Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 25:59

hi i'm adam porter and this is my top 100 board game mechanisms of all time and i'd like to start off by thanking all those people who have been commenting and joining in as we've gone through this list a few of you have commented that some of the things that i've mentioned so far haven't actually been board game mechanisms and i think um i think the definition is a little bit loose i've played fairly fast and loose with the definition here because this is entertainment right this is not an academic study of board game mechanisms so rather than go through an academic text and if you wanted to do that i would highly recommend engelstein and shaliv's building blocks of tabletop design which is a fantastic book but i've deliberately kind of not looked at that and used those categories because i wanted to keep this a fairly personal list of the sort of things that i enjoy in games so please don't take this as any sort of authoritative guide to board game mechanisms that said there's a lot here that i think board game designers could look at and utilize piece together in certain ways to create unique combinations and unique experiences for players so with all that said let's get on with number 30. so number 30 is what i'm calling and there may be a technical term for it but i'm calling discount drafting so this is where you have a series of cards that are available to the players and usually the one that is furthest from the deck is cheaper than the others so there's a sort of river of cards and as one is taken they shift along to the left or shift along to the right and then the other card the spaces are filled in from the deck and so think that the the price

of those cards that the cost changes as you play the game so this is featured in games like if wishes were fishes where if you want to take a card that's further along the chain you have to place worms on the cards that will get you there so you place a worm on the first card on the second card in the third card and worms of currency in this game now a later player who chooses to take one of those cards will get the worms that have been placed on it as well so the value of the cards really shifts this also happens in the game the really popular days of wonder games small world other games which do it architects of the west kingdom has a system a little bit like this where you know you're paying more for certain cards depending on their position in that row it essentially complicates that ticket to ride mechanism where you've got a layer of cards there and you can either take them face up from the display or face down from the top of the deck but now we've got different costs depending on their positions and i find that really engaging number 29 is combative card play and this is one of those ones that probably isn't really a mechanism but it's a sort of a genre of game and this is different to me to the take that mechanism the take that mechanism is where um we're playing a big strategy game then every now and then i pull out a take that card and i say ha ha i've got this card and i play it and i attack you but in a combinative card game we're constantly doing that that's all we're doing we're just playing cards back and forth to attack each other maybe knock off each other's hit points

um or or damage each other in different ways the whole basis of the game is attack and defend a bit like if you're playing a game of chess two player you know all you're doing is attacking and defending that's your whole purpose in the game and so in a big card game like evolution for example my favorite game in fact i find this really really satisfying this constant attack defend evolve adapt to the changing situation that you've got in front of you i also enjoy the game star wars destiny which is a collectible card game which is all about attacking and defending deciding when to put certain cards into display uh into your display and to protect yourself or to attack your opponent and then my favorite game when i was a kid was the game wrastlin an old avalon hill wrestling game where you would be playing wrestling moves on the opponent in an attempt to knock down their hit points but they could block they could reverse you could put combinations of different cards together and i just find it that that quite an engaging back and forth number 28 is the blackjack mechanism and i i think i've been a little bit um a little bit gung-ho here in separating that one out from push your luck in general um but i think there's something very familiar about blackjack so that is where we have to count uh we have to get play our cards and try and get as close as we can to 21 without going over um and i think that's uh that

it just harks back to my childhood really playing pontoon as we called it in the uk and i haven't seen that many games which utilize this this 21. the one game which i have played which i enjoy is the game black jackie from ravensburger a very simple light um card game it's only available in german um but it's it's it's a fun it's a fun game you'd need some paste ups or a translation or something like that if you're going to play in english because there is text on the cards but my own game compromat here which i designed with rob fisher this is very much inspired by blackjack we're trying to get to 21 or as close as possible and not go over in a two-player card game where we're dueling against the other players to control information about some sort of public figure or something like that that's the compromat of the title that's a purely thematic thing but we've got several layers of kind of push your luck in here but blackjack is absolutely at its core so this one is on the list mainly because of familiarity and nostalgia number 27 is drawing and what i mean here is not just that mechanism i've mentioned previously about construct something and then guess what it is so that's what you're often doing in a drawing game in fact in most drawing games that's what you're doing drawing and then other people have to guess what it is but actually just the act of drawing is in itself fun one game which where you draw but you don't have to guess anything is the game identic or duplic it's got two names depending on

