Skip to main content
Loading video...

Games on Our Minds and Action Card Rivers

Transcript 25:29

Hello, welcome to Positively Bored Gaming episode 46. I am Jamie and I am also representing Mitchell today because Mitchell is recovering from surgery. He really wanted to make it today, but he he uh it's just a little bit of a struggle. It was back surgery, so it's a little struggle for him to sit up straight and due to the medications for him to not fall asleep in the middle of the of the of the podcast. So Mitchell, I I got to talk to Mitchell yesterday for a few minutes over FaceTime and we talked about what to do today and we decided that Mitchell would email me some thoughts to share on today's podcast. So Mitchell will still be represented just by me instead of Mitchell's lovely voice. Um so you'll get to hear Mitchell's perspective today and you'll also hear my perspective on my my topic as well. Uh yeah, this is a format that we we will not do very often, but every now and then it's possible that one of us can't show up.

And I hope you'll forgive the uh the change in format for this one episode, and we can all wish Mitchell the best as he recovers from surgery. In a few days, we might record another one for the for the next week. So hopefully he'll be okay by um as usual, I want to start out with a treat of the day. And I can I think I can represent Mitchell by here because I talked to Mitchell right after his back surgery and he spoke very highly of the hospital food that he had. Um I don't know if it was the medication talking or if the food was just that good, but Mitchell has spoken highly of hospital food in the past. And so I think Mitchell's treat of the day might have been the delicious hospital food. I think he said there was something about um some mac and cheese, maybe twice baked mac and cheese or something like that that he really really enjoyed. So, that'll be Mitchell's treat of the day, assigned to him by me. My treat of the day is that I went to a friend's birthday party this weekend. Happy birthday to Mel. And one of the things that Mel's partner, Adam, did for her for her birthday. Um, is that Adam had people bring chocolate bars and then we broke up these chocolate bars and put them into a bunch of different bowls, one bowl per chocolate bar. And people and we did kind of a blind taste test of the different chocolate bars. Some people were trying to guess guess the flavors of the chocolate bars because there was a pretty big variety. I brought 10 different chocolate bars myself. Um, and some people were like rating them to figure out which were their favorites. I love chocolate and I love variety and so this was like this was heaven for me. So I tried all How many were there? Um, there were around

18 different chocolate bars. I think I had a piece of each of them. I rated all of them. Nothing got lower than a seven for me because I do love chocolate even in forms that I wouldn't normally buy a whole chocolate bar for. And my top three, I thought I'd mention my top three really quick. I got to bring some of these home. I really liked a um an espresso one that this one had this like gooey espresso cream in the middle that I really liked. I like the mix of chocolate and coffee quite a bit. There was a peanut butter chocolate one. Peanut butter. I always love it with chocolate. I will and and this bar was really good. Both of these were dark chocolate mixed with the espresso and the chocolate and then a slightly more milkier chocolate maybe around 40 to 50% with a root beer flavor to it. Um, and I really like this one. This was kind of a surprising because I I do gravitate more towards towards dark chocolate, but I enjoyed this one partially because whenever I get a root beer float, a rare treat for me, but I do love root beer floats, I like to get it with chocolate ice cream instead of vanilla ice cream.

And so having a chocolate bar with a root beer flavor was kind of like a chocolate root beer float in the way that I really enjoy. So that was my treat of the day. Now I don't know what Mitchell's before you start topic would have been. We'll say that it's just him recovering from surgery and hopefully doing well. And I did, like I said, I talked to him yesterday. He seems to be in good spirits. Um, my brief before we start is uh just to talk about my love of hosting people for games and hosting in general. I really enjoy that. And I'm mentioning this now because I am hosting a uh a smallish uh Super Bowl party on Sunday. So, this will air on Thursday early in February 2026 and then the Super Bowl is in a few days. And I have found over the last few years that my the version of the Super Bowl hosting that I really enjoy is where I mute the TV. So the game is on. Maybe we'll unmute it during halftime or maybe turn it up a little bit for people who just want to watch it for the commercials.

