Beyond Solitaire Podcast 62: Jason Perez on Healthy (and Unhealthy) Misbehavior in Board Games
Transcript
hey gamers this is liz davidson from beyond solitaire and i'm back for episode 62 of the podcast this is the second half of a double episode with jason perez shelf stories how are you doing jason yo peoples what's up uh this is our second try at this the first try was really good this one's gonna be even better yeah it's one it's always good to have a second draft and two like honestly i have no problem zooming with you on any old weekend morning or weekdays just excuses that that's what your podcast is this excuses for it's like having i think of a podcast like having a dog you know you take the dog to the to the supermarket and it's like i have a podcast talk to me and it's like it's an excuse for it to talk to nice people oh yeah this is this is definitely like my cove cure for loneliness that has just evolved into something else so we are going to continue the conversation from our previous episode which was about historical tourism and games and kind of erasing historical realities in the name of comfort and an enjoyable palatable experience for people who just want to have a good time you know stay out of my board games country fresh
but now we're gonna get into the stinky stuff and under what circumstances you can and should have it in your board games would you say that's about right yeah i mean so you can emerge from a conversation like we had last time episode 61 of bhutan solitaire uh on historical tourist games it's like okay uh you know they're trying to ruin my fun right and they're trying to you know i'm i want to i just want a puerto rican piece i just want to play age of colonization and peace i just want to play uh endeavoring to sail and uh mark hybal all these games that we like kind of in the crosshairs uh i just want to have i just want to have fun and like i wanted to make another episode to kind of specify that i am not against fun people and i i like fun and as a matter of fact i really push it when it comes to like what i would what i think a game could do and we'll talk about that and i call it healthy misbehavior i'm going to speak about that as an educator i'm going to speak about that as a psychotherapist uh as a psychotherapist who i like when people have fun and they they they sometimes need that unsafe space that safe space to be unsafe and to be you know jerks and everything and i'll specify all that and distinguish it from the whole like you know cultural stuff because i think that those are two different things so i wanted to have a conversation that's that specified that distinction yeah that makes sense and you know even thinking about how you know i'm a teacher i um i have to work with my students in those registers too you know there's things that are outright disrespect that i have to like discipline in the classroom but there are also things where you build in like even within a student's relationship right like i play a game called stolta
with my students still to me stupid in latin so i will deliberately misread something that we're all reading together and if they catch my mistake they you'll stall at me and tell me that i'm an idiot which they of course love to do partially because they're telling the truth and then partially because it's misbehavior it's it's contained misbehavior it's contained misbehavior and i think that this can go a really long way into board games and still be 100 healthy absolutely okay all right yes but you have a sponsor oh yes i do so i will mention my sponsor it's always good to have an epic uh so i am being sponsored this season on the beyond celtic podcast by central michigan university's center for learning through games and simulations and it basically is an awesome new development at cmu so if you are younger and you're looking for a place to go to school and you want to play games for credit then i mean i can't tell you not to go for that um they have a games press so they're going to be bringing some academic games to kickstarter over the course the next couple years i'm really excited about there are a few other surprise announcements that i can't talk about yet but let's just say that cmu's up to some good stuff this year i'm a big fan of taking games more seriously than just games so it sounds like cme is doing just that yes honestly what they're doing is right at my alley so i have no issue just plugging it very cool but uh back to gross stuff so no um so you also like to get aggressive
in games so what do you have any experiences like that that you would maybe want to talk about as an exemplar in your own gaming life of what we're talking about okay so so i'm talking about healthy misbehavior right and to be clear like you could see my wall i have a lot of cooperative games i'm a mess of teddy bear you know i'd like and and also like kind of low interaction euros and just building stuff and being pastoral and i i to me i am imagine teddy bear and i have to like really specify this stuff there's like there's you know i don't want to distinguish no good for me and therefore good for thee or like not good for thee i don't want to make that distinction so it's like okay everybody has to play what i play uh there's a lot of people out there that play things that i would never play ever ever and i we're free i think liz coming from a journalistic tradition and me you know coming at it from a humanist uh tradition as a psychotherapist like we want people to be able to misbehave all they want in games within like a circumscribed limit and that limit is pretty broad for us so when i talk about healthy misbehavior um let's talk about this is beyonce so we're going to talk about war games what about war games you know i was like if i'm playing if i'm having a problem with all these colonization games well then i always get that that uh responsible what about war games i want y is it bad player not to you i'm blaming like brutality i'm doing this this and this and yeah you always hear them just like that yeah that's the voice the voice that comes in here so then a war game as let's just take
