Skip to main content
Loading video...

How to choose the right publisher for your Board Game? *Board Game design*

Transcript 19:45

hi I'm Adam Porter and this is my board gaming vlog and this is actually a follow-on video from I suppose by last two videos which were pitching and developing relationships with publishers and as a response to those videos a viewer called Juan asked me a question about whether it was appropriate to pitch games to multiple publishers at the same time and then as a follow on from that what would you do if a publisher showed interest but you also had other publishers showing interest at the same time so I thought I'd broaden that out into a conversation about how do I go about choosing a publisher for my games and that's a that's a strange concept isn't it choosing a publisher because I suppose most designers are going into this thinking that they're going to be lucky if they find a publisher and and I mean that's absolutely true you know often I'll be pitching games around and and and I end up with one publisher that once it and a lot of other people have rejected the game but that said if you have a really good game then multiple publishers are going to recognize that and I think you've got to be honest with yourself and look at your game and ask those sort of questions before you start pitching around you know how unique is this game really I mean obviously when you're speaking to publishers you're going to make your game sound as brilliant as you possibly can and and and you know but you've got to ask yourself those honest questions is this a game that publishers are going to be falling over themselves to publish or is it going to be a bit of a niche sort of product that I'm going to have to find a natural sort of fit

for but it might not be for everybody and then you've got to go into that that sort of process with that in mind and you've got to think about where are you going to be meeting these publishers are you going to be going to a convention if so then that really reduces the pool of publishers that you could approach because not every publisher is going to be there even if you're going to essence feel in Germany or Gen Con in America not every publisher is there in essence Pele in particular I very rarely meet with many American publishers they're just not all present at that convention and you get the feel that that's probably because they're big show is Gen Con which I don't get to go to because it's so expensive to get over there if you're going to be dealing with publishers by email and making your submissions that way then of course it's a little bit you've got a much bigger pool of publishers to approach although I think it's it's probably harder to get notice there because you don't get that face-to-face contact so the first thing you're going to consider when you look at that pool of publishers is which type of games those publishers make I mean I would start by looking at my favorite games and thinking right would those publishers possibly look at one of my games you know I a game design does not bring in an awful lot of profit it can do I mean I hear stories about it it doesn't happen to me I don't bring in lots and lots of money my games do okay they do pretty well but they don't bring in a

fortune so I'm not doing it you know largely for financial gain I'm doing it for satisfaction and enjoyment and and that means that I want to see my game with a publisher that I love where I can feel really proud of that okay so that's gonna be my starting point it's looking at games which I have really enjoyed where I would feel really really excited to see my game in that sort of lineup so for example my game Big Bazaar is with blue orange and for years I've loved blue orange games and it was it was just incredible to have a box with blue orange on it to see it on the on the convention shelves with all the other blue orange games that's an amazing feeling to have your game with a company that you love okay so that's the first your starting point for looking at publishers next thing is are they going to accept submissions and so you want to get onto their website and have a look and see if they've got any guidance on that most publishers do actually if you look at their website they'll have a little section on there for designers and telling you how to submit games or telling you if it would be inappropriate for you to do so and so have a look at their websites do your research get onto BoardGameGeek look at the games that they've made in the past does your game fit into the style of the company you know if my favorite company is blue orange well that's that's fantast stick but not if I've designed a war game okay if I decide a war game it'd be pointless me showing it to them you've got to fit your style of game to the

appropriate company and I've talked about that a little bit before in my in my pitching video about you know how to how to make sure that your game matches with the right the right sort of company so that's the first thing that you want to think about what are the games the publishers made in the past who your favorite publishers would you be happy for your game to sit with this this company and so on the next thing I look for from a publisher is enthusiasm and what I mean by that is do they love their games do they love their games or do they just produce their games and then loosely support some of them and then and then drop others of them or is every single game for them something which they push and they promote and you know and they and they love I would follow companies on Facebook and Twitter and see what sort of promotion they do for their games I'd look at their presence at conventions you know how much do they support their games in terms of demo tables in terms of the sales pitch in terms of the longevity of those games so those games up here year after year or do you see them once and then three months later they've disappeared look at the games with that company that haven't made it so go back through their catalogue look at the BoardGameGeek website look at the games which haven't become massive successes are there numerous games being released every year that you've never heard of that suggests that that company is producing a lot of games and maybe