We'll have the TV on very in the background and then all around our condo isn't a big condo, but it's kind of one big room. Uh this is this is this is my office that kind of extends into the living room where you can see the TV. Um, people will be playing games and uh, usually shorter, lighter games, but there might be some longer games that come out. I've done this over the last few years and it is a delight. It's a delight for people to uh, some people will just eat food. Some people watch the TV, some people play games, some people will go back and forth between the three of them. And I really enjoy it because otherwise in past rural parties, we're just kind of sitting there watching the TV and we're talking a little bit, but we're just watching the TV. And this is a lot more active, a lot more social, and the game is still there for those who want to watch it or who want to take a break from a game and really just focus on the TV for a while as some of my friends might might be doing. Um, Seattle is pay playing the Patriots in the Super Bowl. Two teams that I typically root against. Um, but my my good friend Miles is rooting for the Seattle Seahawks and so I will be trying to root for them as well and supporting them. Ultimately though, I just want a good game. Probably a high-scoring game would be a lot of fun with some big big plays. And I hope no one gets hurt. I always I always hope for that when I watch sports. So that is my little before we start the the idea of a Super Bowl party and both the idea that I love hosting. It's a positively board gaming podcast. And so I I love I really love uh taking care of my friends. I not that I see that as my job or my role, but it feels good to me when I can do that. I feel it really really makes me happy when I can make my when I

can do something that can bring happiness and joy to my friends. Like it really really does. And so, uh, being able to host people and take care of people in that way feels good to me. And as an introvert, hosting hosting is it kind of meets an introvert need of having a little bit of control and a little bit of a job. I I found is uh really appealing to me as an introvert. I I will gladly have like 20 people over at my house to play games and host them, but I will be very hesitant to go to a happy hour um with 20 people where I know maybe some people and not others and I don't really have a role there. I'm just supposed to hang out for a while. Like that to me is is uh drives up some anxiety for me as an introvert. Anyway, let's get to our topics of the of the day about specific games. And let's start with Mitchell. So Mitchell said that he's had uh some games on his mind recently because Mitchell, you know, he had this surgery. He hasn't been able to play games for a few days, but he thinks about games quite a bit and gets excited about the games that he will play in the future. Mitchell loves anticipation. And so Mitchell shared five different games. And a small perk for Mitchell not being here is that I can share them on my second screen. And the first game that Mitchell mentioned is Ironwood from Mine Clash Games.

Mitchell says, "This one is a beauty. two asymmetric factions. As you can guess, one powered by wood, one powered by metal. Beautiful components. As we talked about last week, I've really been drawn to 1v1 games recently. Add the gorgeous components and I can't stop thinking about this one. Now, this is one that I have not played. I have not played Ironwood. I'm very curious to play it. But I will say that Ironwood was I believe it was one of the inspirations for me to really lean into the dual format for the Scythe versus Expeditions game. Dueling game, also an expansion, but primarily a dueling game that will be that we're releasing this summer. I don't remember exactly in the timeline as to like when I was working on that game and when I heard about Wild Ironwood, but uh I was just really impressed. I'm really impressed by these asymmetric 1v one games um like Ironwood and that was I believe at least a partial inspiration for this asymmetric duel in Scythe versus Expeditions which isn't the name of the game. I haven't revealed the actual name but that is the the uh concept of the game. Next up, so there are five games here for Mitchell.

Mitchell picked Wonderlands War game that I have played. Mitchell says this is by Druid City. He says, "I have this one. I've had this one for a while. It's set in the Alice and Wonderland universe. Asymmetric factions again as asymmetry. Battle for supremacy in the Wonderland universe with the added fun of being able to bet on battles that you are not involved with, which I think is a really clever way of including people in kind of doesn't have to be one v one, but any battle that you're not involved with. Mitchell unsurprisingly has the deluxified version and it's absolutely beautiful. Mitchell says, "Perhaps my pain medication has something to do with this one, considering that Alice in Wonderland already seems a bit out there." And yeah, it is a bit of a trippy experience. I could see how Mitchell might have this one on his mind. I believe I've only played this one once, but it may have been twice. Um, and I really do enjoy that that combat mechanism that Mitchell talked about. It also has bag building, one of my favorite mechanisms. I love baguilding. And it has a one-way action selection track in the middle, this tea party mechanism that you go through each round. So, it has a lot of things that I really, really like in games in general, and I do enjoy this game as well.

