like the right thing to come out at the right time yeah yeah there's a lot and i like like just the little bits like they've got little stories about the cats because they're all based on actual cats and they've got the little like um achievement goals that feel like xbox goals in the back of the book and just all these little touches i think make this a great game yeah so this is number ten number nine is this one here pandemic legacy season zero i love all of the legacy pandemics again i am a huge fan of cooperative games and pandemic legacy does them so well you you play through and so you get about you know 14 to 16 plays maybe out of it but every time you play something new is introduced and this one really blew me away i think i didn't expect too much of it because i thought like season two was pretty similar to season one-ish that they did some neat

stuff but this one does it so differently i think this felt so much more different because it's cold war and everything like that that it just again just a whole other kind of kettle of fish but still working within the pandemic system in season two i'm kind of with the masses on it i didn't i i wasn't in love with it it i didn't i didn't hate it as much as some people but i definitely felt like it was a step behind and i felt like this kind of recaptured the magic a little bit it's more like you're sneaking and spying and going into buildings and we don't want to give stuff away from it but it it just it looks great it's nice that like the instead of cubes you've got little secret agents in like the little secret agent hats which is really fun as well yeah you find that out right away so that's that's not a spoiler but that was our number nine our number eight is this is another big gap because this was number five on my list but knit of the layer and nina velir is one of the games that we got um actually we got late last year we got late in 2021 and we first played this one on board game arena and then we played it for like months and then we're finally like okay we gotta get it because we're playing this so much and it it's just a terrific tableau building card drafting game where you've got three rows of three cards you just take turns drafting one from the top row then the middle row and the bottom row and you're trying to make up sets of different kinds of dwarves and they all score differently and it's

got kind of tricky scoring which i think maybe like you got to do you got to do a little bit of math yeah for sure but it's it's so worth it and it's it's just such a it's such a simple but such a fun game and the style is great too yeah and it it is that simple kind of set collection and we really liked it on bga but then when we got it in person the production of it is really nice there's like where the coins are there's a little coin display and i am sucker for good production and so the the art and and the massive size of everything being bigger than it needs to be all of that really made me like this game even more yeah we really thought with the bga we were like what's the point of like do we need to own this and then yeah i'm glad that we do just because it is it's silly like the card holders like you said the coin holders um and it's we've played it a ton super fun game it's nice that it's got a small box so that is our number eight our number seven has a bit of a bigger box and it is this one this is a tidal blades hero of the reef and this it looks gorgeous you could probably see from the box here and it was one that really wasn't on our radar until we went into our game store and wanted to pick something up and we're just drawn to the colors of it didn't quite know what we were getting and it's just a really fun work replacement game where you are building up kind of your your dice and building the levels up and completing these

quests and and trying to impress the judges for that and it's it looks great the the play is fun as as you as you complete those quests and it all comes together really well and that's i had this one a bit higher than you did yeah i didn't think i would like it honestly because it's so much so much dice rolling but i don't know it didn't it didn't feel that random to me because the dice are almost resources and you can like you got a pretty you get pretty good odds that if you've got more dice you're gonna succeed um and yeah it's it's just it's fun with like i i like the surfing like the weird kind of like you're showing off your like surfy skills half of it because it's half that and then half you're like fighting monsters yeah and they they don't totally mesh for me but it still it works well and i'm i i love the colors in this too that's it yeah when we set it up because you're you're advancing your dials on your player board i thought it was going to be a really long experience but it plays in like under an hour at two players which is which is great because that's a really kind of shorter than you want it to be in that really good way that you want to keep playing and that was our number seven our number six and this was number three for me but just doesn't like it quite as much um but that is beyond the sun and beyond the sun definitely not this is not the most

