Cthulhu Death May Die: 2026 Revisit and a Look at Season 4 (review)
Transcript
Hey folks, welcome back to the dungeon dive. Daniel here. I hope you're doing well and if you're not, I hope you are soon. Okay, today on the channel, a quick overview, kind of a re-evaluation of Cthulhu Death May Die. I recently purchased season 4 at retail and so that made me excited to get it back to the table and it has been a while since I've played the game. So with this game with uh Cthulhu Death May Die I have the base game, I have season 2 and I have season 4. I never bought season 3 and with these three sets I feel like I have more than enough Cthulhu Death May Die. probably won't ever buy anything else unless unless of course they just happen to hear my pleas and release uh stande versions for all of the games. I would sell this in a heartbeat and reby the game with standees rather than these uh giant minis. I mean, the minis are pretty cool in this game. I can't argue against that. They look awesome, but I would love a stande version because then I could fit everything that I have into a single box. The minis take up so much space in the boxes, and the boxes are huge. I would love this game a lot more if it was if if the all the sets were in boxes the size of like Eldrich Horror or or Arkham Horror. Um, I will also say that, you know, I'm not a mini guy, but I love these cultist minis. I think these cultist minis are really, really
cool. I think they look great. They feel nice. I like the red color. It's super cool. So, uh, we'll take a a closer look at the stuff you get in season 4, but before we get to that, I just wanted to briefly talk about some things that I love about Cthulhu Death May Die. So, in season 4, you'll get, I think it's six new episodes, and the last one I played here was the Pyramid of Fear. So, this is episode five. You don't have to play them in order. It's not an ongoing story or anything. Each episode is a standalone game. It's not a campaign. And that's something that I really do appreciate. And I thought this uh particular scenario, this particular episode was really cool. It's right up my alley. It's kind of It does remind me of Secrets of the Lost Tomb in a way because you are exploring this pyramid, this kind of lost tomb. You're looking for treasures. You are looking to to assemble the staff of raw with these three different pieces. And uh that's one of the ways that you can like disrupt the ritual that's going on. And so the old one that I am playing against is Narthoep. And Narthoep came with season 4. So, I wanted to experience uh some of the episodes with the included great old one and not use any of the others that I had. I also have a couple of expansion old ones, but I can't remember which ones I have. So, Naroteep
of course has two phases or or two different kind of avatars, two different aspects. We have the human form and the human form starts on the map and then when the ritual is complete, it goes into its really nasty form. Now, one thing you won't see set up on my table and it's something that I never use, it's this uh giant playmat. And season 4 comes with this kind of additional playmat because one of the things that season 4 adds is this idea of an unknown monster. Basically, you can introduce one or two new enemy groups to your games and it makes the game a little bit more difficult. But to offset that, we have some special relics that the investigators can start with.
But I never ever use these two playmats because they take up so much space. They're entirely not needed. I try to play games on my small table and there is no way that I can set the game up and have this out on the table. So, I just keep my enemy cards cuz basically that playmat is just a place to lay out your enemy cards. And so, I just keep them stacked up on the side and it takes up hardly any room at all. And when you need to reference one, you can just pick it up and look at it. So, it's much much easier. And then for my uh my stages for the uh final boss, I just keep them stacked up and put to the side as well. Now, one of the things that Playmat does have is this kind of tracker. And the great old one is being summoned by the being summoned by not summoned, summoned by the cultists, and it is ticking up on this tracker. But there are 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 eight spots on this tracker. So, I just take the little summoning circle and I use a D8. And when that D8 ticks up to eight, then the great old one has been summoned. And then as it ticks back down to one, then your time has run out.
So I just kind of keep that off to the side as well. It saves a ton of of table space. And I just don't really like all of that stuff kind of spled out all over the table. To me, it just doesn't look appealing and it doesn't really serve any s uh purpose. So this episode here, Pyramid of Fear, it says, "There are many pyramids in Egypt built in ancient times and some few are constructed at top confluences of mystic power. Such a one is perfect for a cult's most de demonic ritual. Yet, this place is said to house the staff of Raw. Could its light triumph over the darkness? So, in uh this scenario, you are exploring this pyramid. And what's really cool about this scenario is it does really feel like a dungeon crawl. You are moving through these corridors and there are these various uh what are these called?
