Skip to main content
Loading video...

Podcast 98 - How To Be More Analytical About Games

Transcript 1:22:38

you're listening to the broken me show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's Luke Hector best known for the broken meeple YouTube channel and I'm an everyday gamer just like you and I'll be talking about reviews top 10 and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as I have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game hi everyone Luke Hector here recording podcast 98 yeah we're almost up to the 100 Mark and as I said before I'll probably do some kind of offline uh Q&A for that one you know basically the patreons have given me a lot of suggestions and ideas for questions and they've requested an offline Q&A so I figured I'll do that for episode 100 so we'll cross that bridge in a couple episodes time uh but otherwise yeah I hope everybody's having a good time at Gen Con naturally I'm not there because you know I didn't have enough holiday this year to do any even my arctic Cruise later in December I didn't have enough holiday for I had to request some unpaid leave for that That's how little we got this year when they change the year ends annoyingly but the uh the the the thing also is just the cost of going to Gen Con is just kind of prohibitive I mean it would cost like hundreds to fly there hundreds to stay in a place and then you spend a bunch on games or something it's just like well I already go to Essen and stuff and there's only so many conventions I can go to in a year but you know maybe one day in the

future we'll work out some financially beneficial way of being able to go to that and even then gen con's not really the highest on my list to go to because it just seems too much like too crowded I mean every time I look at the video say this is day one of Gen Con before the doors were open and then it's just a stampede it's like why is that fun or desirable to basically be in what the equivalent is of a Spanish bull race it doesn't really sort of you know Tickle My Fancy but you know something like Dice Tower East or packs unplugged East you know the ones that are on the East Coast a bit closer to the UK side uh you know could be feasible we never know but you know we we'll see but it's just it's hard to get to American cons it just really is but it would be nice if one day I could somebody hurry up and help me win the Euro Millions and then I guarantee I'll be at American cons all year round you know that'll be a given but sadly uh as much as I do play the lottery the winning ticket never comes up for more than a few quid so what's happened with the channel uh generally not too bad you know what we up to now 23,900 Subs so we're on the way to 25,000 you know the next Milestone won't be too long I think before we hit 24 at the rate we're going uh content lately has not been the best in terms of reception um three episodes have come out since the last one one of them I actually think's done pretty well Empire's end that was a you know a review for a game that was requested by the patreons 2,000 views not too bad you only a couple of dislikes you know that

one did pretty well but the other two I'm kind of surprised aren't doing as well Terminus this is a game that like pretty much no one else has talked about outside of Kickstarter previews and you know it's a big heavy game it's from the same publisher who did Earth you know one of the most popular games out there so I figured this one would get a lot more buzz but still less than 2,000 views and it's been out for at least a few days now so I'm kind of curious as to why although no dislikes is positive to see so not even the trolls are going after this one but yeah I kind of expected this one to get a little bit more interest and then probably the biggest disappointment was the top 10 tips for running a board game club I thought that would actually be a topic a lot of people would want to know but then after thinking about it it's like H but not everybody's trying to run a club so why would you necessarily tune into a tips video about it but it was something guy I wanted to do I've had experience with clubs both good and bad so I wanted to kind of sort of vent my thoughts on it and yeah less than 3,000 views for a top 10 list I mean lot of Engagement which is the main thing you know I'm more interested in engagement you know a lot of likes and a lot of comments I mean look at 80 comments bear in mind some of that are my replies but still it's a lot of comments but yeah I don't know that one just didn't quite work as a top 10 list so you know I mean if you if you watch it and get some useful information out of it then fantastic but yeah in terms of viewership and the time it took to come up with the list record it and edit it you know these ones take a long time to edit that one was a bit of a dud oh well maybe the next top 10 will be better I mean the next one on the patreons list I think that was highly rated was top 10 games induce

anger so that could be one that might get few more thoughts and you know anger doesn't necessarily mean oh I hate the game it makes me angry um because otherwise I would just choose my top 10 worst games no we're talking about games that kind of induce induce anger in a fun jovial way if that makes sense but we'll cross that bridge later because in terms of future content you know there's a few reviews I've got to do I mean yesterday I recorded the reviews for uh which ones were they uh day break the kenes bill winner I've reviewed that one and I've also recorded wild Gardens that's uh sitting in a spare cubby hole on the Shelf there so both of those have being reviewed they're going to get edited soon um I also need to play uh draft and right records from inside up games that one's going to get a podcast review not a full review but I will at least play it uh to I mean I've already played it at the UK games Expo I now need to sort of Play It solo a few times and see what it's like uh but then also I've managed to acquire by but I share thanks to the patreons for this I mean the the patreons are the only reason I could afford to grab this at the overinflated cost it uh required but look at this here we go arcs yeah this I had to pay twice I think the value of this game or maybe like one and a half times the value it was stupidly expensive basically zatu games got some late stock in for this and the leaders and law pack so I got that in including here as well I knew it was an inflated price but I can't sit on this until n on what like

Christmas Time by the time I would get it played you know assuming it came out when it was meant to because of all the essence stuff is and the fact that this is getting so buzzed and hyped up by some people I mean some people hate its guts but you know ever since shut up and sit down did their Show everybody's now clamoring for this game regardless of whether they actually know if they'll like it or not you know such as the influence they have so I really wanted to get a chance to play this at least and get some first impressions well now I can do one better for that I can do an official honest non-sponsored review of this CU this is from my own you know this is from patreon Pockets this is uh you know their support helps this show carry on and get these kind of games for me to review because otherwise I wouldn't be able to afford it so yeah you know no sponsorship no publisher backing on this no designer backing on this this is me giving my honest thoughts on arcs I'm learning it this uh um learning today um I'm going to go through all the rules make sure it's learned and then throughout the rest of this week it's been given the beans you know I've got multiple meetups planned to play this multiple times uh it's no solo mode so this will just be a case of multiple games and we'll try I'll try and get the review done for this as soon as possible during well at some point during August I reckon the amount of times I'm going to get this played in the next couple of weeks or like I think this will easily get an August release so yep have faith ARX is coming I mean I even put a little video about it when I got the box saying oh yes I'm doing this it's like someone is tackling the hype train on this one and it's got to be me

uh what anything else for the channel uh stuff I mean I will continue the best and worst um Series so you know that one it will get uh check game editions is the next one I want to do from a publisher perspective and then after that I will probably like I said I'll probably alternate between publisher and designer I think that kind of works well so we got check game editions coming for the next publisher one haven't fully decided on the designer one but I have a feeling I'm probably going to do a v Sera one uh so favorite and worst of the Sera because there's certainly plenty to talk about on that one oh the sun's coming bright through that window but well big deal it's a podcast show was it matter if half my face looks like a Heavenly Halo glow but yeah so not too bad otherwise outside of work uh it's not bad work is giving me a bit of grief lately I won't go into full details but it's just like I say it's heavy workload plus some other things happening it's kind of stressing me out quite a bit uh you know and you know I've had like some game nights with mates and Game Club nights and they've practically been like therapy to try and get over like what works kind of pulling at this point and yeah I mean it will resolve it's just the next couple of months are going to be a bit of a SLO and June and July was already a SLO but I don't think the slug's going to end until probably the end of September and then at that point everything will hopefully be back to a nice pleasant pace and the other things at work will all have dissipated by then so it's you know it's a case of knuckle

down and deal with it for two months but the Autumn I'm looking forward to because I mean the sun and the heat has not exactly helped with the whole stress thing uh you know the fact that we've had a heat wave recently in the last few days which turned the place into a sauner I've only just managed to cool it down to the point where I'm not actually sweating buckets but temperature looks normal for the next couple of weeks that's hopeful but the the more we get into the Autumn the more it's more comfortable for me to do recordings and just generally live which is kind of the deal but then also once we get past September which is a very busy month for me as a tax person because all the accountants want to get their stuff done before September filing date which is a very popular uh uh year end for companies the then my workload will decrease quite a bit even though I know I've got to get all my December stuff done before the 7th of December because you know I won't be around to to do that work because I'm going on the crew so yes I do have a little bit of a time table uh problem in terms of getting everything done but I'm confident I'll be able to be in a good State uh by the time I get there but the Autumn is just as I say there's also cool stuff happening in the Autumn I mean you know we've got Shake battle and roll at the end of September there'll be uh Essen first week of October then I've Got U handy conon will be at end of October there'll be another there'll be grid Con in November so there's quite a few cool things happening in the Autumn convention wise and game wise so it's the Autumn is just such an enjoyable period for me and you've got all the Essen games to play so it's busy but