that as a very as a very starting example a war game to me is is good war games not any old war game you have to be well crafted and you have to be uh you know historically accurate and whatever the war game ethos is to me that represents a case of healthy misbehavior as a matter of fact i just learned this uh tanya pogba put up a blog talking about uh h.g wells and that whole idea like he was published a book i think this was in the 19 i don't know like early early into early 20th century where he talks about war games as almost like a replacement for actual war you know so like people who who want to get that instinct out who just love war it's like okay don't make war with real people don't use real bodies don't use real resources like play this game and get that instinct out in the game which is safe for people so then and that's so that's why a lot of the earliest games are war games like you know i think blitzkrieg was a war game from germany in the in the 19th century uh with minnie's creek spiel yes crease field you know and and chess and checkers are all martial games yeah and the instinct to play war in a game is old as heck and as much as you can kind of focus on like okay well you're you're representing brutality and you're uh you know you're trivializing what people go through on the field in the game space right i'm i'm not in the world now i'm in the game space you
know i am kind of recreating uh or like you know just like we call sublimation right and psychotherapy uh we're sublimating these errors these urges to fight these urges to be violent you know and in a way civilization is a project of sublimating urges like okay give them circus give them lions in the the coliseum give them today mma and give them all these things and give them war games give them conflict you know get and and you know and then we're sophisticated in our not historical knowledge we like to put ourselves not just like abstract combat but like in the in the field of battle that's healthy behavior yeah i would i would argue that it is because i have a so while i was writing my dissertation i was spending my off hours playing skyrim i've played a lot of skyrim and i love it when like they go to the slow frame where you like do a really good kill uh i'm 100 like just murdered everyone i got all the daedric artifacts which requires cannibalism human sacrifice and like other horrible betrayals in order to get them all but this wasn't a game i've actually felt still a little bit guilty about some of the stuff that i was doing because i'm actually a bit of a softball myself but um i really i really enjoyed the experience of being a little bit bad like i love the thieves guild i love sneaking to people's houses and stealing stuff like would i ever do that in real life god no but it felt great students
and we love it we love do do your thing right yeah and i think in a worse scenario you know if you're playing as a general i mean i'm listening to an audiobook about napoleon right now and like there'll be battles where thousands upon thousands of people die but the excitement of strategically winning is clearly kind of winning out a lot of the time for those people who are like in high command i think that's how you feel when you're in that situation and i also think that it's definitely okay in a game to be like yes i made a strategic sacrifice and i was victorious ah you know because you're not actually hurting anyone right and you know i i feel completely comfortable with that personally right and there's a way to have fun and there's there's a bunch of layers to that right so like okay there's a consent that happens so it's like you know and that we'll talk about consent more in just a second but in terms of just like establishing that safe space to misbehave now you know everybody at the table who is participating is giving their consent to be like you know what i'm going to misbehave right now everything that i do is not something it's not something i want to happen in real life but i have these urges and i work hard and i did relieve stress and there's nothing leaves just like you know beheading an orc or you know been hanging on whatever it is i thought about it because like uh the whole frost haven deal right remember this was like a couple of months ago where isaac put up the blog and i'm gonna i'm gonna make frost haven safe for people and i want you know i want i want boy we to be a safe space
so much of that we taking out the cultural stuff for now but like so much of that was like i think a lot of people were like wait a minute i can't miss behaving my game anymore you know wait a minute i want to like i want to be a dirty mercenary because in frost david you're playing like these it's very like kind of gritty mercenary making terrible choices killing you know enoch's babies and you know like making the choice to be you know just go go for money and be a be a dirtbag and i think a lot of people interpreted what isaac was doing as like okay i can't do that anymore because other people be offended and that's not what was happening and i'll explain what's happening in a second but you know you could still be a jerk isaac realizes that he that's where his mu that's where his bread is buttered in helping gamers feel like jerks really smart gamers who turn a lot of gears but like those gears are turning towards being the maximum jerk to kill as many people as possible he wants that and we want that too you know we want you know i want you to in skyrim to you know uh revel in your kill and there's also um i should probably mention this at this point because this is a very we're two americans and so like we we focus on like very very permissible violent aspects and then like we're reapproved about sex and everything i think both of us are in agreement because we had this conversation before that like within consent you can also push sexual boundaries too i think so yeah you know like i mean i don't mind a nude or two in a game i don't mind like a sex scene i don't mind whatever it is it's just you know there's a bound there's a
