The Old King's Crown VS Arcs - BUY THIS, NOT THAT (board game review)
Transcript
We have been absolutely obsessed for the last month. We've been binging Arcs and The Old King's Crown back to back, night after night until our eyes blurred. And honestly, one of these games is a masterpiece of mechanical design and the other is a masterpiece of illustration. And I am here to tell you they are definitely not the same thing. That is the most polite way I've ever heard you say, "One plays better than it looks and the other looks better than it plays." But you're right. We went into this expecting a Clash of Titans. And what we got was a master class in the difference between agency and chaos. Let's break down exactly why you should buy one and skip the other.
So, just to set the stage, we spent the last few weeks practically living at the gaming table. We're talking about Colew World's retro sci-fi space opera Arcs from Leader Games and the handpainted fantasy epic The Old King's Crown from Eerie Idol Games. We played them at two, three, and four players. We gave them equal table time, and what we found is that these games scale completely differently. This comparison matters because they're constantly being put in the same conversation online like their rivals, but they're solving completely different design problems.
Yeah. And remember when we first unbox the Old King's Crown? We were just staring at the components for 20 minutes. It's gorgeous. It promises this deep thematic struggle for a vacant throne. And then we set up Arcs, which looks like a 1970s sci-fi cartoon with wooden spaceships. It's beige. It's weird. But the minute we started moving pieces, the dynamic flipped. We'd been playing arcs in maybe two hours at four players, whereas our four-player Old King's Crown session, 3 hours of checking abilities and reading tiny text. The box says 90 minutes, but we were laughing by hour two because we were nowhere close to done.
The play time difference is real. Arcs just flows. You play a card, I play a card, bang, bang, bang. Decisions are quick, but The Old King's Crown has these distinctive phases. Spring for bidding, summer for resolution, autumn for engine building. And the pacing is stop and start. Long periods of silent bidding where we're all doing math in our heads, then chaotic resolution, where we're flipping cards and groaning. It felt like two different games. Arcs was a race. There's constant pressure. You have limited hands, limited chapters. The Old King's Crown felt contemplative until combat happened. And the core mechanic is just different. Let me explain how each game actually plays because this is where the real divide opens up.
Right? This is where it gets interesting. In Arcs, the engine is this trick- taking action selection system. You lead a card, say aggression, and that dictates what actions are available to everyone. Then I decide, do I follow you to get more actions? Do I copy you for one action and hope to pivot next turn, or do I pivot to seize initiative and block you from leading next round? In our games, seizing initiative became the most important decision every turn. Remember that game where I kept seizing initiative just to prevent you from scoring those ambition points.
That was brutal. You locked me out for two chapters. I couldn't lead anything. I was stuck copying your cards for one action each turn. But here's the thing. I could see it coming. I looked at my hand before the round started, saw I didn't have the high aggression cards, and had to make a tactical choice to pivot and set myself up for the next round. It felt like my failure, my hand management issue. Contrast that with the Old King's Crown. The core is simultaneous blind bidding. We bid on the great road for kingdom cards, then place unit cards face down into three regions. It sounds cool until you actually play it. In our four-player game, I put down my eight strength knight with a supporter token backing it up. I did the math. I counted what I'd seen people play. Thought I'd won that Highlands region. Then you played a three strength assassin. Your assassin's ability triggered before we counted strength and destroyed all my cards above five. My knight died before we even tallied points. I made the strategically correct play based on all available information, but lost to a rock, paper, scissors interaction I couldn't possibly predict because your card was face down the whole time. That feeling of powerlessness haunted me for the rest of the night.
To be fair, seeing your face was absolutely worth it. But you're right, it felt less like I outsmarted you and more like I just played the hard counter to your play. The resolution is basically fancy war. We reveal, check abilities, trigger, count numbers. A lot of overhead for what amounts to my number was bigger or my ability canceled yours. In Arcs, the complexity is in the card decision itself. You're thinking before you play. In Old King's Crown, it's just resolving the chaos afterwards. And the card dice in Arcs, that's another huge differentiator. Arcs uses buckets of dice, skirmish, assault, and raid. The attacker chooses which dice to roll. When I attacked your fleet in that round, I rolled three assault dice. I got two hits, but also a recoil face. I chose to take that recoil damage to my own ships to destroy your starport because it was worth the sacrifice. I managed the risk. In Old King's Crown, combat is just flip and prey. You place cards, they resolve, maybe abilities do weird things, and you hope. Which brings me to victory conditions. In Arcs, we have ambitions. Players actually declare what scores points each round. Remember that game where you were building cities, getting ready to score that tyrant ambition for one point per city?