it's fun you know so it's I'm looking forward to that time uh you so that should be uh pretty good fun but yeah anyway on with the show because there's quite a bit to go into at this point and yeah that sun is really coming through so yeah sorry about I could go and close the curent but I can't be bothered you know you're looking at a tiny image of me on the screen here and those of you listening in audio uh podcast land don't know what it looks like anyways it wasn't matter but basically I've got four games I want to talk about three First Impressions and one full review and then I want to go into the topic of the day so let's talk about the review first all right this isn't going to take long it's a short game but this is free of a Kind by uh Tim Eiser at weird City games so this is the same person who put out Leaf which is something guy rated quite highly canopy which is also one I've rated quite highly I mean generally they have put out some pretty solid games now they're also kickstarting soon March of the ants I have no idea what March of the ants is um like in terms of how it plays in that I never played the original I am totally down for seeing an evolved edition of it though um I I don't think I'm in the running for like well I don't usually look at Kickstarter games 99.9% of the time so this will be something I'll look into in 2025 when there's a more finished copy available but yeah I'm very interested to look into what this game's like I've heard some good things about the original um but what else have they done I mean I don't recognize things like little pig and uh fistle done that's kind of new on

me oh yeah and they got canopy Evergreen coming out later this year which I'm excited for so yeah this they they do some pretty solid games and they tend not to get a lot of buzz but uh you know I'm here to tell you that it's worth look taking a look well fre of the kind is basically a little slight party game so you know some of you might have already turned off at the idea of a party game well I mean stick with me party games are cool but this is kind of something that for me is kind of like a sister game to something like hive mind uh it's one of those games where you're trying to think like other players like come up with the same answer they would so Dixit Stellar did something recently as well but I'm getting a little bit tired of just one just one is still a fantastic filler party game does the job easy to play and all that lot but we do it so often often in Mondays you know it becomes and we don't just play it for 5 minutes we end up playing it for like three qus of an hour while you know going through the filler Tim table and I'm like okay seriously can we play other things during this time because it is starting to get a little repetitive well this is one that I've been bringing to fill that Gap from 2 to eight players 25 minutes you could play it you know does not take long at all and essentially it is one of those games as I said you have to think like other players you try to write matching answers to score more points but here's the twist the idea with this game is that you have these different subjects so like hive mind would get you to think like other players so you didn't get kicked out of the hive uh but it would come up with questions like five things

you put in your pocket three things you wear to the to the theater or something like that and so you would come up with relatively serious questions this one tries to take things in a bit more of a silly view so you have something that could be innocent like mode of transportation mythical creatures uh scientific items I don't know you know a serious category but then what happens is that whoever is choosing the category out of two cards the three players after them choose out of two adjective cards you know describing words to put it on with it so in this case on the example here they got modes of transportation then they say quickest smelliest and most magical so you can tell that there's some weird combinations there and then for each one you write a single answer and you're trying to come up with the same answer as other people to score more points so again it's a bit like hive mind but where this one I mean hive mind has the advantage of there's no winner it's just don't be the loser and the fact that it's got a lot of freedom with serious questions this one has an advantage for a being a quicker game by far but it can create some good laughs with some of these categories I mean what I mean the most magical mode of transportation what comes to your mind when you think of that well the example here wrote unicorn kind of works it's a horse you can ride a horse and it's a magical mythical creature I mean it works but you know with other people write it and what would be your first idea would you be trying to justify why an airplane or a derable or whatever is a magical mode

of transportation would be quite good what do you Cass as a smelliest I mean a smelliest mode of transportation I don't know could almost say trains because most trains smell like a public convenience most of the time uh but you know I'm sure there's better options on that front people might say both because you got to smell the water or something I don't know but or taxis cuz all taxis tend to smell a bit dodgy but the idea with this is that you come up with these weird answers and that's kind of the Crux of the game you play through six rounds see who's got the most points or if somebody gets to the maximum points before that happens and it's just very quick very easy to teach but the fact that you have these different you know different like questions and adjectives that come up just make it a little bit more of a fun weird cheesy game so you know I mean the other examples here it's like the scariest cheese the happiest item in the junk drawer the strangest letter of the alphabet I mean they do come up with some weird ones and because players are choosing they have the option to pick like weird and wonderful stuff but I'm trying to think what we had we had like like U there was definitely a mythical creatures one but then we had like some really weird categories who go with that you know the most innocent mythical creature the largest mythical creature in that but you know there are some other weird categories that you can do so this game I think is a solid seven out of 10 I mean it's a good game it gives you a similar vibe to Dix stellar and hi mind it is definitely a much faster game though it's definitely got that Advantage you can play it in pretty much

the same amount of time as You'll Play something like just one but at the moment I'm enjoying this more than just one just because we' played just one to death you know it's getting to the point where especially with the same people it's just not as interesting anymore I'd rather play so clover but this one is something a bit different it's still easy to teach it's still good fun uh obviously you're going to need some spare dry eras pens cuz they they will run out here these ones dry race markers always a bit finicity but yeah this can create a lot of different combinations and a lot of cool interesting fun party laughs now two to eight players you're really going to want to play this with a lot of players I mean we played it with five and that I think is the lowest count you should play this at you know if you're going to match with other players you really want to play this with a good player count so this is kind of like a 6 seven8 player quickie filler party game to play with lots of players who are around I think playing this with two to four just wouldn't work you wouldn't match up enough and they do have a rule for if you don't match if you don't match at all then the person who came up with the adjective gets a point so I guess there is an incentive to pick something a bit weird and random but they also get to give a style point to the player who you know they think had the best answer out of everyone that's there so there's other ways to score points but even so I don't think two to four player is really the way to go about this one ironically cuz it's three of a kind but yeah five six seven eight players you're in with a good solid fun little party game here so nothing that's going to break the break the mold you know nothing that's going to suddenly you know blow the doors off

or anything it's not the most original game out there we've seen this done before but this one does it in a cool fun quirky way cheap quick well more do you want from a filler party game certainly I want to bring this out a bit more often than just one right now just to add a little bit of variety all keep up the drink because I'm sure my throat's not going to like this episode right now let's talk briefly about some First Impressions so um let's talk let's talk uh bad first so remember I did a review a while ago called the Silverwood Grove it was first impressions and I said this was one of the worst games I had played in recent years like it was just the epitome of bad board game design crooked crown came by and said hold my beer yeah um I played this the other day and we're going to talk about the other game I played at the same time and I've seen this played at my Southampton group and whenever I've seen it played I've had worries about whether I would like it or not and so they wanted to play it it was the end of the night we thought all right let's play it let me find out what this game's like read the rules to it had some doubts just based on reading the rules played the game all my suspicions confirmed and then some this game is terrible absolutely terrible three to six players but you really should play this with six cuz playing it with any less unbalances some of the cards greatly but to put it simply this is one of those chaotic take that games of Randomness you are essentially trying to end up with the Crooked Crown in your

hand of cards at the end of the game so think Lost Legacy although I'm telling you lost Legacy did this a lot better um and the idea is is that each turn you play a card there's four cards they have certain effects and then it goes round eight rounds and then who's at the end of eight rounds that's it that's the Crocs of the game the difference here is that you have cards that steal randomly from other players you have uh cards that lower or raise people on this track which is your hand size so your hand size is a media every time you gain hand size you immediately draw cards and every time you lose hand size you immediately have to discard and then there's also one two what's the other card oh yeah and one to look at other players hands right and then there's a wild so these cards are shuffled up completely randomly so many are bu out at the start one of them has to be at the crown and then you've got to figure out who's got the crown steal it and have it at the end of the game that is literally the whole game this game is so bad so bad all right so let me tell you about some problems with this firstly yes I know it's meant to be a kind of random chaotic game but Co blim is this random as all get out but it's random and you don't have enough choices or options I mean all right not choices and options are bad ver you you have I even low no control TR is the the fact is is that when you get information in this game you don't usually have the means to act upon it so you have a card for looking at other people's hands right in a four player game that we played actually 1 two 3 four yeah we played a four player game of this looking at someone's hand and the Crux with this is