beautiful game that you're gonna own in fact when we first got it even when we looked at it it it looked like like a pre-production copy a little bit but once you got it on the table it does not look like that but just from the pictures we were like is this this is worth like i think it took us like nine months to buy it because of the pictures we just thought it looked like it was maybe in more of a prototype than a full finish it look it looks really cool when it's on the table and it is the mechanics are really good this is like a combination it's basically a giant tech tree but within that you've got worker placement you've got a little kind of mini area control game that's happening off to the side and you're kind of doing all of these things at once a little bit where you're leveling up um like the abilities that you've got or the the different worker placement spots that you can take advantage of while you're also adding ships and there's this really cool economy system where you've only got i guess three things yeah but you've got like uh workers you've got ships and you've got coal or yeah whatever it is it's a black you've got black things and and you've got these little dice that just that go from like suitcase to worker to ship to stronger ship and it's so smart and i don't i don't think i've seen another game do that yeah the management of those dice is a really interesting aspect because some cards let you turn your your dice into ships but then once you've done that you realize that you're no longer able to you don't have dice

left to get people that needed action so you really have to balance everything and it just it plays so good it's so fun and so that is our number six our number five is this one so this is tang garden and you start off basically with a blank canvas and then on your turn you are building out a lovely garden by putting out tiles or putting out decorations and that could be trees or fish or birds and it's the a lot of like decisions you still have to make for that in terms of whenever you put out a tile you often get to advance uh advance your cubes along the way and that gets you some more characters but it it looks gorgeous and again that's one where the looks of it really makes such a difference for this game the trees are three-dimensional the transformation of this this white space to a beautiful color space and it's just delightful to play as as you make that that choice of you know do i do i put out a tree or do i put out a tile oh and i love that one of the main goals too is you just got to put out people and they and you have to put them looking at the things that they want to look at so you have to build like the garden that they want and then they have to look off into like the distance at the sorts of things that they like which is just a it's a really nice thought and and sometimes this game feels pretty you know peaceful we put some music on and then just play our tiles but sometimes we can get really

cut throat as we look at what the other person needs and try and kind of preempt their move and and get in their way a little bit but no matter how we do it it's really fun to play i don't know if it's ever peaceful this game is straight up maybe the first time we played it jess is mean in this game this game is straight up cut throat no not always always i don't want you getting all the points it is straight up cut throat uh but beautiful at the same time and that was our number five our number four is the third part of one of our favorite series and this is vi counts of the west kingdom and i like that the like the the west kingdom games and just the shem phillips games in general have kind of gotten a little bit more complex every time i think and this one is it's you've got a lot of different paths to victory where you've got you're building on a castle you're moving around a space and you can make buildings and you're hiring new people to be part of your town or whatever it is and then you've also got you're like you're moving card tableau as you play cards it's also a deck builder um you're also collecting a menu there's so many little bits within it i don't even know like what kind of game i would call it's like a multiple engine building yeah deck builders like you said yeah it's the rondelle movement and uh like kind of work replacement but within your very limited movement abilities and your deck building and

you're right there is a lot to it in terms of that complexity but i would say it's not quite as heavy as paladins in terms of um like the the strategy and how much you have to make for your decision so it is interesting that so much was built into this game that works really well and and once you understand the icons it really does come together nicely and i i love the series and i love vi counts it's also my favorite one um i love going in the castle and and sometimes there's times when i get to put out just turns upon turns of people in the castle so that is that is one thing that your your hope the expansions maybe boosts the other strategies yeah i think this expansion either it just came out or just coming out but yeah i'm really cause jess is a castle fanatic uh she's crazy for the cast i love the castle i'm always like well maybe manuscripts maybe if i do building slash manuscripts maybe and i win now and then but she definitely wins more than i do with a constant hardcore castle strategy if there's a castle i'm gonna go on it but this is it's a great game and that is our number four our number three is i think the biggest box yeah this is what we have on this list uh dwellings of eldervale and there's there's just so many aspects that i i love about this game uh essentially you still only start off with a few tiles out and those tiles are where you put your workers to be able to perform those actions but part of those actions is

