Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 27:18

this video is brought to you by the 3-minute board game patrons keep us Independent by supporting us on patreon kioto and welcome to the 3-minute board games awards for 2024 this is a video where I'll run through a whole bunch of games that I really enjoyed over the last year and a few that I really didn't as of all award shows there are some caveats the threein ball games awards has a panel of one that panel is me so these awards are entirely my opinion but that's great cuz every single award show is the opinion of a small group of people and they only have as much power as you give them another thing to note is three minute ball games does not do publisher paid content any games awarded things are awarded them on their Merit from my point of view and not because the publisher paid to be here three m b games is also an independent reviewer which means we don't accept sponsorship from Publishers at all but we also don't push things like honey and bitter help down your throat the way to keep us independent is to support us on patreon or to join our YouTube membership now with all that boring wonk out of the way let's get on to the games of the year the first category of award is for foundation games now Foundation games is a term I use instead of Gateway Games to describe rather simple games that have Rock Solid mechanics in them things that aren't overwhelmingly complex but are still very very good games and the winner of the foundation game award this year is ancient knowledge ancient

knowledge is a cve manipulation game and it acts like you're part of a civilization building monuments but it feels way more like you're an alien species coming along and collecting monuments like their Pokémon what happens in the game though is you have a whole bunch of cards you play down into a row in front of you and over time these cards will slide off the row and gain bonuses when they're removed from your culture and there's so much card interaction and card play and different engines you can build within this game to take advantage of this sliding system it's a game that initially doesn't look like much when you look at it but as soon as you put it on the table and start playing it you see the real depth of decision making that's involved in ancient knowledge honestly the theme is a bit of a mess but the game systems and the gameplay loopin has and the decisions you have to make through the game are all really excellent and that's what makes ancient knowledge my Foundation game of 2024 the next award is for small boox game games that come in small packages that generally have low play times low complexity and are very easy to pick up and play this one's a little on the big side as far as small box games it's castle combo now castle combo is all about drafting cards and building sets the cool gameplay here is you're collecting a 3X3 grid of cards and each card has its own Weare Combos and scores points and it's how you draft these cards and lay them out into your grid to maximize their points that makes castle combo really really really really

engaging immediately rules wise it's a very simple game but as you're playing it you'll be sitting there evaluating each card going oh where can I slot this one in and how can I maximize the points I'll get off it I had a really good time with castle combo recently and it's going to be a proper 3-minute board games review of it coming out shortly so yeah castle combo it's nine card plays each it's drafting it's set collection and it's really really fun this award is for the best game from air2 in New Zealand over the last year and I'm not going to give it out now and that's because my overall game of the year is also going to win this award so we'll keep that to later but just so you know I have this award still I've given it out every year but this year it's the first time it's going to the Grand

winner so for solo game of the year I like to pick a game that is solo focused or at least I feel like is a solo focused game more than it is just another game that has a great solo mode and I have two winners for it this year I'm going to split the prize and that's because of a technicality and that technicality is that I reviewed a game this year that isn't going to be out until next year and that game is the Anarchy now the Anarchy is the sequel to Hadrian's War by Bobby Hill uh published by Garfield games and it takes everything you'd expect from hadrians wall which was to take Rolland right and dial it up to 11 uh the anak dials it up to 15 it just keeps dialing up what I would expect out of a roll and right Style game there is so much happening in the Anarchy but I feel like it has stronger and more meaningful decision points than Hadrian will did it's a really really good game now it's marketed as a group game but honestly it is going to be a solo hit I don't see groups playing this very much I see it very much being uh ing to a solo audience first and foremost and that one's going to hit in 2025 people start playing it there and you'll see it pick up a whole bunch of solo awards from a whole bunch of people because it is so much and I mean that in a complimentary way it's a game that you sit down and you know I'm in for a test I'm in for a challenge I have to learn this game I have to master all the systems and then