that if you have multiple copies of the same type of card in your hand you can play them more and it makes the action more powerful so you play a single look card you'll look at one player's hand you play three of them you'll look at everybody's hand in a player game but basically first round I play two of those and I look at two people's hands I see one of them's got the crown every single card I draw for looking at Players hands is now a dead draw from that point it's complete trash but you have no means of mitigation for card draw you draw it randomly there's no face up display what you see is what you get so I know the crown is sitting in somebody's hand and because there's only one card in the game that actually steals from people's hands I know it's it's there for quite a few rounds but the steel card is random you steal a random card from their hand so I know you've got the crown you have five cards in your hand I play two cards to steal two cards in your hand right I'd steal two at random I still don't get the crown I know you have it I just have no means of physically actually taking it from you but then the worst thing in this is that you've got this track of the hand size and I thought that was going to be cool at first it's broken because you have two cards in here one to lower somebody else down and one to raise only yourself now if you raise yourself to a high hand size you have so many options and so many powerful actions it's unreal but if you get lowered down to a hand size of three or two your options are greatly diminished and you have no easy way to raise it back up unless you play the pi card to

raise up your own hand size but what if you never draw the card because I went through six rounds of the game and never saw a single wild or pie card never saw one so my hand size got dropped to three and I had no means to raise it above three for the rest of the game yeah at least not until like the last round at which point it was pointless but yeah so I'm having to mess around with two or three cards and if you can't raise yourself back up you you're done you've got no means of doing anything you'll draw one card of each type most likely so it's like oh I'll steal from you but I can only look at one card or I want to look at people's hands cuz I think the Crown's mov but I can only look at one person you know oh I rais myself back up a hand size but I've only got one piie card therefore I'm only going to go up one hand size would be do two to three such a change and then the Ambush one card is you lower somebody else's people could literally just lower your hand size just to be dicks but you ideally should put it on the person at the top but you need to play at least a good two or three of them for it to actually make a tangible difference and that involves luckily drawing into them but then if you you could spend your time doing that and then the player straight afterwards plays fre pie cards and goes all the way back up you just wasted your time you've only got eight rounds in this game you've only got eight turns this game is just so terrible I hate it you know this it's not funny it's not interesting the cards are completely random your ability to do well is dictated by your hand size which can easily be crippled to the

point where you can never recover from it and even if for the like three rounds of the game I know exactly that the crown is sitting in somebody's hand if I don't draw a s a single Steel card I can't physically do anything about it I have to draw a steel card or wild and if I don't draw any of them which is kind of likely if you've only got a hand sizeer three then I can't do anything I literally can't take his card so the whole object of the game is Just null of void at this point I'm just sitting there going through the motions oh I'll draw three new cards of trash this hand great oh great I just draw free look at people's hand cards so I literally can do nothing but look at people's hands and I only care about of you and I already know where the crown is so what are the point of this card it's stupid I mean this game will still take a good 25 minutes half an hour to play but I would much rather play something like Lost Legacy Lost Legacy did this concept of find a hidden item and a bunch of cards with Shenanigans so much better seriously try Lost Legacy it's like a love letter clone with a hidden item that you've got to find it's really cool I actually kind of feel bad I sold my copy a while ago I think I'm actually possibly if I see another copy of it on a secondhand sale or on a cheap store I'm actually going to buy another copy cuz I think it was pretty solid but yeah I kind of do miss that game actually this game actually reminded me of a better game that I want to get but I don't want to play this game ever I don't want to see it on a table I don't want to see praise for it it it's horrible and I know this is meant to be some oh yeah it's fine for kids and they can have a laugh or whatever yeah kids don't know any better when it comes to

game design you know this is just such a waste and I'm seeing adults play it you know um somebody brought it out at South group and I don't know if it I mean people were laughing in it but what were you laughing at I mean there's nothing to laugh at at this if something gets nicked off you chances are you'll never be able to Nick it back if you have a low hand size you're doing nothing of interest in the game so where's the fun laughter in this this it's it's just so bad this is terrible don't play it two out of 10 one out of 10 you know I hated this and I never want to see it again all right let's try something a little bit more interesting we about the second game I played on that one Metro Runner which annoyingly on Board Game Geek is spelled as a single word so have fun searching for that one when you're not realizing that's a thing two take a risky underworld jobs and hack your way to infamy as mirror City's top Runner so yeah this is basically Blade Runner SL Netrunner you know type Universe it's uh all sort of hacking and digital and C cyber punk you know so it's it's got that kind of setting but this isn't exactly the most formatic game in the world this is a new one from thunderworks games I think it was like a recent Kickstarter and bear in mind I don't look at kickstarters but you essentially have this Rond Del track that you move around uh with your character and you're basically getting resources in the form of Cubes what the different cubes are I don't think even the rule book explains if it does you'll forget it instantly cuz it's literally just colors um and you're trying to complete these job cards which is

basically like Splender so you you know you you get the cubes you trade them in for cards you get the cards and they trigger are like little bonuses like oh I can move up this track or I can get some more cubes or some credits which allow me to do some boost bonus actions you know it's it's basically like I said it's a resource management game where you collect cards for points that's most of the game you've got a couple of tracks to level up which you know are good for points and also an endgame trigger but the main unique selling point of this and I do mean the only unique selling point of this cuz frankly the game as I mean I stressed now I enjoyed it it's very light it it's pretty much everything you've seen before though like there is nothing really new in this game apart from this one little hacking gimmick and even then it's nothing that we haven't seen before it's just the fact that it's used in this way this middle set of tiles here which I've got to admit in their metal Kickstarter version do look fantastic but it's like a t tsuro route connection mechanic you know where you got to put the uh tiles together and you follow the paths well here you have these hacking cards they can get you credits and infamy uh track levels and what you do is that you have two green nodules that you have to like get from start to finish and then there's a couple extra if you've leveled up enough influence to be able to access them and the idea is is that you have so many manipulations of these nine tiles to set them up in such a way that you can make a route from A to B and collect the bonuses it's a little gimmick it kind of fits with the theme that's going on but at the start of the game you can get a couple

of nice things from it by the end of the game you can do it so easily it's trivial like you can pretty much Max out every time this is not a complicated uh thing to work with and if you've got even a modicum of spatial awareness about you you'll be able to Max this out every time you look at any of the card so it just becomes trivial at that point and infamy gets you more points than influence so honestly level up your infamy ignore influence you get a lot of influence from doing job cards but you know infamy lets you collect like cubes of your choice on certain action spaces it's worth more points and you know all you have to do with influen is get about four spaces up the track five Max or something which allows you to access more stuff in the hacking Min game you'll be able to do that without even blinking really from doing job cards but as soon as you get that high in influence there's no point leveling up more influence because there's no extra benefit apart from a very slow progression of points but infamy gets you a lot more points so you would more than likely do that and because the hacking game is not difficult it's like you might as well just carry on doing that but that aside you know yeah here we go so this picture here connect this green to this green which you know you know for two free manipulations how would you do that well easy I mean you can swap tiles you can um yeah you can swap adjacent tiles you can wrap around and stuff like that well all you got to do is swap these two around and boom Bingo you've done it but you know do you want to connect the pink and the blue one as well well that might be a little bit harder but you've got a character card that lets you do various Shenanigans with it and stuff like that

