THE CREW vs MISSION DEEP SEA | What are the DIFFERENCES? | Which one is BETTER?
Transcript
how's it going everyone i'm dylan this is all you can board and if you're watching this video you're likely wanting to know the differences between the crew the quest for planet nine and the crew mission deep sea which just recently released well honestly the biggest difference is how much time has passed and how much i look different because i'm wearing the exact same clothes as when i did the how to play video for the crew so i'm putting up the screenshot right now you can see the comparison this is what a year and a half in a pandemic will do to someone between versions of the crew apparently but honestly there's uh there's a few differences between these versions but honestly there's a lot that's the same if you're coming from the crew the quest for planet nine you love that game you're not really gonna have to learn any new rules to get into mission deep sea but there are some changes that make this version really really exciting so the way i'm going to do this video i was trying to think of the best way to sort of review my experience with the mission deep sea but also compare the versions what i've decided is i'm going to answer five questions that i think are sort of the burning questions someone might have who has either played the crew and wants to know if they should get mission deep sea or is wondering where to start i'm gonna answer all these five questions that should hopefully answer most of the questions you will have about you know which version to jump into or how you're comparing these if i didn't answer something that you specifically want to know don't worry ask me in the comments and i will gladly answer that question obviously there's some stuff i might not cover but i'm going to do my absolute best and so with that the first question that we're gonna answer is what are the differences between these versions i feel like that is the number one question people are gonna have so let's start with the rules the rules are the
exact same there's no differences in terms of how you play so if you know how to play the crew when you buy mission deep sea you don't have to really learn anything else in terms of the core gameplay rules the biggest difference we're going to start there is in the way that the task cards are handled so in the crew you'll remember that there's the task cards that were sort of shuffled up and given and depending which task cards you had they were basically replicas of the cards that were in the main deck so if you got the pink three you might have to you know be the first one to win a trick by game to gain that pink three there's there was different qualifications on what the task was based on the mission you were doing but also based on the number tiles the road it was i don't want to say it was inelegant but that's probably the best way to word it um the tasks should be super simple but sometimes it would get a little confusing with the numbers that were out there and knowing what does the arrow mean in comparison to the numbers i know that's where i got most of the questions when i was teaching the crew and trying to explain it to people you get it after a couple place sessions but it was sort of the one hiccup or one place people will get hung up on the crew mission deep sea is completely different in terms of the task cards all the task cards are now very are all like unique and all much more not complicated but more complex but in a way that doesn't make it harder to get into so rather than it just be you know uh you have the task for the pink three it might it'll be something much more specific saying you have to win the pink three as the you know the first trick of the game and the task card itself will actually say that on it or it'll say you have to win a nine of
any color using a one or something they're they're very i'm throwing out random tests i don't even know if these are all tasks in there but it's a lot more specific and it makes the games more difficult at times and more complex but much much more interesting i find that the tasks in mission deep sea it's almost no comparison i have much more fun with the tasks in this version than i did the original and i love the original not to say the tasks were boring in the original the gameplay was sound it was awesome but i just feel like especially having experienced this game a whole bunch and now moving to mission deep sea my one concern was am i am i gonna play this version say yeah it's great but i was getting that same experience when i played the crew with the quest for planet nine like what what is the difference like why am i owning both these versions and the tasks are one of the biggest arguments to to have mission deepsea much more complex much more interesting makes for harder games and just makes for a more fun experience i think when you win it feels sometimes more accomplished because the tasks have even that more in the original you'd have that sense of oh my god how are we going to figure out how to win this this round i don't know if we can get all these tasks you have that way more often in mission deepsea and it feels way more difficult to overcome so you feel more accomplished when you actually pull it off so another difference you should be aware of is that there are less missions in mission deep sea so i mean obviously this one takes place in space this one takes place under the sea under the sea under the sea so in the original uh the crew for requests for planet nine you've got 50 missions in mission deepsea you do get
32 so there's 18 less missions but one thing to keep in mind is that the crew had this thing where sort of the first 25 missions were a little bit of i would say like not an introduction it's not like it was a tutorial but it was introducing you to the concepts and it was um you know distinctively easier i would say than the second half the second 25. so when you look at it that way the second 25 is really the meat of the crew the quest for plan 9. so you had 25 there you get 32 and i found that even even though the first couple are very much tutorial i would say that by the fifth mission we were already failing and we were already having to like repeat missions because of the tasks we were getting in because of how much more difficult it can be um it was just a lot more of an interesting experience that way so even there's less missions i feel like you're not going to really notice it all that much unless you were someone who just really really like constantly went through all 50 missions and felt really challenged by all 50 but i feel like it was more that last 25 where a lot of people spent their time so the other thing i do want to go back to i'm realizing on the tasks task cards there is also a difference now in terms of how they're distributed so uh in the original it would just say you know there are three tasks in this in this mission uh in this version it's scales per player count and on the back of each task card i'll put some imagery on the screen so you can check it out there's basically numbers for each player count and then number is sort of the power level that is going to be for the scenario you're doing so every scenario we have a power level associated with it and every task card doesn't have a power level of that task card based on its difficulty so if you have a power level of five you're going