These are exploration exploration tokens that are put out on the map and as an action you can reveal an exploration token and it will be one of three different things. It might be a treasure, it might be a trap or it might be a component of the staff of raw. Now what's really cool about this is when you draw a trap, you have a stack of trap tokens and you get to draw one of those and something bad might happen. You might catch fire or there might be um activate your insanity because each of the investigators will have a random insanity that they have to deal with. You might take a wound from the trap. You might lose an item or a companion. Uh you might uh summon a cultist in your space. Uh discard a treasure if you can't take two stress. Summon a sand dweller in your space or take two stress. So I love having to deal with these traps. I think it's really cool.
And then sometimes you might find a treasure. And if you find a treasure, you get to draw one of these treasure tokens. And the treasure tokens are all good. These are all things that you can use to make the game a little easier for yourself once you have found one. Once per turn, as a free action, heal two stress or at the end of your turn, deal three wounds to any enemy in your space. But again, one of them might also be the uh the staff shaft. And so if you find that, if you explore whatever room that's in, you can get the shaft. And it's all randomized. Uh, one of the other components you need is the jewel that sits on top of the head. And that is put off just off camera here on this altar. And so you can go and you can take that to have one of the components that you need. However, by the end of the game, you also need to discard one of your items at that altar in order to place this bag of sand on it, or else it might trigger a trap at the end of the game. very uh Raiders of the Lost Arc Indiana Jones uh style there. And then we also have the head of the staff. And the head of the staff, you have to go up into this room up to the north of the pyramid. And there's this little kind of memory puzzle that you have to figure out. You have to reveal these in number order. One, two to one, two, and three.
And once you solve that little puzzle, then you can get that third piece of the staff. And that is one of the main ways or that is the main way to disrupt the ritual so that the uh great old one can come onto the board in a weakened form and you can fight them. In this scenario, you are playing against the sand dwellers and the white pulpus thing. And the cultist for narotep or the enemies that come with narotep are the cultist and the moon beast. So, all of the great old ones have a cultist, but sometimes they have a little bit uh more going on depending on who the great old one is. But here are the moon beasts. And then here is the uh pulpus thing, the white pulpus thing. And then we have uh the who who else was the sand dwellers. So here are the sand dwellers. They're kind of cool.
These kind of like monkey gray alien looking things. And then as part of the addition to season four, you have these unknown monsters. And so I chose to play as the man of Lang. So there are a number of different unknown monsters that you can play against. And that's just basically adding an additional enemy group to your games. So you can play with one or two. I found that playing with one is where I like and so I am just playing with one there. Now, because we have these new unknown monsters, you will also get a couple of new uh mythos cards that will activate the unknown monsters. And there are two different groups. So, if you're playing with the other group, you will add in uh these two cards. So, each of the unknown monster factions, each each of the groups will have two mythos cards that will activate them. And so for those of you who know, at the end of each investigator turn, the player draws a mythos card and then they do what it says usually summoning monsters or uh using one or bringing one of these summoning symbols in. And when there are three summoning symbols in the discard pile, that's when you would take up your tracker. Whether you're using a D8 like I am or you are using that tracker on the player board on the big uh display board to keep track of the of the ritual to offset the added difficulty of the uh unknown monsters. The players will have
access to these powerful relics. And these relics are double-sided and they will get more powerful as the game goes on. And so you will have a wooden pipe, a handheld magnifier, an old rosary, a viola, a ritual dagger, and a glowing ring. And so these will give you some additional ways to deal with that added threat of having more monsters. So that's just kind of a brief overview of this scenario of the game. Um, it's a really fun game. Cthulu Death May Die is really fun. And here are a few reasons why I think it's a pretty good game. So, uh, the the the main one is I love the setup of this game. Not the setup of setting up the components, but I love the the way that the game is presented.