some of them are mega hits but the ones that that don't know haven't been heard of and a fall in a way did they get any support you know maybe not that's that's the the approach a lot of publishers have taken over the years is to produce a lot of games and then spot the ones which are sort of starting to garner interest and focus all their attention on that meanwhile the other games fall away it's a business model that's been criticized quite a lot over the last couple of years as as publishers have started to realize with the thousands of games that are coming out they might want to focus in on a few key titles and make sure they're really good and that they can really support them so I want to see enthusiasm I want to see that a publisher is going to love my game it's going to support it is going to push it through you know and work with me on that and some of that you only get from face-to-face contact but other bits you can see from their online interactions and you know some publishers you get to know their names just by watching the sort of comments that they make online in the in the forums about their games are they present are they are they involved in discussions about rules and you know and answering queries from the consumers the third thing that I would want to think about with a publisher is scale so how big is this publisher and a contrary to what you're probably expecting to me to say it's not just about I want to go with the biggest publisher as I said sometimes the very big publishers are going to produce a

lot of games and they might produce your game but that does not mean your game is going to get the same love and attention as their sort of flagship games sometimes you're better off going with a smaller publisher who loves your game and is going to support it all the way through now that maybe as a publisher who who doesn't sell in the same quantities it may be a publisher that hasn't been around for as long but your game stands a really good chance of success if it's with a publisher like that who can support it who can love it who has the same enthusiasm for the game that you have and the brilliant thing about the board game market now is that a small game with a small publisher can become a massive success because the builders Yara's jury they look at all these publishers they don't care whether a game is selling you know a potential potentially being produced in hundreds of thousands of units or whether a game is being produced in you know a few thousand units all they're looking for is the quality of the production and the quality of the gameplay so you see games coming through and becoming enormous hits I mean this year on the on the spiritus GRS awards nominee is cartographers by thunder works which aquifers is a phenomenal game I loved it when I when I got it at the end of last year and I've played it a lot but it is not from a major publisher and what you can find is that if a game is really good a lot of these companies even the smaller companies will have partners in

other countries who may be bigger publishers and so your game can can grow and and and can sort of develop a following outside of that initial publisher so I don't think it's the case of avoiding the small publishers and going for the big ones in fact quite the opposite I think it's about going for the publisher that really seems to be in love with your game I do think about the duration that that company has been in business though I would very I very rarely consider a publisher that hadn't kind of been present I want to see that they've been at the conventions I've seen them around for a couple of years two or three years I've seen them around they're doing alright their games do okay I've heard of their games you know at that point I might start to consider pitching to them and discussing whether they might produce one of my games but if they're brand new on the scene then I kind of want to see them prove themselves a little bit before I will you know take a chance on them even if they are extremely enthusiastic and pleasant and you know and make a great sort of pitch to me about why I might consider them as a publisher the final thing that I would consider in thinking about a publisher is which country they're from not because there are any countries that I wouldn't want to I wouldn't want to publish my games but because I need to think about whether that game is going to be sort of present in the marketplace where I live a lot of my pleasure in producing games is in you know when my friends say to me where can I get hold of a copy and I say oh you can actually

buy it at this shop down the road or you can even just you can get it from the Amazon co uk you know but if a game is produced in different country sometimes it's not even going to hit Amazon coda UK let alone hit your friendly local game store and it's not going to be launched at a convention that any of your friends can get to so if you have a game published in the Asian market for example that might be a wonderful publisher and they might make a magical product but are you going to actually sort of see it out there or is that going to be just a case of you know it's produced you get your copies and then it's sitting waiting for royalties that's not as much fun for me as being involved and this is a problem for me in a dilemma for me because and some of the publishers that I really really love don't reach my friendly local game store don't meet reach amazon.com at UK in every case so for example Rockler lager that is one of my favorite publishers I love the German companies offer like I love the German company amigo spyler I love the Chinese company jolly thinkers and you know I I would I in fact I would happily have them published my games but that's because I'm a game fanatic and and actually just having their their logo on my box would kind of be enough for me but otherwise you know I I do get a lot of pleasure out of sending my my friends

and friends of friends and my parents saying to me oh oh my boyfriend wants to get hold of a copy of your game said my parents friends they can get hold of it from Amazon you know or buy it from a local game shop I love that and and I think you need to think about that when you're thinking about where you're pitching your game will you actually see it in your gaming world will your your friends and your local game group be playing it or will it just be sort of done and gone and no one's any the wiser so those are my key things that I'm thinking about when I'm when I'm looking at publishers I suppose I do also think about contractual sort of issues but that comes at a later stage after you've pitched I might want to know from a publisher the sort of estimation that they have of first print run you know how many international partners they have how wide they're sort of spread is in the industry what their most successful games were how many copies they sold and of course you've got to be very tactful and careful about how you ask those questions of when you ask those questions and sometimes I won't ask those questions at all but but it's getting a feel for for those sort of things and other contractual issues too you know what sort of things do they want in the contract and that comes further down the line and when you're deciding whether to work with that publisher or not coming back to Fran's question about pitching to multiple publishers my feeling is that most publishers expect that certainly at conventions it's almost the standard