where you're picking it up from so in this game you uh somebody is plays as the kind of i don't know what they're called the describer so they take a card and it's got a really complex slightly surreal line drawing on it of some sort of crazy scenarios crazy picture it all makes sense you know but it's it's a bit weird and they have to describe what's going on in that picture to the other players but the other players can't see the picture so they don't have to draw what's being described and then at the end of the round they're going to be asked questions like how many buttons have you got on that person's coat did you draw the buttons on the coat in the right place was the cloud you know to the right of the person or the left of the person and so on and so you get points for accuracy which is partly dependent on the person who's describing the picture and partly dependent on your ability to interpret what they're saying and draw it's really really fun but equally it could just be drawing lines it could be something like looney quest where where we're we we've got a central image with lots of little items that we want to connect together with a line but other items that we want to avoid touching and we have to draw a line on an acetate sheet that is going to then be placed over that original image and then we see how we've done have we managed to connect things up so this is a very different skill this isn't about creativity and draftsmanship or anything like that this is this is purely about kind of accuracy and perception but nonetheless just that act of taking pen to paper or pencil to

paper drawing it's just fun it's something we do as children right and we don't do it that much as adults so i really or most of us don't unless you're an artist of some form or an architect or something like that most of us don't do all that much drawing and i still find it fun to do so number 26 is tableau building and this is a huge topic it's another one that i've made a previous video about top 10 mechanisms in tableau building games so i mean it's a huge mechanism it's very hard for me to get stuck into it particularly here but great examples of the genre are games like bruges um and wingspan and abyss and seven wonders and you know and these games can cover a whole gamut of different genres and and mechanisms but at their core a tableau building game you're laying out cards into a sort of static display in front of you and those cards will have a mixture of different powers that will drive your engine so for example they might have end game scoring abilities on them so you're going to be scoring for gathering certain sets into your tableau or they might have um in-game scoring abilities so i've got that card in front of me and when something else happens i generate some points or they might have special powers that i can use so the game becomes more and more asymmetric as we play or they might be worker placement spots on those cards as in evidel where i can place a worker onto one of the cards on my tableau or maybe on the opponent's

tableau in order to achieve certain things but the unique thing about these games is that you have a specific display of stuff in front of you that powers your particular gameplay and it's a really satisfying mechanism and there's loads and loads of space there for for clever design number 25 on my list is contract trick taking and so this is i suppose i ought to start by saying what trick taking is so trick taking is a card game where each of us plays a card in turn usually a numbered card and then the highest number usually will win that trick and take all of those cards and say well there we go i've won a trick now what does that mean well it's different in every different game and sometimes there are other things in here like trump suits and things like that so if i play a a red card then uh then i'm always going to win regardless of the other the other cards that have been played there's also often the requirement to follow suit so if i play a blue card everyone else has to play a blue card if they have one if they don't have a blue card they can play any color of card and again what that means playing a card that's off suit that's not of the correct color what that means is different in every different game so that's trick taking very a very confusing brief description there but again if you want to know more about trick taking please go back and watch my previous videos i've got a number of videos about trick taking and how trick taking games work on the channel but contract trick taking is specifically where you have a hand of cards and you look at them and you have to decide at the start of

the round how many tricks you think you're likely to win or what color tricks you think you're likely to win so essentially you're making bets or bids they're often called in contract trick taking games you're making bids on how many tricks you're gonna win and then you strive throughout the game to achieve that particular total accurately okay now this has um i've mentioned previously that i don't like pre-game auctions don't like pre-game auctions because every player has to be familiar with the value of everything they've got to be quite familiar with the gameplay before they can really engage with an auction so it kind of cuts out you know the first time players newcomers to the game it makes it very difficult for them to join in now this is also true in contract trick taking games but the benefit here is that most players or many many players let's not say most there will be people who have never come across a trick taking game before but many players will have played lots of other trick taking games so they've got a head start in looking at their hand of cards and trying to decide will i how many tricks am i going to win and am i going to be able to achieve this so i feel like there's enough of a leg up in a contract trick taking game that you can kind of get stuck in and the rounds are short enough that even if you don't do so well in the first round well maybe by the second round you've got an idea of how the game flow is working and so now you can start to make more accurate predictions so my game picoco is a contract trick taking game so at the start of the round you look at the cards around the table and in pacoco you can't

see your own cards you can see everyone else's cards but not your own and you've got to make predictions about how many tricks each of the players around the table is going to is going to manage and then you try and make that happen by playing cards from your left neighbor rather than playing cards from in front of yourself so that's contract trick taking and it's one of my favorite card game mechanisms number 24 is end game elimination and i've mentioned previously a mechanism that is unique to habengut okay the game hub go to stock market game and that was about shared partial information to the left and to the right of you but harban good also has one other really distinctive mechanism and i'd hesitate to call this one unique but it is really distinctive to have goot and that is in harmon good you're gathering up stocks and every now and then you can place a stock onto your charity board which means you're going to give any rewards from the from selling that stock at the end of the game to charity but the other players don't know what you've put down there when we get to the end of the game we're the first thing we're going to do before we get on to end game scoring and looking at who's got the most money is we're gonna see how much everyone's given to charity and the person who gave the least money to charity is eliminated from the game regardless of whether they've got the most money they probably will have the most money because they didn't give very much to charity but they are eliminated eliminated regardless and i find that a really tense fun moment in a game it's getting to the