permission boundary there yeah but within that permissible boundary if that is healthy misbehavior in a game i remember like i played god of war the video game and you'd run into like a harem once every once in a while and there'd be naked women all over the place you could do stuff with the naked women yeah or like um you know um dragon's age right you know i you know i like all the little plots enough to get to this part the when you develop romance bioware thing yeah mass effect mass effect as well you could get all the women or if you're a female shepherd all the men are like much but all the women yeah you know it's very and you can be paid if you really want to that's all like within again i'm saying that over and over again with a permission structure that can be healthy this behavior you know and yeah so that one of the lines that we run into so i think one of the i think one of the favorite examples to point to for where this is a problem is something like like cards against humanity where everybody is in the the circle right and it's like i can be as horrible as i want it's even called a party game for horrible people um i will say it's out of those status now right i have played card against cards against humanity and had a great time i did it with people i trusted also as a group we did remove cards that we just didn't think were fine right so i mean it's one of those things right where you know it's it's about consent and that consent definitely since you i think the reason that people get upset we talk about these issues is they're remembering times where they felt like they were agreeing to one thing but then once they had entered that gaming circle it turned into something else something
that was unexpected and something that got ugly and i think that learning how to maintain that space correctly is key to having a good time and i actually do think that that segues into what you're gonna be talking about because it's okay to be horrible but it's not okay to be horrible in a way that feels so personal that it's not going to stay in the circle and it's also possibly horrible in a way that says something about how you view the world that is objectively freaking uncomfortable right um i i actually do want to i'm going to put a pit on that i definitely want to get back to that because there's a level of horribleness that that people bring up all the time i think we need to kind of talk about that and that's nazis yeah right i mean that that is one of the the the big thing whenever talk someone talks about what about war games it usually goes to what about nazis if nazis when someone brings up a nazi it's code for uh this is the worst misbehavior ever like we've kind of decided that in our culture that like okay there's nothing worse than a nazi uh right and then so is it okay to play a nazi in a game you know am i i'm playing you know puerto rico marcaibo all these cultural things or i'm playing like cards against humanity and i'm kind of like crossing boundaries and stuff so then why is that all okay but then like uh or like what about what about nazis basically and i think even that falls in the circle like you know even that falls in circle like okay if you're playing you know uh accessing allies or you're playing you know some war game or something like like zoomed in war game we were playing
like you know a battle uh between you know uh nazi forces and allied forces then you know does that if you're playing nazi does that like mean i justify the holocaust does that mean i think that the holocaust is okay you know you're playing you're you're playing that particular like you're immersed in that particular battle right not every that battle happened yeah you know and so not every like if you're playing that that's not like permission to say the holocaust was okay or whatever it is it's just like okay this happened and you know it is part of the historical drama right and it's it's very important that we know the historical drama we have been asked as a culture by many many jews to never forget yes so like we like it or not you know this is we need our cultural media books tv whatever to faithfully historically represent what's hap what happened so that we don't that we don't forget we don't do it again and so in the gaming space you know maybe you know because it's different because we're doing the thing so it's like okay there's a there's another level of it but still to me it's like that's that's more learning that can go in there obviously you want that consent obviously you don't want just to broadcast to the masses like you know uncritically if someone's uncomfortable with it to let them check out you know don't advertise it there's many games that i don't include on my shelf because i like them but or i get something out of them but like i don't i know that other people don't so it's like you have to be super careful with a
handle with gloves but it's okay yes yeah play a naughty and a game for that it's almost like the ultimate ultimate healthy misbehavior right because it does do stuff i also think that it's okay so it's okay not to want you to so like david thompson does not like to play nazis and will make other people play test the other side of undaunted for example and i also think that that's okay um but yeah i mean if you are being historically accurate you're reenacting history you're using this as a historical experience and you are comfortable with it i don't really see and the other person you're playing with is comfortable with it which hopefully that's obvious because they entered the game with you but make sure to share it be be very explicit be very clear i think it's okay to play it and i also think it's okay to enjoy because like it typically you know this is not like train right where you realize what the train is for and that's going to a concentration camp this is a battle that you're playing out and you're trying to be strategic and see who won and so if you think that that is still too gross for you that's okay but i also think that there are i i think that that is ethically on the good side of the line you're fine um i do get a little bit freaked out if people are a little too into it if that makes sense like what feelings are you having while you play this like are you basically having an onionistic experience while this other person's at the table because you're so excited to play nazi then i'm going to worry about you go ahead and look up onanistic people