And it always feels like you're coming into the final act of a exciting, thrilling story or movie. You know, all of the boring stuff has been taken care of. All of the slow burn has been taken care of. All of the investigation, all of the mystery has been taken care of in acts one and two. And you are entering this game in on act three where the crap is hitting the fan and you only have a little bit of time to stop the cultist to disrupt their ritual before they summon the great old one. And it really does feel like it's in media res where you are hitting the ground running. You are just starting right where the final big action set piece is taking place. And that's something that I really love.
I also love the uh episode system, the kind of modular nature of combining an episode and a great old one together to create your scenario. It makes for a ton of variety. I think the episodes, even though they only come with a few components that are special, that are unique to each episode, each episode does feel different and they play different. Uh you have a couple of different uh actions that you can take in each episode that aren't represented in other episodes. Uh the way to disrupt the ritual is a little different. The setting is different. Uh one of the other scenarios, the first episode I played in season 4 takes place on a zeppelin and you're having to rescue passengers. And so they do a really good job of just giving you just enough of the components to make each episode feel different. And that's especially true how you when you can combine it with a different great old one. It really does make for a lot of variety. And that's kind of why I feel like I really don't need any more Cthulhu Death May Die. I have enough variety to satisfy me for a really really long time. Now, the other thing I really love is at the character level. I think the characters are super fun. So, you'll get, I think, six new investigators in season 4. We'll take a look at it after I talk about the game in general. But um I was playing uh this last two scenarios I was playing with two of the new investig uh investigators, Rosario and Sylvia.
Sylvia is an ex cultist. I always love an ex cultist. Each investigator will have a unique skill and then they share a skill from a pool of skills and so you will have different skills such as brawling, arcane mastery, marksman, and toughness. And these can be leveled up. But what I love about the leveling up system in Cthulhu Death May die is that it's all based on your sanity. And this kind of goes along with my point one of you starting this game and the heat of the action in act three when it is like it is make or break. It is do or die. And so these investigators are pushing themselves to the extreme and they're just running in guns blazing. And they have to do this thing uh or else the world is going to end and they have to do this thing come hell or high water.
You know they are their backs are up against it. And as they take more sanity they become stronger. They get more enraged and they give into their more base instincts and they become deadlier. But if they push it too far and you level up too much you die. And that's one of the ways that you can uh lose the game. if one of your investigators dies before the ritual is complete before the final battle. So, I just love that kind of give give and take, that kind of tug-of-awward between leveling up your character, kind of pushing your luck, but not wanting to get, you know, if you get too powerful, you are just a a a a you know, a breath away from death because you have pushed your investigator too far. I think that's great. It kind of has this built-in timer, but I think the timer works because of the nature of the game.
Because you are dealing with just this final act of the game, and you only have or this final act of a story, and you only have, you know, a couple of hours to get this done. I think it's great. So, that's kind of this built-in timer and sanity system. And then another thing that I absolutely love about this game is the discovery deck. And each episode has its own uh discovery deck. And the discovery deck is such a great a great kind of implementation of multi-use cards. And so I think there's 13 discovery cards in each scenario. And these will be little events, sometimes stat tests, sometimes uh requirements that you have to meet.
And then depending on how you meet that requirement or how you fail at meeting that requirement or how you succeed or fail on your uh dice rolls, you can get certain items. So you can find items, you can find treasures, you can become cursed, you can uh gain a companion that can help you. And it's just a really good system. You know, this could be I could see other games splitting this these cards, these 13 cards up into three different decks, but they did such a good job of combining these kind of three various these three varied elements into a single card. And, you know, they didn't have to cram too much text on it. They're easy to read. It would be nice to have a little more art.
