Spiel des Jahres 2024 | Board Game of the Year Nominee | Who Should and Will Win?
Transcript
hello everybody my name is Ilia and my name is Tyler together we make up c a couple that loves to play board games and today we're talking Spiel days yards Award nominees winners who will win who should win yeah 2024 we did this last year we did and we're excited to do it again this year so without further Ado let's bring forward our nominees our nominees are these three games these three games which we will talk to you about really quickly I guess right exactly so what is the Spiel the yarus now this is the game of the year award that's based from Germany it's done by a jury they do a very thorough process and I personally love this award because out of these nominees the winners are some of the history's best board games in all honesty they include Katan yep Ticket to Ride Rubik Cube Rubik Cube wow Scotland Yard so like a lot of the blast in the past and more recently Cascadia D romantic D romantic yeah so a lot of games that are in households today that most people know about war did start in the 70s so it's been around for quite some time hence why it is probably one of the best known Awards out there yeah and the really fun part about it is the games that win they sell significantly more units across the world as they should because people should enjoy they the game of the year and there's a subset of people that really look for these games to get little badge you look for them uh so
it's really fun it's a good time of the year and today we've had the chance to play all of the nominees so we're going to tell you who should win who will win and any more thoughts or surprises of who we maybe didn't see on this list yes yeah yeah yeah and you'll you'll get a gist of what we mean by who should win uh and who will win but generally speaking we do have like the Spiel is actually like one of those awards that definitely touches on um a lot of different topics one of the big things being like ease of access and uh you'll you'll see that as we begin to explain some of these or these three games here if you want to learn more feel free to head over to the shiel website they have the whole jury the adjudication the whole process the criteria so feel free to read about it if you're interested but without further Ado let's go through all of these games uniqueness nerve and talent exactly now we're going to start off with in the footsteps of Darwin Tyler take it away yeah so in the footsteps of Darwin is kind of exactly what you it sounds like you're taking these uh this track around the world discovering and uncovering a bunch of different species adding people to your journey while also like tile Drafting and creating your like log book the log book will score you a bunch of different points based on how you fill it up and the patterns that you're able to collect the scoring mechanisms and overall it it it's really just drafting until there's no tiles left there's a really cool spatial draft behind it because where
the ship is you can choose any of the tiles in that column or row depending where it is but the tile that you take will actually also determine how far the ship moves which is a really cool aspect of the game but it's the production value of this is so high every little detail here there's so much educational value here too which is really cool to see and recently they just uh announced in the footsteps of Mary Cy which is really cool because they're doing this like it's seems like they're doing this whole series around this stuff so and it looks like the mechanics are completely different completely different so that's really cool to see it'll be interesting to see how that game fits in with this but it's something you can look forward to if you also pick up this game and then whenever that one comes out here to go now next up we have Captain flip now what Captain flip is is a game where you're building up a pirate ship the way you'll do this is you'll draw into a bag and you'll take a tile and you'll decide if you want to keep the face of the tile or flip it and place the other one M now you'll be placing your tiles in columns starting from bottom to top uh and that's essentially it the cool aspect of the game is that flipping of the tiles because there are some tiles that will also flip your tiles so there's a lot of flipping mechanisms that happen and each of tiles score slightly differently uh some of them have immediate scoring versus later at the end of the game scoring and how you place your crew members will determine how you win the game y yeah it's got a bit of push your luck to the game of course because you are drawing from the tiles and then making that decision of whether or not you're going to flip is always interesting and it comes with four different maps that you can play with
