Beyond Solitaire Podcast 186: Emily Knox on Book Banning
Transcript
it's adbreak time I'm proud to announce that the Beyond soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations at this very moment great lauring Albright's keep the faith is crowdfunding on backer kit it's a light RPG about the evolution of a new religion and I'm working on the curriculum guide for it so you already know I think it's great so keep an eye out for it I will also mention that if you want to support this podcast please visit patreon.com onol and help me keep the lights on but for now let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson for be on soliter and this week of the Pod I have a very special guest uh this is Dr Emily Knox she's a professor in the school of information Sciences at the University of Illinois or Bish champagne uh and uh we are talking about something very different today because normally this is a board game podcast but I have invited uh Emily on to talk about book Banning in 21st century America uh which is a book that she uh had previous had previously published is now revising um in the middle of the political climate we're in so how you doing Em I'm okay how are you oh I think okay is probably about as good as it gets right now um but uh I guess I I guess I want to start with um tell us about your book uh why why was book Banning the the topic that Drew you to write about an academic um register yeah so my mom was a high school librarian and we always observed band books week I went to grad school a lot um and I also got my degree
in library information science and worked as a theological librarian for five years uh but when I decided to get my my doctorate I knew I wanted to study uh people why do people ban books so that's always been of interest to me and um this book actually just came out of my dissertation and uh I recently have been working on the second edition of it excellent um so one thing I thought was particularly interesting about your approach is that I mean obviously you were a librarian your mom was also you know in in in liaries and so you know you made an effort to really talk to and listen to people who were Banning books which is something that I'm assuming you do not personally support so um I guess I kind of want to start there like what were you hoping that your book would do and how did you get yourself to a place where you could gather the information to to write it so what I was trying to think about was what are the rational reasons for trying to ban books like what what is the point um first of all it's something that doesn't make a lot of sense if you think about it there are lots of ways to get books so like saying your book can't be in a school or library is kind of weird right because like you can get the book other places you can get it illegally like there just
all sorts of ways to get a book so what's the point of saying you can't read this book um also uh reading is really important to me and so I try to think about it well if reading is important to me it must be important to other people and so why is reading important in our society and how do we think about it so I kind of pulled in all these other ideas um I was a religious Studies major in undergrad and uh grad school the first time so I really tried to pull together a lot of different um theoretical foundations for thinking about books and reading uh and I looked at it from a negative point of view not a positive point of view what does it mean to censor books and reading that's that's really interesting okay there's several things I want to come back to from this but I want to start I guess all the way back at the the beginning of this answer with uh I think a lot of people talk about maybe using the fact that you can get books anywhere to justify Banning them in libraries so like oh well if you wanted your kid to read it you could just go buy it so we're not really Banning anything um but as far as I understand it is still considered a book ban so where do librarians at a professional level fall on this and what does it actually mean to ban a book I think people have a lot of misconceptions about what it means so the best way to think about book Banning is actually to think about
restricting access to a book so when you think about censorship which is kind of a pejorative word right you no one wants to be a sensor uh what I really try to focus on is have you limited access to this text in some way and I describe this using what I call the four RS and those RS are redaction restriction relocation and removal so I can go through those pretty slowly so redaction is when you mark through something so you say like there's like a bad word in a book and so you'll Sharpie through it so that people can't read that word or there's a picture and so you draw a leaf over the naked person you know that kind of thing that's redaction uh restriction um is you really have to think about who is the intended audience for this particular work and we are going to say yes you're the intended audience but you can't just get it instead you have to ask someone for it right you have to go through this process or your parents have to fill out a permission slip for you to read it even though you're the intended audience for the book um relocation means that uh okay the intended audience is supposed to be for example juveniles it's a chapter
