Skip to main content
Loading video...

SKARA BRAE vs. EZRA AND NEHEMIAH | This or That...The Kims Are at It Again!

Transcript 6:34

Scarab. Ezra and Nehemiah. Scarab. Ezra and Nehemiah. Scarre Ezra and Nehemiah. Well, look at all the shades of brown in my box cover. Well, there's a red shawl on that guy. Which one? Oh, the one with the beard. Okay, I see him. But look at the cool hunter on the cover of my box. Let's settle this once and for all. Yeah, luts. In Scarab, players gather resources and shelter the settlers of Neolithic northern Scotland. In Ezra and Nehemiah, players rebuild the walls and temple for the returning exiles of ancient Jerusalem. Sounds like your game is set in the ancient world. Yours, too. How cool. And my game is designed by Shem Phillips. So is mine. Well, co-designed by Shem Phillips and SJ Macdonald. This is so uncanny. Well, players had to manage their resources wisely to provide for their community and to survive the elements in Scarabra.

In Ezra and Nehemiah, players play cards to maximize each turn, sending out workers to rebuild the city of Jerusalem. Tell me more about the mechanics in your game. Okay. On a player's turn, they play one character card from their hand to their player board. Then they take one of three main actions. Sounds pretty straightforward. Oh, but the fun comes in with how the player uses that card and the existing cards in their tableau. The actions are associated with the color banners they choose to select. Gray, red, or blue. Oh, now we're talking. And the number of banners of their selected color showing in their three card spots equals the power of their player action. Whoa. And I bet they all align with parts of the game board. You bet. Gray banners are for clearing rubble and for constructing the city walls and gates. Red banners are for working on the temple and keeping the altar burning. And blue banners are for teaching the Torah and traveling to those camped in tents outside the city walls. I'm beginning to see how complicated your game can get with the chaining, tech tracks, and hand management. Don't even get me started on the auxiliary actions. So, what's your game like? On a player's turn, they select and resolve a card of their choosing from the open display. Then they place and resolve workers. Okay, a nice worker allocation game. Sweet. It's more than that. But yes, your village will grow over time and players get a new worker each round. Very cool. But I

bet you have to feed those people, right? You always have to feed your people. Yes. If settler cards don't have a roof card to shelter in by the end of a round, they must be fed one food each. Otherwise, they leave your village. Okay, I'm on board. Resource management, open drafting, and chaining all sound fun to me. You better believe it. It's a fine balance. So, what makes your game cool? I think the best feature of Ezra and Nehemiah is that players play six cards in each round, but the final three are played on top of the previous three. So, you begin covering up your previously played cards and banners. No way. I bet it's tough to decide. Well, that's not the whole of it. At the end of a round, players will select one of those six cards they played to tuck for a permanent banner and scoring opportunity, but it comes out of their deck, right? You bet. What's your favorite part of Scarabra? Probably the turn order. Players discs are stacked on one another with the topmost acting first. You can choose to pass or play.

By playing early in the turn, you get to draft your card first, but you also become bottom of the stack for the next turn. So, you're sacrificing initiative in the next turn for a strong opportunity in this turn. Interesting trade-off. And another feature I like is that players can begin placing their workers after selecting their card and not waiting for other players to pick their card first. And that really speeds things up a bit. almost like simultaneous play at that point. What if any drawbacks do you see with your game? Honestly, with a 40page rule book and a 3.84 out of five complexity rating on board gamegeeek, this is a heavy game. There are a lot of rules to get straight and complex connections among all three locations on the board. So, in other words, analysis paralysis. Yes, but each of the three colors provides a variety of decisions on top of the initial decision of which banner color you want to activate on your turn. Give me an example. Well, if a player wants to activate their red banners, they can place their Levites, which are workers from their pool, andor place resources in either the temple or the altar.

Players position on the altar track too breaks ties. And that's just for the red banners, huh? Yep. What about your game can be challenging? I think the order in which you place your workers for each turn is important as it can chain to new opportunities. Nice, but also timing is key. And players have to manage their resource board. If they get too many resources, they have to move their slider to the right and gain more miden, which just clogs up their board and are negative points at the end of the game. Wo, that's wild. But I bet there's a location on each player's board to clean that out, right? You got it. And not only can you clean miden from your resource board, you can also move your slider back to the left to prevent from getting more miden and losing more points at the end of the game. Okay, I think I got it hardly. But I think you've just scratched the surface of your game, too. Exactly. However, I will recommend Ezra Renomaya to players who want a juicy, highly interactive game.

There is a lot of competition for desired wall and gate locations, pecking order on the alter track, and valuable scrolls. And in Scarre, you never know who's going to win until the end. Do your best to collect a variety of settlers, progress your furnish, and trade tracks, and select roof, utensil, and stone ball cards. So, if you are up for a 2hour game experience for 1 to four players, play Ezra and Nehemiah. And if you want a 1-hour game for the same number of players, play Scarab. Way to go, Shem. And SJ McDonald. Double header for next game night. How much time do you have?

Progress saved