Skip to main content
Loading video...

3 Witches Review - Why Can't We All Just Get Along?

Transcript 14:00

Hey, I'm Alex Ra from Board Gameco and today I'm reviewing Three Witches from All Play, an exclusively threeplayer trick-T game. If there's two of you, play something else. If there's four of you, play something else or take turns playing Three Witches because this is a three-player trick-taking game. Before we dive more into it, this channel is currently sponsored by All Play. More about them at the end of the video. And in case you noticed that this game is from All Play, which means there is definitely completely bias at play. I will obviously do my best to power past that and to be mindful of it and give you my thoughts and opinions as fairly as I can. But if you don't think I can do that or if this doesn't have value for you, check out a variety of other content creators who have covered this game. With that said, in Three Witches, the general idea is you're going to start by dealing out the cards. Let's go ahead and deal six over here. I'm just counting to six. I can't believe I just clipped them like that, but it doesn't matter in this case. Normally, I would deal them, but it's just faster. So you can deal hands of six to each players and then players are going to take a look and starting with whoever has the elixir which whoa look at that first hand I drew has the elixir then starting from the player to their left meaning this player over here gets to make a bid or a determination as to how many things they think they can win, how many tricks they can win. Because this game is pretty straightforward. I do find playing a sample hand is the best way to kind of teach people how things work.

They'll look at their hand. This is actually not a bad hand. Ooh. Ooh, this is a good starting hand. In fact, to the point that I'm going to go ahead and uh this player is going to go ahead and they're going to go straight to four over here. They think they can do four. If you bid four, you immediately are the lead witch. If on the other hand, you bid three, it now goes to this player. Do they want to out bid them? And if they do, they go to four and then they're the lead witch. If not, it goes to them and then they can either out bid or not. But basically, the bids are three or four. you are bidding that you will win three out of five tricks or four out of five tricks, which is a pretty big number over there that doesn't go to five. But as soon as someone claims four, they are the lead witch. In this case, this player claimed four. So now what we're going to do is this player is going to play two cards. They'll play one face up and one face down. Uh let's go ahead and start off.

We know that green's got to be in play. So honestly, the best way to play this probably is to play a four and a four. That's what we're going to play right now. We're going to play that as our hand. There's a reason. Hopefully, this works out for us. But effectively, what's happening right now is they're playing a face up card and a face down card. Both those cards will count, but for right now, the face up card is the lead card, which means the next player, it's worth noting, by the way, these other players are now part of a team. They are basically trying to together win against the lead witch. The problem is, oh, before the start, by the way, I should have said we should have discarded a card. Uh, the the the non-le witches are going to discard a card from the hand. We'll discard this one over here. So non lead which lead which is discard a card face down so they have a hand of five cards each. Looking at this player's hand over here they have a green which means they have to follow green. So they're going to go ahead and take this and play that because this is a must follow game. This player does not have a green so they can play anything else. The tricky part is this is not a hand we're going to win because of how these things play out. So I'm going to go ahead and get rid of what I guess is my worst card here which is probably this. But honestly potato patat. Let's take a look at the suits. No, the this is probably my worst card. We're going to get rid of this one over here. That's going to be the card we play. And then the lead, which is going to reveal their card. And they have a four and a four.

And we have a two and a three. This is where the scoring comes into play because the highest number wins. The lead trick just matters for forcing players to uh play a certain suit, but the highest number wins, but the way it works is if you have the same suit or the same number, you add them together. Otherwise, you take the highest of the two. For example, a four and a four means the lead witch played an eight for all intents and purposes. A three and a two because they don't share the suit is basically just a three. So this is a eight versus a three. The lead witch has won their first trick. When they win a trick, they're going to take back a card of their choice into their hand. If they lose a trick, then the other witches are going to take a card of their choice, putting it back into their hand. This is technically done privately secretly so other players don't know. But this card we're going to get rid of over here. We'll discard it. And now we go to the next suit over here. So now the lead witch again, they are trying to win, remember, at least four tricks. Well, not at least four, exactly four tricks.

So to that end, they already played the green. So they know that the green is gone. Because you might be looking at this and thinking, well, there's a seven green, so there's more greens. There's not. These are the suits that are in play. There are only four green cards and we just got rid of the last ones because of they lost that last trick, which means if we play a green card, they can go off suit. And if they can go off suit, they potentially have more control. So, we're going to play one of these cards knowing that we have a much higher chance because someone's going to have to play a black three. So, we'll take these cards together for the second trick that we think we're going to try to win here. We're going to play face down over here so they don't see. And then it goes back to this next player again. And once again, this player feels bad, but he has to play his black three. This player could play a three, which would be nice because then that makes it a six. But this is already a six and they know there's a decent chance they play that. He'll get rid of his red, his orange card over here. I don't know. No, you know what? We'll get rid of this card. We're in trouble no matter what.