book but we're putting in the adult section because we don't think it's appropriate for juveniles or we're putting it in something called like a parenting section so that really only adults are supposed to be here but you know we understand this is a picture book but we want to make sure that you know only adults can get at it removal is what most people call bands but it has its own nuances because you have to think about am I removing it from the public Library collection am I moving it removing it from the school curriculum am I removing it from a summer reading list am I removing it from the school library these all have um different levels of restriction and actually have are different requests removing something from a curriculum really means like I don't think this should be part of the education system um you know I don't want to any child to be required to read this book because I don't think this is good pedagogy or something like that removing something of a public library is more saying I disagree with this book I think that you know my taxpayers should not go to anybody else being able to read this book I think it's filth you know these are slightly different um with those requests so those are redaction restriction relocation and removal interesting okay so many flavors
of book ban uh and then I also want to ask I mean I uh my my degrees one of them is in religious studies as well and so I wanted to know um so did did your past as a theological librarian specifically um dovetail with your interest in band books um or do you I mean do you think that having dealt with sensitive material in religious context has like given you a particular kind of insight into how this plays out at other levels of Library curation yeah so actually I explain that in a couple different ways so um my study in religious studies was completely secular I studied uh Christianity and I studied evangelicalism and fism in America so that's really where a lot of this comes in um as a theological library and I actually worked at the general Theological Seminary of the Episcopal church so it was a very left-wing uh in institution um I was actually there when um Jean Robinson who was the first gay Bishop in the uh Episcopal Church in the United States um was confirmed as Bishop um and one thing that we did was we collected everything about lgbtqia books um and the Episcopal Church didn't matter what point of view it was from anything that was published went on our
shelves and um I realized like that was what we were meant to do with our collection development policy right which is to make sure that we had the cultural record for this momentous event that was happening in the history of the church and um not worry about did I agree with what this person was writing that did not matter right because what matters is that in 50 years you can go back and see um why this actually led to a breakup of of the Episcopal church and why it was such a momentous occasion and Jee Robinson was actually one of our alums and uh the people against him were actually our alums also so it was an interesting time to be there so my religious studies really comes in when I think about things like the history of Christianity and um the idea that we are our understanding of reading is descended from the idea that we're people of the book um and how we think about the fact that reading a book can save your soul and I talk quite a bit about that in my in my book and um some of the doctrines that came to us through the uh Reformation they've now been
secularized but they still show up in how we talk about the practice of reading yeah actually one of my favorite discussions in your book um was your discussion of Common Sense reading and how that influences opinions about books and their appropriateness um so for people who are not familiar with this I think that common sense I guess guess theology viewpoints um has really impacted the way that we argue about education curriculum and what we read but also so many people don't really understand what it is so could you maybe give us just like a an overview that kind of leads to why it's so relevant now yeah so this really comes from Scottish Common Sense philosophy so it actually is a full idea that comes into uh um uh philosophy uh in I think the late um 18th century and eventually came to the United States it's actually much more foundational in the United States than it is in other parts of the world um when the Declaration of Independence says we hold these truths to be self-evident this is actually truly a basis in Scottish common sense of philosophy which is taught at places like Harvard College um to all the guys who signed the Declaration of
Independence um what it is in its most basic sense is that things mean what they say and say what they mean you can get very complicated with the actual Scottish competence philosophy which has to do with like moral sentiments and all those things um but the easiest way to think about it is if I read a text and it says that this person used drugs then it can't mean anything else like that's what it means uh you have this idea that there is only one possible interpretation of the text and in many ways it's my interpretation because what Scottish Common Sense philosophy talked about was like we're all moral agents we have this ability to interpret um and if I read something then that is what it is um I was actually talking to my students yesterday about the book gender queer which is a graphic Memoir um it has some very interesting pictures and uh you know what people do is they say look at this picture this picture has to be pornography like how could it be anything else um not realizing that other people might look at the picture and be like oh that's kind of interesting uh you know Maya is showing