end and then going have i given enough and somebody else has given a ton of money to charity because they were they were paranoid about i don't want to be that last player and then that's meant that they don't have enough money at the end to win the game it's a really satisfying sort of tug of war a push and pull there of balance to be found you know have i given enough or have i given too much or have i given too little there's a similar mechanism in reinecknitsia's high society a card game where you're trying to get high point scoring cards and so you're auctioning these off throughout the game spending your money to get these cards and they're all worth victory points or some of them are worth negative points but at the end of the game the player with the most points is going to win but before that happens the player who's got the least money at the end of the game is eliminated from the game so if you've spent your game just spending money loads and loads of money to try and make sure you've got the best stuff well it probably will achieve that you'll probably have the most points but if you've got less money than everybody else you're eliminated before you even get to look at those points there's a similar thing in uh lords of zidid i think a larger strategy game and i can't remember the specifics because it's sometimes since i've played it but in that game i believe there's several rounds of elimination at the end of the game so first we look at this category and the player who's got the least of this is eliminated then we look at this category and the player who's got the least of that is eliminated and then we get onto the final category and the player who's got the most wins something like that happens in lords obsidian it may not be

specifically that but around that sort of idea i'm sure some players find this really frustrating particularly if they didn't quite um understand the mechanism going into the game particularly in a longer game like lords of zidit it's not such a problem in a short game like high society but you've really got to go into the game understanding that that is what's going to happen at the end before you play otherwise there are going to be some serious upset at the end when you're like but i won but i've been eliminated before we get to that victory point um but i love this mechanism i think it's really really clever and you don't see it in all that many games number 23 i'm calling the formula d dice mechanism i'd love to hear if there are other games that use this same mechanism i've not come across any but i'd really like to play something else that does so in formula d it's a racing game formula one racing game you're racing around the track and each dice represents a different gear so if you're in first gear you're rolling a four-sided dice which means you're not going to be moving very fast around the track but then if you go up a gear then you're onto a six-sided dice up another gear you're on to i can't remember is it an eight-sided or a ten-sided and then a 12-sided a 20-sided by the end you're rolling you know you're in fifth gear or or something like that and you're rolling a thirty-sided dice to race around the track now these dice are not numbered sort of one to thirty okay so there is a uh a skewed distribution but nonetheless the the the situation here is that you are going

faster as you get into those higher gears and it simulates that idea of going up gears and going faster and faster really really well now the unique thing in formula d is that you've got to stop in the corners so you can't afford to be going at high speed if you're going to be hitting corners because every time you bypass that corner you're going to take damage to your car and eventually you're going to be knocked out of the race so you've got to be careful about what gear you're in at different stages of the game but i love that mechanism of each individual dice is is doing something slightly different and we can scale up through those dice and the dice physically scale up they get the dice get bigger and they're color coded it's really intuitive it's really exciting it's a clever implementation of push your luck mechanisms number 22 is a headwind so a headwind is the opposite of a previous catch-up mechanism that i've described in this list so previously i've described catch-up mechanisms where the player that's behind is given stuff okay this where when i'm talking about headwind i'm talking about where the player who's out in front is also gathering stuff that's slowing them down so the classic example i would use here is the game dominion so in dominion the player who wins the game is going to be the person with the most victory point cards in their deck okay so they're buying victory points putting them into their deck and at the end of the game we're going to see who's got the most but the thing about dominion is those victory point cards they don't achieve anything for you in fact they slow you down because if you pull a hand

of you know you draw a hand of cards and they're all victory point cards nothing much you can do on that turn where the other players the ones behind who don't have as many victory point cards they're drawing hands that are full of special abilities so that idea of when i purchase stuff it slows me down it pulls me back okay it feels to me a little bit fairer a little bit more natural than the idea of the players who are behind being given stuff artificially to give them a leg up okay i find it more palatable that the person who's out in front in the vanguard they're the people who are being dragged back now again this is a game that i i've only played once or twice and many years ago but i think flam rouge used this really effectively in flam route it's a it's a cycling game and obviously in a cycling game the whole concept of cycling is that the the person the biker who's out in the front is having the hardest time because they're hitting that headwind and the other people who are cycling behind them are able to kind of you know use that to to stay you know just behind that leader and then pull out in front when they need to flam rouge uses a similar sort of mechanism to dominion in that the player who's out in front is being pulled back and the other players can kind of draft into into that into that position just behind the leader or pull out in front number 21 is variable or modular scoring um systems