Next up, we have Dungeon Legends, which I haven't played. This is by Rebel Studio. Mitchell has a very short description for it. He just says, "Cooperative card-based fantasy adventure. Need I say more?" I don't know a ton about this game. I have a photo up on the screen for those who are watching instead of listening. But, I like the concept that uh it's kind of a it's a long board and you your job is to get to the end of the dungeon. So, you have a lot of information about the monsters that you're encountering along the way. You can kind of see them on the board and I believe you like you move from left to right along this board as a party trying to deal with these monsters and potentially potentially collecting loot along the way. I I just it's a different format for a dungeon crawl board and I like that. I like innovations on u common genres and themes and mechanisms.

Mitchell's fourth pick, and these are in no particular order, but he picked the 25th century version of RAW. Mitchell says, "I still haven't played this uh which despite this being one of the the best auction games out there from what Mitchell has heard, he loves the Egyptian backdrop. He loves bidding games and of course the deluxified components. And I love this game. I mean, this is this is my favorite auction game. I really really love RAW. And this new edition makes it even easier to teach than some of the previous editions thanks to the player mats." Uh yeah, this is this is hands down this is my favorite auction game. It is one of my favorite games. It plays up to five players. I will play this with anyone who ever is excited to play RAW, just period. I love it and I I would love the opportunity to play with Mitchell someday if he's up for it. And last, Mitchell picked another game that I have not played. This is The Elder Scrolls: Betrayal of the Second Era. 8.9 rating on Board Gamegeeek.

Mitchell says, "Still haven't played this." He hasn't played it. He owns it. Hasn't played it. is a very complex game from what I've heard. Um, uh, oh, I'm sorry. Yes, I'm reading the raw description. Mitchell says about the Elder Scrolls. He says, "I've talked about this one before." He has, but I can't seem to get it out of my head. Can't wait to see Chip Theory's take on the Elder Scrolls universe, and oh my, those custom dice. Let's see if there's a photo here of the custom dice that we can find. I can see, yeah, here they are. Um, yeah, I can see this one really scratching an itch for Mitchell. Uh I it is a very complex game from what I've heard, but uh I think it uses maybe elements of one of Chip Theory's other games, but it's a beautiful game and my Mitchell loves his custom dice as do I. So I hope Mitchell really really enjoys this one. So thank you Mitchell for sharing those thoughts even though you're not here today on five games that have been on your mind. Um I think this is part of the show where Mitchell will probably ask me if there are any games that have been on my mind lately. That is a topic that I generally cover in a different series of videos where I talk about the three games that I am uh that I am anticipating playing in the near future. Um and uh in fact I might be filming that video later today. So I actually have not thought about that yet, but I will be covering it on this channel here in the near future. And my for version of anticipate anticipation videos are games that I've already played at least once that I'm excited to play again. uh rather than filming about a hypothetical game that I haven't played yet. Um I'm

having to talk about anticipation, but I to film a whole video about a game, I want to have played it so I can talk about it uh somewhat intelligently. So, thank you Mitchell for sharing those thoughts. I uh I appreciate you sharing the games that have been on your mind and I hope you can get some of these games to the table soon. My topic of the day was I I was debating making this a a normal long form Sunday video uh a top 10 video about card rivers. So games that use an action system specifically that uses a card river. I'll explain an example of this in a second. I think it'll make sense pretty much immediately. Um, but uh I there aren't really 10 games that have this mechanism. I have seven of them that I'll mention briefly today. And I've only played four of them. There are three of them that I haven't played. And so I don't really have enough to say about this to make it a top 10, much less even a top five at this point. And so I thought I, you know, I have this podcast with Mitchell. I thought this would be a good opportunity for me to talk about this mechanism in games that I really enjoy.

And one reason I wanted to bring it up is that I hear a lot where people say there hasn't been a new mechanism in tabletop gaming since deck building was invented back with Dominion many many years ago and even arguably a little bit before that with um uh uh what is the game? There's there's a space game that that had it a little bit in the game, but uh Dominion popularized it. And I would contend that there have been many mechanisms since then that have been new and innovative. Maybe they haven't been rifted on as much as tech deck building nor as influential as tech building. But I think there have been a ton of new mechanisms since then. And I think this is a great example. The card river system, the card river action system is a major mechanism that I still think has a lot of potential to for people to to play around with and innovate on. Um I think within a few years there will be a top there will be enough games to do a top 10 list on this and I and I hope it does because I think there's a lot of potential with this mechanism.