something I haven't seen before also it's a picture of a failed sexual encounter this is how Maya realize that he is uh asexual you know like it's got this all these other things when I look at it um but when you have a common sense interpretation of text that becomes impossible and you can hear it when people say things like you know this particular book is harmful it makes students embarrassed or like this is often comes up when you talk about um things like uh diverse books or critical race Theory as it's called um not realizing that other people might have other interpretations of these texts interesting and then I this maybe actually will lead into some of how you got your interviews but I mean why is it bad for someone to be embarrassed because of something they read like to me that seems even more far-fetched than being upset like oh it's porn um which is you know I I think that's very debatable about most books that are in any context where a kid would get a hold of them but um you know why is embarrassment something that makes a book worthy of being banned so I talk about this quite a b bit and it's actually the problem is not the kids are embarrassed the problem is the parents are embarrassed and so uh what Carrie H Robinson talks about is
that these this is difficult knowledge this is knowledge that uh we as adults have trouble discussing in our own lives much less with children so if you are someone who has just never thought about what it means to be uh asexual or something like that how do you explain that to your 13-year-old kid right maybe you don't feel prepared to do that or uh one of my other favorites is um in Tennessee they attempted to get rid of um the book My Life by Ruby Bridges Ruby Bridges talking about desegregating schools and they talk talk about things like the pictures of white people being very angry at this cute little black girl trying to walk in to the school and you realize that it's actually not about the kids at all it's that there are white parents who don't know how to explain to their white children what happened during segregation and why there are all these angry right people yelling at this little girl so embarrassment is actually extremely important for people who are trying to ban books because it's actually like they feel their own embarrassment about it um it's not so
much that the kids are embarrassed um it's really much more I'm not prepared to be able to talk about this um I don't I think it's immoral to talk about this that's another issue that comes up um and I absolutely do not want to talk to my kid about it so we just don't talk about it at all very that is that is just fasinating to me okay so um the way that you got your research for this book you are a very brave person because you had to really like go and talk to people to like get this done and ask for interviews so I guess my my first question is how did you get into the habit of like going to local meetings about book bands and then how do you find them um because that sounds like something you were doing and perhaps still do a lot let me just say it's completely different now than it was uh 10 years ago so I just wrote this in my new edition of my book uh when I first started this research I would like I I had um Google Alerts come to me that said that like this book was challenged and then I would start a new alert for that book and the place and then I would follow and see okay is a hearing coming okay I need to get out to that hearing if I'm POS able to do that um I would request I would do Freedom of
Information Act requests and get the documents for it it was actually very quick difficult to get to the hearings um because you would find out about them a week before they happened and I wouldn't be able to travel um but I actually had a lot of luck getting the documents um most places will send you documents um I actually have done other research on how documents are sent the actually the smaller places the more likely they are to send you documents because they are less likely to have a lawyer who won't send them to you so recently though post pandemic this has become extremely difficult um so I have a fire hose of Google Alerts coming to me now um I actually don't have to go to as many hearings because almost all of them are streamed so it's very easy to find uh transcripts online uh so many places moved to just putting things on YouTube it's pretty easy to find uh board meeting um what I am not able to get anymore is interviews and um this is because I'm also more well known in these circles than I was before and also because
journalists have started writing about this more I often will write someone say you know uh my institutional review board you know we will says like approves my research would you talk to me and they often say no I said everything I needed to to some journalist and I'm like okay so I was not able to get additional interviews for this second edition which I'm really disappointed about but I also give a lot of talks all over the country and often there are people at my talks who disagree with me and so I end up talking to them uh after I give my little talk and seeing what they have to say UNT I cannot include that in my research because they have not signed the consent form but it does help inform um my analysis of of the arguments that they use all right so I definitely want to talk about like updates to the book but first so when you were doing interviews I'm really interested by this so okay you know I I didn't I think people who don't do research that involves human input from Outsiders realize you know a consent form your research is overseen so what is the process for actually getting a legitimate interview you can use and then also um I guess how do you get somebody to open up knowing and I'm sure they know that y'all don't agree with each other oh so I did have to go through my