so and it kind of does depend on the setup sometimes they might be just set up in such a way that it's easy to do anything but you know it's a it's an interesting little gimmick but it is a gimmick uh the characters basically let you do some major manipulation but the the artwork is fine nothing Stellar I mean it's uh it's it does the job for the setting the job cards are just they might give you a little special ability like uh convert one Cube into this Cube get a discount of a blue cube on this I mean it is they've got the setting right and some of the art fits it but man it is themess really I mean this one's like you know these job cards piggyback Port surveillance Insight foreign Revolution pressure stockholders at no point do you feel like you're doing any of those things you are literally just trading in cubes for a card you know so for pretty pictures so honestly the theme is kind of mostly lost in this game apart from the weird hacking element but the game is fine I enjoyed it I think it took a little bit long for what it was but then some of that might have been down to uh one player AP in a bit and we were playing with a young kid so uh you know as soon as you play with children the game's going to go slower anyway but you know the the game is fine it does the job but for something that was a Kickstarter I mean you you'd almost think okay come on we've seen this sort of thing done a 100 times you want to Kickstart this and get funding for it and yeah it's not that expensive a game for the deluxe version I'll give it that but don't you want something a bit more new a bit more unique something that's going to stand out from the crowd this

won't stand out from the crowd I mean I don't think it's bad I don't think it's bad I think it's a six out of 10 it's above average you know it does the job it's light it's not that long probably no apess and that is the the hacking game is what gets a bit few people aping because they sort of go right I'm going to do the hacking action and then they try to figure out how to do the patterns and it's like well try and figure out how to do the patterns before you have your turn because then yeah I mean I was doing that on my one it's like right I'm going to do the hacking action I've already worked out I need to do this this this this this and this done you know I can do my turns really quick perhaps I've got good spatial awareness I don't know but you know other people were struggling a little bit with it but yeah it's uh it's fine I mean the whole Rondell thing you'd think that would restrict your movement a bit because you need to be in certain color districts to do certain things but it's very easy the fast travel in this with the credits so it kind of you know takes away that whole restriction and there's also a random element where when you do hacking jobs cubes appear in the various districts and when you do a district action there you get to take all those cubes it's random how they get put out you might just be in a situation where some hacking happens and loads of stuff gets dumped on your space or it gets dumped near you but it's the person before you gets to act first and therefore they go nickit which again just seems like a very random swingy element I mean it's very powerful to get those sort of things and the fact that it's just completely random I think hurts the game a bit but the game is okay it does the job but it's just nothing new you know the hacking gimmick will get tiresome after about half the

game and then the rest of the game is just what you've seen before so yeah 6 out of 10 average game but if I never well above average game because it does get the stuff it's aiming for right but if I never saw it again I wouldn't really miss it all right and then finally we're going to talk about Sky mines oh God yes an Alexander fer game I've actually played one recently well this is the reimplementation for mombassa never actually played mombassa I just had no desire to but my friends want my friends at the moment that I'm in a group with want to play games we've played before and they thought that i' played Sky mines at some stage with them but nope this is the game I kind of avoided because I knew it was really it was an Alexander Fister game it looked bone dry it was reimplementing a game that didn't sound great in the first place Mombasa so I avoided this one I just let other people get on with it but I'm I'm in that sort of state where I'm like all right fine I'll try anything once let's give it a try see what it happens I mean let's face it stranger things have happened I like Great Western Trail New Zealand so who knows maybe this reimplementation would improve on the original you know in that sense you know it would do something that would go oh yeah this is better so I thought we'll try it we'll try Sky mines and it took us a while um it's not the shortest game in the world even though it likes to well it does say 75 to 150 minutes I think you're definitely looking at the 150 minutes side possibly longer but uh and 3.87 weight that I don't don't

really get this game doesn't really feel to me like that heavy a weight game okay I mean I would put this at midweight there's only so much you've got to think about with this one although I suppose H I suppose that's not entirely accurate but I'll I'll get on to why in a minute it's kind of confused it's it's a weird weight level it's from Deep print games Pegasus Spiel and the idea is is that you are operating on the moon you've got these companies that you're building outposts for these outposts will increase the value of a company and you invest in them and get resources and get victory points yes now it's stand the fista game did you honestly think this was going to have any modum of a theme no the theme is completely pasted on here I mean it wasn't exactly that strong in mombassa here it is completely pasted there is no theme here it's just it's on the moon so let's make everything look all Spacey and say we're getting minerals and stuff but that's about it components wise pretty basic some tiny little wooden building some cards and that although whoever did the graphic design on this um I mean some of the graphic design is not too bad but whoever came up with the color choices for some of these U resources needs to have their head beaten because I'm sorry but you have to being a colossal to come up with the idea that you would have minerals and Cobalt the colors that they are Cobalt or whatever it is the uh the carbon or something right because you've got three types of resources you got titanium which is gray so it sticks out quite a bit then you've got minerals and then you've got carbon car carbon is

a very light blue right so cyan blue basically uh the the minerals is a very light Bluey green and in pretty much any light you get the two of them are very similar this picture probably does it as much justice as it possibly can but I guarantee you you're looking at this across the table like you know a zoomed out picture here let's say you're sitting in this person's point of view you will commonly constantly get mineral and carbon mixed up because they are too similar in terms of color and I do not get why somebody in graphic design thought the color choices would make sense I mean if you're trying to make this a color blind thing then be careful because I don't know if this actually makes it easier for color blind people but you made it so much harder for people who aren't color blind you know so you're for the like the It doesn't make sense why you would do that if you're going to make it color blind friendly then don't make it you know harder for the people who aren't color blind as well you any other color could you have not picked another one could it not been red could it have not been bright you know dark green and very light blue or something could it have not been orange uh yellow's already taken yellow and orange is taken for energy I guess but there must have been another color purple something anything to make it stand out but yeah the choice they made on that was stupid but anyway I digress that's a small nigle so the game itself your turns involve this card mechanic and the card mechanic involves you planning almost sort of like pseudo

programming so you have these cards some get you resources some get you energy some let you do research and Etc and you put them in these slots at the bottom of your board and you flip them over simultaneously and then you do your actions one at a time but you do so by flipping the cards over and you use them in order to buy more cards do research build Outpost that kind of thing now the reason this game has a high weight level is not because the rules complexity is high because honestly the rules complexity is not that High I mean if you play heavy games this one will come fairly straightforward and nothing really stood out as like oh yeah that was particularly fiddly the idea is is that these cards you lay out and when you do an action it's based on what you have visible after you flip the card this isn't something that's that intuitive though with other games so I'm used you know usually you play a bunch of cards out like in a deck build or something like that and you get to use everything that's on those cards but this one has you requiring to plan out your turn pretty extensively but then what you commonly do and all of us did this but I tripped up about four or five times doing this and it was getting more and more frustrating every time I did it which granted I will put down to bad play mostly but still it's frustrating the idea that you go right I know I need these to especially with the research track this is where it really tripped me up you know I lost the game because I couldn't do any research because every time I thought right you can move this white counter across all these tiles and these tiles tell you the prerequisite for what you need to go across these tiles right so I have it planned out that I'm going to go across these

research tiles but I need to grab a card first I need to take this before somebody else takes it that sort of thing and then you flip one card and then you realize that you no longer can do the research thing you were trying to do because you flip one card and by doing it you might think oh well it's okay you can do it a bit later no because when you have your term the cards move to the top of these discard stacks and you can only take back one of those discard Stacks every round and there's not that many rounds in the game so if you make a mistake in this game you will not be able to do the same thing you were trying to do for at least a good two rounds and that's assuming you draw the you know you you have enough cards for it in the first place so getting a plan wrong fundamentally destroys your Tempo and your ability to score some points I could not research because every time I needed to research I forgot that you're supposed to have cards visible face up and all this nonsense and it's like ah for Christ's sake I get that's part of the game but it's not an intuitive thing because in most games you don't have that and so it just there's nothing to remind you that this is a thing there's no iconography on the board or on your reference card or anything like that to remind you that this is an important thing in the game and you just constantly forget it's a thing while trying to plan out your turn because you're already trying to plan out oh I need to do this and this and this and this right I've got the plan that's good but then the fact that you've got to do it in a prescribed order as well just makes it a really fiddly convoluted system and just frustrating every time you trip over it I mean if I didn't trip up on a couple of those researches things I probably

