Don't Buy This Game - Episode 1: Charades
Transcript
hi it's Ryan from night surround a patio table I'm up here in Canada and we have about three days of summer and this is one of them so my wife Cheryl thought that this would be a good idea to come and shoot outside for once instead of me floating in weird wherever space in front of a white background this is part of where I live so welcome to it now I titled this video don't buy this game which I admit was a little bit facetious because this is part of a new series that I want to try out and it's about games that existed and were free to play that were popular parlor games that somebody then came around and commercialized right they put a trademark on it they put a you know fancy word marker they added components to the game in some cases they took an activity and made it into a game and then sold it in stores so what I want to investigate in this series is what that commercialization actually adds to the game whether it improves on it or takes away from it and whether you should actually spend your hard-earned dollars buying something that you could otherwise enjoy for free so the game that I wanted to kick this whole thing off with is charades charades very popular part of game if you're not familiar with it here's what you'll need you're going to need two bowls and two teams now this is a game that can only be really enjoyed I think with two teams of two or more people on each team right you're not really going to be able to play this two player or three player so you've got two bowls and you're gonna need you're gonna need some lined paper
right and you're gonna you know give the line paper to doesn't have to be lined actually it could be like the back of an envelope that's probably gonna be that you're gonna give a sheet or two to each team and then you're gonna get some pens out right and so you're gonna have to test them because this note this pen doesn't work and I'm gonna test this one and okay this pen works and you're gonna have to go through the mall because somebody's gonna complain that one doesn't really work but maybe this pink one does and yes this pink one works so now you guys don't play this on a windy patio you've got two working pens so everybody gets a piece of paper and what they have to do is write stuff down and of course they're gonna be doing this and they're going to complain that there's no stiff back to it and they're gonna be trying to write like you so if you've got a coffee table that's cool maybe you're even going to have to go and get a straight back book in order to put behind the piece of paper but what the two teams are trying to do is they're writing down names of people famous people celebrities maybe books TV shows movies and they're gonna break them down and then they're gonna they're gonna tear those things off and a little strips and they're gonna fold them up and they're gonna put them in the bowl then the two teams swap the bowls you take turds right so one person from one team goes up pull something out of the board Bowl sorry and they have to get the their team members to guess what the book TV show celebrity is and they can't say a word they have to sort of mime it this was a game that was kind of like a hit it goes way back but it was a hit in the in the 70s you know at 70s parties with the the shag carpet never gonna
have they liked a huge hair and you played just before you swapped keys and just after you eat macaroni jell-o salad you know the 70s you know what I'm talking about it's not a perfect game though it's got a few problems one of them is that couples who play together have an advantage over people who aren't couples so if you're playing with maybe a couple of singles friends who you want to meet each other at your dinner party and then you bust out raids on them as a couple you probably know your own secret unspoken language very well and then new people who don't know each other so well can't play that game why does easily so you've got an unfair advantage a lot of shy people hate charades a lot of people hate charades but shy people especially they don't be like being up in front of people and they don't like the pressure and they don't like the failure of not being able to mind the thing properly you ready to say it so it was a big hassle for them they don't enjoy it and then you get other things where you know just some wiseacre puts something in the bowl that nobody's ever heard of and the person goes up and they go I don't even know what that is and you say oh just try just try and then for the next three excruciating minutes somebody tries to you know mime the third lost boy from the left in Peter Pan not the Disney version that some people know but like the more obscure one from the 90s and it just doesn't go well so enter a different take on raids where you split it up into rounds and this is very very smart and everybody's pulling from the same Bowl
right so names and stuff that you put in there you know what's in there so everybody has a piece of knowledge and they know what's going to be pulled out to a degree then you do it in rounds so in the first round anything goes you're actually allowed to talk so you can say oh this is the third lost boy from the left not in the Disney version but in the 90s version that fewer people know and then people can go oh it's Bartholomew you know yeah yeah it's bartholomae right so you can talk all the way through the first round second round it's the same name same movie same books in the bull and you go through and you're still allowed to talk and you're allowed to mime as much as you want but you can only say one word and then in the third round again everything goes back in the bull it's the same names in the bull but for the third round you're not allowed to say anything so you have to sort of rely in the third round on the gestures that have evolved over the course of playing this game which is pretty clever so what somebody did was they took that version of charades and they turned it into a commercialized product called time's up