institutional review board they review like whether or not I'm doing legitimate research they look at my consent form um when I actually well it's actually pretty difficult so what I would do is email someone uh because it's actually not too hard to find people's emails or I would snail mail letter let send them a letter um and include my business card in it so they can tell that I'm Legit as possible um sometimes they would get back to me and they would say I'm absolutely not talking to you or they would say I'm only going to talk to you if you agree that a minor is this Webster's definition of a minor and I would say sure and then they still wouldn't talk to me when I would finally get people to actually talk to me I found that one of the easiest things to do is let them set up how they want to talk to you so it was usually over the phone and I would ask them if they would run and record and I would never start by talking about book Banning I would start by talking about books and reading and what is the book that changed your life what is their favorite book did they like to go to the library so I would do a lot of um questions to build rapport um also most people like to talk
about themselves so once you would say well tell me about the challenge a lot of them would be like I have all these things to say about the challenge and how awful those Librarians were were you know who didn't pay any attention to me or how great they were uh to listen to what I had to say um so really it's just about listening like active listening to the person and hearing them um and then that that was basically it it it was really trying to because I was really trying to see how people felt about books not necessarily this particular book that was kind of secondary um and uh people are often willing to talk about books of all sorts and then why this book was so jarring to them when they liked books so much usually that's a really interesting point because I think a lot of people who are angry about book Banning and like I know I've had this sort of uncharitable thought right are be like oh they just they haven't even read it they're looking at one quote that makes them mad screw these people you know like you get really upset but one thing I really appreciated about your work was that you wanted to bring out I guess how much people who want to ban books usually appreciate them so I guess um
how do you how do you balance like I I do think a lot of people want to ban books because they've seen like the one page where the interesting thing was happening um but also there's like a certain respect for books uh you know you were most of the people you talk to readers um you know how did how does that tend to play out so it's actually both it's not always that people are readers in the sense that like they are book what I call book people like the people in Goodreads um what they have is a lot of respect for books and the publishing process so so they have this idea that books should be true and Truth should be in books so the reason why you sometimes see people not reading the whole book is because they don't want to damage their soul by reading something that is unedifying so what do I mean by that if they put this image or immoral thing into their body through a book then they are are being bad right it's a garbage in garbage out kind of idea on the other hand you have people who read the entire book who are like I got to tell you everything that is terrible with this book but what they all have in common is
that books are incredibly important um why would an author write trash and why would a publish or publish trash books should never ever have trash in them because they are books and this is even true of people who don't read I I hope that this is like clear you know when we think about like the print culture that we live in that books themselves as objects are incredibly important and revered by people yeah I mean I think you can see it in even things like books to gram you know you get a whole lot of like oh that celebrity got caught posing with the book people got very excited about uh a football player on the sidelines of reading a book recently um yeah there's definitely you know the entire dark Academia Trend there is something a little bit sexy about like being a person who is really into books even if you're not actually doing the the book part um so like I would say that probably makes sense no the reading of books is sometimes secondary for all of those Trends so I I'm interested in book people in in general and especially the trend of buying special edition books of course of especially of Romany books you know with sprayed edges and all of these things those aren't about really reading
the books at all like those are just about having pretty books on your shelf which has always been true right this is since books and Guttenberg started printing books people didn't read all those books they put them on the shelves so that they could show how wealthy they are books have a cultural capital of their own um that continues to this day so this also leads me to the question of okay if we're worried about consuming things that aren't edifying I you know I so until very recently I was a high school teacher and so I know what y'all's kids are talking about I know what they're watching on Tik Tok what they're seeing in the movies and on TV uh and in video games so you know especially now that libraries carry board games they carry video games they carry movies what makes um what makes Banning a book particularly special and are we seeing Trends to ban other things that could be on loan to match it or no so I really need to think about this a little bit more clearly but I think the reason you don't see as many bands of movies video games and other materials is that they have an age label on them that is imposed by the publisher and so people take those as gospel truth so you know if it's rated T for teens then it is T for teens whether and so they use this we
