Windmill Valley: Blooming Sails ►►► How does design superstar Dani Garcia improve upon perfection?
Transcript
Hey everybody, the following is an excerpt from the monthly Roto Roundup, and if you'd like to see the rest of the Roundup, you can hit that eye up in the top right corner of the screen, or if you'd like to know more about the game, you can follow link down the show notes. And with that out of the way, let's talk about Windmill Valley: The Blooming Sales Expansion. Which, as you can see on screen, I have done a run-through of it with my wife Jen as an exclusive for backers of the show on Patreon or here on YouTube as a member um as a special exclusive to them to help keep Roto running. Thank you, everybody. Hope you enjoyed the run-through. But let me just tell everybody. Now, you can go back and watch my original Windmill Valley run-through to get an idea of why the game is already great. Um you know, I think it's phenomenal. I think it is designer Danny Garcia's masterpiece.
[sighs and gasps]
Oh, although man, his Coming of Age gives it a run for its money, but I'm still going to say it's my favorite of all of Danny Garcia's games. So, and it is a game where we are running uh windmills in the Netherlands trying to control water levels to get the best yield of tulips, to do all kinds of things, to plant them and grow them ourselves in our tulip fields, or to sell them overseas, or to go to market and just about or to or to invest and build more windmills. Uh you know, and there's lots of different ways to score. It's a brilliant game, and the crux of it is every player has their own little double gear board straight out of Zolk'n the Mayan calendar that you are constantly spinning and creating combos of actions off of one wheel with another and upgrading that, and it's great. It's a phenomenal design. So, why then would you want to get the expansion? Well, it's interesting. Of all the different things you can do in the game, this expansion really only focuses on uh changing one of the elements of the game. And it's the one that I guess players were least entranced by. I mean, you know, it it's the simplest one. It is the shipping tulips overseas. Because in the base game, without this expansion, you know, planting tulips is a is a complex logistical puzzle to solve.
Building more um windmills, and you know, um you know, leveraging the market is a very interactive element where you're piggybacking off of what other players do to become more powerful and getting huge, super powerful turns out of it. I guess people, just generally speaking, aren't excited about the hey, you can also send your tulips overseas and get a couple of actions, or it's an alternate way to get some more tulips into your personal supply. That's what sending overseas used to be, but no longer. That the that action is now as big and robust if uh if maybe arguably more big and robust than all the other actions because uh Blooming Sales adds a whole new board with eight, if I recall, maybe it was eight or 10 different ports of call. And when I choose the action to uh ship tulips overseas, I still get to do that action. That action hasn't gone away. But in addition to all the regular stuff you get to do, you can now take an extra tulip, put it on your own personal ship, and sail that ship to deliver to different ports, which will give you other benefits and bonuses. And uh you know, every time you set up the game, this side board with all the different ports, some of them are you know, just kind of variations of the stuff you already get. Other ones are kind of completely new powers that never existed in the base game. Um but you're trying to, you know, spread throughout the game, there are all kinds of ways you can get bonus actions to move your ship from port to port. Because hey, I've got an extra red tulip, and I want to get
over to that port to sell it cuz I want that particular bonus. Cuz that bonus, for example, will let me have a fourth contract. Normally, you can only have three contracts. Now, you can have four if you get a red tulip over there before somebody else beats you to it. Because uh there are only a certain number of spots in all these different ports to deliver these tulips. And if they get filled up, well, you're going to get frozen out of those bonus actions you can do. Um and so, it adds this whole extra, you know, a a whole extra level of gameplay that again, I would say is kind of comparable to the level of complexity of the windmill building. I mean, this game was called Windmill Valley. Now it could be called Ship Valley. Uh because it feels like the game is as much about the ships as it is about the windmills as it is about the tulips. And it's cool. It is a very, very fun extra level of it definitely makes the game crunchier. It gives you more stuff you can do with your tulips.
And um unlike some of the other expansions I've talked about today, I don't think it introduces, you know, any upsetting or off-throwing, you know, power creep into the game. Because yeah, you get more actions, but you have to spend more to do those actions. So, I do think I I I don't feel like it just, you know, has the potential to shift the balance of power. It just gives you more to play with. And Now, I got to say, did it need it? I don't know, because I never felt like the shipping action was weak. I always felt like that was a very strong action. But again, it's not that it gets stronger, it gets more robust because yes, it does more, but you've got to pay more to do it. So, I do think I I I don't feel like it just, you know, has the potential to shift the balance of power. It just gives you more to play with. And I I think, you know, for people who really love the game, it's it you you in the future, you won't want to play without it.
That said, I think my wife might want because it does it I you know, Windmill Valley just perfectly sits in that nice mid-weight Euro. Putting this into the game gets um Windmill Valley closer to a Lacerda-level depth and complexity. And Jen was saying, I don't know if I needed this extra depth and complexity and more stuff I have to juggle and balance and try to figure out how to best leverage my tulips. She was thinking maybe it made the game a little bit more crunchy than she was looking for because just the base game was about perfect, but I'm not complaining at all. I I love the addition. I think it's great. I wouldn't want to play Windmill Valley without number four of the month, Windmill Valley: The Blooming Sales Expansion. And thanks for watching, folks. If you enjoyed it, please like and subscribe.
It makes a huge difference, believe me. But with that out of the way, if you'd like to see some more over on the left, you can find a playlist of a whole bunch more Roto Rapid Reviews. Up in the top right, there's the latest thing that's been added to the channel. And in the bottom right, you've got something YouTube recommends. Okay, folks. Thanks for watching.