speaking of misbehavior but you know if you're just having fun because you're in the game and you're like doing war together that's i mean i don't really see the problem with that yeah i mean so speaking of that like getting a little bit too into it so like if we can't tolerate playing a naughty in a game then the only people who will play nuts and games other people that are too into it you know like they're the nazis like you know the only people who play nazi games is nazis if we are with a shirk from that yeah right and we don't i i don't i'm not comfortable with that like i mean we need to find ways to have you know we use this word play but not you know not all play has to be fun not all play has to be frivolous you know what i'm not talking about frivolous play i'm talking about like just you know entering into spaces and using your imagination and reacting stuff that play in a higher level like i think there's room for that that's healthy all that is healthy so what is unhealthy though right because we you know even in this conversation right there's like little places at the edge where i certainly start to feel uncomfortable i'm sure you have your own little edges too and part of it's personal comfort but i also think that that discomfort is also a response to something that's a little bit real right okay so so we're talking a lot about consent right and this is going to be always the frame for this conversation so i i'm i really apologize for you you were pushing me beyond where i needed to go you know i have your consent list but you have my i i'm going to consent now so um go ahead and recreate that card against humanity example and we can
kind of go from there yeah well okay it's been a really long time since i played current since community um i mean what you just said the one when you said in terms of like okay this this scenario where it goes too far what was that again well i was i mean those are more theoretical for me because we took all the cards out but like if somebody was like playing a trail tears card and laughing at it i would personally feel gross about that mm-hmm um i also don't like you know ooh a big black dick like i don't think that that's funny fiery poops is funny but okay but you know like when somebody's like i'm just gonna play you know a large penis that belongs to somebody from a race that's not even my race uh and like i'm gonna throw that down and have a big laugh about it like why is that funny right okay so thank you very much for clarifying because of what it goes right into what i'm talking about so then what we're talking about in terms of all these healthy little misbehaviors are like you know recreated individual instances like one gladiator match one you know uh rate of an orc village a rate of a human village or whatever it is uh and you know i'm not going to defend that and say that's beautiful behavior but like it's at least healthy misbehavior it crosses a line for me and i think it's what i'm saying what i'm hearing is across the line for list two when it crosses from like just individual bits of misbehavior to levels of cultural oppression yeah so there is a level of culture which i'm a culture guy so then i can talk i'll head off i'm
about to uh where cultural misbehaviors are unhealthy i i i talk about it in terms of you know a year of good trouble i've been synthesizing it and trying to come up with pithier shorter ways of expressing what i'm talking about and i think i've boiled it down to one acronym case c-a-s-e and if you want to do it ahead uh a liz put up the letters on the on the zoom or whatever it is in the end today's letters of the day kids are a s so cultural appropriation stereotyping and erasure so then when you talk about the big black dick that's a stereotype that why is that bad to talk about not only because of the individual thing but it is a stereotype and that stereotype can be linked directly to cultural ideas that have produced harm what are you know so many of the you know the tulsa massacre and you know there's so many things that have like you know outburst against black folk so many of them have responded it uh started with a white woman claimed that they were attacked by a black man and so when we're talking about big black um i'm not going to say the d word because i don't want to do too many bleeps uh a big black penis we're bleeping this i might have to beep it on the one stop co-op shot yeah you might uh shelf stories no way uh so then if
we're talking about big black penises we're talking we're touching that stereotype that has had real world harm so culture stuff yeah right and in a way we have to kind of assume that games are cultural products like if you assume games are just games you're not going to attract this conversation at all but if you're assuming games a cultural product that just kind of like replicates stuff that happens in the culture well cultural oppression is a thing appropriation stereotyping and erasure are all things that have that were true then 400 years ago 600 however long they're true today and we live with it as marginalized you know people from our community you're a woman i'm puerto rican and you know all the people that we live with we live with that oppression every day because we're reminded liz davidson whole episode on misogyny talking about what she struggles with so it's like when those stereotypes just hey are they are there in the game so like you know a histrionic fit you know as a cardigan humanity thing yeah you know and it's like you you know we could talk about like okay you were having a bad day but when it comes to like you know a stereotyped woman thing you know this is why this is why women can't be precedent this is why women are xyz uh you know that's that stuff that's the stuff that cuts because there's no bad because we live with this stuff every day there's no boundary between like well when there's no boundary between the real life and the game when that cultural stuff