being able to put more tiles out part of those actions is being able to purchase cards which will give you different kinds of powers so it's going up tracks it's tableau building it's it's tile placement and it's all in kind of a d world and so there are monsters that come out there's some battling that happens there might be some quests you have to do there's just so much going on but it's bright it's colorful and everything that is going on are all things that i like to do and it's all really connected like it's cool that um everything you do kind of does another thing so like you put out your things and like you're saying you get like you take resources from the thing from the tile that you're on or you get a power and then when you bring back your guys you've got like a second kind of work replacement section where you put them on your cards to further get resources or actions so you're also building that card tab low for like the second part of the action and then there's also this like resource management where because you're turning dudes into houses by putting hats on them which is the best part that is the whole best part you actually just take the roof and you stick it on your meeple and now it is a house and then you're recruiting like wizards and dragons and you're fighting monsters and it is great and it's great that there's so many options there's what is it's like 16 different races or something that you can be yeah and so again asymmetry is something that we both really enjoy and so the the asymmetry is a bit minor but enough to really

influence the game and that is our number three our number two and this was this was my number one uh jess is number three that is dune imperium and i just i boy do i love this game dune imperium it's so dune like the board is stark the thing you're really trying to build up um influence in different areas and just that you're only playing to 10 points and every point you get is a real battle and it's back and forth with those influence tracks and it's back and forth with the with the um with the fighting board as well which is like another little part where you're deploying troops and it's just who has more troops at the end of the round um and all of that just it feels so doomy and i i love it yeah and you really do have to do a little bit of it all you want to make sure you're going into the battles that are worth points you want to make sure your opponent doesn't run away of with a political victory in terms of getting all the points from being associated with all the other factions um and it again it builds it so well and i think part of i've loved this game as well because i hadn't read the dune books until we got this game and then we read the dune books we watched i watched full movie for the first time you had already seen it and so again all of that just kind of set the scene for it which made it a really great experience and the board game i think really captures it incredibly well yeah well we read the first dune book there's like

12 words just the first one i think we own the second that i started um and i i would strongly suggest reading the first yeah june book and i would strongly suggest playing the game and that is our number two our number one is lost ruins of arnold so that was my number one your number two my number two yeah um and so these two games always get compared we love them both yeah they're fantastic and this one also is a combination of work replacement and a bit of deck building as well and just really really tight resource management and in this you are an archaeologist that is exploring new territories defeating guardians and really importantly doing doing research but this is all about making combos and a lot of careful choices about how you spend your cards because the cards will either dictate what location you can go in or be a resource so you have to balance everything yeah it's the the deck building is it's it's a little bit like less deck building i feel like because you've got cards like your cards might come out three times in a game it's not like like dominion where you're really building that so you can go quick quick real quick this is more like i'm gonna i'm gonna need this card at some point later and this is gonna be helpful uh but the combo-ness of it because your first turn you feel like you do nothing and you're like how am i going to get up that track and then your last turn you're just like boom boom boom boom boom and then this gives me this and then this gives me this and then this helps me fight this

guardian and i think the the theme as well like i just i love the indiana jones um the adventure explorer theme to this yeah and i love the production of it as well because the gems look right the arrowheads and stone tablet tablets all of that contribute to putting you into that theme and into that world and i think this one's at a slight advantage as well because we have played the expansion uh that came out and so maybe that's why it's a bit higher for me is the expansion is fantastic and it adds that asymmetry that we love between the player powers i highly highly recommend it like it moves it from what was already a fantastic game to just a phenomenal game and so that's our number one of 2020. so thanks so much for watching i know that this is uh well it's 2022 now so we're like two years late on this but you know what we might even do more of these i don't know um but that that is our favorite and it was just such a good year that we were like we got we got to talk about it yeah we'd love to hear what your favorites are of 2020 maybe there are some games that we haven't had the opportunity to play so please do put those in the comments and as usual please like subscribe all of that really helps us out and hopefully we will see you for the next one

Progress saved