would call it as a heris device to say like okay then I know who can do this can use this um it is possible though because of where we are right now that we will see more and more challenges to other types of media I would not be surprised simply because um we're kind of at a maximalist state uh when it comes to uh challenging and banning things and so people will try to do whatever they can um but those labeling systems make it a little bit more difficult because it's easy to say well this is a rated R movie you're not supposed to watch this and if you're under the age of 17 without a parent anyway you know um of course we know that these labeling systems are arbitrary they're based on you know very socially embedded ideas about um what is good or not good um the MPAA is based on you know a handful of people saying that something is rated R versus PG-13 um would you agree with those standards or not as a parent who knows um these sorts of things you know but it's it's an easy device right I'm not saying that in a bad way I'm just saying that like well you know my kid
is uh seven years old I probably don't watch them than watching a PG-13 movie it's harder to do that with books because you get a general age for the books but um how people interact with books is is quite different than how they act interact with other types of of mediums yeah actually this leads me R to one of the other really interesting sort of aspects of the book that is very religious studies informed um which is the way that you experience a book is somehow perceived as more maybe deep because it is so seemingly private um so I remember reading references you know about monasteries right like oh everybody used to read everything loud and you got to worry about the person who reads silently because who knows what's going on over there um so is this still like I mean it's amazing to see that tradition carrying forward absolutely this is actually where I start a lot of my talks which is to talk about how the monks read in um the refectory someone would read out to everybody and the key there is that someone can interrupt and say and this is how you should think about this and this is what we mean by this and you know where someone is in a book um when we think about reading today you don't even know what someone's reading if they're reading on their Kindle right that that is a completely and you I like that you said seemingly private because it actually isn't that private right uh reading is a
social practice that that we engage in um but it is you uh interacting with this text in ways that other people may not be able to see um reading is a somewhat mysterious practice of how it works you know like what is happening when we engage with text on a page um and their way to really think about this is to think about the graphic narrative because we don't know what to do with these books that have come out so what is a graphic narrative is it literature how do you engage with both the images and text on the page um it's not just like reading a picture book it's a little bit different um but think about you know the way you engage with texts being like read to you on an audio book reading it with your eyes seeing images on a text um these are very difficult things to talk about um but we do feel them strongly um I ask my students you know think about the book that changed your life I don't know what book that is but I'm sure all of you can think of some book that changed your life and what do you mean by that and how how does a book
how is a book able to do that um there's something about how we engage with text that's that's on a somewhat different plane than how we engage with other mediums I don't so if you have thoughts on this I want to hear them which is why I'm bring this up um but I also find it very interesting that I think we're seeing Arizon book bands at the same time as we're seeing a couple of other like interesting Trends so one is the ability to self-publish especially to Kindle um and you know everybody laughs a little bit about having a Kindle unlimited subscription because you know a lot of that is uh Romany let's just go with that it's spicy as it were uh we're seeing a rise in discussion of spicy literature it is and like pride in reading this among uh especially women on book talk and like of course there's also the sub genre of like men who read it and they're like wow I understand my wife so much better um and then we're also seeing sort of paradoxically um you know we talked about reading as like a private activ versus not you know sort of the the sanitization of physical book covers where it's no longer entirely clear who something's being marketed for like I remember we talked a lot in the past year online about hockey romances that looked like you could buy it for a middle schooler but there's some scenes in there so um how are all these Trends do you think uh how are they connected to what I would say is an increasingly aggressive environment around book Banning in