You'd basically already won that scoring. Then I played a high card and declared warlord instead. Suddenly, everyone was destroying ships instead of building infrastructure. I changed the entire win condition. That level of agency doesn't exist in Old King's Crown. You just get points for winning clashes. Every turn scores the same way. Clashes are always valuable.
That ambition pivot was huge for me. It makes arcs feel like we're writing the story together. Old King's Crown felt like executing a script that the game wrote for us. And let's talk complexity because both games made our brains hurt, but in very different ways. Our first Arks game took 45 minutes to teach. The vocabulary is heavy. tax, secure, influence, they mean specific things. And the cards, we spent half the game looking up keywords. It's classic leader games. You have to learn a new language, but once you speak it, everything clicks.
True. We argued for 5 minutes about whether loyal Marines gave you a bonus per ship in your fleets or total. Had to check the rule book. But here's the thing. By game three, it clicked. The iconography made sense. All the keywords started meaning something. With the Old King's Crown, the complexity comes from visual noise. The art is stunning, but reading card text from across the table, impossible. Every card is unique, so you can't memorize abilities. You have to read everything every time. In our games, I constantly asked, "What does that card do again?" In Arcs, the player aids are fantastic, the best we've seen all year. Everything you need on one double-sided sheet. In Old King's Crown, the central board is pretty, but it doesn't explain the weird ability you just played. The mental overhead stayed high even after several games. And that's crucial when scaling player count. We played both at 2, three, and four. The four player experience was where the biggest gap appeared.
Four-player Old King's Crown was absolute chaos. 12 cards face down across three regions. Zero way to track what anyone was doing. I played hoping to win the Highlands. Then player three played an ability that moved my card to the plateau. Then player four played an ability that cancelled the entire region scoring. Totally random. The game just happened to me rather than me playing it. It loses all strategic tightness at four. But arcs at four players, it absolutely sings. More people fighting for initiative means it moves around the table constantly. The seven and one cards enter the deck at four players, adding swing moments. I loved our four player arc sessions. We were constantly pivoting strategy. Old King's Crown was decent at two players, though. I actually enjoyed two-player Old King's Crown. With just you, I could track your cards. I knew you'd played your 10 strength leader already in an earlier region, so I played my nine with confidence. It felt like a duel, but arcs at two players. Zero some knife fight. Brutal. But thank God for the mulligan rule. In our two-player game, I opened with huge aggression cards. You had nothing to match it. Without the mulligan, where you can discard and redraw, that game would have ended in 10 minutes with me dominating. It's a necessary patch that shows the game is a bit fragile at two without it. If you want pure two-player games, Old King's Crown feels more stable out of the box.
But Arcs at 4 is where the magic happens. Now, let's talk strategic depth because there's so much strategy behind the punch in ARCs. In our sessions, ARCs is fundamentally about managing scarcity. You never have enough actions, never enough resources. You're constantly making impossible choices. So, strategy is pure efficiency and planning ahead. I won one game not because I won the most battles or had the strongest fleet, but because I built a guild card engine that scored passive points while you were killing each other in space. The depth comes from card play. Knowing when to intentionally lose a trick to save a high card for later. That's sophisticated stuff. It's like bridge but with spaceships.
And that's the key difference in strategic depth. In Old King's Crown, strategy is front-loaded entirely. You do all your thinking during spring bidding, trying to build a kingdom card engine, but it's totally dependent on RNG. I was running a Briggin strategy to steal cards and gain points from theft. I needed specific kingdom cards to appear on the Great Road. They didn't come out for three rounds. My strategy was completely dead. I was just waiting for the right cards that never appeared. In Arcs, the guild row is always face up. You see what's coming. You plan accordingly. If something you need isn't showing up, you can adapt. The RNG in Old King's Crown drove me absolutely crazy. And the attrition system on top of it, if you shuffle your discard pile because you ran out of cards, you permanently lose hand size, one point. I got unlucky with draws, had to shuffle early, and spent the rest of the game with one fewer card than everyone else. It's rich get richer without any fun payoff. Arcs has outrage, which punishes aggression, but you can mitigate it and plan for it. It feels calculated, not arbitrary. The difference is meaningful.