That's the card they're going to discard, which means we do have six versus 11. Once again, the lead witch has won the trick. Once again, they can pull back a card. In this case, the six is marginally better. We'll take that. We'll get rid of these. We go to the next trick. Back to the lead witch. By the way, the lead witch always starts even when they lose. And again, I have to remember to I actually want to lose at least one of these. But if I play a green at this point, they can go off suit. This is where you want to try to think things through. I'm going to play a green. They're going to go off suit. But what's going to happen is what could they do? They could play a five and a four possibly. We haven't gone to those colors. They also have that. I think a seven and a four is probably the safest option. I'll play a four over here and the seven because I do Oh, this is actually an interesting strategic play. This is where the game gets a little interesting. I'm thinking through the way I would play this if I was actually playing it because I actually might want to deceptively play my lower number first knowing that they'll think I'll have the higher number and that way they won't even try to beat it. There's things. But for right now, we're not going to worry about that. Back to this player. They can finally play off suit.

The problem is right now they could play off suit. They also could pass. When you don't have to follow, you have the opportunity to pass and let your teammate see if they go first and then it comes back to you. For right now, they know that I could do a five and a four. So the question is, if I did a seven and a one, then right, sorry, if I did a four and a one, then a five and a four can beat that. If I did a four and a seven, none of these are going to beat that. Unfortunately, nothing I can do can beat it. The best chance I have is hoping that it played a one. So, we'll play this five. It goes to this player over here. Doesn't even have the number. I must have gotten rid of at some point or something happened or I had it earlier as the lead witch. Uh, they could play this doubler over here to do a times two. The this elixir is always a times two, making this a 10. Unfortunately, the lead witch wins. And again, it's a 11 versus a 10. This is basically the process that you're doing.

You are pairing up your tricks together to try to figure out who could actually win, whether it's the lead witch or the coven of witches against them as you try to win your exact bid. Now, at the end of it all, if you did correctly, if the lead witch did correctly win their exact bid, in this case it was four, then they're going to get two of these tokens. On the other hand, if they did not, then the minor witches are going to get one token each. And your goal is ultimately to try to play until you get to five tokens total. That is basically how you play three witches. It is a game of allegiances that are going to shift every single round because the lead witch in one round might not be the lead witch in another round, which means you're constantly changing up who your ally is as you attempt to maneuver out maneuver the current lead witch or I guess if you are the lead witch, attempt to maneuver uh the minor witches. That's basically how you play this game, which means it's time for my review of what I like, don't like, and can see others not liking. In general, the sense of of of teamwork here, the collaboration that develops as you play through the game introduces an interesting element.

That's why it's specifically a three-player game. It's one versus two every single time you play it. And the multiple ways, the the mathing out of how you're going to play your cards. That's a big part of the game because you have these little rule sheets over these player aids that give you the exact distribution of the cards. And it's an odd set of distributions because you're both playing with multiple suits and multiple numbers. And so you're trying to figure out how can I play my cards in a way that I can get back the cards I need, team up well either face off against the uh the team of witches and outmaneuver them or team up with other witches as you attempt to work together to take down the lead witch. There's a lot of mathing out not just the opportunities, not just the possibilities of which cards they may have discarded and which ones are in play, but the order things will have to go and even those minor aspects that I was starting to touch upon where you can start playing bluffing games of, okay, great. they will probably assume that a certain card is here. Therefore, if I do that, even if I wouldn't have had a winning hand otherwise, I could bluff my way into them thinking that I would have done X and they're not going to challenge that. Therefore, I'll actually be able to win one more than the cards would have let me. There are interesting elements at play, both the mathing as well as the small degree of bluffing.