schools this is a great question and you making me realize that I need to look at this and research a little bit more I think what we're seeing based on how you asked that is a re um we're going back to when Pulp Fiction became a thing again the dime store noveles um which people hated you know uh we can read about like people reading this crash that they only cost them a dime at the drugstore um we are going we're seeing that happen again um I really I really need to look at that time period um I'm mostly familiar with it when Comics you know the comics code and that kind of thing came in but the dim store novel that's essentially what we're seeing on things like Kindle and limited and those I actually have my students do a semiotic uh semiotic reading of book covers so they can tell me who the book is for based on the design of the cover and almost all of those things are in intentional right to um there's long been a uh a trend in women's fiction to cover up the spiciness of what is inside so most Library don't collect What They Call Erotica and if you actually go to a
library and look at the romance section there's actually tons of erotica on the Shelf it what they actually mean is they don't collect like really trashy erotica Urban fiction erotica the kind that just gets sold and all sorts of places but if you actually read some of the books the spiciness level is off the charts but you can't tell because there's nothing on the cover to make it look like it may be a little bit spicy um so I think this has a long been a trend in uh what I'll just call women's fiction um that we have seen probably since women's fiction was a thing which is that things are often disguised by the cover and what the true Levolution I just have to say with things like e-readers is that genre fiction just exploded because no one will make fun of you for reading whatever cozy mystery romance with cats that you want to read because they can't see the cover if you're reading um it on Kindle and this has made a huge difference in um people's reading uh how they read and what they read oh man like this is
actually such an interesting topic but I want to bring it back around specifically when we talk about banning you know it's hard to tell like who something's for um it's you know if you have unlimited access to your Kindle or to an e-reader nobody knows what it is you're reading would the one thing I've seen pitched a couple times now is like oh well books should just have a rating system like movies and then it would be fine and you would just know what books you were allow to have is that like something that anybody is seriously considering and like would that ever even work I can't imagine that actually working for books because I feel like as a kid I read all kinds of stuff that first of all did no harm to me I'm a much better person for everything I read but also I think that I don't know feel like books are probably the safest place to be exposed to material that's going to challenge you a little bit and how do you decide like when somebody's Ready or Not for some of those things I think my my question would be does the rating system for uh movies actually work um we act as if it works but I don't know that it actually does um I encourage everyone to watch the movie um the documentary this movie is not yet rated it's um you can get it through canopy I think it's still freely available online um this really looks into the NPA ratings board but some things to know about movie ratings is that they are very very sexist so if for example a woman is shown having sexual pleasure in a movie
it will be much more likely to get an nc7 or rated R rating uh than if a man is having shown having sexual pleasure in a movie um how they rate violence I think is you know inscrutable like how they understand violence because violence is male coded in many ways and so like lots of violence you know they talk about things like blood and that sort of thing but it's very arbitrary you have to realize how arbitrary these ratings are thinking about it with books um I just don't know that it will it will ever work the way people want it to um classification is an imposition on your own interpretation of a text because you're in many ways told this is what this is going to be right this is what this is um and libraries have to do this because it's part of making things accessible as well but I encourage people to think about you know you're still imposing these categories on things and categories are real so if you go to a bookstore um and it has say a black
section right how many nonblack people do you see there how many men do you see in the romance section um these are actually restrictions imposed by the categories themselves and and they are problematic uh Diana goalden who wrote Outlander insists that her book is not a romance and I still go places and I see it in the romance section um and why did she say that because romance is for women and so you when you think about it that way you realize how actually categorization is so tightly in meshed with censorship because what people are actually saying is like this is this type of knowledge this is this type of thing and it is not for these other people um so these are all kind of wrapped up with each other and that's why rating systems are a problem um it's not that people shouldn't know necessarily what they're getting into I don't read horror I feel I'm glad that like you know I can find out something about what horror is but you know is horror the same as a little spooky who's making that decision um I would like to make that decision for myself and I can always put a book down if I want to that is very true um so just