intrudes in our game cultural appropriation um stereotyping and erasure when that stuff comes into our gaming life problem i agree and you know what's and you know what's really funny is you know words like histrionic i used to just use those and not think about it or like hysterics because i didn't know the etymological meaning of that right but men don't get history on it no but we're not coded as get it we get histrionic but we not coded as that yeah a huster for those of you who want to learn some greek today is a womb so if you have weird ideas about uteruses that's what the that's what those words indicate but um so there is a difference people and i'm talking directly to a certain kind of person dude about war games people there is a difference between like just these bits of misbehavior and oppression oppression is like you know so we talk about like war being brutality we're celebrating brutality in the game like oppression is brutality that is systemic and is applied to a certain number a certain group of people throughout a very very long historical time period women you know we talk about you know women being oppressed taco poc being oppressed you know oppression is not just a bad day oppression is not just inconvenience oppression is not one time thing oppression happens over and over and over and it's it's applied physically it's applied emotionally it's applied psychologically and it's applied culturally culturally is where the
gaming piece ends in and so that game experience when it has not just like the myth the brutality or the misbehavior when it has the oppression then all it's doing is re-instantiating oppression that we live with i don't want that i do not consent to that no thank you like well when you say i just want to have a good time keep your politics out of my games i would say that that's actually where that's a statement that's legitimate if that makes sense like keep right so like you know yeah like you see these people know political politics well guess what when i call out of an episode of case cultural appropriation stereotyping and erasure you know when i call that out i'm saying no politics in the game i because you know i'm saying no political oppression in the game like do something else that i don't have to experience peace in in my gaming experience and you you know if a person is there and they're not experiencing it then it's not like oh well you know uh this is the way i am therefore whatever or taking it as an attack it's like okay well you're ruining my fun yeah well my phone has already ruined people yeah well it's sort of like that com that conversation that families have right where like somebody is the aggressive one in the family and the other one is asked to keep the peace like the piece is already broken right because the other person was behaving bad or like i don't know it makes me think of uh so this is an off-topic thing but i always think about it uh there's a great martin luther insult generator
online where he can insult you but uh my favorite he was he was kind of very scrabbly a very uh like he had a lot of ulcers and he was just a very crabby guy well he's actually i mean i feel like he was probably really fun to have a beer with but he was really mean uh so one of my favorite insults of his is um you were like a mouse dropping in the pepper and i sort of feel like having a case incident in your game life is like having a mouse dropping in the pepper you're having a spicy good time you're ready to eat this food with your friends oh there's poop in it yeah and okay you like the and for whatever reason that you know people who are in the hobby are have cultured it's the taste of turd and they're like oh this is this is some spicy turd and you know so like perfect example i love that you brought up the card against humanity like card trail of tears right yeah it's a it's it's total case like it's it's the like maximized version of case but like you know it's it's appropriation like they literally stole the land right you know it's an appropriation being stealing right so it's like you can steal cultural ideas but in that particular case they stole the land uh you know so stereotyping you know they had to you know in order to make it palatable they had to you know the merciless indian savage like they don't they don't deserve the land right you know they're just savages not gonna do anything with it they don't you know uh they're they're there and they're like this lower form of life they're not even christian don't even worship god they don't worship property so like you know all the stereotypes right were used to justify that thing and then a literal
erasure right literal removal right and then what we call genocide so like you know when so that's a case of something really really crappy that happened in the war so like why am i like you know and and the oppression is that it's still ongoing like you ask any you know first nations person or an american person however they self-identify like they're still there like and i work with them and i've actually this is one of the things i'm working more and more with they're still there they're still dealing with the effects of this stuff today so it's like well you know the war war is pretty bad you know what if like why am i celebrating war it's like okay war at the very least war is between two agents yes both sides are fighting for it to be a war right you know and it's like okay if i if i play a game then i can imagine different scenarios okay maybe this person wins like this at least fight back right if i if a card against humanity card is being played then the the people can't fight back and i can't fight back as a gamer you know the only thing i could do is just is check out if that's the if that's the thing that's going to be there like i don't have agency when that card is played and the owner's like well would you have a problem with the card no agency so like there's agents on two levels there's one of those agencies being permissioned in the game and then the actors within the game do they have ages to fight back with a with oppression yeah you know and in a euro game a lot of times the workers don't fight back no they don't they're just expecting they're very pliant those those fine little hero workers they come on down