would have easily won the game but it cost me the game because of it despite doing well at other stuff although also H uh balance-wise I'm a little bit concerned I mean you know the The Outpost we played on the reverse map which has you getting blocked up quite easily on there it's very difficult for the company values to shift on that side of the map and so it just SE it felt like that when a company becomes really good it's going to stay really good so why would you not invest in that company uh the research tiles I just found a bit fiddly this whole uh what you call it um helium track or something on the left is literally just a convoluted way to have a a track level up for points that's all it does um but leveling up on these two tracks does allow you to unlock more slots so instead of only playing three cards around you can play five or four or five but for most of the game I was stuck on only three because those mistakes cost me the ability to play more cards and if you play this game with only three cards that you can play you will lose end of story because you just can't get enough done and it's not helped by the fact that the board has a mechanic I really don't like which is this majority thing uh I'll try to find it but basically if you have the majority of a particular resource type um in your icons on your cards you get to have these here you go these Max ones here so if you got the max energy you can put your worker on here and it locks it for the round and you get a bonus based on how many of them you actually have the problem is is that these bonuses you get are substantially good

they level you up colossal amounts on these various share tracks and this is how you basically get the majority of your points as well as unlock cool abilities and stuff but if you don't get these Max abilities on a regular basis then you are going to lose you cannot win the game without getting some of these but you don't know what other players are going to play you don't know if other players are going to suddenly beat you on carbon or whatever at this time so it's random as to whether you stand a chance of getting them and if you are like in a position where H you know somebody else is like on par with me then I have to choose between getting this really cool bonus or doing my original plan and if I go along with the original plan then somebody else gets to go oh well I'll get the max bonus then and it I don't know these Max bonuses just feel too powerful too powerful and too like impactful like if you don't get them you're going to lose um the game itself is not bad I didn't hate it but I think this is kind of like a five out of 10 for me I if I don't play it I wouldn't really care I certainly would play better next time because I wouldn't trip up so much over that stupid face up card rule but it it's just there's no theme in here to capture anything I mean this whole way you level up research tiles just feels like a clunky mechanic that could have been so much more streamlined and you know is just there to be a Euro mechanic um certainly getting high on one of those tracks is going to score you so many points that I think everything else will probably be dwarfed you know cuz even if you get a I mean I had maximum value I had like nine shares in one particular company that was really good

value and I still lost because I couldn't get very high up these two tracks on my player board and and the person who won did so it these two tracks on your player board seem like the Paramount thing you got to do and the outposts are just another thing you can do the boards are different so you do get different abilities for these various companies so that is quite cool there is a bit of variety although again some of the abilities are definitely better than others I mean the amount of effort you go to get a fourth worker isn't worth it I mean you rarely have decent amount of stuff to do with four or five workers so why do that the ability to get discounts on certain cards or get free energy and stuff is so much more useful than getting an extra worker by Miles wish I knew that when I tried to get an extra worker um but yeah it's just the game just seems a bit inflexible you can end up with plans being screwed very easily because somebody takes something you want or you flip a card without remembering oh yeah I've got to do it in this prescribed order and if you do make a mistake you can't recover because it will take you at least two rounds to even have a chance of getting the same setup and there's not enough rounds in the game so anytime you make a mistake it is so costly and so punishing that it just doesn't become fun it the game is okay it's but again it's also not unique there's no unique selling point in this apart from the fact that you have got this site move the cards to the top and get a discard stack although I think some games have done that before but I'm

not a massive fan of programming games either and this one is kind of like a pseudo programming game cuz you got effectively program the entire round exactly not a fan I like to have some flexibility like a chance to be able to go you know what I'm going to do this instead but you don't if you don't follow your prescribed plan to the letter you are going to have problems and it will just mean that you lose so it's another one of those Alexander FIS games I'm glad I skipped I mean what's it ranking on board game gig you know does it have a ranking can I find out rank 643 that feels a bit overrated to me it's okay but yeah if I don't play this again I'm not going to lose uh sleep over it you know I would certainly play it better the next time round but nothing about this wants to bring me back I mean I didn't find a single mechanic in it different from any other game that I could play that's more fun or unique or like enticing to bring me back and there's no theme so there's no theme to keep me immersed in the game it's just a mechanical set of Euros mechanics I that's the best way to describe it so yeah it's got its fans but I only see it played every now and again but this one just felt like me know whoopy I'd much rather play great wrest and Trail New Zealand frankly you know certainly I mean I'm going to take a guess there's a sky Moon there's a sky Moon review here from the dice D I'll bet money that that is a chish ye and I bet there's got to be a chrisy and Wendy like review or something cuz they're the sort of people that they this game has tailor made for them you know I can't see Tom vassel like in a game like this

but yeah yeah me all righty then so assuming you're still listening after I've just berated a Alexander Fister game which is almost like berating Jesus these days so I just want to talk about uh a question that came up by patrons when I asked for suggestions and somebody asked me how do you get to be a bit more Analytical in like when playing games it's like what do you mean by analytical and it's like things you look out for you know ways to critique a game and that because some of them were board game designers and they wanted some tips and that and I thought okay this is interesting although a little bit hard to sort of put it into words but I'm just going to basically summarize a few sort of key points here that I've written down that you know I think about when I'm playing games and how I kind of you know this isn't like a comprehensive guide to how I review a game it's just these are some of the things I can consider and how I what my thinking process with this so we'll talk about length first so length of a game how long is it now that does not mean a game that is 3 hours is too long and hate it you know there were some games on my shelf there like forbidden Stars some of these Ser of Euros Arc NOA can take a while you know and a lot of the times these can still justify the three-hour length because they're that involved hemony is like a 3 to four hour game but I don't know how you would condense it down to 2 hours it's too like involved but man is it a fun game so you know some of these games can be long and still be good the question is is it too

long for what it is and have other games done it shorter and a few of these some of these things are going to repeat uh as I look at other games you know there's definitely an element of you know have other games done it better so I did mention hegemony but hegemony is a massive involved heavy game lots of player interaction asymmetric roles you could not make this a short game if you tried it's just not going to happen but I still love it I am immersed I am involved I'm not on downtime much unless you got a really AP player but yeah this one keeps you involved and that is something to think about with length you know when you're playing a game is it too long for what it is has it outstayed its welcome uh a particularly good example would be the recent review I did for Empire end Empire's end is basically the no thanks mechanic but made four times longer you know it's well that at bare minimum it's 10 times longer really but this one is just that bidding mechanic but you've thrown some extra little like abstract uh Sith stuff on it the thing is is that after playing it I'm like well it's pretty random it's just the same mechanic and honestly after playing no thanks on Monday I'm like I'd just rather play no thanks rather than this you know no thanks does it in about 5 10 minutes and this one is like an hour and a half to two hours at times it's you know why do I need to play this for that length of time but this also is a very rinse repeat game so you go through the track um in the

middle there to say right we're doing industry and then we're doing uh you know economy that kind of thing and you go through this track and it's just rinse repeat the same stuff it's like another disaster disaster combat disaster disaster economy disaster industry disaster disaster disaster all we got to do six in a row now and it's just constant rinse repeat and you know it definitely feels like it outstays it's welcome every time wild Gardens behind me uh that one you know is 90 minutes to 2 hours it's got very simple rules with four players You could argue it kind of gets to that point where it's a bit long but I think the length is pretty good for a game that's two to three players I think it doesn't outstay it's welcome you're involved you're immersed in this uh you know beautiful artwork in colors yeah there's not that much of a theme but certainly the artwork will keep you looking at nice stuff and you know the the length is kind of Justified but that's kind of what I'm saying it's like you know is does the length fit the game you know there's no point having some game that's basically love letter that you play for three hours munchkin for example oh munchkin is a perfect example right you play munchkin yeah it's chaos it's meant to be mainly for sill and stuff like that but would you honestly say munchkin is a good game do you want to play munchkin for 2 hours that this game can last where it's just literally playing cards for like take thatness and this is a genre that is sadly bloated at this point it you know I don't want to play