to draw cards off the top of the deck blindly just looking at the backs until you've drawn the equal until the cards you've drawn are equal to power level of five so say you've drawn a two a two and then also you draw another two you're not going to play that two you're gonna keep drawing until you find a one and that's gonna equal your power level of five um and then those are the cards you're gonna use which is an interesting system it keeps the balance uh in check it make sure that you do have some difficult cards the only thing i'll say is it's a little bit inelegant again in terms of like you know you could draw a power level two power level two and then you're just drawing off the top constantly sometimes you're going through like 20 cards looking for a power level one at that point you're kind of just searching the deck looking for the one you want it doesn't feel super slick but at the same time what's the alternative and it doesn't really affect the gameplay so it never bothered me just something to keep in mind that you're gonna have to be doing um those are honestly the main differences as obviously the theme is different the cards have different artwork but they're still you know function the same way instead of rockets this one's i think submarines if i'm not mistaken so like everything's still there the theme has just changed but those are honestly the main differences the biggest one to just be aware of are the task cards i feel like i i feel like that is the biggest change and the one that's going to influence people's decisions on which one to buy and which one they enjoy more the most out of anything else so that is the answer to the first question let's jump into question number two and the second question is probably another big one that's on everyone's mind do you need to own both versions um this is a it's a tough question to answer for any comparison of games because everyone's going to be different i can give you an answer right now and i'm going to but it's not going to going to apply for
everyone so don't take this as you know law that oh dylan from all you can board said i i should own both or i shouldn't own both obviously it's going to apply to different people i'm going to try to explain that in other in the subsequent questions try to give you a little more clarity but just from my opinion having played both um i think that you can absolutely own both and you can get a lot of mileage out of both and enjoy both but i feel like in my opinion very soon mission deepsea is going to phase out the quest for planet nine for me and that's because i am so much more interested in what's going on in mission deep sea with the task cards and and how much more interesting i'm finding the games because of it that i feel like it's gonna get to the point where going back to the crew quest for planet nine is going to feel like a step back for me personally now that's just if i'm thinking about it from my perspective and me enjoying these games the other thing to factor in is who are you introducing games to and who are you playing with because i've heard a lot of people say that they've had tons of success introducing the crew to people who don't play games at all you know family members or in-laws and things like that that that don't normally play games and they're being able to introduce the crew to them and they're enjoying it there's a bit of a hurdle with some of the rules understanding trick taking games and things of that nature but generally it's a really successful place to go i feel like that's going to still be the case it's going to be way more successful to introduce this version than this version to that specific crowd people who don't normally play games or are very you know general board game players card game players this is going to be an easier place to start because of the less complexity you're finding with the task
cards i feel like some of the task cards in here it's not going to be that the tasks are too hard to wrap your head around it's going to be that the strategy of how to accomplish them all is going to be harder as an introductory place than the crew is where it's just when this speci specific trick for instance so i think if you're someone who is going to be introduced has people in your life or people that you're expecting to introduce um games to that don't play very often or already are really enamored with the crew and you still don't play very often you only play infrequently this is probably one you're gonna want to keep in your collection for those situations but then you're gonna want to have this one in your collection for for you for you specifically and your friends who are more into games and and to explore that complexity and the more interesting design um and because they're these are not expensive games it's not also unreasonable to say you can own both it's not like these are 200 games and i'm saying on both you know we're talking like 15 to 20 games um it's a easier barrier to entry to be able to have both in your collection so i really think it depends who you're playing with and who you're introducing games to me personally and i played mission deep sea with uh i had obviously played the original crew i played with someone else who had played the the crew a lot and i also played with someone in that same session that had never played the crew at all and i had no issue whatsoever introducing this to them it was just like the crew took a couple sessions to understand the strategy of how we're all working cooperatively in this trick-taking environment but there were no other issues with that so me personally i'm pretty confident mission deepsea is going to phase out the original crew for me um but again for you it's going to depend on who you're introducing the crew to and you know who you're playing with more often
all right the next question we're going to talk about these next two are kind of you know sister questions we'll call them um and uh they're gonna be pretty quick i kind of already covered some of this stuff but i just want to stress some of it so the first one's gonna be who is the crew the quest for planet nine for and then we're gonna talk about who the crew mission deep sea is for so the crew quest for planet nine honestly um it's it's this is where i think this one is going to beat out mission deepsea in the sense that the crew with quest from planet nine in my experience is pretty much for everyone um people who are brand new to uh board games card games tabletop games um have absolutely loved the crew when i've introduced it they've just been blown away by what a game of this size that's cooperative can do i've had people that normally don't like cooperative games love the puzzle element of the crew quest for planet nine you know a lot of cooperative games you're playing against the game like pandemic you're playing against the game itself and you you could make an argument saying that's kind of what you're doing here but it's it's not like you're all working together in with these cards to solve a puzzle that you have because of these task cards so it feels different it feels like you're just working on a puzzle together and i feel like that cooperative experience um is unique for a lot of people they don't expect that coming in so it's been really successful with those people but at the same time all my friends who are you know big into card games and board games play all the time and and have you know tons of games in their collection love the crew and anytime we sit down and play it it's never a you know a dull experience even we've played some of the same missions multiple times and come back to it and loved it so i feel like the crew has that over a lot of games