and they they work the fields and they they're so happy here in my corn you know i don't have to get paid enough there's no upkeep or anything like that uh and that that to me is a erasure yeah and these erasures happen in real life all the time and i don't want that in my game so then you know like if you know even like a your game could do so much and be like you know what uh i have to pay the workers and i don't pay the work because they leave yeah that's like that would be enough like even if you're putting me in like a terrible situation of like thinking about it and whatever it is at the very least if you give the worker that little bit of agency if you don't erase it if you actually present that basic aspect of being a worker they have a little bit of agency and like what they can do on the board then i'm on the road to being okay with it that actually has me thinking okay what heroes do you have that i mean i guess in agricola if you don't feed your family you starve and all the families the workers yeah yeah i mean something like that and that's annoying yeah yeah i'm thinking about like i've been i've been prepping rococo right i mean at least in that you have to pay up for a new employee so you don't pay them every round but they are a cost oh yeah i'm just trying to think of like i don't i can't think of very many i mean agriculture is really unique to me in a way in the sense that you have to be able to actually feed people at the end of each turn you have to imagine and i'm sure there are more i mean the
complainant of the rico is that that's annoying and that's that's not fun you know and then oh my god i have to do the workers it's so funny because we in the last episode we talked about boss fantasies so then like what's the ultimate boss fantasy it's like i don't have to pay my workers you know they have yeah they don't show up and they're good and they don't they don't have agency they i erase all their humanity and i just like get the value creation from them yeah they don't have any cigarette breaks they don't go to the bathroom right no pooping on company time right right they they and i pay them nothing and they and they they're fine and so it's like you know in gaming we've educated ourselves i know we're kind of like down a little bit of a road here but workers man that's i'm a big worker guy uh so then in these year games we've educated ourselves to replicate this kind of form of economic oppression yeah of not paying workers we if we even get to the point because i brought this up in forums i'll get people defending it's like okay if you pay the workers it's too complicated you know uh if you pay the workers or the irregular thing happens where it's like okay what what's left over for me you know it's like a scrabble for resources and it's like really that's the construction that we've made in our games that's how much we are like our the gaming culture is lined up against a certain type of oppressed people which is workers yeah it's not only cultural but i'm also absolute worker person too yeah you know so there's there's there's plenty of stereotyping and erasure that happens in that particular case particularly erasure in that particular
uh case so yeah but yeah i think the thing that i think you're right the thing that makes brutality in war more interesting is that yeah you can fire on me and on my soldiers but i also get to retaliate next turn and it's about the two-sidedness that even if something's unfair like you know look at uh david thompson's value defense series it's entirely about unfair we we kind of like those actually it's not about equality of the sides in terms of resources or you know tools to fight with it's about letting somebody try to use their cleverness and the resources they do have to get somewhere it's about giving them agency and of course it's a game so everybody has to have a chance of winning right and games have to simplify games have to gloss and games have to you know so you're going to erase a lot and so there's always going to be you know like oh why did you put this in why did you put that in you know um uh tristan hall put up uh called kill fourth recently uh the third kill fourth game and there was a thread that said okay where are the everybody's white here why are the the black people where are the where the grounds get people all that kind of stuff and i'm actually i'm actually okay with that because tristan isn't telling a big multi he's not pretending to help quote scholarship he's telling a classic lord of the rings fantasy do your thing you know white people fantasy it's fine i'm actually fine with that where i'm not fine in terms of the case is when the erasure happens to people that uh people that should be there and that's where historical games come
in like you know ed you know and struggle you know like the struggle should be there because the struggle is almost always there no one likes to be oppressed no one likes to you know whatever and even if they lose a fight and they become enslaved after the fact the story's not over it's not like okay oh you won now like you just leave me for 100 years yeah it's not how it works there's always rebellion there's always struggle there's always resistance you know whether it's running away or whatever it is and that's the erasure i'm talking about that's really the ratio i'm talking about because that nav is like that cuts across culture and labor and whatever it is you know when when i have a game that erases struggle in particular oh man that that and it's a historical game it's a vulcan store time period or it's you know like a fantasy like you know because there's a big thing about like orcs right so orcs are kind of you know they're racially whatever racially aggressive racially this racially that well that when you talk about something that is racially something now we're talking stereotype now we're bringing the s of the case uh and now that's where so it's like why can't i do hack works part in dnd because orcs are these race of people that are inherently biologically aggressive that's a stereotype that is from real world of certain especially black race yeah well i guess my question about that is why do you prefer to hack orcs instead of other humans right what is that preference that you have can i hack some orcs and then i'm friends with these other orcs right so i don't mind hacking orcs where are
