Skip to main content
Loading video...

Designing games that tell stories with Ignacy Trzewiczek

Transcript 1:01:57

what's up my friends and welcome to the board game Design Lab today talking about stories talking about how to design games that tell stories and I'm talking to ignasi Chevy from Portal Games and over the years he has just become a master of Storytelling through theme through mechanism through the overall experience of a game and stories is kind of what he focuses on with his publishing company and so we get into how to do that how to do it effectively how to really draw players in with the overall experience understand in that when people talk about a game they don't talk about it in terms of components they don't say cubes and dice and things like that they talk about it in terms of a story my Army destroy yours or I cross the finish line first or whatever it looks like in the world of the game so if you want your games to tell stories or to just tell better stories I think you'll get a lot out of this episode ignasi welcome to the show Hello thank you for having me hello everybody so excited to have you here been wanting to get you on on the show for so long so glad that it's finally working out really excited just to get your understanding of games that tell stories this is kind of your company's main thing you want to you know put games out into the world that tell interesting stories at the table and so I want to understand better what that means because I feel like a lot of designers have that same kind of idea they have the same mindset or would like to but maybe don't fully understand how to accomplish it so I'm really pumped just to get your thoughts your ideas your design process for games that tell stories but before we get into that who are you how getting game design all that

kind of thing I'm geek I'm a vivid gamer I'm the person who fell in love with games in my high school times I discovered role playing games I became super addicted to role playing games then there was a college I was I was still playing like crazy role playing games and then after four years of college instead instead of graduating and finishing College in the fifth year I said to my parents I have this great idea that I drop out from the college and found a game company and my parents didn't didn't kill me luckily for me they agreed uh that I will take one year break from uh from college and try to start my own company and then after the year we will decide if I go back to college or the company will survive and grow and here I am 20 years later I never get back to the college I never graduated from the college I made my career from gaming so I'm a basically leaving my dream I'm a gamer who became a professional gamer now that's awesome so I assume that was portal games that was started in that moment right correct wow and so helped me understand what got you into game design so I talked to a lot of people and they start in RPGs they start with you know playing Katon and stuff like that and then something flips the switch and they start thinking hey I think I could make some of these too how did that happen for you what made you really want to get into the design of games yes it was very slow and very very

natural process so when if you think about role playing games and they're all about playing scenarios and Adventures if you're are a game master or dungeon master if you are talking about Dungeons and Dragons you are creating stories to run the sessions of course you have to write them down so I was writing game sessions and scenarios for my friends and then at one point I said well I can write them maybe I can write for somebody else so I wrote a couple of more Adventures I sent them to the Polish magazine about playing games they read it and they said this very good this interesting and they published that so after being published outro and being paid outo which was awesome for me back then when I was in college and somebody was paying me for writing Adventures for all playing games it was like a dream side job I started writing more and more and more and basically when I founded Portal Games at the very beginning our goal and our aim was to release a magazine about role playing games in which in this magazine I was writing more adventures and and more articles about role playing games and then naturally when I was working in this company I discovered card games I discovered miniature games I discovered board games and um one after another I started designing them so it was very slow very organic process from just writing Adventures from my gaming group to writing Adventures to be published then to found my own compan and publish my own role playing games and then discovering board games and doing first some small very simple board games that

were like we could Now call them like munkin style games so very stupid party game style games and then I started doing something more sophisticated more complex and today here I am and being designer of quite complex uh game so it it took me 20 years to slowly slowly develop the whole career yeah that's awesome I can't wait to get into the design process for a lot of these different games and how you tell stories through them but real quick one question I have for you so there's a lot of people who listen to this show who want to do something similar to what you've done they want to start their own company they want to go full-time working in the industry what would be your advice to somebody that's thinking about that what are some things that they should be thinking about like what would you tell somebody sitting in that situation you were sitting in you know 20 years ago thinking gosh I want to do something else I want to travel down this game you know publishing route what would you tell them yeah this is a very dangerous question because because I can talk about this about two hours and you will have no other questions yes on one hand it is so difficult today because we all say that and this is unfortunately true the market is so crowded there is so many companies there's so many games really so today to start the company to start publishing games is so much difficult but on the other hand when I was starting 20 years ago it is so difficult for you guys to understand and to remember these times and many of you were kids back then but back then when I was starting company there was no Facebook there was no Snapchat there was no Instagram there was no social media there was no Board Game Geek there was no internet

whatsoever my first year of the company we had no internet in the office so to check email I had to visit my friend who had you know this modem and I was checking emails in my company once a week so we were talking about them very very long time ago so then back then promote the game and promote the company and make a business was so much harder than today when you can just open super simple web side you can promote your product on Broad game key you can go to the kickstarter and get Crown founded project so on one hand it is so much more difficult today because the market is really crowded and you have to stand out on the other hand you have all these tools that you can run company from your home just using internet which is a blessing for everybody as for my advice for the people who want to go into the industry when I run seminars for the young designers and I I always start with this very simple uh sentence decide if you want to be game designer or if you want to be part of the industry because so many people who L the industry and want to be part of this amazing uh family think that if they want to be part of the industry they have to be designer this is so not true we as industry we are looking for people who know marketing we are looking for people who are very good with logistic so we can ship all these games in time to our warehouses we are looking for accountants because yes we do invoicing and we do stuff with the money we are looking for the coders to do our websites we are looking for all these