I think that's kind of the compromise they took u on this approach is uh each of the cards doesn't have unique art like you might find for all of the various items and companions and things in Arkham Horror or Elder. But, you know, I'm okay with that compromise because just how time and space saving this three use card system is. I really, really do like this. And I like that each of the discovery decks is custom for each scenario, for each episode, because it really does feel like the things you are discovering are part of the episode that you are playing. I think that is great. And the final thing that I like about this game is the dice pool system. I love a good dice pool system. And so in this game, whenever you take a test, you're rolling the three basic black dice. They are d6 with the exclamation points being a success. The elder signs, those are kind of a wild and depending on if you have some kind of power or a unique ability or an item, you might be able to trigger something if you roll one of those. And then if you roll one of the tentacles, then for each tentacle you roll, you take a point of sanity.
But again, sanity is good and bad. It pushes you closer to that endgame where you will lose, but it also powers up your character. Just great. And then we also have these bonus dice. And as your character levels up or as they get more abilities or more items, then they will be able to add bonus dice to their uh pool. And the bonus dice are great because all they have are elder signs and successes. There are no tentacles. So, it's always good to roll one of these uh green dice. But yeah, there's a lot going for this game. It's super fun. It's very fast-paced. I I really do love the game up until that final confrontation up until the great old one is summoned. The uh the the ritual is complete and then it just kind of devolves into this big dice fest where you're trying to kill the old one and they have a ton of health, you know. But that's the that's a the same kind of um criticism I have about the final confrontation in Arkham Horror or Elder Horror. It's just it's really hard to make this kind of big epic confrontation in a board game that tries to keep things simple and streamlined. It's hard to make that exciting. You know, one way you could do that is if you, you know, you would have to go full-on kind of like Kingdom Death Monsters style confrontation to make something really engaging and really exciting. And that would just add a lot of mechanisms, a
lot of components, and a lot of things that a lot of rules that you would have to learn. And so, I get it. There's kind of a balancing act here. So, it's fine. It doesn't ruin the game for me, but it, you know, it's just it's never as exciting. the the final confrontation is never as exciting as I would want it to be. Now, one thing I did want to mention real quick about the episodes is when I think about these, I I kind of think back to the old days of Fantasy Flight and with Runebound and with how they used to sell those small little booster box expansions for Runebound Second Edition. And how cool would it be if Cool Minion or Not had, you know, these booster boxes, these boxes of different episodes that you could uh just go into a game store and buy one for like 10 bucks or something. That would be amazing because, you know, these aren't really you don't you need the minis, of course. So, you would have to know, okay, so this set needs these minis or this set this episode is compatible with, you know, seasons one, two, and three or three and four. But then you could just buy a whole new little uh episode, a little scenario without having to buy a whole new box. And I would love that. I would love the return of small expansions like this because I love those runebound expansions.
But uh let's briefly take a look at some of the stuff you will get in season 4. So, like I said, the main two differences are these unknown monsters, and so that adds a little bit of difficulty, but then we also have these unknown relics. And so, that kind of balances it out. And you can play with one group of unknown monsters or two. Uh, unknown, they're known to you. It's not like a mystery of who you're fighting because you can choose which monsters you want to bring in. And let me find my unknown monster deck. So, you have the opportunity to bring in these additional monsters. You can bring in the man of Ling, the sand dweller, the monstrous frog, the albino penguin, the spider of lang, the white pulpus thing, and the ancient one. And so, you can add those monster groups. As far as new investigators go, we have the two that we've taken a look at, and that is Sylvia and Rosario. And then we also have four more. So yeah, you you'll get six investigators with season 4. We have Bruno, Gary, Anakah, and John. And of course, each one of them has a little a little story on the back if you want to read a little bit about the investigator, the new investigator. Uh we come with an additional little mat that you put to the side of the board of the uh original mat, making it very very big on a small table. Uh, this is where
you will keep track of either your one unknown monster or your two unknown monsters if you're not doing what I do and just stack them up to save table space. And I guess the one nice thing about this additional board is it does have a little uh a little turn uh track there to keep track of your turns. Uh, all of the tiles so far, what I've noticed on the two scenarios I've played is these scenarios only use the new tiles in season 4. So, I haven't yet had to combine any tiles from any previous seasons. I don't know if that's true for everything. I hope it would be because, you know, they don't know uh what scenarios you or what seasons you have, but we get a whole bunch of new tiles. So, we have all of these set up. These are all double-sided. And then you get all of these, which are double double-sided. So, you do get a number of different uh different environments to to play in. I'm not a huge fan of the tiles. I'm kind of getting tired of tiles in games. I just prefer boards.