but especially over even mission deep sea in that it's kind of for everyone you can have this game in your collection you can be feel confident introducing it to people you can feel confident that you're gonna have a good time whenever you pull it out if you are playing with more advanced people you don't have to start on the first mission you can say let's start a mission 30 where things are more complicated um so that that's sort of why i would say the crew is for a little bit of everybody whereas let's talk about who the crew mission deep c is for and in that case i would say it's still going to work really well with lots of groups just like the crew does but i think if you're like i said if you're often introducing games to new gamers or people that don't play games very often the crew mission dfc is probably not for you or for those people specifically i think this is for people who won have experienced the crew and i just just want a whole lot more of it and want you know uh advancements and more interesting decisions and seeing what the the systems of this original game can do when they're stretched to their limits so i think that's specifically who the mission deep c is for and i think it's also just for if you haven't played the crew but you consider yourself a more experienced gamer you've played a lot of trick taking games maybe you've already played the fox and the force duet so you have uh sort of a know-how of cooperative trick taking games as well i think this could be a place to start and you don't even have to necessarily start with the crew unless you really want you know to have 82 missions instead of 32 because you're that into it i think that that's specifically who mission deepsea is for as well is the more experienced gamers or the ones who are looking for a little bit more of a challenge is probably the best way to say it and then the last question i'm gonna answer is the big one which version is better and i'm gonna
also kind of tie in here what is my full like my full final thoughts my quick little review of mission deep sea so which version is better in my opinion i'm not even going to beat around the bush i think mission deep sea is the better game i think this is a better experience of the crew i prefer it to the miss to mission or to i prefer to quest for planet nine and that's saying a lot because the crew was one of my favorite games of 2020 i had it on my list it's still one of my favorite games of all time i absolutely love this game so know that i don't say it lightly the mission deep sea is is my opinion the better game and that's honestly just because it's basically just improved on everything i wanted uh the systems to be improved on from the original um it has the exact same gameplay that i love it has the same puzzle uh elements with you know with your friends around the table trying to figure out how you're possibly going to overcome everything and the one thing i wanted which was more interesting tasks and you know a more and higher difficulty it delivered on so for me specifically the hipaa gamer i am i'll always gravitate towards mission deep sea unless someone specifically wants to start with this version or it's someone i feel like is going this is gonna be a better beginning point but otherwise if i find that i'm just constantly going to this version uh the original is one that's gonna leave my collection just because i i don't need it anymore this is this is the superior game in in my opinion again this is my opinion on it it's you know it's it's based on my level of how much i play board games who i'm introducing games to there's there's tons of merit on both and to actually revisit both it's just for my personal collection i think mission
deepsea is the one that's going to stick around so overall thoughts i think that you know there's a lot of board games that do very well and then right away there's a lot of sequels coming out or follow-ups because they're trying to you know cash in on on on the success of the game you know look at it look at azul right as well as such a popular game we keep getting new versions of azul in that case every time we get a new version of azul it's it's pretty much a brand new experience uh but it maintains that one aspect of how you pick your tiles and then how you're placing them is completely changing every single time i feel like the mission deep sea sticks a lot closer to the formula here it's basically the same game with a new theme new missions and new task cards and those are the things you'd expect to change and i would say that the theme and the story and all that it's just a minor change i mean it's that's never the reason you're coming to the crew is because it's this huge hugely deep story but the task change is exactly what they needed to do and sort of exactly where this the evolution needed to go that i feel like it's the perfect sequel in that sense that it's just taking everything we love and giving you more of it in a better better way and i'm curious how else you evolve the formula when we get the crew desert mission or whatever the next one's going to be what's the evolution there are they just going to come up with even more complex task cards so i feel like we're going to reach a ceiling of complexity and then all of a sudden there's going to be a barrier on those versions of now they're too hard for beginners so what else can you evolve the crew formula with you know maybe there there's a better two-player version you can introduce because it's sort of a two-player
variant that's included in the box that it's a better game from three to five in my opinion you know what can you evolve on to keep the series going if that's something you want to do that's a that's a big question i'm i'm kind of wondering and pondering is like where does this end or how many versions we're gonna get but as it stands right now i think it's a phenomenal sequel phenomenal game i love mission deepsea and what they did with the task cards i've stressed it so much you probably are tired of hearing me talk about task cards um but yeah those are all my thoughts on the different the differences between these games i should have mentioned at the beginning i'll probably include it at the beginning as well but if you click up above there's the how to play version for the crew with the quest for planet nine if you watch that video you'll know exactly how to play mission deepsea the only thing you'll have to wrap your head around are the new task cards so feel free to watch that video if you want to learn how to play you can play both these versions of board game arena you don't even have to own physical copies if you want to check it out otherwise i hope this video helped you out if you have any other questions about these versions and the differences ask me in the comments i'll be happy to answer thanks so much for watching see you next time
you