different jobs and being a game designer is just one of a dozen of careers that you can make to be part of the industry so I always say at these seminars for the designers ask yourself a question are you a designer do you want to be a designer or you want to be part of the industry because there are two different things I am as you will see later in this interview I guess I I became uh designer quite accidentally just designing different games but my most important part of the job is being Market marketing person I run marketing department at protal games offices I prepare all these campaigns for for building the hype and bus for my games and I could be easily hired by Simon or asmodi in a marketing department and I would not need to design games and still I would enjoy my time in the industry so uh I would say be aware of your skills be aware of your talent and U be aware of what you want to achieve in life yeah and you bring up some really really good points you know I hear people say it all the time some you just said the Market's so crowded and so I don't even I feel like I don't even have a chance I might as well not even worry about it but no matter when you're talking about it's always been difficult for one reason or another in 10 years from now it's going to be difficult for maybe a totally different reason than it is now and so it it kind of brings me back to an old proverb I heard it said the best time to plant a tree was 20 years ago the second best time is now and so like go ahead and start if you think you know you're want to get into it somehow and like you're saying it doesn't even have to be

publishing and starting your own company or Corporation or LLC or something like that there are so many different jobs in the industry that can kind of be a a a stepping stone into maybe something down the road maybe if you want to be a full-time designer down the road we start in marketing start off in logistics start off in the warehouse of a fulfillment center just shipping out games and being part of the industry uh in some way and I think that's really really good advice I think also maybe working at a booth for a publisher now would you also suggest people kind of get in that way and start volunteering and working with with companies like Portal Games and others here is a real life example this last B Con in Dallas we had a volunteer who was uh at our booth presenting our games uh helping us promote the brand and basically being this awesome volunteer this month he's going to be hired by portal games as a full-time employee so yes these things happen like you have to make a first step you have to uh let us being aware about you about your talent about what you can bring what is your value that you can add to the company and once again I know that this is this podcast the whole the whole podcast is about game design but if you're talking about the your careers you can be amazing sales person you can be amazing logistic person you can be awesome awesome video editor we need all of you we don't need only game designers yeah absolutely all right well let's get into the topic at hand let's talk about games that tell

stories now this is your your main thing with your companies we want to make games that tell stories but give me a good working definition what do you mean by games that tell stories it's uh very simple for me I'm not because I'm not native speaker so I'm not sure if I will be able to elaborate enough clear but let let me try it if you finish the game after you finish the game uh I want you to be able to say something more than just I want having 85 points so now real life example if you played Robinson crzo after finishing the game whatever you lose or won you will say oh my God we were just fighting with the Tigers we just build this amazing shelter but then there was a rain and the whole shelter was destroyed and we were looking for the for the wood to build this these new staff and weapons but we were not succeeding and oh my God so many things happened and then we lost uh so B gam that tell stories in my opinion is that the game that you are playing and after the game you have to say something more that happened during the game than just you had this amazing combo that brought you 25 points yeah for sure you know if you listen to people talking about games they very rarely say hey do you remember that time I moved those five red cubes onto that space and then I roll dice and I beat you eight to seven like no that's not how we talk we talk in storage right moved my five armies you know into your territory and then I just decimated them you know or something like that and so that's a really cool way to do it and so how do you start a design like when you

have it in your head an idea you know something you want to turn into a game you want it to tell a good story tell me about your beginning process for kind of really starting to bring that game to life yeah the the the most epic examples of course are uh Robinson cruzo and first Marsh and detective these are the the most story-driven games I design and for each of these and stronghold and for each of these three or four games the process was quite similar so so we can really base base this thesis on these four titles and it starts with a research like I literally read a ton of novels I'm a bookworm so I love reading so it was not not hard for me and as we are recording I'm sitting in my my room here at my home and in front of me there are this all these books uh that I had when I was doing research for Robison cruzo and in front of me let me just grab here here we have a destination Mars by Rob pile new explorations of the red planet so so I read books for the first Mar I had to to read about the chemistry and physics in English because not all these books were in Polish so it was quite a task for me for Robinson cruzo I read so many books about on one hand surviving on the island on one hand adventure books I read so many comic books of course I watch a ton of movies so I do a ton of research and I basically uh get the get to be confident

with the theme uh reading watching doing like Pinterest tables and and and have some in inspiration from the artwork and it takes me like three four maybe five months very very slowly preparing preparing to to start design and then when I'm finally feeling very confident with the theme I'm starting making notes and uh these notes for example for Robison kuzo would be like what's important what's crucial for the game to be thematic and called the very very strong thematic about surviving so we want them to explore the island we want them to find something on this island on these different caves and and places we want them to build the tools because this is a very important part of all these movies and all these books that they are trying to create some technology out of nothing we want to have a very harsh weather because in all these movies all these books there's always some rain and storms and cold Knights so I'm making notes what has to be part of this game like it must be in the game and then I'm taking each of these crucial parts and I'm trying to design small small rules how to tell this story so for Robinson Koda it started with of course designing game map we want to explore the island I had a uh Island and then we started moving from this P so how you move on the island how you build the Sher how you build the tools etc etc so it's very slow process