you now this is like a multi award-winning game you can see it's got little award symbols all over the box and it was for the longest time very highly ranked on board gaming sites this is a mass-market version of the game that I just described to you and it goes exactly like I described should you buy it in my opinion I mean I've tried it a couple times but it has a couple of new problems that have been introduced so one of the problems that where people don't really know that the names that are being put into the into the pool time's up has that problem too but they solve it by drafting so you put together a deck of cards and then you split it all up and everyone gets to go through the deck maybe they have 20 cards and they pick ten to go into the bowl and that depends on player account I guess we're not using bowls anymore really we're putting them in a deck however it still suffers from a major problem where if somebody goes up there and they pull out David Foster's name from the bowl and they have no idea who David Foster is I mean I guess they could pass but I mean we go through their whole team and nobody on your team knows who David Foster is by the way he's the guy he wrote the theme for the 1988 Winter Olympics in Canada of course but that's still that's still a flaw with the game the other flaw that I found with this game is that a lot of the names that they've chosen to put in there are just
kind of dorky and lame here I pulled a couple cards out I'm gonna go through a couple and then you can tell me if you think that this is gonna make for a cool evening or not okay all right here we go this Ivanhoe the Sundance Kid you know from that super popular movie 50 years ago Albert Einstein okay he's on the cover sure Mark Twain Halle Berry Bilbo Baggins John Wayne you know so you can kind of tell that there's a certain demographic that this is trying to appeal to so there's another problem too is you're not really going to be able to play this very easily with people of disparate ages or people with different levels of pop culture awareness to improve upon this experience there is another commerce and this one's called monikers now monikers is the exact same game as that modification of charades and times up except I think that monikers makes a couple of really crucial really smart improvements to the times up formula so it takes all the fun of time's up and just yeah it just punches it up a little bit so I grabbed some of the cards from monikers and I'll read you a couple deep throat is the is the first one and I won't explain that the second one is Cohn of course that would be the gesture that goes with it in the third round Octopussy is the next one a streaker so
not even specific people just the concept kurt cobain so you can tell already from those cards that that this one skews a little bit younger than times up but you might say well Ryan it's got the same problem you can't you said you can't play with people of you know disparate age groups how does this solve that well because the rule modification that monikers makes is that in that first round if you get up and you have no idea what a streaker is you've never even heard of that it's kind of a 70s turn term you're allowed to actually just read the entire darn card as long as you don't read that top part that says a streaker so you could go up there and be like I don't know a person who strips naked and runs through a public space either for fun or on a dare or it's a streaker oh yes thank goodness right and then you get to go on to the next card and you earn a point for your team fantastic so I would say just that innovation just the fact that they've added a whole paragraph explaining what this is it does so much a lot of the cards in monikers are kind of like hip in joke stuff they got a bunch of you know internet memes stuff on there here let me read a couple more this next one is Bob Ross he's the guy from the joy of painting and it puts it right there in italics for all right Julius Caesar don't know who Julius Caesar is I mean that's that's fair if you can't really you know he was kind of like a leader maybe in kind of row many times you look smart when you read there's a Roman statesman author in general who in the first century BCE he declared himself dictator in perpetuity look how clever you
that way so I really like that that's a really smart innovation that that removes a lot of the problems that times up has the cards are hipper because you've done a draft off the top just like time's up everybody has a stake in it and everybody kind of knows the moment like two words leave your your lips somebody can guess oh my gosh that's Julius Caesar as soon as you go Roman you go Julius Caesar everybody goes whoa how did you know that forgetting that you're the one who picked the Julius Caesar card to go into the deck to be guessed right so you look brilliant and it's cool because maybe you know up to a quarter of the cards in there and you can guess them really quick that's great being a bit of an art snob I'm not super big on the illustrations in monikers they're a little bit low Phi but I titled this video don't buy this game the verdict that I would like to pronounce on monikers specifically this one implementation of this times up game which is a version of charades which goes back to original charades with all its problems I am going to say that this is absolutely worth your money it removes all this need for going through 50 pens in your house to find the one that doesn't have dry ink you don't have all these papers and the problem of having to put them on a coffee table or get a stiff book for people to write on nobody has to think everybody can look smart everybody can look cool and hip by reading these cards it's got the paragraphs on the bottom of the cards that make you look like a complete superstar and help the game move along that helps the shyness problem so even
shy people can get up there and if they just read the card in that first round they can feel included and part of the action it's tremendous so I don't know how I'm going to rule on a bunch of the other videos that I plan in this series but in this case I would say if you don't like charades for all those problems but like the idea of playing a fun party game this is consistently the most fun I've ever had with a party game this is my favorite party game of all time and I'm telling you I've never laughed harder than when I've played monikers with my friends and there's a secret fourth round to that I'm gonna mention in the way in the fourth round if you're really having a good time getting the end of the third round you don't want it and in the fourth round you you go behind the couch and you do the you can do the actions except nobody can see the rest of your body and you can only do the fourth around with your hands like a puppet show with no puppets and everybody's arms are naked it's hysterical I think you'll really enjoy it I can't remember what I paid for it but it is absolutely worth every penny so don't buy this game don't listen to me buy whatever you want in this case definitely Ryan says bye thanks so much for watching did you just watch that whole thing oh hey there 100% this video
click the badge to subscribe and then click the bell to get notifications when I've got new stuff