I have to figure out you know what to do with it and then I have to play through the campaign and adapt my strategy in each game to fit the various goals and needs that are happening the Anarchy is a solo players uh dream game and anyone who loves the Rolland right format and wants something bigger Bolder Brasher and deeper in that format will really have a good time with the Anarchy I think bobb's uh done a really great job here and for disclosure I know Bobby he's a friend of mine but this is a very good game and I'm judging it on its merits not just cuz I like the BL the second game to win this award is Halls of hegra and Halls of hegra is a solo only game and it's a solo only game about a Siege in Norway where you are the um Norwegians defending against the Nazis and you're trying to hold on as long as you can this game goes through a whole bunch of different stages where first you're Gathering resources then you're Shoring up the fort and then the attacks get more and more and more pressing and desperate and dangerous towards the end it's so hard like this is a super hard game you'll get so frustrated with it because you'll make some bad decisions early on and that they'll ruin you and you'll have to keep playing it and playing it and playing it until you finally Master the game and then it's still a really good challenge this is fantastic solo game for several reasons one it's designed for solo play and that that to me that's a huge plus uh secondly it's got a really

interesting and engaging theme mechanically it feels somewhat unique it feels like its own thing it's got a little bit of worker placement elements mixed with some classic wargaming stuff uh it's it's own unique experience so yeah if you're into solo gaming and you want a solo gaming challenge try hols a HRA so my two winners for the solo game of the year are the Anarchy and hor ofra I have two new Awards this year and the first one of those Awards is the under the radar game this is for a game that you probably haven't heard of and if you have heard of it well you know don't call me on that it's I'm picking relatively obscure games that I think have something extra special of them just to Showcase that game to a wider audience that might not normally have seen it the intent for this award is just to shine that light on something odd and go hey check out that odd game over there you probably haven't considered that one before and this year the award goes to darar the week of five presidents this is a historic game but it's not a historic war game it's a historic influence game it's a historic politicking and betrayal and backstabbing type game and it's about a period in Argentina's history not too long ago 28 years ago where they had a cash crisis an inflationary crisis and there were runs on the banks there were riots in the streets uh money became

worthless overnight and uh the president resigned then his replacement got put in the job and he resigned and someone else came along looked at the books and went I can't fix this problem and they resigned in one week they went through five presidents in the country because no one could get a handle on this runaway financial crisis and that's the game you are playing the various leaders in Argentina at that time and you're trying to build up and consolidate a power base while also defaming other people and trying to secret away money and riding the economy as it collapses is it's fascinating uh you can pass laws you can declare uh martial law you can hold press conferences to try to get rid of your bad PR it's a fascinating game about uh a financial meltdown and the Scrabble for power because the wind conditions the wind conditions are really really clever um you either one person's presentent any time and then the player with the most resources if the debt problem is dealt with um and that's all solved the current president wins so the current president wants to solve the problem everyone else kind of wants to drag the game out a little bit longer uh in order for themselves to become president or if at any point uh the players have accumulated too much negative press um the current president will win um or there's an opportunity to get on a helicopter and steal the WN

it's it's very very interesting uh how it all plays out it's chaotic has lots of table talk and backstabbing there's a a card Drafting and set collection mechanic in it as well but it's different and it's also a living part of history and a part of history that I imagine not a lot of people in the English speaking world are very familiar with uh so yeah I found Derek Car the week of five presidents an absolute delight and I'm also going to do a full review of that coming up as well I held off doing that because I didn't think there would be that much interest in the game uh cuz it's a it's a slightly obscure title from a moderately obscure publisher um but such a good game I'm going to give it a dedicated video uh and that'll come out probably in February so yes my best under the radar game of 2024 was Derk car the week of five presidents the next new award is for best art Direction and uh I'm giving out this award because because of the number of Publishers that are starting to look towards using AI generated images instead of actual art uh something I find quite repellent um so in order to sort of counteract that I'm going to use my Awards to shine a spotlight on what I think is some great Artistic Endeavors happening out there I personally am very big on using Quality Art and board games and you'll see that with my own board games Red Dust Rebellion uh we have fantastic artwork in that one and also