I'm I I have this comfort that I'm not in a rush I can take as much time as I need to design games like this is my you know not my main job my main job is being CE of the company and once a while I design a game so for Rob KO it was all together one year but small small steps and it all started with just picking a theme reading books reading comic books watching movies and then building the whole game very cool all right so you start off right right at the beginning with a whole bunch of theme and experiences in mind and then try to figure out mechanisms and like game rules that kind of support those things do you always do that or do you ever start with mechanisms first I I have I have this very popular game called 50 state that was designed exactly opposite uh it is quite exception from my natural road so with this game I was just driving my car and I got this out of the blue idea for the mechanism I came home I noted it down and a few weeks later the game was ready so but it was like a super accident it was I cannot explain that it just happened I was lucky and I came with the game it was ready very very soon but basically basically is a long process of me just discovering like d diing the theme digging the theme and digging the game this is how I create this strong Rich games gotcha now for a game like 51st state you know how how then do you bring the story out when you do start

with a mechanism first because I know a lot of people who listen to this they start mechanism first and so how what would be your advice for how they can insert story insert theme into it yeah with this I with c f State and then the N set the followup game uh for that it's uh it's a ton of artwork it's a ton of some small small rul that somehow feel thematic but being being honest 51st state Al designed by me I would not call it b game that tell stories of course you can add something to that if you raise opponent cars and if you demolish his Empire you will say it was very thematic but no in my opinion 51st state is like much more Stefan Feld right aresia game in my in my CV and Robinson K detective or strong is more ignas chich version of of design so if we start with the mechanism it is much harder in my opinion for me to design a game that tells the story gotcha and I think that's something for designers to to just keep in mind now one thing that it sounds like whenever you get get going on an idea on a game a theme you spend a ton of time reading books and watching movies and researching all these things that's a lot of effort a lot of energy and so what do you do when you get to a point where you realize the game is just not going to work I've had so many people send me emails and say how do you how do you know when to walk away from a game how to put it you know when to put it on the Shelf tell me about your process of

knowing okay let me switch gears let me try to do something else this is just not happening yeah I'm lucky enough that I have I think I have no single uh prototype uh that uh that I failed to finish or maybe some small projects but basically if I started working on a stronghold I was working as long as needed to finish it and again was ready robon CL the same like if I start working on a game I work as long as much as intense as as as needed to finish the project of course I have this luxury of having the development team uh at my company so if I struggle there might be somebody who will help me some sort Solutions but um my my position is a little bit different from Freelancers from freelance designers that um if I design a game that will be published by portal games uh the company needs this game like I cannot say well guys after six months of of Designing I have no clue how to finish it so we will not have a release next year H it will not happen so I treat it very very seriously and I work as as long as I find solution if there's something not working in the game for the freelancer uh designers who just um create games at home and then pitch them to the design to the publishing houses to the companies for them it's maybe a little bit easier to just abandon some of the projects that they are struggling with

and just move on and find a new project and have a new inspiration and move on with the something new for me it's it's hard to abandon project in progress gotcha so does that also make you more selective on the front end like do you have a lot of ideas and then you're really really selective about which ones you're going to pursue knowing that you you can't spend six months on something that's going to be a waste I don't want to disappoint your listeners but maybe we can say maybe I should say the much earlier now it's a 20 minute in the inet interview but uh let's let's say it right now basically I hate designing games and this is not a joke this is not some fun posture h i really find it super difficult it's a long very hard process is very important for my company I happen to have some successes in this field so I continue to design games but basically I don't like the process because as you mentioned it's long H it's frustrating in my opinion so when I decided I will do a game before I even start I have to be super super confident that this is something I want to spend uh this many many months the work and it is something that will be hopefully successful so there is a potential for being a a bestseller like I I don't do design just for fun like I don't do design oh I have this idea for the nice mechanism let's find out what I can do with that this is quite different like I

say hey we see that uh detective games become popular we see that sh com is amazing design let's try to design a new game that uses this Niche because it may become very popular and I have some good ideas how to do it and how to execute this idea and then one year later we have dective the board game already on the market but it was not just me being okay let's find out now it was very important business decision the market the company I need a game like that and let's let's struggle let's work let's let's build it gotcha and that makes a lot of sense actually it reminds me of the old saying about writers that writers don't like to write they like to have written and so I think it's the same thing because you sit down to write a book and it's just this long process and and you feel like you're bleeding all over the keyboard as you're trying to get this story out or whatever it is and so it sounds like you have the same thing let me explain because maybe people will not understand and maybe will misunderstand my message the thing is and if you if we look it at this very very uh in general perspective uh if you design a game that means that you have a prototype of the game and this prototype is not working and your job as designer is to make a amazing game outfit so you are fixing you are changing you're play testing you're asking for feedback from the play testers you're changing again but basically we all understand designing a game is having a prototype that is does not work and trying to as fast as possible that may take few months make this prototype working and being fun and awesome and becoming a great game this