The fact that you're only ever bidding for three or four tricks makes this a very tight game. You're playing five tricks every single time. You're always playing five tricks every single round, so to speak. And you have to win three or four of those to be in contention. you can't go for five, you can't go for two. It's an exact specification of what it is you're trying to go for. It leaves a very it's a very tight game as far as that bidding process. When you look at your hand and try to think, is my hand good enough? And if mine isn't, is somebody else's hand good enough that I could challenge them? Because you're not just thinking as to whether you can achieve the number yourself, you're thinking through if somebody else does that, can I challenge them? Because if not, maybe it's better to gamble for getting it yourself. The lead witch leading every single time adds an interesting element of control that you don't usually see because usually I'm used to thinking through, well, I'll play a trick, but if I lose control, I straight up lose control. The lead witch still loses some control. That's more manifested through the way that the coven can kind of hand back the card of their choice, but you still have the agency of going first, which means you can come back from a single bad play, although you have to really math it out really well to be able to make that happen. And so seeing the cards go back to your hand as you attempt to incorporate it all into a rapid sequence of winning multiple tricks against the coven of witches, it is very tactically satisfying to play out how it can go and then manifest it as you play. As far as what I don't like as far as what I don't like in the game, the main thing I'd say it's all there two things. I'll say two things. The first thing is that it does run a little long depending. The depending is I've had games where the lead witch won twice in a row and then became a side witch and won and suddenly three rounds of play and boom, they win.

You could have it run a little longer. I mean, you could have it go as much as I mapped out exactly how long it could go in theory, but two tokens are always being handed out. But especially if the side witches are winning every single time, that's five full rounds for them to win. That can feel a little long. So, it's tricky because since you could get two in a round, the game can end abruptly. I'd say honestly even the difference between moving it down to four tokens, I understand why they went with five. It sometimes depending on how it plays out, it feels like it runs a little longer than the game session would ideally be. The bigger issue I have is that once you solve the puzzle, so to speak, solving might be the wrong terminology, but once you've once you've played this a few times and you start to see the various ways you can think through it, the playability, the replayability starts to become limited. For me, this is a game that my first play was kind of like I I guess I'm figuring it out and learning. My next few plays were starting to appreciate the intricacies of how you can try to think through the ordering of your cars, the teaming up of your cars, and even the bluffing element that could be in play. And then after that, it's still fun, but the charm of figuring out the puzzle was kind of lost. And it's just I mean, there's only a handful of cards in this game, and you s get to a point where you've kind of figured out how the number game works. And for the most part, that bluffing element aside, you've kind of mathed it out as soon as you've dealt your car. It's again, not perfectly. Things can go wrong. Players can make mistakes. You do not have perfect information in this game. I don't want to pretend that you do. But the the the feeling that it's a pre-done game, I've started to feel that more and more as I've played this game. As far as I can see, others not liking, I mean,

mind readading. You are with a teammate in this game. Sometimes you're not on the same wavelength. Some days they mess up or trying to figure out how to beat the lead witch. Uh because the lead witch you're it's up just up to you. You don't have to rely on anyone else. You either win or lose in your own merit. But playing as a team, you have to have a teammate who is on the same wavelength as far as how to play things. As far as final thoughts of Three Witches, overall, I enjoy this game with an arc to how this game played out for me. For me, I'm going to give this game a 3.5 out of five. Although, I'd say my middle plays of it were definitely a solid four out of five because again, the first game is kind of just a learning game as I started to figure out and appreciate it over multiple rounds. As I dove into it more, it started to really grow on me. It was very I I felt really clever, specifically as a lead witch. I have a bias towards playing as a lead witch. I will try to go for that even if I'm not quite sure I can make it because I really enjoy kind of that sense of complete control over how things are going to go as opposed to reacting, which could be another thing you don't like. I have a preference for the roles.

But both are fun. Both are fun. But subsequent plays definitely had that aspect where it felt really I felt really clever regardless of which side I was playing as I kind of learned the ins and outs of how things paired up and even that bluffing element. But then like I said already as I played it more it definitely shifted down for me once the sense of exploration wore out. It still is a good game but it's a small enough set of cards that it feels a little too tight and a little too predictable as far as how it's going to play out every single time. So, it was kind of started as learning, jumping to a four out of five, and then the more I played it, going a little down to a 3.5 out of five. As far as other game recommendations, definitely check out The Crew if you appreciate trick- taking with a team, but this time with a full team. And check out Inside Job if you do like the element of like team, but not team. Inside Job is kind of a trick-taking game in which you are working as a team except one of you isn't. Additionally, I mentioned that Allplay is a channel sponsor. If you go to allplay.com, you can go ahead and check out games from both Allplay as well as a variety of their partner publishers. And if you're in the US, you can get it for $4 flat rate shipping for no matter how many different things you can get. I'm going to recommend All Play again on this one. Uh check out Ghost of Christmas. One of my favorite trick- games from All Play. Delightfully good time, a lot of sequencing, and very satisfying. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radical from Board Gameco. Hope you found this review helpful and as always I hope you have a good

Progress saved