Shadow Moon syndicates both my games I feel we went above and aboard on the art Direction and we got fantastic artists and fantastic image and for me that's part of what makes the board game medium a special medium is that it's something you play but it's also it's an art form because you play a game and the interpreting the game is a work of art in itself but also the visual imagery in in here we've had tons and tons of talented artists over the year deliver striking games with beautiful art and I think I think it's something we should really appreciate as part of the hobby uh and before we get on to giving out the award I'll give an honorable mention to uh two games from stonem games uh worms span and Expeditions they're the runner Runners up this year um stonem games consistently do amazing presentations on their games and these two games which I reviewed last year are are no different beautiful art from uh the artists involved here and yeah Expeditions in particular was was really really Happ handsome and I love the the book in worms span that has all the different dragons in it I think that's that's beautiful work uh but they get edged out uh by sort of another slightly under the radar game and that game is Netrunner the new Netrunner by null signal games so as you might know Android Netrunner was around for years and it was made by Fantasy Flight games and Fantasy Flight games had a very distinctive and wonderful art style that I loved they went all the way through

Netrunner so when Netrunner stopped being published a group of fans uh picked it up and tried keeping the game alive and in the last couple of years they've been able to formally do this and be able to sell the games and that's brought Netrunner back to life and that group is null signal games but the reason I'm giving them a shout out here is the art they have on this you know not for-profit game is the same caliber the same quality and the same overall feel as original Netrunner it doesn't look like fan-made content it looks like new official content the artwork just fits into the world perfectly and whoever is responsible for those decisions and for getting those artists on board and briefing them and showing them this is the world we want to create and and actually realizing that so you have these new nitr Runner cards that fit perfectly in the world I I take my hat off to them and that's why Netrunner from from null signal games is my inaugural winner for the best art Direction in board games in 2024 next up is the best new to me game now this is a game that's been out for a couple of years but it's something I've only just discovered and this should be hardly surprising there are thousands of board games that come out each year I'm not going to get to each and every one of them as soon as they' released even some classic games and uh the one I'm going to give this to is a bit of a a classic Euro game but I'll give an

honorable mention out first to Clank and space I haden't played any of the Clank games before this year I picked Clank and space to be the one I wanted to play and I absolutely adore it I love the pushu system in this I I love the goofiness of it I love the different setups uh I just love the overall Tempo and feel of the game I'm a big fan of deck building games allow you to do something and Clank and space is a dick building game that allows me to steal stuff and um that's pretty nifty I also just love how brutal it gets at the end with players dropping like flies but my winner for best new game to me is Hans Tonica this game looks dull as dull could be dull it looks like a game where you putting cubes on a map and that's about it but it's brutal it's mean it is the nastiest most horrible vicious infighting game you can possibly find and I find it fast fasinating and rewarding and engaging and Brilliant because of that the core of the game is yes you are putting cubes on the map but you get so many rewards if someone pushes your cube out of the way so it's all about just getting in everyone's way it's about playing in a way that forces your opponents to give you free stuff all the time and it's so pity it is uh it's hard to describe just how vicious and nasty and hilarious a gave is I would not play it with people who don't

like having sitbs backs in their game uh because playing a game of hona is a constant series of setbacks but if you can embrace the the ethos of the game the the the pettiness of it and also appreciate the puzzle that you're trying to solve here as well because it's not just about being a vindictive the whole time it is about building the right networks and getting into the right places and getting the right Powers at the right time and it's very clever in that regard um so yes I absolutely think this is a top tier game I'm really glad to have finally played it and it's it's going on the forever shelf um it's an absolute keeper so yeah my best new game to me this year is Hans Tonica it's evil give it a go now every year on the patreon we have a patrons Choice Award and this year we got down to five finalists and of those finalists uh here are the runners up uh the first one is void fall then we have slay the Spire Daybreak and June Imperium Uprising all four of those games are excellent games and I can absolutely see why uh the patreon community for three minute board games back them excellent choices uh but the number one game picked by the patrons of three minute board games as their game of the year is ARS from games and that's this is hardly surprising ARX