is obvious right so what does it mean that mean that for this few months you have something that doesn't work that frustrat you that piss you off and you will be working every single day day every single weekend struggling trying to fix it and you still play testing and once again it's not working and then you fix one solution so something is working but something else is not working and now play complaining this is a many months of frustration and when you finally finally make it happen and this prototype is fun and awesome and everybody loves it the producer the publisher takes it from you the game goes to publishing and you start over with once again fresh new prototype that sucks and you have to spend all these new months of being frustrated trying to fix it and having these hopes it is awesome but it is not awesome people are complaining it's boring it's not working like basically designing a game is ongoing process of being frustrated this is my perspective uh well I'm complaining I'm from Poland I'm Slavic all people in Poland are complaining so here I am no I think you're just giving the the real side of things I feel like a lot of times especially people who were getting into this at first you know they're just starting out as designer as a designer they're getting into it as a hobby they kind of have the you know the the rainbows and butterflies idea of what game design is and it's not that a lot of times a lot of times it's a lot of a grind and and figuring things out and being super frustrated over and over again I remember reading an interview or hearing interview you did when you were developing cry havoc and you just kept running into it's not it's not better

than kimet it's not better than kimet and over and over and over again just trying to make it better and how much of a a process that was and so what would be your advice when you are being really really selective about which products to pursue how do you how do you figure that out are you looking at the market and kind of where the market's at right now and and looking at different like what what's your process for like I guess you have like little check boxes that you're going through to say okay this is the product we're g to chase after so yeah this is I wrote an article like two weeks ago about this and the article was uh was called I lost my compass and in this article uh I said that for the couple of years uh I was quite precise with uh what I was designing what I had on my developers desk and what actually Market was looking for I was very lucky and I developed the game called tides of Time amazing micro game exactly in the moment when all these micro games and love letter became popular I had my ti of time and everybody was buying this game and enjoying because it was it last year the huge hype for the Rand right games uh spread all over the industry and yet there was game designed by me and it was run right in p sets back then there was this whole whole explosion of detective games two years ago with Chronicles of crime with Detective Los Angeles and with my detective so once again somehow I felt the trend in the industry somehow I knew what people are playing and I came up with the game that

was matching the demand on the market and it is very important for me as as being a CEO of the big company uh the thing is that what I do is uh as I said I'm a gamer I'm VI gamer I'm on Instagram every single day I'm on Twitter every single day I'm on Facebook Facebook groups every single day I listen to podcasts about Bo games and what I am basically one of you so I I feel this strengths I feel what you are playing I know that at this very moment so many people are playing on Mars from V laerta because the game was sent to the buckers and everybody's now about this game I played it as well today so I'm one of you and therefore I try to understand what we gamers are looking in upcoming months what's hot right now and I'm trying to come up with the game and that will we will make us all make us all happy gotcha so you really just find a way to keep your your hand on the pulse of the gaming industry and then you just kind of go with with what people are excited about what they're what they're into that's that's a really good good idea good way to do it you know I've talked to a lot of people who say I hate social media I hate Facebook I hate Instagram I hate Twitter it's like well that's that's fine um but you're going to put yourself at a bit of a disadvantage one in the marketing of things if you're not posting and for people to you know see pictures of your game and things like that but also like you're saying you're not going to have your hand on the pulse to know really what's in what's out what people are excited about what they're not and so that's that's just some really really good advice I want to talk a little bit

more about detective uh it's such an interesting game it's such a game it's a game that's so different from most other games out there and so tell me about the design process for it maybe some challenges you ran into just kind of tell me how it all came to happen yeah the whole game came out from my absolute love and uh huge respect to the old game called Shock Consulting detective released many many years in 80s and then R released by hisory games and then R released by asmodi I absolutely adore this game I respect designers I think it is something exceptional and I have all these sh hommes games at home and then there is this amazing HBO show called True Detective and one evening it just clicked like I love this Sherlock Holmes I love True Detective the the movie and I thought like Sherlock Holmes is amazing experience but if we can move all this setting into the modern times if you can shake things a little bit and the website at some new mechanism you can come with something absolutely new interesting different from Sherlock Holmes but yet giving this superb feeling of of being a a detective and then more than almost two years about two years later the game was ready it's hard to understand and and believe that

there such a simple game there's almost no rules whatsoever and that such a simple game takes so much time to to design but it was a long process uh there was three designers involved and there was a writer who came up the whole plotline the whole story he basically wrote a book there was me doing the whole game basically like gamification all these cards all this FL like everything that is in the box and then there was this third designer who was the editor of the whole game because it is a inves ation game so there's so many facts dates of the birth size of the shoes color of the hair like there's so many facts and if you want to have a great game you have to add so many details and all these details have to match like you cannot make mistakes because people are playing this game are looking for this details so we has three of our and two years adventure and the game was ready I'm very proud of it I think that we we manag to being inspired by con Detective still design brand new Beast brand new game that maybe will inspire other designers and they will come with something else out of it so I'm very proud that on one hand we we gave respect for the for the previous game and the other hand we created something brand new and exciting yeah absolutely and that seems like a game that not only do players walk away from the game with stories but the game itself is telling a story and so tell me