the orc wizards and scientists right where is the smartest orc that ever worked you know where is the orc that is like 20 intelligence that can rival elminster and gandalf and all these other people i'll take that well that doesn't sound right whatever it is like well why does he sound right to go back to the thing like i don't you know so this is where the isaac thing came in so it's like you know people thought okay i'm taking away the hack and slash no i'm not taking away the hack and slash yeah i'm just taking away the hackerslash based on racial categories like immutable biological racial categories hack slash all you want hack it you know if this enacts culture is like you know rotted to the core then go go have at it but they're rotted to the core because of their culture not because of their skin yes actually you know back to skyrim since that's like my most played like so many hours you know i used to get frustrated when making new characters because there are certain race-based bonuses and also deficits depending on what you choose so you really can't just choose to be anybody with any sort of profession if you want to play an optimal game right and i always found that limiting and it's also just a bunch of bs like put in our in our current cultural context in our lives it's like wait why are we still even doing that even with fantasy and yeah with a human you could be anything you want yeah neutral and the music human is always a white guy yeah well that's true that's just true in our culture still like if you think oh like what is a human uh most images will just be a white guy there's two genders male and political
two skin colors white and political yeah yeah and you know i think that um instead of just getting mad right when you think about these things because i like to play skyrim i'm not going to stop you know booting up a new game every couple years because i just got nostalgic and i wanted to buy a new house and rift it or something you know i um you know i uh i think that when these questions come up i think the other res the other issue we always have right is what a response of like oh you're killing the fun oh you're just a killjoy you're you're why would anybody you must be so fun at parties uh yes i am actually but um i just wanna be myself and i just wanna do whatever and i work hard and i wanna yeah but like shouldn't you be asking yourself questions about why you're so attached to those specific things i mean you can be yourself and wreck enemies without also having to racially stereotype you can be yourself and wreck enemies without needing to colonize anything so and erase the struggle of a colonized people to be clear i don't have a problem with colonization it happened i happened and my problem is the in these colonization games the tendency has been to make the worker to erase the worker agency yeah that's been the ten that's that's the pro and like anyways as we said in the last video lie about it right so like you know colonists and servants and all kind of like you're erasing the struggle and you're wasting the uh humanity of these things so like when we talk about case the erasure part
is really important that all three are important the a the a the s and the er output i will release another video kind of go in detail but like i hope that gives people a acronym to help understand okay when we have a problem the problem is not in the individual actions healthy misbehavior is a good thing it's these the appropriation stereotyping and erasure when when something you're doing is playing on those three things that are tools of cultural oppression that happen all the time in real life yeah then that's where we have the problem yes yeah i don't know if i'm going to leave this in the episode but i do want to draw one line about that which is that okay um i have been working on my openness to games with art i don't necessarily like just in the name of trying to access good gateplay so i ordered medara because kevin erskine had so many good things to say about it i'm not delighted with like the sexy anime art it's really not my thing but but i'm gonna give it a try because i uh i i want to experience the game um that said when we talk about healthy misbehavior there are some things that are just never going to be healthy and so there's the cultural aspect of that you know i think that you know genocide is fun no it's not that's never fun but also i will never be okay with things like sexual assault and games i'm okay with the sex scene in games i'm okay with sexiness in games but there are some things that i just will not ever be cool with and that's one of them so you know we talk about healthiness behavior um are there
what are the limits in your opinion okay we can keep this in if you want yeah like where do we go where you know is there is there such a thing as a misbehavior that's just truly unhealthy i would say yes sure but um yeah i mean how do you delineate that you know what i mean well okay well what's the point though i mean we're talking about criticizing something or canceling something you know so like when when we talk about like okay what is allowable what's not that that conflation gets there or just dr drummond all the time it's like if i disapprove of something that i want to cancel it and it's not the case so it's like i i want i want the freedom so like nadar is a good example madara has just very sexualized characters especially the women uh classic tna poses and you know scantily clad the plays into the whole trope said jrpg because jrpg's kind of played into those trips uh so then i i want to be able to criticize it i want to be able to say okay look what you you know can we go a different direction blah blah blah without saying okay this game is bad it does and shouldn't exist and all this kind of thing like make medara the problem is that we live in a gaming culture right now that like regards that as normal right it regards that as the way to if i'm gonna launch a kickstarter it's gonna be successful that i need to put the you know the the titties you know especially when it comes to women like fantasy women in games like i need i need that to draw in and so like what we're trying to like my project anyway is i don't want to like you know cancel