has been a bit of a revelation I finally played through the uh the three the blighted Reach campaign and that was that was an experience I think I need to play it a couple more times to have like a really properly informed opinion on it but it was interesting it was a very different type of Space Opera than you would expect from say a Twilight Imperium or an eclipse where all of those games sort of build to a crescendo and then the game ends and arcs it's like things are happening and especially in BL of reach where you can you can completely crash out and have be suffering and not doing very well at all in the first and second acts of the game and even come roaring back and steal the win ARX is a Space Opera game but he gets rid of so much of the bloat in this genre by simplifying a lot of your economy and a lot of Your Action systems into one trick taking game and based on who wins those tricks that sits the tempo for the game and it allows for stunning reversals and just dramatic changes in the board State ARX is an exceptional game and I can absolutely see why uh my patrons picked this as their game of the year and spoiler alert it's going to be in my top five as well now that would normally bring us to our final award the golden kgy award for the year which I would give out to my single best game overall in 202 before but this year I've decided to do things a little differently instead of just

having the number one game that I give the award to I'm going to have a top five and not just that I'm also going to have a bottom five part of the reason I want to do this is I keep seeing threads all over the place where people talk about negative reviews being more honest and I'm not sure I agree with that at all I'm not sure just ragging on a game counts as being more honest than praising something you genuinely liked but in the interest of fairness and balance I feel like it's a good idea to call out five games that didn't work well for me while I'm going to praise five games that I thought were absolutely excellent now the funny thing is a lot of these five games are really popular games that were huge hits with other people and at the grand scheme of things just because I don't like a game doesn't really mean much these are just games that were flat out misses for me my bottom five in descending order are Star Trek away missions this looked like it was going to be a fun Star Treck Skirmish game but ultimately there's not enough game there I feel the game's core gameplay Loop was pretty average and it felt like just an excuse to sell you Star Trek toys also skirmish games need a community and I don't think this is ever going to get one number four hegemony I felt like this was a game where four people were assigned to different stations in an office and in your station you had to do your job and there was so many levers in the game pushing everything to the middle that ultimately the game felt like it played itself it's an incredibly interconnected game but no point playing it that I feel that my decisions overcame the inertia built into the game I'd be far more forgiving of the game if it didn't take

itself so seriously number three Sky Team I do not get why this game is so popular to Steph and I it felt like we were collaboratively playing a game of tick tac toe to a draw without any form of communication there didn't seem to be enough meaningful decisions to add any real tension we either had the dice we needed or we didn't I know some people out there have some really fun experiences with Sky Team but for us there was Zero drama whatsoever number two waterfall Park I love Chinatown and I was really looking forward to this as a reworking and reimagining of that great game the problems are that the mechanical rework of the game is just bad it makes the game shorter but it makes everything more random and predetermined also the theme is absolute nonsense in Chinatown different families trading blocks of land in order to build stores that made sense but who is competitively working to build different things inside the same water park absolutely a wasted opportunity and my number one least favorite game of 2024 is myth this is barely a game to me this is an activity the difference between myth wind and watching paint dry is at the end of watching paint dry you have something with dry paint on it I found myth wind to be an absolute chore that went nowhere took a hell of a lot of time and didn't offer any thing back some people this might be a great game for me it's an absolute time