Um, you know, if they had if this game came with two double-sided boards, so you would have four different environments, and then they could write the episodes, the scenarios just around those four environments. And then it would make setup so much faster because you could just take the board out, unfold it, and then have your map already set up. I personally would appreciate that. I'm just a little tired of tiles, especially tiles that don't have any kind of puzzle uh connections because they just like slide around a lot. But that's just me. Uh, you also get four new Insanities. And there aren't any markings that I can tell on the face, so it's hard to know which comes from which set, but luckily for us, the uh the new ones have a little bit of a different color background. And so, uh, these sanities, as your investigator becomes more insane and they hit these thresholds, then you have to trigger your investigator's um, insanity. And these can make for some crazy things going on. They can be a lot of fun. We have a shared psychosis, dissociative identity, uh hyperactivity, and uncontrollable fear. So those are the new um insanities that you will get.
And then here is the rest of the box. So we have six new episodes, of course. Let's take those out real quick. So, we have uh let's see we have episode six, four, three, two, and one. So, one, this is the other one that I have played so far. Horror in the Sky. And this takes place on a Zeppelin where you have to rescue these passengers. That was pretty fun. Uh where is episode two here? Let's see. Episode three. Episode two is a kind of an outdoor location, the haunted garden. And so, there is episode two. Episode three is the fields of hell. Uh no arthotype has a lot to do with fire. So there's a lot of fire in these episodes. Episode five we took a look at already. That's that one that we have set up. Then we have Death on the Nile. So that one takes place kind of on a boat, I would assume. I haven't played it yet. And then the window into the infinite.
So those are the different episodes that you will get. You will get your minis for all of your investigators. You will get some of the new monster minis. I think the spiders of Lang look really cool. Those guys are awesome. I like the the minis are really high quality. So, I mean, sure, people that love minis just love it. So, I'm not complaining about them. Just I would prefer without them because this box right here is everything for Nolarth. And it just takes up so so much space in this box. I could easily consolidate all of the stuff I have for Cthulhu Death May Die into a single box if it wasn't for the minis. And that's just what I prefer cuz again I have a small table, I have a small room and I don't have a lot of shelf space. And this game with the stuff that I have takes up a lot of shelf space and you know that will come into consideration when I have to uh call some things from the collection.
Shelf space is one of the first things that I think about. You know, does this game warrant a whole cubby plus some in a in a shelf? And I'm not sure. you know, I don't know if I love it that much, but it's it's a really good game. But, you know, the smaller the box, the more compact, the less wasted space. You know, that is just something that I have to consider giving the situation that I live in. I mean, it's not a bad situation, don't get me wrong. It's just a small hobby room, but yeah. So, I was really excited to get season 4. I have no idea what season 3 is. I didn't even know they'd put out a season 3. I was surprised to see season 4. I've kind of been out of the loop on cool mini or not just because I prefer the not part of the minis, but this game, this expansion did get me excited. I'm glad I bought it. I've liked the two scenarios that I've played. I'm looking forward to playing more, but I think my my days of buying Cthulhu Death May Die stuff are are over. And that's fine. You know, I have a for me, I have a complete game. I have enough. And I am going to work to consolidate this stuff down. Probably get rid of some of the inserts. Probably just bag up some of the minis. Or if I get really inventive, if I get really um you know uh inspired, maybe I'll make my own little coin capsule standies for all of the miniatures. And I think that would be pretty cool. But all right.
Well, I hope you enjoyed taking this look at season 4 of Cthulhu Death May Die. We will talk to you later. Bye-bye.