that designers will be going around showing their product to multiple different publishers that said I think you should be telling people that that's what you're doing as you go along and certainly when you're emailing people you should be letting them know that there are other companies interested or that you've approached other companies you will find sometimes that a publisher will ask you for exclusivity sometimes that's at a very early stage you'll show them the design and at that first pitch meeting they'll say well if we're going to evaluate this game we need first refusal on it and I think that's that's up to you whether you accept that or not and you've got to think about how important that publisher is to you but I would put a time limit on it you don't want to give in definite first refusal to a company it's got to be a case of well you know I won't sign it to anyone else for this duration and then after that it's you know I'm afraid I'm going to be talking to other people because I can't hold it for you forever so I'd be open with publishers about who you showed it to how much interest you've had and and but but but I don't see an issue with pitching to multiple publishers unless a publisher has expressly told you that they do not want you to do that I have sometimes designed a game with specific publishers in mind in fact I've got two upcoming games which I only ever showed to one publisher that that specific publisher publisher's I've worked with before so I know the sort of stuff they want I went away I thought right I've been a designer game for that company and I

came up with a game specifically which then went on to be signed and that's wonderful when that happens but it's not the the norm I suppose generally I consider pitching two publishers a multi multi stage almost multi-year approach I learned very early on I think the first year that I was pitching my games one of my games I was offered a contract very soon after the convention this was after essence peel and the contract was offered to me by a company that produced lovely looking games none of which I'd ever played I had no idea about the quality of them I hadn't really heard of their games I didn't know whether they were a big company a small company they've been around for a few years so I knew they were established but I didn't know what sort of level of sales I could expect and I don't know their games that the reputation was fairly sort of middling so I wasn't really sure about this company meanwhile I had another company that I loved I just thought was an amazing company I knew their games and they were so enthusiastic about my game but they didn't offer me a contract they wanted to evaluate so I was stuck with that dilemma of do I sign the contract with this company that I didn't really know or do I hold on for this company that I love who was enthusiastic but I had no way of knowing whether they were seriously gonna sign the game so I turned down the contract with the company that I didn't really know and I waited for the company that was enthusiastic and inevitably that company

didn't want to sign my game so a few months later I went back to the company that had initially offered me the contract and they said I'm sorry we've already got our catalogue lined up for the next year and they weren't interested anymore so I lost that contract and that game never came to market I've I've shown it to other publishers it's come very close at times but it's never quite come to market so I learnt a lot from that and from then on I've always taken this same approach which is to not show my games to everybody I don't just get so to anybody who will look I choose a number of publishers that I would be very happy to produce my game if I would be slightly disappointed I won't show it to them I will show it to the people where I would be delighted for them to publish my game and I make a list and it might be five publishers it might be ten publishers but I'll probably cap it around there okay fully aware that they might not go for it in which case I might be left waiting for another six months until the next convention or maybe even another year before I can show it to anybody again but I'm fine with that because I I work on multiple games at any one time so if I have a game on the shelf three year fine I'm working on other stuff in the meantime but what that means is the following year I can look back and I can write okay those ten companies that I showed it to they weren't interested who else would I be delighted to publish my game and I can come up with another ten and

then I'll go and approach them and it might be the third year I come up with another ten and by this point I've shown it to 30 people and finally I might find a match now at each stage I'm taking on board the feedback of the publishers that first ten they give me their feedback they tell me why they weren't interested and I can develop the game ready to show it to the next ten okay and so that sort of staged approach means hopefully you don't get into the situation where multiple people want your game or if you do get into the situation where multiple people want your game you're going to be much more comfortable with a sort of first-come first-served approach and I don't think that's a bad approach to take because if somebody is coming back to you quickly it's usually an indication of enthusiasm and if they're that enthusiastic about your game that they want to move quickly on it and they it probably means they're going to get it to market quickly and and that is all beneficial to you I don't have an issue with pitching to multiple publishers I think it's perfectly reasonable to just be open about what you're doing and try and avoid getting yourself into those sort of dilemmas that I got into early in my career anyway I hope this video was useful to you if it was please watch some of my others I have loads of videos on my channel Adams board game Wales about game design but also just looking at various different games that out there and the mechanisms they use and one of my favorites of the year and so on if you want to follow me on Twitter it's at board game wails on board game geek I'm Adam 78 thank you very much for watching and all the best

Progress saved