sync that was the games I did not particularly care for this year so let's rapidly change pace and go for the five games that I really really liked we'll start with my number five game raising robots there's no doubt about it wingspan has a huge influence on this game but I found it in every way shape or form a superior game it had a far more interesting decision space it had a theme I liked and I just loved all the things you could do inside raising robots to build engines and chain effects to me raising robots is wingspan with rocket boots attached and a death laser strapped to its head my number four favorite game of the year was Daybreak Daybreak is the latest in a long line of Cooperative games from Matt Leo the guy known for the Forbidden Island series pandemic and a whole bunch of other Cooperative games including one of my favorites Thunderbirds Daybreak is his take on climate change it's a Cooperative engine building game that uses elements from things like terraforming Mars but what I really love about this game is that there are only five actions you can take each turn you can only have five projects in play so instead of having a sprawling table like you would in terraforming Mars with a 100 different effects going on here you have to have five and you have to focus on them and build them up and then change them in and out as the board State changes I think is a really great decision space and Daybreak I think it's got an amazingly well researched theme and it's a very intense and engaging Cooperative game my number three game of the year is June Imperium Uprising I didn't care much for June Imperium when

it came out I've said that before multiple times I played it just after lost ruins of arnac and I was a little bit over this combination of worker placement and and Dick building I thought it was a little bit me but the game grew on me over the years afterwards and it steadily built up in my estimation but I always thought the one thing this game needs is a little bit more Cutthroat action and in June Imperium Uprising came out out and it delivered exactly what I wanted it took the stuff that was successful in June Imperium that everyone loved but it added in more fisty cuffs and it made the fights more important more vital and more Cutthroat I don't know what to call June Imperium Uprising it's not quite a second edition it's almost like a patch of the game whatever it is it fixed a whole bunch of things I didn't quite like about the original game and made it into one of my favorites my number two game of the year is the Patron's Choice Game of the Year ARX from leader games everything I said about ARS earlier I'm going to reiterate here I love how swingy it is I love how Dynamic it is I love that it got rid of so much of the busy work and chaff that you have in a 4X game of managing ships and Tech trees and all that kind of stuff and I just love how dramatic the game can be time will tell how I feel about the blighted Reach campaign but after a first play through I think it's pretty damn clever I need to see more though but ARX just as a standalone game is my number two game of the year now we're on to the final game of the year my number one game of the year and also the winner of the best game from our Tira New Zealand

award as well uh just a bit of a disclaimer I've known the designers of this game for quite a while one in particular I've known for over 20 years that said I didn't review their last game uh because it had depictions of slavery in it but in this game they took the core ideas from their previous games Endeavor and Endeavor age of sale and turn them into something magical Endeavor deep sea there is a bunch I love about ende de a deep sea the first of all is the expanding board as you play through the game you go deeper and deeper into the oceans and discover things I think that's neat secondly I love the really tight engine building in this game every decision matters you have limited actions and you absolutely have to maximize them and create chain effects all the way through the game to get the best score thirdly it has a ton of different scenarios which test different facets of the game so you can't just get into a pattern of deciding what is the best course of action each time you need to adapt and changed based on the map that's being built in front of you and the scenario you're trying to fulfill for it has a stunning solo mode a really really challenging and engaging solo mode and could easily have taken out my solo game of the year if it hadn't won these two Awards as well and finally it just has a really cool theme deep sea exploration is just Neo and I feel it took everything good from Endeavor age of sale all of the mechanics it works really well in that game and Link them to a theme that I engage with much much more to create something truly special so Endeavor deep sea is our game of the

year so that's our awards for the year with Endeavor deep sea winning two big Awards if you want to give me your top five and bottom five games of the year just post them in the comments below and we'll talk about them and if there's any game I miss that you think I'd like just let me know in the comments below because I'm usually 6 months behind getting games anyway there's a very good chance that something you're playing right now will be something I'll be playing in 6 months time especially if you tell me about it right now and just reminder 3in ball games does not do paid content keep us Independent by supporting us on patreon and thank you from Stephanie and myself to all our patrons who backed us over the last year you keep the channel going thank you so much take care

Progress saved