which adds a little bit of variability but doesn't over complicate the game which makes it pretty great I saw a fifth promo map in the store and I really wanted it but I think we had to buy the entire game again yeah honestly would do mhm and last but not least we have Sky Team Sky team is a silent Cooperative game where you are playing as a pilot and co-pilot attempting to land your plane safely in a variety of different airports now this is a two-player only game and the way the mechanics in this game work is you'll roll your dice behind your little screens and then well first you'll communicate what you want to do then you roll the dice you do get to actually and then you'll place your dice making sure the flaps are down making sure the speed is slowed down the elevation is down because you don't want to crash you want to land land very safely into the airport your Landing in there's potentially lots of Hazards to go through there's so many different modules and it's a Cooperative yeah yeah You' got to like C radio radio planes like one of the yeah like make sure the sky is clear so you can actually keep going through it and like IIA said is there's a lot of different um modules that you can play through and it does feel very like campaign esque mhm so that is the three nominations this year MH now when they were announced what do we think what was our first First Impressions what was our gut reaction uh yeah all right gut reaction gut reaction
gut reaction to the three let's start with that um I was surprised that okay a couple things I guess I'll start with Sky Team I was surprised that Sky team was dominated because it's a two-player only and I think it's a little bit more complicated like even though it's like a this blind uh or this like hidden um campaign game where you're not really speak to one another I think that there's a bit of Randomness obviously because you're using dice but just with how complicated it was I wasn't sure that it fit into the Spiel but I'm no expert y I like how different they all were they are very different cuz I feel like in the footsteps of Darwin is I think more educational more attention to like each component each detail of the game Sky team is a Cooperative game where these are competitive it's two-player only uh it has some unique mechanisms and it feels really thematic as uh and then Captain flip I feel feels like Joy the Box you have that kind of Lottery with the tiles you're trying to see what's happening every T every turn feels exciting uh and they I feel like all convey like almost a different sense of emotion as well which was really interesting y now I was surprised that some of the recommendations didn't surpass to be the fin because there's usually the recommendations are the finalist yeah that's the other and there's two in particular that we've played that I have played yeah uh and the first one being harmonies now harmonies is a gorgeous game yeah it's so much fun and maybe it's because of the recency bias because it has Rec
come out everyone's been raving about it we've been playing it a ton uh it's just so beautiful so much fun to play but it is also a little similar to Cascadia so it's interesting that you say that because the most common comment I hear about people when they talk about harmonies is it plays very similar to Cascadia now I do agree to some point I also agree that maybe they shouldn't they some like some games shouldn't be compared like that um you can tell people that it plays similar to it but like to say I don't know anyways I'm not going to get into it but the harmonies is very similar to Cascadia and I agree I think maybe it is recency bias because same thing and actually I'll add to it is same thing with Captain or the next game that I want to talk about Captain flip is also a bit recent but it's here so it's nominated the other game is Trio Orana yeah I think a lot of people have been talking about Trio and harmonies a lot maybe that's just like within our community uh and we've been playing it a lot I love showing people both of these games especially um most recently that's what I've been liking to do so those are like conflicting I'm not saying that they should have bumped any of these games all of the games in that list of recommendations were that we had played at least were very worthy of being a nominee and it's it's exciting to see these three here my favorite types of games are games like diseases and I feel like Tri diseases diseases diseases so like Trio and
harmonies really contagious diseases contagious because Trio and harmonies are both games that you play and then people that you play with want to play and then it just spreads and I feel like both of those I think maybe we could just call them contagious no diseases so I feel like both those games have I witness more of a spread right than some of these potentially but those were my surprises but I think these are very deserving I'm very excited to see them it's really cool to see a vast diversity of games represented I think the only one only other thing that I would say is I was a little surprised by in the footsteps of Darwin just because I think we had played it such a long time ago that um when I saw it up for nomination I was like oh I didn't even realize that game was like new and I guess is the best way to say it but uh when we played it I enjoyed it like we've played all three of these back and like all of them are really fun so mhm very true so now the question you've been waiting for who should win and who will win so we'll start with who should win so I think we should it's more of a maybe we like these games more I think it's mostly our opinion well both these are opinion yes but who will win is more of like we've considered outside sources I think like in internally should win is what we believe like personally should win I think who should win is Captain flip that's fair because there is