this game for two hours I'd play it for 30 minutes maybe but two hours no and that's something to think about uh well on the subject of Randomness actually so we got this one here Randomness just because there are random elements in the game doesn't mean it's necessarily bad either I mean camel up is just Flatout chaos but it's silly chaos it's a racing game you're bidding on stuff it's meant to be not taken seriously so it works kind of in that one but you still have control over what you're bidding on it's your choice but then something like the munchkin for example where you are playing these cards and just bad stuff happens well firstly the random stuff that can happen is just punishing the players but also again this combines with length do you want to play a game that is mostly random for Two Plus hours you know you can play it for quarter of an hour fine let's play Love Letter there's random card drawing that but the game's like 5 minutes a piece what does it matter but then play something like uh you know people use this argument with ar NOA with luck of the draw the cards but I'd argue terraform Mars gets it worse but you know when you play a three-hour game and there's a random element in it so uh well maybe not three hours but long game so for example I'll go Dune Imperium right so I don't like this one anywhere near as much as other people and one of the key reasons for that is because I think the random element kills this game because it's deck building so deck building has a element of Randomness you will draw cards and not necessarily get the ones you want but the problem is in most games you can still do something useful

with the hand you've got here though because worker placement spots are limited and because it's so few victory points and because there's only so much time you must get when you need something you want the card to do it but the cards also dictate where you're allowed to go on the board if they didn't dictate that I think this game would actually be a lot better because then you would have the freedom to at least go to the worker placement space you wanted to go to even if you don't have the cards to necessarily make it as good as it could be but here I desperately may need to go to a particular faction because if I don't I won't have anything for the combat nor will I be able to beat you to nicking this uh you know Alliance token off me great draw my cards I know I've got something in here that will do it oh I didn't draw it great so now I can't go there oh you've gone there now right so bad luck meant that I couldn't do this all right well I suppose I could get some spice oh I don't have any yellow cards either I've just conveniently drawn all my blue ones and this game is not short this game is like a 2 and a half to three hour game at the best of times so that level of punishing Randomness in that long a game which normally is meant to be a fairly thinky Affair doesn't work it doesn't gel it doesn't fit so if you're going to have a random element in your game it should be more mitigable and it should be justified for the length uh theme let's go back to them so you know theme is the game immersive will it keep you engaged in that respect now not everybody cares about theme so if you're going to make a very dry mechanical Euro then fine you don't necessarily need to have a theme but if

you're going to have a theme then I don't know why I stopped the camera there for a sec um you need to at least make certain the theme works or is relatable I mean if I play something like Arc Nova yes okay it's not the most fmatic game in the world you know you are getting cards for icons but animals are a great theme you know it's just a theme that most people like animals and you know when you're playing this I just get immersed in the fact that I am building a zoo yes it is abstracted to a point but I still like the setting that I'm in but okay let's talk about a really formatic game that I love um and it's talk about uh sentinals in the Multiverse for example I mean theme is a lot easier to do in something like a co-op game and this one perfectly represents the theme of superheroes yes it's a card game and you're playing it with various effects but you feel like a superhero team the villain is the big bad you are killing minions you are blowing up devices you are utilizing your powers the game Flow even works matically where you get beaten up a lot at the start and then you get powerful you rise up and then you come back a bit like Avengers endgame type scenario you know this one really does the theme well and if you are going to put theme in the game and make it a focal point then you certainly do need to make certain it strong now if I'm being critical of games it's a case of right is this meant to have a theme no then okay fine you're a dry mechanical theme but you can tell when some games are trying hard to justify the theme they've done even though the theme is blatantly not there

you know and it can be a little bit of weirdness I mean Pulsar 2849 this is the game I love but oh my God is it a dry point salad but it goes on you know you've got a mechanic about spinning gyro and you know this is how they what they would do with pulsars and and it's like dude this is a mechanical Point salad stop trying to justify the theme in whichever way you can and trying to think of some other examples I guess I mean even Daybreak I suppose I've done recently I mean it's got a climate change uh theme but when you're playing the game I don't feel like I'm really stopping climate change hell I probably just feel like I'm stopping a disease it's basically a pandemic type scenario but at the end of the day you're playing cards and doing icons it's I don't really feel like I'm stopping climate change when I play Daybreak for example and it's got to be others Scythe You could argue that something like Scythe theme is a little bit uh pasted in some respect yeah it may look good and have nice artwork but that doesn't necessarily mean the theme is there and you know if you're going to do an atmospheric game like Nemesis or Manch of Madness then yes you're definitely going to want theme strong and those games have a strong theme so great but you know I'm trying to is there anything on my wall anything on my shelf that I can see that is a blatant like lack of fee despite the fact it tries to be and they do exist these ones do exist but strugg I suppose stuff like you know I mean Mystic Veil and some of these card games where they try to say oh you're oh mean run Stones actually runestones is a good one actually so you know run Stones

is U you know a very dry deck builder it's a fantastic dry deck builder but it you know the artwork and all the stuff is like saying oh you're doing magical artifacts and you're Druids and you're doing all this and it's like dude there's no Fe don't stop trying to sell it as a ftic game cuz it really isn't but this is kind of one that's not necessarily one that drops games marks just because it's not thematic but it's a case of if you are going to have a theme how well have you like respected that theme particularly with IPS you know if a game pays an IP on a game then you need to have a good theme you know if you make an abstract game with cyberp punk you know which is a beloved PC game then you better have a good cyberpunk theme if you've literally just copied and pasted an IP on it to try and sell copies I'm going to call you out for it rules complexity uh rules complexity well you know how easy is the game to learn for what it is you expect the game to be complex if it's a Lera game but then it does take a while and it is heavily involved so that makes sense but I don't expect a game that is meant to be for Gateway Gamers to suddenly be a bit too complex now some you know this can be a little uh subjective but then for example dog park reviewed it recently very nice light game I think it was trying to portray to a Gateway audience or some people try to claim it's a Gateway game it really is not you've got too much going on with dog abilities on cards to make it Gateway level so it doesn't work it's a little bit too complex for that market so I'm

certainly going to be critical of the fact that a game that has the theme that really should make it Gateway level isn't Gateway level the game is still good but I would have liked it if it was just a bit more new gamer friendly but then uh while Gardens actually I'll go back to that one actually slight spoiler alert for the review but the one thing that this game has going for it is that for the amount of that you're involved and the amount of depth it has the rules are not complicated to this game at all there's not a lot of rules to learn and when it makes it easier to teach the game that's a good thing but then also the Terminus review I did you know I only gave it a I think I gave it a six out of 10 which is still decent enough rating but one thing I did give terminus a bit of credit for us yes it does get the graphic design a bit RW in places and you know there are a couple of fiddly bits for the most part for the amount of weight that this game has there's not a ton of rules in the game compared to something else like there are heavy games here where you've got so many rules it's unreal but you still only have but you still play it for that long but this one seems to have like half the rules of a typical Euro game and yet is still as heavy and weighty which is a good thing so you know is your you know are the rules to this game too complex are they too convoluted is it too fiddly are the reference cards garbage you know the reference cards need to be good they need to make it so that I don't need to check the rule book for most of the time and if I have to still check the rule book despite you having reference cards then there's a critical falling um but yeah you

certainly think about like you know this game how simple and heavy is it is the rules teach and rules curve Justified for it I mean arcs I've got arcs over there I've heard that the rules are a little bit of a chore to learn but we'll see but the game doesn't look like something that should be that complex so if I read this and I find that it's a bit of a chore to do then I'm going to be a bit critical of it but then you could also argue this is also down to rule books so is the rule book good certainly if you had trouble learning the game because the rule book was bad you should be critical of that I mean that's should be an easy thing to analyze out you know have you played similar games where you've had a much easier time time learning it you know do you tend to play Heavy games great well out of the heavy games you've played which ones did you find easy to learn and which ones did you find more of a chore why did you find them more of a chore was it a bad rule book was it a lot of fiddly rules was it just too many rules in general and it could be more streamlined these are things to think about uh other games yeah other games Empires M was a great example you know but are there other games that already do this we we're coming to a point where there's so little um like uh innovation in the industry that we're basically seeing the same stuff made all the time so the question is when a new game comes out is it any different from something we've already seen before and if it's not improving the formula then why does the game need to exist Empire n tries to take a mechanic that is done in a tiny