about the process of really figuring out a compelling story like you said you had another designer that was basically writing a book you know for all the different content and things that were in there tell me about maybe some of the challenges with that as far because you want it to be riveting you want it to be interesting but it's going to be more than just how the game plays out it's actually telling you stories and things like that so tell me more about that yeah this is so exactly as you said there is lots of things involved let me start with a uh absolutely honest price uh for the uh writer of the plot uh detective um there is many cases right now because the game was reled two years ago so there's many cases but we if we talking about the base game of detective the one that is on the market for the past two years it is a campaign it is a five scenarios long campaign and it is so tense uh so complex so interesting there's so many different twist and the Liars of the plot it is absolutely brilliant I hire this person pmer because I know him for the more than 20 years this is the guy who was my game master when I was in college when I was before I founded the company we played together call ofu he was the best game master I had in my whole life and out of all these games I played in my life he was the best and he wrote the best Adventures for Call of Kulu and now 20 years later I called him and I said P I need you I'm designing a detective game I'm designing the game about investigation and I need you to write me

a story for this game game and then a few months later he gave me a a a a book basically so for everybody who wonders how it looks like this is about 80 Pages 10 dance dance font uh all the what happened who killed why he killed how he connected to different persons like the whole script it is more or less probably like a script for the movie or TV show so all the facts um motivations of the people etc etc and uh when I had this script it was terrifying it was so big there was so many details and then you have to chop it into the single cases so every case is a one game night so we have to chop it we chop it into into five uh five cases and then if you know if you have this case now you know what what plot it is what who is a murderer what are the uh some proofs what is the way he killed etc etc and then you start designing the whole case so we are plotting into the cards you are putting some Clues on the cards different Clues on different cards and you are building the whole story detective the one thing that makes me mad is the fact that the game of course is spoiler dependent so I cannot talk too much about the the game because I will ruin the whole experience because players need to discover by themselves what happened and what's interesting in this particular cases so I not able to talk too much about these cases and uh they are very different so if you are talking about what were the challenges

the challenges were that on one hand if you want to explain the dective in a few sentences it is a very simple game in which you draw a card you read the flavor text on the card in this flavor text there are hidden Clues and each of the cards give you links or numbers to draw different Cs and you are making a choices because there's so many options for you so many different cars that you can draw and you draw these cards you read the flavor text you get conclusions you get chance to find the clues and then you pick another card and this is basically the card game the each case basic comes with the 30 cards you are able to read about 15 of them based on the rules of the game so this is the game of the choices which cards you want to to read and then if you read these cards you have to find Clues hidden in the text but the challenge here is that these Basics are shaken in every single case because we want to surprise players so all these as I said the general structure of the the game of the cases in each case is completely different and this is something I cannot share this drives me mad because I put so much effort and so much work and so much hard and talent to make them every single case different if you go to the forums game forums you can you can find information that everybody says hey Case three in detective is amazing I cannot say anything but it shakes things like play case free so people are trying you know without being too spoilery talk about them but the basically each case is very very

different in terms of the structure so this is the Big Challenge how to use this very simple mechanism draw a card read the card find the hidden Clues and that's it how to use this basic mechanism and shake things and surprise players so they're excited to play another case because they will find something absolutely new in terms of this small small mechanism yeah absolutely and so then not only do you have a game that tells the story in of itself but then you have to figure out how to translate it into English and other languages and so tell me about that that process of of taking this Rich huge story and translating it and is that something you've also run into with other games and like really time trying to tell a story but then the translation sometimes gets in the way or anything like that we've we've deductive over these two years we builded a whole team of of people so with each expansion with each new case that we are publishing the process is better uh we have bigger team so for example last year here we released case called natural causes which is a free to play so everybody can go to our website download the case and there are print and play material so if everybody everybody's anybody is listening and are interested in dective this is your free-to-play demo natural causes and this case natural causes which is given for everybody on this very planet for free is so much better than some of the cases in the base game because because we learned so much more about the system because I became better

writer and better designer over these two years because I have a bigger team and speak about the team right now we have in the team not only writers who write the thing in Polish not only we have better translators because over this two years and over we we at this point we released I think 15 different cases so we had different translators right now we are working with the absolutely amazing translator but now we have a team in America native speakers who polish the the cases who find the the problems who find the issues and we are talking not about only the grammar issue that what was done in the in the previous cases but right now and they are editing also on in terms of the cultural level in terms of the differences how we perceive things in Poland and how you perceive things in America or different countries so there's so many things that when we send the case to the native speakers and then they have this comments and we discuss how to change some part of the of the case because something works different than I thought or maybe than I knew in in America we we are just releasing this upcoming week another case and there was couple of moments when we had to change the plot of the case and after the native speakers read the case and said hey G it is impossible in America it doesn't work like that H clearly this is a system from from polish it was a thing about the hospital and things are working a little bit different when you're wounded and go to