So let me explain exactly what I mean by this mechanism. And the first example that I am aware of is Civilization: A New Dawn. Now I will talk about Ark Nova in a second. If you need to think about Ark Nova's action system to uh to conceptualize this, you can because that is the game that people know more than Civ New Dawn. But it did start with Civ New Dawn. In Civilization New Dawn, you have a a little very thin player map with numbers on it. You can see the numbers here on the screen if you're watching this on YouTube. And underneath this playmat, you have different cards. And the power level of those cards, if I remember this correctly, because some of these have to do with cost and some of them have to do with strength. But I believe the power level of these cards is related to the number above them. And whenever you play a card, so if I play this masonry card at strength three, I will play that card. I will gain this benefit for strength three. and then I will shift it all the way over to the left and then slide all the other cards over to the right. So any cards to the left of it become more powerful. I really like this system in general because for a number of reasons. I think it presents players with a really great puzzle. I think it it doesn't have any randomness to it because you you have the information out there that you want.

You can you can choose when to activate cards and so you have a lot of agency. You have all your options in front of you as well, all your action options. and it kind of steers you in moments that could lead to could otherwise lead to analysis paralysis. It steers you towards the more powerful cards. If you're like, I don't know what to do on this turn, choose the strength three one or the strength four one. I really like that. Sivan New Dawn also did something that I actually forgot it did when I talked about Arn Nova originally where there are ways to upgrade the cards to flip them over to the backside to make them even more powerful. We'll talk about that a little bit more in Arc Nova. So, Civ Dawn, the as far as I know, the first game to have this action, this card river action system, but Arc Nova came along and made everyone know about the system or it feels like everyone knows about this system now and yet we have not seen a lot of games with this system. So, Arc Nova gives you five cards, just five actions. And one of actually one of the other things I love about ArcNova and this system is that you can describe in as much text as you want exactly how the action works on the card itself. You can see that here. I'll zoom in a little bit. Um the text just tells you how the actions work. It's right there on the card because you don't have to read the card from across the table. You don't have to read the card upside down. It is literally the thing is that is the closest to you on the table. And you can even pick it up without ruining any elements of randomness or or giving away information and hold it close to your face and read it if you need to. I think that is wonderful. The accessibility of it and the how it gives you permission

to spell out an action in text. It almost entirely can replace a rule book if you do this well. Um, in fact, I have a whole video about games that use uh that the cards in the games explain in text how the rules work to the point that you probably don't really need a rule book all that much. Um, the other thing that Arn Nova does, two other things actually. One is is that it has the card upgrade system. This card, this card is upgraded here. So, there's different ways that you can flip over cards in the game to a stronger side. And, uh, that feels really good to have a stronger version of that action from then on. And also, Arch Nova has these tokens that let you temporarily increase the value of a card. So, if I really want to play this card in the four slot, but I want to play it as a five or even a six, I can discard this special type of token that looks like this icon to make it a five or a six instead of a a four. I think that's really cool. So, that's Arc Nova. I mean, and when I asked ambassadors what their favorite game in this category was, 62 ambassadors chose Arknova. I think it's the most well-known and it's a really, really great game for a lot of people in my opinion. So, a lot of people chose this one. The followup to Ark Nova is a game called Sanctuary. And Sanctuary, I won't explain exactly how this system work, but it uses tiles, which I think is clever because tiles are easier to push than cards. So, since you are constant frequently sliding these things to the right, tiles make it a little bit easier to do that. And since cards are nice when you need to randomize content,

cards are also cheaper and easier to reprint than tiles. Like, they're faster to actually reprint. Um, but for this system, I think tiles actually work really, really well. Um, and you don't have to shuffle them. So, I like the tile system and the the tweak that I like or two tweaks that I like in Sanctuary. One, I like that the value of the number is um I it is the resource in the game. There knows there's no other resource token to spend in Sanctuary. The resource is the power level on the card. And also, unlike in Arkn Nova where unless you have a very specific map pack, you can't ever upgrade all five cards, in Sanctuary, the game lets you upgrade all four tiles, which feels good to complete that and have four very powerful tiles.