buckets of joy in that game you never know the tile that it's going to come out you never know when you flip when it's like the perfect to that you've been looking for the different Maps play so differently it just it feels good every single time you play that game the games feel close and they're fast enough that if they're not close you can just play again that is true a push your luck game I think that that's like a pretty key highlight yeah it doesn't feel overly like different it's one of those games that I'm surprised it's not around yeah like you play it and you're like well why did this take so long but there are quite a bit of like Pusher luck push your luck but not in this I feel like it's a really clean design uh and what it does it does very well in my opinion you're right so that is why I think Captain flip should win mhm I don't agree with that that is my opinion this is your opinion my opinion on who should win is I think Sky Team should win okay I think because it's a two-player Cooperative it's got this interesting like hidden uh placement uh hidden like role type thing that you got going on um there's a campaign it's lengthy it is more complicated than um the other two here in my opinion but I do think that's like a double-edged sword I think a lot of the stuff that I'm saying here is a double edge sword for Sky Team I think that the fact that it's a two- player uh could be detrimental to it I think that it's the fact that it's Cooperative could be detrimental but I think that also uh proves just how unique the game
is and that's why I think it should win it's a trend Center yes like the million new dual games that are coming out who who saw that coming well with that said who will win I will flip on this and I will say captain flip will win I think from how I understand it um and from like just personally playing it this game is way way more accessible and easy to get to the table easy to replay it has a bunch of different replay replayability just in the board the four boards that it comes with I think that's one of the biggest things that I've seen with this award is the accessibility part of it uh the uniqueness thing I haven't really seen another game like this be put into the nominees in quite some time I would say or at least for a lot of the time that we've been really really in the hobby um so I think that that's why it has an edge I I I hear nothing but good things from it as well so that's another thing okay um this one was really hard for me because I think when I think of who will win I always think of like contextually like which game is going to be around in 20 years right which game is going to stick around which game is going to appeal to the masses surprise people potentially and get more people into the hobby M um I tossed actually between even the three of them because I do think like to give
a shout out to in the footsteps of Darwin there's a lot of educational value which I've really enjoyed seeing in the games that have come in the last few years and I think this game really celebrates that and that's really cool to see um but with that said I was my top two were these two yep uh and I do think I will say uh this is a lot of pressure cu the last two years I got it right yeah so just saying I think Sky team will take it I got it right last two years too though did I think we disagreed on one of the years I think that was for the kenish Spiel oh you're right regardless I think this is where we're going to differ so this will be who whose streak will be broken maybe both maybe both maybe both of us yeah but I think Sky team will win I think Sky team will win for the reasons of it be unique different uh I do think it's one of those games that you play and you just feel although it is more complex I think when the theme flows really smoothly complexity Le feels lessened which I think is the case for the sky for Sky team and I do think it's one of those games that people have been really excited about uh and it does change the scope of what board games can do because it does feel really different to what you're doing in this game uh I love Cooperative games I love how this game kind of took a spin on and make a really thematic Cooperative game so I for that I do think Sky team will take the Spiel yeah that's fair there's a lot in the Box I mean I definitely tossed between the two um it'll be an interesting one I think I just took the opposite stance where I thought
everything that is great about Sky Team presented as a detriment to this award specifically we'll see what the jury has to say uh in about a month and we'll see who is correct yeah now for our question of the day which of these three do you think should win and will win and of course like which one is your favorite out of the three what's our favorite uh my favorite I think would definitely be Sky Team I think that's my who should play well who should win but yeah that's my that's similar with me I think my favorite out of the three is Captain flip yeah that's fair yeah um all right if you like this video though give us that Thumbs Up Hit That subscribe button cuz we make weekly board game content not necessarily like this because it's only an annual award but we talk about board games every week and we'd love join our journey do you want to see a similar video for the keniel we can finish the whole Ticket to Ride Legacy yeah no we're going to Iceland for two weeks we we could play Ticket to Ride Legacy yeah that might not not work for with our luggage but but if you want to hear our thoughts about the Gish peel feel free to check out our Discord feel free to check out our patreon all those links are down in the description below and thank you so much if you've made it this far to the end of the video mhm Tyler has a joke for you I don't have a joke for you but I do have a goodbye for you bye