the hospital in Poland and different in America because the action takes place in America I had to adjust and I had to listen to my native speakers and we had to change the whole part of the plot so now the the team is a huge the the adventure finishes even after I design after I finish designing because after I finish designing it goes to the translation and then there's another weeks of discussion with Native Ed editors and polishing quite the task and detective at this very moment is my main project I'm working designing new cases and uh giving new interesting game nights to our funds so yeah big project uh uh lots of work yeah but like you were saying earlier this is also another opportunity for a way into the industry if you understand multiple languages and you understand how to edit and things like that this might be another way to to have a job in game the gaming industry uh so let's switch gears just a little bit let's talk about Pratt a porter one of your other games this is game's all about fashion fashion design and things like that so tell me about the design process for it and how like what kind of stories you were trying to tell through that game yeah we've dis we've this game is a very interesting uh origin story because the game uh was basically designed for the propose um there was a special project in the National Bank of Poland uh quite the organization who had a additional fund I would call and they were having money to

support different initiatives H that will promote among the young people in Poland the right and the good way of spending money or managing money basically they wanted to educate young people how to manage finances and we knew about this this project um and we send our offer that our idea is to create a board game that we will teach people how to manage finances then the National Bank of Poland accepted our offer they gave us funds they gave us money to design such a game and then suddenly I became a designer of the economy game which is my only so far economy game Heavy economy game in in my in my catalog so that was a inspiration came from the from outside Source I would say from the National Bank of Poland and then after we got accepted we had to create economy game so I used my whole experience about the Running Company that is Portal Games I used the team of fashion because we had this interesting protot about fashion and the designer of this of this protype agreed to use it and I decided I'm going to design a game about running a company in a fashion industry so if you look at the at the at the game it is very very thematic in the way that it basically tells the story of running a company

you're hiring people you're renting a buildings you're signing a contract you're preparing for the trade shows like in the game industry going to genor or going to Asen you have to build them you have to buy materials you have to produce the product like all the things that I do that my company is doing on a regular basis I just put all these actions in game so basically my research was 10 years of experience in the field not fashioned by the by the running a business and uh here we are with the game that is called one of the most thematic Euro games out there and of course it is thematic because it tells the story of running a business the team of the fashion of course is a nice touch is additional flavor and is beautiful if you look at at the board if you look at the components but this game tells a story about running a company gotcha and you like you're saying the new addition especially looks phenomenal now I know for a while you were thinking about retheming it to the video game industry and and kind of going a different direction now tell me a little bit more about that and why ultimately you decided not to do that why you decideed for the new addition just to keep it in the fashion industry so when we released the first edition of prap was year 2010 it was complete disaster and the sales were able we printed 1,000 copies so we we were barely selling it for like two or 3 years it was basically disaster and um and over the years I got so many geek

mails because people contact me on board game geek uh from the customers who bought the game Who Loved the game and were complaining that each time they go to the gaming club or if they go to the game store that have a game night and they put this game on the table everybody body is making love of them that they brought the fashion game and nobody wanted to play with them this game and the gamers prefer fantas team Gamers prefer science fiction team Gamers even prefer angri Cola team and ships and and cows but fashion everybody was laughing so when we started about thinking about the new addition of the game we decided that this theme of fashion is not good for the gamers like most of the gamers back then were male were guys and they wanted axess and guns not the clothes and and skirts so we decided that we would change the theme we were discussing with r famous reviewer who had his background in the video game industry and he's a huge fan of Prapa he he put this game in his top 10 of all time and he said that the video game industry would make a perfect sense for this game and he can help us r theme the game so change the Cs change the the the theme of the game and we started working we actually had a a meeting in Asen there was a brainstorming it was a great time and we

were changing all these cards into the team of video games to reach the audience that is Gamers uh but here we are year 2019 and I'm very happy and very proud to see that the market is changing there is so many uh girls joining the the home there so many women playing the games right now the industry is so much more open if you visit conventions these days like as and like genon like Origins you see so much more families playing the games not only the Geeks like I love Geeks I am a geek as well I also play Dungeons and Dragons but hey geks we need some fresh air we need woman we need the families we need other people in the industry and now I see it's happening there's so many new uh new blood in the industry so we decided let's try to reach this new audience let's try to respect this new blood in the industry and let's try to go with this crazy crazy theme that is a fashion and see what happens and we decided to go to the kickstarter and basically flip the coin like we will see if the feedback will be like this few years ago everybody will making fun of us that we are doing a fashion game or maybe the industry changed and as everybody knows uh probably the kickstarter was stunning success so we had more than 5,000 buckers which for Euro game is like a record super popular lots of price for