Okay, but we have to talk about the one area where Old King's Crown destroys arcs completely. It's not even close.
The pretty pictures.
It's not just pictures. It's the vibe. When Old King's Crown was on the table, people literally stopped talking. The map is sprawling watercolor. Every single card is unique art. The nobility faction looks like decaying velvet clad aristocrats. The uprising faction looks muddy and desperate. It creates an atmosphere of a dying gilded kingdom. Arcs looks fine, functional, beige. Nobody gasped at the board. Sure, the art is monkrade labor, but it comes at a readability cost. After round one, I ignored the art because I was squinting to read the text and table presence. Old King's Crown sprawls everywhere for a game that's basically blind bidding. Arcs is compact. Components are built for play, not for a gallery.
No soul. But the usability is better. There's one thing Old King's Crown has that Arcs doesn't. A solid solo mode. The Simulacrim bot looked surprisingly robust. It's fantastic. The bot uses priority based bidding that feels human. If it has kingdoms favor, it prioritizes high-v value cards. In solo sessions, it felt like a real puzzle. Arcs needs the expansion for solo capability. So, if you're a solo gamer, Old King's Crown wins by default. Fair point, but let's circle back to interaction style. In Arcs, interaction felt purposeful. I attacked you to score Warlord points. Business, not personal. Old King's Crown interaction felt spiteful or random. You stole that Herald card, which crippled my entire turn. In Arcs, I could mitigate attacks or at least see why they happened. The outrage mechanic costs you for aggression. In Old King's Crown, being a jerk is just optimal play. There's no cost.
Yeah. And that affects fun factor significantly. For me, fun and arcs came from table talk. Don't attack me, attack him. If you pivot, you hand the game to him. The game created a social puzzle above the table. Old King's Crown was quieter. We stared at hands, calculating numbers. Fun was the reveal. Aha. But those moments were fleeting. Arcs kept energy up for two straight hours. And replayability is completely different. Arcs with just leaders and lore felt infinitely replayable. We played five games and saw maybe 10% of setups. That's before Blighted Reach expansion. Old King's Crown. After five games, I'd seen the loop. The factions, the kingdom cards, asymmetry takes a while to emerge. The core war mechanic doesn't change. Arcs forces different plays every time based on your hand and the ambitions people declare. It's a deeper well. So, let's talk value. Arcs is 60 bucks. Old King's Crown is 80. Is the extra $20 worth it for art alone?
Unless you're framing cards on the wall and displaying them. No. Arks at 60 feels like a steal for the amount of game and replayability. The components, the tightness of the design, the expansion path. Old King's Crown feels like a premium product, sure, but mechanically it feels like an $80 version of a $20 card game underneath all that beautiful paint.
Look at you. $80 war. That's harsh, but I can't argue with it based on our experience. So, here's the bottom line. Who should this be for?
Firm. If you're a solo gamer or you play strictly at two players and you want something gorgeous and meditative, maybe Old King's Crown is for you. It's not a bad game, it's just fragile. It breaks at higher player counts. But for the right person who values solo play and loves the aesthetic, vibes are immaculate. But for everyone else, buy Arcs. Buy it if you want agency and control. Buy it if you want a game that rewards skill and planning. Based on our weeks of playing both backto-back, Arks isn't just the better game, it's the overall better experience. It's the one we kept wanting to set up immediately after finishing the last game.
The not that scenario is crucial here. Do not buy The Old King's Crown if you hate chaos and unpredictability. Not if you want to feel in control of your destiny. Definitely not if you play primarily with four players. Do not buy arcs if you can't handle direct conflict. If you get upset when someone blows up your spaceship, stick to Eurogame. But if you can lean into conflict, it's magnificent.
Look at you. Final verdict from our couch. I'm keeping Arcs. It's the one staying on the shelf to be played regularly. Old King's Crown is beautiful, but I might keep it just to look at occasionally.
Same. Arcs is the winner. It's messy, it's mean, and it's brilliant. Old King's Crown is a beautiful tragedy. Beautiful to look at, but a bit heartbreaking to actually play.
Beautiful tragedy. Look at you getting poetic. Thanks for hanging with us while we dissected these two games. Hopefully, we saved you 80 bucks or cost you 60.
We're Board Game Critique, helping you spend your money on the right cardboard. We'll see you in the next