before I ask and then down the next you know V of questions I feel like um we're also having a cultural conversation about things like Trigger or content warnings and how those should be deployed um I actually generally appreciate them because sometimes I don't want to like I mean if I'm looking up a romance novel to read I don't really like romances to have a cheating Trope or a you know love triangle so I actually like knowing a little bit about things going in because I know if I don't want to read it um but do you see changes in I guess content warnings happening and is that at all a solution to the problem or are the same people who um are Banning books also the people who are like well why are there content warnings on things yes they are this is the thing is that these are communication devices I actually have a book that edited on trigger warnings um so the thing about all of these types of warnings and labels is that they are embedded in speech communities and so yes there are certain types of content warnings that are used by um a certain Community online but that does not mean that they translate for other people um my other worry about things like trigger in content warnings is that inevitably uh people who are more margin marginalized will end up with their Works having These Warnings on them we saw that happen in music what gets the
parental ratings hip hop um that's not a mistake it is because people who are marginalized often have more trauma in their lives and people who are less marginalized um so once again this becomes a an issue of power and dominance that always needs to be thought about carefully interesting Okay so we've talked a lot about work that you've done to date we know that you've got another addition of this book coming so the first edition of book Bing in 21st century America was published in 2015 is now 2025 we are on a roller coaster ride in terms of what is considered okay for kids schools woo um so um what is your update looking like so far and what like aspects of your work have you chosen to Target for the most updating that's a great question so what on let me look address this a couple of different ways so one thing I did is I put a new chapter in the book that is about a uh public hearing that I went to in Metropolis Illinois home of War what's largest Superman um statue uh down by Kentucky in Southern Illinois uh if you're ever driving down there I recommend checking it out it's pretty cool um they had a whole thing happen at their library and I was able to go to that hearing so I have a whole chapter on that and it was amazing there was
cussing at the hearing people yelling at each other I know this is sad but that that makes my day like what could be better than people getting excited at a hearing at a library um I also expanded all of my examples so um you know if new things came up I would I would put those in there I talk a bit more about things like diverse books and critical race Theory intersectionality but quite honestly the reasons people give for Banning books have not changed over 500 years um it is pretty much the same books are really important reading can change your life um you know I don't like what this talks about uh how do I make sure that uh my kids don't end up being bad or like not having my values um how can I make sure that my soul will be fine as I go forward um these reasons just have not changed it is really book Banning is about reading it is about reading and books and there only so many reasons you can give for like reading and books so what I actually found was that um people are making very similar arguments sometimes the context is a
little bit different um you know we're seeing more of calling people groomers and pedophiles but these are actually arguments that started in the late 19th century and have come forward again um they are not necessarily new arguments um to be made um so the book is longer and I tried to find you know updated examples and I had way too much to choose from and so I really had to limit what I could look at uh because otherwise I would have been really overwhelmed yeah we mentioned this a bit in this conversation previously but your research methods have also had this change a bit because of all that overwhelm um so it sounds like you have in some ways access to more information you know via streaming uh in some ways less access to information because you can't get interviews anymore how are you sifting um through and deciding what is important because I feel like you might be getting a lot more data than you would have in 2015 oh gosh um so honestly I could not look at all everything I had so I actually have two huge cases so one is at St Tam's public
library in Covington Illinois I mean sorry Covington Louisiana oh that's awful s tames Parish I'm sorry that's Louisiana um I think they had 200 or 300 requests um Samuel's public library in Front Royal Virginia had about that many plus an entire uh non-profit organization that's against them I could only use some of that information I it is still sitting on my uh computer because I I would I actually would could do case studies on these These are fullblown case studies um my advise is working on the MCM County Mouse um Banning that happened in the public schools there um you just have to let things go I actually still have data I haven't used from my dissertation honestly it's just so much um that I just can't worry about it in many ways like this is work work work that could go on forever um I actually also have my former colleague Christine Jenkins I have her box of research from the Satanic panic in the 1980s I have not been able to look through that either whoa yeah