the game and we proved our point the industry changed the industry is open for the for woman in gaming I'm very happy that we were one of the companies that proved that so yes uh overall I'm very happy that this one game prapor first edition and prapor Third Edition is a nice interesting symptom signal proof that industry is growing and is open for new people in the industry yeah absolutely and I think this goes back to what we were talking about before you know a lot of people say you know the industry is too crowded it's too noisy yeah but there's so many new amazing people coming in from all different walks of life all different countries all brand new markets are being opened up you know I had a interview recently with a guy from the Middle East and he's you know making games for the Middle Eastern Market and he was talking about how much potential there is out there with so many you know there's billions of people around the world who have not y really accessed games yet men women and you know and so many different amazing cultures and so it's going to be interesting times over the next five ten years to see all these new markets opened up all these amazing new people coming in now let's talk about a game that did get a rethe or at least you know was changed a good bit and that's 51st state kind of being turned into Imperial settlers so tell me a little bit about that process and and what you were like why you why you did that and what you were trying to accomplish so that's a that's a great question I'm happy that I forgot about this game I'm so happy that you're bringing it up so first a small small small funny story

how I came out with this idea for impia sets but then we'll go to the more serious uh serious topic because it's a part of my seminar for young designers so it is very good that you touch the base with that so how it came up it's very simple H I designed 51st state the card game my wife fell in love with this game uh she played with me this game hundreds of time and believe it or not uh we were in the position that I hated this game I couldn't play it anymore and my wife was just play with me again play with me again I love 50 plus St I want to play I was in defense like I was no I don't want to play this game no please I want to play 50 first8 again it was disaster it was quite funny now but back then it was not funny and uh at some point uh there was so much pressure in the house and that my wife told me please change the team of 51st state into more friendly and I will play with my kids because you don't want to play with me so the first prototype of imp setas now we know the game as impas was basically cast for 501 said that I H hand a drone uh done so she can play with my kid so instead of bad mutants there were some Merchants instead of some you know killing people there were some dealing but basically I did a prototype at home so my wife can play with my kids because

I was not able to play any more of f first state so this is a funny this is crazy but it's a true story H after I did this handmade prototype of this fantasy light family oriented version of 51st state H she played with my kids she said it's really working it's very fun kids wanted to play so I took this prototype to the office I showed my my team and said hey guys probably accidentally we have something very interesting this is me of 51st state change into family oriented fantas tee and it works it's fun and we should consider doing it as a real project and of course A year later it it became a thing and became imp so this this crazy hard to believe Story how EPS was made but on a serious note on a on a like advice part of the of the podcast uh there's this old saying which I believe so much in that says ideas are execution is everything so basically what he saying is say is telling is that we all have these great ideas we all have this 1 million idea we all have these great ideas for the games and card games but the key point is not to have the idea because everybody has ideas the key point is to execute to actually do this game to actually execute it and this old saying is very popular everybody heard

it everybody knows it but I believe not everybody understand how true this saying is and 51 St and EPS is a great example so let me explain now I designed 51st state the game was released it got two expansion so it was quite popular I got a few nominations for the hour so this is a quite successful game for for me and for my company we were nominated for international gamer hour we were nominated for the golden geek so it was a good successful uh release and then I got this Imperial Setters game that became worldwide phenomenon was released in 12 different countries won a dozen of awards handled at this point six or seven expansions was sold in thousands thousand of copies worldwide and brought me so much more than 51st state the thing is that these games in general have exactly the same rules like 50 for state and impers have basically the same idea so what I'm saying is that ideas are imp sets had no new single idea it was basically a copy of the 50 First State the difference is the execution because the execution is the key in impas you have the better executed theme because is more family friendly in imp set we have a better component because we use the custom wooden components in imp sets we has much more better artwork because we paid more for the artwork in in set you have a much better rulebook because we knew how to write better rule books back

then as a dresser and I could go on and on and on this example is perfect for all these young designers to understand that we all have ideas and back then I had the idea for 5 first state and became quite successful and then this exactly same idea I used in the Imp cetus I executed better with the better artwork better rle book better components better distribution and I made a worldwide phenomenon worldwide hit that sold 10 times more than 50 First State the same game but execution so this is this serious part of the of the podcast H understand that everybody has ideas and the best designers are these designers who can execute them and make smooth nice perfect prototype yeah that's a really really good point I think it also brings up the fact you should never be afraid to make a big change you know totally change the theme if if it's going to be something that uh fits better into the market and again if you're wanting to do this as a company those are some things you really have to think about it can't just be I want this game because I want it it's like well what do the customers want what does the people in general want do you have any any do you have have any other examples of games that you've either changed the theme you know even behind the scenes like maybe for several months you worked on one thing you're like no let's do something totally different let's drastically change this and you know became something yes you mentioned you mentioned earlier The Cry Havoc The Cry Havoc the pro we received was about the wars in Europe and Napoleon and this kind of stuff so it was basically historical game and we said to designer

of the game Grand roic we said we love the Solutions in the game the Battle Board is something unique exceptional and we love to publish this game but we are not GMT we don't want to make an each game about the wors in Europe we want so many more players to discover this amazing battle board so we want to change the theme and we said this is a perfect game for the Starcraft audience let's make it sci-fi let's make it to fight on the planet let's make aliens like make humans like Marines let's make it fullblown Starcraft experience and then people will discover this game and we were right the game was released in 2016 became absolutely phenomenon we sold back than 15,000 copies in in in few months and we were right and I'm absolutely positive and sure that if we release this game as this historical setting we would sell like 1,000 or 2,000 copies because people think that the war games historical war games are complex difficult not for them and they would not be interested with the Sci-Fi game and the aliens and Marines everyone was interested the game became successful and so many people discovered this amazing amazing piece of mechanism that is a battle board that grand roic designed so I think that he had the guts to trust us uh and he agreed for us to change the theme and we knew the market we knew what we want to achieve with