little filler game and make it into something a bit bigger so okay so no thanks is already good for this reason does this one work when you've already got no thanks and personally I don't think it does I think I would just rather play no thanks but the one I talked about earlier Metro Runner um you know I said that it doesn't really have a unique selling point it's like stuff we've seen before you know get resources that are cubes generic cubes trade them in for cards get points well we've seen this done a 100 times so when you're being analytical over whether this is a decent game or not you can't review it in a vacuum you have to consider the rest of the market because I can't recommend a new game game that comes out just because it's new you know if it's got zero Innovation and is just basically a carbon copy of something we've seen before it's why I'm not a big fan of Roland rights cuz Rolland rights just seem to rinse and repeat the same boring tropes here's a bunch of little mini games that have no fmatic connection whatsoever cross things off get victory points so how can I say that the next one that comes along is fantastic when all I'm seeing is the same stuff all the time you know you've got to you know consider that but then also as I say compare the mechanics to other games compare the theme to other games superhero theme is this superhero game more thematic than this other superhero game uh is this point salad give you more options than this other game does someone feel more restrictive than this other game you got to consider other games in the Market within the same type of game that you're making and

that's a big factor because if something did it better then yours didn't need to exist uh uh let's see runaway leader knockout I mean certainly if I'm being critical of games from that perspective it's like okay can you be knocked out of the game to the point where you might as well not even you know play it one of the games I'm really critical about like I really do not late is food chain magnate this is like a one out of 10 for me I hate this game with a passion right and I know it's got its Die Hard fans I am most certainly not one of them but then I'm not a fan of pretty much anything made by splotter games I think I hate all their games but yeah yeah not one of them I don't think I like any but this game is one of those games where if you make a bad move or wrong decision in the first one to four turns you're done like you will not be able to get an engine going you're done you're going to lose and you're there for like 4 hours there 240 minutes you're there for 4 hours like at least and you can't do anything wow I mean that's supposed to be good game design and the the stupid thing is that this guy has a you know the people who make this have the same where they go if you can't lose on the first term then what's the point of the first term but then the rebuttal to that is if you can't it was it if you can win on the first turn and what's the point of the rest of the game because you know you've got to have some degree of catch up or some degree of I'm contributing to this game but if you feel like you have no chance from the get-go because things

started off badly then why play the rest of the game that's not fun and certainly I'm very critical of this game because it's like that how is that fun to know that your first few turns will completely decide your ability to win you know it's not fun it doesn't work runaway leader similar thing you know if you get a game where the leader just gets further and further ahead and it's a nightmare to catch them up that's something to be critical for one uh one that does this I think a bit too much is Lords of Water Deep Lords of water deep does have a bit of a runaway leader issue if you start off well and you continue to do well there's not a a lot you can really do to hamper them apart from playing those really annoying mandag quests but if they're doing well it's not going to hold them up that much and they still get a little bit of points for them so no big deal but I would say that you know Lords of water deeps one of its problems is that yes you can have somebody just run away with a game and you're not going to catch them up something to be critical about I mean you want to have a game where it's tightnit scores you want to be uh you know in a situation where it's like yes I reckon I can get it it's it's not going to be easy but I reckon I can catch you let's just do this come on we can do it if you've got that kind of feeling then brilliant but if I'm already like 40 points behind somebody because they've started off well I'm like well we might as well just give this game to you then because you're going to win there's no way I can catch you up so why are we playing and then that means not very enjoyable all right how many more of these I got

uh set up and Tak down oh yeah set up and Tak down so being analytical with that one how long does the game take to set up and put away well I've definitely been critical of some games in this and you know there seems to be a consensus at the moment that everybody's in this dream world bubble where time does not exist and so nobody factors in the setup or take down for a game so Publishers never print the setup or takeown time on a box I really wish they would they never Factor it into the time it takes to play the game nor the rules teach they really should because for the most part you are going to have to teach people and you always have to set up and take down a game so you should have it factored into your time frame but there are so many times where the Box will say 60 minutes but it will take 20 minutes to set up for you know 20 minutes to teach it and by the time the 60-minute game is finished it's 2 hours later so it it ends up with that problem but is the setup and takedown Justified you know for what this game is for what other games exist that can do it quicker do I am I Justified to do this and one of the biggest like misses for me on that front is yes I'm sorry to bring it up void fall void fall look whether you love this game or not fair enough you know I liked it fine I gave it a decent review from a solo perspective but I will refuse to play this multiplayer ever again but even then my rating has dropped for you know even as a solo game and I sold it and I never want to play

it again you know the problem this game has is the length and investment required I mean let's go back to the rules rul complexity the rules complexity of this game is off the freaking chain there's so many things you've got to bear in mind a lot of little Edge rules so learning this game takes an absolute Lo load of time right then you've got uh you know the you know now it does do well on certain other things like there's not a lot of Randomness in the game great uh there's not a you know it's a very heavyweight game it's certainly very thinky so it's doing pluses on that but then let's look at setup and takedown this game takes like anywhere between 40 to 60 Minutes to set this thing up it is ridiculous you have got to take so much out of this game to get it on I mean you need to figure out which scenario you're doing then you've got to populate these hexes sorry you got to put these hexes down so you got to find the right ones first then you got to put them down then you got to put these various tokens on various ones depending on the scenario then you got to put these corruption markers everywhere then you got to put the corruption walls on then you got to find out where you're starting as a player then you got to set up all the players individual boards then you've got to think right hang on which factions are we playing okay so which factions are not in the game which ones are Fallen factions right we got to get the Technologies for them right well let's find the you've got these tiny little boxes for each one right well let's find the ones that we need right so we got there so we need these particular technology cards right so fine uh which one are we going to pick a or b well we'll pick this one then we got to lay out more Technologies there on the line everybody's still got their player board right oh you need to turn your dice to this particular section you need these cards you need your individual resource things set to this

level the setup is insane and for a game like this I've played heavy games I've played heavy Space Games the setup is not justified here no game deserves like a 45 minutes to 60 Minute setup time nothing and hegemony I can set up hegemony in less than like 25 minutes you know 20 25 minutes and I've already got hegemony ready to go because a lot of it kind of makes sense and I've got it down to a te but you could argue well okay you can get void for down to a t there is too much in this to get void fall down to a t you've got to check so many things and I'm pretty sure nobody's memorized the map layout from every scenario so you're going to have to follow that and it's just H such a pain to get it and then when you put it away whoa you've got all these tokens everywhere all these ships everywhere all these little pieces dice cubes your boor I mean if your board state is going to look like this and you know you want to put that away and try and get it in the box with those tiny little trays that are used for each of the separate factions oh have fun with that oh have fun so you know is it Justified and for me this was a big critical negative I had of the game I don't think it is Justified I think this no game deserves a setup time that's that much and um hopefully the image is working it's kind of been a bit weird here but yeah I I just can't see why you would have it like that so you know that's something to be mindful of now is there other games you know I'm trying to think of

something where the setup's really quick I mean I suppose Terminus I did mention termin Terminus setup is pretty quick when you play that as a multiplayer uh anything else that's pretty quick as a setup while Gans doesn't take much to set up but then it's a light game I would expect it not to take that long uh let's think of a big game though big heavy game that doesn't take a huge amount of setup um I mean out of the serers I would say gallerist is a fairly basic setup I mean you you you put you put some cute meatles in a bag put out the art type choose your starting location a starting bonus tile and set up some bonus tiles on the left hand side that's kind of it I mean for a Lura game it's definitely got one of the lowest setup times although compare that to something like on Mars on Mars takes a hell of a long time to set that one up very rules complex heavy so that one you know is very tricky to get to the table and played and my reason I don't want to play on Ms anymore is because when I compare it to the other of the serers it's too complex and too you know too overly complex and too overly fiddly for what it needs to be uh let's see something else with a quick well while saying that living Forest now this could be a negative here actually living Forest one of the negatives I do have of that game is that the setup is a little bit long for living forest for what is a fairly simple game you've got the individual players with all their with their cards then you've got to set up the board with specific positions for your thing then