those games but i do want to criticize those games and i want to clear space for other dungeon crawl designers to make something make an alternative and to really hype that up and be like you know what you know that's over there and that and they're and they're doing their thing i don't approve of that and i don't i think that has bad effects but you know whatever let's let's try to clear space so that this other game with you know clothed women or with you know equitable nudity right or whatever it is like you know the the funny pictures of like you know the men making the tna poses and you know like maybe you know it make room for for that game too right now you have you know that the hobby looks the way it is it's very dominated by you know just like white guys who like to have a lot of fun and there's a this immediate shutdown of like no i don't like that i was like well i mean there should be room for all this stuff that we should make gaming open to all sorts of human experiences and the and to me the best one will win out that's like to call the whole point of free speech you know you have the right to be wrong and then we figure it out until something we come up with something that everybody can kind of go along with so when it comes to medara i wanna i'll criticize the heck out of it i don't wanna cancel it my solution to that is more games that undo that question that approach things differently than madara does yeah i mean i'm about to play it i'm hoping i'll enjoy it very much i just know already that i'm not going to have a great aesthetic experience at an ugly paper map to be honest and then anna as a perfect example case that's the total stereotyping of women
yeah sexualized stereotype women all over the place and that plays into the oppression of women women and sex object women as like you know kind of willing to do whatever and if people have a hard time grocking that well how do you relate redaro the voice again uh how do you lay you know school girls to sexual assault in the workplace you're putting that in there it's like well it all comes from the same cultural tree yeah it all comes to the same stereotype that women exist to be looked at by men yeah no that's true but i like what you had to say too about um kind of just i think that what we're asking for too we talk about inclusion in the hobby and we talk about you know wanting more voices in the hobby is that you know i think you're right like the view that is the best will ultimately win out it's okay to have a whole bunch of viewpoints but things that are the most widely appealing will do well i mean we live in a capital society right uh but in some ways trying to um to fight that to complain about it to not hear the criticism it's almost like trying to artificially cap the market like we're the market too and right you know if you want a bunch of free trade of game ideas you got to let it in i can't stand that that people think that free market means just let like no voices you know the money is speech and it's complete garbage like no speech is speech speech is still speech and if i can with you know my words and your words and everything we put this content out and we can sway some minds to be like you know what okay um madara or whatever
other game that engages in some kind of stereotyping or some kind of erasure or appropriation or whatever like you know if we speak out against these games that enough people will be like you know what we don't need that i can have fun other ways yeah you know like madara will not be any less cool if it has badass women you know that might even be a cooler version of the game and i want to be able to make that persuasive case i don't want to have to like result to that kind of um the cancellation route you know i want to be able to persuade people like hey look let's try this you will have the same good time and you won't be replicating a stereotype that in other areas causes real world harm that and like even if you know things with the sexy art that's not really my thing so continue to exist what i really want is options where i don't have to deal with it as the price of entry if that's the price that you if that's something that you want in your games like in your home i mean okay this is your business but um you're kink baby but you know i want that game play without having to pay the price of needing i bleach afterwards right and uh you know it's uh it's it's an ongoing process but i do think that trying to think through it is the best way forward true which is of course why we're on here talking about case that's right so there we go healthy misbehavior is the individual little bad things that
we do we didn't mention true crime we didn't even mention like playing jack ripper and playing like fine i will not play jack ripper and i think that's but you know millions of people do whatever it is right yeah i love true crime like i'm a typical white lady i like to go to starbucks in the way to work and i listen to my little true crime podcast about murders and and you know like all those tick talks about you know what you're what your wife's really home doing on a friday night her arms were cut off her legs were cut off i'm like listening unbelievable but do i really want it no is it part of my healthy recreation i would say yes and you know human mind is weird it's fine we have these urges and whatever do it in the safe space when it comes to oppression oppression knows no boundaries oppression is systemic oppression is culture wide it invades all our cultural space and innovates are games too and it is it's the same brutalities happen to the same people over and over again and being reminded of those things in our games that cro that's where our the line is crossed and that's that's a weird thing people think about who just think of oppression who don't even think of a pressure because they don't experience pressure yeah so you know they did they just think it was like a bucket of bad and it's like why are you picking this one and not that one's like well there's a whole bucket of things that are that are whatever but there's this particular
aspect which i'm calling case which i'm hopeful that people remember the acronym that you know that's where we're crossing the line it's like it's representing real world stuff that happens to us and i don't want that yeah you know so are you going to start a new video series called case studies his files case files yes i wish i i'm going to go back to all the good trouble be like okay case files jamaica case files trudbang legends k-spot sounds like a board game true crime podcast to me and i think that's a good enough to end it so we can just continue giggling off here but uh absolutely everyone jason can be found at shelf stories um you're still doing the podcast in the what's up co-op shop you still do dice tower jason's everywhere go find him and thank you so much this was real as always amazing time yeah always and find me be on solitaire leave comment hopefully leave a like subscribe and most of all happy gaming late everybody
you