this game and the game became a success so yes uh you need to think about the market you are designing the game for the market you want that in the end it all is a business you want to earn money you want to sell this game you want this game to be popular so you have to think about the good artwork good theme good rule book like all these pieces together very cool that's that's really interesting to uh to realize that that game was going to be you know old school you know battles and and and ships and and that kind of thing and to see what it became yeah if you can if I can even add more the grand Ric the design of the game he already paid for the artwork so we received the Prototype with the artwork which was insane for him basically to if I can advise don't pay for the artwork if you have prototype and not publisher yet but he was young designer he didn't know that so basically upfront paid for the artwork so we received the Prototype with the amazing illustrations and we said we love prototype we love the battle board but the whole artwork we don't get it we are changing it so that's gotcha well it worked out pretty well let's um let's switch gears a little bit let's talk about play testing tell me about your play testing process and and kind of what you're looking for to make sure that the game is telling a story kind of how the reactions of play testers and things like that tell me about your or the portal games play testing process I'm I'm looking at the at the watch and I see that we have not enough time for me to to talk about the play testing that I have the whole seminar one hour seminar play about play testing

so maybe in a few months we will do another recording of the podcast and we will just talk about the play testing because it is a fascinating topic and we can come back to this in a few months but right now just like a like a small bit like a Ence of the of the seminar play testing is in my opinion a work is a job and the if you want to get the one thing from this interview is to understand that playing the game and play testing the game are compl completely two different things and uh I see when I talk with the designers young designers who come to me and give me some prototypes at conventions for example and they say hey I play tested this prototype 100 times it's it well play tested and then I start talking with them and it basically turns out it was played 100 times not play tested 100 times where's the difference what I mean by saying that playing and play testing is different things when you want to play test a game you have this prototype you have play testers and you have to have on a perfectly if you can do it on a p of paper wrote down written down what is the goal of this particular play test like today we are play testing the economy of these Goods today we are play testing if the track of the round works well today we are play testing if the balance is shaken if I have less units etc etc etc you cannot just sit with

your friends play the game uh drink beer have fun discuss and then forget what happened you you go to play test like you go to work you have the goal of this particle play test you have to understand what you are play testing and after the play test is done after this game session is done you have to have conclusion you have to have the answer for the question that you put on this paper before you started if the question was if the balance is shaken if I have less units after this one hour play test you have to have the strict answer yes or no this is very important for me this is how I play test like there is no play test just for play just for fun just see what happens no no no there I have no time for just see what happens like I when I'm play testing I have a goal so it is very important for the young designers to understand that I don't care if you play test did 100 times uh I'm fine if you play tested it 15 times or 10 times but if this play tested were well done they had a goal they have a aim you had your answers you fixed the Prototype after this play test and you moved on and uh and this is a small bit as I said I have the one whole one hour seminar that I run at at the conventions about play testing because this is so much important this is the most important part of the game design process because the game design means you're play testing and after the play test you're fixing then you're play

testing then you are fixing so basically designing a games is basically play testing and having the right conclusions getting the right conclusions from each play test and this is how you develop games this is how you design games so basically designing mean play testing but play testing doesn't mean playing the game yeah I definitely definitely agree you know play testing you need to be approaching it like a researcher like a scientist and going in with an intentional idea about something you're trying to prove or a hypothesis you're trying to figure out like does this happen or does that happen but you need to be intentional totally agree and I think I speak for all the listeners when I say that you would be more than welcome to come back for another show here sometime soon and we can just discuss play testing in depth I know a lot of people would get a lot out of that winsi this has been phenomenal man do you have any do you have any closing thoughts for somebody who's trying to figure out how to make sure their games are telling stories how to kind of bring themes to life so that stories just kind kind of come to the Forefront and players walk away excited about the EXP that they had what would you tell somebody who's trying to make sure that they're doing that in their game designs I would I would give you the the final tip that I'm I'm using myself and it works nice for me so maybe it can work for you after I play a game I make a note if I play different games like not m games like I'm playing onars I'm playing tapestry I'm playing Arham horror I'm making a note uh what I liked in this game one small sentence and what I dislike in this in in this game game one small sentence so I have the whole

book right now the whole notepad with all these conclusions from the games and then when I design a new game I'm just broing and I see what sucks in the games in my opinion what I didn't like in different games I played and what I loved in the games I played and then I try to learn and be better so on one head as I said at the very beginning I'm a vivid gamer and playing broad games like crazy I love this hobby but then once a while I become professional and after I finish a game I'm just remember to make a note to myself what was awesome about this game what was not awesome about this game and therefore I build my whole encyclopedia my whole one personal uh booklet of good advices about the design awesome well man really appreciate your time really appreciate you coming on the show Good Luck with with all the games that you're working on and everything else you got going on right now thank you sir

Progress saved