The last game of in this category that I've actually played is Dragon Eclipse. Dragon Eclipse does introduce an element of randomness to this system, which I'm fine with. I'm fine having it having some randomness. So, you have a deck of cards. you put five uh four cards out and then this is the discard pile on the far right and each of the cards has a gem value associated with it. So it isn't the strength of the action rather the gem value is just a bonus that you get for playing the card in that slot. So the first slot is one gem then two then two and then three. So if you play the card in the rightmost slot as you play that card as you choose that card you also gain three gems. And some cards have ways that you can use those gems to make the cards even stronger. So, it's kind of like this power up action system, but it's more flexible. You don't have to use those gems at that moment. You could use them on a future turn on a card that maybe needs a lot of gems. I think that's really cool as well. Let's talk about the three games that I have not played that use this system. The first is the second edition of Assyria. Now, here's what an ambassador said about this because I am not familiar with this game. I have it up on the screen, but I I'm not familiar with it. The ambassador says, "As a serious second edition has a neat variation on this where the bonus actions you can take from the factions on the sideboard shift at the end of every round, making some of them more valuable yet more expensive and then eventually unavailable. It's a really neat way to gather some resources that you might need other places of the game.

And because it moves on this river system, it's all about the timing." So, I think this is a a neat variation on this idea where it makes the the river public. And yes, as I'm saying this, there is actually a subset of games that use card rivers in a different way. Uh the example of this being I'm gonna blank on it right now. Century Century Spice Road. the system where if you want to actually it started with um small world where if you want to move if you want to buy something that isn't uh at the far left or the top of the chart you can move further down the chart putting a coin of yours on every card along the way or a token in sentry on every card along the way making them more valuable and they slide over to the left that is a variation of the system that I'm not going into today because it isn't an action system but in Assyria I wanted to mention it because it is a bonus this action. So, I thought it might be applicable here. And that to me is intriguing that you could have a game where the core action system is maybe its own thing. Maybe it's worker placement, deck building, whatever it is. But the bonus actions, the optional actions, um, use a card river system for strength and value. And there might even be some other games that do this that I'm not thinking of right now. U, maybe even some that I've played. So, that's a serious second edition. Two more here.

Uh, Storyfold Wildwoods is a game that I've heard that uses this system. I think Carol on the Mill recently mentioned that she really recommends trying this system. And my understanding of this system, rudimentary understanding of best because I haven't played this, is that it is a skill test system where the difficulty is the number above the card. So, if I want to choose the if I want to successfully explore, I need to have uh a success level of five or more on my role. However, uh the cards actually get better based on that success level. So, for example, this help card, I can kind of read it here. It says, "For each success, gain what I think is a it looks a little bit like a coin, but I think it's probably some other resource. Maybe it's a coin.

We'll call it a coin." So that means that it gives you a reason to wait until a card actually is more difficult to use or achieve with that skill test because the higher success makes it better. I think that's pretty cool. Um that's storyfold wildwoods. And last we have another twist on the system. This is Disney animated. The last one that I haven't played but I've heard good things about it. And I believe it uses this action system, this card river action system cooperatively where there's one shared card river in the middle of the table. And all players when it when it's like my turn, I will choose one of these actions and I'll and I'll select it. I'll activate it for its strength and then I'll move it along the row back to the start and shift all the other tiles over. It does use tiles it looks like, which I like. Um, but it's a cooperative thing, so we're all sharing the one action system. I actually think this could work in a competitive game as well. It's an interesting interaction in a game. If you uh if the action you choose makes the other actions for the other players stronger and or weaker, I think that's pretty cool that you could have that in a cooperative game as well. So, I think a shared card river action system could work as well. And maybe again, maybe there are some examples of this that I just haven't uh contextualized as a car a shared card river action system um in other games. But yeah, I'm curious to play Disney animated as well. So yeah, this is me sharing my enthusiasm for the Card River action system and what may come in the future of the system. I I

say this as if I have something up my sleeve. I don't, but I would love to use this system because it is such a clever system. Or I'd love to use a version of it that hasn't been done before. Um like some of these games that innovated off that original Civ a New Dawn system. [snorts] If I'm forgetting any examples, please mention them in the comments. I'd love to hear about them in the comments below. And uh Mitchell would love to hear what games have been on your mind recently. What game whether it's something to get to the table or you've just been thinking about it. Uh sometimes games just get in our heads and we like thinking about the strategy or or or the components or whatever it may be. Feel free to mention that in the in the comments as well. Mitchell, I missed you for this live cast. I really did. It's more fun to talk to you than to talk to myself, but I will hopefully see you soon and I look forward to hearing from anyone else in the comments. Thanks. Take care.

Progress saved