yeah so that sounds cool it is just so much work um and uh I just look with through what I can and I'm looking for exemplars and I can find those pretty quickly um it's pretty clear what someone's going to say uh in about two seconds you know um and sometimes they write very big on the uh actual form so I just transcribe that and put it in the in my uh book and I'm done you know this person is once again talking about um how all these book should be removed and you should never buy another one again so that's that's pretty easy to say all right so you know a lot about this process of book Banning fighting about books and you know what it does in communities if you are a person who really really cares about this issue um how do you get involved in these conversations about book Bannings how do you play a role especially if you're not a parent oh so get a public library card um stay aware of what is happening in your local community so I do encourage people to run for board if you um support uh access to information for all um show up at the board
meetings anything that might happen um read these books so not necessarily the ones that are at the top of the list but the midlist books need support uh encourage your library to buy them give them as gifts for friends um there's so many things to do join organizations like United against book bands that's a national one um actually I'm chair of the board the national col stud censorship I'm a former president of the freedom to read Foundation these are organizations you can join um but the main thing is to be vigilant in your local community because the the phenomenon of Outsiders coming in is a real phenomenon for these and it is not effective what your um mayor your library director the board wants to hear is to say I live right here in town and this is how I feel about this um these are ex hyper local events even though they are going across the country um they really are about what is happening in your own community and just where we are with our
Administration um you know there's not actually not much that a lot of us can do on the federal level you know get in touch with your um Congress people call them that sort of thing but where you actually make a difference um is to get involved locally vote in local vote in local elections um those are coming up this year uh apparently my my town will have a mayor I see signs around I need to learn more about these people support uh League of Women Voters when they do their uh nonpartisan uh debates uh these things are all really important and you can really make a difference by showing up I mean showing up makes a huge you don't even have to say anything but just be there let people know you know I think that my public institutions are good and that we should support them and the people who work in them fantastic I feel like a good place to leave off this series interview but I will ask you my softy questions that I always ask at the end so normally I ask people about a game they've been playing that they've really been enjoying but I feel like in the spirit of this conversation you can recommend a game too if you want uh but what is a book that you think people listening to this should go and read oh gosh uh just for fun like let me actually let me actually talk about
games first so I I we have play a lot of games um we were just playing descent um which is kind of intense but it is so awesome because you get to build up the uh game board and it is 3D and so um that is really fun um I'm trying not to buy too many board games right now we have lots to play but I actually just bought Star Realms so I am a star rooms completist and I have their new Legacy game and I haven't opened it yet but I probably will soon um I'm a big fan of deck builders in general um so let's see a book that I recommend people read um wow that's such a good question um so it's kind of an old school book I'll I'll recommend an old school book which is um reading becomes a necessity of Life by Gilmore it if you're into academics and thinking about reading uh this is one of the best that I've um read um I'd say like a book um to read
for fun gosh it's so hard hard I'm just going to mention my favorite author who is Tamara Pierce and I'm going to say how much oh yes I love her Toral books and her circle of Magic books um she really got me into fantasy and um I've been reading many more like lighter fantasy and also uh you mentioned people who've been publishing more uh I've been reading a lot of books by um just authors who publish three books a year these cozy Mysteries one is Benedict Brown and another is CJ Archer and um I think I'll leave it there I think I'll leave it there they're trying to go through all the books that I've been reading recently and I've mostly been reading really fun books because it's been so hard um I I like to read to escape and I listen to a lot of audio books um while I'm playing slay the sappire uh on video game so that's one of my favorite things to do before I go to bed oh that's a good combo I got to try that now um and then if people want to follow your work online you know they want to track your work they want to see what you're up to uh where can you be found uh so I'm ejm KNX Kox at on Blue Sky I don't post
much but I probably will start posting more and my website is Emily knox.net so all my information is there if you want to find out more about me perfect Emily thank you so much for coming on I really enjoyed this conversation and I really appreciate getting to have it now a thank you so much this is great all right everybody I can be found anywhere online as Beyond soliter I am terminally online so I will see you somewhere um but until then please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming and reading me