you've got these trays to set up with the trees that's very fiddly to do you've then got the display of cards you've got the fire tokens and all the other bit of tokens if you've got the expansion you've then got to set up the kadama board so there's quite a bit to set up in this game for what is a relatively Light Affair so it's not just heavy games that this can AFF effect but trying to see anything else on my immediate shelf that's well Seven Wonders Architects actually is not a bad shout the setup and takedown for that game is n non-existent now it's meant to be a you know fairly simple game at that that because it's a very light Gateway level little card game well good that's something to give praise for and be analytical about you know this game is meant to be super light and super easy so it should be really easy to learn really quick and you know take very little time to set up and take down setup is literally to pull a tray out take the box off it put the tray next to you and your opponent and you're done get going you know put some tiles out for your wonder you're done setting this game up in about 5 minutes you can teach it in 5 minutes it is that simple po then you get the game done and dusted within about 20 25 minutes and you know half an hour absolute tops and then when you put it away all you got to do is just collect the cards together and shove them in the trays it probably takes twice as long to take it down as it does the setup but you can be done and dusted with this entire thing in 45 minutes 45 minutes you can set it up teach it play a whole game and take it down have it in the Box on the Shelf 45 minutes or less which is what you want from a quick light game so this one

ticks those boxes whereas some like void fall doesn't for me uh player count uh player count so this can go to multiple players so this game says two to four players maybe it says one to four players as a solo mode is the solo mode a good solo mode or is it literally just copy and paste a beat your own score thing like a lot of kickstarters do um wild Guardians again I keep bringing this one up it's fresh on my mind you know that one has a solo mode where they actually went above and beyond trying to make it an interesting solo mode more about that in the review but but then you know player account for something like Daybreak uh again like spoiler for that one is that this is a co-op game that doesn't feel like a co-op game it's multiplayer solitire so the fact that it's got two to four players on the box makes no difference because there's no reason to play it with more players than just yourself but you know a lot of games I criticize for having the fifth player they say right this game can go from two to five players because we want to sell more copies yet five players rarely Works in a game okay I mean let's take a a game I like I mean it's not just ragging on games I'm not a big fan of I love tribes of the wind I think this is a brilliant game very nice very cool like game but it says two to five players on the box you would have to be critically insane to play this with five players because is your your actions are dependent on the two people to the side of you so that means this game is fundamentally a fre player game works well in two-player though the two-player variant is pretty good and you could play it with four you won't have any

effect on the person directly opposite you but they will be influencing your two neighbors that's not too bad but if four players is jubia why the hell would you add a fifth there's no reason all it does is adds to the time length and downtime so it's not worthy so when I'm being analytical of this game I'm thinking right you've said two to five players does it scale well do does the game actually scale with player count because some games don't the map size doesn't change the card display doesn't change so you suddenly find that two players is very Wishy Washi and freedom Central but then you get to the upper level and suddenly it's an absolute slugfest for spaces because there's just not enough spaces to cope with the player count well that's an EV that's evidence of something that doesn't scale well and that's a critical problem because you're creating a fundamentally different experience with a certain player count when ideally the game should give you a similar experience with all players even hegemony has this problem you know hegemony is a two to four player game right how many people do you see play this as a two-player game be honest you might do it as a solo game and even then as a solo game I would rather play this with at least two AI factions you're playing this minimum three players and typically most people who want to play a giny want to play it with a full count of four so why is the two-player option On The Backs you know if you if it doesn't work at a certain player count you shouldn't even try Seven Wonders who plays that two- player come on it was always at least a free player game people I prefer to play it with a lower player count some people like to play it the higher player count

but who the hell plays it at two all right the variant for Seven Wonders at two was garbage so Nobody Does it so why is it on the box and if you're going to be critical of that game you have to criticize the fact that the two-player variant is garbage because nobody liked it um the player counts uh well I mean I mean what does player count affect it affects the uh tightness of the game you know is there not enough spaces to cope with things it also affects game length for the most part you know most of the time when you add a player it adds time length now simultaneous games get away with this a bit more but even then I find that that's a problem because even something like Planet unknown where some people argue oh well I can play it with six players and it doesn't take any longer well you still have to go as slow as the lowest common denominator in your group and the more people you have the more chance you have of the lowest common denominator so yeah it's you know 60 to 80 minutes here where it says on the back that is way too small a time frame and trust me this game goes on for longer than 80 minutes when you got six players going it just takes too long for people to hurry up and finish their turns so this one I found that you know it scales well in the sense that you have a similar experience but then bear in mind you're only caring about maybe a player to the side of you every now and again in this game for the most part you're doing your own thing so there's not really any player interaction in it so why do I need to play it with more players and I suppose that's the key word actually interaction you know if you're going to add more players to a game is there a reason to add more

players does the interaction increase emony yes it does an area control game probably yes it does Daybreak there is no point adding extra players in that at all more on that in the review you know um you know other things uh forbidden Stars I mean you could play at two player but you want a slugfest with four really don't you new Angeles the underrated uh hidden identity game you could play it with four but let's face it you're trying to play it with six five minimum you know so you want that extra interaction in there and you know it's another thing to be critical of um yeah Thro is starting to go right an hour and 20 I think I'm going to wrap it up at that point you know there were other ones I could maybe go over like uh decision space and a few other ones I hadn't written down but you know by all means you know you can put your thoughts in the comments about some ones that I didn't consider but hopefully I was answering the question you were asking for because it was a little bit weird trying to understand analytical about games but this is kind of like my thinking space you know these are various characteristics of a game that when I play a game when I review a game these are the thoughts that are kind of going around in my head so if you're designing the game maybe this will help you think more about all right well I want to do this but should I how does it compare to this you know do other people like it I mean you're supposed to get these things play tested so you should already be getting some feedback but some people will literally just play a game and go oh it's a new game I like it yay new stuff yay jingle keys in front of them you know there are there are

some people that are that bad like you could literally just shove a nice shiny box in front of them and they'll be like oh yeah love it love it love it love it give me give me you know and it's just really annoying when I see that me I'm generally quite a critical person anyway you know I am somewhat of opinionated I do like to get my opinion out but that's just the personality trait but I'm also after playing lots of games after doing this sort of thing on a Blog I'm naturally becoming more more critical about games and so you know some Publishers like that I mean if they get a really good review out of me then they know they've had to jump over a few more hurdles to achieve that as opposed to giving it to a channel that literally gives good reviews for everything they get in front of them in which case does it really mean anything if they give you a good review it's like IGN you know does it really make any sense if IGN give a good review about anything because frankly they give a good rating to just about anything unless it's a very popular thing in which case IGN like to give a very negative review just to be clickbaity yeah you know they they had problems with the Deadpool and Wolverine movie look okay it's not for everybody if for crying out loud it was good fun wasn't it so yeah just stuff like that but yeah hopefully that was a interesting one for you so by all means enjoyed that was a long episode 99 who knows what I'm going to do for 99 we shall see but I might have a couple of extra game reviews to do on that one like maybe I could get drafting right records and clink from Rebel Studio could possibly get those reviewed for that episode that would be quite cool

and of course the patreons gave me a bunch of topics so I'll pick another one out of there but uh thank you uh to patreons for coming up with these ideas they certainly are helping and it will make uh episode 100 pretty cool as well for now I'm going to sign off so take care everybody enjoy the rest of your weekend and remember regardless of whether you are as opinionated and critical of games as I am it really doesn't matter if you are or not you know everybody thinks in different ways it's still at the end of the day only a game so let's not get too worked up about it okay even though I suppose for me that sounds slightly hypocritical who knows but I'm just trying to end it bye for now take care everybody

Progress saved