and so this is where each game or each round of the game we lay out a bunch of different cards which tell us what the scoring is going to be based on for this round or for this game and so it adds a huge amount of variety to gameplay so for example in cartographers at the start of each game we lay out four scoring cards and we know that this game that's what's important it's important to get i don't know forest next to mountains or or cities next to rivers or whatever it is or to form a consistent line from the top of the map to the bottom of the map it could be all sorts of different things but you've got four of them in any given game and so the massive number of combinations you know once you've got um the expansions as well well the cartographer's heroes the standalone game you've got billions of different combinations of these cards um that just gives massive variety to the gameplay um this happens in a lot of games now it was i remember it was quite novel when i picked up kingdom builder years ago and and you'd have a series of different scoring criteria that was that was quite exciting to see that every game was going to be slightly different it's something that you see in isle of skye that has a very similar mechanism to to what we see in cartographers where at the end of round one um the scoring conditions a and b will score and in round two b and c will score and then round three c and d and then the next round it'll be d and a you know it's that that sort of fluid scoring system and working out right what am i focusing on for this game and specifically what am i focusing

on for this round of the game i find that it's manageable keeping track of one or two different things and it's exciting laying out the cards at the beginning of the game again right this is what this game is all about and it always makes you feel like you've got you know a fresh new chance okay i didn't do so well last game but this game is going to be totally different maybe this game i'm going to absolutely ace it so that is numbers 30 down to 21 of the board game mechanisms that i love but as with all my previous videos we're also going to talk about the 10 board game mechanisms that i really don't enjoy and today we're at number three so this is a a mechanism that crops up in games like um viticulture i don't like it in viticulture i didn't particularly enjoy it in the game pre-histories i don't particularly enjoy it in the game new york zoo and they're all quite disparate different games aren't they very different games to each other um and they're actually games that i enjoy all of all three of those i enjoy the games but i don't like this mechanism and it almost ruins it for me so it's a kind of anti-climactic ending i find in these games and the reason for that is because they all feature a race to hit a certain objective and then the game ends instantly almost you might have a another few turns or this is the final round because we've hit that objective but ultimately the player who first achieved that goal wins the game so in new york zoo the first player to

fill up their entire zoo with tiles wins the game instantly it's over the other player gets the other players getting nothing i find it a bit frustrating bit anticlimactic particularly if i wasn't expecting it and then suddenly it happens and i couldn't spot it coming um in pre-histories which is an excellent polyamino uh thai laying game i suppose as as is new york zoo but in pre-histories you're aiming to complete certain objectives and each objective that you complete you get rid of a little token you want to get rid of all your tokens but the instant i get rid of my final token the game is over and the other players may not have spotted that coming okay in fact frequently i find that's the case the game is over i had no idea and now you know okay i'm done well everything that i was aiming to do nothing i i get nothing for what i've achieved so far i don't know i find that a little bit anti-climactic viticulture has the system where you score a number of points and there's a certain total of points that you have to get to that brings about game end uh and yes everybody gets that final turn or something like that to try and you know match up with the points at the end there but ultimately the player with the most points wins and that's likely to be the player who who hit that total first so essentially it's a race to a victory point total now that's okay but it's quite a big long strategy game and i kind of want to be rewarded for what

i've achieved throughout the game i don't just want the game to just end suddenly like that and it's over and we pack it away and say well that person was the winner i quite like that mechanism that is frequently employed in euro games where we count up our victory points at the end and i can see that okay you did better than me in this category but i did better than you in that category or i feel really proud of what i've achieved with this particular part of the game even if i didn't win or okay i came second but at least i i beat number three and number four in the list okay so in a game like um abyss or san juan which are tableau builders where we're laying out cards on the table or everdell the end of the game is triggered by a certain number of cards being laid out on the table okay so that's similar to what i've talked about previously but that isn't what decides who wins the game the winner of the game is the person who's got the most points on those cards regardless of whether they've got the most cards or not they may not have the most cards but if they've got the most points they win and i think that second layer to me is much more satisfying than that anticlimactic ending we see in a race to hit a certain points total or a race to achieve an objective that immediately ends the game end of rant i hope you enjoyed the video if you did please maybe go back and watch some of the others in this in this series if you haven't please comment let me know what you think of these mechanisms that we've talked about i really enjoy reading your comments

please subscribe to the channel if you haven't already done so and i'll see you on the next video all the best

Progress saved